Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nutritional Care The Poor Child' of Clinical Cerebral Palsy
Nutritional Care The Poor Child' of Clinical Cerebral Palsy
Nutritional Care The Poor Child' of Clinical Cerebral Palsy
on
si
er
Abstract. There is a considerable risk of malnutrition for children with CP due to insufficient nutritional intake. The most im-
fv
portant causes of insufficient intake are feeding problems which are highly prevalent in children with CP (depending on def-
inition, age and heterogeneity of the researched population). Considering these facts, nutritional status should have the full
attention of healthcare professionals but this is not yet the case. Evidence from research in clinical practice suggests that:
oo
1) there is no consensus regarding who should perform the measurement and how often, 2) no standardised nutritional assess-
ment is implemented, and 3) there is suboptimal communication and management about feeding and nutritional status in most
pr
healthcare networks.
To overcome these problems, validated and practical tools for the screening and assessment of nutritional status should be a topic
of research and subsequently made available and implemented in clinical practice. Because body composition is an objective
ed
indicator of available energy stores, research should focus on optimising measurement methods to determine body composition
using anthropometric measures or bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA). Furthermore, there is a definite need among health
ct
care providers for explicit and clear agreements on organisation and communication about nutritional care for children with CP.
rre
1 11
6 tors: 1) insufficient attention to nutritional status dur- rent suboptimal nutritional care for children with 16
1874-5393/19/$35.00 c 2019 – IOS Press and the authors. All rights reserved
Galley Proof 12/06/2019; 14:15 File: prm–1-prm180537.tex; BOKCTP/xhs p. 2
2 D.A.C. Snik et al. / Nutritional care: The ‘poor child’ of clinical care in children with cerebral palsy
25 2. Nutritional challenges in children with CP have been carried out. There are no further data about 75
27 heterogeneity) and used definitions, at least 19% of in- Currently, Anna and her mother regularly visit a 78
28 dividuals with CP have feeding difficulties that may ‘saliva control team’ for evaluation and treatment of 79
29 lead to malnutrition [1]. Extreme prevalence numbers her oral-motor problems. This team does not check nu- 80
30 (99%) can be found in the literature when consider- tritional status. Furthermore, a school-affiliated physi- 81
31 ing children with severe CP [2]. Malnutrition in chil- atrist and dietician are involved. Unfortunately, they do 82
32 dren with CP is a serious problem as it markedly in- not have access to hospital data. Based on assumptions, 83
33 creases their mortality rates [3] and worsens quality of the school team expects that specialists at the hospi- 84
34 life. Thus, nutritional status should have the full atten- tal will monitor Anna’s nutritional status. Occasion- 85
35 tion of healthcare professionals. The following case of ally, the dietician checks and adjusts the volume of the 86
36 Anna illustrates the omissions in clinical practice. enteral formula according to age, but only when the 87
37 Anna is a six-year old girl with bilateral mixed type mother asks for it. 88
38 Cerebral Palsy. She walks with a walking aid (Gross In this case, the earlier mentioned problems are ob- 89
on
39 Motor Functioning Classification System (GMFCS) vious: 1) there is an insufficient amount of attention 90
40 level III) and has severe feeding difficulties because of given to nutritional status during doctor consultations, 91
si
92
41 oral-motor dysfunction, drooling, gastro-oesophageal
and 3) there is a lack in communication and manage- 93
reflux, recurrent periods of vomiting, and poor gastric
er
42
ment considering feeding and nutritional status among 94
43 emptying. Anna is completely tube fed, but occasion-
healthcare professionals. 95
44 ally, she is given a few bites orally for taste (Eating and
fv
45 Drinking Ability Classification System (EDACS) level
V). Because of her swallowing problems, there is high
oo
46
3. A dutch survey 96
47 risk of aspiration, leading to frequent respiratory tract
infections. Despite extensive medical evaluation, par- To investigate the extent of these shortcomings in
pr
48 97
49 ents report that they never received an explanation for clinical practise, a survey was conducted as part of a re- 98
50 the recurrent periods of vomiting. liability study of the Dutch Eating and Drinking Abil- 99
ed
51 At the age of 5.5 years, Anna learned to walk and ity Classification System (EDACS, accepted, 2017). 100
52 is very proud of this accomplishment. Especially at Caregivers of 69 children with CP (child characteris- 101
ct
53 school, she wants to walk and play with her friends as tics, Table 1) answered the following questions: 102
54 much as possible. Anna temporarily loses the ability to 1. What are the current height and weight measure-
rre
103
55 walk during exhausting periods of frequent vomiting ments of your child? 104
56 and is unable to complete a full week of school atten- 2. How often are height and weight measured? 105
co
57 dance. In addition, she also loses weight during these 3. Who, among your child’s healthcare providers, 106
58 periods. feels responsible for evaluation of the height and 107
un
60 nutritional status on activities and quality of life. The results are notable. Of the children, 36.2% 109
61 Furthermore, it illustrates nutritional care should be (25/69) suffered from malnutrition (WHO definition 110
62 optimized in healthcare networks, as set out hereafter: of height/weight scores z-score < −2), 30.4% (21/69) 111
63 To evaluate growth and nutritional status in “usual were measured less than yearly, and seven different 112
64 care”, Anna’s height has been measured with a stand- health care professionals were reported to be in the 113
65 ing calliper and weight has been measured with a scale lead (paediatrician, physiatrist, school nurse, child and 114
66 device while she could barely stand up straight. From adolescent healthcare doctor, neurologist, endocrinol- 115
67 the age of 4 years, measurements have been carried out ogist, physiotherapist). In 11.6% (8/69) of cases, par- 116
68 roughly every 6 months in an out-patient setting at pae- ents reported that they were responsible for the mea- 117
69 diatrician visits and have been recorded on a growth surements. The study results show that a fundamental 118
70 chart for typically developing children (Fig. 1). Re- problem exists in organising assessment of nutritional 119
71 viewing the results, the consulted physician was satis- status. It is unclear for parents whom of the healthcare 120
72 fied and therefore expanded visit intervals to once ev- professionals should be held responsible for nutritional 121
73 ery year. No other anthropometric measures or other assessment, how it should be documented, and how of- 122
74 (laboratory) diagnostic tests for nutritional assessment ten it should be carried out. 123
Galley Proof 12/06/2019; 14:15 File: prm–1-prm180537.tex; BOKCTP/xhs p. 3
D.A.C. Snik et al. / Nutritional care: The ‘poor child’ of clinical care in children with cerebral palsy 3
on
si
er
fv
oo
pr
ed
ct
rre
co
124 4. What can be measured? best indicator of the health and nutritional status of 137
125 Scarpato et al. are calling for a practical approach gardless of their aetiology, invariably affect the child’s 139
126 of nutritional assessment for children with CP [4]. It growth. Height and weight measurements necessary 140
127 is important that measurements are feasible in the out- to evaluate growth may be difficult to assess in chil- 141
128 patient setting, time efficient, inexpensive, and stress- dren with CP; e.g. because of joint contractures that 142
129 free for the child and the parents. Repeated and reliable might complicate reliable measurement of height. Fig- 143
130 measurements should be carried out to prevent under ure 1 (see the arrow) shows that in this case not all 144
131 or overdiagnosing, as well as starting nutritional inter- measurement points are in line with what can be ex- 145
132 vention when unnecessary, putting the child at risk of pected based on age and growth pattern. Children may 146
133 becoming overweight. also be wheelchair users impeding adequate weight as- 147
134 4.1. Height and weight tal measurements, may be necessary. An example of 149
135 As stated by the World Health Organisation, in typ- mental measures like knee height [6]. After weight 151
136 ically developing children, growth monitoring is the and height are measured or estimated, they are plot- 152
Galley Proof 12/06/2019; 14:15 File: prm–1-prm180537.tex; BOKCTP/xhs p. 4
4 D.A.C. Snik et al. / Nutritional care: The ‘poor child’ of clinical care in children with cerebral palsy
Table 1
Demographics of participants
whom reference data were derived, were malnour- 168
(n = 69) erly inform the health care professional about available 171
Boys 41 55.3 height and weight measurements as markers for ‘good 173
Girls 28 44.7 nutritional status’ is insufficient in children with CP. 174
CP classification according to Thus, the European Society for Paediatric Gastroen- 175
SCPE
terology, Hepatology and Nutrition (ESPGHAN) com- 176
Spastic 51 73.9
Dyskinetic 2 2.9 mittee guidelines do not recommend the use of CP- 177
on
III 6 8.7 age of fat mass and fat-free mass, is a more objec- 181
si
183
er
I 12 17.4 tion technique, 2) from dual-energy x-ray absorptiom- 185
II 24 34.8
etry (DXA) scans and, double indirectly from 3) an- 186
III 12 17.4
fv
IV 14 20.3 thropometric measures like BMI and skinfold mea- 187
Degree of assistance needed with analysis (BIA) [16–20]. The deuterium dilution tech- 189
eating and drinking nique and DXA (indirect techniques) are mainly used 190
Independent 25 36.2
pr
Requires assistance 29 42
in large-scale scientific studies because of their costs 191
Totally dependent 15 21.7 in terms of money and personnel. The double indirect 192
Tube feeding 5 7.2 easy to use in clinical practice but their precision on an 194
Oral feeding 59 59 individual level is questionable and needs to be opti- 195
ct
ity classification system. carbohydrates, and proteins, sufficient intake of mi- 199
un
153 ted on standard growth charts. These charts, based mins, minerals, and trace elements. They are impor- 201
154 on healthy reference groups, can be used to monitor tant for many metabolic pathways and micronutrient 202
155 whether children remain in their growth curve, but they deficiencies may affect cognition, behaviour, social in- 203
156 may not be suitable for conclusions about desirable teraction, developmental outcomes and hence quality 204
157 growth and target height in children with CP. For ex- of life [21]. Children with CP often eat less and non- 205
158 ample, children with CP who have GMFCS levels II-V diversified food compared to typically developing chil- 206
159 are significantly shorter compared to ‘typically devel- dren, which puts them at risk for low micronutrient 207
160 oping’ children. In an attempt to correct for this differ- intake [22]. Also, when the child is exclusively tube 208
161 ence, CP specific growth charts were designed [3]. Un- fed, there is a risk of insufficient intake of micronutri- 209
162 fortunately, there are three issues that introduce bias: ents, because necessary amounts of micronutrients are 210
163 1) Segmental length formulas include some potential only met when enough volume is consumed. Related to 211
164 errors. For instance, when calculating body mass index oral-motor and gastrointestinal impairment, volume in- 212
165 (BMI), these errors are squared. 2) For the aforesaid take is often reduced in children with CP. To assess the 213
166 reasons of feeding problems leading to risk of malnu- micronutrient status of a child, a blood sample needs 214
167 trition, it is probable that some of the children from to be collected which can be uncomfortable. 215
Galley Proof 12/06/2019; 14:15 File: prm–1-prm180537.tex; BOKCTP/xhs p. 5
D.A.C. Snik et al. / Nutritional care: The ‘poor child’ of clinical care in children with cerebral palsy 5
Table 2
Red flag warning signs
Physical signs of undernutrition, such as decubitus skin problems, poor peripheral circulation
Weight for age z-score < −2
Triceps skinfold thickness < 10th percentile for age and sex
Mid-upper arm fat or muscle area < 10th percentile
Faltering weight and/or failure to thrive
216 5. What should be measured? dren with CP due to insufficient nutritional intake nec- 256
essary for their needs. The most important causes of in- 257
217 Reviewing the options and pitfalls of the different sufficient intake are feeding problems which are highly 258
218 measurement methods, it is a challenge to decide what prevalent in children with CP (depending on defini- 259
219 measuring methods are applicable in which children tion, age and heterogeneity of the researched popula- 260
220 and on what time interval. Valuing results in the ab- tion) [1,2]. Considering these facts, nutritional status 261
221 sence of optimal reference values complicates these should have the full attention of healthcare profession- 262
222 decisions even more. Until recently, there was no prac- als but this is not the case yet. 263
tical guideline for the clinical evaluation of nutritional
on
223
Nutritional care in children with CP is complex, 264
224 status in children with CP. However, the ESPGHAN therefore, validation of practical tools for screening 265
225 working group has developed guidelines for the eval- and assessment of nutritional status should be a topic
si
266
226 uation and treatment of gastrointestinal and nutritional of research. Subsequently, those tools should be made 267
complications in children with neurological impair-
er
227
available and implemented in clinical practice (e.g. 268
228 ment [10]. Multiple suggestions and recommendations
through education of health care professionals). Be- 269
229 have been formulated with sometimes limited evidence
fv
cause body composition is an objective indicator of 270
230 to substantiate them.
available energy stores, research should focus on opti- 271
The working group suggests combining measure-
oo
231
mising measurement methods to determine body com- 272
232 ments and ‘red flag warning signs’ for the identifica-
position (using anthropometric measures or BIA) [24]. 273
233 tion of undernutrition in neurologically impaired chil-
pr
276
236 ever, the identification of physical signs of undernutri-
237 tion and used anthropometric measurements are prone care for children with CP. 277
238
278
240 this guideline suggests that children should have an-
241 thropometry assessment at least every six months and
The authors have no conflict of interest to report. 279
242 that micronutrients are checked annually. Because this
co
280
245 not yet been evaluated.
[1] Parkes J, Hill N, Platt MJ, Donnelly C. Oromotor dysfunc- 281
tion and communication impairments in children with cere- 282
246 6. Who should be measuring? bral palsy: a register study. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2010; 283
52(12): 1113-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8749.2010.03765.x. 284
247 The case of Anna highlights that, beside the pres- [2] Calis EA, Veugelers R, Sheppard JJ, Tibboel D, Evenhuis 285
248 ence of a capable multidisciplinary team, it is crucial HM, Penning C. Dysphagia in children with severe general- 286
ized cerebral palsy and intellectual disability. Dev Med Child 287
249 that there are regional agreements about who is respon- Neurol. 2008; 50(8): 625-30. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8749.2008. 288
250 sible for each part of the nutritional assessment, who is 03047.x. 289
251 responsible for the overall management, and that there [3] Brooks J, Day S, Shavelle R, Strauss D. Low weight, morbid- 290
252 is reciprocal communication among health care profes- ity, and mortality in children with cerebral palsy: new clini- 291
253 sionals and the child and/or parents. cal growth charts. Pediatrics. 2011; 128(2): e299-307. doi: 10. 292
1542/peds.2010-2801. 293
[4] Scarpato E, Staiano A, Molteni M, Terrone G, Mazzoc- 294
chi A, Agostoni C. Nutritional assessment and intervention 295
254 7. Conclusion in children with cerebral palsy: a practical approach. Int J 296
Food Sci Nutr. 2017; 68(6): 763-70. doi: 10.1080/09637486. 297
255 There is a considerable risk of malnutrition for chil- 2017.1289502. 298
Galley Proof 12/06/2019; 14:15 File: prm–1-prm180537.tex; BOKCTP/xhs p. 6
6 D.A.C. Snik et al. / Nutritional care: The ‘poor child’ of clinical care in children with cerebral palsy
299 [5] Physical status : the use and interpretation of anthropometry. [15] Tomoum HY, Badawy NB, Hassan NE, Alian KM. Anthro- 344
300 Meeting Report: WHO; 1995. pometry and body composition analysis in children with cere- 345
301 [6] Haapala H, Peterson MD, Daunter A, Hurvitz EA. Agree- bral palsy. Clin Nutr. 2010; 29(4): 477-81. doi: 10.1016/j. 346
302 ment between actual height and estimated height using seg- clnu.2009.10.009. 347
303 mental limb lengths for individuals with cerebral palsy. Am J [16] Azcue MP, Zello GA, Levy LD, Pencharz PB. Energy ex- 348
304 Phys Med Rehabil. 2015; 94(7): 539-46. doi: 10.1097/PHM. penditure and body composition in children with spastic 349
305 0000000000000205. quadriplegic cerebral palsy. J Pediatr. 1996; 129(6): 870-6. 350
306 [7] Samson-Fang LJ, Stevenson RD. Identification of malnutri- [17] Bell KL, Boyd RN, Walker JL, Stevenson RD, Davies PS. 351
307 tion in children with cerebral palsy: poor performance of The use of bioelectrical impedance analysis to estimate total 352
308 weight-for-height centiles. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2000; body water in young children with cerebral palsy. Clin Nutr. 353
309 42(3): 162-8. 2013; 32(4): 579-84. doi: 10.1016/j.clnu.2012.10.005. 354
310 [8] Kuperminc MN, Gurka MJ, Bennis JA, Busby MG, Grossberg [18] Liu LF, Roberts R, Moyer-Mileur L, Samson-Fang L. Deter- 355
311 RI, Henderson RC, et al. Anthropometric measures: poor pre- mination of body composition in children with cerebral palsy: 356
312 dictors of body fat in children with moderate to severe cere- bioelectrical impedance analysis and anthropometry vs dual- 357
313 bral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2010; 52(9): 824-30. doi: energy x-ray absorptiometry. J Am Diet Assoc. 2005; 105(5): 358
314 10.1111/j.1469-8749.2010.03694.x. 794-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jada.2005.02.006. 359
315 [9] Finbraten AK, Martins C, Andersen GL, Skranes J, [19] Oeffinger DJ, Gurka MJ, Kuperminc M, Hassani S, Buhr 360
316 Brannsether B, Juliusson PB, et al. Assessment of body com- N, Tylkowski C. Accuracy of skinfold and bioelectrical 361
317 position in children with cerebral palsy: a cross-sectional impedance assessments of body fat percentage in ambulatory 362
on
318 study in Norway. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2015; 57(9): 858- individuals with cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2014; 363
319 64. doi: 10.1111/dmcn.12752. 56(5): 475-81. doi: 10.1111/dmcn.12342. 364
[10] Romano C, van Wynckel M, Hulst J, Broekaert I, Bronsky [20] Rieken R, van Goudoever JB, Schierbeek H, Willemsen SP,
si
320 365
321 J, Dall’Oglio L, et al. European society for paediatric gast- Calis EA, Tibboel D, et al. Measuring body composition and 366
er
322 roenterology, hepatology and nutrition guidelines for the energy expenditure in children with severe neurologic impair- 367
323 evaluation and treatment of gastrointestinal and nutritional ment and intellectual disability. Am J Clin Nutr. 2011; 94(3): 368
complications in children with neurological impairment. 759-66. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.110.003798.
324
fv 369
325 J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2017; 65(2): 242-64. doi: [21] Penagini F, Mameli C, Fabiano V, Brunetti D, Dilillo D, Zuc- 370
326 10.1097/MPG.0000000000001646. cotti GV. Dietary intakes and nutritional issues in neurologi- 371
oo
327 [11] Fomon SJ, Nelson SE. Body composition of the male and fe- cally impaired children. Nutrients. 2015; 7(11): 9400-15. doi: 372
328 male reference infants. Annu Rev Nutr. 2002; 22: 1-17. doi: 10.3390/nu7115469. 373
329 10.1146/annurev.nutr.22.111401.145049. [22] Hillesund E, Skranes J, Trygg KU, Bohmer T. Micronutrient 374
pr
330 [12] Noble JJ, Charles-Edwards GD, Keevil SF, Lewis AP, Gough status in children with cerebral palsy. Acta Paediatr. 2007; 375
331 M, Shortland AP. Intramuscular fat in ambulant young adults 96(8): 1195-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1651-2227.2007.00354.x. 376
332 with bilateral spastic cerebral palsy. BMC Musculoskelet Dis- [23] Conkle J, Ramakrishnan U, Flores-Ayala R, Suchdev PS, 377
ed
333 ord. 2014; 15: 236. doi: 10.1186/1471-2474-15-236. Martorell R. Improving the quality of child anthropometry: 378
334 [13] Gurka MJ, Kuperminc MN, Busby MG, Bennis JA, Grossberg Manual anthropometry in the body imaging for nutritional as- 379
335 RI, Houlihan CM, et al. Assessment and correction of skinfold sessment study (BINA). PLoS One. 2017; 12(12): e0189332. 380
ct
336 thickness equations in estimating body fat in children with doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0189332. 381
337 cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2010; 52(2): e35-41. [24] Snik DAC, Van Hulst K, Jongerius PH, Verschuren O, Kete- 382
rre
338 doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8749.2009.03474.x. laar M, Erasmus CE, et al. Poster presentations, validity of 383
339 [14] Hurvitz EA, Green LB, Hornyak JE, Khurana SR, Koch LG. bioelectrical impedance analysis to determine body composi- 384
340 Body mass index measures in children with cerebral palsy tion in children with cerebral palsy: a review. Dev Med Child 385
co
341 related to gross motor function classification: a clinic-based Neurol. 2017; 59: 46-87. doi: 10.1111/dmcn.13456. 386
342 study. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2008; 87(5): 395-403. doi:
10.1097/PHM.0b013e3181617736.
un
343