Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Crossing Merfolk, The Human, A
Crossing Merfolk, The Human, A
overboard during the Middle Passage transformed into oceanic beings—as its
point of departure. This idea appears in many texts besides the sonic fiction of
Drexciya, and it should be theorized as a recurring tradition in Black culture
(Davis, “Crossing Merfolk”). I call this narrative “crossing merfolk,” following
M. Jacqui Alexander’s use of “the Crossing” to describe both “the enforced
Atlantic Crossing of millions of Africans that serviced from the fifteenth
century through the twentieth the consolidation of British, French, Spanish,
and Dutch empires” (2) and “the crossroads, the space of convergence and
endless possibility” (8). Focusing my analysis on Nalo Hopkinson’s 2004 novel
The New Moon’s Arms and Rivers Solomon’s 2019 novel The Deep, I argue
that crossing merfolk narratives enhance the mermaid figure’s potential to
disrupt the hierarchical and ecologically disastrous category of the human.
By anchoring mermaid lore within the transatlantic slave trade as it launches
modernity and global racial capitalism, crossing merfolk narratives interrupt
the human. In doing so, these narratives reveal the imbrication of white
supremacist and environmental violence and embody alternative forms of
being.
Several scholars have proposed the mermaid as a figure that disrupts
Western humanism. In Mermaids and the Production of Knowledge in Early
Modern England, Tara Pedersen states that “The notion of a ‘whole human’
who exists in distinct hierarchical separation from the animal world is arguably
upset by competing popular images such as that of the mermaid” (26-27).
In From Amazons to Zombies: Monsters in Latin America, Penelope Braham
argues that “the siren’s hybridity and mutability embody resistance to modern
science and statehood, portending unfamiliar paradigms for human enterprise
and understanding” (89). And Peter Mortensen insists in “‘Half Fish, Half
Woman’: Annette Kellerman, Mermaids, and Eco-Aquatic Revisioning” that
mermaid fictions “specifically can trouble anthropocentrism, which situates
humanity outside (and above) the nonhuman biosphere, and geocentrism,
which particularly disavows humanity’s vital interdependence with aquatic
creatures and oceanic environments” (201-02). These studies signal the
mermaid’s potential challenge to the human, but they pay little attention
to the human itself as a raced, gendered, and classed construct produced
through conquest and racial chattel slavery. As Zakiyyah Iman Jackson
points out, “A critique of anthropocentricism is not necessarily a critique
of liberal humanism…Many critics of anthropocentricism have mistakenly
perceived that the problem of our time is anthropocentricism rather than a
failed praxis of being” (15). Such an analysis of the human, as not a given
but a “failed praxis of being,” is unavoidable in looking at crossing merfolk
narratives, which locate the origin of mermaids in the stratified making of
the human. According to critical humanist Sylvia Wynter, “Man”—white,
straight, male, able-bodied, propertied, rational, individual, and sovereign—is
that suggest the effects of climate change, threatening the demise of both the
Wajinru people and the human world. My analysis focuses on how each of
these novels disrupts two facets of Western humanism: (1) epistemologies that
disregard otherhuman ways of knowing in favor of Western rationalism and
science, and (2) concepts of the normative and desirable body that maintain
colonial hierarchies and perpetuate a racialized human-animal divide. I then
briefly analyze how these disruptions play out in the novels’ representation of
crossing merfolk and human communities’ experiences of and resistance to the
Anthropocene.
“It’s interesting, you don’t find, that we have all these stories about devils
living in the sea?”
She shrugged. “Sea kill plenty people in the history of Cayaba. It make sense
the devil would live in the sea.”
Shit, how to get her to think this through? “You know the legend about
Captain Carter?”
“Yes. Such a beautiful love story.”
“I guess. Except the lovers throw themselves into the water and die.”
She kissed her teeth. “You have to have a little romance, man. The story
says they transformed.”
“They adapted to living in the sea.” (Hopkinson 134)
It is only after Calamity has pushed Evelyn to recall these oceanic oral
narratives that Evelyn becomes willing to consider that Agway may be one
of the island’s fabled sea people, that his bodily differences are evolutionary
adaptations to aquatic life. The alternative knowledge source of oral culture
and the possibilities of evolution coalesce to form an imaginative rationality
that overturns the dominant rationality that transatlantic voyages can only
have ended in death for African people—either literal death in the ocean or
the social death of enslavement (Alonso 108; Kaplan 100).
Throughout the novel Hopkinson also presents an alternative, supernatural
origin for her crossing merfolk: that they were transformed by the Igbo goddess
Uhamiri into seals that can take human form (316). Uhamiri is associated
with Mami Wata, which refers to both a singular divinity and a group of water
spirits that syncretize Indigenous West and Central African water spirits with
“foreign” influences that include Indian snake charmers and European mermaid
lore (Chuks and Makwudo 1; Osinubi 4-5). That the sea people are initially
transformed into seals and can shed their sealskins for their more human forms
evokes the selkie, Northern European folkloric figures who live in the ocean as
seals and on land as beautiful women (Le Couteur 66). Hopkinson’s fluid and
playful intersection of Mami Wata, mermaid, and selkie lore echoes her blend
of African-derived religion, oral culture, and evolutionary science. She does
not attempt to set one authoritative account or resolve the tensions inherent
between these biological and magical origins for the crossing merfolk. The
coexistence of multiple narratives allows for coexistence of multiple realities
and epistemologies—rationality is neither surrendered as beyond Black
capacity nor privileged over the otherhuman ways of knowing represented by
orality, memory, and African cosmology.
Unlike the origin story in The New Moon’s Arms, in which the crossing
merfolk are transformed in response to a prayer, The Deep, inspired by
Black, electronic group Drexciya, depicts a process of spontaneous uterine
mutation. In the liner notes to Drexciya’s 1997 compilation album The Quest,
an “Unknown Writer” extrapolates from evidence of amphibious features
in developing fetuses and from aquatic survival instincts of newborn babies
to propose the possibility that the babies in the wombs of enslaved African
women survived (Eshun 143). Solomon’s novel fleshes out this idea as it
depicts the watery, postmortem births of a new species:
Then the surface dweller’s legs begin to splay apart, and we come under it.
We see it: the head. Our eyes widen, struck. It is not a two-legs head. There
are fins at the center of its back, on its sides, and at its front. Hairless. And
darker than any land creature...What magic had intervened to transform the
pup in the womb? Was it the ocean itself, the progenitur of all life? Did the
zoti aleyu have a god after all? (Solomon 60)
At the corner of each picture was a mermaid, exotically brown but not too
dark. No obvious negroes in Cayaba Tourist Board publicity, unless they were
dressed as smiling servers. The fish woman sported the kind of long, flowing
hair that most black women had to buy in a bottle of straightening solution.
They had shells covering their teacup breasts. I would love to see the shell
big enough to hide one of my bubbies (Hopkinson 222).
the Wajinru’s human ancestors, most textual details reveal alien, amphibious
creatures dramatically different from the beautiful, long-haired half-women
of myth and billboards. The Wajinru are described as hairless, scaled, and
boneless (Solomon 42), with gills and fins (Solomon 2). Unlike many
mermaids in popular culture representation and The New Moon’s Arms’s
shapeshifting seal people, they are not what Hayward defines in Making a
Splash as “transformational mermaids”; they cannot become human (188). An
African woman named Waj, who teaches the merfolk human language and
culture and whom they see as a mother of their “civilization,” initially names
them zoti aleyu, “strange fish,” demonstrating that she perceives them as more
fishlike than human (Solomon 48). A striking image of their difference comes
when Yetu tries to ward off the humans who discover her stranded in a tide
pool: “She settled for a scream, opening her mouth wide, showing rows of
sharp, long teeth, narrow and overlapping. Her eyes and nose disappeared
as her mouth expanded, her face replaced with a black, endless pit guarded
by fangs” (Solomon 72). The disappearance of Yetu’s semihuman face into a
“black, endless pit” with rows of fangs asserts her otherness and animality. Her
somewhat human features disappear completely into this scream, revealing
the porousness of the arbitrary boundaries between human and Other. The
image of a Black woman’s face disappearing into rows of fangs invokes the
ways in which Black femininity has been read as monstrous (Brooks 25-27).
Associations of Black femininity with monstrosity have inhibited Black
feminist studies’ critical explorations of monstrosity’s potential to unsettle
the logics of Western humanism. I explore this potential in my earlier work,
“Butler’s Monsters: The Grotesque and the Black Communal Body in Octavia
Butler’s Dawn”:
Two-legs had specific ways of classifying things that Yetu didn’t like...They
organized the world as two sides of a war, the two-legs in conflict with
everything else. The way Suka talked about farming, it was as if they ruled
the land and what it produced, as opposed to—they’d just said themselves—
existing alongside it. (Solomon 84)
of bats, seals, and fish whose habitats and populations are destroyed by the
hotels and salt plants. This linking of human and ecologies’ ghosts connects
these novels to environmental justice movements, which, as T. V. Reed claims,
“fully understand that the fate of the other-than-human world and the fate
of human beings are inextricably linked, and that the degradation of certain
‘primitive’ peoples and certain ‘underdeveloped’ places go hand in hand”
(252). The same large-scale economic powers that drive small fisheries and
salt farmers out of business also pollute the island and threaten both Cayaban
people and the sea life’s health. Calamity is initially skeptical and disinterested
in her daughter’s involvement in projects to support small-scale, sustainable
industries, reduce Cayabans’ dependence on the tourism industry, and stop
the pollution of the region (Hopkinson 198). This skepticism shifts once
Calamity is moved by her feelings of kinship to the sea people:
“Bittern. That’s what get leave behind when you manufacture salt. One
pound salt give you a pound of bittern. And bittern in high levels is toxic.
Gilmore Saline supposed to dilute in three hundred to one with water and
pipe it way out to sea. We think they releasing it strong just so into the waters
around Cayaba.”
“Oh, shit.” The water the sea people lived in. (Hopkinson 250)
human-animal boundary. The sea people and the local Cayaban people
stand together against big industry in defense of their lives. Rather than the
possessive conservationism that underlies mainstream environmentalism,
Calamity’s new desire to protect the ocean is motivated by the knowledge that
she has kin in the ocean. Such relationalities, as Chelsea Frazier describes,
“trouble ecology” by “challeng[ing] the (dis)connections between human and
non- human entities, and initiat[ing] alternative notions of environmental/
ecological ethics” (46).
As Persephone Braham describes in “Song of the Sirenas: Mermaids in
Latin America and the Caribbean,” mermaid lore frequently depicts mermaids
or sirens as culpable for shipwrecks and human destruction, either through
their mesmerizing songs or ability to cause storms (150-51). Rivers Solomon
plays upon this mermaid lore but rewrites it within Black Atlantic history. In
The Deep it is the justifiable grief of crossing merfolk rather than the casual
mischief of the Western mermaid that causes human destruction. This shift of
the mermaid’s destructive power moves it away from a misogynist suspicion of
femininity to a linking of racial chattel slavery with the Anthropocene. Once
the Wajinru discover their relationship to those imprisoned on enslavers’ ships,
they also discover their power over the water: “We and the other zoti aleyu
now present gathered together to trouble the waters, to sink the ship. This
did not come about by plan, but by anguish. As all of us wept and raged, we
noticed the way that our fury made the water pulse and rise” (Solomon 62). In
hip-hop group clipping’s song “The Deep,” the merfolk launch a cataclysmic
tidal wave after humans attack their seafloor home while drilling for oil.
Solomon’s The Deep references this event, not as the central narrative of the
novel but through Yetu’s collective memory: “She saw the two-legs drowning,
but not just in water, on land, too. Water erupted from the sea and flowed onto
the surface…The drownings had been part of the Tidal Wars—that was the
name—a conflict between wajinru and two-legs” (73).
The memory of the Tidal Wars foreshadows and intercuts the storms
caused by the frenzied energy of the Wajinru left in trance state after Yetu flees
the Remembrance ceremony: “They were so lost in it, they were taking their
grief out on the whole world” (Solomon 125). The storms flood the region
where Yetu had been rescued and cared for by a rural human community and
wash away her human lover Oori’s ancestral islands, illustrating the irreparable
harm of increasing climate extremity to the communities that depend directly
on the water for survival (Hobart). While the cause of the current storm is
Yetu’s flight away from the Remembrance ceremony, we must trace her flight
back to the violence that makes the Memory so unbearable. Yetu’s intersection
of the trauma of the Crossing with the current storms answers in narrative
form Ian Baucom’s query, “Can we hold the view from the Anthropocene
and the view from the Middle Passage in concert?” (14). In History 4 Celsius:
Search for a Method in the Age of the Anthropocene, Baucom builds upon Dipesh
Chakrabarty’s radical argument for the need to desegregate human history
and natural history in the humanities. Also building upon the work of Black
Atlantic scholars Paul Gilroy and Achille Mbembe, Baucom argues that
studies of the Black Atlantic must encompass and are essential to:
Conclusion
Joshua Bennett argues that within Black Atlantis myths (which overlap and
intersect what I call crossing merfolk narratives), “The haunting presence of
the Middle Passage is recalibrated toward the end of imagining an elsewhere,
however remote or deeply submerged, where black life can flourish” and
“demands a more dynamic approach to organizing life on Earth” (178).
Extending a creative tradition first established in black music, Hopkinson and
Solomon suggest that a place where Black people’s lives could flourish would
be a place where other forms of being cast outside and below the Western
human could flourish as well. By locating the origins of mermaids in “the
haunting presence of the Middle Passage,” these narratives complicate the
ecocritical fantasy of the mermaid, highlighting modernity’s disastrous impact
upon otherhuman and nonhuman lifeworlds. Therefore, any unmaking of
both the ideologies and the systems that make humanity such a dangerous
force of nature must attend to the hierarchies within the human, to the
violence of conquest and racialization. Crossing merfolk that exist because of
this violence, but also exceed it, offer possibilities for a more lateral and livable
world.
Works Cited
Alexander, M. Jacqui. Pedagogies of Crossing: Meditations on Feminism, Sexual Politics,
Memory, and the Sacred. Duke University Press, 2005.
Alonso, María Alonso. Diasporic Marvellous Realism: History, Identity, and Memory in
Caribbean Fiction. Brill/Rodopi, 2015.
Anatol, Giselle Liza. “The Sea-People of Nalo Hopkinson’s The New Moon’s Arms:
Reconceptualizing Paul Gilroy’s The Black Atlantic through Considerations of
Myth and Motherhood.” Diasporic Women’s Writing of the Black Atlantic, ed.
Esther Alvarez-Lopez and Emilia Maria Duran-Almarza, Routledge, 2014, pp.
202-17.
Barounis, Cynthia. “Special Affects: Mermaids, Prosthetics, and the Disabling
of Feminine Futurity “ Women’s Studies Quarterly, vol. 44, no. 1/2, 2016,
pp. 188-204.
Baucom, Ian. History 4 Degrees Celsius. Duke University Press, 2020.
Bennett, Joshua. Being Property Myself: Blackness and the End of Man. The Belknap
Press of Harvard UP, 2020.
Braham, Persephone. From Amazons to Zombies: Monsters in Latin America. Bucknell
UP, 2015.
—. “Song of the Sirenas: Mermaids in Latin America and the Caribbean.” Scaled for
Success: The Internationalization of the Mermaid, edited by Philip Hayward, John
Libbey Publishing, 2018.
Brink-Roby, H. “Siren Canora: The Mermaid and the Mythical in Late Nineteenth-
Century Science.” Archives of Natural History, vol. 35, no. 1, 2008, pp. 1-14.
Brooks, Kinitra D. Searching for Sycorax: Black Women’s Hauntings of Contemporary
Horror. Rutgers University Press, 2018.
Brown, Ras Michael. African-Atlantic Cultures and the South Carolina Lowcountry.
Cambridge UP, 2012.
Caputi, Jane. Call Your “Mutha”: A Deliberately Dirty-Minded Manifesto for the Earth
Mother in the Anthropocene. Oxford UP, 2020.
Chuks, Madukasi Francis and Kenechukwu Makwudo. “A Philosophical Appraisal
of Spirituality and Witchcraft through Mami Water Belief System in Igbe Cult
Traditional Religion in Aguleri Cosmology.” American Journal of Multidisciplinary
Research and Development, vol. 2, no. 2, 2020, pp. 1-14.
clipping. “The Deep.” The Deep, 2019. Sub Pop, https://megamart.subpop.com/
products/clipping_the-deep.
Davis, Jalondra A. “Crossing Merfolk: Mermaids and the Middle Passage in African
Diasporic Culture,” in The Routledge Handbook to Alternative Futurisms, edited by
Bodhisattva Chattopadhyay, Grace Dillon, Isiah Lavender III, and Taryne Jade
Taylor, Routledge, forthcoming 2022.
—. “Butler’s Monsters: The Grotesque and the Black Communal Body in Octavia
Butler’s Dawn.” On the Politics of Ugliness, edited by Sara Rodrigues and Ela
Przybylo, Palgrave Macmillan, 2018, pp. 309-34.
—. “Power and Vulnerability: Black Girl’s Magic in Black Women’s Science
Fiction.” MOSF Journal of Science Fiction, vol. 2, no. 2, 2018, pp. 13-30.
Dillon, Grace. “Indigenous Scientific Literacies in Nalo Hopkinson’s Ceremonial
Worlds.” Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts vol. 18, no. 1, 2007, pp. 23-41.
Drewal, Henry John. “Mami Wata: Arts for Water Spirits in Africa and the
Diaspora.” African Arts, vol. 41, no. 2, 2008, pp. 60-83.
Eshun, Kodwu. “Drexciya as Spectre.” Aquatopia: The Imaginary of the Ocean Deep,
edited by Alex Farquharson and Martin Clark, Tate Nottingham Contemporary,
2013, pp. 138-46.
Frazier, Chelsea M. “Troubling Ecology: Wangechi Mutu, Octavia Butler, and Black
Feminist Interventions in Environmentalism.” Critical Ethnic Studies, vol. 2, no.
1, 2016, pp. 40-72.
Gaskins, Nettrice. “Mami Wata Remixed: The Mermaid in Contemporary African
American Culture.” Scaled for Success: The Internationalisation of the Mermaid,
edited by Philip Hayward, John Libbey Publishing, 2018, pp. 195-208.
Hale, Lindsay. Hearing the Mermaid’s Song: The Umbanda Religion in Rio De Janeiro.
University of New Mexico Press, 2009.
Hayward, Philip. Making a Splash: Mermaids (and Mermen) in 20th and 21st Century
Audiovisual Media. John Libbey Publishing, 2017.
—, editor. Scaled for Success: The Internationalization of the Mermaid. John Libbey
Publishing, 2018.
Hejnol, Andre. “Ladders, Trees, Complexity, and Other Metaphors in Evolutionary
Thinking.” Arts of Living on a Damaged Planet, edited by Anna Tsing Heather
Swanson, Elaine Gan, and Nils Bubandt, University of Minnesota Press, 2017.
Hobart, Hiʻilei Julia. “On Oceanic Fugivity.” Items: Insights from the Social Sciences,
September 29, 2020, https://items.ssrc.org/ways-of-water/on-oceanic-fugitivity/.
Hopkinson, Nalo. The New Moon’s Arms. Warner Books, 2007.
Abstract
Mermaids are plural and complex beings with significant implications, as
human-animal-hybrids, for a critique of androcentrism and the Anthropocene.
Yet theorizations of the mermaid within monster studies rarely critically engage
Black mermaid texts. This article defines a particular recurring narrative
within Afrofuturism’s imaginings of aquatic hybrid people: what I call
Crossing Merfolk, the proposal that those lost during the Middle Passage and/
or their offspring transformed to survive in the sea. Foregrounding mermaid
studies, Black feminist critical humanisms, and feminist, anticolonial, and
environmental justice ecocriticisms in an analysis of Nalo Hopkinson’s The
New Moon’s Arms and Rivers Solomon’s The Deep, I argue that Crossing
Merfolk narratives disrupt the Human and its power over subordinated humans
and the Earth. By locating the origin of mermaids in African cosmologies and
the launch of racial chattel slavery, crossing merfolk interrogate the violent
conditions of modernity and the Anthropocene and propose otherhuman ways
of being.