Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 24

SEPTEMBER 2013 the voice of the investor relations profession

Social Media:
Cause for
Pause
Surveys show
that IROs are
slow to sign on.

12 NIRI 2013 Conference


Builds Value 16 Review of the 2013
Proxy Season 22 NIRI Recognizes Leaders
at Awards Program
Global IR FoRum
November 18 – 20, 2013
New York, NY

Register at www.globalirforum.org

Evolving best practices for marketing to investors


around the world demands a new kind of event.
NIRI and IR Magazine have partnered to present
the first ever Global IR Forum
• learn successful targeting strategies for different regions
• Network with senior-level IRos from your industry based in other countries
• meet fund managers, buy-side analysts and sell-side analysts with a global outlook

Global Top 50

attend the gala awards celebrating


the Global Top 50 best IR programs
SEPTEMBER 2013

President/CEO and Publisher


Jeffrey D. Morgan

Vice President, Communications


and Practice Information &
Editorial Director
Social Media: Cause
Matt Brusch for Pause
Editor-in-Chief
6 Surveys show that IROs are slow to
Al Rickard sign on.
arickard@associationvision.com
By Marj Charlier
Advertising Sales
Mike Hyatt
Manager, Professional Development
703-562-7684
mhyatt@niri.org

Art Direction
Thor Design Studio
colby@thor-studio.com NIRI 2013 Conference
Builds Value
12
Contributing Editor
Linda Daily New initiatives kept the energy high and
Contributing Staff promoted learning at this year’s meeting.
Tammy K. Dang By Matt Brusch
Michael C. McGough

Letters to the Editor


IR Update welcomes letters to the editor.
Please send your questions, suggestions and
feedback to arickard@associationvision.
com.

About NIRI
A Review of the 2013
Founded in 1969, the National Investor
Relations Institute (www.niri.org) is the
U.S. Proxy Season
professional association of corporate officers
and investor relations consultants responsible
16 Most companies received greater
investor support on executive pay, but
for communication among corporate other governance challenges remain.
management, shareholders, securities analysts
and other financial community constituents. By Ted Allen
NIRI is the largest professional investor
relations association in the world, with more
than 3,300 members representing over 1,600
publicly held companies and $9 trillion in
stock market capitalization. DEPARTMENTS
About IR Update
IR Update is published monthly by the
National Investor Relations Institute as a
4 At the Bell 22 Spotlight on Chapters
service to its members. Sell in May and Go Away? NIRI Recognizes Leaders at
ISSN 1098-5220 By Hulus Alpay Annual Conference
© 2013 by the National Investor
Relations Institute. All rights reserved.
20 NIRI Now
For Change of Address, Contact:
• NIRI Ethics Council Plays Crucial Role
NIRI–IR Update
225 Reinekers Lane, Suite 560 • IR Research at a Glance
Alexandria, VA 22314-2875 USA • NIRI eGroups Moves to New Platform
phone: (703) 562-7700
fax: (703) 562-7701 • Quick Takes
dmeisner@niri.org • Professional Development Calendar
www.niri.org

IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 3


Editorial Advisory Board
At the bell
Darin Arita
ING North America
Mike Beckstead

Sell in May and Go Away? Stillwater Mining Company


Marj Charlier

W
Investor Relations Consultant
hat happened to “Sell in May and go away?” The old adage refers to a
Hala Elsherbini
seasonality trend going back to 1950 reflecting depressed investment Halliburton Investor Relations
returns from May to October relative to the rest of the year.
Laura Gagnon
Like many rules of thumb, it doesn’t always work, and it certainly hasn’t this year. The The Mosaic Company
markets have been extremely active this summer, with indices marking records on very Clint Halverson
healthy trading volumes. Extra Space Storage Inc.
And it means we, as IROs, remain equally active, which can be a blessing and a curse. Julie Kegley
Tyson Foods, Inc.
We’re obviously happy to be needed, but we hope our constituents recognize our need
for summer vacations and a time to recharge. I took a little time off following our second Dave Parker
MEDNA X, Inc.
quarter results to travel abroad, and hope you found some downtime as well.
Andrea Passalacqua
The spring and summer months were also high season for association conferences, and The New York Times Company
NIRI was no different. The NIRI Annual Conference in June was another resounding suc- Heather Rowe
cess. We provide a brief recap in this issue of Kythera Biopharmaceuticals, Inc.
IR Update. If you missed the conference, ses- Tony Takazawa
The markets have been sion replays and materials are now available EMC Corporation

extremely active this at www.niristream.org.


NIRI Board of Directors
In this issue we also cover one of the hot-
summer, with indices test topics at the conference, social media. Hulus Alpay, NIRI Chairman
marking records on very As you know, the Securities and Exchange Medidata Solutions Worldwide

Commission released guidance on the use of


healthy trading volumes. Jane Okun Bomba
IHS Inc.
social media for disclosure earlier this year,
Robert Burton
and NIRI released the results of our recent
Lambert, Edwards & Associates
social media use survey at the annual conference. We’ve taken a look at the topic from a
John Chevalier
variety of perspectives, and hope the article is helpful in guiding your disclosure program. The Procter & Gamble Company
One trait of top-performing IROs is the ability to “see around corners,” and we’ve Ruth Cotter
written our third feature to give you a leg up in this regard. With the bulk of the 2013 Advanced Micro Devices
annual meetings now behind us, this is a good time to consider lessons learned from the Mark Donohue
past proxy season. This article should arm you, your corporate counsel, and your C-suite Impax Laboratories, Inc.

with information that your team can use to your advantage in 2014. Anne Guimard
FINEO Investor Relations
I wish everyone the best for a relaxing end of summer. As always, I look forward to
Dennie Kimbrough
kicking off the 2013-2014 NIRI chapter programming year in September. Please don’t hesi- Microsoft Corporation
tate to contact me, the NIRI Board, or any NIRI staff member with your questions, sugges-
Mary Beth Kissane
tions, or comments. Walek & Associates
Felise Kissell
HSN, Inc.
Andrew Kramer
Interactive Data Corporation
Jeffrey D. Morgan
National Investor Relations Institute
David Myers
Hulus Alpay Express Scripts, Inc.
Chairman, NIRI
Deborah Pawlowski
Vice President, Investor Relations Kei Advisors LLC
Medidata Solutions Worldwide Michelle Levine Schwartz
halpay@mdsol.com Moriah Shilton
Tessera Technologies, Inc.
Charles Triano
4 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update Pfizer Inc.
IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 5
6 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update
Social Media:
Cause for
PauseSurveys show that IROs are slow to sign on.
By Marj Charlier

W
ith all the chatter about social media applies to company websites. The SEC noted that company com-
these days, IROs might be excused for munications made through social media channels could constitute
having the impression that everyone selective disclosures and, therefore, require careful Reg FD analysis.
else is doing it. Nearly 75 percent of the 227 IROs who responded to the
That, however, is not the case. NIRI survey in early May said they don’t use social media.
According to survey results released at the NIRI Annual And, no matter how the data was diced, NIRI reported that the
Conference in Florida in early June, most IR officers aren’t using results didn’t vary much – whether by market cap, geography, or
social media channels to disseminate information to investors, member type (counselor or corporate), although larger compa-
and more than half of those who don’t use it say that’s because nies are slightly more likely to use social media.
they see no interest for the channel on the part of investors. “It Preliminary data from 385 of the 533 IROs interviewed by
is clear that social media does not yet have a role in an IRO’s Rivel Research in late June ratifies the NIRI findings. In that tele-
daily functions,” NIRI concluded in its summary. phone survey, nearly 70 percent of respondents said they do not
The survey, titled “Social Media Use in Investor Relations,” use social media to disseminate investment information.
also indicated that nearly half of IROs intend to reassess the IROs who did identify themselves as social media users in
issue over the next year, due in large part to the recent Securities the NIRI survey, said earnings information is the most popular
and Exchange Commission statement issued on April 2, 2013. form of information disseminated through social media channels,
The statement came after the SEC examined the Netflix CEO’s followed by events, press releases, presentations, annual reports,
Facebook post about subscriber numbers and confirmed that annual meetings, financial information, fact sheets, SEC filings,
Regulation FD applies to social media and other emerging means changes in management, stock info, corporate governance data,
of communication used by public companies the same way it FAQs, proxy issues, and long-term goals, in that order.

IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 7


The NIRI survey identified the top five nels, making it a less time-consuming and dent at PR Newswire. “A lot more needs to
social media channels used by IROs as labor intensive effort. be done in terms of providing additional
Twitter, webcasts, LinkedIn, Facebook, and Of course, some companies are already guidance on the use of the (social media)
StockTwits. (The definition given for “social making extensive and effective use of social channel” to meet Reg FD standards, he said
media” in the survey did not list “webcasts” media in reaching their investor audiences. in a webcast organized by Commpro.biz late
as a social media channel. If it had, more Dell, which has a comprehensive social in April on the subject.
IROs would probably have identified them- media program utilizing StockTwits, a blog, Jeff Corbin, CEO of KCSA Strategic
selves as social media users. The option of and a video blog among other channels, Communications, a public, media and
“webcasts” was offered in a list of possible is using social media to improve the effi- investor relations firm based in New York,
channels only to those who had already ciency with which it is able to respond to was similarly critical of the agency in that
identified themselves as social media users.) the myriad investor questions and requests webcast: “By not giving any further guid-
About two-thirds of social media users it receives daily. “We believe there are lots ance, I believe [the SEC] creates a huge
have formal social media policies that pre- of different media we can use to be more amount of ambiguity for investor relations
scribe expected employee behavior on social productive and efficient and to reach our professionals,” he said. In a letter to the
media channels, the NIRI survey found. shareholder base in a productive manner,” SEC following its statement, Corbin wrote:
And, IR consulting firms are more likely to explains David Mehok, executive director of “Social media is a great way to com-
have a social media manager on staff than investor relations. municate and one that I wholeheartedly
are corporate IR departments. And even if companies aren’t distributing embrace. It would be a shame if compa-
“I would say that I was a bit surprised information through social channels now, nies refrained from using it simply because
by the decidedly anti-social-media results they should at least be “listening” to what’s of the lack of clarity on how to do so for
in the survey,” says Tony Takazawa, vice happening on social media channels today fear of violating Reg FD.
president of IR at EMC Corp., and a critic and learning what’s being said about their “The SEC should provide guidance on the
of social media use by IR. “I guess that the organizations, says Tom Becktold, senior vice use of social media similar to what they did
pro-social media folks and the consultants president of marketing at Business Wire. in 2008 with respect to the use of corporate
are a lot louder than the rest of us.” “Companies should get into listen mode,” websites,” Corbin said. “They should say
He may have a point there. Nearly all of he contends. “They should be looking at ‘this is how it can be used and what compa-
the companies that have traditionally been social media before there is a crisis. Talk to nies should be thinking about in its use.’”
in the business of distributing standard PR, what resources should they have? They
press releases over their wires and to the should get a sense of what conversations are Need for a Policy
news media worldwide are gearing up to happening and on what platforms so they With or without SEC guidance, compa-
offer – or are already marketing – products know what the most relevant platforms are, nies need to adopt a social media policy and
and tools for managing social media. It’s learning who is the audience, what kinds of program that is conceived with just as much
easier to sell a product – whether Coca Cola content are they interested in, who’s talking thoughtfulness as is given to policies that
or social media tools – if the world is con- about them now.” govern the dissemination of 8-Ks, 10-Ks,
vinced everyone else is doing it. As IROs, their management teams, and and formal press releases, observes Kenneth
outside IR and legal counselors wrestle with Florin, a partner in the law firm of Loeb
An Evolving Area social media, they will need to weigh a bevy & Loeb and chair of the firm’s advanced
Still, while slightly more than half of IROs of issues, including privacy and security, media and technology practice.
surveyed said they don’t intend to revisit simultaneity, consistency, utility and the But, surprisingly, more than half of the
the question of whether to use social media overall attitude the company projects through respondents in the NIRI survey who use
over the next year, chances are all IROs will its channels, all the while keeping an eye and social media said their postings are held
have to re-evaluate their positions on social ear out for future SEC statements, guidance, to a lower standard of internal review than
media usage sooner rather than later. Not and decisions on the subject. other disclosures. “They tend to see it as
only are social media channels themselves The SEC’s brief statement on the use of something informal,” Florin explains. “Not
constantly evolving, so are the vendor offer- social media isn’t helping anyone figure this everything needs to be reviewed by teams
ings that allow IROs to manage those chan- all out, cautions John Viglotti, vice presi- of lawyers, but if it’s not, then there ought

8 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update


to be rules about what can and cannot be (SEC Guidance on the Use of Company To master simultaneity, companies can use
revealed through the channel with very Websites) when the SEC says it is going to one of several new social media tools, such
clear boundaries.” consider -- in analyzing the effectiveness of as those now offered by their wire distribu-
That lack of thoughtful and compre- the public dissemination via social media tion partners and exchanges. But managing
hensive policy development in IR depart- channels -- whether the company has a pat- those channels may still require IR staffs to
ments worries Corbin. The very day after tern or practice of using the social media bulk up. Companies like Dell that use social
AP’s Twitter account was hacked and used channels, whether they are the predominant media extensively have individuals assigned
to send a false tweet about a White House methods used, or whether they are just the specifically to tweeting and blogging.
attack, The Wall Street Journal asked several supplemental method. You have to wonder To maintain security, a company needs to
corporate IR practitioners if the hacking how effective is this prophylactic filing that “establish controls over who owns the chan-
would affect their usage and practice of says, ‘We might use social media channels’ nels” at the company, advises Becktold of
social media for corporate disclosures. if the company doesn’t actually use them.” Business Wire.
They all denied any such musing. The David Hudson, managing director for Jim Delaney, CEO of Marketwired, notes,
rapidity with which they responded “no” Nasdaq’s Corporate Solutions, suggests “By adding additional layers of authentica-
surprised Corbin. the best strategy is a broad one that uses a tion, the security risks often associated with
“We are a thoughtful industry,” he variety of media, all of which cross-reference social media can be mitigated, ensuring that
observes. “I think many are reaching hap- each other. “When disclosing material infor- information remains secure and only those
hazard conclusions on their use of social mation – broadcasting, not narrowcasting with authorization are able to access wire
media without fully thinking it through. is the key – it's that broad, simultaneous and social media distribution tools.”
We need to slow down.” distribution that needs to happen, with But, for safety measures to work, the
plenty of cross-linking to a deeper set of investment community will need to be more
Key Issues to Address information to avoid issues inherent in the astute. Rivel, which also interviewed 350
A social media policy needs to settle medium,” he wrote in an e-mail. “Naturally, buy-side professionals on social media in
some key questions: What behavior can a press release is a good, standard part of its June survey, found that, of the 41 inves-
investors expect and rely on regarding dis- any such strategy." tors interviewed who use Twitter feeds as a
closure? How will the company ensure that
it simultaneously releases its news to all of
its selected outlets at once? How can the Social Media and Reg FD
company protect itself against hacking and An April NIRI webinar titled, “Social Media and the SEC,” provided a comprehensive overview
hoaxes so that investors can rely on the of the legal and compliance issues involved with moving into social media for corporate disclo-
legitimacy of social media messages? sure. In the webinar, speakers reviewed use of social media in the context of the Securities and
As the SEC noted, a company should Exchange Commission’s Netflix Report of Investigation, and made the following relevant points:
inform investors what channels it intends to • Communications made through social media should be examined for compliance with
use for disclosure. A press release through Regulation FD.
its established distribution channels or an • The SEC’s 2008 Guidance on the Use of Company Websites provides the relevant analytical
8-K can satisfy that notification, but once framework to assess whether information is being disseminated consistent with Reg FD.
the company has set those expectations, it • Social media may be used as a primary means of complying with Reg FD if
needs to do what it says and do so consis- the information is disseminated through a “recognized channel of dis-
tently, Corbin believes. tribution,” and the webinar speakers reviewed the relevant factors from
To this point, in a jointly sponsored NIRI the 2008 Guidance applicable to this determination.
and Society of Corporate Secretaries and • Webinar speakers recommended that companies view the SEC
Governance Professionals webinar on the Report as a catalyst for reassessing which disclosure methods are most
topic, speaker Jim Brashear, vice president, appropriate for complying with Reg FD.
general counsel & corporate secretary, This webinar may be accessed via the archived webinars page of the
Zix Corp., noted, “I think you do have NIRI website: http://www.niri.org/ArchivedWebinars.
to pay attention to the 2008 guidance
“There is a He believes the lack of interest on
the part of investors is due to the over-
generational shift whelming amount of information and

that means social sources they already have to follow. “They


can’t keep up with the scale of data coming
media use for a at them, and as in most systems like this,
source of investment the things floating around become more
noise than useful.”
information will However, Mehok of Dell points out that
increase.” – MarketwiRED his company is using social media chan-
nels because “our investor base thinks it’s
important.” Twitter feeds regarding recent
earnings reached 32.6 million Twitter users,
source for news, 56 percent follow up on generational shift that means social media use including the company’s tweets and fol-
tweets by clicking on a link included in the for a source of investment information will lower retweets, he says. And face-to-face
Twitter feed. If the tweet is a hoax, the link increase.” It found that 70 percent of younger feedback from institutional investors indi-
may well be, too. investors (40 years old and under) thought cates they find Dell’s blogs and video blogs
To further protect against hoaxes and the SEC statement on social media would be useful, he adds.
unauthorized use of the channels, observes beneficial for investors, compared with only Although the surveys show varying
Viglotti, a company should clearly state its 33 percent of those over age 65 and 51 per- degrees of investor interest, most of them
communication policy and follow it. Then, cent of those between the two age groups. point to another cause for pause: Even
investors will be able to ferret out hoaxes. Corbin Perception’s recent survey of those who pay attention to social media
For example, if a company says it will simul- 87 global buy-side professionals found channels don’t put much credence in
taneously release its news on Twitter and that 52 percent of investors “utilize social much of what they see. “Interestingly
through PR Newswire, a Twitter post that media as part of their research process,” and somewhat concerning, 92 percent
isn’t backed up by a PR Newswire release whereas Rivel’s preliminary data from 239 (of respondents) consider the information
can be dismissed by the market. investors showed that 68 percent of the gleaned from social media sites as either
buy side never use social media at work. somewhat or not at all reliable,” Corbin
Lack of Demand (Corbin Perception is not affiliated with Perception found.
Given the significant effort required to Corbin of KCSA.) Still, advocates like Marketwired’s
execute a social media plan, it’s no wonder Every survey of the buy side reviewed Delaney thinks more IROs will begin to use
most IROs aren’t rushing in. Add to that for this article indicated that at least one- the new social media channels over time, as
deterrent the possibility that no one is third of investment firms disallow the use Dell has. “Some IROs are embracing it as a
paying attention to social media anyway. of social media on company computers, move toward building an authentic, trust-
The NIRI survey found that the number- although the Marketwired survey also found worthy brand,” he says. “We recognize IROs
one reason IROs don’t use social media that 40 percent of those blocked from and CEOs are not going to get there over-
is because they see no demand from their social media sites by their firms have seen night. However, the thought leaders are lis-
investors. Other surveys back that up. colleagues use their personal electronic tening so that they can launch, leverage,
Marketwired found that the 120 financial devices to check social media channels. and lead on social media. We are very
market participants it surveyed in April use Takazawa of EMC did his own survey of excited about the SEC [announcement],
social media considerably less than other 1,000 of his investors, and found “there is because it allows IROs to provide more
sources – such as press releases, news sto- no demand” for disclosure through social financial information to analysts, investors,
ries, analyst reports, or corporate websites – media. “We do not get any requests for and the business community.” IRU
to glean information about companies. this form of information dissemination,” he
The company countered that sobering says. “One would think if they valued it and Marj Charlier is an IR consultant at Sunacumen
finding with an optimistic note: “There is a wanted it, they would speak up.” Investor Relations; mcharlier@dc.rr.com.

10 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update


IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 11
NIRI 2013
CONFERENCE
BUILDS
VALUENew initiatives kept the energy
high and promoted learning at
this year’s meeting.
By Matt Brusch

J U N E 9 – 1 2 • H O L LY W O O D , F L J U N E 9 – 1 2 • H O L LY W O O D , F L

12 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update 2013 2013


Nearly 1,300 IR professionals gathered in June at Summit with sessions about structuring
global IR teams and targeting non-U.S.
the NIRI 2013 Annual Conference in Hollywood, investors, and a networking reception.
Florida to increase their knowledge, expand their Co-chairs Chevalier and McCabe kicked
off Monday morning with a new twist by
professional networks, and enhance their impact. celebrating the first class of NIRI Fellows.
In short, they met to build their value. The NIRI Fellows Recognition Program
is an honorary recognition program dis-
And that is exactly how the 2013 Annual the conference overall. However, the big- tinguishing those living NIRI members
Conference Committee planned it beginning gest buzz may just have been generated by who epitomize the leadership, integrity,
in July 2012, when it settled on the confer- news of the 2014 location: the Bellagio in involvement, and contributions of investor
ence theme of “Building Value: Knowledge | Las Vegas! relations professionals. Eleven luminary
Network | Impact.” Session materials and replays are available NIRI members were recognized for their
Led by co-chairs John Chevalier, director, free to attendees, and for purchase to non- contributions to the IR community. More
global investor relations, The Procter & attendees at www.niristream.org. information about the program is available
Gamble Company; and Angie McCabe, vice at: www.niri.org/fellows.
president, investor relations, HealthNet, the Conference Highlights
conference committee’s dedicated volunteers With 35 professional development
presented attendees with three exciting days sessions, Sunday and Wednesday
of idea sharing, networking, and fun. workshops, 20 new participant-defined
Responsive to attendee feedback from topic breakouts, and 23 industry breakout
previous conferences, and in the interest of discussions, the 2013 Conference offered
continuous improvement, the conference something for everyone.
committee worked on several new initiatives A slate of three workshops beginning on
to continue increasing the value of the Sunday afternoon got the conference off
meeting, and keep the energy level high. to a fast start. Attendees had the option to
So this year’s event featured one high-value learn from experts about road shows, valu- Above: NIRI Chair Hulus Alpay (left), and NIRI
CEO Jeff Morgan (right) celebrate the new NIRI
daily general session and introduced topic- ation models, and the proxy process. The Fellows Recognition Program with inaugural
specific breakouts with topics defined by day’s offering also included the Global IR Fellows class member Len Griehs.
attendees and facilitated by peers. In addition,
TED-inspired sessions throughout the agenda
provided attendees with a different experience
from panel conversations. Beach volleyball
and a beach walk were fun events added to
increase the opportunities for networking.
Plus the 2013 conference included 2
a wealth of other new and traditional
learning, networking, and fun events: the
Services Showcase Exhibit Hall, Global
IR Summit and Reception, Senior-Titled
Lunch, NIRI Signature Event, NIRI Senior
Roundtable Breakfast, Breakfast Briefs,
Lunch and Learns, Golf Classic, Fun Run, 1 3
Yoga, and more.
1. NIRI 2013 Annual Conference attendees learning and networking at the Services Showcase Exhibit
Survey data confirms that attendees were Hall. 2. NIRI Chair Hulus Alpay enjoying conference with fellow NIRI Board member Dennie Kimbrough.
very happy with the new ideas and with 3. NIRI founder and First Fellow Dick Morrill enjoying conference.

IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 13


Some of the nearly 1,300 Annual Conference attendees View of the beautiful south Florida
take a moment to meet and greet between sessions. beach from the conference venue.

NIRI Board Chair Hulus Alpay, and NIRI influence. There has also been a rise in the • On investor outreach:
President and CEO Jeff Morgan discussed idea that activists can manufacture returns »» There is an understandable tendency
the state of NIRI, and gave a Washington by simply drawing attention to their for companies to focus on existing
regulatory recap fresh on the heels of involvement. In a flat or nearly flat market, investors. But companies should also ask
Morgan’s congressional testimony on this has a lot of appeal. But in a market who their investors should be. Create a
improving shareholder communication. with more normal returns, investors are discipline or mechanism to force yourself
Moderator Diane Brady, Bloomberg less likely to chase the noise makers. to identify those who could or should
Businessweek senior editor; and general »» One voice isn’t necessarily indicative be your constituents, and make sure to
session panelists Timothy Ingrassia, co- of the desires of all shareholders, and it is allocate time to that outreach.
chairman, global mergers & acquisitions, incumbent on IROs to have a good under- »» Look also to overseas investors, which
Goldman Sachs; Jon Moeller, chief financial standing of the shareholder base, and the will be an incredible source of capital over
officer, Procter & Gamble; and Nick Sargen, diversity and variety of its needs. the next 10 years.
chief investment officer, Fort Washington
Investment Advisors, served up thought- • On potential disconnects between Great Options
provoking insights into ways companies and management and shareholders: NIRI conference attendees are often pre-
IROs can build value in today’s global mar- »» Shareholders seem most to appreciate sented with a nice problem – which session
kets from a wide variety of perspectives. the dialogue with management, regardless to attend? The 2013 conference was no
In a fast-paced session, the panel moved if management has the “right” answer to different, and this survey comment sums it
from global macro-economic issues down shareholder questions. They just appreciate up well, “There were a lot of great options, very
to IR-specific recommendations from the that management acknowledges shareholder difficult to choose.”
perspective and discipline of each speaker – concerns enough to have the dialogue. The educational opportunities were
M&A, long-term investor, and Fortune 500 »» Investors and IR/companies must both many and varied. Presented here are just
chief financial officer: continue educating each other about the a few topic-based key learnings. Those
opportunities, realities, and other issues on interested in a deeper dive should visit
• On the influence of shareholder either side of the fence. www.niristream.org for complete session
activists: »» Being in IR right now is incredibly playbacks and materials.
»» The rise in stock-indexers and closet- daunting and exciting. IROs build their
indexers, and the growth of proxy voting brand with the knowledge of their compa- • Proxy Process
services that have separated ownership nies’ business opportunities and strategies, »» IR involvement in the proxy process has
from the act of influencing corporate and increasingly that will be a global knowl- grown substantially over the past 10 years.
behavior has led to an environment ripe edge and understanding. The better IR can »» Driven by “Say-on-Pay” and share-
for noisy activists who feel they can rally do its role, the fewer disconnects will exist holder proposals, the process is now
passive shareholders for some form of between shareholders and management. extremely high profile, and is another way

14 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update


for IR to demonstrate value to the C-suite other laws that may easily reach the same funds emerged from the downturn well
and boardroom. U.S. conduct, and that may even apply positioned;they are targeting larger-cap
»» The trend of directors meeting more broadly. companies; many situations are “settled”
directly with investors is growing, but IR »» Companies should consult with before a proxy fight; activists do not
must be involved in order to ensure com- local counsel on specific international always seek board seats.
munication compliance. disclosure questions. »» Each situation requires specific analysis
»» IROs should pay close attention to »» Protect yourself: IROs should seek and an understanding of the temperament,
executive compensation, even if their com- coverage under their company’s insur- tactics, and capabilities of the relevant
panies received strong support during their ance and indemnification programs cov- activist or bidder.
past Say-on-Pay votes. Support levels can ering directors and officers. »» The first five (of the top 10) “do’s” in
fluctuate each year depending on industry the IR playbook for shareholder activism:
pay practices and one-time compensation • Using Social Media Safely 1. Identify and address potential vulner-
payouts to which investors may object. »» Publicly announce that certain informa- abilities – even without an activist in
tion will be posted on a specified Web page. your stock.
• Global Benchmarking »» Direct investors to a corporate, not per- 2. Assemble your team and hire
»» How companies measure their IR sonal, Web page. outside partners.
programs varies somewhat between North »» Make simultaneous disclosure in an 3. Keep your board informed and
America and Europe, but the dominant 8-K or press release until the company constructively engaged.
measures tend to be: investor/analyst feed- can verify robust traffic at the specified 4. Take the high road: Focus on your
back, composition of investor base, percep- Web page. company’s strengths.
tion studies, market surveys, relative stock »» If all goes well, announce the date 5. Define your core messages/positioning.
price, and volatility. when your use of the 8-K/press release
»» Similarly, although the order of pre- backup will be retired. Worth the Wait
cedence differs by region, IR program »» Be aware of, and continue to Final general session speaker Michael
traits that North American and European comply with, stock exchange-specific Sheehan was clearly worth waiting for
investors most value include: accessibility; disclosure rules. judging by the number of attendees happy
knowledge of the business/ability to answer to stay through Wednesday. The president
questions; communications/disclosure/ • Non-Deal Road Shows of Sheehan Associates is known for his
contact; responsiveness/timeliness; trans- »» Most investors find value in hearing communication training work with high-
parency; quality deliverables; proactivity; management speak in non-deal road shows. profile clients including corporate CEOs,
visibility; consistency; personal relation- »» The corporate executive most investors policymakers, and political leaders such as
ships; road shows; and investor days. want to take part in road shows is the CFO. U.S. presidents.
»» Meet with top investors at least once Sheehan delivered. In an entertaining pre-
• Global Disclosure Considerations per year. sentation full of humor, real-world examples,
»» With respect to disclosure, despite »» If using corporate access, take control and video clips, the highly rated speaker
the Securities and Exchange Commission’s of the process: Target your “best fit” inves- shared his unique techniques for everyday
definition of materiality, the real world test tors and approve the meeting schedule. messaging, handling controversy, and
of materiality is more likely to be anything dealing with crises.
that in hindsight resulted in a material • Shareholder Activism Finally, be sure to make your plans now
change in stock price and/or abnormal »» Activists target companies with poor for the NIRI 2014 Annual Conference
trading volumes. share performance, perceptions of an June 8-11, 2014, at the beautiful Bellagio
»» This need not necessarily be a state- entrenched board or a board that is not Hotel in Las Vegas! IRU
ment, but may be body language and tone holding management accountable, or sig-
of voice. nificant cash balances. Matt Brusch is vice president, communications and
»» Few if any countries have an equiva- »» The activism environment is practice information & editorial director at NIRI;
lent to Regulation FD, but many have changing: the more prominent activist mbrusch@niri.org.

IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 15


I
n the third year of mandatory
Say-on-Pay votes, most U.S. com-
panies appear to be doing a better
job of attracting investor support
for their executive compensa-
tion practices – thanks in part to
improved disclosure, greater engage-
ment, and better alignment of pay
with performance.
During the spring 2013 proxy
season, 76 percent of Russell 3000
index firms received at least 90 per-
cent support, up from 73 percent in
2012, according to a report by Semler
Brossy, a compensation consulting firm.
Overall, Russell 3000 firms averaged
91 percent support, up one percentage
point from last year.
Meanwhile, just 2.4 percent (or
47 companies) failed to win majority
approval, down slightly from 2.7 per-
cent in 2012, Semler Brossy reported.
Another 6 percent received between
50 and 70 percent support, and can
expect to receive greater scrutiny from
proxy advisors and many institutional
investors next year. Among the factors
that contributed to this year’s low votes
were pay-for-performance misalign-
ment; insufficiently rigorous perfor-
mance goals; large one-time awards;
grants of non-performance-based equity
incentives; and poor shareholder out-
reach or disclosure.

A Review of the
2013 U.S. Proxy Season
Most companies received greater investor support on executive pay,
but other governance challenges remain.
By Ted Allen

16 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update


Proxy Advisor Role Georgeson, said a supplemental filing can broadly each year, depending on the pay
Once again, proxy advisors played a sig- provide documentation to help a portfolio practices of the company’s industry peers
nificant role during the season’s Say-on-Pay manager override an institution’s internal and if there were large one-time payouts to
votes. Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS), voting guidelines and support management. executives. Noting the standard disclaimer
the largest U.S. proxy advisor, issued negative Brauer reminds companies “to be careful of in investment documents, “Past results do
recommendations at 13 percent of compa- the tone,” refrain from “bashing” the proxy not guarantee future performance, and that
nies that conducted pay votes this year, down advisors, and “be very respectful and explain certainly will be the case as you deal with
from about 14 percent in 2012. Companies where the misunderstandings were. Say-on-Pay,” he said.
receiving negative ISS recommendations Most of the companies with failed Say- In addition, companies should not assume
averaged 65 percent support this year, or 30 on-Pay votes last year have fared better in that all is well if they obtain proxy advisor
percentage points less than those that ISS 2013, averaging 40 percent more support, support but still receive less than 80 percent
endorsed, according to Semler Brossy. according to Semler Brossy. Most of these approval. A company’s long-term investors
However, IR professionals should not companies expanded their engagement may have concerns that the proxy advisors
assume that the proxy firms’ advice will be efforts and adopted substantive pay changes. have not yet noticed, Kenneth Bertsch, presi-
followed by all their investor clients. Of the Many of them tightened performance dent and CEO of the Society of Corporate
261 companies that received negative ISS metrics, granted more performance-based Secretaries and Governance Professionals, said
recommendations during the spring proxy equity, revised their peer groups, and during NIRI’s proxy season webinar in July.
season, just 18 percent failed to win majority increased disclosure, according to Equilar, To effectively engage investors on com-
support, Semler Brossy reported. a compensation data provider. Other firms pensation (and other proxy matters), an IRO
While proxy advisors may have a greater responded by adopting clawback policies or needs to know who actually makes the voting
influence at smaller institutions, which have by eliminating pay practices (such as single- decisions. In most cases, it won’t be the port-
less staff to analyze hundreds of proxy state- trigger severance provisions or tax gross-up folio managers or analysts who regularly cover
ments, most large institutions have their payments) to which the proxy advisors and the company; many institutions have separate
own internal voting guidelines. During a some investors object. proxy voting or corporate governance teams.
panel on “Demystifying the Proxy Process” Many of the companies that received more Robert Williams, vice president, corporate
at the 2013 NIRI Annual Conference, John Say-on-Pay support this season also improved financial planning and analysis at Dell, said
Siemann, executive vice president of AST their proxy disclosures. One example was IROs should try to develop a relationship
Phoenix Advisors, said IROs “need to have Integra LifeSciences, which received 85 percent with these proxy voting contacts. “Call them
conversations with their bigger holders” and approval this year after barely passing in 2012. in October or September – when things are
understand that they have different criteria to Angela Steinway, Integra’s head of IR, said her really slow – introduce yourself and get to
evaluate compensation. “It will be your job company added an executive summary, pro- know them,” Williams said at the annual
to understand that, because that will deter- vided details on outreach efforts, and did an meeting panel at NIRI’s Annual Conference.
mine how you craft your Say-on-Pay [mes- in-depth analysis to improve the readability “If you do need them at a time that is really
sage],” he said. of the proxy statement. “We are seeing a lot important for your company, you have built
So far this year, fewer issuers have of investors who are pushing back and asking that relationship in advance.”
responded to negative proxy advisor rec- for a proxy statement that is more transparent Looking ahead to next proxy season,
ommendations with supplemental filings. and consistent,” Steinway said during a NIRI Patrick McGurn, senior counsel at ISS, warns
According to Semler Brossy, 59 companies Annual Conference panel, “The IRO Agenda that there may be a record number of com-
made such filings after receiving negative ISS and the Annual Meeting.” panies holding compensation votes in 2014.
reports, down from 100 in 2012. While com- As the several hundred companies with a
panies with supplemental filings don’t earn Engaging Investors triennial Say-on-Pay frequency hold their
more support on average, some governance While most companies receive over- second pay votes next season (in addition
experts say that filings still can be helpful. whelming support on pay each year, corpo- to all the issuers with annual votes), institu-
During a July NIRI webinar, “2013 Proxy rate governance experts remind IROs not to tions will face a greater voting workload and
Season: Lessons Learned,” Rhonda Brauer, take investor support for granted. Siemann will have less time for detailed case-by-case
a senior managing partner at proxy solicitor noted that support levels can fluctuate analysis. “If a company thinks it may have a

IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 17


problem, it may be a good idea to start early independent chair resolution at JP Morgan For the second year in a row, the New
on engagement,” McGurn said during an Chase’s annual meeting in May. The propo- York State Common Retirement Fund and
Equilar webinar in July. nents, which included labor and public fund other activists filed more than 110 proposals
investors, argued that separating the roles that relate to corporate political activities or
Activism on Governance of CEO and chairman would provide better lobbying. Resolutions seeking more disclo-
Reforms oversight and reduce the risk of large losses. sure of political spending averaged 29 per-
Another important proxy season concern JP Morgan successfully campaigned against cent support, up from 22 percent in 2012,
is shareholder proposal activism, and IROs this measure and it earned just 32 percent according to ISS, and activists negotiated
should be particularly aware of proposals that support, eight percentage points less than a agreements with 16 companies.
seek board election changes or enhanced similar proposal in 2012. While support levels for these proposals
shareholder rights and traditionally receive The proposal at JP Morgan was part of a are modest when compared with most gover-
broad support from investors. wave of 58 proposals on this topic this year. nance resolutions, this issue likely will remain
For the second consecutive year, a coali- Overall, support for independent chair reso- on proxy ballots. A group of law professors
tion of public pension funds affiliated with lutions declined by 4.5 percentage points to and Democratic lawmakers have called on
the Harvard Law School’s Shareholder Rights 31.1 percent, although there was majority the Securities and Exchange Commission to
Project has filed dozens of proposals that ask support at five companies, according to ISS. mandate disclosure, while business groups
large-cap companies to drop their classified These results suggest that many investors and Republican lawmakers have argued that
boards in favor of annual elections for all may be receptive to management arguments such spending is not material. At this point,
directors. The pension funds withdrew 57 against these proposals, especially if there is a new SEC rule appears unlikely, but IROs
resolutions after obtaining corporate commit- a lead director with a robust set of duties, should be prepared for questions about their
ments to declassify. unless the company has significant perfor- company’s political activities.
Twenty-eight proposals went to a vote mance or governance problems.
and averaged more than 80 percent support Fewer proxy access proposals were filed Opposition to Directors
this season, according to ISS data. Most this year, as some activists focused on other There has been a marked increase in proxy
institutional investors now support declas- issues. Eleven proposals went to a vote fight activity in 2013; there were 26 such
sification as a matter of principle, regardless and averaged 32 percent approval, down contests in the first half of the year, up from
of a company’s performance. “There are good from 36 percent in 2012. These resolutions 19 and nine during the same periods in
arguments, in my view, for staggered boards, received a majority of votes cast (excluding 2012 and 2011, according to ISS data.
but they’re losing with investors, and I don’t abstentions and non-voted shares) at Verizon At the same time, there has been less
see that changing,” Bertsch noted in the Communications and CenturyLink, which opposition in uncontested board elections.
NIRI proxy season webinar. both have a history of labor activism, and Only 43 directors (out of 14,774 up for
Likewise, shareholder proposals seeking Nabors Industries, where an access proposal election) failed to win majority support,
majority voting in uncontested director earned majority support in 2012. All three according to ISS data. Eleven of these direc-
elections continue to attract wide investor resolutions were based on the SEC’s invali- tors were at S&P 500 firms; the most notable
support, averaging 58.1 percent approval at dated Rule 14a-11 and called for a 3 percent example was Occidental Petroleum where
28 companies, according to ISS data. These ownership stake for three years. Chairman Ray Irani was ousted.
proposals are part of a broader campaign led There was less support (33.8 percent However, there may be more opposition to
by the California State Teachers’ Retirement on average) for a trio of proposals filed by directors in the future because of a new ISS
System, which engaged with more than 100 Norges Bank Investment Management that voting policy. Starting in 2014, ISS plans to
companies this year. While 78 percent of S&P sought more permissive (1 percent for one recommend against directors at companies
500 firms have adopted majority voting provi- year) thresholds to allow investors to nomi- who fail to fully implement shareholder pro-
sions, only one-third of the Russell 3000 have nate board candidates. Looking ahead, it posals that receive a majority of votes cast.
done so, so small- and mid-cap issuers should appears that most companies won’t face the In the past, a shareholder resolution had to
expect to see more activism on this issue. prospect of a successful proxy access pro- receive a majority of votes cast for two years
The shareholder proposal that attracted posal in 2014, unless their directors already (or approval from a majority of shares out-
the most media attention this year was the are under siege by activists. standing) to trigger this ISS policy.
Continued on page 21

18 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update


IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 19
NIRI NOW

NIRI Ethics Council IR Research at a Glance


Plays Crucial Role Social Media Scrutiny
Relative to degree of review used for press releases,
or SEC filings in your company, your company’s social
The NIRI Board of Directors formed the NIRI Ethics Council in media postings are held to:
March 2002. Comprised of former national board members, the pri-
mary functions of the council are to: 21%

• Provide advice and counsel to the NIRI Board of Directors 34%


regarding ethical issues, as requested, and recommend appropriate
41%
actions the organization may want to evaluate.
• Review the NIRI Code of Ethics annually to ensure it is 3%
addressing the needs of the membership and profession.
1%
• Provide confidential advice to the NIRI membership at-large,
assisting members with ethical questions and concerns and reaching 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%

out to members whose companies may be involved in publicly  uch lower degree
M Somewhat higher degree
announced ethical situations. of review of review
Somewhat lower Much higher degree
• Provide recommendations to the NIRI Board concerning the degree of review of review
enforcement of the NIRI Code of Ethics. The NIRI Board makes all
Same degree of review
final determinations regarding ethical matters.
Members may contact council members in confidence with ethical Note: Question was asked of IROs who had previously stated they engage in
questions or concerns. social media use for investor relations. N=29.
Source: Social Media Use in Investor Relations – 2013 Survey Results.
Compiled by NIRI, June, 2013.

NIRI Ethics Council


Mark Aaron, Chair David W. Olson
Vice President, Senior Counselor
Investor Relations The Abernathy
Tiffany & Co.
(212) 230-5301
MacGregor Group
(213) 630-6550 NIRI eGroups Moves
mark.aaron@tiffany.com dwo@abmac.com
to New Platform
Ralph Allen Bina Thompson One of NIRI’s most valued social media tools just got
Managing Partner Senior Vice President, even better.
Beacon Advisors Investor Relations NIRI eGroups, the members-only online discussion
(914) 763-9388 Colgate-Palmolive Company forum, was the most highly rated social media application
ralph@beaconadvisors.us (212) 310-3072 in the 2012 survey of NIRI members. As frequent users
bina_thompson@colpal.com know, eGroups is a great way to connect and network
Pamela Murphy with other members and receive immediate response
VP, Investor Relations and Tabitha Zane to any type of question about IR practice – from small
Corporate Communications VP, Investor Relations and groups to the entire NIRI membership.
Incyte Corporation Corporate Communications But there is always room for improvement. NIRI transi-
(302) 498-6944 Highwood Properties tioned eGroups to a new platform in August, rolling out
pmurphy@incyte.com (919) 431-1529 a major upgrade to the service that will provide members
tabitha.zane@highwoods.com with an easier, more intuitive functionality.
Look for the new improved NIRI eGroups on
www.niri.org.

20 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update


NIRI NOW

Quick Takes Professional Development


Calendar
What are some ways to grow For program information and registration, visit www.niri.
and advance your career? org/calendar.

Rob Williams
September 2013
22-25 Fundamentals of Investor Relations seminar,
Vice President, Corporate Financial Boston, MA
Planning and Analysis 23 Senior Roundtable In-City Meeting, Boston, MA
Dell 26 Writing Workshop for Investor Relations seminar,
Boston, MA
“I challenge people every day to ask themselves, ‘What is 27 IR Road Shows seminar, Boston, MA
your strategic impact on the organization, and when you are
gone what will people remember you for?’ If someone can October 2013
8 Planning the Annual Meeting webinar
answer that question, they are advancing their career.”
November 2013
13-14 Finance Essentials seminar, New York, NY
Katharine W. Kenny 15 Shareholder Activism webinar
Vice President, Investor Relations 18-20 Global IR Forum, New York, NY
CarMax
December 2013
4-6 Senior Roundtable Annual Meeting, Miami Beach, FL
“Network! IROs say they don’t have time,
12 What’s Coming in 2014? webinar
or do it only when they’re job hunting. I think they’re missing
a bet. My IR network has informed my strategic plan, helped
me continue to improve my knowledge base, and given me 2013 Proxy Season, continued from page 18
more confidence to push for program innovation. I believe it Business groups have voiced concern about this stricter policy,
not only has helped me grow but has enhanced my profes-
noting that a board may decide that it is not in the best interests
sional reputation.”
of all investors to fully adopt a shareholder resolution. ISS has said
that it will weigh various factors (such as the company’s outreach
Don Bullock efforts) when evaluating partial implementation of a proposal.
Senior Vice President, Investor Relations During the spring 2013 season, 72 shareholder proposals
Eaton Corporation received majority support. IROs at those issuers should be con-
sulting with management to make sure the company is prepared
“Be receptive to career opportunities and to make its case to investors if it decides not to fully implement
roles that are not a natural extension of your past experi- an investor resolution. For those IROs – and those at companies
ence. A broad range of experiences across different businesses, with low Say-on-Pay support – the preparations for the 2014
functions, geographic regions, and cultures will create a proxy season should already be under way.
portfolio of skills that you can access when you are faced “This is a year-round function now,” observed Siemann of AST
with new or difficult challenges. Developing the competency Phoenix Advisors. “When your 2013 annual meeting is over, you
needed for those new roles keeps you in a mode of continu- should begin the process of reaching out to your institutional
ous learning, which I find invigorating.”
holders, particularly the ones who voted against you . . . You want
to see if there are any potentially recurring issues that you’re going
to have to speak to senior management about.” IRU
“Quick Takes” features brief comments from IR professionals in response
to a question. If you would like to be featured in this column, contact IR Ted Allen is director of practice resources, NIRI; tallen@niri.org. For more
Update Editor-in-Chief Al Rickard at arickard@associationvision.com. insights, listen to a replay of a NIRI webinar, “2013 U.S. Proxy Season: Lessons
Learned,” at http://www.niri.org/Main-Menu-Category/learn/webinars.aspx.

IR update SEPTEMBER 2013 21


SPOTLIGHT ON CHAPTERS

NIRI Recognizes 2012-2013 Individual Leadership Awards


Dennis Walsh and Carlynn Finn – Boston

Leaders at Annual
Beth Carty – Capital Area
Elizabeth Higashi – Chicago

Conference
Sarah Graman – Cincinnati Tri State
Sarah Jager – Dallas/Ft. Worth
Sydney Isaacs – Houston

T
he annual Individual Leadership Award winners Bruce Burns – Kansas City
were presented at the Volunteer Appreciation Fred Clayton – Los Angeles
Cheryl Gedvila, Eleanor Powell, and Patrick Tracey – New York
Dinner during the NIRI 2013 Annual Conference.
Justin Moisio – Orange County
Chapter peers selected award winners in recognition of their
Emily Riley – Philadelphia
outstanding performance during the program year. Steve Nutt – Rocky Mountain
The traits of award winners are numerous and varied. But John Stoepler – San Diego
the leaders also share several common characteristics. They: Marty Palka – Silicon Valley
• possess high integrity, Matthew Thayer – St. Louis
• instill confidence and enthusiasm, Jamie Andelman – Triangle
• act as educators and motivators, Bernadette McCormick – Twin Cities
• demonstrate mutual respect, Eileen Durey and Katherine Strege – Virtual
• support others through appreciation and 2012-2013 NIRI Volunteer of the Year
encouragement, and Maureen Wolff, president and partner, Sharon Merrill Associates
• exhibit leadership skills as shown in past University of Michigan Scholarship Award
service to NIRI National and NIRI chapters. Shawn Southard, president, NIRI Philadelphia

SAVE THE DATE


NIRI ANNUAL CONFERENCE
June 8 – 11, 2014
Bellagio Hotel, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA

Register by September 30th for early bird rates


www.niri.org/conference

22 SEPTEMBER 2013 iR update


DON’T BE LEFT OUT

Join theIRevolution

THIS
COULD BE
YOU

To experience theIRapp sign up for a demo at


www.theIRapp.com

You might also like