Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

The development of music therapy in mainland china

YUE WU, MM, MT-BC MacPhail Center for Music, MN

ABSTRACT: The application of music therapy in mainland China of music therapy in mainland China from a historical perspective
has unique features, with its own cultural and historical charac- and to introduce recent accomplishments and future developmental
teristics. From the ancient usage of music to cure diseases to the trends.
modern standardized practices of music therapy, the history of
exploring the therapeutic use of music in China goes back thou- Ancient Philosophy and Theory
sands of years. The purpose of this article is twofold: to review the
development of music therapy in mainland China from a historical Since ancient times, the Chinese words for “music” (樂) and
perspective, and to introduce recent accomplishments and future “medicine” (藥) have been very similar. In ancient China, “music”
developmental trends. (樂) and “medicine” (藥) have the same origin in oracle bone
Evidence of the therapeutic use of music in China dating back to script and Jin script (formed between 1600 BC and 1000 BC)
the earliest music theory book and a traditional Chinese medicine (Wang, 1987, p. 467). Many people believed that their ancestors
book indicates the relationship of music and medicine in the roots of used music as medicine to improve their physical, emotional,
Chinese culture. The invention of music electrotherapy, the collabora-
and spiritual well-being in ancient times (Lai, 2000, p. 119).
tion between doctors and musicians, as well as experimental music
therapy projects are just a few examples of early exploration of music Two ancient books written between 476 BCE and 221 BCE
therapy in China. Tian Gao is considered the pioneer in this field of discussed the therapeutic use of music. Yue Ji, translated as
study, with contributions in education, advocacy, and the application Record of Music, is the earliest fully developed treatise on
of music therapy in modern mainland China. music to survive in China (“Record of music,” 2011). This doc-
Today, music therapy in mainland China is facing both chal- ument systematically discussed ancient Chinese music theory
lenges and opportunities. International conferences and trainings as and music philosophy, including “the origin, substance, and
well as exchange programs and opportunities to study abroad are
opening doors of communication and collaboration. The political
characteristics of music and its relationship to government
and financial support of the government as well as the introduc- and society” (Cook, 1995, p. 11). The book recognized that
tion and popularization of different music therapy approaches will music is an indispensable part of people’s lives and empha-
propel the music therapy profession in mainland China into a new sized the social-cultural function of music; the use of music
developmental era. should cooperate with other areas, including governance,
social norms, ethics, and education (“Yue Ji,” 2016). The book
Keywords: history; culture; music therapy; philosophy; music is “thought to be the single most influential work on music in
the Chinese tradition, inasmuch as the thought exemplified
Music therapy in mainland China has come a long way from the in this work has continued to exert a great and inescapable
ancient therapeutic use of music to modern standardized practices, formative influence on much of subsequent Chinese musi-
and yet still maintains its own cultural and historical characteristics. cal thought” (Cook, 1995, p. 11). According to Yue Ji, music
As a country that has over 5,000 years of history, China started to is a reflection of social life and also a method of expressing
use music to cure diseases, to enforce social norms, and to execute emotion (“Yue Ji”). On the other hand, music can affect one’s
the administration of government as early as 500 BCE, as recorded
(Lin, 2006, p. 164). The ancient philosophy and theory of thera-
emotions, will, characteristics, and behaviors (ibid.). Different
peutic uses of music built a profound foundation for today’s music types of music have different effects: rapid and loud music
therapy practices, and this legacy has been cherished and continu- typically makes people fretful and impatient; harmonious
ously adapted to the contemporary application of music therapy in and soft music usually has calming and satisfaction-inducing
mainland China. effects (“Record of music”). Yue Ji indicates that music educa-
In the 1980s, music therapy as a profession began to take hold tion includes not only teaching knowledge of music and arts,
in mainland China (Chinese Music Therapy Association, 2013).
but also cultivating moral virtue and emotional health (ibid.).
A growing number of people had access to music therapy services,
and the Chinese government supported the field both politically and Because music is sequential and structured, social rules and
financially. The purpose of this article is to review the development norms were often taught through songs and dances; because
music is expressive and inspirational, it was also used to
Yue Wu is a native of China, who completed her graduate music therapy study at develop value traits such as honesty, love, kindness, and
Colorado State University and now is working as a full-time music therapist at integrity (ibid.). Based on this philosophy, music was used
the MacPhail Center for Music in the Twin Cities area.Address correspondence
concerning this article to Yue Wu, MM, MT-BC, MacPhail Center for Music, 501 as a political and educational tool in the administration of
S 2nd Street, Minneapolis, MN 55401. E-mail: wu.yue@macphail.org. Phone: society to promote social stability, to educate social morals
970-980-4720.
The author wishes to thank Tian Gao, Hongyi Zhang, Mingming Liu, Bing Li, Jinyi Li, and norms, as well as to develop good personal characters
and Lujie Wang for generously providing information about the development of music and enhance self-cultivation (“Yue Ji”).
therapy in mainland China, as well as Drs. Michael Thaut, Lisa Summer, and Dawn Miller
for graciously sharing their experiences and perspectives on music therapy in China. The Some controversy exists regarding the authorship and pub-
author is immensely grateful to Drs. William Davis, Roberta Kagin, Blythe LaGasse, and lication of Yue Ji. Guo Moruo (1892–1978), a Chinese his-
Andrew Knight for their guidance and support during the process of writing this article.
© American Music Therapy Association 2018. All rights reserved. For permissions,
torian, archaeologist, and writer, asserted that the book was
please e-mail: journals.permissions@oup.com written by Gongsun Ni Zi (birth and death unknown), who
doi:10.1093/mtp/mix023 was Confucius’s second-generation disciple and lived during
1

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758


by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018
2 Music Therapy Perspectives

the early Warring States period (476–221 BCE) (Guo, 1945, apply this signal to patients’ meridian system (the meridian
p. 161). In contrast, Cai Zhongde (1947–2004), a Chinese system is “a concept in traditional Chinese medicine about
musical historian and philosopher, indicated that Yue Ji was a path through which the life-energy known as ‘qi’ flows”;
written by Liu De (?–130 BCE), the second son of Emperor Jing Novella, 2012) while patients are listening to the music. Since
of Han and a bibliophile in the Western Han Dynasty (206 music is melodic, rhythmic, and has changes in volume,
BCE–8 AD) (Cai, 1997, p. 72). the random pulse waveform stimulates the meridian system
Besides being used by governors as a political and educa- with varied electrode frequency that enhances the effect of
tional tool, music was also used by average people to enhance the treatment (Wang, Xu, Dong, & Dong, 2014, p. 1247). In
their health. As written down in the literature of traditional addition, soft music with a flowing melody can calm patients
Chinese medicine, music is the link to mood and behavior and bring enjoyment to them during treatment. The benefit of
and helps promote harmony and balance between body, soul, music electrotherapy is “improving the person’s psychological
and spirit (Alter, 2005, p. 7). and physiological conditions through music and music sig-
Huangdi Nei Jing, also translated as Yellow Emperor’s Inner nals that act on the auditory system and other systems in the
Canon, is the earliest traditional Chinese medicine theory human body to achieve health, disease prevention, and re-
book and is “treated as the fundamental doctrinal source for habilitation purposes” (Zhang & Huang, 2010).
Chinese medicine for more than two millennia” (“Huangdi Music electrotherapy was widely used for various psychi-
Neijing,” Wikipedia, 2014). The book collected 162 traditional atric and neurologic conditions such as depression, muscle
Chinese medical articles and was most likely written during injury, facial paralysis, neurasthenia, neurosis, dementia, and
the Warring States period (475221 BCE) (“Huangdi Neijing,” stroke (Wang, Xu, Dong, & Dong, 2014, p. 1247). Music
Medical Encyclopedia). According to Huangdi Nei Jing, differ- electrotherapy was utilized in stroke rehabilitation by apply-
ent types of music have different effects on the human body ing electric current on the impaired limb and causing muscle
(Li, 2007). Traditional Chinese music is based on pentatonic contraction (Liu, 1987, p. 111). The muscle contraction and
scales. The five basic modes are Gong (C-D-E-G-A), Shang expansion caused by electric pulses can enhance muscle
(D-E-G-A-C), Jue (E-G-A-C-D), Zhi (G-A-C-D-E), and Yu (A-C- strength and muscle tension, and thus promote functional re-
D-E-G). Huangdi Nei Jing discussed the relationship between covery of the impaired limb (ibid., p. 113). The blood ves-
these five modes and five human organs, the liver, heart, sels also contract and expand under the stimulation of electric
spleen, lung, and kidney (Mu, Xuan, & Li, 2000, p. 92), as current. Research has shown that this “blood vessel massage”
well as how to use this relationship to improve overall health can promote vasodilation and increase blood flow, and there-
in human beings (Zhang, 2000, pp. 138–139). fore improve the cerebral ischemia and hypoxia status (ibid.,
These two ancient books showed the rich tradition of the p. 112). In a study conducted by Shuyun Chen (1991, p. 106),
therapeutic use and philosophy of music in Chinese history; she compared the effects of music electrotherapy and regular
this became part of the culture and influenced the subse- electrotherapy on athletes’ muscle soreness recovery. The
quent development in Chinese music therapy. In Horden’s results suggested that music electrotherapy was more effective
book Music as Medicine—The History of Music Therapy since than regular electrotherapy and that music also helped reduce
Antiquity, he said that “the whole of Chinese culture, includ- central nervous system fatigue (ibid., p. 107). The Qingdao
ing music, is therapeutic” (2005, p. 47). Air Force nursing home tested the long-term effectiveness of
music electrotherapy on 168 patients who had neurosis with
Early Exploration symptoms such as headache, insomnia, fatigue, and anxiety
After the establishment of the People’s Republic of China in (Dong & Sun, 1996, p. 54). The researchers followed the 168
1949, music therapy attracted the interest of many musicians, patients after their treatment for 2–5 years. Results showed
researchers, and clinicians. Music electrotherapy became an that 52.38% of the patients did not relapse over two years
early, exploratory tool for Chinese medical practice and music and also avoided the side effects of traditional medication
therapy. Research suggested the effectiveness of music elec- therapy (ibid., p. 55). According to Jihong Liu et al. (2013,
trotherapy on a variety of populations. Many clinical and edu- p. 101), music electrotherapy can also assist in keeping up
cational institutes started to develop their own music therapy the morale of navy officers and soldiers. The “Healthy Music
programs. In the 1980s, music electrotherapy was introduced Electrotherapy Machine” used in this study combined electro-
at international conferences and China started to be active in therapy, heat therapy, music, and pictures, resulting in two na-
music therapy affairs worldwide. tional utility patents in China (ibid., p. 104). During the 1990s,
In the 1970s, hospitals began to apply music electro- music electrotherapy was used with psychotherapy in treating
therapy in rehabilitation and disease prevention (Zhang & anxiety neurosis in order to enhance the treatment effect (Hu,
Huang, 2010). Music electrotherapy is the use of music Liu, & Li, 1994, p. 160).
incorporated with electro-acupuncture. Electro-acupuncture Music electrotherapy was first introduced internationally to
attaches needles to electrodes, which “send electrical currents music therapy professionals at the International Music Therapy
or pulses into the body” (Hsu, 2013). One shortcoming of Leadership Conference beginning April 16 through 20, 1987,
electro-acupuncture is that the electrodes keep the same fre- in Provo, Utah (Miu, 1987, p. 155). Hongshi Miu gave a pres-
quency. This increases the likelihood that patients will get used entation on music electrotherapy that attracted great attention.
to the repetitive electrode signals; the outcome is therefore not Dr. Peter Jampel, the president of the American Association
as effective (Wang, Xu, Dong, & Dong, 2014, p. 1247). The for Music Therapy at the time, commented that this approach
principle of music electrotherapy is to transfer a music signal “opened another door and developed a new approach for
into low-to-middle electrode frequency (20–20000 Hz) and music therapy” (ibid., p. 156). In 1993, the First International

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758


by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018
The development of music therapy in mainland china 3

Symposium on Oriental Medicine was held in New York. of musicians, psychologists, and medical professionals in
Delin Li, representing the Chinese Music Therapy Association, October 1989 (Chinese Music Therapy Association). The mis-
gave a speech, “Current Development and Future Trends of sion of CMTA is: “Discussing, studying and advocating music
Music Electrotherapy in China,” that received positive feed- therapy, as well as creating and developing music therapy
back (Zhao & Li, 1996). with Chinese characteristics by cooperating closely with pro-
In 1980, Bangrui Liu’s introduction of music therapy to fessionals from the disciplines of music, medicine, psych-
mainland China greatly expanded people’s knowledge of ology, science and medical equipment making” (Zhang, Gao,
music therapy and spearheaded the recent exploration of this & Liu, 2016, p. 67). The association became the bridge to con-
field. Bangrui Liu, a Chinese American who was an Arizona nect music therapy researchers and clinicians that spurred the
State University Associate Professor of School of Liberal Arts, development of music therapy in mainland China (Zheng &
was invited to the Central Conservatory of Music in China in Chen, 2004, p. 92). In 1993, China was invited to join the
1980 and first introduced music therapy to China (Liu, 1980, World Federation of Music Therapy (WFMT) and Hongyi
p. 58). During her stay at the Central Conservatory of Music in Zhang became one of the council members (Zhang, 2004,
China (March 14–June 27), Liu presented five lectures under p. 106). Since then, China has participated in music therapy
the title of “Several Topics of Western Musicology Study” and affairs worldwide.
held eight seminars with students in the Asian-African-Latin
music group in the musicology department (ibid.). The last Development over the Past 20 Years
of the five lectures, “The Topic of Music Therapy,” was given The modern practice of music therapy in mainland China
on June 27, 1980 (ibid.). In this lecture, Liu talked about the began with the contribution of Tian Gao.
origin and development, research trends and theories such as Gao came to the U.S. and studied music therapy at Temple
ISO principle, and application of music therapy in the U.S., University in 1986. At the end of 1996, he moved back to
as well as her own experience working as a music therapist Beijing, China, becoming the first and only person to return
(ibid., pp. 58–63). Thereafter, many agencies and individuals after studying music therapy systematically overseas during
started to explore music therapy in mainland China. the next 15 years (Gao, e-mail message to author, January
In 1984, Hunan Mawangdui Nursing Home founded the 29, 2014). He then implemented in China those theories
first music psycho-therapy center in mainland China, and and techniques he learned during his studies (Gao’s Music
used the “YZJ series microcomputer-controlled music psycho- Therapy Center, “Therapist Tian Gao,” 2014). After returning
therapy machine” to address physical and psychological dis- to China, Gao attended many trainings related to psycho-
orders such as neurosis, hypertension, coronary heart disease, social therapy, such as hypnotherapy, family therapy, psycho-
and so on (Chinese Music Therapy Association). In the 1980s, dynamic psychotherapy, and Eye Movement Desensitization
Beijing Huilongguan Hospital and Shanghai Mental Health and Reprocessing (EMDR), all of which were presented by
Center explored the application of music intervention with international well-known professionals (Gao, e-mail message
psychiatric patients (Peng, 2009, p. 22). From 1986 to 1988, to author, December 1, 2015). As a certificated EMDR ther-
the China Conservatory of Music and Beijing Huilongguan apist, Gao combined the idea of music entrainment and
Hospital developed a partnership on studying “Music Therapy music imagery with EMDR, then developed one kind of treat-
and Chronic Schizophrenia”; this study was awarded the ment for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) called Music
third-place Beijing Science and Technology Progress Award Entrainment and Reprocessing (MER) (Gao, 2013A, p. 99).
(Zhang, 2004, p. 106). Beijing Huilongguan Hospital built the “MER is aimed at changing clients’ state of pain and anxiety
first music therapy room among all the psychiatric hospitals toward more positive states as the therapist guides the cli-
in the nation in 1991, becoming a new method in psychiatric ent through various relaxation, imagery, and cognitive-based
rehabilitation in China (Chinese Music Therapy Association). techniques that are supported with therapist-selected music”
Thereafter, many psychiatric hospitals, nursing homes, and re- (ibid.). This technique has been suggested to be an effective
habilitation centers launched music therapy programs (Zhang, method “in eliminating the influences of traumatic events on
2004, p. 106). many clients” (Gao, 2013B, p. 108).
In 1994, the psychological counseling department at Beijing In his 25 years of clinical practice in both Western and
Tongren Hospital launched a program to facilitate the treat- Eastern cultural conditions, Gao gradually developed his cul-
ment of elderly cardiovascular disease and sleep disorders by turally based approach to facilitate the situations and meet the
using music (ibid.). The program was well received and was needs of Chinese clients. According to Gao, many Western
called “enjoyable treatment” by the public (ibid.). Soon after, psychology theories and cultural norms are in conflict with
music therapy was not only practiced in specialized medical traditional Chinese culture and values (Gao, e-mail message
facilities, but was also integrated into various departments in to author, February 6, 2014). For example, in Chinese culture,
general hospitals (ibid.). children obey their parents when they are young. As they grow
In 1988, the China Conservatory of Music established the up, they become responsible for their elders. At the beginning
first music therapy program in mainland China beginning in of his practice, Gao employed the Western style of psycho-
1989 (Chinese Music Therapy Association).The music therapy therapy techniques to guide clients, but it turned out that the
program included both undergraduate- and graduate-level tension between clients and their family members increased
studies with Hongyi Zhang as the only instructor (Hongyi (ibid.). In order to meet the needs of Chinese clients, blend-
Zhang, e-mail message to author, April 13, 2014). The first ing the Western and Eastern philosophies and adapting music
music therapy organization in mainland China, the Chinese therapy theories and techniques has been necessary. Gao
Music Therapy Association (CMTA) was founded by a group started to involve traditional Chinese cultural context and

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758


by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018
4 Music Therapy Perspectives

social norms to treat clients; by using this cultural structured of music therapists in China, establishing a team of Chinese
application, the clients’ conditions improved (Gao, e-mail music therapists that meets the international professional
message to author, December 1, 2015). standard and driving the profession to develop in a fast and
In 1996, Gao established the Music Therapy Research Center healthy way” (Zhang, Gao, & Liu, 2016, p. 68). The Music
of the Central Conservatory of Music in Beijing, China. This in- Therapy Certified Training Institution provides a comprehen-
stitution was the first specialized music therapy research insti- sive curriculum including courses such as Music Therapy,
tution that combined teaching, research, and clinical services Music Theory, Musical Skills, Psychology, Physiology, and
together. In order to establish a standard, high-quality, inter- Counseling, among others (Gao, e-mail message to au-
nationally acceptable program, the Music Therapy Research thor, January 29, 2014). Certification includes three levels
Center referred to American curricula to develop courses; (novice, intermediate, and advanced), with each level having
English materials were also used to teach. Many researchers specific requirements (Chinese Professional Music Therapy
and music therapists from all over the world were invited to Association). After completing coursework, students must
give guest lectures or trainings in the Central Conservatory of complete a 720-hour supervised internship before becoming
Music in China. The master’s program in music therapy at the certified. By 2015, about 2,000 people had participated in the
Central Conservatory of Music was established in 1999, and training, with over 200 people receiving certification (Gao,
a bachelor’s program followed in 2003 (Central Conservatory e-mail message to author, December 1, 2015).
of Music, 2014). In 2008, the devastating Sichuan earthquake occurred in
In 1999, Gao opened the first specialized music psycho- Wenchuan, Sichuan Province, China. This earthquake measured
therapy agency in China, called Gao’s Music Therapy Center 8.0 on the Richter scale, causing the deaths of 69,712 people
(Gao’s Music Therapy Center, “Therapist Tian Gao”). In the with 17,921 people missing (“The number of dead and missing
same year, he started a radio program named “Music Therapy students in Wenchuan earthquake reached 5,300,” 2009). In
in Beijing People’s Broadcasting Station” that provided ser- response to this tragedy, Gao organized three groups of music
vices for people suffering from sleep disorders and neuras- therapy undergraduate and graduate students who traveled to
thenia (ibid.). Chinese society was quite open to accepting Wenchuan. Each group spent one month in the earthquake-hit
music therapy, with many newspapers and TV stations pro- area and applied music therapy to relieve the pain of people
ducing reports about music therapy (Gao, e-mail message to who suffered the loss of family and loved ones (Wang, Zhang,
author, January 29, 2014). Consequently, through extensive & Song, 2013). They set up a series of music therapy experi-
media coverage, music therapy gained more recognition by ences and interventions, such as “music performances, music
the public. In addition to an increased number of students games, sing-alongs, and music with dance or movement activi-
enrolling in music therapy programs, there has also been an ties” to help the victims vent their agony, relieve suffering, and
increased interest by many music teachers, students, doc- rebuild their hope for life (ibid.). As an observer, a TV reporter
tors, nurses, and counselors who were hoping to have more stated that, due to music interventions, “it was the first time
opportunities to learn music therapy theories and techniques he had seen people happy since the earthquake” (Gao et al.,
(ibid.). Since 2004, Gao’s Music Therapy Center has offered 2012). Besides Gao and his team, the Guangdong Provincial
music therapy training programs to the public. The center Association of Chinese Medicine launched the “Music Love
developed a systematic training model that included both Home” post-earthquake music therapy rehabilitation assist-
online and on-campus courses at novice, intermediate, and ance project, which involved the Guangzhou University of
advanced levels. Each level has 5–7 courses that are available Chinese Medicine, Xinghai Conservatory of Music, and China
throughout the year. However, since these courses are being Conservatory of Music participating (Huo, 2010, p. 685). Gao
offered to working professionals, most classes are held dur- became a founding member of the International Association for
ing summer, winter, and holiday breaks (Gao, e-mail message Music and Medicine (IAMM) in 2009, where “He has played a
to author, December 1, 2015). In the past 10 years, over 50 critical role in the international efforts in growing and integrat-
trainings have been held; students and professionals from all ing music and medicine across the globe” (Zhang, Gao, & Liu,
over the country have completed the training and received 2016, p. 69).
certificates (Gao, e-mail message to author, January 29, 2014). After 2012, many Chinese music therapists decided to
The number of attendees has steadily increased by 600 people return to China after studying overseas (Gao, e-mail mes-
every year (Gao, e-mail message to author, December 1, sage to author, January 29, 2014). Currently, there are 13
2015). Some of the trainees were from medical institutions, universities/colleges that have a music therapy major in
such as hospitals and clinics, and then incorporated music mainland China (see Figure 1). Current programs include the
therapy into their own practices (Gao, e-mail message to au- Central Conservatory of Music, China Conservatory of Music,
thor, January 29, 2014). Shanghai Conservatory of Music, Sichuan Conservatory of
In 2007, Gao established the Chinese Professional Music Music, Wuhan Conservatory of Music, Shenyang Conservatory
Therapy Association (CPMTA) in Beijing that provides dis- of Music, Minzu University of China, Yunnan Arts University,
tance education, professional training, updated music therapy the Third Military Medical University, Jiangxi University of
information, and certified examinations in China (Chinese Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shandong University of Arts,
Professional Music Therapy Association, 2007). CPMTA is Nanjing Technical College of Special Education, and Shanxi
the organization that identifies Chinese music therapists who Changzhi Medical College (Gao, e-mail message to author,
have advanced knowledge and skills for music therapy prac- January 29, 2014). In addition, there are other schools prepar-
tice (Bing Li, in discussion with the author, March 2016). The ing to offer music therapy courses (Gao, e-mail message to
mission of CPMTA is “promoting the education and training author, December 1, 2015).

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758


by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018
The development of music therapy in mainland china 5

Figure 1. Schools that offer music therapy degrees in mainland China.

One of the weaknesses of Chinese music therapy education and Child Health Care Hospital, among many more (Li, in
has been the lack of supervision by qualified music therapists discussion with the author, March 2016).
in students’ practica and internships (Gao, e-mail message As an authority in Chinese music therapy, Gao recom-
to author, January 29, 2014). Therefore, the students’ clinical mended two students who studied abroad to work in Wuxi
experience may have been substandard, hindering their abil- Tongren International Rehabilitation Hospital, in Jiangsu
ity to achieve a high standard of practice. This lack of super- Province (Gao, e-mail message to author, January 29, 2014).
vision began to change in 2013. First, more music therapy Wuxi Tongren International Rehabilitation Hospital is an upper
major students were encouraged to work in hospitals after first-class hospital (the highest level of hospital in mainland
graduating, in order to gain clinical experience. Moreover, a China) and has various departments, including neurological
group of students who had studied abroad and were system- rehabilitation, psychiatric, cardiovascular, otolaryngology,
atically trained joined the field of music therapy in mainland and geriatric wards, among other medical services (Wuxi
China and brought the standards of Western clinical practice Mental Health Center, “About the hospital,” 2013). Gao had
into Chinese music therapy practices (Gao, e-mail message an agreement with the hospital director to establish the hos-
to author, December 1, 2015). In 2015, Gao’s Music Therapy pital as a designated internship setting for music therapy major
Center in Beijing started to accept music therapy interns. students; the hospital director indicated that all the depart-
At the same time, a number of music therapists returned to ments of the hospital would be open to the practice of music
China after finishing their course of study and clinical train- therapy students (Gao, e-mail message to author, January
ing, working as both clinicians and supervisors at the center. 29, 2014). The hospital became a university-affiliated intern-
The growing needs of music therapy and growing number of ship site for Chinese students who study at the University of
music therapy supervisors enabled the center to have more Melbourne in Australia, Chonbuk National University in South
interns. According to Gao, there are many more students who Korea, the Central Conservatory of Music, Jiangxi University of
will finish their studies in the U.S. and plan to go back to Traditional Chinese Medicine, Xiamen University, Changzhi
China (ibid.). The center plans to expand their services and Medical College, and others in mainland China (Wuxi Mental
aims to have the largest capacity possible to accept music Health Center, “The first international neurologic music
therapy interns in mainland China (ibid.). In addition, many therapy training program in China was held in Wuxi,” 2016).
cities, such as Beijing, Guangdong, Zhengzhou, Chengdu, in The full-time music therapists working in this hospital also
mainland China have started to hire music therapists on staff serve as supervisors for the music therapy internship pro-
in their public or community health care systems. Some of the grams, providing students more opportunities to practice and
hospitals include Peking University Cancer Hospital, Fengtai gain clinical experiences (Gao’s Music Therapy Center, “A no-
Maternal & Child Health Hospital, and Jiangmen Maternity tification of music therapy internship”).

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758


by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018
6 Music Therapy Perspectives

In addition to Wuxi Tongren International Rehabilitation children with developmental delays such as autism spectrum
Hospital, other music therapy internship sites that employ disorder, Down syndrome, and cerebral palsy. The families of
full-time music therapists are Beijing Anding Hospital, Beijing these children often cannot afford the expenses of therapies
Boai Hospital, Xuanwu Hospital, Beijing Children’s Hospital, (Wang, in discussion with the author, February 2017). After
Beijing Xicheng Pingan Hospital, China Rehabilitation three years of therapy, the clients’ communication skills, so-
Research Center, and the Young Activities Center of China cial adaptability, along with speech and language abilities,
Disabled Persons Federation (CDPF) (Zhang, Gao, & Liu, improved greatly (Yueling Music Therapy Service Center). Up
2016, p. 68). In 2014, Beijing Yinling Nursing Home and the to now, the center has worked with more than 3,000 homeless
Second Hospital of Beijing were added as designated intern- children, with the support of government funds (Zhang, Gao,
ship settings for music therapy major students; these facili- & Liu, 2016, pp. 69–70).
ties also have full-time music therapists to supervise students’
practice (Gao, e-mail message to author, March 23, 2014). Future Prospects
In addition to teaching and conducting music therapy
and research, Gao has written, translated, and edited several Government’s Involvement
books that are quite influential in mainland China (see ap- The Chinese government has also played an important role
pendix): Basic Theory of Music Therapy; An Introduction to in supporting the growth of music therapy in mainland China.
Music Therapy; Clinical Training Guide for the Student Music China has an increasingly aging population, which presents
Therapist; Receptive Music Therapy; Improvisation: Methods challenges for Chinese society. The Ministry of Civil Affairs of
and Techniques for Music Therapy Clinicians, Educators, the People’s Republic of China predicted that in 2050, China
and Students; Music Therapy Clinical Application; and will have about 400 million people above 60 years old, which
Music Therapy in Dementia Care (Tian Gao’s Music Therapy is about 30% of the total population (“A forecast report on
Center, 2015). the development trend of population aging in China,” 2006).
In recent years, with the development of music therapy in The China Central Television (CCTV), the official media in
mainland China, many music therapists who once studied China, presented a one-week special report about dementia
under Gao have carried out their own music therapy programs and Alzheimer’s disease in 2013. The government empha-
around the country. sized the aim to “establish a fairer and more sustainable social
Chunmiao Burn Camp in Chongqing has been providing welfare system” and “further develop the elderly services in-
free services every year since 2011 for children ages 6–18 dustry” (“The decision on major issues concerning compre-
who have experienced burn trauma but do not have access hensively deepening reforms,” 2013). These facts support the
to outpatient treatment. Music therapy is part of this interdis- argument that Chinese society needs music therapy services,
ciplinary team that includes doctors, psychotherapists, phys- which in turn promotes further development of music therapy
ical therapists, and occupational therapists. Starting in 2015, in mainland China.
the camp began to recruit music therapy student volunteers The social challenge of a growing elderly population be-
nationwide and music therapy professional volunteers world- came a catalytic factor for China’s New Government Funded
wide. Music therapists, music therapy students, and musicians Public Service Model. “A Government’s Purchase Public
from America, Canada, Taiwan, and mainland China have Service (GPPS) model is defined as government transfer-
participated in this program. Charities and companies donate ring part of public service to social organizations, in order
to cover fees and living expenses for the clients and volunteers to enhance the quality of public service and efficient use
(Li, e-mail message to author, January 25, 2017). Dr. Annie of funding, to improve the social governance framework,
Heiderscheit from Augsburg College was invited to visit the and to fulfill the more diverse and individualized needs of
camp in 2015, developing a program called “Music Therapy the public” (Yueling Music Therapy Service Center). The na-
in China: Chongqing Burn Camp,” which was designed to tional conditions and government’s support provide more job
enrich students’ global education experience by visiting opportunities for music therapists and new graduates. Gao’s
music therapy clinics and communicating with Chinese Music Therapy Center contracted with the Beijing Disabled
music therapists. Augsburg College now offers music therapy Person’s Federation to serve approximately 500 people who
undergraduate and graduate students the following courses: have developmental disabilities (ibid.). By the end of 2016,
Music Therapy Practicum (MUS 374) and Transcultural Music thirty-seven community music therapy service programs were
Therapy II (MUS 582) (Center for Global Education and currently thriving (Li, in discussion with the author, November
Experience, 2017). 2016). The music therapy team at Gao’s Music Therapy Center
Yueling Music Therapy Service Center, founded in 2014 in have been striving to expand the areas of music therapy ser-
Chengdu, Sichuan Province, is the first and only music therapy vices and advocate for the music therapy profession. From
public welfare service organization in mainland China (Yueling 2015 to 2016, the amount of government funding increased
Music Therapy Service Center, 2017). The organization pro- from $101,890 to $159,480; the number of employed music
vides music therapy services to children with developmental therapists increased from three full-time and two part-time
disabilities, homeless adolescents, older adults, and the gen- music therapists to six full-time and one part-time music ther-
eral public (ibid.). In August 2014, the Yueling Music Therapy apist; and the number of music therapy interns increased from
Service Center (in cooperation with the Chengdu Charity five to eighteen (Li, 2016). Besides government grants, other
General Association) launched the “Sunshine Charity Music sources of income in the field of music therapy in mainland
Therapy Project.” This project provides free music therapy China are insurance reimbursement and personal pay (Li, in
intervention to homeless children and orphans, as well as to discussion with the author, March 2016). In 2014, Gao and

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758


by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018
The development of music therapy in mainland china 7

his team started to popularize music therapy interventions for Dong Min Kim, the president of the Korean Nordoff-Robbins
Alzheimer’s disease and patients with post-stroke symptoms on Music Therapy Association, were invited to Beijing to provide
a large scale (Gao, e-mail message to author, March 23, 2014). the second training in March 2017 (Wucailu Autism Spectrum
This important historic opportunity to promote music therapy Disorder Research Center, “Nordoff-Robbins music therapy
development in China is closely related to international pro- training,” 2017). This event has also received support from the
fessional development and academic communication. China Disabled Persons’ Federation (ibid.).
Dawn Miller, the music therapy internship director at Park
International Conferences and Trainings Nicollet Health Services, was invited to present at two confer-
China has hosted several international conferences and ences in different parts of China. At the Fourth International
invited well-known music therapists and researchers as key- Conference of the International Association for Music and
note speakers and workshop trainers. Many internationally re- Medicine (IAMM) (June 11–13, 2016), which was hosted by the
nowned music therapists, including Drs. Cheryl Dileo, Clive Chinese Society of Music Therapy and the Chinese Professional
Robbins, Barbara Wheeler, Roberta Kagin, Suzanne Hanser, Music Therapists Association, Miller gave a presentation enti-
Michael Rohrbacher, Rob Amchin, Maria Montserrat Gimeno, tled “Healing from the Core: Music and Imagery in the Cancer
Blythe LaGasse, and Annie Heiderscheit, have come to main- Journey.” At the CPOS Academic Annual Conference and
land China to share their knowledge and skills with Chinese Eighth Psycho-Oncology and Palliative Care Training Meeting
music therapists (Zhang, Gao, & Liu, 2016, pp. 68–69). The (June 17–19, 2016) hosted by the Hunan Cancer Hospital and
conferences and trainings have provided important opportuni- Chinese Psycho-Oncology Society, Miller presented on the
ties to build international connections. topic of “Music Therapy in Oncology.” After interacting with
Since 2009, Dr. Lisa Summer, the Director of Music Therapy Chinese music therapists and learning about music therapy in
at Anna Maria College, has led the Guided Imagery and Music China, Miller stated her impression of Chinese music therapy:
(GIM) training institute in Beijing, and she has been invited to pre- “It is a very exciting time right now for music therapy in China.
sent in multiple universities and colleges across mainland China I met some music therapy professionals and a lot of students,
(ibid., p. 69). Throughout the years, Summer witnessed the quick who are intelligent, competent, motivated, and excited about
growth of music therapy in China and found “the spirit of the music therapy. I am very impressed about the students from the
Chinese music therapists to be so kind, giving, and dedicated to Central Conservatory of Music and the leadership from Tian
their work” (Summer, e-mail message to author, April 15, 2017). Gao.” Miller also learned that many music therapists who stud-
Today, Chinese music is widely used with most methods in the ied in America or Europe had come back to China to develop
Continuum Model of GIM that developed in the 1980s (except this field. According to Miller’s observation, these professionals
for the Bonny Method, which only uses Western classical music). worked well with each other, and “Music therapy will grow in
This allows Chinese music therapists to provide a client-centered, China, and people will need music therapy” (Miller, in discus-
supportive environment for Chinese clients (ibid.). sion with the author, July 2016).
Dr. Michael Thaut, the director of the Robert F. Unkefer
Academy for Neurologic Music Therapy and the founder of Exchange Programs
Neurologic Music Therapy (NMT), attended the Twelfth Chinese The undergraduate exchange program between the Central
Music Therapy Association conference as a keynote speaker in Conservatory of Music (CCM) and the State University of
April 2015 (Gao, e-mail message to author, January 29, 2014). New York (SUNY) at New Paltz, New York, was established
The first International Neurologic Music Therapy Training in in 2005. The exchange program provides the music therapy
China was held in Wuxi on June 18–21, 2016 (Wuxi Mental undergraduate students at CCM the opportunity to spend their
Health Center, “The first international neurologic music ther- senior year in the U.S. and study at SUNY, New Paltz (Liu, in
apy training program in China was held in Wuxi”). Over 150 discussion with the author, October 2016).
music therapists attended the training, and it was estimated that Exchange programs with Colorado State University and
one-third of the attendants are from countries outside mainland Augsburg College in Minnesota are in process, and this ex-
China, such as America, France, Singapore, Malaysia, Korea, change may provide opportunities for students from both
Hong Kong, Macao, and Taiwan (ibid.). The training program countries to learn from each other (ibid.).
“provides therapists with advanced clinical training and scien-
tific knowledge in the field of NMT” (Center for Biomedical Summary
Research in Music, 2014). Dr. Thaut expects the introduction of From the ancient usage of music by governors to today’s
NMT to supply this developing profession in China with a scien- application of Western music therapy techniques blended
tific foundation (Thaut, e-mail message to author, May 1, 2014). with Chinese cultural traditions, the history of exploring the
In October 2016, the first Nordoff-Robbins Music Therapy therapeutic use of music in China goes back thousands of
training in mainland China was held in Beijing. Jacqueline years. Since early exploration of this subject included cul-
Birnbaum and Jenny Fu from the Nordoff-Robbins Center for tural traditions, the practical application of music therapy
Music Therapy introduced this approach to Chinese music in mainland China has very unique features. The increas-
therapists, behavior therapists, social workers, special educa- ingly aging population in China’s society provides an oppor-
tion teachers, and so on (Wucailu Autism Spectrum Disorder tunity for the further development of this profession. The
Research Center, “The first Nordoff-Robbins music therapy support of government and the introduction and popular-
training held in Beijing,” 2016). Due to the great feedback ization of different music therapy approaches will propel
received from the first training, Dr. Alan Turry, the managing the music therapy profession in mainland China into a new
director of Nordoff-Robbins Center for Music Therapy, and Dr. developmental era.

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758


by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018
8 Music Therapy Perspectives

As a timely topic of intercultural experience and diversity “Huangdi Neijing.” Wikipedia. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
in music therapy, this article may provide Western clinicians Huangdi_Neijing
Huo, X. (2010). “Progress and prospect of clinical application of music therapy in
with an insight into traditional Chinese music philosophy and
China.” Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 25(7), 685–686.
its impact on today’s practice. The author hopes that the cul- Lai, W. (2000). “Five notes of ancient music and its relationship to five elements and five
tural differences discussed in this article will provide impli- zang organs.” Nanjing University of Chinese Medicine University Journal, 3, 119–122.
cations for clinicians who may be working with people of Li, B. (2016). A government’s purchase public service (GPPS) model for music ther-
Chinese descent. Music therapy in mainland China is grow- apy program in China. Paper presented at the 2016 American Music Therapy
ing rapidly, and there is an air of expectancy for future inter- Association Conference, Sandusky, OH, November 10–13.
Li, C. (2007). A discussion of five-tone music model. Paper presented at the Eighth
national collaborations.
Chinese Music Therapy Association Conference, Nanchang, Jiangxi, China,
November 3–7.
Lin, H. (2006). “The history of Chinese music therapy.” Chinese Journal of Clinical
References
Rehabilitation, 11, 164–165.
Alter, J. S. (2005). Asian medicine and globalization. Philadelphia: University of Liu, B. (1980). “The topic of music therapy.” Journal of the Central Conservatory of
Pennsylvania Press. Music, 1, 58–63.
Cai, Z. (1997). Notation and study of “Yue Ji” and “Sheng Wu Ai Le Lun.” Zhejiang: Liu, J., Jiao, X., & Xu, Y. (2013). “Effect of music electrotherapy on mental health of
China Academy of Art Press. escort officers and soldiers.” Proceedings of the 11th Academic Symposium of
Center for Biomedical Research in Music. “NMT Training Institute.” Retrieved from Chinese Music Therapy Society, 101–104.
http://cbrm.colostate.edu/?page_id=36 Liu, M. (1987). “Observation on effect of music electrotherapy on 60 patients with cerebral
Center for Global Education and Experience. “Programs: Brochure. Retrieved thrombosis consequence.” Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 2(3), 111–113.
from http://studyabroad.augsburg.edu/index.cfm?FuseAction=Programs. Miu, H. (1987). “A report of the 1987 International Music Therapy Leadership
ViewProgram&Program_ID=55383#DATES Meeting.” Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation, 3, 155–156.
Central Conservatory of Music. (2014). “An introduction to the Music Therapy Mu, J., Xuan, Z., & Li, X. (2000). “The meaning of five-tone music in Huangdi Neijing
Research Center.” Retrieved from http://www.ccom.edu.cn/aboutccom/jigou/ and its relationship with five human organs.” Journal of Shandong University of
jxjg/yykjb/yyzl/xxjj/ Traditional Chinese Medicine, 24(2), 92.
Chen, S. (1991). “Effects of music electrotherapy on muscle soreness recovery in Novella, S. (2012). “What is traditional Chinese medicine?” Science-Based
athletes.” Chinese Journal of Sports Medicine, 2, 106–107. Medicine, January 25. Retrieved from https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/
Chinese Music Therapy Association. “An introduction to Chinese Music what-is-traditional-chinese-medicine/
Therapy Association.” Retrieved from http://cmta.chnmusic.org/info/ “The number of dead and missing students in Wenchuan earthquake reached
JEHUCBJIKBEJDLDDC.html 5,300.” (2009). Sichuan News, May 7. Retrieved from http://scnews.newssc.
Chinese Professional Music Therapy Association. “Music therapist certified examin- org/system/2009/05/07/011881366.shtml
ation.” Retrieved from http://www.chinamusictherapy.org/8.html. Peng, R. (2009). The current situation and prospects of Chinese music therapy
Cook, S. (1995). “Yue Ji 樂記—Record of music: Introduction, translation, notes, and (Master’s thesis, Hunan Normal University).
commentary.” Asian Music 26(2), 1–96. “Record of music.” Chinese Encyclopedia Online. Retrieved from http://www.zwbk.
“The decision on major issues concerning comprehensively deepening reforms.” org/MyLemmaShow.aspx?zh=zh-tw&lid=108582
(2013). China Daily, November 18. Retrieved from http://www.chinadaily.com. Tian Gao’s Music Therapy Center. “Books.” Retrieved from http://www.musicther-
cn/language_tips/news/2013-11/18/content_17112855.htm apy2003.com/index6.html.
Dong, X., & Sun, J. (1996). “Long-term therapeutic effect of music electrotherapy Wang, C., Zhang, J., & Song, N. (2013). “Reborn in music—the notes of psychologi-
on neurosis patients.” Proceedings of the 4th Academic Conference of Chinese cal assistance in Sichuan from the teacher and students of the Institute of Music
Music Therapy Society, 54–55. Therapy, the Central Conservatory of Music.” Central Conservatory of Music,
“A forecast report on the development trend of population aging in October 25. Retrieved from http://www.ccom.edu.cn/aboutccom/jigou/jxjg/
China.” 2006. People. Retrieved from http://theory.people.com.cn/ yykjb/yyzl/xwdt/201009/t20100930_13396.html
GB/40557/59413/59414/4165813.html Wang, F., Xu, C., Dong, G., & Dong, H. (2014). “Developmental status and prospect
Gao, T. (2013A). “An introduction to MER, a new music psychotherapy approach of musical electroacupuncture.” Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion, 34(12),
for PTSD: Part 1–the theoretical and clinical foundations.” Music and Medicine, 1247–1250.
5, 99–104. Wang, X. (1987). The explanation of Shi San Jia. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company.
Gao, T. (2013B). “An introduction to MER, a new music psychotherapy approach Wucailu Autism Spectrum Disorder Research Center. “The first Nordoff-Robbins
for PTSD: Part 2–the outcomes and case examples.” Music and Medicine, 5, music therapy training held in Beijing.” Retrieved from https://freewechat.
105–109. com/a/MzAwNDQxMjQyNw==/2651960003/1
Gao, T., O’Callaghan, C., Magill, L., Lin, S., Zhang, J., Zhang, J.,…Shi, X. (2012). “A Wucailu Autism Spectrum Disorder Research Center. “Nordoff-
music therapy educator and undergraduate students’ perceptions of their music Robbins music therapy training.” Retrieved from https://mp.weixin.
project’s relevance for Sichuan earthquake survivors.” Nordic Journal of Music qq.com/s/T-g9Rc9bn2mdS8Cw_TMuyg
Therapy, 22(2), 107–130. Wuxi Mental Health Center. “About the hospital.” Retrieved from http://www.wux-
Gao’s Music Therapy Center. “A notification of music therapy internship.” Retrieved imhc.com/text.asp?fid=11
from http://www.musictherapy2003.com/201.html Wuxi Mental Health Center. “The first international neurologic music therapy train-
Gao’s Music Therapy Center. “Therapist Tian Gao.” Retrieved from http://www. ing program in China was held in Wuxi.” Retrieved from http://www.wuximhc.
musictherapy2003.com/gaotian.html com/news.asp?act=show&fid=2&cid=2&tid=1698
Guo, M. (1945). “Gongsun Ni Zi and his musical theory.” In M. Guo (Ed.), The Yue Ji. (1958). Translated by J. Liankang. Beijing: Music Publishing House.
Bronze Age (pp. 161–178). Chongqing: Chongqing Literature and Art Publishing “Yue Ji.” Baidu Encyclopedia. Retrieved from http://baike.baidu.com/view/25026.
House. htm
Horden, P. (2005). Music as medicine—the history of music therapy since antiquity. Yueling Music Therapy Service Center. “Yueling music therapy.” Retrieved from
Farnham, Surrey: Ashgate Publishing Limited. http://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/vWbq7c1fGLToJd7LYhGxQA
Hsu, D. (2013). “An introduction to electroacupuncture.” The Dr. Oz Show, May Zhang, H., & Huang, H. (2010). Status and prospects of music electrotherapy.
6. Retrieved from http://www.doctoroz.com/videos/introduction-electroacupuncture Paper presented at the Fourth International Conference on Bioinformatics and
Hu, S., Liu, G., & Li, M. (1994). “Observation on the efficacy of music electrotherapy Biomedical Engineering, Chengdu, Sichuan, China, June 18–20.
plus psychotherapy for treating anxiety neurosis.” Journal of Convalescence & Zhang, H. (2000). The introduction to music therapy. Beijing: China Electronic
Rehabilitation, 9(4), 160–162. Audio-Video Press.
“Huangdi Neijing.” Medical Encyclopedia. Retrieved from http://www.a-hospital. Zhang, J., Gao, T., & Liu, M. (2016). “Music therapy in China.” Music & Medicine,
com/w/黄帝内经 8(1), 67–70.
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758
by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018
The development of music therapy in mainland china 9

Zhang, W. (2004). “The introduction of music therapy and its development in Gao, T. (2008). An introduction to music therapy. Shanghai: World Book Publishing
China.” Chinese Music, 1, 105–107. Company.
Zhao, Y., & Li, D. (1996). Chinese music electrotherapy. Paper presented at the Wheeler, B. L., Shultis, C. L., & Polen, D. W. (2010). Clinical training guide for the
Eighth World Congress of Music Therapy, Hamburg, Germany, July 14–20. student music therapist. Translated by T. Gao and X. Zhang. Beijing: People’s
Zheng, Y., & Chen, J. (2004). “The definition and formation of music therapy and its Medical Publishing House.
development in China.” Explorations in Music, 3, 92–95. Gao, T. (2011). Receptive Music Therapy. Beijing: China Light Industry Press.
Wigram, T. (2012). Improvisation: Methods and techniques for music therapy cli-
nicians, educators, and students. Translated by T. Gao. Beijing: China Light
Industry Press.
Appendix
Aldridge, D. (2014). Music therapy in dementia care. Translated by T. Gao. Beijing:
Books Written and Translated by Tian Gao China Light Industry Press.
Gao, T. (2007). Basic theory of music therapy. Shanghai: World Book Publishing Gao, T. (2015). Music therapy clinical application. Edited by T. Gao. Beijing: China
Company. Science Publishing House.

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mtp/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mtp/mix023/4859758


by University of Durham user
on 22 February 2018

You might also like