Comparison of Dosing Pumps in AOI process within budget 2024

Make
Prominent Prominent ( Direct delaing with prominent) Helio Power (Milton Roy India) Helio Power (Milton Roy Europ) Direct (Milton Roy India) Direct (Milton Roy Europ) Rheoserve
Tag No Caustic Dosing Pump Aluminium Sulphate Dosing Caustic Dosing Pump Aluminium Sulphate Dosing Caustic Dosing Pump Aluminium Sulphate Caustic Dosing Pump Aluminium Sulphate Caustic Dosing Pump Aluminium Sulphate Caustic Dosing Pump Aluminium Sulphate Dosing Caustic Aluminium Caustic Dosing
Pump Pump Dosing Pump Dosing Pump Dosing Pump Pump Dosing Pump Sulphate Dosing Pump
Pump (Alternate)
Model S3BAH120270PVTS070S000 S3BAH120330SSTS040S000 S3BAH120270PVTS0 S3BAH120330SSTS040S000 GB403 GB403A G539-547N G529-561Q GB403 GB403A G539-547N G529-561Q DM4E3AB DM4D3PB DM5D3AB
70S000

Type
Dosing Pump Dosing Pump Dosing Pump Dosing Pump Dosing Pump Dosing Pump
Origin
Germany Germany Germany Germany India India France France India India France France China China China
Flow rate in (LPH)
300 220 300 220 320 220 345 236 320 220 345 236 260 230 350
Head in mlc
12 12 12 12 10 10 10 8 10 10 10 8 10 10 7
Daiphragm Stainless Steel Stainless Steel Stainless Steel Stainless Steel Gylon (High Gylon (High PTFE PTFE Gylon (High Gylon (High performance PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE
performance teflon) performance teflon) performance teflon) teflon)

Ball
SS-316 Teflon 316L Stainless Steel Glass SS-316 Teflon 316L Stainless Steel Glass SS316L Ceramic SS316L
Seat
SS-316 PVC 316L Stainless Steel Hostalen GUR/PE SS-316 PVC 316L Stainless Steel Hostalen GUR/PE
Motor rating (KW)
0.37 0.37 0.37 0.37 0.75 0.75 0.55 0.37 0.75 0.75 0.55 0.37 0.75 0.75 0.75
Make

Motor rpm
1500 1500 1500 1500 1440 960 1500 1500 1440 960 1500 1500
Motor IE Efficiency Class
IE3 IE3 IE3 IE3 IE2 IE2 IE3 IE3 IE2 IE2 IE3 IE3 IE3 IE3 IE3
Motor Enclosure Class
TEFC TEFC TEFC TEFC TEFC TEFC TEFC TEFC TEFC TEFC TEFC
Motor Insulation Class
F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F
Pump+ Motor Efficiency
100%/80% 100%/80% 100%/ 77.2% 100%/ 73.8% 100%/80% 100%/80% 100%/ 77.2% 100%/ 73.8%
Supply voltage/Hz/phase 230/400 V- 50 HZ - 3 phase 230/400 V- 50 HZ - 3 phase 230/400 V- 50 HZ - 3 230/400 V- 50 HZ - 3 phase 415V-50 HZ - 3 Phase 415V-50 HZ - 3 Phase 230/400 V- 50 HZ - 3 230/400 V- 50 HZ - 3 415V-50 HZ - 3 Phase 415V-50 HZ - 3 Phase 230/400 V- 50 HZ - 3 230/400 V- 50 HZ - 3 phase 230/400 V- 50 230/400 V- 50 HZ 230/400 V- 50
phase phase phase phase HZ - 3 phase - 3 phase HZ - 3 phase

Temp in °C
60 Ambient 60 Ambient 60 Ambient 60 Ambient 60 Ambient 60 Ambient 60 Ambient 60
Density (Kg/m3)
1.39 2.67 1.39 2.67 1.39 2.67 1.39 2.67 1.39 2.67 1.39 2.67 1.39 2.67 1.39
Viscosity
50 Mpas 25 Mpas 50 Mpas 25 Mpas 50 Mpas 25 Mpas 50 Mpas 25 Mpas 50 Mpas 25 Mpas 50 Mpas 25 Mpas 50 Mpas 25 Mpas 50 Mpas
Sealing Type
PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE PTFE
Suction connection (mm)
1/2" Female 1/2" Female 1/2" Female DN25 1/2" Female 1/2" Female 1/2" Female DN25 1"BSP 1"BSP 1.5"BSP
Discharge connection (mm)
1/2" Female 1/2" Female 1/2" Female DN25 1/2" Female 1/2" Female 1/2" Female DN25 1"BSP 1"BSP 1.5"BSP
Base frame
NA NA NA NA not available not available not available not available not available not available not available not available
Foundation Bolts
NA NA NA NA not available not available not available not available not available not available not available not available
Coupling
NA NA NA NA direct coupling direct coupling direct coupling direct coupling direct coupling direct coupling direct coupling direct coupling
Coupling guard
NA NA NA NA not available not available not available not available not available not available not available not available
Price unit
2310 EUR 2812 EUR 1501 USD 1213 USD 6040 EUR 4175 EUR 2470 USD 2000 USD 2620 USD
Price (EGP) per unit
188500 228500 78540 95608 180500 142500 399800 288500 51034 41242 205360 141950 83980 68000 89080
Taxes (14%)
26390 31990 10995.6 20077.68 25270 19950 27986 40390 12758.5 10310.5 21562.8 14904.75 11757.2 9520 12471.2
Total price inclusive taxes 214890 260490 89535.6 115685.68
205770 162450 427786 328890 63792.5 51552.5 226922.8 156854.75 95737.2 77520 101551.2
Delivery Period 8 to 10 weeks 8 to 10 weeks 4-5 weeks 4-5 weeks 8 -12 from PO 8 - 12 weeks from 8 -12 from PO
PO
5 weeks 5 weeks 3 weeks 3 weeks 5 weeks 5 weeks 3 weeks 3 weeks
Price basis Ex-work Germany Ex-work Germany Ex-work India Ex-work India Ex-work France Ex-work France Ex-work India Ex-work India Ex-work France Ex-work France CIF Alexandrai Alexandria CIF Alexandrai

Payment terms 50% advance with Order 50% advance with Order 100% in advance 100% in advance 100% in advance 100% in advance Agianst delivery Agianst delivery 100% in advance 100% in advance Agianst delivery Agianst delivery 100% against 100% against CAD 100% against
and 50% after delivery and 50% after delivery CAD CAD

Warranty 1 year against 1 year against 1 year against 1 year against 1 year against 1 year against 1 year against 1 year against manufacture 1 year against 1 year against 1 year against
manufacture defects manufacture defects manufacture defects manufacture defects manufacture defects manufacture defects manufacture defects defects manufacture manufacture manufacture
defects defects defects

We recommend Milton roy india as we use these pump in ETP unit since 2020 easy to maintain and low cost also
We will have another Two pumps to replace Phsoric , citric acid pumps of alfa laval & repair kit for all 4 pumps

Purshasing Departement Mechanical Section head Engineering manager

Technical office manager Operation director General manager