Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dulac 1987
Dulac 1987
Dulac 1987
Abstract
were observed (21). This study was conducted to investi-
gate: (a) the metabolic and hormonal responses to a long.
S. Dulac, A. Quirion, D. DeCarufel, J. LeBlanc, M. Jobin,
J. Côte, G. R. Brisson, J.M. Lavoie, and P. Diamond,
duration swimming competition in cold water and there-
Metabolic and Hormonal Responses to Long-Distance fore the possible relationship between rectal temperature
Swimming in Cold Water. mt J Sports Med, Vol 8, No 5, change and the hormonal responses as well as (b) the in-
Discussion
I:
O -20
The mean percentage of body fat of male long-distance 33 34 35 36 37 38
swimmers in the present study (13.6%) is higher than what rectal temperature (° C)
has been reported for shorter distance swimmers (7%) (9,
23) and for marathon runners (4.3%) (29). For the female
swimmers, the percentage of fat is 24.5% compared with omen —0,80** 0
Table 2 Hormonal and metabolic response before and after a swimming competition for men and women.
Men Women
Before After % of basal Before After % of basal
value value
• Women
o Men
400
•1 3OO
L
** **
100
inauftn iactc FFA triglyceride. cholesterol
acid
E NE cORTISOL HGH 14 13
Fig. 2 Plasma concentrations of glucose, insulin, lactic acid, free Fig. 3 Plasma concentrations of epinephrine (E) norepinephrine (NE),
fatty acids (FFA), triglycerides, and cholesterol during a 32-km cortisol, growth hormone (HGH), thyroxine (T4), and triiodothyronin
swimming competition in cold water In male and female swimmers. (T3) during a 32-km swimming competition in cold water in male and
Results are expressed in percent of the basal value (fasting state). female swimmers. Results are expressed in percent of the basal value
(fasting state).
The changes in plasma hormone concentration were not the carbohydrate reserves before exercise (only three swimmers
result of plasma volume changes since there was no modifi- had followed a carbohydrate overloading diet) or from an
cation in plasma protein concentration. insufficient carbohydrate intake during the event.
Contrary to the results observed during long-distance run- A decrease in blood insulin concentration was observed in
ning (from marathon to 100 1cm) where the authors found both groups after the competition, and this result re-
no change (16, 40) or an increase (13) in glycemia, we did presents the logical consequence of both hypoglycemia and
observe a decrease in blood glucose concentration at the marked increase in blood catecholarnines (1, 10, 33).
end of the competition in spite of the fact that the swim-
mers were permitted free carbohydrate intake during the The blood lactate concentration observed in both groups
race. This decrease in glycemia could result from inadequate seems to indicate that the swimmers have exceeded the
Metabolic and Hormonal Responses to Long-Distance Swimming in Cold Water mt. J. Sports Med. 8 (1987) 355
anaerobic threshold of 4 mmolfl'. This relatively high level the higher level of blood thyroxine concentration will
of lactate is probably the result of the sprint at the end of activate the thermogenesis, in cooperation with the increase
the competition (the faster swimmers for the last mile re- in blood epinephrine and norepinephrine, to prevent the
ceived cash money prizes). cooling effect of long-duration exposure to cold water.
The observed increase in blood FFA concentration upon In summary, long-distance swimming in cold water produces
completion of the swimming competition is in agreement higher blood concentrations of cortisol and thyroxine and
with other studies dealing with long-distance events (1, 10, lower glucose, insulin, and growth hormone concentrations
13, 16, 20,40); it seems to be related to the duration of than comparable activities in a neutral environment.
the event (20,40). The post-exercise blood concentration Furthermore, our study has demonstrated that long-distance
of FFA ( 2.5 mmol/l) observed in our study is high enough swimming in cold water represents, for some swimmers, the
to have a high uptake and metabolism of free fatty acids by limit of cold and long-duration exercise tolerance: some
working muscles. swimmers had suffered from marked hypothermia (E34°C)
The lipolysis seems to be mainly in the adipose tissue since and/or hypoglycemia ( 3 mmol/1'), which represents
there is no change in blood triglycerides concentration. values below the normal physiologic range.
These results contrast with the 50% decrease in plasma tri- Despite the small sample size of the F group, our results
glycerides concentration observed after a 100-km run (16). lead us to assume that female and male swimmers have
As expected, plasma cholesterol concentration was not the same metabolic and hormonal response pattern to a
changed significantly after long-duration exercise (6). long-distance competition in cold water.
During long-distance exercise with normal or increased core
temperature, the increased lipolysis is to be related to
14 Katch F.J., Michael E.O.: Prediction of body density from skin- 30 Refsum H.E., Stromme S.B.: Serum thyroxine, triiodothyronine
fold and girth measurements of college females. .IAppl Physiol and thyroid stimulating hormone after prolonged heavy exercise.
25: 92—94, 1968. ScandJClinLablnvest 39: 455—459,1979.
15 Keul J.: Muscle metabolism during long lasting exercise, in 31 Rennie M.J., Johnson R.H.: Alteration of metabolic and hor-
Howald H., Poortmans J.R. (eds): Metabolic Adaptation to Pro- monal responses to exercise by physical training. Eur J Appl
longed Physical Exercise. Basel, Birkhluser, 1975, pp 31—42. Physiol 33: 215—226, 1974.
16 Keul J., Kohier B., VonGlutz G., Luthi U., Berg A., Howald H.: 32 Schalch D.S., Parker M.L.: A sensitive double antibody immuno-
Biochemical changes in a 100-km run: carbohydrates, lipids, assay for human growth hormone in plasma. Nature 203: 1141,
and hormones in serum. Eur/AppiPhysiol 47: 181—189, 1964.
1981. 33 Scheele K., Herzog W., Ritthaler G., Wirth A., Weicker H.: Meta-
17 Kindermann W., Schnabel A., Schmitt W.M., Biro G., Cassens bolic adaptation to prolonged exercise. EurJApplPhysiol 41:
J., Weber F.: Catecholamines, growth hormone, cortisol, insulin 101—108, 1979.
and sex hormones in anaerobic and aerobic exercise. Eur JAppi 34 Sloan H.W.: Estimation of body fat in young men. JAppl Phy-
Physiol49: 389--399, 1982. sioI23: 311—315,1967.
18 Kirkeby K., Stromme S.B., Bjerkedal I., Hertzenberg L., Refsum 35 Sloan H.W., Burt JJ., Blyth C.S: Estimation of body fat in
H.E.: Effects of prolonged, strenuous exercise on lipids and thy- young women.JApplPhyszol 17: 967—970, 1962.
roxine in serum.Acta Med Scand 202: 463—467,1977. 36 Vecsei P.: Glucocorticoids: Cortisol, corticosterone and com-
19 Lavoic J.M., Cousineau D., Pbronnet F., Provencher P.J.: Meta- pound S, in Jaffe B.M., Behrman H.R. (eds): Methods ofHor-
bolic and hormonal responses of elite swimmers during a regular mone Radioimmunoassay. New York, Academic Press, 1974,
training session.EurlApplPhysiolsO: 173—177, 1983. Ch. 23.
20 Liesen H., Korsten H., Holiman W.: Effects of a marathon race 37 Viru A., Smirnova T., Tomson K., Matsin T.: Dynamics of
on blood lipid constituents in younger and older athletes, in blood levels of pituitary trophic hormones during prolonged
Howald H., Poortmans J.R. (eds): Metabolic Adaptation to Pro- exercise, in Poortmans J., Niset G. (eds): Biochemistry of Exer-
longed Physical Exercise. Base!, Birkhäuser, 1975, pp 194—200. cise IV—B. International Series on Sports Sciences. Baltimore,
Serge Dulac, Dpartement des sciences de l'activite' physique, Universit du Quebec Trois-Rivires, C.P. 500,
Trois-Rivières, Que. G9A 5H7