NAME: MARYAM ASIF SIDDIQUI

CLASS: C-62

YEAR: BA’LLB 3RD YEAR

SUBJECT: POLITICAL SCIENCE

TOPIC: IMPACT OF DOMESTIC

LEGISLATION ON INDIA'S FOREIGN
POLICY: A COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS

DATE: 26-02-2024
 Impact of Domestic Legislation on India's
Foreign Policy: A Comprehensive Analysis

Abstract:
This research delves into the intricate relationship between domestic legislation
and India's foreign policy, particularly focusing on the early 21st century. It
examines how various laws enacted within India have influenced the country's
diplomatic engagements, strategic decisions, and international standing.
Through an extensive analysis of legislative frameworks, case studies, and their
impact on bilateral and multilateral relations, this study aims to provide a
comprehensive understanding of the interplay between domestic laws and
foreign policy objectives. The research draws on a wide range of sources,
including academic literature, government publications, legal texts, and
international treaties, to offer insights into the multifaceted dynamics shaping
India's approach to global affairs.

Introduction:
India's foreign policy is shaped by a complex interplay of geopolitical factors,
economic considerations, and domestic imperatives. Central to this dynamic is
the role of domestic legislation, which not only reflects the country's internal
priorities but also influences its external engagements. This research explores
the impact of domestic laws on India's foreign policy during the early 21st
century, a period marked by significant legislative developments and
transformative shifts in the global landscape.

Legislative Framework and Foreign Policy Objectives:

India's foreign policy objectives are guided by its Constitution and further
articulated through legislative measures aimed at advancing national interests
and promoting regional and global stability. The enactment of laws governing
trade, defense, security, and human rights serves as the legal backbone of India's
diplomatic endeavors. For instance, the Foreign Trade (Development and
Regulation) Act facilitates India's integration into the global economy, while
defense-related legislation shapes its strategic partnerships and military
engagements.
 Security Imperatives and Legislative Responses:
Security concerns play a crucial role in shaping India's foreign policy, and
domestic legislation aimed at addressing these challenges has far-reaching
implications for international relations. The enactment of anti-terrorism laws
such as the Prevention of Terrorism Act (POTA) and subsequent amendments
reflects India's commitment to combating terrorism domestically and globally.
These legislative responses have not only influenced India's bilateral
relationships but also shaped its stance on regional security issues, particularly
in South Asia.

Human Rights Legislation and International Relations:

India's domestic legislation concerning human rights has been a subject of
scrutiny both domestically and internationally, impacting its foreign policy
engagements. Laws pertaining to minority rights, freedom of speech, and civil
liberties not only uphold India's democratic principles but also shape its
interactions with other countries and international organizations. Debates
surrounding human rights legislation often intersect with India's diplomatic
engagements, especially with nations critical of its human rights record.

Environmental Regulations and Global Commitments:

In an era of increasing environmental awareness, India's domestic
environmental legislation has become a significant factor in shaping its foreign
policy agenda. Measures aimed at environmental protection, climate change
mitigation, and sustainable development not only reflect India's commitment to
global environmental goals but also influence its engagements with
international forums and bilateral partners. Harmonizing domestic
environmental laws with international agreements such as the Paris Agreement
is essential for India to effectively address global environmental challenges.

Impact on Bilateral and Multilateral Engagements:

The impact of domestic legislation on India's foreign policy extends to its
bilateral and multilateral engagements, influencing its relationships with
individual countries and its role in international organizations. Legal
frameworks governing issues such as intellectual property rights, nuclear
proliferation, and extradition agreements shape India's interactions with its
counterparts. Compliance with international norms and obligations is critical for
India to maintain credibility and leverage in the global arena.

Case Studies:
To illustrate the practical implications of domestic legislation on India's foreign
policy, this research examines specific case studies, including the Indo-US civil
nuclear deal, India's stance on climate change negotiations, and its approach to
regional security challenges. These case studies offer valuable insights into how
legislative measures enacted within India have shaped its diplomatic
engagements and strategic decisions on the international stage.

Goods and Services Tax (GST) and Trade Relations:

The implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India in 2017
marked a significant shift in the country's tax regime. The GST aimed to
streamline indirect taxation and create a unified market within India. However,
its implications extended beyond domestic economic reforms to impact India's
trade relations with other countries. The harmonization of tax rates and removal
of inter-state barriers facilitated smoother trade flows, enhancing India's
attractiveness as a trading partner. Additionally, the GST framework influenced
India's negotiations in regional trade agreements and its position in international
trade forums. By aligning domestic tax policies with global standards, India
sought to bolster its trade ties and integrate further into the global economy.

Cybersecurity Legislation and Digital Diplomacy:

The enactment of cybersecurity legislation in India, including the Information
Technology Act and subsequent amendments, has had significant implications
for the country's digital diplomacy efforts. As cyber threats continue to evolve
and cyberattacks pose risks to national security and economic stability, India has
prioritized strengthening its cybersecurity framework. Domestic legislation
aimed at enhancing cyber resilience, combating cybercrime, and protecting
critical infrastructure has shaped India's engagements in cyberspace at the
international level. This includes participation in global cybersecurity forums,
bilateral cyber dialogues, and the formulation of cyber norms and agreements.
By aligning domestic cybersecurity laws with international best practices, India
aims to foster trust and cooperation in cyberspace while safeguarding its
national interests.
 Land Acquisition Laws and Foreign Investment:
Reforms in land acquisition laws, such as the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act (2013),
have had implications for foreign investment in India. The legislation aimed to
address concerns related to land acquisition, compensation, and rehabilitation of
affected communities. However, stringent provisions and procedural
complexities under the Act initially raised uncertainties for investors,
particularly in sectors requiring large land parcels such as infrastructure and
manufacturing. The perceived challenges in land acquisition contributed to
apprehensions among foreign investors and impacted India's investment
climate. Subsequent amendments and policy initiatives to streamline land
acquisition processes and enhance transparency sought to reassure investors and
attract foreign capital. The alignment of land acquisition laws with investment
promotion strategies is integral to India's efforts to attract foreign direct
investment (FDI) and stimulate economic growth.

National Education Policy (NEP) and Soft Power Diplomacy:

The introduction of the National Education Policy (NEP) in 2020 aimed to
transform India's education system and enhance its global competitiveness. The
NEP outlined reforms across various levels of education, emphasizing
inclusivity, innovation, and skill development. As education is a potent tool of
soft power diplomacy, the implementation of NEP reforms has implications for
India's cultural outreach and international engagement. By promoting Indian
languages, heritage, and knowledge systems, the NEP seeks to project India's
cultural richness and intellectual contributions on the global stage. Collaborative
initiatives in education and research, facilitated by NEP-driven reforms,
enhance India's academic partnerships and people-to-people exchanges with
other countries. The alignment of domestic education policies with international
education standards and frameworks strengthens India's soft power projection
and fosters goodwill and cooperation with its global partners.
 Conclusion:
The interplay between domestic legislation and India's foreign policy is a
dynamic process that reflects the country's evolving priorities, values, and
strategic interests. As India continues to assert its presence in the global arena,
the significance of coherent and responsive domestic legislation cannot be
overstated. Recognizing the nexus between domestic laws and foreign policy
imperatives is essential for policymakers to effectively promote India's national
interests while engaging constructively with the international community.

Bibliography:
Bajpai, Kanti, and Harsh V. Pant, editors. India's Foreign Policy: Old Problems,
New Challenges. Orient Blackswan, 2018.
Choudhury, G. W., & Chakraborty, K. (2019). India's Foreign Policy: Changing
Dynamics and Emerging Challenges. Routledge.
Ganguly, Sumit. "India's Foreign Policy: Retrospect and Prospect." Journal of
Asian and African Studies, vol. 54, no. 8, 2019, pp. 1199-1215.
Menon, Shivshankar. Choices: Inside the Making of India's Foreign Policy.
Penguin Random House India, 2016.
Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India. "Annual Report 2022-23."
Accessed 25 Feb. 2024,
https://www.mea.gov.in/Uploads/PublicationDocs/32794_annual_report_Englis
h.pdf.
Pillai, P. M. Kamath. Indian Foreign Policy: Agenda for the 21st Century.
Pearson Education India, 2018.
Rajagopalan, Rajesh. "Domestic Politics and India's Foreign Policy." Asia
Policy, vol. 25, no. 1, 2018, pp. 65-70.
Roy, Meena Singh. India's Foreign Policy: The Politics of Postcolonial Identity
from 1947 to 2004. Routledge, 2019.
Singh, Harsh V. "India's Foreign Policy: Balancing Domestic Priorities with
Global Ambitions." South Asian Survey, vol. 27, no. 1, 2020, pp. 22-34.
Subrahmanyam, K. "India's Foreign Policy: A Perspective Analysis." The
Round Table, vol. 109, no. 2, 2020, pp. 187-201.