Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Das 1964
Das 1964
J. P. DAS 2
Ulkal University, Bhubaneswar, India
As in the previous study (Das, 1957), Post- and the four personality variables. Only Ri-
hypnotic suggestion appears as the most diffi- gidity had a sizable significant correlation
cult item. All items of suggestion found in this (- .231, N = 58, p< .05). This signifies an
table had been given in the same order dur- inverse variation for lack of satiation and ri-
ing hypnosis. The cumulative % frequencies gidity. Probably, to some extent, individuals
against the items show that if the subject intolerant of an ambiguous stimulus or situa-
could not accept a preceding suggestion, he tion are likely to develop satiation. But the
never accepted a succeeding one. Thus, the correlation is too small to permit generaliza-
assumed hierarchy of suggestions was empiri- tion.
cally supported. Vigilance scores. Separate scores were avail-
able for each of the six 5-minute periods.
Analysis of Other Scores Their totals for all 62 subjects run as follows:
Verbal Satiation. One of the outstanding 38, 44, 54, 75, 93, 54. As expected, errors in
findings is a high positive correlation (r — Vigilance gradually increase as the test pro-
.757) between Verbal Satiation and Vigilance gresses except in the last 5-minute period.
scores. This means that lack of satiation This unexpected trend is further in evidence
varies concomitantly with low vigilance. If in the large number of subjects who had zero
the subject has poor vigilance, he will show errors in the last 5-minute period. Twenty-
poor satiation. It may be assumed that if a nine subjects as compared to 14 in the preced-
verbal stimulus has been intensely attended ing 5-minute period had zero errors.
to during its repetition, it should produce On completion of the Vigilance test, sub-
greater loss in meaning than if it has re- jects were asked if they felt drowsy. Some
ceived only casual attention. These results, did, but the majority said they felt slightly
however, go against the explanation of both bored towards the end.
satiation and vigilance from the standpoint None of the personality measures corre-
of reactive inhibition. Subjects who tend to lated significantly with Vigilance. Although
accumulate IR faster should have high Satia- there was some suggestion (Eysenck, 1960)
tion and low Vigilance scores which is clearly that extraversion and vigilance should be
not the case here. negatively correlated, this was not found to
The Satiation scores were polarity differ- be so in the present study where the correla-
ences as described in the section on Method. tion between the two was near zero.
It was felt that if the responses were scored Intercorrelation for personality tests. Only
as extent of shift in judgment, a closer rela- one product-moment correlation for the four
tion with the Vigilance score might be ob- personality tests was statistically significant
tained. Shift in judgment referred to the dif- (Rigidity and the Lie scale). Many of the
ference in the two scale positions of the stimu- Lie questions were framed in such a way that
lus word which was obtained by subtracting they induced a set for extreme responses. For
the presatiation rating from the postsatiation example, "Would you declare everything at
rating. the customs, etc.?" or "Have you ever been
Following Osgood et al. (1957) this was late for an appointment?" It may be possible
called d and by summing up all the rf2 for a that subjects prone to giving extreme re-
subject, a D value = (3d 2 ) 1 was obtained. D sponses (high scores in Rigidity) agreed with
thus became a measure of shift in judgment the extreme statements of the Lie scale. Since
irrespective of the direction of shift. Vigilance not all Lie items were extreme statements,
scores, it may be remembered, were likewise the obtained correlation was small.
obtained by summing up all deviations irre- Correlation between the Extraversion and
spective of their direction. However, in spite Neuroticism scales of the MPI had been con-
of such apparent similarity between the two, sistently found to be very low and negative
the resulting r (.215) was much less than the whenever a normal sample was used. This
r between the former Satiation score and finding was repeated here (r — .031). Inci-
Vigilance (.757). dentally, the MPI was applied in its Oriya
Correlations were estimated for Satiation translation and the Means agree closely with
HYPNOSIS AND VERBAL SATIATION 77