Adista Maura – 1202622058

Class 22A

Bridging the Technological Divide: Addressing the Lag in English

Language Learning through Technology Integration in Indonesia
Introduction
In today’s globalized world, knowing how to communicate in English is a crucial skill
that allows people to take advantage of a wide range of opportunities, establish international
connections, and succeed in a society that is becoming more interconnected. With technology
developing as a promising tool for increasing language learning results, countries all over the
world have sought out innovative approaches to language learning in recognition of the
significance of English fluency. It raises questions about the efficacy and competitiveness of
language education in Indonesia as the country uses technology for English language learning
at a far lower rate than other countries.
More than 17,000 islands make up the unique archipelago of Indonesia, which also has
a burgeoning economy and a rich cultural legacy. It is the world’s fourth most populated nation
with a population of more than 270 million people (World Bank, 2020). The importance of
English proficiency has grown in Indonesia’s educational policies and initiatives as English is
acknowledged as a more universal language. Despite its importance, Indonesia has lagged
behind other nations in its adoption of technology in language learning, which restricts the
possibility of efficient language learning and competency.
There can be no doubt about the value of technology in language learning. According
to a study conducted by Brown & Warschauer (2006), using technology in language learning
can increase students’ motivation, engagement, and overall language competency. With the use
of interactive platforms, language learning apps, online courses, and multimedia resources,
educational institutions, and language learning centers throughout the world are using
technology to enhance traditional classroom learning. Indonesia, on the other hand, has not
made equivalent advancements in the use of technology in English language instruction,
placing the country far behind other nations in terms of technological integration.
This technological divide has broad-reaching effects. Indonesian students encounter
substantial challenges in improving their English language abilities due to a lack of proper
access to technology and training. Their ability to learn a language can be hampered by a lack
of access to real-world communication opportunities, interactive learning experiences, and
authentic language materials. The technical divide in English language learning also limits
Indonesia's capacity to actively engage in the global community in an increasingly
interconnected world where technology acts as a bridge for cross-cultural understanding and
collaboration. Therefore, this study seeks to investigate the difficulties and effects of this
technology inequality on Indonesia’s language teaching system. By bridging the technological
gap, Indonesia can provide its students with the instruments and materials they need to thrive
in the international context of English-language communication.
Supporting Arguments
Digital Divide and Socioeconomic Factors
The socioeconomic disparity and the digital divide make Indonesia’s technological
English language learning gap even worse. According to studies, socioeconomic position and
access to technology are correlated (Liyanagunawardena et al., 2013). As a result, they are less
likely to be able to participate in technology-based language learning than students from
advantaged homes or families with higher incomes. The socioeconomic divide worsens the
digital divide between Indonesian students and their peers in nations with more equal access to
technology.
Insufficient Teacher Training and Digital Literacy
The lack of sufficient training and digital literacy among teachers is another factor
contributing to the technological imbalance in English language instruction in Indonesia.
Despite the potential advantages of educational technology, it is found that many Indonesian
teachers lack the knowledge and skills required to successfully incorporate technology into
their teaching methods (CIPS Indonesia, 2021). Teachers find it difficult to use technology to
its full potential for language instruction without the right training and digital literacy.
Varied Teaching Approaches and Autonomy
Teachers are given a lot more freedom to create their own teaching methods, strategies,
and resources as compared to Finland, the nation with the best educational system in the world.
The Finnish educational system places more emphasis on student development and growth than
just grades. On the other hand, the school system in Indonesia is still mostly score-oriented,
and parents frequently place a high value on good scores. As a result of this cultural difference,
Finland emphasizes creativity and experience learning, whereas Indonesia’s system continues
to be more traditional and exam-focused (Setiawan, 2018).
Opposing Arguments
Contrary to the opinion that Indonesia lags significantly behind other countries in the
use of technology for language learning, there is also research that presents evidence to refute
this claim and demonstrate that the use of technology in language learning in Indonesia is well-
developed that serves as a refutation for this essay’s main argument.
Accessibility of Language Learning Apps and Websites
Mobile phone users in Indonesia have access to a variety of websites and apps for
language learning. As stated by Jati (2017), these instruments provide a wide range of strategies
and approaches that can be used in language teaching and learning. Since these resources are
readily available, students have many possibilities to participate in enjoyable and simple
language learning exercises through a variety of interactive activities. Due in large part to this
accessibility, Indonesian language learning has a highly developed technology integration.
Adoption of Learning Management Systems and Online Platforms
The adoption of learning management systems (LMS) and online platforms by a large
number of educational institutions in Indonesia has made distance learning and language
learning possible. These platforms, which include Google Classroom, Moodle, and other
locally created platforms, give teachers the chance to offer courses online, share resources, and
communicate with their students (Pardede, 2021). The broad use of these systems suggests
progress in utilizing technology to enhance English language learning for students.
The writer agrees to some extent that there are many language learning apps available
in Indonesia, like Duolingo and Rosetta Stone, which let users practice their English at their
own pace and convenience. These programs offer interactive exercises, vocabulary growth, and
pronunciation practice, all of which help with the improvement of English (or any other
language) skills. However, Indonesians’ restricted access to technology and internet
connectivity is one of the biggest obstacles to using it for language learning. Especially in rural
and remote areas, Indonesia’s internet penetration rate and access to digital devices are still
very low, according to the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) (2021). Due to
students’ potential lack of dependable access to the devices and internet connectivity needed
for online learning, the digital divide hinders the efficient installation and usage of LMS
platforms like Google Classroom.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Indonesia’s students and language teaching system face substantial
difficulties as a result of the technological imbalance in the country’s English language
learning. The issue is exacerbated by the low adoption of technology for language study and
the digital divide, leaving Indonesian students with restricted access to options. The ineffective
integration of technology into language instruction is a result of socioeconomic conditions and
inadequate teacher preparation. Furthermore, the cultural emphasis in Indonesia on grades and
exam-oriented education contrasts with the more student-centered and innovative techniques
used in nations such as Finland. Despite some progress in the use of learning management
systems and online platforms, limited access to technology and internet connectivity continues
to be a significant barrier. The efficiency of language learning applications and programs is
constrained by the unreliable availability of devices and internet connectivity, especially in
rural and isolated areas.
Therefore, Indonesia has to prioritize infrastructure investment, improve teacher digital
literacy, and encourage equitable access to technology for all students in order to address these
issues and close the technological divide. By doing this, the nation can give its students the
tools and opportunity they need to thrive in English language learning, empowering them to
take part fully in the global community and benefit from living in a connected world.
References
Brown, D., & Warschauer, M. (2006). From the university to the elementary classroom:
Students’ experiences in learning to integrate technology in instruction. Journal of
Technology and Teacher Education, 14(3), 599-621.
CIPS Indonesia. (202). Opinion: Is there still a place for EdTech now that we’re back to school?
Retrieved from https://www.cips-indonesia.org/post/opinion-is-there-still-a-place-for-
edtech-now-that-we-re-back-to-school
International Telecommunication Union (ITU). (2021). ITU Statistics:
Telecommunication/ICT Indicators Database. Retrieved from
https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/stat/default.aspx
Jati, A. G. (2017). The use of smartphone applications in English language teaching and
learning. In The 5th Undergraduate Conference on ELT, Linguistics, and Literature.
Liyanagunawardena, T. R., Adams, A. A., & Williams, S. A. (2013). MOOCs: A systematic
study of the published literature 2008-2012. International review of research in open
and distributed learning, 14(3), 202-227.
Pardede, P. (2021). A review of current conceptual research on short stories use in EFL
classrooms. Journal of English teaching, 7(1), 31-42.
Setiawan, W. A. (2018). Differences of education systems in developed and developing
countries curriculum, educators and financing in Indonesia and Finland. Didaktika
Religia, 6(1), 139-152.
World Bank. (2020). Population, total (Indonesia). Retrieved from
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?locations=ID