Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spe-215029-Ms - Successful Deepwater MPD Application in Drilling and Cementing Through Depleted Formation With Wellbore Instability and Loss Circulation Challenge Offshore of Saba
Spe-215029-Ms - Successful Deepwater MPD Application in Drilling and Cementing Through Depleted Formation With Wellbore Instability and Loss Circulation Challenge Offshore of Saba
B. Benny, J. Tan, J. See, and J. Foo, Managed Pressure Drilling, Weatherford Asia Pacific, Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia; F. Othman and M. Mathew, Sarawak Shell Berhad, Sarawak, Malaysia
This paper was prepared for presentation at the 2023 SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition held in San Antonio, Texas, USA, 16 - 18 October 2023.
This paper was selected for presentation by an SPE program committee following review of information contained in an abstract submitted by the author(s). Contents
of the paper have not been reviewed by the Society of Petroleum Engineers and are subject to correction by the author(s). The material does not necessarily reflect
any position of the Society of Petroleum Engineers, its officers, or members. Electronic reproduction, distribution, or storage of any part of this paper without the written
consent of the Society of Petroleum Engineers is prohibited. Permission to reproduce in print is restricted to an abstract of not more than 300 words; illustrations may
not be copied. The abstract must contain conspicuous acknowledgment of SPE copyright.
Abstract
Managed Pressure Drilling (MPD) has become the essential drilling technique to drill problematic zones
in these past decades due to its ability to precisely manipulate downhole equivalent mud weight (EMW).
This ability empowers the operator to save time and cost when drilling through loss zone with lower drilling
fluid and at the same time, able to retain EMW above the wellbore instability or, if required, pore pressure
gradient.
This paper describes the crucial role of MPD in a drilling operation on a horizontal deep water oil producer
well in Sabah region, offshore of East Malaysia, to help the Operator recover from Wellbore Instability and
Loss Circulation issues and successfully drill and cement the problematic section. The main challenge of
the well is the tight drilling window between depleted sand formation and the interlayered shale formation.
Therefore, the MPD Integrated Riser Joint (IRJ) was deployed along with the riser string prior drilling 12.25
in hole section. Initially, the section was drilled conventionally with wellbore strengthening techniques, only
to encounter unmanageable static losses. After multiple unsuccessful attempts to cure losses, the section
was cement plugged to sidetrack the well.
Considering the substantial challenges encountered, the well was sidetracked with lighter drilling fluid
and applied surface back pressure (SBP) to maintain its bottom hole pressure above the wellbore instability
gradient and below the fracture gradient. After the well had reached target depth, the drilling assembly was
pulled out of hole in MPD mode without having to displace the well to heavier tripping mud and, once it
was above the Subsea Blowout Preventor (SSBOP), the well was then isolated with blind shear rams (BSR).
To continue maintaining SBP below the BSR, the MPD system was lined up on a surface loop circulation
in such a way that the SBP was applied to the well via kill line. With the casing string delivered to the
bottom, Managed Pressure Cementing (MPC) was utilized to cement the casing by having a schedule of
SBP against pumped strokes that was formulated by software simulation to give a minimum pressure surge
when the cement slurry entered the open hole.
In addition, the paper also describes the equipment setup required onboard a drillship for drilling with
MPD in a deep-water setting. The MPD setup enables the application of advanced flow detection system and
2 SPE-215029-MS
riser gas handling which are critical in drilling deep water wells. With all these features, MPD Deepwater
application has successfully delivered the well to target depth which once was undrillable.
Introduction
This paper emphasizes the importance MPD in achieving objectives of the initial drilling section within a
broader drilling campaign. By implementing Managed Pressure Drilling (MPD), the operator effectively
overcame challenges related to wellbore instability and loss circulation, enabling the successful drilling, and
• Limited sidetrack trajectory: Due to the limited options available for a sidetrack trajectory, there
was only one more attempt remaining before a walk-away scenario would need to be considered.
This limitation added significant pressure to execute the subsequent steps effectively and achieve
the desired outcomes.
• Wellbore Stability: Initial prognosis of 10.4 ppg EMW to maintain wellbore stability, however
severe losses occurred at a value much lower in the main bore.
• Leak-off test (LOT) at 13.625 in casing shoe: next challenge was to perform a leak-off test at the
13.625 in casing shoe as there was a potential risk of wellbore flexing, particularly at the kick-
off junction. This could potentially cause cement breakouts and result in the cement falling onto
SPE-215029-MS 3
the sidetrack wellbore. It was crucial to carefully manage this risk to ensure the integrity of the
wellbore and the success of subsequent operations.
• Open Hole Formation Integrity Test (OH FIT): Another challenge was to perform an open hole
FIT to establish the window required for displacing the well to an overbalance fluid. This step was
essential to allow operations to continue conventionally, without the need of MPD techniques. The
challenge here was to conduct the FIT successfully and obtain the necessary data while ensuring
the stability of the wellbore and preventing any potential issues.
• Displacing the well to statically overbalanced SOB depend on the OH FIT result, displacing the
Engineering Planning
During the Front-End Engineering Design (FEED) phase, it was determined that three out of eight sections
would require MPD as a contingency due to a narrow drilling margin. Originally planned for conventional
drilling, a precautionary measure was established in case the drilling margin in the open hole was insufficient
for displacement Equivalent Circulating Density (ECD). The plan involved plugging back the open hole with
cement and isolating it at the previous casing shoe. This ensured the maintenance of an overbalance drilling
mud weight. The subsequent operation included running the BHA, displacing the well to a lighter mud
weight, and drilling to TD with the MPD approach. If the depleted sand could be adequately strengthened,
the well would then be displaced to an overbalance mud weight at the section TD before conventionally
tripping out the drilling BHA.
Following severe losses encountered during the initial 12.25 in section, the losses were remedied by
squeezing cement into the loss zone. The squeezed cement was carefully tagged and dressed, and a leak-
off test was conducted to confirm the hydraulic isolation of the loss zone. Subsequently, a balanced cement
plug was placed as a kick-off cement plug.
With limited alternative sidetrack options available, the team recognized the significance of their
remaining opportunity to meet the objectives. Consequently, the primary focus shifted towards securing
the hole section and ensuring the successful completion of the drilling operation. The contingency plan
underwent a meticulous reassessment, resulting in an optimized strategy that incorporated both MPD
techniques and wellbore strengthening strategies. This approach ensured a more robust and resilient path
forward. The optimized strategy included the following elements:
• Light mud weight: To optimize the selection of the starting light mud weight and ensure wellbore
stability with MPD, extensive analysis and modeling were conducted. The resulting starting light
mud weight of 9.2 ppg SOBM was determined through Equivalent Circulating Density (ECD)
modeling. This mud weight was chosen based on the criteria of maintaining wellbore stability
within the limits of the minimum wellbore stability requirement of 10.4 ppg EMW, as shown in
Fig. 1.
The selection of the starting light mud weight also considered the ability to achieve the maximum
loss-free ECD in the event of severe losses, as shown in Fig. 2. By starting with 9.2 ppg SOBM
and carefully managing the SBP, the team will be able to reduce the ECD to 9.91 ppg EMW which
was the loss-free ECD established on the initial 12.25 in section.
4 SPE-215029-MS
Meanwhile, continuous monitoring of MPD Early Kick Detection (EKD) and downhole
conditions such as pressure while drilling (PWD), were also implemented to detect any signs of
severe losses on the sidetrack bore. This will enable the drilling team to respond earlier to loss
events and adjust the drilling parameters accordingly to maintain loss-free downhole circulation.
In the event of encountering losses, the team planned to promptly reduce the ECD to the loss-
free ECD by adjusting the SBP. This flexibility allowed for a rapid response to mitigate losses and
maintain wellbore stability. By continuously monitoring the well conditions and adjusting the SBP
as needed, the team aimed to minimize the impact of losses and prevent any potential issues that
Figure 2—MPD Hydraulic Simulation to Maintain max EMW of 9.91 ppg in the event of loss circulation.
6 SPE-215029-MS
Figure 4—MPC Simulation to maintain EMW of 10.4-10.6 ppg during 9.625 in liner cementing operation.
By implementing these strategies and conducting thorough modeling and analysis, the team were able
to overcome the challenges and maintain the integrity and stability of the wellbore, ensuring the successful
completion of section objectives.
During MPD operations, the RCD bearing assembly is installed on the RCD that seals the top of the
annulus and allow the return flow to divert into two flowspool outlets with 5″ coflex hoses connecting to the
MPD surface equipment. A 2″ coflex hose is connected to the side flange of the RCD that allows to bleed
off trapped pressure between the RCD and the DSIT or flowspools. The DSIT serves as a conventional riser
gas handling and also, acts as a barrier to keep the well under pressure if there is a need to replace the RCD
bearing assembly during MPD operations. Six hydraulic piper valves, DSIT and the RCD hydraulic latches
are controlled from surface using the Umbilical Reels.
The drilling operation in MPD mode successfully reached the section target depth at 9300 ft MD which
was deeper than originally planned at 9058 ft MD, holding 10.5ppg (See Fig. 8) at the casing shoe depth
and took 44.5 drilling hours with a total of fifteen MPD connections performed. No circulation loss or pack
off event was encountered throughout the drilling operation in MPD mode.
Figure 8—SBP & Bottom Hole ECD (PWD) profile during 12.25 in drilling operation.
10 SPE-215029-MS
Figure 9—Line up for MPD system to trapped pressure below closed BSR
With the riser system isolated from the well and MPD system, RCD Bearing Assembly was then retrieved,
and the BHA was pulled out and laid down for 9.625 in liner run.
SPE-215029-MS 11
The cement unit was lined up to the cement head and pump 80 bbls of 9.7 ppg lead spacer, followed
by 136 bbls of 14.5 ppg cement slurry before pumping another 10 bbls of mixwater as tail spacer. While
pumping with cement unit, MPD applied 310 psi of SBP and increased to 460 psi SBP when pumps are off
to switch between fluids. The cement unit continue to displace the string by pumping 9.2 ppg SOBM at 4
bpm while MPD continue to apply 310 psi SBP. Due to much heavier cement slurry (14.5 ppg) compared
to SOBM in the annulus (9.2 ppg), a significant U-tubing was observed during the displacement.
After displacing 201 bbls of 9.2 ppg SOBM which was the theoretical volume of the string, SBP was
gradually reduced to compensate the hydrostatic of cement slurry coming out to annulus. Once top plug was
bumped and cement unit stopped pumping, SBP was ramped up again to 230 psi to hold the casing shoe
at 10.5 ppg EMW until 9.625 in liner packer was set and tested. With a comparison of the volume pumped
and returned on cement tank, no loss was observed during the MPC operation.
12 SPE-215029-MS
Conclusion
The integration of the MPD system in deepwater operations has provided significant advantages and
technical capabilities for the Operator to overcome downhole challenges and achieve successful drilling and
cementing of the well without encountering losses in the depleted formation. The use of MPD has allowed
for efficient navigation within the tight pressure window, and the full spectrum of MPD operations from
drilling to cementing has proven to be a time and cost-saving approach by eliminating the need for additional
overbalance mud and reducing the time required for well and riser displacement.
Furthermore, running casing and performing cementing operations in MPD mode have been successful,
with no losses or significant hole collapse experienced throughout the operations. This success has
reinforced the decision to integrate the MPD Deepwater system for future narrow window drilling
wells originally planned for conventional drilling. By adopting the MPD strategy, the Operator can save
costs, minimize time spent on addressing losses that require LCM squeezing, cement plugging, and well
sidetracking, which were unexpected challenges faced in previous wells.
Overall, the application of MPD in deepwater drilling has proven to be an invaluable setup, providing
a wide range of capabilities to the operation. It has successfully enabled the drilling of wells that were
previously considered undrillable, ensuring the delivery of wells to the target depth. This success highlights
the effectiveness and reliability of MPD in deepwater operations, demonstrating its ability to enhance
efficiency, mitigate risks, and improve overall drilling performance.