Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Moderation Resource For Schools
Moderation Resource For Schools
Moderation Resource For Schools
schools
Version 2.0 | Updated 2019
Part A: Understanding moderation and key principles – a general overview of moderation, suggested
membership of the moderation team and advice on the best time to moderate.
Part B: NCCD moderation process – a sample moderation process that a school might use to undertake
moderation.
Part C: Reference material – links to key resources that schools should refer to during the process of
moderation to improve the consistency and reliability of their data.
1
‘An adjustment is a measure or action taken to assist a student with disability to participate in education and training on the same basis
as other students. An adjustment is reasonable if it achieves this purpose while taking into account the student’s learning needs and
balancing the interests of all parties affected, including those of the student with disability, the education provider, staff and other
students’ (DET, n.d., p2) ‘Adjustment’ means one of: support provided within quality differentiated teaching practice; supplementary
adjustments; substantial adjustments; or extensive adjustments, as defined in the NCCD guidelines
(https://www.education.gov.au/nationally-consistent-collection-data-students-disability-guidelines).
2
https://www.nccd.edu.au/sites/default/files/nccd_guidelines.pdf
the level of adjustment being provided for each student to meet the identified educational needs arising
from their disability
the broad category of disability for which support is provided.
The NCCD captures the ongoing work undertaken by teachers and school staff throughout the year in
providing personalised learning and support for students with disability. It reflects the valuable knowledge
teachers acquire about students’ educational needs and the decisions they make about how these needs
can be best supported.
The moderation process and timeline is shown in Figure 1 on the next page.
3
https://www.legislation.gov.au/Series/C2004A04426
4
https://docs.education.gov.au/node/16354
5
https://www.nccd.edu.au/wider-support-materials/what-nccd-model-1?parent=%2Funderstanding&activity=%2Fwider-support-
materials%2Fwhat-nccd-model-1&step=-1
6
https://www.nccd.edu.au/wider-support-materials/when-student-eligible-be-included?parent=%2Funderstanding&activity=%2Fwider-
support-materials%2Fwhat-nccd-model-1
7
https://www.nccd.edu.au/sites/default/files/nccd_guidelines.pdf
Figure 1 shows the timing of the NCCD moderation process within the school year and the completion of the
NCCD process. There is a horizontal arrow pointing to the right with four icons denoting the four school
terms.
Term 1 is labelled Planning.
Term 2 is labelled Implementation.
Term 3 is labelled Validation.
Term 4 is labelled Process review and reflection.
Beneath this horizontal arrow there is a vertical flow chart that contains the seven steps of the NCCD
moderation process, linked by arrows to show the process of the moderation is linear.
8
Moderators refer to the following: Australian Professional Standards for Teachers (Proficient); Level of adjustment provided to the
student; and Broad categories of disability.
Student Moderator 1: Moderator 2: Agree (before Agree (after Moderator 1: Moderator 2: Agree Agree (after Notes regarding
identifier Level of Level of moderation) moderation) Category of Category of (before moderation) decisions
adjustment adjustment Y/N Y/N disability disability moderation) Y/N
Y/N
9
Quality Differentiated Teaching Practice
Bibliography
DECD 2016, Moderation matters: A guide to leading collaborative moderation in schools, DECD, South
Australia.
DET (2015) Fact Sheet: Disability Standards for Education 2005. Canberra: DET.
Hipkins, R & Robertson, S 2011, Moderation and teacher learning: What can research tell us about their
relationships?, Wellington: New Zealand Council for Educational Research.
Planning for personalised learning and support: A national resource, Canberra: DET.
Students with disability are supported through active Students with disability are provided with Students with disability who have more substantial Students with disability and very high support
monitoring and adjustments that are not greater than those adjustments that are supplementary to the support needs are provided with essential adjustments needs are provided with extensive targeted
used to meet the needs of diverse learners. These adjustments strategies and resources already available and considerable adult assistance. measures and sustained levels of intensive
are provided through usual school processes, without drawing for all students within the school. support. These adjustments are highly
Level of adjustment descriptors
Quality differentiated teaching practice caters to the needs of a Specific examples of adjustments at this level Adjustments at this level generally: Specific examples of adjustments at this level could
diverse student population. Students at this level do not require the could include: are considerable in extent include:
adjustments that are captured in the other three levels. adjustments to teaching and learning, such as: occur within highly structured situations. adjustments to teaching and learning, such as:
o modified or tailored programs in some or o personalised modifications to all courses and
Adjustments at this level generally: Specific examples of adjustments at this level could include:
many learning areas programs, school activities and assessment
are explicit, albeit minor, adjustments to teaching and school adjustments to teaching and learning, such as:
o modified instruction using a structured task- procedures
practice that enable students with disability to access learning on o frequent (teacher directed) individual instruction
analysis approach o intensive individual instruction
the same basis as their peers o access to bridging programs
Typical adjustment
Through support provided within quality differentiated teaching Students at this level often require support in Examples might include: Students at this level may be dependent on adult
practice, a student is able to participate in courses and programs at accessing the curriculum at the appropriate year students who require curriculum content at a different support to participate effectively in most aspects of their
the school and use the facilities and services available to all level (ie the outcomes and content of usual year level to their same-age peers school program.
Student characteristics
students, on the same basis as students without a disability. learning programs or courses). students who will only acquire new concepts and skills, or
Without highly intensive intervention, these students may
access some of the outcomes and content of the usual
Examples might include: Examples might include: otherwise not access or participate effectively in
learning program, courses or subjects, when significant
• students who have particular difficulty schooling.
• students with medical conditions such as asthma, diabetes and curriculum adjustments are made to address their
acquiring new concepts and skills outside a
anaphylaxis, that have a functional impact on their schooling, but learning needs Many students at this level will have been identified at a
highly structured environment.
whose disability-related needs are being addressed through students who have limited capacity to communicate very young age and may also:
quality differentiated teaching practice and active monitoring The needs of some students at this level may be effectively have complex, associated support needs with
• a student with a mental health condition who has strategies in related to their personal care, communication, students who need regular support with personal regard to their personal care and hygiene, medical
place to manage the condition in consultation with medical safety, social interaction or mobility, or to physical hygiene and movement around the school. conditions and mobility
professionals, that can be provided within quality differentiated access issues, any of which may limit their use an augmentative communication system
These students may also have considerable, often
teaching practice capacity to participate effectively in the full life of have particular support needs when presented with
associated support needs, relating to their personal care,
a student with a medical condition or a mental health condition their school. new concepts and skills.
safety, self-regulation or social interaction, which also
that has a functional impact on their schooling and requires
impact significantly on their participation and learning.
ongoing monitoring but who does not require a higher level of
support or adjustment during the period they are being
considered for the data collection
• a student who has been provided with a higher level of
adjustment in the past or may require a higher level of adjustment
in their future schooling.
Cognitive
f) a disorder or malfunction that
results in the person learning
Learning disabilities
differently from a person without
the disorder or malfunction
Sensory Sensory
f) a disorder or malfunction that
results in the person learning
differently from a person without
the disorder or malfunction