Tetris

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

Published online: 2020-09-04

Original Research

The Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty:


The Split Tetris Concept
Jose Carlos Neves, MD1 Diego Arancibia Tagle, MD2 Wilson Dewes, MD3 Mario Ferraz, MD4

1 Department of Facial Plastic Surgery, My Face, Clinics and Academy, Address for correspondence Diego Arancibia Tagle, MD, Department
Lisbon, Portugal of Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery, Hospital Universitari Son
2 Department of Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery, Hospital Espases, Carretera de Valldemossa 79, Planta 0, Modulo D,
Universitari Son Espases, Baleares, Spain Despacho Q018, Secretaria Otorrinolaringologia Palma de Mallorca,
3 Department of Facial Plastic Surgery, Clinica Dewes, Baleares 07120, Spain (e-mail: arancibiadiego@gmail.com).
Lajeado, Brazil
4 Department of Facial Plastic Surgery, Clinica Mario Ferraz,
Campinas, Brazil

Facial Plast Surg

Abstract Dorsal preservation rhinoplasty has seen considerable advances in the recent years as
many doctors have improved and developed new ideas on the subject. In the era of

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.


minimal trauma surgery, it is important to achieve a beautiful nasal aesthetic result
Keywords with minimum injury to the nose. Preserving the main structures of the nasal pyramid
► preservation has been pursued for more than a century, and some different approaches have been
rhinoplasty described and developed since then. Their strengths and weakness have been shown.
► letdown The present society’s demand for perfection is an added reason for improving the
► pushdown stability and predictability of preservation rhinoplasty. We describe a brand-new
► split Tetris concept philosophy of approaching the nasal dorsum hump that combines both safety and
► Vitruvian Man split delicacy in dealing with the anatomical structures with elegancy and accuracy and
maneuver achieving the aesthetic goal required.

Our article on split preservation rhinoplasty1 showed the to instability in the structure with a consequent lateraliza-
real advantage of the intermediate resection in stabilizing tion. Nevertheless, in our practice, this problem did not
the rhinion position by putting a suture from our free occur, probably because if any instability was felt, we used
anterior dorsal septal cartilaginous flap to the basal posterior to suture a cartilaginous strut laterally to the caudal border of
stabile septum. In fact, this is a critical stitch for predictably the septum. However, there was room for improvement in
keeping the rhinion in the desired position and helping avoid this intermediate approach, and this is when the split Tetris
the criticism of the so-called “pushdown” family techniques concept was developed.
for its supposed lack of accuracy.
This fixation can be made with a single stitch including
Goals of the Tetris Concept
the contralateral perichondrium or, eventually for more
stability, a running figure-of-eight stitch can be used. The goals of the preservation approaches to the nasal dorsal
line are very clear: keep the nasal pyramid framework unit
intact to avoid healing problems, achieve a natural and stable
Criticisms to the Split Preservation Rhinoplasty
result preserving the patient’s own anatomy, and create the
The weakest aspect of the split preservation rhinoplasty1 best conditions for promoting an easy revision if needed.
technique we described was apparently that the caudal The goals of the Tetris concept are as follows: design a block
border of the septum was cut and needed to be stabilized of cartilage below the cartilaginous hump that will fit the
with sutures since some colleagues believed this could lead designed box, which will be sutured so that the final rhinion

Issue Theme Preservation Rhinoplasty: Copyright © by Thieme Medical DOI https://doi.org/


An Update; Guest Editor: Jose Carlos Publishers, Inc., 333 Seventh Avenue, 10.1055/s-0040-1714672.
Neves, MD New York, NY 10001, USA. ISSN 0736-6825.
Tel: +1(212) 760-0888.
Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty Neves et al.

height is stable and accurate; resect a small amount of cartilage mucosa, leaving a few millimeters not dissected at the dorsal
and eventually bone under the bony pyramid (similarly to the level to prevent instability of the unit.
high resection approach) in a progressive way to avoid the
creation of a step at the level of the traverse osteotomies; and Drawing the Cartilaginous Block
preserve a caudal septal cartilage wide strut from the caudal A rectangular piece of septal cartilage will be designed below
border of the upper lateral cartilage (ULC) till the caudal septal the cartilaginous hump in between the most prominent point
border, whose height will be adjusted at the end of the of the hump (at or slightly caudal to the rhinion) and the caudal
procedure, so that a supra tip saddle cannot be seen. border of the ULC (►Fig. 1A). We start measuring a 5 to 8 mm
perpendicular line to the dorsum at the level of the ULC caudal
border. This line represents the caudal border of our rectangle.
The Tetris Concept Technique
Another perpendicular line is drawn at the level of the most
Lateral Wall Letdown prominent point of the hump with approximately the same
We always start treating the lateral wall first using the height. This represents the cephalic border of the rectangular
letdown concept. This is paramount for performing the piece. A new line is drawn uniting the two previous ones at
lateral wall split maneuver1 so that the elastic articulation their posterior end, which creates the posterior border of the
between the ULCs and pyriform ligaments with the lateral block. The septal–UCL connection represents the anterior
bones do not promote a relapse of the hump. We will dissect border. We prefer the block (quadrangular or rectangular)
the bones from these structures and at some level the figure compared with a triangular shape, for instance. This is

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.

Fig. 1 (A) The Tetris block is designed in between the highest point of the hump and the WASA. (B) The two slots are created to permit the
pushdown maneuver of the block. (C) The nasal hump is pushed down and the block fits its slot. The caudal and the posterior borders are
stabilized using 5–0 PDS sutures. The caudal septal natural strut keeps, at this point, its original height (left panel); it will be trimmed to fit the
ideal profile (right panel). (D) Harvesting septum below the stabilized structure. We respect the L-shape concept.

Facial Plastic Surgery


Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty Neves et al.

because it is designed to achieve a stabler structure, and once below the block must have the height that we intend to
we have stabilized a vertical and a horizontal vector, we can deproject the dorsum. Since the deprojection will be bigger
avoid tilting of the free pyramid. under the highest point of the hump and less the more caudal
we go, on most occasions the slot shape will be trapezoid.
Isolating the Block Below the bony bone, we draw (or assume without drawing)
Using a no. 15 blade we cut the caudal, posterior, and a triangular shape with its vertices ending at the level of the
cephalic borders of the rectangular block. It must free the transverse osteotomies (►Fig. 1B). These new shapes will be
cartilaginous hump. When pushed down, the block overlaps resected, and thus the space for the pushdown maneuver will
with the stable septal cartilage, and we create a saddle nose be created (►Fig. 2A).
below the UCL caudal border.
Removing Cephalic Septal Excess
Drawing the Space Slots We remove our triangle below the bony hump with scissors,
Two new geometrical shapes will be designed: one below the and we always start at a tangent to the undersurface of the
rectangular block and another below the bony hump. The one bony vault to avoid big resections that can lead to a radix step.

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.

Fig. 2 (A) The Tetris block was created. The slots below the block and below the bony dorsum were created. The caudal border of the block was
trimmed to perfectly fit its slot after the rotational movement. (B) Pushdown maneuver. A posterior and caudal movement is produced in the
mobile cartilage so the nasal pyramid adapts to the desired profile. (C) Stabilizing the caudal border of the block. The spring effect can be seen as
a small residual hump appears. (D) Stabilization of the posterior border of the block. After we stabilize the block below the rhinion no more
relapse of the hump will be seen.

Facial Plastic Surgery


Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty Neves et al.

We like to remove a smaller triangular piece, and then perform


the pushdown maneuver and analyze how much we have
deprojected. If this is not enough, we go in again and remove
another triangular slice until reaching the desired level. In
some cases, we only remove cartilage; hence, scissors are
enough, but sometimes we have to remove a small piece of
bone, for which we often use scissors. However, we rarely use a
baby rongeur since it can create a bigger space than is needed,
and the radix step will appear as a consequence.

Removing Intermediate Septal Excess


Now, the hump can be reduced, and the cartilage block
overlaps the posterior stable septal cartilage, and as we
have isolated the Tetris block, we press it down, and at the
level of the cephalic chondrotomy we can create the side split
effect (similar to the Vitruvian side splits described previ-
ously), bringing it posteriorly and caudally in a rotation
movement. At this moment, we check if the previously
designed trapezoid slot below the block matches the dorsal
height, and we try to achieve this by moving the dorsal

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.


framework. We are ready to remove this piece of cartilage
and create the slot our Tetris piece will occupy when we push
the nasal pyramid down (►Fig. 2B). Eventually, in deviated Fig. 4 The block overlaps and is sutured to the septum on the
noses, we suture the overlapped cartilages side by side opposite side of the deviation.
(without resection the trapezoid piece, ►Fig. 3), with the
rectangular block being sutured on the opposite side of the create a caudal overlap of a small portion of the cartilage
deviation so that it can compensate (►Fig. 4) (will be block with the caudal septum strut we have left intact. Thus,
described next). we trim the caudal border of the block so that it fits the slot
created perfectly (►Fig. 2A).
Adjustments to the Block
The rectangular block movement is caudal and posterior in a Split Tetris Preservation
rotational fashion, as already described. This movement will This movement brings the pieces down into their spaces in a
perfect match resembling the Tetris game, so we have called
it the “Tetris preservation concept” (►Fig. 5).

Fig. 3 In high septal deviations, we can overlap the block to the stable Fig. 5 The Tetris block. Intraoperative image showing the block
septum without creating a slot. sutured in this slot.

Facial Plastic Surgery


Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty Neves et al.

Suturing Splitting the Tetris Block


It is now time to stabilize the mobile structure. Three The cartilaginous component is always convex in a nasal
fundamental points must be perfectly controlled. First is dorsal hump. This can lead to two phenomena: a curved line
the radix region, where the septal resection meets the that creates a small hump in-between the rhinion and supra
transverse osteotomy, whose importance we have already tip region (the cephalic cartilage), and a supratip saddling
stressed. We must maintain a perfect nasal septum support (the caudal cartilage).
below this point, avoiding the bony dorsum to come down If this kind of effect is seen, it is essential to flatten the
and create a step. Second, the suture of the caudal border of cartilaginous curve. One (or eventually two) vertical cuts of the
the Tetris block to the caudal septal strut will stretch and Tetris block can be made by splitting it into two (►Fig. 6) (or
bring the dorsum down. This movement resembles what we eventually three, ►Fig. 7) pieces. The caudal block will be
performed in the Cottle pushdown technique,2,3 and because brought more anterior and caudal in a rotational movement.
of this here we can see a mini-Cottle using an intermediate This movement resembles maintaining the fingers of a hand
approach but preserving the caudal border of the septum and together and then separating them from each other. The more
the stability of its attachment with the anterior nasal spine the block pieces are apart, the more concave the profile is, and
(ANS). Third, after performing the previous suture, the hump what we can achieve with this movement is really spectacular.
is reduced. Nevertheless, immediately we observe a small Performing this movement can produce too much tension in
relapse of the hump that will slightly increase with time, the the caudal ULC septal joint. The more we curve anteriorly the
spring effect (►Fig. 2C), which is one of the major problems septum to achieve a concave profile, the more distorted the ULCs
of the preservation concept, leading to certain fragility, and are. Based on this, it is sometimes necessary to free these caudal
has been criticized. So, we perform a second suture that articulations until the level the ULCs are not distorted. The block

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.


definitely solves this problem. At the level of the rhinion, we pieces are then sutured individually in their ideal position.
suture the cephalic border of the Tetris block to the stable
septal cartilage and the profile remains stable during the
The Segmental Dorsal Preservation
healing process (►Figs. 1C and 2D). These sutures can be
performed as one simple interrupted stitch or as a figure-of- The split Tetris is an evolution of the intermediate split
eight continuous stitch. Additional sutures can be made at approach whose fundamental goal is the stabilization and
the caudal and the posterior borders of the Tetris block with predictability of the nasal dorsum final position. It was
the surrounding stable septal cartilage. To increase stability, designed to avoid conceptual weakness, mainly regarding
in our sutures we include the contralateral perichondrium coronal axis deviations and caudal septal border instabilities.
and mucosa on the side we are working on. The sutures are At first, this technique may seem demanding, but once it has
5–0 polydioxanone. been learnt it is really simple to perform.

Adjustments to the Caudal Septal Strut


At this point, we have brought the dorsum to the ideal
position except at the level of the caudal septal strut that
we preserved. In fact, the result is a polybeak appearance.
The anterior border of this natural strut must be addressed.
We can trim it following the height of the dorsum we
achieved or leave a higher end at the level of the anterior
nasal septal angle to act like a strut to the tip.
Since we performed the lateral wall split and put sutures
at the fundamental spots, we have a very stable flat dorsum.
We can achieve a more concave dorsum if we are more
aggressive at the level of the rhinion and remove a bigger
amount of cartilage below it. However, a problem can be
created. If the rhinion was brought down too aggressively, we
can promote a slope and a deflection at the cephalic carti-
laginous hump level (reaching the rhinion), which leaves a
nonnatural transition from the cartilage to bone. This effect
shows how powerful the technique is. In those cases, the
stitch below the rhinion must be released and restored in a
looser fashion.
As the shape of the bony dorsal line can vary a great deal,
we perform an osteosculpture after we have defined and
stabilized the final dorsal height so that we can have a
smooth transition. Also, the lateral bony wall is sculpted as
a refinement. We prefer burrs, but ultrasonic devices or rasps Fig. 6 The Tetris block split. It creates a more flatness or concavity of
can be also used. the cartilaginous dorsum.

Facial Plastic Surgery


Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty Neves et al.

these two blocks are sutured and stabilized with a high level
of predictability. It works like a subdivision of this segment.

Caudal Septal Strut Segment


By preserving the septum caudal to the WASA, we can play
with its position after stabilizing the mobile pyramid in its
new position. The new design of this segment avoids the
creation of a supratip saddling. In fact, before sculpting it, a
polybeak aspect is visible. Also, depending on the way, we cut
the caudal septal strut defining whether the profile is flatter
or more concave following the tendency of the last segment.
This strong natural septal strut can also be used for tip
supporting maneuvers, with or without grafts.

Indications
In coronal straight noses, both the split Tetris1 and other pre-
servation approaches are indicated. In fact, the best candidate is
the one with a straight narrow delicate nose with a dorsal hump.
If the nasal pyramid has a slight deviation (mainly in the

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.


Fig. 7 The split of the Tetris block. We can achieve a concave aspect cephalic–caudal axis), we can take advantage of the block by
of the cartilaginous dorsum. overlapping it with the basal septum and suturing it contral-
aterally to the deviation (►Figs. 3 and 4). In bigger deviations
The preservation techniques 2–16 have been criticized for and severe crocked noses, if a preservation approach is indi-
many years due to their lack of precision and the stigma of the cated, we prefer to indicate a classical septum pyramidal
outcome. The main problems are relapsing of the hump, adjustment and repositioning (SPAR)/Cottle approach.
difficulty to produce a precise flat or even concave profile, If the septal deviation is mainly basal, we can perform the
supratip saddling, and radix step. Our approach offers sol- split Tetris preservation rhinoplasty and then perform the
utions to these problems. septoplasty. In fact, it works exactly as the L structure preser-
We address the nasal dorsum as segments. vation in direct hump resection procedures.17,18 Because our
Tetris block is around 5 to 7 mm high, if we stabilize it to a 5 bar
Bony Segment of the stable septum, it means that we end up with 10 to 12 mm
By addressing the septum to be removed below the pyramid of septum we cannot harvest. Below it we can proceed with a
cephalically to the split with scissors or any other delicate traditional septal harvesting (►Fig. 1D).
cutting in a progressive fashion, we prevent an excessive In broader noses at the upper third, it is possible to adapt
resection and the consequent radix step. In many cases, we the technique by adjusting the width of the bony dorsum at
only resect the septal cartilage, with one solitary cut in the the end of the procedure. We use an ultrasonic device to
perpendicular ethmoidal plate to free the pyramid. It is produce two green stick osteotomies at the level of the dorsal
interesting to observe that sometimes we create a pivotal aesthetic lines. The device will not completely cut the bone in
point in between the split and the transverse osteotomy by its depth. After the partial osteotomy, a squeeze movement is
removing septal cartilage but not the ethmoidal plate. This produced in the bony dorsum achieving a narrower anatomy.
causes an elevation of the cephalic free pyramid when we We do not use preservation techniques in wide middle third
push the hump down and creates an upper step (opposing to dorsum (broad cartilage roof).
the classic lower step). To avoid this problem, we do not
connect the two transverse osteotomies in the midline. Then,
Conclusion
we create a greenstick fracture at the radix level to avoid a
complete disconnection of the bone. Recently, and for more than a decade, the main author has
been dedicated to achieving stable, accurate, and predictable
Upper Lateral Cartilage Segment results in preservation rhinoplasty. Inspired by the SPAR
It represents the Tetris block area from the WASA until the concept4,5 developed by Wilson Dewes, the big advantages
split. We can play with the position of the block: more or less of this approach are the stability of the rhinion area, based on
rotation, more or less caudalization, more or less deprojec- the central suture, the stability of the caudal septal border
tion. And since we stabilize the block, we can be very accurate and its attachment to the ANS, and the way that by means of
in avoiding relapses of the hump. If we can improve the splitting the Tetris block we can achieve a flat or, eventually
design of the new dorsal profile, making it flat or eventually concave profile, of the cartilaginous segment.
slightly concave, we can split the Tetris block and create an To date, we believe that the split Tetris preservation
anterior and caudal rotation for the caudal block by achieving technique performed in indicated noses consistently pro-
concavity in between the two new smaller blocks. Again, motes these goals.

Facial Plastic Surgery


Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty Neves et al.

Clinical Cases

Case 1

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.

Case 1 Close approach, dorsal segmental preservation rhinoplasty, pre- and postoperative images. (A) Frontal view. (B) Lateral view. (C) Three-
quarter view.

Facial Plastic Surgery


Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty Neves et al.

Case 2

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.

Case 2 Open approach, dorsal segmental preservation rhinoplasty, pre- and postoperative images. (A) Frontal view. (B) Lateral view.
(C) Three-quarter view.

Facial Plastic Surgery


Segmental Preservation Rhinoplasty Neves et al.

Conflict of Interest 8 Saban Y, Braccini F, Polselli R. Rhinoplasty: morphodynamic


None. anatomy of rhinoplasty. Interest of conservative rhinoplasty.
Rev Laryngol Otol Rhinol (Bord) 2006;127(1-2):15–22
9 Ishida J, Ishida LC, Ishida LH, Vieira JC, Ferreira MC. Treatment of
References the nasal hump with preservation of the cartilaginous framework.
1 Neves JC, Arancibia Tagle D, Dewes W, et al. The split preservation Plast Reconstr Surg 1999;103(06):1729–1733, discussion 1734–
rhinoplasty: “the Vitruvian Man split maneuver. Eur J Plast Surg 1735
2020;43:323–333 10 Lothrop OA. An operation for correcting the aquiline nasal defor-
2 Cottle MH, Loring RM. Corrective surgery of the external nasal mity; the use of new instrument; report of a case. Boston Med
pyramid and the nasal septum for restoration of normal physio- Surg J 1914;170:835–837
logy. Ill Med J 1946;90:119–135 11 Sebileau P, Dufourmentel L. Correction Chirurgicale des Diffor-
3 Cottle MH. Nasal roof repair and hump removal. AMA Arch mités Congénitales et Acquises de la Pyramide Nasale. Paris:
Otolaryngol 1954;60(04):408–414 Arnette; 1926:104–105
4 Ferraz MBJ, Zappelini CEM, Carvalho GM, Guimarães AC, Chone 12 Maurel G. Chirurgie Maxilla-Faciale. Paris: Le François; 1940:
CT, Dewes W. Cirurgia conservadora do dorso nasal – a filosofia do 1127–1133
reposicionamento e ajuste do septo piramidal (SPAR). Rev Bras Cir 13 Huizing EH. Push-down of the external nasal pyramid by resec-
Cabeca Pescoco 2013;42(03):13 tion of wedges. Rhinology 1975;13(04):185–190
5 Atolini Junior N, Lunelli V, Lang GP, Melotti LF, Yamamoto TT, 14 Gola R. Conservative rhinoplasty [in French]. Ann Chir Plast Esthet
Munerolli EJ. Septum pyramidal adjustment and repositioning – a 1994;38(03):239–252
conservative and effective rhinoplasty technique. Braz J Otorhi- 15 Gola R. La Rhinoplastie Fonctionnelle et Esthétique. Paris: Spring-
nolaryngol 2019;85:176–182 er-Verlag; 2000:360
6 Ulloa FL. Let down technique. Available at: http://www.rhino- 16 Gola R. Functional and esthetic rhinoplasty. Aesthetic Plast Surg
plastyarchive.com/articles/let-down-technique. Accessed Janu- 2003;27(05):390–396

Downloaded by: Karolinska Institutet. Copyrighted material.


ary 11, 2017 17 Joseph J. The classic reprint: nasal reductions. Plast Reconstr Surg
7 Saban Y, Daniel RK, Polselli R, Trapasso M, Palhazi P. Dorsal 1971;47(01):79–83
preservation: the push down technique reassessed. Aesthet 18 Joseph J. Beitrage zur rhinoplastik. Berl Klin Wochenschrift 1907;
Surg J 2018;38(02):117–131 16:470–472

Facial Plastic Surgery

You might also like