Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LCGC NAmerica December2023
LCGC NAmerica December2023
The Effect of Monodispersed Particles Company Profiles | Product Profiles | Multi-Analyte Method Analysis of Agriculture
in HPLC Column Performance Application Notes | Directory Product Ingredients and Products
GC LC APPLICATIONS
Current State ACCELERATING LC METHOD Aroma and Flavor
of Sample Profiling of Honey
Preparation on Gas
DEVELOPMENT USING Using High-Capacity
Chromatography CHEMOMETRICS AND Sorptive Extraction
MACHINE LEARNING
436 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
SAMPLES & METHODS The 2023-2024 RESOURCE ISSUE THEORY & FUNDAMENTALS
The Effect of Monodispersed Particles Company Profiles | Product Profiles | Multi-Analyte Method Analysis of Agriculture
in HPLC Column Performance Application Notes | Directory Product Ingredients and Products
2023–2024
GC LC APPLICATIONS
Current State ACCELERATING LC METHOD Aroma and Flavor
of Sample Profiling of Honey
Preparation on Gas
DEVELOPMENT USING Using High-Capacity
Chromatography CHEMOMETRICS AND Sorptive Extraction
MACHINE LEARNING
Cover art:
Chemometrics and machine
learning in chromatography:
ML data flow concept
COLUMNS
442 LC TROUBLESHOOTING
Troubleshooting Odds and Ends to Close Out 2023: Questions from the Mailbag, and Second Opinions
Dwight R. Stoll
There are three important habits and practices that can improve the effectiveness and efficiency
of any troubleshooter.
454 GC CONNECTIONS
Reflecting on the Influence of the Current State of Sample Preparation on GC, Part 1
Nicholas H. Snow
A recent sample preparation survey explored the critical role of sample preparation in gas
chromatographic analysis.
479 VIEWPOINTS
ExTech 2023, Celebrating 25 Years of Innovation in Extraction Technologies
Emanuela Gionfriddo
Cover image NicoElNino - stock.adobe.com
Extraction technology is a rapidly growing sect in separation science, and ExTech remains
the largest conference dedicated to discussing and sharing research done in this field.
FEATURE ARTICLE
472 Multi-Active Method (MAM) for the Analysis of Agriculture Product Technical Ingredients
and Formulated Products
Jim Garvey, Olga Nováková, Olivier Pigeon, and Mary Ellen McNally
A collaborative multi-analyte method developed utilizes HPLC and UHPLC to analyze more than
70 active ingredients. This method offers a validated approach for determining technical AI
alongside linearity, precision, accuracy, and specificity tests for seven active ingredients.
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 40 NUMBER 11 437
PEER-REVIEWED ARTICLE
506 CDS Analytical 508 Resonac America 510 Tosoh Bioscience LLC
LCGC North America (ISSN 1527-5949 print) (ISSN 1939-1889 digital) is published monthly by MultiMedia Healthcare, LLC., 2 Clarke Drive, Suite 100, Cranbury, NJ 08512, and is distrib-
uted free of charge to users and specifiers of chromatographic equipment in the United States and Canada. LCGC is available on a paid subscription basis to nonqualified readers in the
United States and its possessions at the rate of: 1 year (13 issues), $91.00; 2 years (26 issues), $163.00; in Canada and Mexico: 1 year (13 issues), $116.00; 2 years (26 issues), $182.00; in all
other countries: 1 year (13 issues), $170.00; 2 years (26 issues), $304.00. Periodicals postage paid at Trenton, NJ 08650 and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Please send address
changes to LCGC, P.O. Box 457, Cranbury NJ 08512-0457. PUBLICATIONS MAIL AGREEMENT NO. 40612608, Return Undeliverable Canadian Addresses to: IMEX Global Solutions, P. O.
Box 25542, London, ON N6C 6B2, CANADA Canadian GST number: R-124213133RT001. Printed in the USA.
438 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
MANUSCRIPTS: For manuscript preparation guidelines, see chromatographyonline. PUBLISHING/SALES Managing Editor
com/lcgc-author-guidelines, or call The Editor, (609) 716-7777. LCGC welcomes unso- Jeanne Linke Northrop
Executive Vice President,
licited articles, manuscripts, photographs, illustrations, and other materials but can- JLinke@clinicalcomm.com
Healthcare and Industry Sciences
not be held responsible for their safekeeping or return. Every precaution is taken to Brian Haug Senior Editor
ensure accuracy, but LCGC cannot accept responsibility for the accuracy of informa- BHaug@mjhlifesciences.com Megan Manzano
tion supplied herein or for any opinion expressed. MManzano@mjhlifesciences.com
Vice President,
Pharmaceutical Sciences Senior Editor
SUBSCRIPTIONS: For subscription and circulation information: LCGC, P.O. Box Shannon Stolz
Todd Baker
457, Cranbury, NJ 08512-0457, or email mmhinfo@mmhgroup.com. Delivery of SStolz@mjhlifesciences.com
TBaker@mjhlifesciences.com
LCGC outside the United States is 14 days after printing. (LCGC Europe and Senior Editor
LCGC Asia Pacific are available free of charge to users and specifiers of chro- Group Publisher Terri Somers
matographic equipment in Western Europe and Asia and Australia, respectively.) Oliver Waters tsomers@mjhlifesciences.com
OWaters@mjhlifesciences.com
CHANGE OF ADDRESS: Send change of address to LCGC, P.O. Box 457, CONTENT MARKETING
Associate Publisher
Cranbury, NJ 08512-0457; alternately, send change via e-mail to mmhinfo@mmhgroup.com. Senior Virtual Program Manager
Edward Fantuzzi
Allow four to six weeks for change. PUBLICATIONS MAIL AGREEMENT EFantuzzi@mjhlifesciences.com Lindsay Gilardi
No. 40612608. Return all undeliverable Canadian addresses LGilardi@mjhevents.com
to: IMEX Global Solutions, P.O. Box 25542, London, ON, N6C National Account Manager Digital Production Manager
6B2, CANADA. Canadian GST number: R-124213133RT001. Michael Howell Sabina Advani
MHowell@mjhlifesciences.com
SAdvani@mjhlifesciences.com
C.A.S.T. DATA AND LIST INFORMATION: Contact Stephanie Shaffer,
National Accounts Associate
tel. (774) 249-1890, e-mail: SShaffer@mjhlifesciences.com. Claudia Taddeo MARKETING/OPERATIONS
REPRINTS: Contact Stephanie Shaffer, ctaddeo@mjhlifesciences.com Associate Marketing Director
e-mail: SShaffer@mjhlifesciences.com Brianne Pangaro
INTERNATIONAL LICENSING: Contact Kim Scaffidi, BPangaro@mjhlifesciences.com
e-mail: kscaffidi@mjhassoc.com EDITORIAL
Audience Development
Associate Editorial Director Stacy Argondizzo
CUSTOMER INQUIRIES: Customer inquiries can be forwarded directly to MJH Caroline Hroncich SArgondizzo@mjhlifesciences.com
Life Sciences, Attn: Subscriptions, 2 Clarke Drive, Suite 100, Cranbury, NJ CHroncich@mjhlifesciences.com
08512; e-mail: mmhinfo@mmhgroup.com Reprints
Managing Editor Stephanie Shaffer
John Chasse SShaffer@mjhlifesciences.com
JChasse@mjhlifesciences.com
ycled P
Rec a
% CORPORATE
pe
aste
Jerome Workman
Mike Hennessy Jr
rW
Po JWorkman@mjhlifesciences.com
s t C s u me
on
Chief Financial Officer
Editor Neil Glasser, CPA/CFE
Will Wetzel
© 2023 MultiMedia Pharma Sciences, LLC. All rights reserved. No part of this publi- WWetzel@mjhlifesciences.com Chief Marketing Officer
cation may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or Brett Melillo
mechanical including by photocopy, recording, or information storage and retrieval Editor Chief Data Officer
without permission in writing from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items Patrick Lavery Terric Townsend
for internal/educational or personal use, or the internal/educational or personal PLavery@mjhlifesciences.com
Executive Vice President,
use of specific clients is granted by MultiMedia Pharma Sciences, LLC. for libraries
Assistant Editor Global Medical Affairs &
and other users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Dr.,
Aaron Acevedo Corporate Development
Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 646-8700, or visit http://www.copyright.
AAcevedo@mjhlifesciences.com Joe Petroziello
com online. For uses beyond those listed above, please direct your written request
to Permission Dept. email: ARockenstein@mjhlifesciences.com
Creative Director, Publishing Senior Vice President, Content
Melissa Feinen Silas Inman
MultiMedia Pharma Sciences, LLC. provides certain customer contact data (such as
customer’s name, addresses, phone numbers, and e-mail addresses) to third parties MFeinen@mjhlifesciences.com Senior Vice President, Human
who wish to promote relevant products, services, and other opportunities that may Resources & Administration
Senior Art Director Shari Lundenberg
be of interest to you. If you do not want MultiMedia Pharma Sciences, LLC. to make
Gwen Salas
your contact information available to third parties for marketing purposes, simply Senior Vice President,
GSalas@mjhlifesciences.com
email mmhinfo@mmhgroup.com and a customer service representative will assist Mergers & Acquisitions,
you in removing your name from MultiMedia Pharma Sciences, LLC. lists. Senior Graphic Designer Strategic Innovation
Helena Coppola Phil Talamo
LCGC North America does not verify any claims or other information appearing in
HCoppola@mjhlifesciences.com
any of the advertisements contained in the publication, and cannot take responsi- Executive Creative Director
bility for any losses or other damages incurred by readers in reliance of such content. Jeff Brown
CUSTOM PROJECTS
To subscribe, email mmhinfo@mmhgroup.com. Founder
Vice President, Content, Mike Hennessy Sr
Custom Projects 1960 - 2021
Subscribe to Colleen Hall
our newsletters CHall@mjhlifesciences.com
for practical 485F US Highway One South,
tips and Director Suite 210
valuable resources Robert Alaburda Iselin, NJ 08830
RAlaburda@mjhlifesciences.com (609) 716-7777
Build Your Own
HPLC Column
Hamilton offers 21 polymer-based stationary phases and two silica
gels (C8 and C18) to satisfy most separation/purification needs. Our
specialty resins are offered in a wide variety of hardware dimensions.
We Build It!
© 2023 Hamilton Company. All rights reserved. All trademarks are owned and/or registered by Hamilton Company in the U.S. and/or other countries.
Hamilton Americas & Pacific Rim Hamilton Europe, Asia & Africa
Hamilton Company Inc. Hamilton Bonaduz A.G.
4970 Energy Way Via Crusch 8
Reno, Nevada 89502 USA CH-7402 Bonaduz, Switzerland
Web: www.hamiltoncompany.com Tel: +1-775-858-3000 Tel: +41-58-610-10-10
USA: 800-648-5950 Fax: +1-775-856-7259 contact.pa.ch@hamilton.ch
Europe: +41-58-610-10-10 sales@hamiltoncompany.com
440 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
profiles, application notes, and a directory of companies. • Deirdre Cabooter – KU Leuven (University of Leuven), Leuven, Belgium
We are also pleased to provide you with the quality editorial
• Peter Carr – University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
that you’ve grown to expect from LCGC. The effect of particle
monodispersity in HPLC column performance is the topic of • Jean-Pierre Chervet – Antec Scientific, Alphen a/d Rijn, The Netherlands
this month’s “Column Watch,” where we explore the impact
• André de Villiers – Stellenbosch University, Stellenbosch, South Africa
of particle size distribution on chromatographic parameters,
and discuss the trend towards improved monodispersity of • John W. Dolan – LC Resources, McMinnville, Oregon
silica particles for enhanced HPLC performance.
• Michael W. Dong – MWD Consulting, Norwalk, Connecticut
Nick Snow reflects on current state of sample preparation
in GC in the first of a two-part “GC Connections.” Discussing • Kevin Endres – DuPont, Wilmington, Delaware
the results of a recent LCGC survey, Snow emphasizes the
• Szabolcs Fekete – Waters Corporation, Geneva, Switzerland
critical role of sample preparation in gas chromatographic
analysis, setting the stage for a follow-up installment • Emanuela Gionfriddo – University of Toledo, Toledo, Ohio
focusing on specific sample preparation techniques and • Joseph L. Glajch – JLG AP Consulting, Nashua, New Hampshire
their management.
“Focus on Food Analysis” examines automated aroma • James P. Grinias – Rowan University, Glassboro, New Jersey
and flavor profiling of honey using high-capacity sorptive • Davy Guillarme – University of Geneva, University of Lausanne, Geneva, Switzerland
extraction. and demonstrates how this technique can combat
• Emily Hilder – University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia
food fraud by uncovering subtle differences between tested
honey samples through automated statistical analysis. • John V. Hinshaw – Serveron Corporation, Beaverton, Oregon
Our peer-reviewed cover story, “Approaches to Accelerate
• Ronald E. Majors – Analytical consultant, West Chester, Pennsylvania
Liquid Chromatography Method Development in the
Laboratory Using Chemometrics and Machine Learning,” • Debby Mangelings – Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels, Belgium
explores innovative workflows and the implementation
• R.D. McDowall – McDowall Consulting, Bromley, United Kingdom
of computer-aided methods, emphasizing the role of
machine learning in optimizing kinetic and thermodynamic • Michael D. McGinley – Phenomenex, Inc., Torrance, California
parameters for liquid chromatography.
• Mary Ellen McNally – FMC Agricultural Solutions, Newark, Delaware
Finally, our featured article, “Multi-Analyte Method
(MAM) for the Analysis of Agriculture Product Technical • Imre Molnár – Molnar Research Institute, Berlin, Germany
tool for regulatory laboratories, offering an efficient and • Koen Sandra – RIC Group, Kortrijk, Belgium
accurate means of analyzing technical active ingredients
used in formulated products. • Pat Sandra – RIC Group, Kortrijk, Belgium
As 2024 approaches, the world of separation science • Peter Schoenmakers – University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
continues to advance at a dizzying pace, and we want
• Kevin Schug – University of Texas, Arlington, Texas
you to know we are working hard to stay at the forefront
of this scientific field and endeavor to keep our readers • Nicholas H. Snow – Seton Hall University, South Orange, New Jersey
fully informed of the latest developments. We encourage
• Dwight Stoll – Gustavus Adolphus College, St. Peter, Minnesota
you to explore these articles, columns, and features to stay
informed and inspired by the cutting-edge developments • Michael E. Swartz – Karuna Therapeutics, Boston, Massachusetts
in the field of chromatography.
• Caroline West – University of Orléans, France
TRIPLE DETECTION FOR ADVANCED
POLYMER CHARACTERIZATION
n Tosoh Bioscience is a registered trademark, and EcoSEC Elite and EcoSEC are trademarks of Tosoh Corporation.
LenS is a trademark of Tosoh Bioscience LLC.
LC TROUBLE SHOOTING
A s 2023 comes to a close, I’ve been things to keep in mind, including get-
reflecting a bit on the problems ting a second opinion and the value of a
with instrumentation that I’ve encoun- robust professional network.
Does It Make Sense?
A few troubleshooting cases this year
have highlighted the importance of
tered this year, both through messages In the October 2020 installment of asking a basic question when consid-
from folks in my professional network “LC Troubleshooting,” I wrote about ering potential causes of instrument
who ask me troubleshooting questions, some essential principles of effec- malfunction, and potential solutions—
and in my own laboratory. In the process tive troubleshooting (1), referring to a does it (that is, the cause or solu-
of thinking about these various prob- manual developed by the U.S. Army tion) make sense? Part of what makes
lems, a few themes have emerged, and that provides an introduction to logical troubleshooting most analytical instru-
I think it is worthwhile sharing them here troubleshooting (2). The list of principles mentation challenging is that there are
because—at least on the timescale of a included: so many ways for things to go wrong.
career spent working with instruments— 1. Change one thing at a time Given all these possibilities, it is also
they are relevant to all of us at some 2. Do no harm not hard to come up with a pretty long
point. I’m a big fan of systems—systems- 3. Drawers are not repair centers list of potential causes and solutions.
based approaches to tackling complex 4. Build up knowledge about Moreover, it is typically prohibitively
problems, and a systematic approach expected behavior expensive to actually evaluate all the
to problem solving. Maybe this is the 5. Documentation helps in the potential causes and solutions in the
training I had as a young scientist rub- long run laboratory. Thus, it is exceedingly
bing off on other parts of my work, but 6. Know when to ask for help important to critically evaluate each of
I think a systematic approach to liquid them so that we can prioritize which
chromatography (LC) troubleshooting is In this installment, I’d like to extend ones from the list we will actually eval-
Icon Image: Joe Zugcic / Zugcic Photographers, Inc.
very valuable because it leaves us with this list with two additional ideas: uate. Prioritizing the wrong possibili-
“results” that we can interpret and use to 7. Does it make sense? ties can lead to a lot of wasted time,
inform rational next steps in the trouble- 8. Get a second opinion effort, and money working through the
shooting process. If we don’t follow a causes that are unlikely to be the real
systematic approach, the only tool we Developing troubleshooting habits problem, and the solutions that are
have at our disposal is a trial-and-error based on these principles can lead to unlikely to work.
approach, which is usually frustrating, more effective and efficient trouble- So, how do we actually evaluate the
and it can also be very expensive. In shooting over time, reduce stress over potential causes and solutions? I guess
this installment, I elaborate on this point instruments that don’t work, and lead as individual troubleshooters we either
using troubleshooting cases I’ve encoun- to significant savings in the cost of need to have the expertise and knowl-
tered this year to emphasize important instrument operation. edge needed to critically evaluate the
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 443
causes and solutions, or we need to sure to increase”; and 2) “Check the elusive. They explained to me that
seek out the expertise and knowledge flow rate: Verify that the flow rate is the main symptom they observed
from other individuals or sources. As within the recommended range for the was bubbles in the waste line of the
I often say to my students, in 2023 column and the instrument. If the flow pump during purging, and that after
the question is not whether informa- rate is too high, it can cause increased purging, the pump would slowly lose
tion on a particular topic exists, but pressure.” On the other hand, some pressure to the point where the pump
rather discerning which information is responses did not make sense at all. was unusable. They also indicated that
“good” (as in correct, accessible, and For example: “Check the detector: the pump vendor suggested that the
approachable), or “bad.” Determining Verify that the detector is properly cause of these symptoms was that
which troubleshooting advice is good calibrated and functioning correctly. If their method involved a high concen-
or bad can be tricky, especially if it the detector is not calibrated correctly, tration of a commonly used organic
comes from a source unfamiliar to us. it can cause increased pressure.” This solvent (and not tetrahydrofuran [THF],
At a minimum, though, we can ask a simply has no basis in reality. How by the way). My first reaction upon
simple, yet powerful question—does it could calibration of a detector affect hearing the facts of the case was that
make sense? A couple of months ago the pressure drop in an LC system? In the stated cause of the symptoms sim-
when I was playing around with Chat- this case, I would not seriously con- ply did not make any sense. I could not
GPT, I asked it some LC troubleshoot- sider evaluating this potential cause of imagine any physically- or chemically-
ing questions. For example, I asked it: my pressure problems, and move on based line of reasoning that would
“What should I do if the pressure on my to other possibilities instead. lead to this explanation. Although the
HPLC instrument is too high?” Some Another real-life troubleshooting suggested cause of the problem could
of the responses made good sense, example from the mailbag will help possibly have been correct, it seemed
including: 1) “Check the column: illustrate the value of asking—does it improbable, and there would be many
Make sure that the column is properly make sense? Earlier this year, a PhD other explanations that I would put
installed and has not been damaged. chemist with considerable experi- on a list before the one that was sug-
Check for any clogs or debris in the ence in LC reached out to me about gested. In the end, after further inves-
column that may be causing the pres- a problem with a pump that had been tigation, it turned out that the actual
YMC America
For all Your Liquid Chromatography Needs
cause of the bubbles was that the is that if the conclusion of the exer- such as books and expert sources like
pump head was so loose that it was cise is that I’m going to spend a lot of LCGC magazine. However, as I thought
drawing air into the pump head from time and money on a repair, then I will about the question after our board
the back, and then pushing that air always get a second opinion moving meeting, alongside of my thoughts
out of the head, which manifested as forward. Much like it is common to get about this installment of LC Trouble-
bubbles in the waste stream. second opinions on health matters in shooting, it occurred to me there is a
cases where the suggested interven- deep and important connection here.
Get a Second Opinion, tion is going to be painful, expensive, A big reason to join a chromatography
Particularly if the Fix is or both, we should also feel comfort- discussion group is that it can be a
Going to Be Expensive able reaching out for a second opinion really efficient way to grow your profes-
On two separate occasions in the past in cases of troubleshooting complex sional network, and a network of 10, or
year, a troubleshooting exercise I’ve instrumentation where there is high 30, or 100 chromatographers that you
participated in has led to the conclu- potential for misdiagnosis and painful can reach out to at the drop of a hat
sion that a very expensive repair would and expensive repairs. to get some troubleshooting advice is
be required involving the replace- invaluable. Just think about this—an
ment of an electronic board. In each Professional Networks Hold annual membership in the MCF costs
case, the troubleshooting process Tremendous Value—Grow Yours, a whopping $25. This fee buys you
was guided remotely by a person very and Use It to Help You admission to quarterly MCF meetings
knowledgeable about the particular Troubleshoot where you get to know tens of other
instrument. In the first instance, I con- I live in the upper Midwestern state of chromatographers in the area. There is
tacted a different person I knew that Minnesota in the United States, and a good chance that one of them will
had intimate knowledge of the instru- we have a local (regional) professional have good advice when you encounter
ment, purely on a hunch that we should organization for chromatographers and the next problem with your LC instru-
double-check to be sure we were not those with some affinity for chroma- ment that you can’t answer. If their
overlooking a different explanation for tography called the Minnesota Chro- advice saves you from a single visit by
the cause of the symptoms. Indeed, matography Forum (MCF). I have been a service engineer, this will probably
the second person suggested a com- involved with MCF in various ways for save you or your employer enough
pletely different potential cause, and it approximately 20 years, but currently money to pay for a lifetime member-
turned out that resolving this problem, I chair the Symposium and Educa- ship in the MCF.
which was entirely software-related, tional committees. At our most recent On a related note, recently Dr. Jim
resolved the root cause and we did not board meeting, we were discussing Grinias and I interviewed Dr. Kevin
have to replace any parts at all! Hav- the trajectory of the organization and Schug for LCGC’s podcast Analytically
ing had this experience, it was natural related factors including a lot of turn- Speaking (www.chromatographyonline.
for me to seek a second opinion again over in membership as we see long- com/analytically-speaking-podcast). I
a few months later when we encoun- time members retire, and many new like to finish these conversations with
tered a different set of symptoms with people coming into the field. We also some quick, light questions, and one
the same instrument. Again, the sug- discussed how the Covid-19 pandemic of them is: “If you could wave a magic
gested remedy was replacement of a has or has not affected how scientists wand and solve any problem in your
very expensive electronic board. As in and their employers interact with an laboratory, what it would it be?” Kevin’s
the first case, a second expert on the organization like MCF. At one point answer (paraphrasing here) was that he
instrument suggested a different line during the discussion one of the board would wish to have service contracts for
of inquiry that ultimately concluded in members asked rather pointedly— all the instruments in his laboratory. As
finding that the observed symptoms what is our response to people who an academic researcher (Kevin is at the
were software-related and could be ask what is the value of membership in University of Texas at Arlington), instru-
addressed at the level of the software, MCF? In other words, why should they ment maintenance is an acute, persis-
rather than replacing electronic com- bother joining and regularly attend tent challenge because the organiza-
ponents of the instrument. MCF events (typically three quarterly tions we typically seek funding from
No troubleshooter I know has a per- meetings and an annual symposium, in (as well as our host institutions), such
fect track record, and sometimes the our case)? I think this is a fair question, as corporate sponsors and govern-
best of us misdiagnose. The point here especially in 2023, post-pandemic, in a mental agencies, are not fond of pay-
is not that I think we can completely time when it seems increasingly likely ing for instrument maintenance. My
eliminate those mistakes and over- that people turn more to AI tools like point in bringing this up here is that
sights. Rather, the lesson I’ve learned ChatGPT for answers rather than con- in laboratories where funds for service
from these troubleshooting exercises sult the historical sources of expertise, contracts simply are not available, hav-
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 445
COLU MN
WATCH
why silica remains today the number one designed a process for growing non- lored to produce particle sizes ranging from
support material for chromatographic porous silica particles. By mixing alkyl sili- sub-2-µm through to 10 µm.
stationary phases despite the availabil- cate with ammonium in a water-alcohol The difference in uniformity between
ity of other materials such as carbon, solution, the formation of spherical silica polydisperse and monodisperse particles
polymeric supports, zirconia, and hybrid particles was achieved, with the ability to can be seen in Figure 1. The scanning
materials, which have all been evaluated produce different particles sizes by alter- electron microscopy (SEM) images of tra-
over the years. Because of the high sur- ing the reaction conditions. The problem ditional HPLC particles and new mono-
face area and the highly reactive nature was that this produced non-porous parti- disperse particles visually highlights the
of amorphous silica, there are few limi- cles only. Later developments led to sur- uniform size distribution of the new mono-
tations to the stationary phase types factants and porogens being introduced disperse particles.
that have been bound to the surface to as a modification to the Stober process To accurately quantify particle size and
ANALYTICAL
DEGASSING
SOLUTIONS
MEET THE INCREASING
NEEDS OF CHALLENGING
ANALYTICAL WORKFLOWS
WITH A UNIVERSAL DEGASSER
IDEX Health & Science is the
trusted leader in degassing
technology across life science Extended coverage
applications. Our degassing of flow rates
up to 10 ml/min
capabilities support powerful
performance control with
increased solvent compatibility Universal solvent
compatibility
to meet your analytical Highly efficient
workflow needs. compact design
Enhance your analytical workflows by partnering with IDEX Health & Science
for our class-leading degassing capabilities: idex-hs.com/filmdegasser
%
%
distribution, techniques such as electrical
! !"#$% % !%#$
zone sensing or laser diffraction are com- ! !"#$ !%#$
! !"#$ !%#$
monly used. To characterize the particle ! !"#$ !%#$
size distribution generated by either of
these techniques, the ratio of D90/10 may
be applied to gauge the degree of size
uniformity of the particles. The parameter
D90 signifies the point in the size distribu-
tion, up to and including, 90% of the total
volume of material in the sample is “con-
tained.” For example; if the D90 is 6 µm, ! !
this means that 90% of the sample has size ! !
! !"#$%&'()%%()*+",-$%!./%"')0"102%3)4%,5''$*,")-%65-78"96$*9$%
!"#$%&'()%%()*+",-$%!./%"')0"102%3)4%,5''$*,")-%65-78"96$*9$%
! 9"-",)%6)*+",-$92%)18%3:4%'5158"96$*9$%
9"-",)%6)*+",-$92%)18%3:4%'5158"96$*9$%
FIGURE ! 1: Particle SEM imaging, (a) commercial polydisperse
!"#$%&'()%%()*+",-$%!./%"')0"102%3)4%,5''$*,")-%65-78"96$*9$%
!"#$%&'()%%()*+",-$%!./%"')0"102%3)4%,5''$*,")-%65-78"96$*9$% silica particles, and (b)
9"-",)%6)*+",-$92%)18%3:4%'5158"96$*9$%
9"-",)%6)*+",-$92%)18%3:4%'5158"96$*9$%
of 6 µm or smaller. The definition for D50 ! 6)*+",-$9%3;5*+"9%<$,=15-50"$9%>+84?%
6)*+",-$9%3;5*+"9%<$,=15-50"$9%>+84?%
monodisperse particles (Fortis Technologies Ltd).
6)*+",-$9%3;5*+"9%<$,=15-50"$9%>+84?%
6)*+",-$9%3;5*+"9%<$,=15-50"$9%>+84?%
is then the size point below, in which 50% % %
%
of the material is contained. Similarly, the %
D10 is the size below, in which 10% of the
material is contained. This description has
long been used in size distribution mea-
surements. As the particle size distribution
for chromatographic silica moves towards
monodisperse then the D90 and D10 val-
ues become closer together and the D90/10
ratio moves toward a value of 1.
Using a Coulter Multisizer 3 (Beckman
Coulter Inc.), an electrical zone sensing
instrument, we measured two commercial
3-µm porous silicas and compared against
the MFPP. Figure 2 shows the particle dis-
tribution of two commercial 3-µm spheri-
cal silica samples in comparison with the %
%
MFPP. As can be seen, both commercial % !"#$%&'%
% !"#$%&'%
silicas have a much broader size distribu- %
!"#$%&'*)%%()*+",-$%9"#$%8"9+*":@+"51%'$)9@*$8%:7%A5@-+$*%,5@1+$*?%/$)9@*"10%)6$*+@*$%BC%&'2%)6$*+@*$%
tion than the monodisperse material, with FIGURE !"#$%&'*)%%()*+",-$%9"#$%8"9+*":@+"51%'$)9@*$8%:7%A5@-+$*%,5@1+$*?%/$)9@*"10%)6$*+@*$%BC%&'2%)6$*+@*$%
2: Particle size distribution measured by Coulter counter. Measuring % aperture
,@**$1+%DCC%&E2%'$)9@*$'$1+%8"-@$1+%"9%F95+51%FF?%A5-5*%G$7%3H*$$1%"9%,5''$*,")-%I%&'%9"-",)%9)'6-$%
% !"#$%&'%
,@**$1+%DCC%&E2%'$)9@*$'$1+%8"-@$1+%"9%F95+51%FF?%A5-5*%G$7%3H*$$1%"9%,5''$*,")-%I%&'%9"-",)%9)'6-$%
one having a slightly smaller mean particle 50 %µm, aperture
EJ% K-@$% current
"9% ,5''$*,")-% 800
I% &'% µA,
9"-",)% measurement
9)'6-$% diluent ,5''$*,")-%
KJ% L$8% "9% '5158"96$*9$%
!"#$%&'% is Isoton I%II.&'%
Color Key: Green
9"-",)% 9)'6-$?%
EJ% K-@$% "9% ,5''$*,")-% I% &'% 9"-",)% 9)'6-$% KJ% L$8% "9% '5158"96$*9$% ,5''$*,")-% I% &'% 9"-",)% 9)'6-$?%
L$9@-+"10%1@':$*9%)*$%9=5M1%"1%<):-$%F?%
is!"#$%&'*)%%()*+",-$%9"#$%8"9+*":@+"51%'$)9@*$8%:7%A5@-+$*%,5@1+$*?%/$)9@*"10%)6$*+@*$%BC%&'2%)6$*+@*$%
commercial 3 µm silica sample A; Blue is commercial 3-µm silica sample B; Red is
size and the other a slightly larger mean L$9@-+"10%1@':$*9%)*$%9=5M1%"1%<):-$%F?%
!"#$%&'*)%%()*+",-$%9"#$%8"9+*":@+"51%'$)9@*$8%:7%A5@-+$*%,5@1+$*?%/$)9@*"10%)6$*+@*$%BC%&'2%)6$*+@*$%
monodisperse commercial 3-µm silica sample. Resulting numbers are shown in Table I.
,@**$1+%DCC%&E2%'$)9@*$'$1+%8"-@$1+%"9%F95+51%FF?%A5-5*%G$7%3H*$$1%"9%,5''$*,")-%I%&'%9"-",)%9)'6-$%
%
particle size than the 3 µm specified in the ,@**$1+%DCC%&E2%'$)9@*$'$1+%8"-@$1+%"9%F95+51%FF?%A5-5*%G$7%3H*$$1%"9%,5''$*,")-%I%&'%9"-",)%9)'6-$%
EJ% K-@$%% "9% ,5''$*,")-% I% &'% 9"-",)% 9)'6-$% KJ% L$8% "9% '5158"96$*9$% ,5''$*,")-% I% &'% 9"-",)% 9)'6-$?%
manufacturer’s literature. EJ% K-@$% "9% ,5''$*,")-% I% &'% 9"-",)% 9)'6-$% KJ% L$8% "9% '5158"96$*9$% ,5''$*,")-% I% &'% 9"-",)% 9)'6-$?%
L$9@-+"10%1@':$*9%)*$%9=5M1%"1%<):-$%F?%
The D90/10 values calculated from the TABLE I: Results from Coulter counter analysis of three samples of commercial silica.
L$9@-+"10%1@':$*9%)*$%9=5M1%"1%<):-$%F?%
Pore
% volume has to be similar so electrolyte concentration within the particle is the same.
size distribution data can be seen in Table %
1, where the traditional particles possess Monodisperse Commercial Commercial
D90/10 values greater than 1.5. In comparison, Silica Silica A Silica B
the new monodisperse particles achieve a Mean particle size (d50) 2.66 µm 2.49 µm 2.97 µm
D90/10 of 1.1. To this day, commercial silica
columns containing particles with these D90/10 1.14 1.58 1.61
high D90/10 values (>1.5) are being success- Pore volume ccg -1 0.89 0.88 0.89
fully used with an acceptable level of col-
umn efficiency for the user. Theoretically, we
should now expect these monodisperse disperse C12 (internal Fortis Technologies columns of identical dimension. There-
particles to improve column performance. bonding) with a D90/10 value of 1.5. An aver- fore, a gain in the region of 57% efficiency
age efficiency of 72,500 plates per meter because of the difference in the monodis-
Origin of Efficiency with a MFPP (p/m) was achieved. A monodisperse 5µm persity of the particles was achieved.
Figure 3 shows a graph of the average col- particle exhibiting a D90/10 of 1.1 with iden- When the experiment was repeated
umn efficiencies obtained for twenty 150 x tical C12 bonding realized an average with 20 columns of 3-µm particles, the
4.6 mm columns packed with a 5-µm poly- efficiency of 114,000p/m over 20 packed average efficiency for traditional polydis-
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 449
(b)
(a)
FIGURE 3: Efficiency gains over traditional porous particles. Each bar represents the Average of 20 packed columns of each material.
(a) 5 µm traditional porous particles D 90/10 1.5 and 5 µm monodisperse particles D90/10 1.1. (b) 3 µm traditional porous particle and 3 µm
monodisperse particle. All columns: 150 x 4.6 mm; 60:40 acetonitrile:water, flow rate 1mL/min, wavelength 254 nm. Analytes: uracil,
phenol, propiophenone, butyrophenone, napthalene.
perse 3-µm particles was 98,000 p/m. Monodisperse particles a smaller impact from the rapid mass transfer of solutes into
achieved 165,000 p/m on average. and out of the reduced porous shell structure. Further stud-
Figure 4 shows a typical chromatogram from each batch ies (8,9) have suggested that longitudinal diffusion into a
of monodisperse and polydisperse columns or packed col- lower pore volume could be a more significant contributing
umns. Using the 3-µm C12 150 x 4.6 mm columns, efficiency factor than was initially envisaged. With MFPPs, we should
is shown to be significantly higher on the monodisperse potentially see the same gains from the A term (Eddy dif-
column, as would be expected. Efficiency is manifested
chromatographically as improved resolution and sensitivity.
This research will continue to include multiple column
diameters (that is, 3 mm and 2.1 mm i.d. columns) to ascertain
the contribution from packing and to ensure it is represen-
tative across dimensions and is not adversely influenced by
increased wall effects or the inherent difficulty in packing nar-
row bore columns.
So, What Causes This Efficiency Increase Seen in HPLC Over 25 Years of
Columns Packed with Monodisperse Particles?
Assuming the particles are packed under controlled conditions
Quality HPLC and
and testing has been optimized (reduced dwell volume of sys- SFC Columns
tem to a minimum), there will be three main parameters which
contribute to lower reduced plate heights (5) (hmin) as defined
in the van Deemter equation. The first term, A (Eddy diffusion)
is the function of the size and distribution of the interparticle
channels or nonuniformities in the packed bed. Secondly, the
B term is inversely proportional to linear velocity so describes
the molecules diffusion in the axial direction into and out of the
Offering a wide range
pore structure. Finally, the C term which is proportional to linear
velocity represents the mass transfer of the molecule from the of phases and dimensions for
solvent into the particle stationary phase and back again. both analytical and prep
When superficially porous particles (SPP) with narrower
particle size distributions came to market (6.7), it was widely
assumed that their lower h min counts were attributed to www.pci-hplc.com | 609.860.1803
the narrower PSD, allowing the formation of homogenous
packed beds and therefore, a reduced A term, coupled with
450 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
250
pore diameter. From the results shown
2.49µm
in Figure 5, we can see that although
200
um2.66µm the mean particle size affects the back-
2.97µm pressure, the degree of monodispersity
bar
150 um
ing in chromatography with increased improved monodispersity. By increasing Ken Butchart is co-founder
and Research Director of For-
speed, efficiency, and sensitivity. How- monodispersity we have in effect simulta- tis Technologies Ltd and has
ever, these changes always appeared neously eliminated both small and large master degrees in Chemi-
to provide a benefit at the expense of particles, and their respective contribution cal Technology and Business
another parameter, whether that be to increasing and decreasing back pressure from Bradford and Strathclyde Universi-
ties. Over the past 25 years he has worked
the high backpressure trade-off for the is therefore canceled out. Hence, we see directly in the chromatography industry,
efficiency gain in UHPLC, or the lim- no net increase in backpressure. specifically on the manufacture of silica
ited sample loading and cost trade- By maintaining a fully porous struc- particles and the design and commer-
off made for the efficiency gain seen ture in these monodisperse particles cialization of stationary phases for HPLC.
With a proven track record of successful
with SPP particles. With the develop- we show the high surface area leads to product development, he has presented
ment of a monodisperse fully porous high sample loading capacity. Our load- his research and development data at
particle (MFPP) there is now a com- ing studies showed a >4-fold increase symposia worldwide. His continued focus
mercially available silica support that in capacity on a simple pharmaceutical remains on the improvement of particle
and phase chemistry performance in order
brings performance benefits without molecule when comparing to a high effi- to provide the analytical chemist with the
associated drawbacks. ciency core-shell particle. best tools for achieving their desired chro-
MFPP particles have now been opti- We acknowledge how even with the matographic separations.
mized to a degree where commercial- enhanced efficiency of a monodisperse Mark Woodruff co-founded
ization has now been achieved. Improv- particle, a choice of orthogonal station- Fortis Technologies Ltd in
ing the particle morphology has led to ary phases is critical to the more complex 2005, having spent 10 years
developing stationary phases
gains in efficiency over existing porous samples faced in the current pharmaceu-
for what used to be the Hyper-
particles in the region of 50–60%, giving tical and biomolecule workflow. This topic sil brand. Mark worked as the Technical
greater sensitivity and resolution. These will be covered in further articles. manager and the Global Product Manager
gains are attributed to the reduced Further study of these monodisperse for HPLC columns at Thermo Hypersil. Mark
has a BSc and Masters in Analytical Chem-
A-term as a result of the better flow path particles will revolve around additional
istry as well as an MBA from Manchester
through the interstitial spaces in the comparison with SPP, trying to under- University (UK). Mark is currently involved
packed column bed. stand all of the contributions leading in the development and marketing of new
Our studies show when comparing to the source of the efficiency gains. columns from Fortis Technologies and has
an excellent relationship with many key
equivalent 3-μm monodisperse packed Assuming the A-term, particle size and
people in major pharmaceutical compa-
beds and polydisperse packed beds we packing density are similar with both, nies in order to ensure that the needs of
see no discernible backpressure differ- what is the difference between C-terms? the industry are met.
ences that could be attributed to the Also, can you compartmentalize the col-
Cheminert UHPLC injectors, switching valves, and selectors make it easy. Internal
volume is minimized with zero dead volume. A proprietary rotor material and
stator coating on some models achieve pressures up to 20,000 psi,suitable for
the most demanding analytical techniques. All models are compatible with any
VICI actuation option.
454 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
GC
CONNEC TIONS
plotted against log K. If K is large, indicating TABLE I: Sample types amenable to common sample preparation techniques for GC
that the analyte is much more soluble in the (S = solid, L= liquid, G = gas).
organic phase than the aqueous phase (as Technique Sample Types
is commonly seen in gas chromatographic “Neat” injection L, G
methods, when extracting organic com-
Dissolving in a solvent S, L
pounds from water or other aqueous systems
Liquid-liquid extraction (LLE) L
into an organic phase), then a nearly com-
plete, or quantitative, transfer of the analyte Solid-phase extraction (SPE) L
from the aqueous phase to the organic phase Sorbent Extractions (SPME, SBSE) L, G
is possible. QuEChERS L
The second subtlety, also seen in Figure 1, Headspace extraction (SHE, DHE) S, L
is seen in the relative volumes of the sample Membrane extraction L, G
(in this case aqueous) phase and the extract
Supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) S
(organic) phase. The micro-liquid-liquid extrac-
Accelerated solvent extraction (ASE) S
tion (MLLE) case is a low, but roughly equal,
volume of both phases, volumes that would Pyrolysis S
fit into a single autosampler vial; the high case Thermal desorption S
is a large volume of aqueous phase extracted Microwave
! assisted extraction (MAE) S
with a small volume of organic phase, while !
the low case is like MLLE, but using a smaller
volume of organic phase and a large volume
of aqueous phase. Finally, SPME represents
an extreme volume difference with the very
low-volume coated fiber immersed in a large
volume of aqueous sample.
The third subtlety is that while equilibrium
constants may be very large or very small,
they are finite. This means that in any extrac-
tion system, even with a very large constant,
some amount of the analyte will remain in
!
the original phase. This challenge opens an FIGURE 1: Comparison of some extraction methods. MLLE–liquid-liquid extraction with
)*+,-%&.(!90'(&23-0.!07!-0'*!*J+2&1+30.!'*+40<-A!M>>KU)3563<I)3563<!*J+2&1+30.!T3+4!/0+4!
additional idea that has not been explored both phases of low volume; SPME–solid-phase microextraction; High–large volume of
(4&-*-!07!)0T!H0)6'*V!%LMKU-0)3<I(4&-*!'3120*J+2&1+30.V!Q3?4U)&2?*!H0)6'*!07!&56*06-!(4&-*!
much in the literature. If the equilibrium con- aqueous phase extracted with a small volume of organic phase; Low–like MLLE but using
*J+2&1+*<!T3+4!&!-'&))!H0)6'*!07!02?&.31!(4&-*V!>0TU)3W*!M>>K!/6+!6-3.?!&!-'&))*2!H0)6'*!07!
02?&.31!(4&-*!&.<!&!)&2?*!H0)6'*!07!&56*06-!(4&-*A!!!!
a smaller volume of organic phase and a large volume of aqueous phase.
stant is small, multiple extractions form the ! !
same sample, using a fresh extraction phase,
can result in appreciable extraction of the In short, when diluting or making solutions, simplest case, we have individual particles
analyte when the separate aliquots of the allow sufficient time for complete mixing. partitioning between two phases. Extraction
extraction phase are combined. We see, from the simplest of techniques, kinetics may be complicated by additional
A fourth subtlety is that for any chemi- that all sample preparation methods require matrix components in the sample phase that
cal reaction or process, especially extraction, time to come to equilibrium. This amount of bind or adsorb the analytes of interest. In any
reaching equilibrium takes time. Even in the time may be on the same order of or longer method development involving extraction,
simplest of systems, a “dilute and shoot” than the time required for the chromato- the kinetics of extraction should be carefully
procedure, the diluted liquid must be mixed. graphic separation. Our fifth subtlety in all studied. A kinetic plot for a simple and fun
When diluting one liquid by another, how sample preparation techniques is kinetics. extraction is shown in Figure 2. This is the
does the analyst know that the two liquids While equilibrium determines how much extraction of fats from a chocolate bar using
have fully mixed into a homogeneous mix- analyte we can transfer between phases, supercritical fluid extraction (5). In this case,
ture? Mostly, we count on indirect evidence kinetics determines how long it takes. Due time is measured by the volume of supercriti-
based on our judgment of the time and vig- to the variety and complexity of most sam- cal carbon dioxide delivered at constant flow.
orousness of mixing, appearance of the solu- ples, the kinetics of extraction must be deter- This is a quantitative extraction example, but it
tion, and reproducibility of the data. The same mined experimentally and may vary widely shows the key elements of extraction kinetics.
questions apply to simply dissolving solids. for seemingly similar samples. For the best reproducibility and maxi-
Mostly, we determine that the solid has dis- Fortunately, coming back to the simplicity mum recovery, extraction should be allowed
solved when we no longer see particles, and of equation 1, most extraction techniques fol- to proceed for long enough so that the
we also know that no solid dissolves instantly. low or approximate first order kinetics. In the amount extracted is expressed on the flat,
456 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
!
!
3+#4+&5'6"5'#+4%,+#7
80 often-overlooked time, complexity, kinetics,
60 and equilibrium involved in sample prepara-
tion may often be the most important and
40
challenging steps in the full method.
20
0
References
0 200 400 600 800 (1) Majors, R. E. Trends in Sample Preparation.
!"#$%&'()%*)(+',%-./+'0/12'
!"#$%&'()%*)(+',%-./+'0/12' LCGC 1991, 9 (1), 16–20.
!"#$%&'()%*)(+',%-./+'0/12'
!"#$%&'()%*)(+',%-./+'0/12'
!
)*+,-%& (!KJ+2&1+30.!07!7&+!720'!&!1&.< !/&2!6-3.?!-6(*2123+31&)!7)63<!*J+2&1+30.A! *(23.+*<!T3+4! (2) Raynie, D. Trends in Sample Preparation, Part
FIGURE 2: Extraction of fat from aA!90(
(*2'3--30.!720'!2*7*2*.1*! candy
23?4+!bar! using supercritical
'*231&.!94*'31&)!%013*+ A!!! fluid extraction. Reprinted I: Current State of the Field, LCGC N. Am.
with permission from reference (5). Copyright 1996, American Chemical Society. 2023, 41 (9), 374–380,393. DOI: 10.56530/lcgc.
na.tu5672b5
nearly horizontal part of the curve. Small • Equilibrium constants, large or small, are (3) Snow, N. H. Is Golay’s Famous Equation for
variations in the extraction time or condi- finite. There is always some analyte in both HETP Still Relevant in Capillary Gas Chroma-
tography? Part 1: A Common View of HETP.
tions will have the least effect on this por- phases. LCGC N. Am. 2022, 40 (1), 22–26,31. DOI:
tion of the curve. Shorter extraction times, • Dissolving and mixing take time. 10.56530/lcgc.na.uk4587d6
where the curve is steeper, can be used • Extractions are subject to kinetics. (4) Snow, N. H. Is Golay’s Famous Equation for
with calibration, but at the risk of larger • Glassware has inherent experimental HETP Still Relevant in Capillary Gas Chroma-
tography? Part 2: Assumptions and Conse-
uncertainty and impact of minor variations uncertainty. quences. LCGC N. Am. 2022, 40 (2), 68–71.
in the extraction conditions. Returning to the survey results, Raynie DOI: 10.56530/lcgc.na.mm7085y7
A sixth subtlety is the experimental uncer- points out some interesting changes since (5) Snow, N. H.; Dunn, M.; Patel, S. Determination
tainty inherent in the use of glassware for vol- 2003 that, along with the subtleties, provide of Crude Fat in Food Products by Supercriti-
cal Fluid Extraction and Gravimetric Analysis.
umetric measurements and sample transfers. some interesting challenges and observa- J. Chem. Educ. 1996, 74 (9) 1108–1111. DOI:
The most common experimental error that tions about the current state and future of 10.1021/ed074p1108
impacts all analytical methods, including GC, sample preparation for GC. In the survey, (6) Snow, N. H. Is the Solution Dilution? Hidden
is the experimental error and overconfidence several shifts are seen since 2013, with new Uncertainty in Gas Chromatography (GC)
Methods. LCGC N. Am. 2022, 40 (7), 304–308.
involved with any use of volumetric glass- fields, including cannabis, cosmetics and DOI: 10.56530/lcgc.na.re9187d2
ware, which is often assumed to be error-free, personal care and a drop in the percentage (7) Snow, N. H. Green Chemistry: What Is It (and
but is not. A second, often hidden, error is of users reporting work in pharmaceuticals. What Is It Not)? And How Does It Apply to Gas
seen in the volume of the glassware itself, In all industries, there are both increased Chromatography? LCGC N. Am. 2023, 41 (5),
176–180. DOI: 10.56530/lcgc.na.az3979e4
as pipets and flasks have increasing relative regulation and pressure to “go green” with
uncertainty as their volumes get smaller. This reduced solvent and consumable usage, ABOUT THE AUTHOR
is discussed in detail in a previous column, miniaturization, more efficient laborato-
Nicholas H. Snow
where we see that smaller volume flasks and ries along with lower detection limits and is the Founding Endowed
transfer pipets introduce larger experimental reduced experimental uncertainties (7). Inter- Professor in the Depart-
uncertainties, and that, with improved instru- estingly, the subtleties can work against these ment of Chemistry and
Biochemistr y at Seton
mentation over the decades, these uncer- pressures, as the kinetics of extraction often
Hall University, and an Adjunct Pro-
tainties may eclipse those from the instru- work toward longer extraction times and fessor of Medical Science. During his
mentation or other method steps (6). In short, lower sample throughput, and the glassware 30 years as a chromatographer, he
there is a tradeoff of increased experimental uncertainty favors larger samples and more has published more than 70 refereed
articles and book chapters and has
uncertainty when using serial dilution meth- solvent usage. When evaluating techniques,
given more than 200 presentations
ods or any method that requires additional users report the greatest importance in price, and short courses. He is interested
sample transfers and volume measurements, time, recovery and low contamination. in the fundamentals and applications
which use smaller solvent volumes and sin- Sample preparation and GC are inher- of separation science, especially gas
chromatography, sampling, and sam-
gle-step dilution, which uses larger volumes. ently connected. One cannot run a gas chro-
ple preparation for chemical analysis.
In summary, six subtleties in sample prep- matograph without samples, and all samples His research group is very active, with
aration result from the seeming simplicity of require some amount of preparation, from ongoing projects using GC, GC–MS,
equation 1. the simplicity of loading “neat” samples into two-dimensional GC, and extraction
methods including headspace, liq-
• The equilibrium constant determines how vials, through the complexity of on-line instru-
uid–liquid extraction, and solid-phase
much can be extracted. mental extractors, such as accelerated solvent microextraction. Direct correspond-
• The relative volumes of the two phases extraction (ASE), supercritical fluid extraction ence to: LCGCedit@mmhgroup.com
determine how much can be extracted. (SFE), and headspace. All extraction tech-
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 457
FOCUS
ON
FOO D
ANALYSIS
tion, are becoming obsolete because FIGURE 1: Automated sample extraction workflow on the Centri platform.
they involve time-consuming sample
preparation and pollen analysis by spe-
cially trained analysts. As a result, a new Experimental space extraction, HiSorb DVB/CWR/
type of analysis is required. This article The samples analyzed were five dif- PDMS inert-coated (H4-AXAAC) probes
demonstrates how a high-capacity ferent varieties of honey, including a were used, with the whole process being
sorptive extraction technique can be mass market honey, hobbyist honey, fully automated using a Centri 360
used to sample key aroma compounds forest honey, Manuka honey, and extraction and enrichment instrument
in different types of honey samples to Welsh honey. A sample of golden (all Markes International). Each sample
assess their potential for use as unique syrup was also used as a sixth sample was analyzed five times for reproduc-
markers of authenticity. The different for comparison. The samples were ibility, and the scan range on the gas
properties of the compounds in honey prepared in a 20 mL headspace vial chromatography–mass spectrometry
mean that sorptive phase combinations containing 1 g of sample and 1 mL of (GC–MS) system was 35–450 m/z. The
must be selected carefully to maximize water. Vials were crimp-capped and software used for data mining and che-
uptake and achieve the most compre- sonicated, and the analytes extracted mometrics was ChromCompare+ (Sep-
hensive profile. from the headspace (Figure 1). For head- Solve Analytical).
458 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
2
1
2 0
)
Syrup
nts
1 Mass market
cou
Hobbyist
2 0
05
Manuka
1
1 Forest
(×
Welsh
ce
2 0
an
nd
1
u
Ab
2 0
1
2 0
1
0
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Retention time (min)
FIGURE 2: Aroma profiles of syrup (red), mass market (blue), hobbyist (purple), Manuka (pink), forest (light green), and Welsh honey
(dark green).
Results
Aroma Profiling of Honey
The aroma profiles generated for each sample (Figure 2) indi-
SONNTEK/Knauer cated that some compound classes were common to all the
honey samples, but others differed between samples. Each
class contributed characteristic aromas; for example, ketones,
New HPLC Compact Pump common in all samples, confer buttery and nutty odors.
with 10ml stainless steel pump head Multiple esters were discovered in all samples, which was
not unexpected given that this group of compounds provides
sweet and fruity aromas. Aldehydes were prominent, bestow-
ing fresh, green, and herbal notes. Alcohols, which add fresh
flavors to honey, were a large component. They can occur natu-
rally or as a result of heat treatment during processing (3).
Furans, known for their sweet woody notes, are also common
in honey and are typically present because of the dehydration
of reducing sugars in the matrix. Their presence can also indi-
cate that thermal processes and storage after collection from
hives have degraded the sugars in the honey (2).
Overall, the honey profiles had common descriptors of fruity
and sweet notes. However, naphthalene, an aromatic hydrocar-
bon commonly derived from coal, was also highlighted as an
On Sale and In Stock in USA odor in one honey sample. This off-odor may have come from the
smoke used by beekeepers to calm bees before removal of honey
from hives (4).
PH: 201-236-9300 Sales@sonntek.com
Combating Food Fraud Using Markers
To distinguish the key variances between samples, a cus-
tom library of VOCs in each sample was created using the
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 459
Forest
Welsh
Manuka
Hobbyist
FIGURE 3: Principal components analysis score plot in the software for the comparison of honey varieties extracted using DVB/CWR/
PDMS HiSorb.
Relative abundance (n = 5)
Manuka Welsh
1.5
0.5
le can e
l-5 th ce ol e
e
et hy ioc ne
ce al de
ro e
iso he ate
-m et ph ne
et pa ne
xy y-2 -Cy an
l
en e
ld de
lo de ur e
t- d)
nz ac in e
ro th lde ol
]h ano l
ea ald ol
no
n
hy Me xya xyt at
yl oat
yd tan
.2 (fu ura
xy 1-N hyd
n
en
et rad eno
h no
i
ya yl s hy
yd e za n
-(1 l t to ue
o e
en et alo
p ur
hy no
ta y
ze
n
ty oyl top cyl
he
-H M n na
-4 -p m
ce eh
2-
ya
ah Oc
f
f
)p
be o
r
lb
L
ep
hy e
r
th
o
t
ho dr
.1
tr
xi
-
-m
Be e-1
lte
ho ox
bi ol o
x
[2
ro
o- ed
y
hy
Bu nz
yd
yd
xe
t
o
t
la
ie
Be
l
cy
H
M
et na
he
D
1-
2-
et
4'
im s-Li
lo
5-
yl
M
yc
2,
h
an
1-
-c
et
l-3
tr
M
hy
PREMIUM LIQUID
Tr
2-
7-
et
7,
im
1,
CHROMATOGRAPHY
4-
α,
SOLUTIONS
The SCION LC 6000 high FIGURE 4: Comparison of relative abundance for the top 20 differentiating compounds
performance liquid chromatograph identified in five honey varieties and a golden syrup.
HPLC, guarantees confidence in
results, having been engineered
for excellent life-time performance. as confirmatory markers when classify- used to extract a wide range of com-
Designed for accuracy, reliability ing samples of unknown origin that are pounds, particularly those with key
and speed, this instrument
maximizes uptime and productivity labeled as Manuka. aroma and flavor properties.
while minimizing cost of operation.
Featuring an extensive range of Conclusions
automation options, our HPLC will Analysis of the VOC content of This article has additional
optimize workflows and make the foodstuffs is important in the food supplemental information
laboratory experience simpler and
more efficient. and beverage industry, with a wide only available online.
range of applications in research Scan code for link.
Key Features: and development, quality control,
• Excellent Detector Performance shelf-life assessment, and the detec- ABOUT THE AUTHOR
• Low Volume Degassing Options tion of food fraud. A common tech-
• Extra Large Solvent Cabinet
Rachael Szafnauer
nique in food VOC profiling is sorp-
received an MSci in forensic sci-
• Manual Injection Valve tive extraction, wherein compounds ence from the Universit y of South
• Super Gradient Performance and partition from food onto a sorptive Wale s, UK , w here her final-year
Excellent Flow Rate Precision projec t focused on fingerprinting
phase and are transferred to analyti-
• Excellent Injection Volume emerging psychoac tive substances
Precision and Ultra-Low Carry-Over cal instrumentation such as a GC–MS
using advanced techniques such as
• Peltier-Based Heating system for separation and detection GC×GC–TOF-MS, in collaboration
(5). Sorptive extraction offers a highly with Markes International. She later
sensitive, robust, and fully automat- took up the role of thermal desorp-
tion produc t specialist at Markes,
able extraction solution, and provides
providing technical and application
excellent results in GC–MS-based suppor t to the commercial team,
analysis of foodstuffs. before taking on her current role
For more as produc t marketing manager and
information This article has demonstrated that
specializing in the development of
on the LC6000 SCAN TO VISIT sorptive extraction is a highly effi-
applications using ex trac tion and
please visit: OUR WEBSITE cient technique for the VOC profiling enrichment techniques for GC– MS.
of honey samples. The technique was
! scioninstruments.com
462 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
as a quality descriptor.
Software-assisted
Untargeted optimization suffers from Optimization
Computer-aided
1 2 3
the vast number of adjustable param- method development
2. Simulate
eters and the large interdependence 1. Retention
modelling candidate
3. Candidate
selection
gradients
between these. It is inherently difficult
to predict whether a change in param- FIGURE 2: Example of a generic representation of a method development workflow.
eters will result in an improved method.
Improving one metric (analysis time) ing that both analytes experience a to be highly sample dependent, and
may result in worsening another met- similar column efficiency (that is, N 1 = it has been extensively treated else-
ric (resolution). Computer-aided devel- N 2), we can rewrite equation 1 as fol- where (14,15). It is outside the scope
opment of a chromatographic method lows (13): of this review.
thus requires a balanced approach. Equation 2 can be schematically
N –1 • k expressed in the context of method
RS = •
Resolution to Adjust a Chromato- 2 +1 1+k [2] development workflows as depicted
graphic Method: in Figure 2, which represents a typical
One useful quality descriptor that quan- Now, we have resolution quantified as case often faced by chromatographers.
tifies the degree of separation, yet also the product of three contributions: effi- After having used their experience to
instructs on possibilities to improve it, is ciency (N), selectivity ( ), and average select an appropriate column and ini-
the resolution (equation 1): retention factor (k). Equation 2 demon- tial method parameters, chromatogra-
strates that the only means to adjust phers are recommended to first adjust
tR,2 – tR,1 the separation is to change something the method conditions by altering
RS = 2σ + 2σ
1 2 [1] within either of these three parameters. thermodynamic parameters that affect
At this point, it is important to retention and selectivity. For example,
Here, the separation between ana- acknowledge the significance of sam- they may change the gradient program
lytes 1 and 2 is expressed with tR and ple preparation and the crucial effect or—if necessary—adjust the selectiv-
representing the retention time and this has on the method development ity dramatically by selecting a differ-
peak standard deviation. When assum- workflow. Sample preparation tends ent column or mobile-phase chemistry.
464 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Finally, they may opt to improve the effi- PO strategy for the chromatographic For column selection, stationary
ciency or analysis time of the method separation of a phenolic red-wine extract phase characterization methods aim to
by regarding the kinetic parameters. (19), implemented a predictive kinet- simplify the end user’s choice of sta-
Different approaches that have been ic-optimization tool for a hydrophilic tionary phases based on characterizing
developed to facilitate method devel- interaction liquid chromatography×re- the physicochemical interactions with
opment through automated workflows versed-phase liquid chromatography small-molecule probes. For an extensive
or chemometrics will be reviewed in the (HILIC×reversed-phase LC) separa- review the reader is referred elsewhere
following sections. tion of procyanidins (11), and used the (22). The best-documented example
same tool to compare reversed-phase is the hydrophobic subtraction model
Kinetic Parameters LC×HILIC and HILIC×reversed-phase LC (HSM) developed by Snyder, Dolan, and
Improving the efficiency (that is, the for phenolic analysis (20). In all cases, co-workers, which may be used to select
theoretical plate number) of the sepa- optimization of kinetic parameters pro- columns with different selectivity (23).
ration provides a clear metric relevant vided higher peak capacities and pro- Recently, workflows have emerged
to method optimization, as it increases duced valuable knowledge on the influ- related to selectivity screening for 2D-LC
the peak capacity for the separation ence of under-sampling, dilution factors, method development. For example,
and decreases the likelihood of coelu- and band broadening. Zhang and associates developed a mul-
tion. For 1D-LC it is possible to predict tiple heart-cut 2D-LC setup for pharma-
how different parameters will affect Thermodynamic Parameters ceutical purity testing that enabled auto-
the efficiency. Another method is the Selectivity in liquid chromatography mated screening of the 2D selectivity (24).
use of kinetic plots (16). However, the is influenced by the thermodynamic In other work, Wang and co-authors
square-root dependence of R s on N parameters related to analyte interac- (25) used an automated column screen-
implies a rapidly diminishing return on tions with the mobile and stationary ing framework for analyzing chiral and
investment. phases. Changes in mobile phase com- achiral impurities, with online multiple
In comprehensive two-dimensional position, gradient program, stationary heart-cutting 2D-LC; in a similar study,
liquid chromatography (LC×LC), kinetic phase chemistry, pH, or temperature Zhang and co-workers described fast
optimization schemes can be applied to can significantly affect the distribution of chiral and achiral profiling of com-
substantially improve the method. This peaks in a chromatogram. While modi- pounds with multiple chiral centres by
is attributed to the additional parame- fying the mobile phase, pH, or tempera- an LC–multicolumn-LC approach (26).
ters, including the second-dimension ture is relatively straightforward in theory, Together with automated data acquisi-
(2D) column dimensions, and phenom- in practice this may not suffice to meet tion, these workflows constituted a step
ena such as under-sampling (of the 1D the objectives of the separation. Chang- forwards, but interpretation and pro-
effluent) and 2D sample-dilution (17). ing the stationary phase in principle cessing of the data are still dependent
Vivo-Truyols and associates proposed requires a re-optimization of the mobile on manual input and user experience.
the use of sample-independent Pareto phase, making it more expensive in
optimization (PO) for LC×LC (18). In this terms of effort (apart from the column Interpretive Automation
chemometric-driven approach, multiple cost), but generally provides broader In an ideal scenario, a method devel-
method parameters (column dimen- changes in selectivity. opment workflow must be capable of
sion, flow rates, gradient slope) were Various strategies and workflows have integrating all previously discussed
varied and the effects thereof were been described to select appropriate parameters and optimizing these in an
evaluated using (theoretically related) chemistries for both the mobile and automated and interpretive manner.
quality descriptors such as peak capac- stationary phases in LC. One such strat- In this context, the word interpretive
ity, analysis time, and dilution factor. egy involves optimizing the parameters implies that the chromatograms are inter-
The authors demonstrated that opti- through a Design-of-Experiments (DoE) preted as a result of the elution of the indi-
mizing the kinetic parameters can be workflow, in which sets of parameters vidual analytes. In the workflow the peaks
highly rewarding and that this approach (for example, mobile phase, temper- should be tracked and simple models
is suited to deal with tradeoffs between ature, pH) are varied and an extensive may be established for each analyte—all
different objectives. The PO method screening is performed, often on multi- of this in an unsupervised and automated
provided optimal values for a large ple columns, to determine the optimum manner. Based on the analyte models,
number of parameters, including 1D approach. Similar approaches are com- many chromatograms can be simulated
and 2D particle sizes and column diam- monly used in the industry (21). They and the objective function can be opti-
eters, while taking into account pressure may be efficient in terms of manpower mized. Such a method development
restrictions. required, but can be quite inefficient workflow has the potential to minimize
This work was extended by the group in terms of numbers of measurements, manual input and the expertise required
of de Villiers (11,19,20), who applied the time, solvents, and instruments required. for developing complex methods.
466 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Bos and associates developed the sented a CRF based on connective for accelerated method development
AutoLC approach, in which the mobile components in graph theory to assess (40,41). Machine learning has the poten-
phase gradient was optimized in a both separation quality and time. It has tial to enhance various stages of the
closed-loop fashion (27). Based on an also been demonstrated that the selec- chromatographic-analysis workflow,
earlier theoretical LC×LC proof-of-prin- tion of inappropriate quality descriptors including baseline and noise correction
ciple study (28), and the pioneering can lead to suboptimal separations (27). (42), retention-time or retention-index
work of Dolan and co-workers (29), Bos Therefore, it is crucial to create CRFs that prediction (43–45), peak detection
and co-authors designed an algorithm can effectively weigh quality descriptors, (46,47), peak annotation (48), and clas-
that could accommodate different while the program provides quantitative sification (49). This section will focus on
chemometric optimization strategies. information regarding various practical the utilization of machine learning to
Two examples were presented: one aspects of analytical queries, such as optimize the gradient program, which
using empirical retention modelling, method time and sensitivity. frequently relies on several of the afore-
and one using the machine-learning The second challenge is related to the mentioned stages.
Bayesian optimization technique. In data processing. The quality of the out- One type of machine learning is
both cases, the algorithm developed put of an algorithm relies strongly on the artificial neural networks (ANNs).
multi-segment gradient programs to input data and the data processing. Any The application of neural networks in
optimize the retention and selectivity error in background correction, peak chromatography has been explored in
of separations of a monoclonal anti- detection, or peak tracking can lead the past (50–53). In a recent study, Ken-
body digest by LC–MS. to cascading errors in later iterations sert and associates (42) investigated the
The examples above demonstrate the (27). While MS provides information to potential use of reinforcement learning
possibility of including computer-as- reduce the errors in 1D-LC, data pro- for selecting optimal isocratic scouting
sisted optimization strategies for kinetic cessing remains a significant challenge runs for retention modelling. The neu-
and thermodynamic parameters in for LC×LC. This is especially the case for ral network was trained on simulated
automated workflows. However, despite peak tracking, where an algorithm must data using a Q-Learning algorithm and
the significant progress made, three establish the location of each analyte evaluated based on the accuracy of the
major challenges remain that need to across multiple signals and account for retention predictions for 57 small-mole-
be addressed to achieve a closed-loop, incorrect clustering of coeluting peaks cule analytes in situ experiments. While
interpretive algorithm for developing (37,38). In addition, it is difficult to quan- the work is promising, the algorithm
LC methods in a completely unsuper- titatively compare the performance of from this study has only been tested on
vised and automated manner. the large number of data processing isocratic data for a specific reversed-
The first and arguably most impor- approaches available (27,39). phase LC setup with a limited number
tant challenge is to define quality The third challenge concerns the of simplistic molecules. A downside of
descriptors that can assess the quality computation costs associated with the the use of artificial neural networks is
of a separation. The success or failure large number of simulations and the that they require a large amount of data
of the optimization process critically number of parameters that need to for training. This can be mitigated with
depends on the objective function. The be optimized. Improving the perfor- simulated data, but this carries a risk
latter depends on quality descriptors mance of the algorithm either requires of the model not capturing the actual
that, in turn, may depend on chemical more measurements or more simulated chromatographic space with sufficient
and physical parameters. The objective data that resemble the experiments accuracy (46).
function serves as the primary driving more closely. The former increases the Several authors have explored the
force for every algorithm. Single-num- amount of time and solvent needed, potential of evolutionary algorithms to
ber descriptors, known as chromato- while the latter requires more compu- optimize gradient profiles (35,54). In
graphic response functions (CRFs), have tational power. Machine learning tech- particular, Hao and co-authors (54) used
been developed to quantify the critical niques may be employed to reduce the a genetic algorithm to optimize mul-
information that the method is intended computation time required. ti-linear gradient profiles for the sepa-
to provide. Various CRFs have been pro- ration of lignin-degradation products.
posed in the past (30). Although many Machine Learning They validated their simulations by
CRFs exist for 1D-LC, few are availa- Interest in machine learning methods is comparison with experimental measure-
ble for 2D-LC (31–36). Alvarez-Segura rapidly gaining momentum in the field ments and found good agreement. Huy-
and co-workers recently included peak of chromatography (7). The increasing gens and associates (35) investigated
prominence in their CRF (33,34), Huy- computational power available, com- evolutionary strategies for optimizing
gens and associates (35) introduced a bined with the demand for advanced 1D and 2D separations through in silico
CRF for 2D-LC based on peak purity, simulation tools, has led to the explo- experiments of an LC×LC separation of
and Boelrijk and co-authors (36) pre- ration of machine learning approaches 100 experiments. Their genetic algo-
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 467
rithm required less than 100 experiments that the efficiency of Bayesian optimiza- mation sciences. Automated LC method
to reach a better CRF than a grid search tion is heavily dependent on the accu- development workflows are rapidly
of 625 experiments. This suggests that rate definition of the objective function. advancing through the implementation
evolutionary algorithms have the poten- Machine learning approaches show of chemometric and machine learning
tial to guide search-based method tremendous potential to optimize algorithms. Nevertheless, despite the
development, accelerate computational the gradient program, yet the most potential and promise of such algo-
model-based method development, advanced applications often have limi- rithms to expedite method develop-
and deal with many parameters simul- tations that render them unsuitable for ment, the challenges are still daunting
taneously. However, the authors sim- widespread use. This is partly due to the and require a combined effort by the
plified the experimental conditions by fact that these models can only handle chromatographic and chemometric
assuming perfect orthogonality, equal scenarios that were present in the train- communities. Better ways must be found
concentrations, and perfect Gaussian ing data. Insufficient data can stem from to mathematically express the chroma-
peaks. This raises concerns over the risk a lack of appropriate standards or from tographic end goals, improve data anal-
of oversimplification and the underutili- insufficient resources to perform all the ysis (peak detection), and invent smart
zation of the full range of variations in necessary measurements. One way to algorithms that can interpret chroma-
chromatographic conditions, as can also alleviate this issue is by employing simu- tographic data and combine these
occur with neural networks. lated data, but this approach only works with fundamental kinetic (kinetic plots)
One of the biggest limitations of effectively if the simulated data closely and thermodynamic (retention mod-
applying machine learning is the resemble real-world situations, which is els) concepts to create better methods.
required amount of data. An emerg- frequently not the case. With the rapid Meanwhile there is also the continuous
ing optimization method that is less advancements in the field of machine need for chromatographers to deepen
dependent on the amount of input learning, the issues currently encoun- the understanding of physicochemical
data is Bayesian optimization, a type of tered are expected to be addressed in interactions of analytes inside our col-
machine learning tool that can optimize the near future. umns. The use of machine learning has
expensive-to-evaluate functions (expen- recently been demonstrated by several
sive in terms of computation cost), even The Need for a Combined Effort groups to show great promise (35,55).
when there is a low amount of data Driven by the ever-increasing need for From the above-mentioned strate-
available. Due to the compatibility with more information, separation technol- gies it is clear that optimization work-
black box functions, only the score ogy is advancing faster than our ability flows, especially for selectivity, remain
itself needs to be ascertainable, while to use it to its full potential. Despite the heavily dependent on prior knowledge
the underlying mechanics or processes enormous size and importance of the of the sample dimensionality or a tri-
do not necessarily need to be under- field, separations are often performed al-and-error approach. New machine
stood or known. Boelrijk and co-au- under suboptimal conditions and tech- learning algorithms should be able
thors investigated the potential use of nical capabilities remain unused. For to optimize more parameters without
Bayesian approaches for LC×LC in silico advancements in LC, such as 2D-LC, to needing unreasonable amounts of data.
(36); they developed an unsupervised make a significant impact, it is impera- Other approaches may entail optimiz-
closed-loop algorithm to predict 1D-LC tive that our community develops tools ing subsets of parameters at a time to
gradient profiles for a complex dyestuff to fully exploit the current potential. lower the dimensionality of the problem
mixture (55) and compared Bayesian To this end, the chromatographic or combining retention modelling with
optimization to retention modelling for community must continue to deepen its machine learning; in that way, aspects
automated method development (27). understanding of fundamental concepts. that can be well described do not need
These studies demonstrated the versa- This review has underlined the huge to be captured in the machine learn-
tility of Bayesian approaches and high- benefits and impressive advancements ing models. The practical challenges
lighted their applicability in method by scientists who have developed tools are mostly on the required number of
development workflows, with the added to streamline method development, measurements or computations. Every
benefit of being less reliant on retention focusing on kinetic or thermodynamic optimization process is quicker when
models and peak tracking. However, a parameters—or both. Many of these starting with a good setup. By scanning
potential limiting factor for LC×LC is the advances are expressed as improved various columns at the start, a good
maximum number of parameters that method development workflows that estimate can be made of which columns
can be optimized simultaneously. Due capture the experience and knowledge show potential and are candidates for
to the multivariate nature of the method, of the chromatographer. orthogonal separation in 2D-LC.
the number of necessary measurements However, the chromatographic com- Computer-aided method develop-
for each additional parameter increases munity cannot do it alone. Indeed, we ment for LC has been under develop-
exponentially. The authors emphasized need the help of computers and infor- ment for some four decades and it has
468 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
ters by a Versatile Two-Dimensional (36) Boelrijk , J.; Pirok , B.; Ensing, B.; (46) Kenser t, A .; Bos ten, E.; Collaer t s,
Multicolumn Liquid Chromatography Forré, P. Bayesian Optimization of G.; et al. Convolutional Neural Net-
(LC-mLC) Approach. J. Chromatogr. C o m p r e h e n s i v e Tw o - D i m e n s i o n a l wor k for Au tomated Peak Detec -
A 2020, 1620, 460987. DOI: 10.1016/j. Liquid Chromatography Separations. tion in Reversed-Phase Liquid
chroma.2020.460987 J. Chromatogr. A 2021, 1659, 462628. Chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A
(27) Bos, T. S.; Boelrijk, J.; Molenaar, S. DOI: 10.1016/j.chroma.2021.462628 2022, 1672, 4 630 05. DOI: 10.1016/j.
R. A.; et al. Chemometric Strategies (37) Pirok, B. W. J.; Molenaar, S. R. A.; Roca, chroma.2022.463005
for Full y Au to mate d Inte r p ret i ve L. S.; Schoenmakers, P. J. Peak-Track- (47) Risum, A . B.; Bro, R. Using Deep
Method Development in Liquid Chro- ing Algorithm for Use in Automated L e a r n i n g t o E v a l u a t e Pe a k s i n
matography. Anal. Chem. 2022, 94 Inter pretive Method - Develo pment C h r o m a t o g r a p h i c D a t a . Ta l a n t a
(46), 16060 –16068. DOI: 10.1021/ac s. Tools in Liquid Chromatography. Anal. 2019, 204, 255 –260. DOI: 10.1016/j.
analchem.2c03160 Chem. 2018, 9 0 (23), 14 011–14 019. talanta.2019.05.053
(28) Pirok, B. W. J.; Pous-Torres, S.; Ortiz- DOI: 10.1021/acs.analchem.8b03929 (48) Bonini, P.; Kind, T.; Tsugawa, H.; Baru-
Bolsico, C.; Vivó-Truyols, G.; Schoen- (38) Molenaar, S. R. A.; Dahlseid, T. A.; pal, D. K.; Fiehn, O. Retip: Retention
makers, P. J. Program for the Interpre- Leme, G. M.; et al. Peak-Tracking Time Prediction for Compound Anno-
tive Optimization of Two-Dimensional Algorithm for Use in Comprehensive tation in Untargeted Metabolomic s.
R e s o l u t i o n . J . C h r o m a t o g r. A Two-Dimensional Liquid Chromatog- Anal. Chem. 2020, 92 (11), 7515 –7522.
2016, 1450, 2 9– 37. DOI: 10.1016/j. raphy – Application to Monoclonal- DOI: 10.1021/acs.analchem.9b05765
chroma.2016.04.061 Antibody Peptides. J. Chromatogr. (49) Kant z, E. D.; Tiwari, S.; Watrous, J.
(29) Dolan, J. W.; Snyder, L. R.; Quarry, M. A 2021, 1639, 461922. DOI: 10.1016/j. D.; Cheng, S.; Jain, M. Deep Neural
A. Computer Simulation as a Means of chroma.2021.461922 Networks for Classification of LC-MS
Developing an Optimized Reversed- (39) Niezen, L. E.; Schoenmakers, P. J.; Spectral Peaks. Anal. Chem. 2019, 91
Phase Gradient-Elution Separation. Pirok, B. W. J. Critical Comparison of (19), 124 07–12413. DOI: 10.1021/ac s.
Chromatographia 1987, 24 (1), 261– Background Correc tion Algorithms analchem.9b02983
276. DOI: 10.1007/BF02688488 U s e d i n C h r o m a t o g r a p h y. A n a l. (50) Met ting, H. J.; Coenegracht, P. M.
(30) Ty teca, E.; Desmet, G. A Universal Chim. Acta 2022, 1201, 339605. DOI: J. N e u r al N e t w o r k s in Hig h - Pe r-
C o m p a r i s o n St u d y of C h ro ma to - 10.1016/j.aca.2022.339605 for mance L iq uid Chromatog r a phy
graphic Response Functions. J. Chro- (40) Houhou, R.; Bocklit z, T. Trends in O p t i m i z a t i o n: Re s p o n s e S u r f a c e
matogr. A 2014, 1361, 178 –190. DOI: Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learn- Modeling. J. Chromatogr. A 1996,
10.1016/j.chroma.2014.08.014 i ng, a n d C h e m o m e t r ic s A p p lie d 728 (1–2), 47– 53. DOI: 10.1016/0 021-
(31) Duar te, R. M. B. O.; Matos, J. T. V.; to Chemic al Data. Anal. Sci. Adv. 9673(96)82447-2
D uar te, A . C . A New C hromato - 2021, 2 (3 – 4), 128 –141. DOI: 10.1002/ (51) Marengo, E.; Gianot ti, V.; A ngioi,
graphic Response Func tion for ansa.202000162 S.; Gennaro, M. C. Optimization by
Assessing the Separation Qualit y in (41) Subraveti, S. G.; Li, Z.; Prasad, V.; E xperimental Design and Ar tificial
C o m p r e h e n s i v e Tw o - D i m e n s i o n a l Ra j e n d r a n, A . C a n a C o m p u te r Neural Net work s of the Ion- Inter-
L iq uid C hro matog r a p hy. J. Chro - “Learn” Nonlinear Chromatography?: ac tion Reversed-Phase Liquid Chro-
matogr. A 2012, 1225, 121–131. DOI: Phy sic s - Ba s e d D e e p N e u r al N e t- matographic Separation of Twent y
10.1016/j.chroma.2011.12.082 works for Simulation and Optimiza- C o s m e t ic Pre s e r v a t i ve s. J. Ch ro -
(32) Matos, J. T. V.; Duarte, R. M. B. O.; Duarte, tion of Chromatographic Processes. matogr. A 20 04, 1029 (1–2), 57– 65.
A. C. Chromatographic Response Func- J. Chromatogr. A 2022, 1672, 463037. DOI: 10.1016/j.chroma.2003.12.044
tions in 1D and 2D Chromatography as DOI: 10.1016/j.chroma.2022.463037 (52) Novotná, K.; Havliš, J.; Havel, J. Opti-
Tools for Assessing Chemical Complex- (42) Kensert, A. Collaerts, G.; Efthymiadis, misation of High Performance Liquid
ity. TrAC Trends Analyt. Chem. 2013, 45, K.; et al. Deep Convolutional Autoen- Chromatography Separation of Neu-
14–23. DOI: 10.1016/j.trac.2012.12.013 coder for the Simultaneous Removal ro prote c t i ve Pe pt id e s: Fr ac tional
(33) Alvarez-Segura, T.; Gómez-Díaz, A.; of Baseline Noise and Baseline Drif t Experimental Designs Combined with
Or tiz-Bolsico, C.; Torres-Lapasió, J. in Chromatograms. J. Chromatogr. A Ar tificial Neural Net works. J. Chro-
R.; García-Alvarez- Coque, M. C. A 2021, 1646, 4 62093. DOI: 10.1016/j. matogr. A 20 05, 1096 (1–2), 50 – 57.
Chromatographic Objective Function chroma.2021.462093 DOI:10.1016/j.chroma.2005.06.048
to Characterise Chromatograms with (43) Albaugh, D. R.; Hall, L. M.; Hill, D. W.; (53) Malenovi , A.; Jancic-Stojanovic, B.;
Unk now n Com pound s or W ithout et al. Predic tion of HPLC Retention Kosti , N.; Ivanovi , D.; Medenica, M.
Standards Available. J. Chromatogr. Index Using A r tificial Neural Net- Optimization of Artificial Neural Net-
A 2015, 1409, 79– 88. DOI: 10.1016/j. works and IGroup E-State Indices. J. works for Modeling of Ator vastatin
chroma.2015.07.022 Chem. Inf. Model 20 09, 49 (4), 788 – and Its Impurities Retention in Micel-
(34) N a v a r r o - H u e r t a , J. A .; A l v a r e z - 799. DOI: 10.1021/ci9000162 lar Liquid Chromatography. Chro-
Seg ur a, T.; Tor re s- L a pasió, J. R.; (44) Hall, L. M.; Hill, D. W.; Bugden, K.; et matographia 2011, 73 (9–10), 993 –998.
García-Alvarez-Coque, M. C. Study al. Development of a Reverse Phase DOI: 10.1007/s10337-011-1994-6
of the Per formance of a Resolution HPLC Retention Ind ex Mod el for (54) Hao, W.; Li, B.; Deng, Y.; et al. Com-
Criterion to Charac terise Complex Nontarg eted Metabolomic s Using puter Aided O ptimization of Mul-
Chromatograms with Unk nowns or Synthetic Compounds. J. Chem. Inf. tilinear Gradient Elution in Liquid
Without Standards. Anal. Methods Model 2018, 58 (3), 591– 6 0 4. DOI: Chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A
2017, 9 (29), 4293 – 4303. DOI: 10.1039/ 10.1021/acs.jcim.7b00496 2021, 1635, 4 6175 4. DOI:10.1016/j.
C7AY00399D (45) Ju, R.; Liu, X.; Zheng, F.; et al. Deep chroma.2020.461754
(35) Huygens, B.; Ef thymiadis, K.; Nowé, Neural Net work Pretrained by (55) Boelrijk, J.; Ensing, B.; Forré, P.; Pirok,
A .; Desmet, G. Application of Evo- Weighted Autoencoders and Transfer B. W. J. Closed-Loop Automatic Gra-
lutionar y A lg orithms to O ptimise Learning for Retention Time Predic- dient Design for Liquid Chromatog-
One - and Two - Dimensional Gradi- tion of Small Molecules. Anal. Chem. raphy Using Bayesian Optimization.
ent Chromatographic Separations. 2021, 93 (47 ), 15 6 51–15 6 5 8. DOI: Anal. Chim. Acta 2023, 1242, 340789.
J. Chromatogr. A 2020, 1628, 461435. 10.1021/acs.analchem.1c03250 DOI: DOI:10.1016/j.aca.2023.340789
DOI: 10.1016/j.chroma.2020.461435
CATEGORY SPONSORED CONTENT
In November 2022, OpenAI’s launch of ChatGPT transformed Artifi- Addressing common chromatographic challenges is one potential
cial Intelligence (AI),1 and more specifically, generative AI, from sci- application AI-driven improvements in the laboratory, but there are nu-
ence fiction to an everyday reality. While there is no doubt that gen- merous other opportunities. There are many tedious and human error-
erative AI is going to be a disruptive technology across a multitude prone steps to follow in an analytical workflow that are better suited
of industries, AI techniques like machine learning (ML) and deep for AI-powered automation to perform, such as data review and in-
learning have been utilized within the scientific laboratory setting strument maintenance. Additionally, complex and highly manual tasks
for several years, particularly in drug discovery and development. such as setting up runs for method development and data analysis that
In fact, there have been several highly publicized collaborations are currently done in third party applications such as Excel can benefit
between pharmaceutical companies and AI technology providers from AI solutions. Identifying a problem that AI could solve is likely the
that have started to yield results.2,3 For example, In Silico Medicine easiest step in the process. The harder challenge is getting the data.
entered clinical trials with the first new therapeutic where AI was
used to identify the target and generate the design.4 Other recent Building the data set
partnerships, like the new collaboration between Imperial College, The challenge is that to build AI, ML and advanced analytics solu-
BASF, and Sterling Pharma, are deploying AI to improve continu- tions, data scientists need large data sets to train their models. Given
ous manufacturing processes.5, 6 While scientific organizations are the focus on generation of reproducible, high-quality data in science,
recognizing and capitalizing on the potential of AI in many ways, analytical applications seem to be an obvious opportunity for AI. Un-
there are still many challenges in the present day analytical labora- fortunately, the reality is that the scientific data needed to train AI
tory that AI can be leveraged to overcome.. AI has the potential to models is often siloed in disparate systems. In recognition of these
change the way that we do science inside and outside of the labora- challenges and the growing value of data science, in 2016, the FAIR
tory but, before that ambition can be realized, organizations need to Guiding Principles for scientific data management and stewardship
unlock their data to turn AI from science fiction into science. were published. They focused on the “machine-actionability” of data
in that it needs to be findable, accessible, interoperable, and reus-
Identifying the problem able.7 Open standards like the Allotrope Ontologies and Data Model
The first step in leveraging AI is identifying the problem that needs seek to break down these siloes by creating “linked data that stan-
to be solved and what data is available to inform the solution. AI is dardizes experimental parameters so we can remove human error
particularly well suited for data-rich processes where understand- and enhance scientific reproducibility.”8 While Allotrope and other
ing the data that has been generated can inform and improve that open standards like AnIML9 and MZML10 help to translate scientific
process over time. For example, instrument telemetry data can be data into a common ontology, the reality is that this solution does not
used to inform AI models that warn and ultimately even prevent address all the challenges organizations face.
common run failures. Analytical instruments produce vast amounts Open standards, like MZML, are useful for further data processing
of telemetry data, instrument readouts that do not contain any in- enabled through third-party industry solutions, but as organizations ap-
tellectual property (IP) about what is being run, but describe the petite for AI-driven solutions grows, so will their need for complete, con-
instrument conditions before, during, and after runs. Of course, the textualized data sets. Conversion into a common ontology does not by
reason for instrumental analysis is the scientific data, and AI can itself enable organizations to aggregate and correlate processed results
help here too. AI algorithmic techniques like anomaly detection with the associated instrument telemetry data since it is often not saved
can help identify common analytical challenges in chromatographic with the result files. Given the variety of analytical techniques and other
data by monitoring for variances, such as spikes, baseline noise data sources like Laboratory Information Management Systems (LIMS)
and retention time drift, from the typical patterns’ baselines and and Electronic Laboratory Notebooks (ELNs), it is difficult for organi-
peak detection. A human in the loop approach would allow chro- zations to make meaningful associations across all the different data
matographers to confirm or reject the algorithm’s suggestions that types in their data lake through open standards alone.
there is a trace impurity, gas in the line, or it is time for a new col-
umn. Over time, the algorithm learns how the lab-specific workflow, Automating data pipelines
method, and compounds impact the various chromatogram proper- Rather than doing manual data conversion and upload, organiza-
ties, becoming more accurate and improving its recommendations. tions need automated data pipelines that help them to bring data
from laboratory systems into their data lakes. With real-time data References
pipelines that upload, catalog, transform and store data in compli- (1) https://openai.com/blog/chatgpt#OpenAI
ance with FAIR data principles, organizations can utilize different (2) https://pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/acs.molpharmaceut.8b00930
data science methodologies and tools. Dedicated pipelines also (3) https://www.pharmaceuticalprocessingworld.com/ai-pharma-drug-develop-
have the added advantage that telemetry data, scientific raw data ment-billion-opportunity/
and processed results can all be uploaded and associated, giving a (4) https://www.clinicaltrialsarena.com/comment/first-drug-created-ai-enters-
complete picture of the data as it was acquired. Robust data pipe- trials/?cf-view
lines ensure the data is fully contextualized and avoid what is often (5) https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/238391/imperial-basf-major-partnership-
referred to as a data swamp - the less-than-ideal state where mas- advance-future/
sive repositories of data exist but are unusable.11 (6) https://www.sterlingpharmasolutions.com/articles/sterling-to-join-cross-disci-
As Kate Wearden recently described in The Digital Revolution: plinary-partnership-to-advance-ai-flow-chemistry-techniques/
The Connected Lab of the Future, connectivity is critical to real- (7) https://www.go-fair.org/fair-principles/
izing the Lab of the Future. Today, multiple mechanisms exist to (8) https://www.allotrope.org/
export data from Waters data systems to open standards or to map (9) https://www.animl.org/
and parse data into custom data pipelines. While these solutions (10) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3073315/
meet the needs of many customers today, they are often discon- (11) https://www.cio.com/article/230163/3-keys-to-keep-your-data-lake-from-
nected, manual processes. Our future vision is to eliminate the becoming-a-data-swamp.html
burden organizations face by maintaining these solutions and to
provide contextualized data that is AI-ready through automated
data pipelines. Trish Meek
Sr. Director and Portfolio Owner,
waters_connect Cloud Platform
Summary
We are only beginning to scratch the surface of what AI could do Industry Insights, a paid program
to improve laboratory operations and aid scientific discovery. Given
the strategic importance of chromatography, there is significant
potential to improve laboratory operations and derive insights by
incorporating chromatography telemetry and analytical data into an Marisa Gioioso
organization’s digital strategy. To realize this potential, organizations Global Research Segment Lead
for Connected Science
need to focus on how to FAIRify their data making it available for
scientists and data scientists alike. Robust, automated data pipe- Industry Insights, a paid program
lines will bring data science to scientists so that they can use their
data to solve problems that matter.
Jim Garvey, Olga Nováková, Olivier Pigeon, and Mary Ellen McNally
Standard Preparation
Internal Standard Stock Solution
Dissolve 80 mg of dicyclohexyl phthalate (to
the nearest 0.1 mg) into a 100 mL volumet-
ric flask and dilute to the mark with acetone. FIGURE 1: Example chromatogram of Spirotetramat using the HPLC conditions of the
Internal standard solution concentration is multi-analyte method, concentration is 150 g/L. Axis labels are Time (min) for x-axis and
Signal (mAU) for y-axis.
approximately 0.08 mg/mL.
Calibration Solution
Weigh in duplicate about 10 mg of the
required analytical standard to the nearest 0.1
mg in a volumetric flask (100 mL). Dissolve and
fill to the mark with acetonitrile. This gives a
standard concentration of approximately 100
mg/L, calibration solutions CA and CB.
Sampling
Ideally, an intact product should be taken
from the market as intended for use with an
end user.
FIGURE 2: Example chromatogram of Pendimethilin, CS, using the UHPLC conditions of
Sample Preparation the multi-analyte method, concentration is 455 g/L. Axis labels are Time (min) for x-axis and
Sample preparation is dependent on the Signal (mAU) for y-axis.
474 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
TABLE IV: Formulated products examined by UHPLC conditions of the multi-analyte method less than 1.0% for retention times and by less
FAO than 2.0% for peak areas.
Formulation Declared
No. Active Substance λ (nm) Unit Tolerances
Type* Content
(±) Determination of the Species of Interest
1 Acetamiprid SP 240 g/kg 200 12 For HPLC
Acetamiprid AL 240 g/L 0.05 0.0075 Inject in duplicate 5 µL portions of each sam-
2 Azoxystrobin SC 220 g/L 120 7.2 ple solution, bracketing them by injections of
the calibration solutions as follows; calibra-
3 Clomazone CS 210 g/L 360 21.6
tion solution CA, sample solution S1A, sample
4 Deltamethrin OD 210 g/L 10 1.5
solution S1B, calibration solution CB, sample
5 Difenoconazole FS 210 g/L 25 3.75 solution S2A, sample solution S2B, and so on.
6 Diflufenican SC 230 g/L 40 4 Measure the relevant peak areas.
7 Dimethomorph WP 240 g/kg 60 6
8 Epoxiconazole SC 210 g/L 125 7.5 For UHPLC
9 Fenhexamid SC 240 g/L 500 25 Inject in duplicate 0.5 µL portions of each sam-
ple solution, bracketing them by injections of
10 Fipronil WG 220 g/kg 0.143 0.036
the calibration solutions as follows; calibra-
11 Fludioxonil FS 210 g/L 25 3.75
tion solution CA, sample solution S1A, sample
12 Flufenacet SC 210 g/L 80 8 solution S1B, calibration solution CB, sample
13 Flurprimidol EC 240 g/kg 130 7.8 solution S2A, sample solution S2B, and so on.
14 Giberelin GA4/GA7 SL 210 g/L 10 1.5 Measure the relevant peak areas.
15 Chlortoluron SC 240 g/L 280 14
16 Metamitron SC 220 g/L 700 25 Calculations
Calculate the mean value of each pair of
17 Pendimethalin CS 240 g/L 455 22.75
response factors bracketing the two injections
18 Pethoxamid EC 240 g/L 600 25
of a sample and use this value for calculating
19 Prothioconazole EC 254 g/L 250 15
the active substance contents of the brack-
20 Quizalofop-p-ethyl EC 330 g/L 50 5 eted sample injections as shown below.
21 Pyraclostrobin SE 260 g/L 85 8.5
22 Sedaxane FS 220 g/L 25 3.75 Individual response factors for CA and CB:
23 Silthiofam FS 210 g/L 125 7,5
[1]
24 S-metolachlor EC 220 g/L 960 25
25 Spinetoram SC 254 g/kg 117 7
Mean response factor for CA and CB:
26 Tebuconazole WG 220 g/kg 500 25
Tebuconazole SC 220 g/L 200 12 [2]
27 Tefluthrin GR 220 g/kg 15 3.75
28 Terbuthylazine SE 220 g/L 187.5 11.22 Content of active substance wt % active sub-
29 Thiacloprid OD 210 g/L 100 10 stance =
Thiophanate-
30 GCCB 260 g/kg 23 5,75 [3]
methyl
31 Triclopyr AL 295 g/kg 0.7 0,105
where:
32 Trifloxystrobin WG 220 g/kg 250 15
fi = individual response factor
Triflusulfuron-
33 OD 240 g/L 150 9 f = mean response factor
methyl
Hs = peak area of active substance in the cali-
34 Trinexapac-ethyl EC 240 g/kg 50 5
bration solution
35 Triticonazole FS 260 g/L 25 3.75
Hw = average peak area of the active substance
Source: *Formulation Types: CS – Capsule Suspension, EC – Emulsifiable Concentrate, EW – Concentrated
aqueous emulsion, FS – Flowable Concentrate, GCC – Ground Corn Cob, is an effective carrier for various
from the two injections of the sample solution
pesticides., GR – Granules, ME – Micro Encapsulate, OD – Oil Dispersion, SE – Suspoemulsion (Combination s = mass of the active substance working stan-
of SC and EW), SC – Soluble Concentrate, SG – Soluble Granule, SL – Soluble Liquids, WG – Wettable Granule,
WP – Wettable Powder, XX – Unknown
dard in the calibration solution (mg)
w = mass of sample taken (mg)
P = purity of the active substance working
standard solution until the response obtained from two consecutive injections deviates by standard (g/kg)
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 477
TABLE V: A comparison of linearity and accuracy equivalency data for eight active ingredients by individual GLP enforcement and the
multi-analyte method
Linearity Accuracy
Passed
Correlation Average
Compound Method Type Y-Intercept Slope RSD Modified
Coefficient Recovery (%)
Horwitz
GLP Enforce-
Bifenthrin 0.9998 -25.66 1478 99.53 1.14 Yes
ment
Multi-analyte 1.000 -9.98 1550 100.32 0.87 Yes
Cyantra- GLP Enforce-
1.0000 0.055 719.8 100.18 0.85 Yes
niliprole ment
Multi-analyte 0.9999 0.021 719.7 97.99 0.50 Yes
GLP Enforce-
Indoxacarb 0.9995 0.010 502.5 98.41 0.80 Yes
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9997 0.008 419.6 97.45 1.28 Yes
GLP Enforce-
Flutriafol 0.9991 -23.65 1095 98.94 0.45 Yes
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9999 82.87 1089 99.02 0.33 Yes
GLP Enforce-
Triflusulfuron 0.9999 0.001 95.8 99.12 0.52 Yes
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9999 0.006 97.11 99.25 0.45 Yes
GLP Enforce-
Azimsulfuron 0.9993 -0.014 2.64 100.17 0.23 Yes
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9992 -0.004 2.63 100.16 0.37 Yes
GLP Enforce-
Chlorsulfuron 0.9999 0.014 633.6 98.61 0.48 Yes
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9997 0.043 613.6 98.51 0.61 Yes
n=6
Results and Discussion curve with concentrations at the product in Table V, the correlation coefficient for
The conditions that have been outlined concentration and two further points at each active using both the registration
above for both HPLC and UHPLC have +50% and -50%. Figure 3 shows a typi- method and the multi-analyte method
been used to analyze the compounds cal calibration curve. Repeatability was was 0.99 or greater.
listed in Table III and Table IV, respectively. calculated via dual preparation and dual Both method and instrument precision
Given in these tables are the formulation injection of each sample. Seven individual were tested in these experiments. Eight
types of the samples where the method active ingredients were used to study the individual weighings of one sample of
was used successfully, the UV maximum difference in results for Santé et Consom- each active ingredient were measured
wavelength determined during our exper- mateurs (Directorate General Health and to determine the method precision. One
iments, and the declared content includ- Consumers, European Commission, or sample injected eight individual times
ing the units of the specific material. SANCO) guideline validation parameters defined instrument precision. Results of
Figures 1 and 2 show example chro- (3) using both the registration method for this can also be found in Table V.
matograms for two representative com- the technical material and the multi-ana- Accuracy equivalency was established
pounds analyzed by the HPLC and UHPLC lyte method described herein. The valida- by preparing duplicate samples at three
methods, respectively. tion includes linearity, precision, accuracy, separate concentrations. These concen-
and specificity or selectivity. The active trations were set at 75, 100, and 125% of
Validation of Technical Materials ingredients examined during this compar- the GLP sample solution concentration in
Using the Multi-Analyte Method) ison were chlorantraniliprole, azimsulfuron, the enforcement method. Average weight
Acceptable linearity of the active ingredi- bifenthrin, chlorsulfuron, cyantraniliprole, percent results, which ranged from 98.5
ent for all the products outlined in Table III flutriafol, indoxacarb, and triflusulfuron. to 100.3 with relative standard deviations
and Table IV was demonstrated by using To prove equivalency, a seven-point (RSD) for n=6 ranging from 0.23 to 1.28, all
a characterized analytical standard of the calibration curve was determined for all passed the modified Horowitz limit. The
same AI using a three-point calibration seven active ingredients. As can be seen data can be found in Table VI.
478 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
TABLE VI: A comparison of precision equivalency data for eight active ingredients by individual GLP enforcement and the multi-analyte
method
Linearity Precision
Correlation Average RSD
Compound Method Type Y-Intercept Slope RSD Method
Coefficient Weight (%) Instrument
GLP Enforce-
Bifenthrin 0.9998 -25.66 1478 100 1.18 0.14
ment
Multi-analyte 1.000 -9.98 1550 99.45 0.45 0.09
Cyantra- GLP Enforce-
1.0000 0.055 719.8 98.11 0.86 0.19
niliprole ment
Multi-analyte 0.9999 0.021 719.7 98.67 1.17 0.22
GLP Enforce-
Indoxacarb 0.9995 0.010 502.5 98.59 1.05 0.07
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9997 0.008 419.6 98.20 1.08 0.05
GLP Enforce-
Flutriafol 0.9991 -23.65 1095 100.97 0.41 0.71
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9999 82.87 1089 99.77 0.27 0.23
GLP Enforce-
Triflusulfuron 0.9999 0.001 95.8 99.23 0.21 0.06
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9999 0.006 97.11 99.25 0.28 0.04
GLP Enforce-
Azimsulfuron 0.9993 -0.014 2.64 100.97 0.53 0.06
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9992 -0.004 2.63 101.19 0.52 0.17
GLP Enforce-
Chlorsulfuron 0.9999 0.014 633.6 97.32 0.69 0.20
ment
Multi-analyte 0.9997 0.043 613.6 97.74 0.60 0.11
n=8 n=8
A qualitative analysis for potential to be continually tested for specificity their appreciation to the staff in their
impurity interferences for all samples was with each active ingredient and shows laboratories involved in this work.
conducted to determine method specific- great promise in meeting GLP statistical
ity. Ideally, an impurity exhibits no interfer- requirements.
ence, and acceptable interference is less The multi-analyte method is evergreen This article has additional
than 3% of the overall sample composi- in terms of its future use, and the addition supplemental information
tion. No interferences were seen in either of actives and products are possible if the only available online.
method for the seven active ingredients. following criteria are met: Scan code for link.
• An unequivocal identity confirmation;
Conclusion preferably mass spectrometry
Although the multi-analyte method is not • Injection repeatability data for stan-
Jim Garvey is with the Food Chem-
istry Department of Agriculture at
the registered method, it does provide a dards – RSD should be ≤ 1% the Food and The Marine, Back-
very useful screening tool for laboratories • Linearity should be demonstrated weston, Laboratory Campus, in Cel-
that see a variety of agricultural product between 50 and 150 mg/kg bridge, Ireland. Olga Nováková is
samples. It eliminates the need for a wide • The repeatability for sample analysis with the Central Institute for Super-
vising and Testing in Agriculture at
variety of columns and can accurately should be less than 5%—typically three
the National Reference Laboratory,
measure the active ingredient content in subsamples of the product and two Department of Testing Plant Protec-
the formulated product, thus determining injections of each sub-sample. tion Products, in Brno, Czech Repub-
whether the material meets the registered A proficiency test or collaborative trail lic. Olivier Pigeon is with the Wal-
manufacturer’s specifications. data would be beneficial to support the loon Agricultural Research Centre,
Building Rachel Carson, in Gembloux,
The validation comparison for eight use of this methodology for any addi-
Belgium. Mary Ellen McNally is
active ingredients using the multi-ana- tional agricultural compounds. with FMC Corporation in Newark,
lyte and enforcement methods diligently Delaware. Direct correspondence to:
shows the equivalence of the method for Acknowledgment Mary-Ellen.McNally@fmc.com
linearity, accuracy, and precision. It needs The authors would like to express
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 479
V IE WP OINT S
ExTech 2023, Celebrating 25 Years of
Innovation in Extraction Technologies
Emanuela Gionfriddo
incorporating the fundamentals of extraction committee of ExTech, are proud of the over- the Depar tment of Chemistr y and
processes into graduate and undergradu- all attendance of the symposium, especially Biochemistr y of The Universit y of
Toledo, Ohio. Direc t cor re s pon -
ate textbooks, to train the next generation considering about half of the attendees are dence to: emanuela.gionfriddo@
of scientists and unify teaching strategies PhD students. This testifies that research in the utoledo.edu
for this important and ever-growing field of extraction technology field is very active and
separation chemistry. The plenary concluded vibrant, and we are truly impressed with the
with an important message: “When the next quality of the oral and poster communications Read the full
generation of scientists enters the regulatory delivered by these young scientists.” original version.
affairs, the analytical manufacturers, and the By the end of ExTech, Hernández-Borges Scan code for link.
analytical laboratories, they will have a very delivered a powerful take-home message for
480 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Antec Scientific
SweetSep™ Colums
The new benchmark for superior
separation of all classes of carbohydrates
using HPAEC with PAD or MS detection.
Company Description
For over 33 years, Antec Scientific has been the world’s leading
supplier of analytical instrumentation based on electrochemistry
(EC). Antec’s line of instruments include electrochemical detectors
(ECD), analyzers built on HPLC-ECD, and electrochemical
reactors for use with MS (EC–MS) and synthesis.
CDS Analytical
Major Products/Services
Pyroprobe™ with DISC technology of-
fers easy sample loading, unparalleled
reproducibility, and superior resolution.
The 7550S 72-position Thermal Desorp-
tion autosampler supports the Peltier
electric cooling to handle C2 to C44 level
VOCs with 10,000:1 Sample Split and
quantitative Sample Saver. The 8500A
110-position automated purge and trap
concentrator is the newly launched 3rd
gen Purge and Trap platform to maxi-
mize efficiency for EPA 8260, 524, and
624 methods. The Empore™ SPE 47 mm
and 90 mm disks, 1 ml, 3ml, and 6 ml
cartridges ,96-well plate, Ez-disk and
Stagetip adopts a proprietary membrane
technology from 3M to offer the fastest
flow rate with the smallest dead volume
among all Solid Phase Extraction filtration
Company Description products. The water chiller, rotary evapo-
CDS Analytical is an ISO 9001:2015 certified manufacturer of rator and digestion blocks are reliable
thermal sample preparation instrumentation for 55 years. CDS and cost effective lab equipment to help
offers a complete suite of diverse front-end GC equipment the sample preparation work.
including pyrolyzers for Py-GC-MS, purge & trap concentrator
for EPA waste and drinking water test methods (8260, 524, Facility
624), thermal desorption systems for TD-GC-MS to meet CDS Analytical’s facility is located in Ox-
the requirements from today’s most demanding analytical ford, Pennsylvania. CDS products passed
customers. CDS Analytical has acquired the rights from 3M™ various safety regulations, including CE,
to manufacture licensed Empore™ solid-phase extraction METlab and NRTL. The Oxford plant has
products, extending the reach into laboratory consumables been ISO 9001:2015 certified and has
CDS Analytical to provide solutions for Environmental, Life Science, and GMP-compliant ISO clean room capability.
465 Limestone Road, Biopharma customers. CDS Analytical also distributes various CDS Analytical is bringing its production
Oxford, PA 19363
lab equipment including chillers and rotary evaporators for compliance to the next level..
TELEPHONE chemistry labs.
(800) 541-6593
FAX Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported
(610) 932-4158 ⦁ Pyrolysis-GC-MS
⦁ Purge and Trap-GC-MS
E-MAIL
info@cdsanalytical.com ⦁ Thermal Desorption-GC-MS
⦁ Solid-Phase Extraction
WEB SITE
www.cdsanalytical.com
Markets Served
YEAR FOUNDED CDS Analytical products have been serving the following
1969 markets as: Polymer, Rubber, Environmental, Aerospace,
Automobile, Energy, Food and Flavor, Forensics, Paper &
Ink, Pharmaceuticals, Semiconductor, Textiles, Tobacco, Life
Science, and Clinical Diagnosis.
482 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
CEM Corporation
Hamilton Company
Chromatography Products for HPLC and GC
with the pressure stability of silica-based
columns. With our Polymeric Reversed Phase
(PRP™) HPLC columns and resins, the sample
dictates the necessary separation conditions,
not the limitations of the column. We can
also customize HPLC columns to meet a
desired application need. Each product is
manufactured to achieve the highest level
of accuracy.
Major Products/Services
Gas generator modules can be operated as
stand-alone calibrators or combined into a
Gas Standard Generator System.
LR EA B
A DY?
powered by
GET READY
486 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Major Products/Services
LabVantage’s integrated laboratory
informatics platform includes the most
technologically and architecturally modern
Laboratory Information Management
System (LIMS) available, with optional
embedded Electronic Lab Notebook
(ELN), Laboratory Execution System
(LES), and Scientific Data Management
System (SDMS). LabVantage Analytics, an
advanced analytics solution seamlessly
integrated to offer AI, ML, and more
through the platform, enhances analysis
and insights from a greater range of data:
LIMS, business, and external sources.
The complete LabVantage platform is
entirely configurable without the need
for any coding. It features modern
technology and architecture that enable
Company Description remote, compliant user-access from
LabVantage Solutions is the recognized leader in any device; its zero-footprint means no
enterprise laboratory software and services, as well as client programs or plugins to install or
advanced analytics. More than 1500 global customer validate; it can be installed on-premise,
sites across industries rely on LabVantage’s highly via the cloud, or SaaS (with standard or
configurable, 100% web browser-based Laboratory enterprise options). Purpose-built industry
Information Management System (LIMS) platform to accelerators of its LIMS are pre-configured
innovate faster in the R&D cycle, improve manufactured for ease of use and faster deployment in
product quality, comply with regulations, increase pharma, biobanking, food & beverage,
cybersecurity, and leverage AI. As a technology and digital oil & gas, and more.
LabVantage Solutions transformation leader, LabVantage offers configurable
265 Davidson Avenue Software-as-a-Service (SaaS), cloud-hosting, or on-premise Facilities
Suite 220 implementations. Investments in analytics bring the LabVantage customers are supported
Somerset, NJ 08873 benefits of AI to customers, while global services provide locally from nearly two dozen global
TELEPHONE consistent, knowledgeable deployments, validation, offices with support and service contracts,
(908) 707-4100 migration, and professional and managed services. as well as training.
FAX
(732) 560-0121
Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported
LabVantage supports all analytical techniques,
E-MAIL including all chromatographic techniques, by interfacing
lvsinfo@labvantage.com to any commercial chromatography data system (CDS).
WEBSITE
www.labvantage.com Markets Served
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES ⦁ Life Sciences ⦁ Oil, Gas, and Energy
Approximately 500 ⦁ Pharmaceutical/ ⦁ Genetics & Diagnostics
Biotechnology ⦁ Public Health
YEAR FOUNDED
⦁ Medical Device ⦁ Healthcare
1983
⦁ Biobanking ⦁ Forensics
⦁ Food & Beverage
⦁ Consumer Goods
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 487
LECO Corporation
Products include:
⦁ Pegasus® BT GC–TOFMS: The tried-
and-trusted reliability and durability
of our Pegasus brand in a convenient
benchtop unit
⦁ Pegasus BT 4D GCxGC–TOFMS:
Four dimensions of analytical resolution
offer a more complete analysis in a
benchtop instrument
⦁ Pegasus GC-HRT+: GC–MS with industry-
leading resolution (up to 50,000)
and mass accuracy for high-information
content analysis
Company Description ⦁ Pegasus GC-HRT+ 4D: Combining the
For over 85 years, industries around the world have trusted highest performance GCxGC and TOFMS
LECO to deliver technologically advanced products and solutions. on the market with High Resolution
Today’s technologies for separation science reflect LECO’s Deconvolution®(HRD®)
commitment to understanding your laboratory’s challenges
and providing solutions that can investigate highly complex Facility
samples while streamlining your analysis. LECO instruments offer LECO’s global headquarters in St. Joseph,
unparalleled separation, accuracy, resolving power, deconvolution, Michigan include the Elizabeth S. Warren
and speed to increase your laboratory’s productivity using Technical Centre, a 28,000 square-foot
GC–TOFMS, GCxGC, GCxGC–TOFMS, and high-resolution GC– facility exclusively dedicated to the research
and GCxGC–TOFMS. For more information, please visit them on and development of innovative instrumen-
LECO Corporation the web at www.leco.com. tation and equipment for LECO’s separa-
3000 Lakeview Avenue tion science line. LECO has more than 25
St. Joseph, MI 49085 Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported subsidiaries worldwide, plus additional
⦁ GC–TOFMS international distributors.
TELEPHONE
⦁ High Resolution GC–TOFMS
(800) 292-6141
(269) 985-5496 ⦁ GCxGC–FID/ECD
⦁ GCxGC–TOFMS
FAX
⦁ High Resolution GCxGC–TOFMS
(269) 982-8987
E-MAIL Markets Served
info@leco.com LECO Separation Science instruments are used in a variety of
WEBSITE applications, helping users to uncover unidentified compounds in
www.leco.com their samples. Markets include metabolomics, consumer product
safety, food, flavor, fragrance, environmental, and energy and
YEAR FOUNDED
1936 fuels analysis.
Major Products/Services
An ideal choice for laboratories investigating highly complex
samples, LECO products feature exclusive ChromaTOF® brand
488 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Markes International
Major Products/Services
Markes is globally recognized for its
innovation, high-quality products,
unrivaled technical expertise, and high
level of customer service within the
field of separation science. As a global
technology leader of thermal desorption
and other sample preparation for GC,
Markes has introduced many highly
successful products and technologies
to the laboratory, enabling analysts to
discover more and deliver more.
⦁ A range of analytical thermal desorption
systems for tube, online, and canister
Company Description sampling (products include: UNITY-xr,
Markes International Ltd.
Markes International—an industry leader in extraction and TD100-xr, TT24-7 and CIA Advantage-xr)
1000B Central Park,
enrichment (sample preparation) technology for trace ⦁ Centri: A breakthrough in automated
Western Ave.,
Bridgend, CF31 3RH, UK organic analysis—manufactures a range of instrumentation sample extraction and enrichment
and software that enhances the analytical capability and for GC–MS
Markes International GmbH
productivity of GC–MS systems. ⦁ Micro-Chamber/Thermal Extractor
Bieberer Straße 1–7, 63065
Offenbach am Main, Germany Markes’ technologies enable analysts to discover more for fast sampling of emissions from
about their samples, and to deliver higher throughput for products and materials
Markes International, Inc.
both research and routine applications. ⦁ TC-20 sorbent tube conditioner
2355 Gold Meadow Way
Gold River, California, USA ⦁ Wide range of supplies and
Markes Instruments
Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported consumables for sample preparation
⦁ Thermal desorption (TD) as a sample concentration and (extraction and enrichment)
(Shanghai) Co., Ltd
Room 901, Building 1, No. introduction technique for GC
2899 Lianhua South Road, ⦁ Automated sample preparation and concentration Facility
Minhang District, Shanghai (headspace, headspace-trap, SPME, SPME-trap, and high Markes International’s factory, technical
201109, P.R. China capacity sorbent extraction) center, and headquarters are located
⦁ Time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOF-MS) for GC and near Cardiff, UK. The company also has
TELEPHONE
+44 (0)1443 230 935 (UK) GC×GC (through Markes’ sister company, SepSolve Analytical) technical centers in Germany, USA, and
+49 (0)69 6681089-10 (Germany) ⦁ GC–MS data reprocessing software (through Markes’ China. It also supports a global distributor
+1 866 483 5684 (toll-free) (USA) sister company, SepSolve Analytical) network. Markes and its sister company,
+86 21 5465 1216 (China) SepSolve Analytical Ltd, are companies of
E-MAIL
Markets Served the Schauenburg Analytics Ltd group.
enquiries@markes.com ⦁ Defense/Homeland security
⦁ Environmental
WEBSITE
⦁ Food and drink
www.markes.com
⦁ Forensic and toxicology
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES ⦁ Breath analysis
200 ⦁ Petrochemical
YEAR FOUNDED
1997
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 489
Facilities
NORTH AMERICA
Postnova Analytics Inc.
230 South, 500 East, Suite 110
Salt Lake City, UT 84102, USA
Tel: +1 801 521-2004
Fax: +1 801 521-2884
info.usa@postnova.com
EMEAI
Postnova Analytics GmbH
Max-Planck-Strasse 14
86899 Landsberg, Germany
Tel: +49 8191 985 688-0
Fax: +49 8191 985 688-99
info@postnova.com
UNITED KINGDOM
Postnova Analytics UK Ltd.
Company Description Unit 64, Malvern Hills Science Park,
Field-Flow Fractionation (FFF) is a separation technology that Malvern, Worcestershire
separates macromolecules or particles that are dissolved WR14 3SZ, UK
or dispersed in a suitable solvent in an open separation Tel: +44 1684 585167
channel. Postnova is the exclusive manufacturer offering the info.uk@postnova.com
whole range of FFF systems including Flow FFF, Thermal FFF,
Centrifugal FFF, and SPLITT FFF. FFF provides fast, gentle,
and high resolution separations of any particulate matter from
1 nm up to 100 µm in any liquid media in various matrices.
Particularly in the fields of nanotechnology, nanomedicine
and biotechnology, but also with increasingly complex
questions in the area of food, polymer and environmental
sciences, FFF technology has become a reliable alternative to
Postnova Analytics Inc. established chromatographic separation methods like
230 South, 500 East, Suite 110 GPC/SEC or HPLC. Because of its broad application range
Salt Lake City, UT 84102 and its compatibility with detection systems known from
TELEPHONE liquid chromatography, such as Multi-Angle Light Scattering
+1 (801) 521-2004 (MALS), Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS), Raman Microscopy,
FAX
Refractive Index and ICP-MS.
+1 (801) 521-2884
Separation Techniques Provided
E-MAIL
⦁ Field-Flow Fractionation (FFF)
info.usa@postnova.com
⦁ Asymmetrical Flow FFF (AF4)
WEBSITE ⦁ Electrical Asymmetrical Flow FFF (EAF4)
www.postnova.com ⦁ Thermal FFF
⦁ Centrifugal FFF
⦁ Multi-Angle Light Scattering (MALS)
490 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Major Products/Services
Princeton Chromatography Inc. offers a
wide range of stationary phases to support
analytical, prep, and ultrahigh-pressure
liquid chromatography workflows.
With new, innovative phases being added
periodically, we continue to expand our
catalog to meet your evolving HPLC and
SFC needs. All phases are available in a
range of particle sizes, column diameters
and lengths, from 2.0 mm i.d. to
50.0 mm i.d. Popular phases include
C18, 2-Ethylpyridine, Diol, and Cyano.
In addition to our standard phases,
we also specialize in custom phases
as well as column packing services,
and bulk chromatographic material.
Facility
Company Description Headquarters, production, and testing
With over 25 years of experience, Princeton laboratories are located in Cranbury, NJ.
Chromatography Inc. delivers premium chromatography
products backed by unmatched technical support.
From SFC to HPLC, analytical to preparative, all columns
are subjected to rigid quality standards. We are one of
the earliest developers of novel commercial SFC phases,
and continue to lead in this area. We also provide bulk
chromatographic media, column packing services,
and consulting.
Princeton
Chromatography Inc.
Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported
259 Prospect Plains Road,
⦁ UHPLC
Building L,
⦁ HPLC
Cranbury, NJ 08512
⦁ SFC
TELEPHONE
⦁ Analytical
(609) 860-1803
⦁ Preparative
FAX
(609) 860-1805 Markets Served
E-MAIL Globally providing chromatographic columns and media
info@pci-hplc.com to the following markets: pharmaceutical, bioscience,
cannabinoids, education, and drug discovery.
WEBSITE
www.pci-hplc.com
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
5
YEAR FOUNDED
1994
Over 25 Years of Quality
HPLC and SFC Columns
Personalized support
www.pci-hplc.com | 609.860.1803
492 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Major Products/Services
Plus 1 Service in everything we do. Living
this corporate core value every day ensures
we will surpass your expectations every
time you contact us! Our customer service
team will suggest time- and money-saving
options, and is dedicated to getting your
products to you fast. Our technical service
chemists can help you from set-up to
method development. Visit our website,
where you can interact with our chemists’
blogs and explore an extensive library of
technical publications, chromatograms,
product documentation, step-by-step guides,
interactive calculators, animations,
and educational material.
Restek’s commitment to continuous
innovation in chromatography sets us apart
from our competitors. We introduce and
stock hundreds of new products every year,
designed by chromatographers for
Company Description chromatographers.
For over 30 years, Restek has been a leader in developing ⦁ Exceptional columns for UHPLC, HPLC,
technologies and manufacturing products for gas and liquid LC–MS, GC, GC–MS, and GC×GC
chromatography (GC and LC), including columns, ⦁ Innovative accessories, instrument
reference standards, sample preparation materials, replacement parts, and consumables
accessories, and more. We have decades of hands-on, ⦁ Air monitoring canisters and sampling
practical experience in chemistry, chromatography, and supplies
engineering, and our reputation for going the extra mile with ⦁ Sample preparation products
Plus 1 customer service and top-performing products is well ⦁ Reference standards: stock and
known throughout the chromatography community. Restek is custom-prepared formulations
proud to assist analysts around the world with monitoring the ⦁ Thousands of innovative products,
quality and safety of air, water, soil, food, pharmaceuticals, hundreds of chromatograms
Restek Corporation and petroleum. We proactively offer integrated solutions—
110 Benner Circle
products, applications, and assistance—perfectly matched to Facilities
Bellefonte, PA 16823
your needs, regardless of your industry. www.restek.com Restek opened for business in 1985 in
TELEPHONE a small business incubator in central
(814) 353-1300 Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported Pennsylvania. Today, more than 500
FAX ⦁ UHPLC employee-owners work, play, and
(814) 353-1309 ⦁ HPLC celebrate milestones in a state-of-the-art
⦁ LC–MS 140,000-square-foot facility in Pennsylvania,
E-MAIL
support@restek.com ⦁ GC and in our regional offices in China, England,
⦁ GC–MS France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and Japan.
WEBSITE
⦁ GC×GC
www.restek.com
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
Markets Served
500+
⦁ Air monitoring
YEAR FOUNDED ⦁ Chemical
1985 ⦁ Clinical
⦁ Environmental
⦁ Food safety
⦁ Forensic
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 493
Sciencix
Facility
⦁ 28,000 square foot facility
⦁ 132+ combined years of experience
in reverse engineering, with an
emphasis on quality
⦁ Serving customers in 100+ countries
⦁ High stock levels, same-day shipping
on most orders
⦁ Customer-driven pipeline for new
product development
Company Description
Sciencix, Inc. was founded in 1985 and serves customers
in over 100 countries as a trusted ISO 9001:2015 certified
supplier of HPLC & Mass Spec repair parts and PM kits
proven comparable to OEMs in fit, form, and function.
With same-day shipping and up to 30% less cost than
OEMs, customers can rely on Sciencix for efficient and
Sciencix easy ordering.
Research & Engineering
Lab Headquarters Products & Services
14261 W. Burnsville Pkwy
⦁ Repair parts for HPLC and Mass Spec equipment,
Burnsville, MN 55306
deuterium lamps, piston seals, check valves, rotor seals,
needles, capillary electrodes, fittings, and tubing
Customer Relations &
Marketing Headquarters ⦁ Custom PM kits with only the components you need
110 Brady Court, Cary, NC ⦁ Designs and manufactures custom “off the main menu” parts
27511 ⦁ Free technical support and consult on Sciencix parts
from team of engineers with 132+ years of experience
TELEPHONE
⦁ Techniques Supported: HPLC, UHPLC, DAD, VWD,
(952) 895-8292
Mass Spec
FAX
(952) 895-8493
Major Markets Served
E-MAIL ⦁ Pharmaceutical
sales@sciencix.com ⦁ Environmental
WEBSITE ⦁ Bioanalytical Chemistry
www.sciencix.com ⦁ Forensic & Toxicology
NUMBER OF FACILITIES: 2 ⦁ HPLC & Mass Spec Service Companies
⦁ Academia
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
⦁ Food & Beverage
27
⦁ Energy & Fuels
YEAR FOUNDED
1985
494 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Scion Instruments
Major Products/Services
⦁ Scion 8500 GC and 8300 GC offer
versatility and superior performance for
any application. Detectors: FID, TCD,
ECD, PFPD, NPD, PDHID, MS
⦁ Scion 8700 SQ and 8900 TQ are
designed for today’s fast-paced labs.
Company Description Both have a small footprint without
Built on the history of Varian in GC and GC–MS, Scion compromising on quality.
Instruments was acquired by the Techcomp group in 2014. ⦁ Scion LC6000 aims for confidence
Scion Instruments is committed to continuing the 50+ in results through outstanding lifetime
year legacy of products, service, and innovation. We design, performance and superior gradient
develop, supply, and support GC, GC–MS, LC, Headspace, precision.
and CompassCDS (chromatography data system) product ⦁ Scion’s Versa and HT3 provide static
lines. Scion Instruments maintains a global infrastructure and dynamic headspace solutions for
to support sales and service not only for Scion Instruments any laboratory.
customers but also for users of legacy Varian and Bruker ⦁ Scion 8400Pro and 8410Pro offer dual
systems. Our gas and liquid chromatography solutions help injector access with one autosampler.
you boost productivity and generate data confidently. ⦁ CompassCDS is our industry-proven,
powerful, and operator-friendly chroma-
Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported tography data system software solution.
⦁ Gas Chromatography (GC) ⦁ Preventative Maintenance and
⦁ GC Mass Spectrometry (GCMS) Instrument Repair
⦁ High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)
⦁ Static and Dynamic Headspace Facility
Scion Instruments
⦁ Autosamplers for GC, GC–MS, and HPLC Scion Instruments prides itself on global
11840 West Market Place,
⦁ Chromatography Data System (CDS) sales and service infrastructure with
Suite K
Fulton, MD 20759 ⦁ Preventative Maintenance and Instrument Repair the US office located in Fulton, MD.
⦁ Laboratory Accessories Our instruments are designed at our
TELEPHONE
▪ GC Columns R&D facility in Livingston, Scotland and
+1 (844) 547-0022
▪ HPLC Columns manufactured at our headquarters in
E-MAIL ▪ GC Gas Filters Goes, The Netherlands.
Sales-USA@scioninstruments.com ▪ GC Inlet Liners and Septa
WEBSITE ▪ Syringes
www.scioninstruments.com ▪ Vials
▪ Balances
▪ Temperature Control Units
Markets Served
⦁ Petrochemical and Refineries
⦁ Pharmaceutical
⦁ Food & Beverage
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 495
Major Products/Services
The wide range of products and
techniques offered by SepSolve includes
the company’s own INSIGHT-Flow and
INSIGHT-Thermal GC×GC modulators,
ChromSpace® and ChromCompare+
software for GC and GC×GC, and
BenchTOF range of time-of-flight mass
spectrometers with groundbreaking
simultaneous hard-
and soft-ionization technology—
Tandem Ionisation®. SepSolve also offers
sample preparation equipment, robotic
autosamplers and thermal desorbers from
leading global suppliers.
Facility
SepSolve has offices and demonstration
laboratories in Peterborough, UK,
Company Description and Waterloo, Canada, and works closely
SepSolve Analytical provides analytical platforms for separation with partners to support customers world-
scientists, including equipment for automated sample wide, with facilities in countries including
introduction, advanced GC separation, state-of-the-art mass the United States, Germany, and China.
spectrometry, and powerful data analysis.
With many years of experience in the field and access to a
range of leading equipment suppliers, SepSolve is very well placed
to advise on the most difficult challenges in analytical science,
helping analysts to discover more and deliver more—in everything
from environmental monitoring and biomarker discovery to
petrochemical analysis, food aroma profiling, and more.
SepSolve Analytical Ltd, and its sister company Markes Interna-
SepSolve Analytical Ltd
tional, are part of the Schauenburg Analytics Ltd group of companies.
4 Swan Court, Forder Way,
Hampton, Peterborough,
PE7 8GX, UK Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported
⦁ GC and GC×GC
TELEPHONE
⦁ TOF-MS
UK: 44 (0)1733 669222
⦁ Software for GC/GCxGC-MS
USA: +1 519 206 0055
GERMANY: 49 (0)69 668 108 920 ⦁ Sample preparation (extraction and enrichment):
Thermal desorption, SPME and SPME–trap, High-capacity
E-MAIL
sorptive extraction, Headspace and Headspace–trap
hello@sepsolve.com
WEBSITE Markets Served
www.sepsolve.com ⦁ Biomarker discovery
YEAR FOUNDED ⦁ Food and drink
2016 ⦁ Petrochemical
⦁ Fragrance
⦁ Environmental
⦁ Tobacco and e-cigarettes
⦁ Cannabis
496 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Major Products/Services
Shimadzu offers a wide range of advanced
UHPLC/HPLC, GC, and mass spectrometry sys-
tems and components. Key systems include:
⦁ Nexera 40 series UHPLC—Offering the
most advanced performance features
available, the 40 series enables smart,
efficient workflows and delivers
excellent data quality.
⦁ Nexera SFC/Prep SFC—User-focused
automation and streamlined software
simplify processes, enhance accuracy and
increase productivity
⦁ Single-quad LCMS-2050—Compact,
robust system provides a complete
package of easy-to-use high-level
performance
⦁ Triple-quad LC–MS/MS—Outstanding
speed, sensitivity, and robust operation
Company Description for maximum uptime and the utmost in
Shimadzu Scientific Instruments (SSI) is the North American data quality
subsidiary of Shimadzu Corporation’s Analytical and Measuring ⦁ Nexis GC-2030—Offers a modern ap-
Division. Headquartered in Columbia, Maryland, SSI offers a proach to a classic chromatographic
comprehensive portfolio of robust, precision-engineered platforms. technique, delivering exceptional
From teaching environments and QA/QC to innovative R&D projects, performance and faster ROI.
customers can count on the stability, experience, and support only ⦁ * Brevis GC-2050—Best-in-class analyti-
Shimadzu offers. cal performance and scalability in an
ultra-compact design.
Shimadzu Scientific
Instruments Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported ⦁ GC–MS/GC–MS/MS Systems—
7102 Riverwood Drive ⦁ Analytical HPLC, UHPLC With Smart Technologies, single-
Columbia, MD 21046 ⦁ Prep HPLC, SFC and triple-quad systems enable new
⦁ Inert UHPLC possibilities in sensitivity, durability,
TELEPHONE
⦁ SFE–SFC stability, and reliability.
(800) 477-1227
⦁ Ion Chromatography
(410) 381-1227
⦁ LC–MS/MS Facilities
FAX
⦁ Q-TOF LC–MS Shimadzu’s US headquarters includes a
(410) 381-1222
⦁ Multiplex LC–MS customer service and training center, a
E-MAIL ⦁ GC solution center to showcase technologies,
webmaster@shimadzu.com ⦁ GC–MS/MS and an innovation center for promoting
WEBSITE collaborative projects with customers.
www.ssi.shimadzu.com Markets Served Shimadzu’s regional facilities, strategically
Shimadzu’s product line flexibility enables chromatographers in any located around the US, provide customers
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
environment to select the instrument best suited to their application. with local sales, service, and technical support.
US: 605
Worldwide: 13,800 Shimadzu instruments are found in a wide range of laboratories,
including pharma/biopharma, environmental, food and beverages,
YEAR FOUNDED
Shimadzu Scientific petrochemical, life sciences, and clinical. Shimadzu provides free
Instruments: 1975 technical support for the life of the instruments, and encourages
Shimadzu Corporation: 1875 customer alliances to further product development.
Brevis TM GC-2050
www.ssi.shimadzu.com
Shimadzu Scientific Instruments Inc., 7102 Riverwood Dr., Columbia, MD 21046, USA
498 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Facilities
Resonac America, Inc., based in New York,
New York, provides technical and sales
support for Shodex HPLC columns for
customers and distributors in North and
South America. Our stock point in New
York allows for fast delivery in the United
States. Working with our laboratories in
New York City and Japan, we support
customers’ analytical needs.
Company Description
Shodex HPLC columns have been manufactured by Showa
Denko K.K. in Japan since 1973. Now under Resonac
America, Inc. our columns are designed to provide superior
separation and purification of complex mixtures, making
them a valuable tool for researchers in a wide range of
industries. Our strength in polymer synthesis led to the
production of many unique and durable polymer-based
columns. The golden-mechanical fish is a symbol of fast
and smooth liquid chromatography analysis.
SilcoTek Corporation
⦁ Process
⦁ Analytical
⦁ Bio/Pharma
⦁ Oil & Gas
⦁ Refining
⦁ Petrochemical
⦁ Semiconductor
⦁ Corrosion
⦁ Coking/Fouling
⦁ Automotive
⦁ Aerospace
Major Products/Services
Major Products/Services: SilcoTek offers
custom silicon coatings to OEMs and labs
worldwide. Send in your stainless steel,
alloy, glass, or ceramic part and we’ll apply
our signature CVD coatings. Our coating
options include:
Company Description ⦁ SilcoNert®: The most inert coating
SilcoTek® Corporation is the world’s leading provider of flow available.
path deactivations and coatings. Our patented CVD coating ⦁ Dursan®: An inert, high durability
technologies improve analytical reliability, increase system coating. Ideal for lab and field analysis.
uptime, and boost your bottom line. SilcoTek’s coatings are used ⦁ Silcolloy®: A high purity corrosion
in a large, diverse variety of industries and applications where resistant coating.
analytical accuracy and superior performance are critical. ⦁ SilcoKlean®: Prevent carbon coking and
Whether for industry-leading chemical compatibility, corrosion fouling in automotive and aerospace.
resistance, bio-inertness, or hydrophobicity, SilcoTek coatings will ⦁ SilcoGuard®: A low outgassing, high
expand the material limits of your instruments and products. purity coating, ideal for research and
SilcoTek Corporation
semiconductor applications.
225 PennTech Drive
Bellefonte, PA 16823 Chief Chromatographic Techniques Supported ⦁ Dursox®: A high purity corrosion-
⦁ Sulfur analysis resistant coating.
TELEPHONE
⦁ VOC analysis ⦁ Siltride®: SilcoTek’s most protective
(814) 353-1778
⦁ Environmental and versatile silicon nitride CVD
FAX ⦁ Thermal desorption coating technology.
(814) 353-1697 ⦁ Fenceline monitoring
E-MAIL ⦁ CEMS Facility
TechService@SilcoTek.com ⦁ Flare subpart JA SilcoTek applies coatings to customer-
⦁ Stack monitoring supplied products from their newly
WEBSITE
www.SilcoTek.com ⦁ Protein analysis renovated 70,000 square foot facility state
⦁ NOx, SOx testing of the art facility in Bellefonte, Pennsylvania.
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
⦁ GC Want to speak to an expert about your
65
⦁ LC application?
WEBSITE Email TechService@SilcoTek.com
www.SilcoTek.com Markets Served or call +1 (814) 353-1778.
YEAR FOUNDED SilcoTek coating technologies are utilized in diverse applications and
2009 industry segments worldwide. Since 1987, customers have relied on To find a sales representative nearest to you,
SilcoTek coatings to improve the performance of their products and please visit
increase revenue in the following markets and applications: www.silcotek.com/international-reps
500 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
Syft Technologies
Major Products/Services
⦁ Syft Tracer
⦁ Syft Tracer Pharm11
⦁ Voice200Infinity
⦁ ContainerSure
Facilities
New Zealand
68 St Asaph Street
Christchurch Central,
Christchurch, New Zealand 8011
Taiwan
4th Floor, No. 455,
Wenhua 3rd Road
Section 2,
Linkou District,
New Taipei City, Taiwan
UCT, Inc.
⦁ Food safety
⦁ Forensic
⦁ Pharmaceutical
⦁ Veterinary
Major Products/Services
⦁ CLEAN SCREEN® SPE columns
⦁ Refine® Ultra Filtration Columns &
Well Plates
⦁ CLEAN UP® SPE columns
⦁ STYRE SCREEN® SPE columns
⦁ XtrackT® SPE columns
⦁ ENVIRO-CLEAN® SPE cartridges
⦁ ENVIRO-CLEAN® universal cartridges
⦁ Fusion® Ag+
⦁ Chlorofiltr® Sorbents
⦁ QuEChERS
⦁ Quick QuEChERS
⦁ SpinFiltr™
⦁ LipiFiltr®
⦁ Selectra® U/HPLC columns
Company Description ⦁ SelectraCore core-shell columns
UCT is at the forefront of sample preparation technology and ⦁ SELECTRASORB™ bulk sorbents
a leader in chromatography consumables. The company’s ⦁ SELECTRA-SIL® derivatizing reagents
wide range of highly reproducible silica and polymeric SPE ⦁ SELECTRAZYME® & ABALONASE™
sorbents provides scientists a consistent extraction technique. β-glucuronidase enzyme
UCT is in a unique position within the sample prep and ⦁ SELECT pH buffer pouches
chromatographic sorbent industry; we are one of the few ⦁ Positive pressure manifolds
manufacturers of chromatographic silane materials. ⦁ SPeVAP® Multi-Function Solvent
This expertise provides us with greater control and extensive Evaporator
UCT, Inc.
knowledge of the chemical processes involved in producing ⦁ Vacuum manifolds
2731 Bartram Road
high quality bonded phases. UCT’s commitment to ensuring ⦁ MicroPrep™ 96-Well Microelution Plate
Bristol, PA 19007
customer satisfaction is accomplished by delivering on our
TELEPHONE promises: top quality, reproducible chromatographic and Facility
(215) 781-9255 sample prep products, and unmatched technical support. UCT is headquartered in Bristol,
FAX The company’s sample prep product lines include SPE car- Pennsylvania. Manufacturing and
(215) 785-1226 tridges and well plates, bulk sorbents, QuEChERS tubes, distribution sites are in Lewistown,
E-MAIL
derivatizing reagents, hydrolyzing enzymes, premeasured Pennsylvania, and Wexford, Ireland. UCT is
info@unitedchem.com buffer salts, and extraction manifolds. Chromatography represented worldwide by more than 50
products include HPLC columns and GC liners. partners and distributors.
WEBSITE
www.unitedchem.com
Chief Techniques Supported
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES ⦁ Solid-phase extraction
>100 ⦁ QuEChERS
YEAR FOUNDED ⦁ HPLC
1986
Markets Served
⦁ Clinical
⦁ Environmental
WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM DECEMBER 2023 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 503
Major Products/Services
Spectroscopy Software & Spectral Libraries
Wiley is a leader in spectral data with
IR, MS, NMR, Raman, and UV-vis spectra
that are essential to analytical laboratory
workflows for the interpretation,
identification, verification, and
classification of spectra. Consistently
evolving to increase coverage for
meeting today’s research demands, these
trusted databases cover a wide range of
applications including polymer/materials,
Company Description environmental, forensics/toxicology,
Wiley Science Solutions is home to high-quality, pharmaceutical, biotech, automotive/
comprehensive spectral databases and powerful aerospace, food/cosmetics, and more.
software for spectral analysis and identification, and data At the helm of our collections are the
management. renowned Wiley Registry, KnowItAll
Spectral Libraries, Sadtler Libraries, and
About Wiley many other important databases used
Wiley is a knowledge company and a global leader in re- in spectral analysis.
search, publishing, and knowledge solutions. Dedicated to
the creation and application of knowledge, Wiley serves Learn more: https://sciencesolutions.
the world’s researchers, learners, innovators, and leaders, wiley.com/spectral-databases/
helping them achieve their goals and solve the world’s
most important challenges. For more than two centuries, Wiley’s KnowItAll software offers
Wiley has been delivering on its timeless mission to unlock integrated solutions to analyze and
human potential. Visit us at Wiley.com. manage multiple types of spectral
and chemical data in multiple file
Chief Spectroscopic Techniques Supported and instrument formats. KnowItAll’s
⦁ MS integrated toolsets eliminate the need
⦁ IR for multiple software packages and
⦁ Raman increase overall lab efficiency. Combined
⦁ NMR with Wiley’s comprehensive reference
John Wiley & Sons ⦁ UV-vis databases, KnowItAll Software provides
111 River Street, Hoboken, an unparalleled solution for spectral
NJ, 07030 Markets Served analysis. So, whether you use one or
WEB SITE ⦁ Metabolomics more analytical techniques, KnowItAll has
sciencesolutions.wiley.com ⦁ Forensics and Toxicology the right solution for your laboratory.
⦁ Polymers and Materials
MAIN WEB SITE
www.wiley.com ⦁ Pharmaceutical and Biotech Learn more: https://sciencesolutions.
⦁ Environmental wiley.com/knowitall-analytical-edition-
YEAR FOUNDED
⦁ Food and Cosmetics software/
1807
⦁ Quality Assurance, and many more
Take spectral analysis to new
heights with KnowItAll 2024
KnowItAll offers solutions to identify, analyze, and manage analytical data. Combined with
Wiley’s comprehensive, high-quality spectral reference libraries, it provides an unparalleled
solution for fast, reliable spectral analysis.
To empower researchers, KnowItAll 2024 revamps manual GC-MS processing to provide users
greater control of component separation and identification. These improvements, combined
with the completely automated data analysis in the previous release, make KnowItAll an even
more reliable, efficient, powerful, and accurate tool for GC-MS analysis.
www.knowitall.com/lcgc
ENVIRONMENTAL
plastics, along with attached additives, enter our bodies, PVC 0.982
resulting strong concerns and demands to quantify micro- PE 0.985
plastics in the environment. PET 0.987
Many analytical techniques are capable of quantifying microplas- Table III: RSD Cryo-grinding Replicates.
tics. Py-GC-MS can be an effective solution to detect multiple mi-
Area
croplastics in a single analysis under 40 minutes, as opposed to
Counts
days by optical counted-based methods. In this application note,
Polymer 1 2 3 4 RSD
a Py-GC-MS method combining with sample prep by cryo-milling
is used to quantify microplastics in Shellfish on a CDS Pyroprobe, PMMA 930897 968001 887338 970507 4.15%
which is a pulsed resistive heating pyrolyzer without 2nd pyrolysis PS 207426 214896 203695 213600 2.51%
even at the slowest flow rate, due to the minimum temperature PP 208176 224057 204323 222725 4.67%
gradient between sample and heating element during pyrolysis. PVC 242205 246945 241199 257526 3.02%
This design feature enables the instrument to quantify complex PE 87323 83657 87368 89454 2.77%
microplastic samples at any GC/MS split ratio.
PET 723135 686987 667420 695292 3.34%
Experimental
All solvents were pre-filtered on a 0.45 µm PTFE membrane. ground in the mill for 40s at a 65Hz vibration frequency for a
Four types of shellfish were purchased, de-shelled, and 1 gram total of 8 repetitions. A 2 mg ground subsample was added to a
of each sample type were transferred to individual 30 mL glass pre-cleaned DISC tube for pyrolysis.
flasks with glass stoppers for alkaline digestion. After digestion, For the standard calibration, 1 mg each of Polyethylene (PE),
the sample was filtered onto glass fiber filters under vacuum. polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA), polyethylene terephthalate
Filters containing particles from alkaline digestion were then (PET), polyvinyl chloride (PVC), polystyrene (PS) and polypro-
ground with a CDS liquid nitrogen cryo-mill (P/N 6204-3023). pylene (PP), were weighed and added to cryo-mill vessels with
Each filter was placed into the 5 mL grinding vessel of the cryo- 0.15 g of diatomaceous earth and ground to obtain a 6.67 μg/mg
mill with a 9.6 mm grinding ball and capped. Next, each vessel concentration of microplastics as a stock standard. Then 0.66
was immersed in liquid nitrogen for 5 min, then removed and mg, 0.97 mg, 1.48 mg, 1.97 mg and 2.44 mg of stock standard
were placed in pre-cleaned DISC tubes and analyzed for a total
Table I: 6 Chosen Indicator Peaks for 6 microplastics of 5 calibration levels.
Figure 1: Overlay of 4 replicate standards. Peak Identifications 1: Methyl methacrylate, 2: 2,4-Dimethylhept-1-ene, 3: Styrene.
Conclusion
Quantification of microplastics in shellfish was accomplished by CDS Analytical, ISO 9001:2008 Certified
sample preparation involving a solid diluent and cryo-milling, fol- 465 Limestone Road, Oxford, PA, 19073
lowed by Py-GC-MS. Website: www.cdsanalytical.com
Phone: 1.800.541.6593
TM
Figure 1: The chromatogram compares the performance of a Shodex™/Showa Denko America, Inc.
Polymer GFC column to the ShodexTM OHpakTM LB-806M column
420 Lexington Avenue Suite 2335A, New York, NY 10170
to detect 0.5% Pullulan (MW of 12,000 Da) using a MALS detector.
The table shows the Signal to noise ratio comparison of a Poly- tel. (212) 370-0033, X109
mer GFC column to the ShodexTM OHpakTM LB-806M column. Website: www.shodexHPLC.com
DAR Isomers
VH
0
VH
VL
N
VL
CH
CH
CL
2
CL
Clearance
Efficacy
O N O S O
S O H NH
CH
CH
N 4
N H O
O
CH
CH
Elution Order:
1) DAR 0 (native mAb)
DAR 3.9 2) DAR 2
3) DAR 4
4 4) DAR 6
146474 5) DAR 8
100
2 2
145135 6
147812
%
0 8 4
143799 149147
0 5
143000 144000 145000 146000 147000 148000 149000
1
Mass
0 10 20 30 40 50
Figure 3: Native SEC/MS spectrum of the ADC mimic Retention time (minutes)
Conclusions
SEC/MS and HIC/UV can be effectively used to characterize the
DAR profile of ADCs. The mobile phase ensured a non-denaturing,
MS compatible condition that was successfully used alongside Tosoh Bioscience LLC
the TSKgel SuperSW3000 SEC column to elucidate the molecular 3604 Horizon Drive, Suite 100, King of Prussia, PA 19406
weight of the ADC species present in the drug mimic by high resolu- tel. (484) 805-1219
tion ESI-MS detection; SEC/MS analysis indicated that the average Website: www.tosohbioscience.com
PRODUCT PROFILES
Polymeric HILIC Columns LenS™3 MALS-V Detector
iHILIC-Fusion(P) and The LenS3 MALS-V
detector is the
iHILIC-(P) Classic are two
only all-in-one
lines of polymeric HILIC MALS-Viscometry
columns with different detector on the market,
surface chemistries. They offering a simple and
compact solution for triple
provide complementary
detection measurements
selectivity, ultra-low column when combined with a
bleeding, and excellent concentration detector
durability at basic conditions. According to the company, (RI or UV) to enhance
your polymer analysis.
the columns are particularly suitable for LC–MS-based Viscometry is a perfect complement to MALS for polymer
analysis of polar compounds in “Omics” studies at analysis. The intrinsic viscosity (IV) of polymers reflects how
pH 1-10. dense and how flexible polymer chains are in dilute solutions.
The lower the IV, the more compact the polymer is while rigid
Hilicon AB polymer chains show a higher IV than flexible random coils.
Tvistevägen, Umeå, Sweden
When combined with light scattering measurements, the MW
www.hilicon.com
and IV distributions provide a wealth of structural information
about polymers.
PRODUCT PROFILES
Sciencix PM Kit CTS-21939 Single-Quad LCMS-2050
Sciencix PM Kit Shimadzu’s LCMS-2050
CTS-21939 contains combines ease of use
all parts necessary to as an LC detector with
maintain the Waters® excellent mass spec
ACQUITY® Arc™ capabilities. The Dual Ion
SM-FTN system’s Source, which combines
peak performance heated electrospray and
and is comparable atmospheric pressure
to OEM 201000302. ionization, can analyze a
Since 1985, Sciencix wide range of compounds
is recognized as a from multiple chemical
premier alternative classes. Ultrafast technology, including a 15,000 u/sec scan
provider of HPLC speed and polarity switching time of 10 msec, maintains high
& Mass Spec data quality while improving overall throughout. The system
replacement parts with can be used like an LC that operators simply turn on and use,
lower prices and enabling everything from MS data acquisition to data analysis.
same-day shipping on orders placed by 6pm EST, M-F. Additional features lead to streamlined operations and easy
Each product must pass a rigorous ISO9001:2015 QMS maintenance for greater uptime.
process and is designed, tested, and proven as comparable
with the OEM part. Shimadzu,
Columbia, MD.
Sciencix, www.ssi.shimadzu.com
Burnsville, MN.
www.sciencix.com
RESOURCE DIRECTORY
www.chromacademy.com
520 LCGC NORTH AMERICA VOLUME 41 NUMBER 11 DECEMBER 2023 WWW.CHROMATOGRAPHYONLINE.COM
ELECTROPHORESIS
Products and Services for Chromatography
ONLINE DIRECTORY
CAPILLARY GEL ELECTROPHORESIS
ELECTROPHORESIS ACCESSORY EQUIPMENT SCAN QR CODE TO VIEW
COMPLETE SYSTEMS Hamilton Company
908 Devices 800-648-5950
AMPHOLYTES BUFFERS
REAGENTS, SOLVENTS, STANDARDS Acrolab Acrolab
PreOmics GmbH
Products and Services for Chromatography BIOCHEMICAL
Acrolab CHIRAL
Biovenic Acrolab
Cayman Chemical Company Regis Technologies, Inc.
REAGENTS, Acrolab
Phone: 252-331-1997, 800-628-4584 KARIN ASPEN E-mail: contact@lcservs.com Mid Glamorgan CF31 3RT,
Fax: 252-331-2886 Kloosterstraat 6 5349AB www.lcservicesltd.co.uk United Kingdom
E-mail: janna@hofferflow.com Netherlands Phone: +44 (0)1443 230935
www.hofferflow.com Phone: +31882779484 ■ LECO CORPORATION E-mail: enquiries@markes.com
Email: kvullings@nl.aspenpharma.com 3000 Lakeview Avenue, www.markes.com
HPLC DIRECT LTD Saint Joseph, Michigan 49085,
Ropeworks, Newton Street, KCA LABORATORIES Phone: (269) 985-5496 MARVEL REFRIGERATION
Macclesfield, Cheshire SK11 6QJ, 232 North Plaza Drive, E-mail: info@leco.com 1260 E Van Deinse Street,
United Kingdom Nicholasville, Kentucky 40356, www.leco.com Greenville, Michigan 48838,
Phone: 07831 447 486 Phone: (833) 522-5227 See our ad on page 465 Phone: (616) 754-5601
E-mail: info@hplcdirect.co.uk E-mail: trustedresults@kcalabs.com www.marvelrefrigeration.com
www.hplcdirect.co.uk www.kcalabs.com LGC GROUP
IAC INDUSTRIES Queens Road, MCKINLEY SCIENTIFIC
KINDWELL INC. Teddington, Middlesex TW11 0LY, 100 E. Six Forks Rd St. 145
3831 S Bullard Avenue,
Goodyear, Arizona 85338, 1007 N. Orange St. United Kingdom Raleigh, NC 27609
Phone: (800) 229-1422; (714) 990-8997 Wilmington, DE 19801 Phone: +1 6036227660 Phone: (877) 502-7082
E-mail: benchsales@iacindustries.com Phone: (302) 588-2895 E-mail: infousa@lgcgroup.com Email: francine.jackson@mcksci-
www.iacindustries.com Email: andreas.h@kindwell.net www.lgcstandards.com
entific.com
www.kindwell.net
IJEST MARKES INSTRUMENTS www.mckscientific.com
626 Wilshire Boulevard, KNAUER WISSENSCHAFTLICHE (SHANGHAI) CO., LTD.
Los Angeles, California 90017, GERÄTE GMBH Room 901, Building 1, MILES SCIENTIFIC
Phone: (707) 633-3769 Hegauer Weg 38, Berlin, No. 2899 Lianhua South Road, 75 Blue Hen Drive,
E-mail: admin@ijest.org Berlin 14163, Minhang District, Shanghai Newark, Delaware 19713,
www.ijest.org Germany 201109, P.R. China Phone: (302) 737-6960
Phone: +49 30 8097270 Phone: +86 21 5465 1216 E-mail: cs@MilesScientific.com
INFOMETRIX, INC. E-mail: info@knauer.net E-mail: enquiries@markes.com www.milesscientific.com
11807 N Creek Pkwy S, Suite B-111, www.knauer.net www.markes.com.cn
Bothell, Washington 98011, NANOCHROM
United States LADYBUG SCIENTIFIC LLC MARKES INTERNATIONAL TECHNOLOGIES CO LTD
Phone: (425) 402-1450 12 Warren Court GMBH 4 F, Building NE-37, 99 Jinjihu
E-mail: sales@infometrix.com Northport, NY 11768 Bieberer Straße 1–7 , Avenue, China-Singapore Suzhou
www.infometrix.com Offenbach am Main, Hesse 63065, Industrial Park, China
Phone: (631) 606-0088
Germany Phone: +86-0512-62626680
INNOVAQUARTZ Email: info@ladybugscientific.com Phone: +49 (0)69 6681089-10
23030 N 15th Avenue, www.ladybugscientific.com E-mail: info@nanochrom.com
E-mail: enquiries@markes.com www.nanochrom.com
Phoenix, Arizona 85027-1315, www.markes.com
Phone: 1(623) 434-1895 ext. 107 LCGC
E-mail: info@innovaquartz.com 485 US Highway 1, MARKES INTERNATIONAL INC. NINGBO EXCELLENT NEW
www.innovaquartz.com Iselin, New Jersey 08830, 2355 Gold Meadow Way , MATERIALS CO LTD
Phone: (732) 710-2175 Gold River, Sacramento, CHAOYANG ROAD 667,
JAYTEE BIOSCIENCES LTD www.chromatographyonline.com California 95670, SHANGHE JIANGSHAN
Unit 5, The Boulevard, Phone: +1(866) 483-5684 (toll-free) YINZHOU NINGBO ZHEJIANG
Altira Business Park, LC SERVICES LTD E-mail: enquiries@markes.com
Herne Bay, Kent CT6 6GZ, Station House, Station Road, CHINA 315191
www.markes.com Ningbo, Zhejiang 315191 China
United Kingdom Turvey, Bedford,
Phone: +44 (0)12 27 265 333 Bedfordshire MK43 8BH, MARKES INTERNATIONAL LTD Phone: 13626849982
E-mail: sales@jaytee.com United Kingdom 1000B Central Park, Email: hamagjinx@hotmail.com
www.jaytee.com Phone: +44 (0)12 3488 1900 Western Avenue, www.septacapvials.com
15
TH Multidimensional
Chromatography
Workshop
NITROGEN & HYDROGEN PSS GMBH - PERFECT SORBENT TECHNOLOGIES, INC. WELCH MATERIALS, INC.
GENERATORS SEPARATION SOLUTIONS 5955 Peachtree Cors. East, No. 168 Shuanglin South Street,
3637 Marquis Drive In der Dalheimer Wiese 5, Norcross, Georgia 30071, Jinhua, Zhejiang 321016, China
Fort Worth, TX 75042 Mainz, Rhineland-Palatina 55120, Phone: (770) 936-0323 Phone: +86-579-89138282;
Phone: (817) 889-0700 Germany E-mail: info@sorbtech.com +1(203) 691-1721 (US Company)
Phone: +49 6131962390 www.sorbtech.com E-mail: info@welchmat.com
Email: jeffrey.walters@nitroge- www.welch-us.com
nandcompressorglobal.com E-mail: info@pss-polymer.com
www.pss-polymer.com STRUCTURALS WILEY SCIENCE SOLUTIONS
www.nitrogenandcompressorglobal.com Jindal Steel & Power Limited 11 River Street ,
NORTHWEST ANALYTICS INC PYROMATION, INC. Plot No. 2, Sector 32,Gurugram - Hoboken, New Jersey 07030,
111 SW Columbia Street, Suite 1080, 5211 Industrial Road 46825-5152, 122001, Haryana Phone: (201) 748-6000
Oregon 97201, Phone: (260) 484-2580 Makkah 122001 E-mail: info.knowitall@wiley.com
Phone: (503) 224-7727 E-mail: cs@pyromation.com Saudia Arabia www.sciencesolutions.wiley.com
E-mail: info@Nwasoft.Com www.pyromation.com Phone: +91 9667032300 See our ad on page 505
www.nwasoft.com Email: jsplsaudi@gmail.com
QUANTITATIVE IN SILICO WYATT TECHNOLOGY
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY jsplstructurals.com 6330 Hollister Avenue,
NOVILYTIC Santa Barbara, California 93117,
1281 Win Hentschel Boulevard, 1-1-2-10-602 Kominatocho SUNCHROM GMBH
Suite 2541, Nakaku中区小港町1-1-2-10-602 Phone: (805) 681-9009
SunChrom GmbH; Industriestr. 18d E-mail: info@wyatt.com
West Lafayette, Indiana 47906, 231-0802, Japan
Phone: +81452951468 Friedrichsdorf, Hesse 61381 www.wyatt.com
Phone: (765) 340-7140 Germany
E-mail: info@novilytic.com E-mail: hanai104@kf7.so-net.ne.jp ■ YMC EUROPE
www.hanai-toshihiko.net Phone: +4946172953350
www.novilytic.com Schöttmannshof 19, Dinslaken,
Email: gbarka@sunchrom.de
North-Rhine Westphalia 46539,
PDR-SEPARATIONS QUANTUM ANALYTICS www.sunchrom.de Germany
3 Old Meadow Way, 8301 New Trails Drive, Suite 100, Phone: +49 20644270
The Woodlands, Texas 77381, ■ SYFT TECHNOLOGIES
Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 33418, 68 St Asaph Street E-mail: info@ymc.eu
Phone: (561) 818-8445 Phone: (800) 992-4199 www.ymc.eu
E-mail: info@lqa.com Christchurch Central, Christchurch
E-mail: gwyanik@pdr-separations.com New Zealand See our ad on page 443
www.pdr-separations.com www.lqa.com
Phone: +64-3-338 6701
REGIS TECHNOLOGIES, INC. E-mail: info@syft.com
PEAK SCIENTIFIC 8210 Austin Avenue, www.syft.com
Fountain Crescent, Morton Grove, Illinois 60053, See our ad on page 461
Inchinnan Business Park PA4 9RE, Phone: (847) 967-6000
United Kingdom E-mail: sales@registech.com TEKNOKROMA ANALÍTICA S.A.
Phone: +44 (0) 141 812 8100 www.registech.com Camí de Can Calders, 14
E-mail: discover@peakscientific.com 08173 Sant Cugat del Vallés
www.peakscientific.com ROOTS ANALYSIS Barcelona, Spain
India Phone: +34 936 698 650
PERKINELMER E-mail: export@teknokroma.es
Phone: +4158003415
CHROMATOGRAPHY www.teknokroma.es
Email: rootanalysisusa@gmail.com
SOLUTIONS
940 Winter Street, www.rootsanalysis.com THERMO FISHER SCIENTIFIC
Waltham, Massachusetts 02451, S-MATRIX CORPORATION 168 Third Avenue
Phone: (800) 762-4000; Waltham, Massachusetts 02451,
1594 Myrtle Avenue, Phone: (800) 678-5599
+1(203) 925-4602 Eureka, California 95501,
E-mail: info@perkinelmer.com E-mail: info@thermofisher.com
www.perkinelmer.com Phone: (707) 441-0406 www.thermofisher.com
E-mail: support@smatrix.com
PHENOMENEX, INC. www.smatrix.com ■ TOSOH BIOSCIENCE GMBH
411 Madrid Avenue Im Leuschnerpark 4,
■ SCIENCIX Griesheim, Hesse 64347,
Torrance, California 90501, 14261 W. Burnsville Pkwy,
Phone: (310) 212-0555 Germany
Burnsville, Minnesota 55306, Phone: +49 6155-7043700
E-mail: info@phenomenex.com Phone: (952) 895-8292
www.phenomenex.com E-mail: info.tbl@tosoh.com
E-mail: sales@sciencix.com www.tosohbioscience.com
POLYLC INC. www.sciencix.com See our ad on page 441
9151 Rumsey Road, Suite 180, See our ads on pages 459, 511
Columbia, Maryland 21045, ULTRAVIEW CORPORATION
SEPSOLVE ANALYTICAL LTD 808 Gilman Street,
Phone: (410) 992-5400 Berkeley, California 94710,
E-mail: info@polylc.com 4 Swan Court,
Forder Way, Hampton, Phone: (925) 253-2960
www.polylc.com E-mail: sales@ultraviewcorp.com
Peterborough, PE7 8GX
United Kingdom www.ultraviewcorp.com
POLYMER CHAR Phone: +44 (0)1733 669222;
Gustave Eiffel 8 Valencia +1 519 206 0055 (Canada) UTILITY TESTING LABORATORY
Technology Park 46980, Spain E-mail: hello@sepsolve.com 1615 W 2200 S Suite A
Phone: +34961318120 www.sepsolve.com Salt Lake City, UT 84119
E-mail: info@polymerchar.com Phone: (801) 485-8941
www.polymerchar.com SERVICIOS INTEGRAL Email: becky@ut-labs.com
EN CROMATOGRAFÍA - www.ut-labs.com
PORVAIR SCIENCES SISCHROM
Unit 73, Clywedog Rd S, San andres 540, La Puerta 4001, VERDER SCIENTIFIC INC
Wrexham Industrial Estate, Venezuela 11 Penns Trail, Suite 300,
Wrexham LL13 9XS, Phone: +58 424 8801812 Newtown, Pennsylvania 18940,
United Kingdom E-mail: Sischrom@gmail.com Phone: (267) 757-0351
Phone: +44 (0)1978 661144 https://sischrom.wixsite.com/sischrom E-mail: info-us@verder-scientific.com
E-mail: int.sales@porvairsciences.com www.verder-scientific.com
www.microplates.com SHIMADZU SCIENTIFIC
INSTRUMENTS VERULAM SCIENTIFIC LTD
7102 Riverwood Drive, 4 Appley Court Appley Wood Corner,
■ POSTNOVA ANALYTICS Columbia, Maryland 21046, Bedfordshire MK45 3QQ ,
Rankinestrasse 1, Phone: (800) 477-1227 United Kingdom
Landsberg am Lech, Bavaria 86899, E-mail: webmaster@shimadzu.com Phone: +44 (0) 1234 38 1000
Germany E-mail: enquiries@verulamscientific.com
www.shimadzu.com www.verulamscientific.com
Phone: +49 8191 985 688-0
E-mail: info@postnova.com See our ad on page 497
www.postnova.com ■ VICI VALCO INSTRUMENTS
SILICYCLE INC. CO. INC.
See our ad on page 434 2500 Parc Technologies Blvd PO Box 55603,
PREOMICS GMBH Quebec G1P 4S6 Canada Houston, Texas 77255-5603,
Phone: (418) 874-0054 Phone: 1(713) 688-9345;
Am Klopferspitz 19, Email: info@silicycle.com 1(800) 367-8424
Haus 2, 2. OG, Martinsried, E-mail: sales_usa@vici.com
Bavaria 82152, www.silicycle.com
www.vici.com
Germany SOLUTIONS FOR LC/GC-MS See our ad on page 453
Phone: +49 8923141630 DATA AND APPLICATIONS
E-mail: info@preomics.com ■ WATERS CORPORATION
www.preomics.com Feliciano Barrera 9B 34 Maple Street,
Santiago de Compostela 15706 Milford, Massachusetts 01757,
Spain Phone: (508) 478-2000
■ PRINCETON Phone: +34 881 976 775 E-mail: customerservice@waters.com
CHROMATOGRAPHY INC. Email: marketing@mestrelab.com www.waters.com
259 Prospect Plains Road Building L bit.ly/3rmY3E1
Cranbury, NJ 08512
www.pci-hplc.com
See our ad on page 491
W I T H L U M A ™ F R O M V U V A N A LY T I C S
SENSITIVE SIMPLE
to low part per billions (PPB) levels. Fits into existing laboratory workflows and requires
minimal training.
SELECTIVE UNIVERSAL
Acquire up to 12 independent channels of data Nearly every compound absorbs except for GC
across a wide wavelength range. carrier gases.