Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1992 TESE NuclearPhenomenainBrazilianPortuguese
1992 TESE NuclearPhenomenainBrazilianPortuguese
1992 TESE NuclearPhenomenainBrazilianPortuguese
net/publication/305775973
CITATIONS READS
5 95
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Thais Cristófaro Silva on 02 August 2016.
NUCLEAR PHENOMENA IN
BRAZILIAN PORTUGUESE
by
UNIVERSITY OF LONDON
1992
ABSTRACT
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ------------------------------------------------------- i
PREFACE --------------------------------------------------------------- ii
CHAPTER 1: THE THEORY OF CHARM AND GQVERNMENT
14
1.4. Conclusion ------------------------------------------------------- 16
To Johnzinho
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The completion of this thesis would not have been possible without help from:
My supervisor, Professor Jonathan Derek Kaye.
My colleagues from the School of Oriental and African Studies and University
College, London, especially Dr. Monik Charette.
Dr. John Harris and Dr. Harry van der Hulst for their comments and suggestions
on various sections of this thesis.
My friends~ espe9ially, Ariadne; Baofa; Barbara; Bernadete; Carlos and Nice;
Cecilia; Ceri; Chico and Cris; Chris and Vania; Dani; Dana; Dona Isa and
family; Evelina; Gracinha and Chris; Isa Terezinha; Krenak people; Lena;
Lucinha; Luiz Carlos; Lysle; Marcio; Marco Antonio; Moyra; Peter; Polly and
lara; Sanzio, Ivana and Natalia; Vic, Help, Carol and Barbara; Zina; Willer
and, of course, Johnzinho.
~
Fabio (he knows why).
The CNPq - Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Cientifico e Tecno16gico - for
grant numbers 20.24.24-86 and 40.24.69.91-7.
i
PREFACE
PREFACE
In this thesis we will analyse phonological phenomena which involve nuclear
positions in Brazilian Portuguese. Specifically, we will consider vowel
coalescence with emphasis on the process of vowel-glide alternations.
The data we present comes from the Brazilian Portuguese dialect spoken in Belo
Horizonte, in the state of Minas Gerais. We will refer to this dialect as BP.
References to other dialects are made whenever they are useful for supporting
e:m ar~ent or when they throw some light on the discussion of a given
lssue.
The analysis we provide is based on nouns and adjectives, whose morphological
structure consists of a noun stern, which may optionally be ~ollowed by a
derivative suffix, in. turn followed by the morpheme of gender.
The framework we have adopted is the theory of Charm and Government which has
been developed by KAYE, LOWENSTAMM and VERGNAUD (1985, 1990).
In Chapter 1 we present the basic assumptions of the theory of Charm and
Government, providing the tools necessary for the analysis we propose later .
. In Chapter 2 we provide a general account of how word stress is assigned in
BP. We will argue that primary stress is lexically determined. We will also
consider how secondary stress and word level stress are assigned and we will
state some constraints which are impos~d on posttonic constituents in BP.
In Chapter 3 we discuss the distribution of BP vowels with respect to the
primary stressed position. We will see that some vowels may only occur in
posttonic posi tion, whereas others may occur ei ther pretonically or in primary
stressed position. We will propose that the distribution of vowels in BP with
respect to the primary stressed posi tion is accounted for by charm constraints
imposed on nuclear segments.
In Chapter 4 we present a review of the literature on high vowels and glides
in BP. We will see that there is controversy as to whether high vowels and
glides are both underlying segments or whether the latter are derived. We will
consider both views in different frameworks showing that further research is
still needed to account for the distribution of high vowels and glides and the
phonological representation of glides in BP.
PREFACE
iii
CHAPTER 1: THE THEORY OF CHAR! AND GQVERHKEIT
CHAPTER 1
1.0. Introduction
In this Chapter we will present the theory of Charm and Government with the
aim of providing the tools necessary for the analysis we propose later. We
will first discuss how the theory addresses the organization of phonological
strings. Then we will consider the internal representation of nuclear segments
in ...Brazilian. .f..Qrt..ugu.e..s.e.. .we .w.ill....al.so.....a.d!1.J'.e..s.s...t.he. .gQy~.~nIDg ..~~QP~.~.t.!~§_P~ .
nuclear segments, d'efining the potential governors and the potential
governees.
v- u20
I I I
i + d- r'0
segment rOo We have seen that charmed segments are governors and charmless
segments are governees. Therefore, the negatively charmed segment d- must
govern the charmless segment rOo Given that the non-nuclear position filled
with d- has to govern the non-nuclear position filled with r O, it must be
associated to a constituent head. This is because only a head position. may
govern a complement. In order for the skeletal position filled with d- to be
associated to a constituent head it is projected over the onset constituent.
Given that d- is associated to a constituent head, it can govern the following
non-nuclear position which is filled with rOo We derive a structure where two
positions interacting in a governing relation are associated to the same
constituent.
(3) 0 R 0 R
I
,l\ \
I
1 I
N I N
I I
I \ I
X X ~ X X
I I I I
v-
I I I I
i+ d- r O aO
I
I i
A governing relation involving two adjacent positions which are associated to
the same constituent is defined as:
(4) Constituent Government
a. Strictly local
b. Strictly directional - head initial
The strict locality condition requires the governor to be adjacent to the
governee at the zero level of projection. The strict directionality condition
requires the head to be initial in all phonological systems. Constituent
government operates from left-to-right. It follows from the conditions in (4)
that constituents are maximally binary, i.e. franching constituents are at
most associated to two skeletal positions. In (5) we illustrate the
branching constituents (the head is underlined).
(5 ) a. 0 b. N c. 1lI
I I
1\ I \ I \
I I I
I \ I \ I \
I
I \ I
I \ N .\
! x ! x I
I. \
I I I I
X :It
a-
I I
a~/o
I
~o ~o ..... I
I
a+/ o '0
(3
(Sa) represents a branching onset governing domain where the head presents a
negatively charmed segment and the comp4leffient must present a neutrally charmed
segment. Branching onsets present a stop or non-sibilant fricative in the head
position and a liquid in the complement position. BP is a language which
P
- I I
a+ sO t- uO
I I
From the lexical representation in (6) we must show to which constituents the
non-nuclear posi tions are associated. The far left non-nuclear posi hon filled
with the segment p. is associated to the initial available onset. As for the
two other non-nuclear positions filled with SO and t-, we again must show to
which constituents they are associated. Non-nuclear skeletal positions along
with their segments are associated to constituents according to the governing
relations they contract with each other. Therefore, the non-nuclear positions
in (6) will be associated to constituents according to the governing relations
established between them.
In the preceding section we considered the form [vidru] 'glass' showing that
its sequence of adjacent non-nuclear positions - filled with the segments d-
and r O - are associated to the same constituent (cf. (3)). In this case the
first non-nuclear position in the sequence is filled with a negatively charmed
segment, Le. d-, being followed by a non-nuclear position filled with a
neutrally charmed segment, i.e. rOo In (6) we also have a sequence of non-
nuclear positions. However, unlike the case of [vidru] - where the sequence
of non-nuclear positions presents a negatively charmed segment followed by a
---n~tLaH-y-eha-rmed-se-gment--the-rep-resent-ation-i-n-{-6i--presen-t8-a-s-equenee-of--------------
non-nuclear positions where a neutrally charmed segment, i.e. so, is followed
by a negatively charmed segment, i.e. t~.
We have seen that charmed segments are-governors and charmless segments are
governees. Therefore, the non-nuclear position filled with t- in (6) will
govern the position filled with so. In order for the non-nuclear position
filled with t- to govern the non-nuclear position filled with SO it must be
associated to a constituent head. This is because only a head position may
govern a complement. The non-nuclear position filled with t- is then projected
over the onset constituent - which is a non-nuclear head. Given that t- is
associated to a constituent head, it can govern the preceding position filled
with SO which is then associated to the rimal complement (which is a non-head
position). We derive a structure where two positions interacting in a
governing relation are associated to different constituents.
(7) 0 R 0 R
:\ I
I
I
I
N\ I
I N
I I J
I \ I I
X X X ~ X
I I I I I
I
p-
I I I I
a+ SO t- o.0
I
1 I
6
CHAPTER 1: THE THEORY OF CHARM AND GOVERXKRNT
(9) 0 R 0
I
1\ 1
N\ I
t
I I
I \ I
X X X
I
~o
I 1
a-
t t
I
N N
I
I
X X
,
I I
I
a ~
~ a 0 a 0(
15 The theory claims that "empty" positions are filled with an element
which presents special properties. This element is called the cold element -
which is represented by vo. The properties of the cold element are addressed
later in this Chapter when we present the internal representation of nuclear
segments. Empty positions ate subject to a special type of government called
Proper Government. For the discussion of Proper Government see KAYE (l990a),
CHARETTE (1988, 1991).
16 We refer the reader to CHARETTE (1988) for the discussion on the
different behaviour of onsets which dominate no segmental material (cf. (l2b»
and onsets which dominate no skeletal position (cf. (l2c».
8
CHAPTER 1: THE THEORY OF CHARM AND GOVERNMENT
governed is given by the charm value of the segments which are linked to the.
skeletal positions. The charm value of a segment is given by its internal
representation. The internal representation of a segment consists of the
elements of which it is formed.
In this thesis we will be concerned with governing relations which may hold
in representations such as ~e one illustrated in (10), i.e. sequences of
adjacent nuclear positions. In order to consider governing relations
invol ving adjacent nuclear positions we have to determine the governing
properties of nuclear segments. That is, we have to define which nuclear
segments are potential governors and which ones are potential governees. In
---------the-to.ll.ow-i.ng-s.ectionsJl_a.wil LdiscJ1SS the internal representation of nuclear
segments defining the class of governors and the class of governees. ---------
The superscripts assigned to the elements in (13) represent their charm val ue.
Charm is a property WhichigamOng other things, expresses the combinatorial
possibilities of elements.
Elements occurring in nuclear positions are either positively or neutrally
charmed. Positive charm represents the property of "voweliness". Since what
characterizes a vowel is resonance, an element which enhances a particular
resonating cavity is positively charmed. In (l4) we illustrate the positively
charmed elements from (13) and the respective resonating cavity they enhance.
(14) Oral cavity
Pharyngeal cavity
Nasal cavity
The remaining elements in (13), Le. 1°, tfl and vo, are neutrally charmed, Le.
charmless. A neutrally charmed element has neither the property of
"voweliness" nor "consonantiness". That is, a charmless segment can be
assigned ei~her2~0 a nuclear position or to a non-nuclear position, 1.e. an
onset or a rIme. The theory claims that any vowel system is derived from the
set of elements given in (13). Those elements may occur either alone or in
combination. In order to combine elements the "Charm Principle" must be
satisfied .
. (15) Charm Principle
Elements with like charm cannot combine.
-AccoTdi-ng-t(')~he-eha-rm-Pri-ne·i-pte,·t-he--pos-i-t-i-ve-l-y-eh-a-rmed.-eternen-t-s---Ai,-.... i.,-_·_·- _._. __...
N+ - cannot combine with each other since they have like charm. Notice that
neutrally charmed elements - 1°, tfl, V o - may combine with each other. This is
because the charm property of a neutrally charmed element is the absence of
charm so that the charm principle is not violated. The combination of elements
is given by a phonological expression which reflects a fusion process. In (16)
we illustrate a combination of two elements.
(16) (A+. 1°)
I I
I I
operator head
A phonological expression always involves a binary operation. The full stop
in (16) separates the two terms of the phonological expression. The term on
the ~1ft is called the operator and the -term on the right is called the
head. Each element has a number of pnonetic properties one of which is
marked. TEe marke.d phonetic property of an element is called its salient
property. In (17) we illustrate the elements presented in (13) and their
respective salient properties.
(17) A+ openness (non-high)
1° frontness (non-back)
tfl roundness
...+ ATR-ness
Nt nasality
V
o none
In a phonological expression the element which is the operator is not fully
expressed; only its salient property is. In a fusion process the element which
is the operator transmits its salient property to the element which is the
head. The segment which results from a fusion process has all the properties
of its head except for the salient property of its operator. Consider the
phonological expressions in (18).
(18) a. (A+ 1°)0 = [E]
b. (1° A+)+ = [at]
Let us first consider (18a). The operator in (l8a) is the element A+ whose
salient property is openness. Given that in a fusion operation the operator
transmi ts its salient property to the head, the property of openness is
-tr.ansmi-tt.ed...to.the-elementI~ which.J.s_the'Hhead._of_the....phonolD.gical .expr.ess.i.on
in (18a). The result of the fusion process illustrated in (18a) is an 1° which
has the property of openness, i.e. [E]. In (18b) the operator is the element
1° whose salient property is frontness. The property of frontness from the
operator is transmitted to the head of the phonological expression in (18b),
Le. A+. The result of the phonological expression in (18b) is an A+ which has
the property of frontness, i.e. [~).
Notice that outside the parentheses which enclose the phonological expressions
in (18) there is a superscript. This superscript corresponds to the charm
value of the phonological expression, i.e. the charm value of a s~ent. The
charm value of a segment is given by the charm value of its head. In (18a)
the head is the element 1° which is 'neutrally charmed so that the charm value
of the segment resulting from the phonological expression in (18a), i.e. [El,
is neutrally charmed. In like manner the segment which results from the
phonological expression in (lab), i.e. [~), is positively charme~ since the
head of the phonological expression in (18b) is the element A+ which is
positively charmed. Let us now consider phonological expressions which involve
more than two elements. Consider (19).
11
CHAPTER 1: THE THEORY OF CHARM AND GOVERNMENT
positively charmed. Notice that the segment resulting from the phonological
expression in (19), i.e. [e], is positively charmed.
In (17) we have illustrated the salient property of the elements from which
vowel systems are derived. Notice that there 1s an element, i.e. vo, which
does not present any salient property. This element is called the "cold
element" or the "cold vowel". Given that the cold element does not have any
salient property, it cannot be open - which is the salient property of A+; it
_cannot be front - which is the salient property of 1°; it cannot be round -
which is the salient property of UO; it cannot be ATR, which is the salient
property of .+; and it cannot be nasal - which is the salient property of N+.
Therefore the cold element must be a high, back, unrounded, lax and non-nasal
vowel, Le. [-']. Recall that in a phbnorogTcal expre-ssioIC tne resulting-
segment receives all the properties of its head except for the salient
property of the operator. If the cold element occurs as the operator in a
phonological expression it has no role to play since the cold element does not
have any salient property to transmit in a fusion operation. For example, the
phonological expression (vo .~+)+ is interpreted as the same as the single
element A+, i.e. both expressions correspond to the segment [a]. This is
because in a phonological expression such as (vO.~+)+ the operator, i.e. the
cold element has no salient property to transmit to the head, Le. A+.
Therefore (vO.~+)+ is interpreted as [a]. On the other hand, if the cold
element is the head of a phonological expression, e.g. (A+.vO)o, it has a role
to play. That is, in a phonological expression such as (At.yo)o the salient
property of openness from the operator, i.e. A+, is transmitted to the head,
i.e. the cold element. The segment which results from (A+.yO)o is an open [~]
which corresponds to a schwa, i ,e. [a!.
Notice that the segment [a] is
neutrally charmed since its head, i.e. y, is a neutrally char~ed element.
As we have seen, the cold element only plays a role in a phonological
expression when it occurs as the head. If the cold element occurs as the
operator, itnas no effect over the phonological expression. The cold element
may be understood as the number zero in the representation of numbers in the
decimal numerical system. Notice that "three" can be represented either as 3
or as 03. This is because the number zero has no effect over the
representation of decimal numbers when it occurs to the left of a given
number. In like manner the cold element may be understood as being present as
the operator in a phonological expression. That is, a phonological expression
such as (vo.~+)+ is identical to A+ given that the cold element has no effect
over the phonological expre~sion when it occurs as the operator. Consider the
phonological expressions in (20) which represent the BP oral vowels:
(20) a. A+ or (vo .~+)+ = [a]
b. 10 or (vo.lo)o = [i)
c. u<> or (vO.YO)o = [u]
d. (A+ .10)0 = [E]
4 ' (A+ .:!f)o
e.
(A+ .yo)o
= [::>1
f. = [a]
g. (.i'+ .10 )+ = [i]
h. (~+ .~)+ = [u]
1. (~+ .(A+ .1°)0)+ = [e]
j. (Jr+ .(A+ .~)o)+ = [0]
12
CHAPTER 1: THE THEORY OF CHARM AND GOVERN~EHT
The segments [a,i,u], correspond to the elements A+, 1°, uP, pronounced in
isolation or with the cold element as the operator. The segments [E,~,a,i,u]
result from a phonological expression involving a simplex head and an
operator. The segments [e,o] result from a phonological expression involving
a complex head and the ATR element as the operator. In (20) we presented the -
internal representation of BP oral vowels. Nasal vowels also occur in BP as
illustrated in the forms below.
(21) a. [14J 'wool'
b. [ku~tru] 'coriander'
c. [kofbra] 'Coimbra'
______________________d~_Ln.e.6J-- ~.o~_ _
e. [piQ.] 'black fly'
f. [pi4nu] 'piano'
g. [vi~na]
, 'Vienna'
h. [haIiia] 'queen'
1. [mi5ma]
,
j. [siG.ml]
. 'myoma'
'jealousy'
Nasal vowels in BP are derived from vowel-nasal consonant sequences where the
nasal consonant mayor may not surface. (2la-e) illustrate cases where the
nasal consonant does not surface, e.g. /lan0/ --> [laJ and !kuEntru! -->
[ku~tru]. (21f-j) illustrat~5the cases the nasal consonant surfaces, e.g.
/pianu! --> [pianu] 'piano'. .
According to the theory, the nasal element ~ can only combine With neutrally
charmed segments. This constraint follows from the Charm Principle which
establishes that elements with like charm cannot combine (cf. (15». Given
that the nasal element is positively charmed it cannot combine wi th post ti vely
charmed elements. Considering the set of BP oral vowels illustrated in (20)
one expects only the neutrally charmed segments, l.e. [i,u,a,E,::>J, to co-occur
with the nasal element ~. This is exactly the c~se. In (22) we illustrate the
internal representation of nasal vowels in BP.
(22) a. (N+ . (A+. yO ) °)+ = eli]
b. {N+ . (A+.1°)°)+ = [~]
c. (If. (vo .1°)0)+ = [i]
d. (N+ .(A+ .YO)o)+ = [0]
e. (If. (vo .YO)o)+ = [0.]
Notice that when the low vowel [a] is nasalized, e.g. !kama/ --> [kdma] 'bed',
it is phonetically manifested as a nasal schwa, i.e. [aJ, rather than as a
nasal open vowel, i.e. *[a]. The fact that the vowel [a] is phonetically
manifested as a schwa when it is nasalized follows from the theory of Charm.
As we have seen [a] is a positively~harmed segment whose internal
BP nuclear segments are potential governors and which ones are potential
governees. In (24) we i 11ustrate the BP oral vowels and thei r respective charm
value and complexity nature.
(24) Positively Charmed SeFents
a. [a] A
b.
c.
d.
[e]
[i]
[0]
(..+.1° r
( ..+.(A+ _1°)°)+
(..+•("A. yo )° )+
e. [u] (..+.!f)+
29 Recall that nasal vowels are positively charmed segments (cf. (22»
so that they are also potential governors.
15
i'
1. 4. Conclusion
In this Chapter we have presented the theory of Charm and Government. We have
defined how phonological government operates and we have shown how skeletal
positions are syllabified. We have also defined the internal representation
of BP nuclear segments and we have determined the class of governors and the
class of governees.
Throughout this thesis we will be investigating phonological phenomena in BP
which involve nuclear head positions. Nuclear heads are potentially subject
to bear stress. In BP phonology the role of word stress is accorded a
particularly significant place. Therefore, in the following Chapter we will
discuss how word stress is assigned in BP.
16
CHAPTER 2: WORD STRESS IN BP
CHAPTER 2
WORD STRESS IN BP
2.0. Introduction
The role of word stress in BP phonology is very important since various
processes are sensitive to stress placement. Therefore; in order to consider
the processes we will address later in this thesis, we have to·show how stress
is assigned. In this Chap er we aim to provide a general account of how word
stress is assigned in BP. 1 We will argue that primary stress is lexically
determined. We wi 1L.al.s.o-C.ans~.s..ec.ondarLSires.s---and......w.QrQ. level stress
are assigned. Finally, we will state some constraints imposed on posttonic
constituents in BP.
1 There are few works on BP which deal explicitly with stress assignment.
Among these are: MAJOR (1981, 1985) and SEGUNDO (1990, in preparation). In
this Chapter we refrai.a from discussing previous analyses of stress assignment
since we aim to provide a general account of stress placement rather than to
provide a detailed theoretical discussion on the topic. Nevertheless, we will
assume some of SEGUNDO's (in preparation) proposals throughout this thesis.
There· are few forms where primary stress may fallon the fourth-to-
last nuclear position, e.g. [hitimika] 'rhythmic'. We will consider these
forms later in this Chapter.
17
.: .
b. [kazerG.] 'housekeeper'
kaz + er + \1
STEM SUFFIX GENDER SUFFIX
(2a) illustrates the morphological structure of the noun [kAza] 'house', where <
the noun stem kaz is followed by the gender suffix g. (2b) shows that the
morphological structure of the noun [kazeru] 'housekeeper' consists of the
noun stem kaz fo?lOWed by the derivative suffix er which is followed by the
gender suffix !i.
We assume that the gender suffix corresponds to a nuclear position which may
either be empty, i.e. 0, or it may be filled with any of the nuclear segments
[i,u,a]. The spelling out of the gender suffix, Le. either as 0 or as
[i,6,aJ, is lexically determined. This is because the same noun stem may have
the gender suffix nuclear position eithfr empty· or filled with any of the
segments [1,6,a], as illustrated in (3).
(3) a. (pas + 0) [pas] i~'
b. (pas + i) [pasi] 'pass"
c. (pas + u) [pasu] 'step'
d. (pas + a) [pasa] 'raisin
Nouns may be either feminine or masculine. We assume that the information
concerning the gender of a noun, i.e. whether it is feminine or masculine, is
determined in the lexicon. This is because no principle rules the information
for gender. That is, it is idiosyncratically defined.
In sum, we assume that the lexicon provides information concerning the gender
of a noun as well as how the gender suffix nuclear position will be spelled
out. In (4) we illustrate feminine and masculine forms where fhe gender suffix
nuclear position is either empty or spelled out by [i,n,al. The parentheses
enclose the morphological structure of the nouns and the forms inside the
square brackets correspond to their respective phonetic realizations. Below
each form we provide the lexical information on g~nder and how the gender
suffix nuclear position 1s spelled out.
(4) a. (kaki + 0) [kaki] 'persimmon'
GENDER: Masculine
GENDER SUFFIX: 0
(pas + 0) [pas] 'peace'
GENDER: Feminine
GENDER SUFFIX: 0
8 Usually feminine nouns do not have the gender suffix spelled out as
[0.]. Except for the example given in (4c), i.e. (trib + 0.) [tribo.] 'tribe',
we only find shortened forms of some feminine nouns where the gender suffix
is realized as [11]. For example: [m5tu] from [motosiklEta] 'motorcycle' or
[f5to.] from [fotografia] 'photography'. Notice that in the shortened forms the
gender suffix occurs as [0.], whereas in their unshortened counterparts it
occurs as [a].
9 The analysis of final and penultimate stress assignment we present in
the following pages is proposed in SEGUNDO (in preparation). Antepenultimate
stress assignment is addressed later in this section.
20
CHAPTER 2: WORD STRBSS IX BP
x x x x x x x x X
I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I
k a k i 0 k a k r
[kaki] 'persimmon' [kaki] 'khaki'
(5) shows .that final and penultimate stressed forms present a binary foot
where the strong node is assigned to the final nuclear position of the no~~
stem and the weak node is assigned to the gender suffix nuclear position.
We thus conclude that in final and penultimate stressed forms primary stress
is assigned in like manner, i.e. the strong node is assigned to the final
nuclear position of the noun stem or derivative suffix.
We have seen in (l) that primary stress may be final, penultimate or
antepenultimate. The proposal that primary stress falls on the final nuclear
position of the noun stem or derivative suffix allows us to group final and
penultimate stressed forms into a single binary foot pattern as illustrated
in (5). We now have to account for how antepenultimate stress is assigned.
Recall that nouns in BP consist of a stem optionally followed by a derivative
suffix which is followed by the gender suffix. Therefore, in an
antepenultimate stressed form such as (makin + a) [makina] 'machine' primary
stress falls on the second-to-last nuclear position of the noun stem. In this
case we have a ternary foot as illustrated in (6).
10 The proposal that in final and penultimate forms primary stress falls
onto the final nuclear position of the noun stem or derivative suffix was
first presented in LOPEZ (1979). SEGUNDO (in preparation) develops such a
proposal. Secondary stress assignment and word level stress are addressed in
the followtng section.
11 In derived forms the strong node is assigned to the final nuclear
position of the derivative suffix and the weak node is assigned to the gender
suffix nuclear position. The stress pattern for the derived form (fak + er +
u) [fakerfi] 'cutlery set' is given below:
s/'....:w
f a k e r u
21
CHAPTER 2: WORD STRESS IN SP
~
(6)
s
w w
0 R 0 R 0 R
I.
I
t
I
I
I
I
1
,
I
I
I
I
I N I
I N I
I N
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
X X X X X X
I I .I I I I
I I I I I I
m a k i n a
(6) shows that the strong node is assigned to the second-to-last nuclear
position of the noun stem. The weak node which immediately follows the primary
stressed nucleus is assigned to the final nuclear position of the noun stem.
The final weak node is assigned to the gender suffix nuclear position. We now
have to determine whether when primary stress falls on the second-to-last
nuclear position of a noun stem it is ruled by some principle or whether it
is idiosyncratically determined.
If primary stress is idiosyncratically assigned then we can expect to find
noun stems wi th identical segmental sequences where primary stress wi 11 either
fallon the final nuclear position of the noUn stem, i.e. (CVCVC + V), or
primary stress will fallon the second-to-Iast, nuclear position of the noun
stem, i.e. (CVCVC + V). This is because pri~ary stress may fall either on the
final or on the second-to-Iast nuclear position of a noun stem or derivative
suffix (cf. (5,6)). Thus, if we find noun stems with identical segmental
sequences which differ only with respect to primary stress assignment we
conclude that primary stress is idiosyncratically determined. On the other
hand, if primary stress is ruled by principles and parameters we expect that
these principles and parameters will define primary stress placement.
In BP we do find pairs of forms whose noun sterns present the same segmental
sequence where in one case primary stress falls on the final nuclear position
of the noun stem and in another case primary stre~s falls on the second-to-
last nuclear position of the noun stern. These forms are illustrated in (7).
(7) a. (tonik + u)
[toniku] 'Tonico'
[t6niku] 'tonic'
b. (azi + a)
[azia] 'heartburn'
[azja] 'Asia'
c. (paris + 0)
[paris] tparis'
[paris) 'pairs'
The examples in (7) illustrate the morphological structure of nouns with their
phonetic realizations shown below it. Note that both the final and the second-
to-last nuclear position of a noun stem may bear primary stres~~
22
CHAPTER 2: WORD STRBSS IX BP
Forms in (7) lead us to assume that whether primary stress falls on the final
nuclear position of a noun stem (corresponding to the penultimate stress
pattern) or on the second-to-last nuclear position of a noun stern
(corresponding to the antepenultimate stress pattern) is idiosyncratically
determined. This is because the noun stems illustrated in (7) present the same
segmental sequence differing only with respect to primary stress placement.
However, one could question whether there is any particular difference in the
phonological representation of forms in (7). It has been noticed in the
metrical literature that in some languages primary stress is attracted to a
rime which branches. That is, rimes which present either branching nuclei or
____----hr.anc.h.ingJ-.ime.s. These langyages are assumed to be quanti ty sensitive. In W _
we illustrate the representation of a long vowel, a heavy diphthong and a
branching rime.
(a) a. R b. R c. R
1
I
I
I 1\ -
N N N \
I I I
I \ I \ I \
X X X X X x
I I I I
\/ I I I I
a a j a s
Long vowels and heavy diphthongs present a structure where two nuClear
positions are associated to a single nuclear constituent. In (8a) we
illustrate the representation of a long vowel, i.e. [a:], and in (8b) we
illustrate the representation of a heavy diphthong, i.e. raj]. In (8c) we
illustrate the representation of a branching rime.-
One could suggest that BP is quantity sensitive. Thus, the primary stressed
rime would either present a branching nucleus, i.e. it would be filled with
a heavy diphthong or a long vowel (cf. (Ba,b}), or the primary stressed rime
would be branching (cf. (Be». The proposal that primary stress in BP is
sensitive to branching rimes cannot be sustained. The first argument for
denying that primary stress in BP is sensi t1 ve to branching rimes follows from
the fact that we find penultimate stressed vowels preceded by a branching
rime, e.g. (ahtig + u) [ahtigii] 'article'. If primary stress were sensitive
to branching rimes' we would expect the bra~ching rime to be primarily
stressed, I.e. Jahtigii), what is not the case. ._
However ,one -could claim that in a form such as [ahtigii] -'article' primary
stress falls on the second-to-Iast nuclear position because the primary
stressed vowel corresponds to the representation of a long vowel - which is
a branching structure (cf. (8a». According to this proposal, the form
[ahtigii] 'article' woul have the following representation:
(9) 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I
1\ I I
I
N \ N I N
\ l\ I
I
X X X X X X X
I I I I I
I 1 I \I I I
a h t i g u
There are two arguments against the proposal that BP has long vowels. The
first one concerns the lack of experimental evidence for assuming that primary
stressed vowels in BP are long. The second argument against the proposal that
BP has long vowels concerns the phonological behaviour of languages which have
_ _Lo.ng_....Y.O.Wal~s-.and-..he..a...'lY---dipA.thQng.s-ln_ suc~g:es there is usuaIU _
phonological contrast between long and short vowels as well as segmental
restrictions concerning the vowels in the vowel-glide sequences which
correspond to heavy diphthongs. More specifically, a reduced set from the
overall set of vowels in the language may fill the vowel position in the
vowel-glide sequences which correspond to heavy diphthongs.
BP does not display the typical behaviour of languages which have long vowels
and heavy diphthongs. That is, there is no contrast between short and long
vowels nei ther ~re there segmental restrictions imposed on vowel-gl ide
sequences in BP. 1 Since there is neither phonetic nor phonological evidence
for assuming that BP has long vowels and heavy diphthongs we have to exclude
the proposal that primary stressed vowels in SP present the structure of a
branching nucleus (cf. (9».
The facts we have discussed above lead us to assume that primary stress in BP
is idiosyncratically assigned. Whether primary stress falls on the final
nuclear position of a noun stem, i.e. (kaki + 0) [kaki] 'persimmon' and (kak
+ i) [kaki] 'khaki', or whether it falls on the second-to-last nuclear
position of a noun stem, i.e. (makin + a) [ma.kina] 'machine', is determined
in the -lexicon. We then conclude that primary stress in BP is lexically
determined where feet may be either binary or ternary. In (10) we present
final, penultimate and antepenultimate stressed forms, their corresponding
morphological structure, and their respective stress pattern.
(10) a. (kaki + 0) [kaki] 'persimmon'
/ \
s w
0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I
I I I I I
I I
I N I N N
I I I I I
I 1 I I I
X X X X X
I I I I I
I I I I I
k a k i 0
~
s
w w
0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I
I I I I I
I I
I N N I N
I I I I
I I I I
X X X X X X
I I I r I I
I I I I I I
m a k i n a
25
.: .
concerning the construction of the metrical structure, i.e. that only those
nuclear heads which are not governed are projected to the level of nuclear
projection where metrical structure is built, is given in Chapter 5 where we
address governing relations between adjacent nuclear posi tions. Metrical trees
are built as follows:
(11)
a.Primary stress is assigned at the level of lexical
representation where feet may be either binary or ternary.
b.Phonological processes apply and those nuclear heads which are
not governed are projected to the level of nuclear projection.
c.Secondary stress is assigned onto the level of nuclear
projection according to the following parameters:
- feet are binary and left-headed.
- foot construction begins from the right edge.
d.Right-headed word trees are built onto the projection of
metrical heads.
According to the parameters defined in (11) forms such as (parana + 0)
[parana] 'Parana' ; (paralEl + a) [paralEla] 'parallel' : (satElit + i)
[satEliU] 'satellite'; have the following metrical trees:
(12) a. (parana + 0) [parana] •Parana'
w--------.. s word tree level
:-=z:::::::: w
sI I
~w
I I
foot level
~ ~ ~ ~
R R R R nuclear projection
I I I I
I I I
0
I
R
I
0
I
RI
0
I
R
I
0 R
I
I I
N I Ii I N
I I
N
II I
I
I
I
I
1
II I
I
I
I
X X X X X X X
I I I I I I I
I I
I
P a
I
r
I
a n a
I
"0
b. (paralEl +[paralEla] 'parallel'
(1)
w~s word tree level
F=:::::::
sr w :----
sI W foot level
I I
~ ~ ~ ~
R R R R nuclear projection
I I I I
I I I I
0 R
I
0
I
R
I
0
I
R
I
0
I
R
I
I
1 I I
I
I
I
N I N I N I N
II I
I
II I
I
II I
I
II I
I
X X X X X X X X
I I I I I I I I
I
I
P
I
a r
I
a
I
i E
I
i a
26
·: .
II ~I II ~I I
I
~I II ~I
X X X X X X X X
I I I I I I , I
I
S
,
a tl i J. t' J.
I
Ell
e. R f. R g. R 0
I
I
I
I
I 1\ I
N N
, N\ I
I
I I
I I \ I
X
I
I
,
X
I
,
X
I
X
I
I
X
a 0 a 13 or
(13a-d) illustrate the inventory of BP onsets and (Be-g) illustrate the
inventory of BP rimes. Let us consider each representation in (13) in more
detail.
27
CHAPTER 2: WORD STRESS 1M BP
2.4. Conclusion
In this Chapter we have considered how word stress is assigned in BP. We
showed that primary stress is lexically determined where feet may be either
binary or ternary. We have also addressed the construction of metrical trees.
We argued that metrical trees are built onto the level of nuclear projection.
Finally we have stated some metrical constraints imposed on posttonic
I
30
~CKAPTER 3: TKE VOWEL SYSTKK OF BP
CHAPTER 3
3.0. Introduction
In this Chapter we will see that the occurrence of certain vowels in BP
depends on their position with respect to the primary stressed vowel. That is,
~ome vQwels only occur 1n posttonic position, others only in primary stressed
position whereas others may occur either pretonically or in primary stressed
position. We propose that the distribution of BP oral vowels with respect to
the primary stressed position is accounted for by charm constraints imposed
on nuclear segments. In this thesis we are concerned with phonological
processes involving sequences of adjacent oral vowels. Once the distribution
of vowels is defined with respect to the primary stressed position we will be
able to establish which sequences of vowels are found in BP. Thus, we can
analyse phonological processes involving sequences of adjacent oral vowels.
e. [faraS] 'pharaoh'
f. [kra6] 'Krao (tribe)'
g. [bali] 'trunk'
ii. Penultimate stress
a. [piada] , joke'
b. [duElii] 'duel'
c. [kue).ii] 'rabbit (masc) ,
d. [saida] 'exit'
e. [viSla] 'viola'
f. [di6gii] 'Diogo'
g. [saudi] 'health'
ii1. Antepenultimate stress
a. [mfikina 1 'machine'
b. [elisi] 'helix'
c. [ezitti] 'success'
d. [sHaba] 'syllable'
e. [kaStlkii] 'chaotic'
f. [kr6nikii] 'chronic'
g. [uvUla] 'uvula'
31
CHAPTER 3: rHE VOWEL SYSTEM OF BP
Forms in (1) show that in primary stressed position the following oral vowels
occur: [a,e,E,i,o,~,u). The internal representation of these vowels is given
in (2).
(2) f
(vo .A+ or A+ = [a)
{.+ .(A .1.0)0)+ = [e]
(At .1°)0 = [E]
f
(.+ • 1°
(.+.(A .~)o)+
= [i]
(A+ .!f)o
= [0]
= [~]
(.+ .~)+ = [u]
Notice that- all the--segments in (2) p.~t-lea.st one posit-i-¥e1¥--c-hame4--
element in their internal representation. Indeed this fact reflects a
requirement imposed on the phonological system of BP, according to which a
segment occurring in primary stressed pesi tion must have at least one
positively charmed element in its internal representation. Accordingly, we do
not find the lax hi~h vowels [1] and [u] - whose internal representations are
(vo.lo)o and (vo.!f) respectively - in primary stressed position since these
segments do not present any positively charmed element in their internal
representation. With respect to the schwa - which contains the positively
charmed element A+ in its internal representation, Le. (A+ .yo)o - it is never
found in primary stressed position. Given that the segment [a] has the
posi ti vely charmed element At in its internal representation we have to
explain why it does not occur in primary stressed position. According to our
proposal, a segment which presents at least one positively charmed element in
its internal representation should be able to occur in primary stressed
position. The fact that a schwa is never primary stressed follows from .RIa
contrainte de Kryocephalie" proposed in LOWENSTAMM (1986) rhiCh aims to
account for the fact that a schwa is never long, i.e. *[a:]. According to
this constraint, a segment which has the cold element as its head cannot be
the head of a branching nucleus, i. e. « N•
1\
x x
\/
a
Let us extend LOWENSTAMM's proposal as follows: a segment which has the cold
element as its head cannot be the head of a domain. Such a proposal accounts
for the fact that a nuclear position filled with the segment [a] ~annot bear
primary stress. This is because a nuclear position which bears primary stress
is. the head of the metrical domain. Thus it cannot be filled with a segment
such as [a] which has the cold element as its head. In the following section
we consider the distribution of posttonic vowels.
34
CHAPTER 3: THE VOWEL SYSTEK OF BP
illustrated in (6) • 3
(6) a. [sed!] 'thirst'
b. [sEd!] 'headquarters'
c. [f6hma] 'baking pan'
d. [f~hma] 'form'
We have seen that in underived nouns pretonic mid vowels must be tense (cf.
(5)). On the other hand, in derived nouns either tense or lax pretcinic mid
vowels occur (cf. (4}). The fact that pretonic lax mid vowels only occur in
derived forms (cf. (4c-d» - but never in underived ones (cf. (5» - leads us
to posit that the morphological structure should be relevant in accounting for
forms which present pretonic lax mid vowels. We will propose that derived
forms which present pretonic lax mid vowels, e.g. [~rifta] and [duElisimu] (cf.
(4c-d», present a different morphological structure from derived forms in
which a tense mid vowel occurs pretonically, e.g. [orista] and [duelista] (cf.
(4a-b».
Let us assume that lax mid vowels only occur in primary stressed position in
BP (where indeed phonological contrast is observed (cf . (6) ) • If our
hypothesis is correct, we have to assume that in derived forms such as [~rina]
and [duElisimu] (cf. (4c-d» there must have been a point within the
derivational history of these forms where the lax mid vowels occurred in
primary stressed position. For reasons which we will consider shortly,
throughout the derivational process it happened· that the lax mid vowels
surfaced in a position which is no longer primary stressed. We propose that
the morphological structure of forms in (4c-d) is.
(7) a. « in + a)
~r+a) [~rina]
b. «duEl+u) isim + u) [duElisimu]
~
(a) ./'...
s w
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
N I N N 1
I N
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
X X X X X X
I I I I 1 I
I I I I I I
« :::l r a) i 11 a
I
N
I
I
X x 1- x x X
I I I I
I
I I I I I I
(:::l r a 1 fi a)
The deletion of the nuclear position in (10) yields a structure which presents
a sequence of onsets. According to the theory every onset must be followed by
a nucleus (cf. Chapter 1). Therefore, a structure presenting two consecutive
onsets is ill-formed since one of the onsets is not preceded by a nucleus. We
propose that the pointless onset in (10) is deleted in order to allow an
onset-nucleus sequence to occur. 'rfius, the final onset from the noun is
followed by the initial nucleus from the suffix. Nuclear heads are projected
and the metrical structure is constructed. The final derivation of the form
[~rifia] is illustrated in (II).
(ll) ~
w s word tree level
r---
ssw foot level
I I I
.!. .L .!.
R R R nuclear projection
I I I
I I I
-------·--------------O--R---o-R--o--R- ---- --_..---._--:-------------------.-.-------
I I I I I
I I I I I
N I
I N I
I N
I I I I
I I I I
X X X X X
I I I I I
I I I I I
(~ r i fl. a)
CHAPTER 3: THE VOWEL SYSTEM OF BP
domain, i.e. a word, they will not present lax mid vowels in pretonic position
(since any single domain in BP does not allow lax mid vowels to occur
pretonically). Given that forms in (l2) must present tense mid vowels, we have
evidence that (12) contains a single domain. The forms [orista] and [due1ista]
are obtained.
According to the analysis we have proposed in the preceding pages we should
find mainly two ways of grouping morphemes in BP. In one case morphemes would
be grouped as «x)y), Le. where more than one morphological domain is
involved. In the other case the morphemes are yrouped as (xy) when they are
analysed as a single morphological domain. The proposal to analyse
morphological domains as above is presented in KAYE (1989d). According to KAYE
····an--t-nstance- --trr---wh1-ctr·--morpho-togrca1:·-cat:egorteg--are---group-eu---crs·_-(-(-xly-)-or-
«x)(y» is called 'analytic' morphology and an instance in which
morphological categories are grouped as (xy) is called 'non-analytic'
morphology. In (13) we illustrate the forms which involve analytic and non-
analytic morphology that we have considered in the preceding pages.
(l3)
a. « ::Ir+Q) iii + a ) [::Irida] 'hour (dim)'
b. «duEl+u) iS1m + u) [duElisimu] 'duel (sup) I
40
CHAPTER 3: THE VOWEL SYSTEM OF BP
Forms in (22) show that in derived forms a pretonic vowel followed by a nasal
consonant can be either oral or nasal. The alternation between oral and nasal
vowels in forms in (22) is accounted for by the non-analytic nature of the
derivat!ve suffixes. The morphological structures of forms in (22) are
illustrated in (23).
(23) a. (osEan + ~raf + 6)
b. (pEn + oz + u)
c. (fin + ez + a)
Forms in (23) are phonologically interpreted as a single morphological domain.
Therefore, as in underived nouns (cf. (l5d-f» a pretonic vowel followed by
a nasal consonant in (23) can be either oral or nasal. In the preceding pages
we have considered phonological processes which involve analytic and non-
analytic morphological domains. We have shown that pretonic lax mid vowels,
e.g. [~rifta] and [duElisimu], and pretonic nasal vowels, e.g. [osedniftu] and
[penisima], must occur when the analytic suffixes -in-, -isim- and -met- are
involved in derivational processes. Throughout this thesis - unless otherwise
stated - derived forms that we will consider involve non-analytic morphology,
i.e. they are phonologically interpreted as single morphological domains. Let
us now return to the discussion of constraints imposed on pretonic vowels in
BP. Underived forms and forms involving non-analytic morphology must present
pretonic positively charmed oralYowels, i.e. [a,e,i,o,u]. In (24) we
illustrThte the internal representation of BP positively charmed oral
vowels.
(24) (vo. A+)+ or A+ = [a]
( ...+. (A+ .1°)0)+ = [e]
( ...+.1°)+ = [i]
("'+. (A+ .!f)o)+ = [0]
( ...+.!f)+ = [u]
42
CHAPTER 3: THE VOVEL SYSTEM OF BP
with like charm cannot combine. Given that the nasal element is positively
charmed it cannot combine with positively charmed elements. If high vowels in
BP corresponded to the tense vowels Iii and lui - which represent positively
charmed segments, Le. (..+.1°)+ and (...+.yll)+ - we would not expect high vowels
to be nasalized. This is because the positively charmed segments Iii and lui
cannot combine with the positively charmed nasal element N+. Indeed, high
vowels may be nasalized in BP, e.g. [st] 'yes' and[u] 'one'. The fact that
high vowels may be nasalized in BP, provides us with evidence that' the
underlying represennation of high vowels in BP corresponds to the lax high
vowels IiI and luI.!
According to our proposal, the underlying representation of high vowels in BP
corresponds to lax high vowels. We have seen that both tense and lax high
vowels occur in BP, e.g. [piada] 'joke' and [Elisi] 'helix' (cf. (1». Thus,
we have to explain the conditions under which a tense or a lax high vowel is
phonetically manifested. We propose that whether a tense or a lax high vowel
is realized depends on charm constraints imposed on nuclear segments,
according to their position in relation to the primary stressed position.
Let us first consider primary stressed vowels. Recall that a nuclear position
which bears primary stress must be filled with a segment which presents at
least one positively charmed element in its internal representation (cf.
(2Sa». The lax high vowels [I] and [u] - whose internal representations
consist of the charmless elements 1° and UO - do not present any positively'
charmed element in their internal representations. Then, their occurrence in
primary stressed posi tion violates charm constraints. We propose that in order
to satisfy charm requirements 'the lax high vowels [1J and [u] receive either
the ATR element ...+ or the nasal element ~ to their internal representations.
The positively charmed segments [i,i,u,6], which present a positively charmed
element in their internal representations, are realized. Thus, charm
requirements imposed on primary stressed nuclear heads are satisfied.
Let us now consider pretonic high vowels. We have seen that pretonic nuclear
positions must be filled with a positively charmed segment {cf. (2Sc». We
assume that in order to satisfy charm requirements imposed on pretonic nuclear
heads either the ATR element or the nasal element ~ which transmits positive
charm to a phonological expression - is added to the internal representation
of the lax high vowels Iii and lui. Tense high vowels, i.e. [i,u], or nasal
high vowels, i.e. [I,Q] - which are positively charmed segments - will occur
in pretonic poSitiO~i Thus, charm requirements imposed on pretonic nuclear
heads are satisfied.
Regarding posttonic nuclear positions we have seen that they must be filled
with a neutrally charmed segment (cf. (25b}). Thus, the lax high vowels [i]
and [6] - which are neutrally charmed segments - satisfy charm requirements
imposed on posttonic nuclear positions.
3.6. Conclusion
In this Chapter wehave seen that the occurrence of certain vowels in BP is
dependent on charm constraints imposed on nuclear heads. Such constraints
define which sequences of adjacent vowels we shall find in BP (cf. (25}).
Throughout this thesis we will be investigating forms which present sequences
of adjacent nuclear positions. OUr analysis aims to account for the processes
of vowel coalescence in BP with emphasis on the process of vowel-glide
alternations. In the following Chapter we present a review of the literature
concerning high vowels and glides in BP. We will see that further research is
still needed on this topic. Then, in the remaining Chapters of this thesis,
we will present our analysis to account for the processes of vowel-glide
alternations in BP.
CHAPTER 4
REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE
4.0. Introduction
A perusal of the phonological literature on BP shows that there has been
controversy as to whether high vowels and glides are both underlying segments
or if the latter are derived from the former. In this Chapter we will consider
both views in different frameworks. First we consider CAMARA's (1953,1970)
phonemic 'ana-i ell --are'
ys1s. 'Later'we"conside"i --works wh'i based-- on
the -linear'
generative framework. Finally, we discuss BISOL's (1989) analysis which aims
to define the syllabic structure of diphthongs in BP wi thin a non-linear
framework.
45
.: .
framework. 5
5 We have opted for not discussing any specific work which is based on
the linear generative framework. This is because such works alm to provide a
general analysis of the phonological system of BP rather than to provide an
analysis which deals with a specific topic. Regarding the phonological
behaviour of glides and high vowels in BP the authors we have quoted above
only state their assumption as to whether glides are underlyingly present or
derived from their corresponding high vowels - without presenting arguments.
6 In (I) we only specify the relevant features for the representations
of these segments.
48
.: -
where a glide follows primary stress. In the following section we consider the
proposal that glides are derived from high vowels.
Rule (3) states that an unstressed high vowel turns into its corresponding
glide when it is preceded by a vowel. In a similar way to the proposal of
deriving prevocalic gl~des (cf. (2»1 a problem which arises from deriVing
postvocalic glides from a rule such as (3) is that it would be awkward and ad
hoc to express the fact that posttonic postvocalic glides do not alternate
with their corresponding high vowel ([gajta] 'tin fife' but *[gaita]) whereas
pretonic postvocalic glides do ([kajpira] - [kaip1ra] 'bumpkin'). In other
words, once again the relationship between the position in which the high
vowel occurs with respect to the primary stressed vowel, i.e. whether it is
pretonic or~sttonic, requires the stipulation of awkward and ad hoc
constraints to rule (3).
7 Rule (2) must define that the high vowel does not bear primary stress.
This is because, unlike unstressed vowels, a primary stressed high vowel
cannot turn into its corresponding glide, i.e. [pia] 'sink' but *[pja] or
[asai] rA~ai' but *[asaj].
49
CHAPTER 4: REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE
.to ". _
50
.: .
. [ ... ] [ ... ] ..
I I
[ ... ] / [ \... ]
[pawza] 'pause' [f~jra] 'market'
[hejnu] 'kingdom' [pejSi] 'fish'
[sEw] 'sky' [k6wru] 'leather'
..,.
8 This work reflects the research done during her sabbatical year at
Stanford University (1988). In her bibliographical references no other works
on the same topic in BP are mentioned.
51
: .
According to BISOL (Sa) represents the structure of a heavy diphthong and (5b)
represents the structure of a light diphthong. 9 Heavy diphthongs correspond
to "true" or phonological diphthongs and are associated to two skeletal
positions. Light diphthongs are derived from assimilation processes at t~~
melodic tier (cf. (4» and are associated to a single skeletal position.
According to BISOL's proposal heavy diphthongs differ from light diphthongs
in the sense that the former are phonologically present and the latter are
derived. Another difference between heavy and light diphthongs is that the
former cannot be reduced whereas the latter are likely to be reduced.
BISOL assumes that the same diphthong, e.g. [ej], might have two different
phonological representations. That is, a diphthong such as [ej] may have the
structure of a heavy diphthong in a formiilCe [h~jniir-'-Klngdom'--~-rsar);;:----------------
which, according to her, is a phonological diphthong - and the diphthong [ej]
may have the structure of a light diphthong in a form like [fejra] 'market'
(cf. (5b» - which is a diphthong derived at the melodic tier. It follows from
BISOL's analysis that in a form like [hejnu] 'kingdom' the diphthong [ej] is
not subject to reduction - since it corresponds to a heavy diphthong (cf.
(Sa» - whereas in a form like [fejra] 'market' the diphthong [ej) may be
reduced to [e], since it corresponds to a light diphthong (cf. (5b».
BISOL's analysis aims to explain wny some falling diphthongs are reduced, Le.
[ow] is reduced to [01 and [ej] is reduced to reI, whereas others are not. In
order to solve this problem she proposes two different structures shown in
(5). Diphthongs having a structure such as (5a) cannot be reduced whereas
these presenting the structure (5b) are subject to reduction.
Let us .consider in detail what has been called the process of diphthong
reduction in BP (cf. NUNES (1951), NARO (1973), ALVARENGA ET AL (1989».
Basically two diphthongs are said to undergo a reduction process: [ow] is
reduced to [0] and [ej] is reduced to reI. That is, forms such as [k6wru]
'leather' and [fejra] 'market' may be manifested as [k6ro] and [feral
respectively.
According to BISOL's analysis the phonological representation of diphthongs
which may undergo reduction corresponds to the structure (5b), i.e. a light
diphthong. As she notes, the assUmption that diphthongs which are subject to
reduction are derived and therefore have thelftructure of a light diphthong
(cf. (5b» is problematic (our translation):
4.4. Conclusion
In this Chapter we have considered how the process of vowel-glide alternations
and the" phonological representation of diphthongs have been treated within
different frameworks. We have seen that these works encounter problems in
explaining when a high vowel alternates or fails to alternate with its
corresponding glide, and in determining the phonological representation of
diphthongs in SP.
In the following Chapter we will discuss governing relations between adjacent
nuclear positions. The proposal on governing relations presented in the
following Chapter will be applied to our analysis of vowel-glide alternations
in SP which is presented in the remaining Chapters of this thesis.
55
CHAPTER 5: ON GOVERNING RELATIONS BETWEEN iUCLEAR POSITIONS
CHAPTER 5
ON GOVERNING RELATIONS BETWEEN
NUCLEAR POSITIONS
5.0. Introduction
In this Chapter we will consider governing relations involving a sequence of
strictly adjacent nuclear positions. It is important to mention that no major
work has dealt specifically with this topic. Therefore, the discussion
addressed in this Chapter aims to provide a general discussion on this issue
as well as to discuss the theoretical implications of governing relations
between nuclear positions within the GP framework. The proposal presented in
this Chapter will be applied to our analysis of vowel-glide alternations in
BP which 1s presented in the remaining Chapters of this thesis. Consider (1).
(1) 0 R 0 'R
I l
I I
N N
x, x
I
I I
VI V2
(I) illustrates a sequence of adjacent positions which are associated to
phonological constituents that belong to the same category, namely nuclei.
Given that the adjacent positions in (I) are associated to constituents that
belong to the same category (nuclei) we have a sequence of identical
phonological units. It has been argued in the Ii terature that a representation
which presents a sequence of identical phonological units is not well-formed.
This constraint has been defined as the Obligatory Contour Principle or the
OCP. According to this constraint, sequences of identical phonological units
are prohibited in phonological representations. Thus, in order to prevent a
sequence of identical phonological units from occurring, phonological
processes apply. In the following pages we will discuss the notion of OCP and
we will address how governing relations involving a sequence of adjacent
nuclear positions have been analysed within the GP framework.
5.1. The Obligatory Contour Principle
In this section we will discuss the notion of the Obligatory Contour Principle
. (henceforth OCP) since this concept has been applied to the analysis of
governing relations between adjacent nuclear positions which we will discuss
later in this Chapter. It has been argued in the literature that a sequence
of identical phonological units is not a well-formed representation. This
constraint is stated in (2).
(2) Obligatory Contour Principle
Sequences of adjacent identical units are prohibited in
phonological representations.
OCP was initially proposed by LEBEN (1973) to account for tone simplification
56
CHAPTER 5: ON GOVERNING RELATIONS BETWEEN NUCLBAR POSITIONS
(3) a. HL
mbu 'owl'
. b. LH
mba 'rice'
c. HL H HL H
mbu i ---> mbu i 'the owl'
d. LH L LH L
mba ngaa ---> mba ngaa 'rice(pl)'
e. HL L H L
mbu ngaa ---> mbu ngaa 'owls'
f. LH H L H
mba i ---> mba 1 'the rice'
(3a-b) illustrate nouns which present a falling and a rising tone
respectively. In (3c-f) the nouns given in (3a-b) are followed by a suffix.
In (3c-d) the nouns are followed by a suffix whose tone is different from the
adjacent tone of the preceding noun. The tonal pattern of forms in (3c-d)
corresponds to' the tone of the noun followed by the tone of the suffix.
In (3e-f) the nouns given in (3a-b) are followed by a suffix whose tone is
identical to the adjacent tone of the preceding noun. In this case the tonal
pattern of forms in (3e-£) is simplified. That is, the final tone of the noun
which precedes the suffix is deleted. This process isfllustrated in (4).
(4) a. HL L ---> H¥: L ---> H L
mbu ngaa mbu· ngaa mbu ngaa
b. LH H ---> L~ H ---> L H
mba i mba i mba i
(4) shows that in a sequence of identical tonal units the far left tone is
deleted. The process of tone simplification illustrated in (4) is accounted
for by OCP which prohibits sequences of identical phonological units.
The notion of OCP discussed above has been applied to analyses of governing
relations between adjacent nuclear positions. We have seen in (1) that a
sequence of adjacent nuclear positions represents a sequence of identical
58
.: .
I a g a r s 5
In (7a) we have a sequence of strictly adjacent nuclear positions which is
subject to government. Charm requirements define that the noun-ini tial nuclear
position has the property of governing the nuclear position of the article.
A right-headed governing relation is established between the adjacent nuclear
positions and the deletion of the governed nuclear position, Le. "2he article-
final nuclear position, takes place as a consequence of the OCP.
2 Notice that in (7a) the governed nuclear position is deleted but the
segmental material which was formerly associated to it, i.e. a, remains as a
floating segment. The role of floating segments in phonological
59
CHAPTER 5: ON GOVERNING RELATIONS BETVEEN NUCLEAR POSITIONS
Vowel deletion does not take place in (7b) since no sequence of strictly
adjacent nuclear positions occurs so that no governing relation holds. In (8)
we summarize CHARETTE's proposal on the governing relation between nuclear
positions.
(8) Government Point deleted
by OCP
! I
I ! I
I
0 R 0 R 0 ~ 0 R
I I I
---- I ~--------- 1 I
N N If N
1
x x 1-
I
I
,
I 1
fi
I
I
vI V2 VI V2
In the following pages we will consider YOSHIDA's (1990) proposal which deals
with left-headed governing relations between adjacent nuclear positions.
(10) a. 0 R 0 R 0 R
I
I
I
I 1\ I
I
I
I
I
I N N \ I N
I 1 I I
I I \ I 1
X X X X X X
I I
I \ / \1 I
k 0 t a
b. 0 R 0 R
1 I
I 1\ I
I I I
I I \ I
I
I N \ N
I
1 l\ \
x ! x (x) x X
I I
I \I \1 I
k 0 t a
c. - - 0 R 0 R
I
1 I
I
\ I
I ,
I
I I I I
I I \ I I
1
I N \ ·1 N
I t I
1 1\
1 . \ I I
X ! (x) ::It X X
I I
I \/' \1 I
k 0 t a
In -(lOa) there are two distinct nuclei linked to the segment Q. In careful
speech no change occurs and the form kootta - which presents a long vowel
followed by a geminated consonant - is derived.
(lOb) illustrates the representation of the form koota in which the long vowel
remains but the first half of the gemination is lost. According to YOSHIDA the
sequence of adjacent nuclear positions undergoes nuclear fusion and a
branching nucleus is formed so that the successive vowels 00 become a true
long vowel. Notice that in (lOb) the strict adjacency condition (which
determines that the head must be strictly adjacent to its complement (cf.
Chapter 1» is violated. This is because the underlined head of the rimal
consti tuent is not strictly adjacent to the rimal complement (which is
associated to the first half of the gemination). To avoid a violation of the
strict adjacency condition, YOSHIDA proposes that· the rimal pasi tion (in
parenthesis) is deleted. The form koota is derived.
In (IOc) we illustrate the representation of the form kotta which displays
vowel shortening while retaining gemination. YOSHIDA proposes that the nuclear
complement (in parenthesis) is deleted, so that the underlined head of the
rime can govern the rimal complement. Once the nuclear complement is deleted
the governing head and the rimal position are adjacent so that the strict
adjacency condition is respected.
In sum, YOSHIDA'S proposal on "Nuclear Fusion" (cf. (9» argues that in a
sequence of strictly adjacent nuclear positions where the far left one has the
property of governing the nuclear position to the right a constituent
governing relation is established and the two nuclear constituents are fused
61
.: .
5.2.3. Conclusion
CHARETTE and YOSHIDA's proposals aimed to account for French and Japanese
phenomena respectively. However, nei ther of these works speci f i cally addresses
the theoretical issues which arise from their analysis. In the following pages
we will see that CHARETTE and YOSHIDA's proposals are in conflict with a basic
principle of GP, namely the projection principle. We will also see that their
works fail to define the conditions under which the OCP applies to a sequence
of adjacent nuclear positions.
We have seen that CHARETTE (1988) claims that in a right-headed nuclear
governing domain the governed nuclear position is deleted by OCP effects (cf.
Section 5.2.1). Nevertheless, to assume that the establishment of a governing
relation between nuclear position causes the deletion of the governed nuclear
posi tion viol ates one of the basic principles of the theory, namely the
projection princip~e.
(11) Projection Principle
Governing relations are defined at the level of lexical representation
and remain constant throughout a phonological derivation. (KLV
(1990:221»
62
CHAPTER 5: ON GOVERNING RELATIONS BETWEEN NUCLEAR POSITIONS
~ ~
I I
I I
0 R 0 R 0 Jt 0 R 0 R
I I I
I I 1 I
I I
N N )r N N
1 I
I
I
I
..
X ! ;. ~ x
I • I
I
I
I 1 I
I I
VI V2 VI V2 VI V2
63
.: .
(13)
a. Government b. Constituent c.Branching nucleus
dissociation under formation
government
,
I
! I
1 !
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I 1 I I I
1 I I I I
N N N N N
I I I .1- I
I I I T I \
~ X ~ X ~ X
I I I I I I
I I 1 I I I
Vi V2 Vi V2 Vi V2
For a left-headed internuclear governing relation to be established, the
segment associated to the governing position, i . e. Vi' must either be a
charmed segment or a complex charmless segment. The governed position, i.e.
V2, must either be filled with a simplex charmless segment or must be an empty
nuclear position. We propose that the OCP applies under government. Thus, the
governed position dissociates from its nucleus and relinks to the governing
nucleus forming a branching nucleus (cf. (l3b». Noti ce that according to this
process no sequence of identical ph,ono1ogical units, i.e. no sequence of
adjacent nuclear positions, occurs. Indeed, we have two nuclear positions
bound together within a branching nucleus governing domain. When the governed
posi tion in a left-headed internuclear governing domain is empty the branching
nucleus corresponds to the representation of a long vowel where the governing
segment VI spreads over the governed position. When the governed position in
a left-headed internuclear governing domain is filled wi th a simplex charmless
segment thf branching nucleus corresponds to the representation of a heavy-
diphthong. Let us now consider the cases in which a sequence of adjacent
nuclear positions is not subject to government. Consider (14).
(14) 0 R 0 R
I I
I I
N N
I I
I I
X X
I
I ,
I
VI V2
5.4. Conclusion
In this Chapter we have considered governing relations between adjacent
nuclear positions. We have discussed earlier proposals on this topic and the
theoretical issues which arise from them. Then, we presented our proposal on
internuclear government which is an expansion of the earlier treatments of
governing relations between adjacent nuclear positions. We claimed that in a
sequence of adjacent nuclear positions the OCP applies under government. The
proposal presented in this Chapter will be applied to the analysis of vowel-
glide alternations in BP in the remaining Chapters of this thesis.
66
...: .
CHAPTER 6
PREVOCALIC GLIDES AND PREVOCALIC
HIGH VOWELS
6.0. Introduction
In this Chapter we will investigate forms in which prevocalic high vowels and
prevocalic glides occur in BP. We will refer to these forms as iV and uV
sequences, where y'stands for any vowel. We aim to define the conditions under
which a prevocalic high vowel alternates or fails to alternate with its
corresponding glide and we will also determine how glides are syllabified in
BP. In the first section we discuss the phonological representation of
prevocalic high vowels and prevocalic glides and 1n the following sections we
consider the behaviour of iV and uV sequences in relation to primary stress.
~ x X
J\ . I
I
I
I
I
I
t
I ,
I
d. 0 N e. 0 N 0 N
I I
I I
X X X .X
I I
/ \ II I I
C i/\i V i/\i V
(1985,1990b).
2 A governing onset position, i.e. an onset position which is the head
in a branching onset governing domain, must be fi lIed with a negatively
charmed segment (cf. Chapter 1).
3 In section 6.3 we will discuss in detail the representation of complex
consonants.
68
·~ .
~
I
I !
,
I
0 R 0 R 0 it 0 R 0 R
I I I I
I I 1 I' I
N N )f N N
I
I ,,; I
I
X ~ j.
I
I
I
I
~
I
I •
.' ,
X
I
1° /UO V IO/J V 1°/00 V
4"
According to our proposal illustrated in (7) the phonological
representation of glide-vowel sequences in BP corresponds to the structure of
a light diphthong. That is, either the element 1° or UO together with the
vowel are both associated to the same nuclear position. Given that in (7) the
elements 1°/00 occupy a position which is not a nuclear head, i.e. they occur
as the left-member of the segmental sequence in a light diphthong, they are
phonetically manifested as a glide, i.e. [j,w].
71
CHAPTER 6: PREVOCALIC GLIDES AND PREVOCALIC HIGH VOWELS
In the following pages we will provide evidence for this proposal, i.e. we
will show that glide-vowel sequences in BP correspond to the structure of a
light diphthong. We will then determine the conditions under which a glide or
a high vowel occurs. Let us first consider the phonological interpretation of
word-ini tial glide-vowel sequences, e.g. [jAtli] 'hiatus I and [werekema]
'Amazonian Indian group'. Evidence that word-initial glide-vowel sequences in
BP correspond to the structure of a light diphthong comes from a phonological
process which takes place in the Carioca dialect of BP (spoken in the state
of Rio de Janeiro). In this dialect s-final nouns are phonetical\y manifested
with a final palatal fricative, e.g. fmesf --> [meS] 'month'. When an s-
final noun is followed by a noun which begins with a filled onset, e.g. fmes
+ pasadli/ 'last month', the final § of the first noun appears as a palatal
'---rrlcaflve, l.e. [mespasadu]. In other worC1S; an s=final noun-ls reallzed as ,"--.-.------
a palatal fricative when it isSfollowed by a noun whose initial onset is
filled with segmental material. On the other hand, if an s-final noun is
followed by a noun which begins with a nuclear position, e.g. fmes + interlif
'whole month', the final ~ of the first noun is realized as an alveolar
fricative, i.e. [meziterli], but *[meSiterli] or *[me~iterli].
Let us consider the cases in which glide-initial nouns are preceded by an s-
final noun. Notice that if the glide occupies an onset position, we expect
that, as in forms which present an initial f~lled onset, the final § of the
first noun will be phonetically manifested as a palatal fricative (cf. fmes
+ pasadlif --) [meSpasadft]). On the other hand, if the glide occupies a nuclear
position we expect the final ~ of the initial noun to behave like a vowel-
initial noun, i.e. the final § of the first noun will appear as an alveolar
fricative (cf. fmes + interlif --> [meziterft]). Considering sequences of nouns
such as /tres + jat(isf 'three hiatus' or /tres + werekemas/ 'three Uerekemas'
- where an s-final noun is followed by a glide-vowel sequence - we observe
that the final § of the first noun is phonetically manifested as an alveolar
fricative, i.e. [trezjatliS] and [trezwerekemaS]. The fact that the final § of
the first noun is realized as an alveolar fricative when it is followed by a
glide-initial noun, i.e. [trezjatliS] and [trezwerekemaS], is ~vidence that the
phonological representation of word-initial glide-vowel sequences in BP
corresponds to the structure of a light diphthong. That is, both the glide and
the vowel are associated to a single nuclear position. This is because glide-
initial nouns behave like vowel-initial nouns when they are preceded by an s-
final noun. In both cases the final s of the first noun is phonetically
manifested as an alveolar fricative,- e.g. [meziterli] 'whole month' and
[trezjAtliS] 'three hiatus'; [trezwerekemaS] 'three Uerekemas'. In (8) we
illustrate the representation of the forms [jatli] 'hiatus' and {werekema]
'Uerekema I , where the glide-vowel sequence is syllabified iIi the
representation of a light diphthong.
(8 )
a R a R a R a R a R a R
I I I I I I I I I I
N
I I
I
I
I
N
. I
N
I
I
I
I
N
,
I
I
I
N
I
I
I
I
N
I I I I I I I· I
I I I I I I I I
X
/ \ :
X X
I
I
X
/ \ I :
X X
I
I
X
I
I
X
I
I
X
,x
I
1° a t U UO e r' e k e m a
Let us now consider the phonological interpretation of glide-vowel sequences
.-----.....-.--p·r.eGeded-by-a-GQnsQnan-t-,-e-.-g-.-tp-i-ada-]-'3.Q·ke-'--[-kwalu-]--'GU-~d-'-.-I-n-(-9-)-we-···_-··--
illustrate the possible representations of these farms.
(9)
a.a R 0 R b. a R a R c. '0 .R o R
I
I , ,
I I I
I :\ I I II : I I I
I
I
N I
N : \ N : N I N
I I
I ~ I
I
I
I
I
1
,
I
I I \ I I : J .,, I
X X X X x x x x X )( X Jt X
I I
/ \ I
,
I
1
I
I
I
'0
I
I
I
I
I
I J /\ I I
p 1° a d a P I a d a p 1° a d a
kUO a A u k UO a A U k UO a A U
(9a) illustrates the case where the element 1° or UO together with a
consonantal segment occurs in the representation of a complex consonant. (9b)
illustrates the case where. the element 1° or UO occupies the governed posi tion
in a branching onset. (9c) illustrates the Case where the element 1° or UO
occurs in the representation of a light diphthong. In all representations in
(9) the elements 1° and UO are phonetically manifested as a glide since they
do not occur in a nuclear head position.
We have seen that word-initial glide-vowel sequences correspond to the
structure of a light diphthong (cf. (8». Similarly, we expect glide-vowel
sequences preceded by a consonant to correspond to the structure of a light
diphthong (cf. (9c». Thus, we have to show that representations like {9a-b)
do not correspond to the structure of glide-vowel sequences preceded by a
consonant in BP. If glide-vowel sequences correspond to the representation of
a complex. consonant - as illustrated in (9a) - we expect to find segmental
restrictions imposed on the consonant-glide sequence. This is because complex
consonants present restrictions with respect to the segmental materials, which
may occupy their skeletal position. However, this is not the case. That is,
no segmental restriction is imposed on consonant-gltde sequences where the
glide alternates with its corresponding high vowel. In fact any consonant
of BP may precede a glide-vowel sequence which alternates with a sequence of
~owels. Given that there is no segmental restriction as to which consonantal
material may precede the glide-vowel sequence (where the glide alternates wi th
74
CHAPfER 6: PREVOCALIC GLIDES AND PREVOCALIC HIGH VOWELS
(12)
a. 0 R 0 R b. 0 R 0 R
I I
I
I
I
I
I
I 1\ I I
I
I
I N N I \ N N
I I I I I . I
I I I I \ I I
X X .X x x x x x X
I
I t\
I a d
I
I
I
a
I
I
I
I / \
I
I
r t;i': cJ. K
I
I
a-
P b
In the preceding pages we have seen that glide-vowel sequences in BP
_.. ---- -----GQ~lOes_penQ-te-t-he-
s-t-x:uG-tu-Fe-e-f-a--l-i-g-ht-d-i-ph-t-heng-.--ReGa-l-l-tha-t-any-f-Q-x:m--wh-i-Gh-------
presents pretonic glide-vowel sequences may also occur as a sequence of
vowels, i.e. [jV] - [iV] and [wV] - [uV] (cf. (4». We have argued that the
process of vowel-glide alternations in BP takes place as a consequence of the
establishment of a governing relation between adjacent nuclear positions (cf.
(7». In the following pages we will consider the derivation of the forms
[piada] - [pjada] 'joke'. We assume that any form which presents a pretonic
prevocalic glide that alternates with a pretonicprevocalic high vowel is
derived in a similar manner. Consider thf lexical representation of the forms
[piada] - [pjada] 'joke' given in (13).
(13 )
/ \
s w .'
0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I
I . I I I I
I I
I N N I N
I I I I I
I I I I I
X X X X X
I I I I I
I I I I I
P i a d a
1° At
In (14b) the segment 1 occupies a position which is not a nuclear head, i.e.
it occurs as the left member of the segmental sequence in a light diphthong.
Given that the element 1° occupies a position which is not a nuclear head, it
appears as a palatal glide. The form [pjada] - which presents a glide-vowel
sequence - is derived and the metrical structure is built onto the projection
of nuclear heads. This is illustrat~d in (15).
Let us now consider the derivation of the form [piada], i.e. where a sequence
of vowels occurs. We reproduce its lexical representation in '(16).
a. 0 R 0
I
R
I
s
/
0
\
R
I
w
b. 0
I
R 0
I
s /'
R 0
I
w
R
I
I I I I I I I
I
N N N I N N N
I I I I I
I I I I I
X X X X X ---> )( K K x-· ><
I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I
P i a d a p i a d a
1° A+ 1° A+
I
1+
...
In order for a governing relation to hold, one of the positions must be filled
wi th a segment which has the property of governing the segment that occurs in
the other position. In the sequence of adjacent nuclear positions in (17b) the
far right nuclear position is filled with the positively charmed segment [a].
The nuclear position which iHllllT~iate1y follows raJ is filled with the
positively charmed segment [i). Recall that positively charmed segments
may govern a charmless segment, but not another positively charmed segment
(cf. Cha~ter 1). That is, positively charmed segments cannot be governed.
Thus, given that the adjacent nuclear positions in (l7b) are both filled with
positively charmed segments, a governing relation cannot hold between them.
Given that no governing relation holds between the adjacent nuclear positions
in (17b), no nuclear position is deleted and a sequence of strictly adjacent
nuclear positions is allowed to occur. The form [piada) is derived and the
metrical structure is built onto the projection of nuclear heads. This is
illlfst-rated- in (18).
P i a d a
1° A+
I
...'+
In this section we have considered the derivation of forms which present
pretonic prevocalic glides, e.g. [pjada], and pretonic prevocalic high vowels,
e.g. [pia-da]. Whether a prevocalic glide or a prevocalic high vowel is
phonetically manifested depends on whether or not a right-headed internuclear
governing relation is established. More specifically, we showed that pretonic
iV/uV sequences are subject to the following processes:
a) A right-headed internuclear governing domain is established
resul ting in the deletion of the governed nuclear position. The
segmental material which was formerly associated to the governed
position, i.e. the high vowel, relinks to the governing position
forming a light diphthong. A glide-vowel sequence is realized.
b) In order to prevent the loss of a nuclear position (which we
claim takes place under the establishment of a right-headed
11 Recall that when the element UO occurs as the left member of the
segmental sequence in a light diphthong it does not have the properties of a
nuclear head, e.g. it does not bear stress. Thus, although in the
representation of a light diphthong the element UO occurs in a nuclear
79
CHAPTER 6: PREVOCALIC GLIDES AND PREVOCALIC HIGH VOWELS
k trO a d r u
We claim that (21) does not correspond to the lexical representation of
[kwadru]. The first argument against a structure like (21) comes from the lack
. of restrictions concerning the vowel in the glide-vowel sequence. This is
because in languages which present lexical I ight diphthongs there are
constraints with respect to the vowel in glide-vowel seqUences which
correspond to light diphthongs (cf. KAYE (198ge».
Let us cOrfider French which is a language that has lexical light
diphthongs. Interestingly, in the glide-vowel sequences that correspond to
a light diphthong in French there are restrictions with respect to which
vowels can occur in the glide-vowel sequence. That is, the vowel can O~1Y be
(a,e,o] as in [wat] 'wad of cotton', [lw~] 'far' and (lwo] 'we rent'. If
in forms like [kwadru] the glide-vowel sequence corresponded to the structure
of a light dipbthong - as proposed in (21) - then there woul~4be constraints
concerning which vowels can follow the glide. Consider (22).
position it does not occupy a position which is a nuclear head (cf. Section
6.1) .
15 In (22) the vowel which follows the glide bears primary stress. Recall
that in primary stressed positions the following vowels occur in BP:
[a,E,e,i,o,~,u] (cf. Chapter 3). The only constraint in forms in (22) is that
the glide cannot be followed by the vowel [u], i.e. *[wu].
16 Recall that glide-vowel sequences which alternate with a sequence of
vowels may be-p-receded by- branching- ensets ie. g; [brwaka] - [bruaka-]' saddle-
bag' (cf. Section 6.2). As we have seen, in these forms the glide is derived
from a sequence of nuclei. In this section we are analysing forms where the
glide [w] corresponds to the element ua lexically associated to a position
other than a nuclear head. In these forms the glide-vowel sequence does not
alternate with a sequence of vowels.
Let us then consider (20b) which presents the element UO syllabified in the
governed position of a branching onset. If in a form like [kwadru] the glide
is syllabified in the governed position of a branching onset, we have a
representation such as the one illustrated below.
(23) / \
s w
0 R 0 R
I I
1\ I
,!\ I
I
I \ N I \ N
I
I \ ,
1 I
I \ I
I
X X X X X X
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
k UO a d r 6.
Assuming that the glide ~ represents the element UO syllabified in the
governed posit ion of a branching onset - as illustrated in (23) - we can
expect that whenever the glide ~ occurs it will be preceded by a consonant
(which will be the head of the branching onset governing domain). Indeed, a
consonant always precedes the glide in all forms where the glide ~corresponds
to the element UO lexically associated to a position other than a nuclear head
(cf. (19,22)). That is, a consonant-glide sequence, i.e. Cw, occurs. Recall
that constituents are maximally binary (cf. Chapter 1). That is, branching
constituents are at the most associated to two ske~etal positions. Thus, if
in a form like [kwadru] the glide represents the element tf' syllabified in the
governed position of a branching onset, the presence of the glide maximises
the onset. Given that constituents are maximally binary, we expect not to find
any forms where the glide ~ is preceded by a b.ranching onset. Tha\aiS, a form
like *[krwadru] would not occur - and that is exactly the case. Thus, if
we assume that the glide ~ represents the element UO syllabified in the
governed position of a branching onset (cf. (23)), we account for the lack of
forms where a branching onset precedes the glide ~, i.e. *[krwadr6.]. If we
a~sume that the glide ~ corresponds to the element UO syllabified in the
governed position of a branching onset, we expect forms which present a
consonant-glide sequence to behave like any branching onset in BP. Lei us
consider a phonological process which involves branching onsets in BP. 1 In
(24) we illustrate forms which present branching onsets,-Le. obstruent-liquid
sequences, followed by a primary stressed vowel.
18 Once again we stress that the cases under discussion in this section
involve those glide-vowel sequences which do not alternate with a48equence of
vowels (cf. (19,22)). According to our proposal in these forms the glide ~
corresponds to the element UO lexically associated to a position other than
a nuclear head. Recall that derived glide-vowel sequences may be preceded by
branching onsets, e.g. [brwaka] - [bruaka] !saddle-bag'.
19 For more details of this process see SILVA (1989b).
82
CHAPTER 6: PREVOCALIC GLIDES AND PREVOCALIC BIGB VOWELS
(28) 0 R
I I
I I
I
I N
I I
I I
X x
I
/ \ I
C UO V
11"
24 There are cases in which the glide in posttonic glide-vowel sequences
is syllabified in the representation of a complex consonant. In these cases
a velar stop-glide sequence must occur, e.g. [ligwa] 'language'. These forms
are discussed later in this section.
25 We assume that any form in (29) - presenting posttonic iV/uV sequences
which occur as glide-vowel sequences - is analysed in like manner.
86
CHAPTER 6: PRETONIC GLIDES AND PRKTONIC HIGH VOWELS
I
J ! I
I s w
o R 0 ~ 0 R o ..~
I I
C
I
·R
I
I I I
I J 1 I I I I I
N I
I Jf N I N I N
I
I
I
I 1 I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
X X x t X ---> )q.x.X.K
I I I I
I I I 1 I I : I / \
S a b i a s a b i a
IO
26 Recall that in a governing domain one of the posi tions must have
adequate charm value to govern the segment occurring in the other position. ~
The final nuclear position in posttonic iV/uV sequences (which may be filled
with either [a,u,i]) has the property of governing the immediately preceding
nuclear posi tion, which is filled wi th ei ther of the simplex charmless segment
i/u. For details on governing properties of nuclear segments see Chapter 1.
21 The fact that the simplex charmless segments, i.e. i/u, may govern
each other is addressed in Chapter 8, where governing relations between high
vowels are discussed.
87
CHAPTER 6: PRETOHIC GLIDES AND PRETONIC BIGB VOWELS
88
CHAPTER 6: PRETONIC GLIDES AND PRETONIC BIGH VOWELS
(34)
a. [inikwi dlldi] *[inikuidlldi] 'iniquity'
b. [ligwistlka] *[liguistika] 'linguistics'
c.[inokwidlldi] - [inokuidadi] 'innocuousness'
d.[agwadu] - [aguadu] 'watered'
(34) illustrates derived forms of the nouns listed in (32). Forms in (34a-b)
show that the pretonic glide cannot alternate with its corresponding high
vowel. Forms in (34c-d) show that either a pretonic high vowel or a pretonic
glide may occur.
--,"---- __ • _ _
---,-"~._---_._._. - . _ . _•• ,_ •• __ • .,~ •• , _ ••• " _ _ ., • __ , _ , ••• _ _ ' . _ _ ,•• , • ._" __ _ _ _•• ' __ M _ . . . . _ . . ., _ . _ . • _._ ,~_ ", , __" '." .,, _ _ ._._ _ " • • ._. _ ••• ~ __ " .•• _
iV/uV sequences where the nuclear position filled with the high vowel bears
primary stress.
However, such forms have not been reported in BP. That is, in forms which
present post tonic glide-vowel sequences primary stress must fall on the
nuclear position which immediately precedes the glide, i.e. [inikwa]
'iniquitous'but ~[inikwa]. For the metrical constraints imposed on complex
consonants in BP see SILVA (1992).
29 Forms which present antepenultimate stressed high back vowels followed
by a schwa have not been reported, i.e. *[manuaka].
..,.
30 Forms in which a primary stressed high back vowel is followed by a
palatal glide, e.g. [flujdii] - [fluidu] 'fluid', will be considered in Chapter
8, where governing relations between high vowels are addressed.
31 Forms such as the ones illustrated in (35g-i) - in which a primary
stressed high front vowel is followed either by [ii] or [w] - will be addressed
later in this section.
. .'
90
CHAPTER 6: PREfONIC GLIDES AND PRETONIC HIGH VOWELS
1° yO
I
t
...
It
At
32 We assume that any form which presents a primary stressed high vowel
immediately followed by a schwa (cf. (35a-f» is derived in like manner.
91
CHAPTER 6: PRETONIC GLIDES AND PRETONIC HIGH VOWELS
P i a
1.0 yO
I I
I I
...+ A+
P i a
1.0 yO
I I
1+ 1+
... A
92
CHAPTER 6: PRETONIC GLIDES AND PRETOHIC HIGH VOWELS
(40) / \
s w
O' R 0 R
I I
1 1
N N
x x X
I I I
I I I
h i li
1° ~
I
1+
~
33 We assume that any form which presents a primary stressed high front
vowel immediately followed by a high back vowel or a back glide is derived in
like manner.
93
CHAPTER 6: PRETONIC GLIDES AND PRETONIC HIGH VOWELS
1°
I
UO 1° UO
I
I 1
...+ ...+
94
CHAPTER 6: PRETONIC GLIDES AND PRETONIC HIGH VOWELS
(42) / \
s w
0 R 0 R
I I I
I I I
I
I N N
I I I
I I -I
X X X
I I I
I I I
h i 0.
1° UO
I
...1+
We have seen that a representation such as the one illustrated in (42) is
subject to government. More precisely a left-headed internuclear governing
relation holds so that a branching nucleus is formed, and a vowel-glide
sequence is manifested (cf. (41)). Notice, however, that in the process of
deriving the form [hia], i.e. where a sequence of vowels occurs, the segment
[0.] remains associated to a nuclear head position, thus appearing as a vowel.
We assume-that the derivation of the form [hia] 'river' corresponds to its
lexical representation, i.e. the structure presented in (42). Although charm
requirements are satisfied, a left-headed internuclear governing relation does
not hbld between the adjacent nuclear positions in (42) so that no vowel-glide
sequence is realized. The reasons why a left-headed internuclear governing
.relation mayor may not hold
.' between adjacent nuclear positions which are both .
filled with a high vowel (cf. (41,42)) - will be discussed in detail in
Chapter 8, where the governing relations between high vowels are addressed.
Suffices to say here that whether a governing relation holds or not, involves
sequenc
vowels.rr of adjacent nuclear positions which are both filled with high
6.6. Conclusion
In this Chapter we have considered the derivation of forms which present high
vowels and glides followed by a vowel, i.e. iV/uV sequences. The lexical
representation we propose for iV/uV sequences is illustrated in (43).
(43) 0 R 0 R
I I
I I
N N
I I
I I
X X
I I
I I
i/u V
x X
I I
I I
i/u V
Given that the far left nuclear position in (45) is filled with either of the
positively charmed segments [i,u] - which cannot be governed - a governing
relation does not hold between the adjacent nuclear positions. No nuclear
position is deleted and a sequence of vowels is realized.
96
CHAPTER 6: PRETONIC GLIDES AND PRETONIC HIGH VOWELS
x x
I
/ \ I
cUO V
We have claimed that when the back glide is phonologically interpreted as the
element lfl syllabified in the representation of a complex consonant (cf.
(46) ), it corresponds to the cases when the element UO is lexically associated
to a position other than a nuclear head. In the following Chapter we will
consider forms in which ei ther a postvocalic high vowel or a postvocalic glide ..
is realized.
CHAPTER 7
POSTVOCALIC GLIDES AND POSTVOCALIC
HIGH VOWELS
7.0. Introduction
In this Chapter we consider forms which present vowel-glide sequences, i.e.
[Vj,Vw], and forms which present a sequence of vowels where the far right
member is a high vowel, i.e. [Vi,Vu]. In the first section we discuss the
phonological representation of vowel-glide sequences. In section 2 we provide
evidence that vowel-glide sequences in BP are derived from a sequence of
adjacent nuclear positions and we determine how postvocalic glides are
syllabified in BP. In section 3 we will consider the phonological behaviour
of vowel-glide sequences, and sequence of vowels in BP in relation to primary
stress. We will determine the conditions under which a vowel-glide sequence
alternates or fails to ,alternate with a sequence of vowels.
7.1. The Representation of Vowel-Glide Sequences
In this section we consider the phonological representation of vowel-glide
sequences. Glides represent the cases in which the simplex charmless segments
i/u occupy a position othe~ than a nuclear head. Therefore, when representing
vowel-glide sequences we will have a vowel occupying a nuclear head position
immediately followed by either of the simplex charmless segments [i,u]
occupying a position -other than a nuclear head. In (l) we illustrate the
potential syllabifications of vowel-glide sequences.
( 1) a. 0 ·R b. 0 R 0 R
I I I
I I I
N N N
j \
.! x x x X
I I I I
I I I I
V iju V iju
(la) illustrates a heavy~diphthong governing domain. In a heavy diphthong
governing domain the governor, i.e. the far left nuclear position, must be
filled with either a positively charmed regment, e.g. [a,e,i,o,u], or with a
complex charmless segment, e.g. [E,~]. The governed position in a heavy
. -~ . .,."
.: .
d. [kawza] 'cause'
e. [kajpira] 'bumpkin'
f. [bawru] 'Bauru'
Le. *[aj].
2 In this section we are considering cases in which a vowel-glide
sequence occurs. Therefore, in (lb) the final nuclear position is empty so
that a vowel-glide sequence is realized. Whenever an onset position filled
with a simplex charmless segment is immediately followed by a filled nuclear
posi tion we have intervocalic glides, i.e. [VjV, VwV]. Intervocalic glides are
addressed in Chapter 8.
3 It is important to mention that in most BP dialects there is a process
of I-vocalization. This process yields a lateral consonant that is
phonetically manifested as a back glide either when it occupies a rimal
position, e.g. /altiira/ --> [awtura] 'height', or when it is followed by a
final empty nucleus, e.g. /saI0/ --) [saw] 'salt'. The forms we consider in
this work which present back glides exclude those which are related to the
process of I-vocalization.
99
CHAPTER 7: POSTVOCALIC GLIDES AND POSTVOCALIC HIGH VOWELS
r
f. fluj li] 'fluid'
fi:i. aw al
hubEw a]
'cause'
. 'rubella'
•
dewzaJ
periw ii]
'goddess'
~: k6wrii]
'leriod'
, eather'
Forms in (I) show that any BP vowel may precede the glide in the glide-vowel
sequences. The lack of segmental restrictions concerning which vowels may
occur in vowel-glide sequences in BP - as illustrated in (4) - provides us
wi th evidence that vowel-glide sequences in BP do not correspond to the
structure of a lexical heavy diphthong. This is because if vowel-glide
sequences corresponded to the structure of a lexical heavy diphthong, there
would be constraints on which vowels could precede the glide, which is not the
case. We have just seen that BP does not display the typical behaviour of
languages which have lexical heavy diphthongs, since there is no segmental
restriction concerning the vowels in vowel-glide sequences (cf. (4».
Furthermore, when considering BP vfwels we observe that no contrast between
short and long vowels is attested.
We have just seen that the proposal that vowel-glide sequences are lexically
present in BP and that they correspond to the structure of a heavy diphthong
(cf. (3)) cannot be sustained. Let us now consider the proposal that vowel-
glide sequences are lexically present in BP and that the glide in the glide-
vowel sequence corresponds to a simplex charmless segment syllabified in an
onset position (cf. (lb). According to this proposal a form such-'as [muzew]
'museum' is syllabified as in (5).
(5) 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
I I I
I N I N I N
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
X X X X X X
I I I I
I I I I
m u z e U
We argue that the glide in the vowel-glide sequences in BP does not correspond
to a simplex charmless segment syllabified in an· onset position - as
illustrated in (5). Evidence that postvocalic glides in BP do not correspond
to a simplex charmless segment syllabified in an onset position, comes from
the behaviour of derived forms of finally stressed vowel-glide sequences.
Recall that the morphological structure of nouns in BP corresponds to a noun
stern followed by the gender suffix, e.g. /trabaA + u/ --> [trabaAu] 'work'
(cf. Chapter 2). The gender suffix corresponds to a nuclear position which may
be filled with either [a,u,i], e.g. [kaza] 'house', [ladu] 'side' and [b5di]
'goat'. In derived forms the noun stem is followed by one or more suffixes
which are then followed by the gender suffix nuclear position, e.g. /trabal
+ ad + a/ --> [trabaAada] _'worked' and /trabaA + ad + or + a/ -->
[trabaAad6ra] 'worker (F)'. Consider the derived forms in (6).
c. [er:,j] 'hero'
[eroismo.] 'heroism'
In each pair of words illustrated in (6) the first form corresponds to an
underived noun, and the second one corresponds to one of its derived forms.
-- --All--the-urrderlved--rrOUIls-in To) ,-f ~-e---:--[muzewL- [TsKansE-wT;- [erSn,--p-resent-a
final stressed vowel-glide sequence. Notice that in the derived forms, i.e.
[muze:,lo.gii], [iskahseado.], [eroismo.], no vowel-glide sequence occurs.
In derived forms the suffixes are added directly to the noun stem~, i.e. the
gender suffix is suppressed, and is added after the las~suffix. The derived
forms illustrated in (6) are evidenceq that glides in word-final vowel-glide
sequences do not belong to the noun stem. Instead, the glides correspond to
the gender suffix nuclear position. This is because in all derived forms in
(6) the word-final glide of the.underived noun is suppressed when a suffix is
added to form a derived form. Therefore, the fact that word-final glides
correspond to the gender suffix leads us to assume that vowel-glide sequences
in BP do not corre,~ond to ,the segments i/O. lexically syllabified in an onset
position (cf.(5». -
In th.e preceding pages we have provided evidence that the glide in vowel-glide
sequences in SP does not represent a simplex charmless segment lexically
associated to a position other than a nuclear head. That is, the glide in
vowel-glide- sequences does not represent either a simplex charmless segment
lexically syllabified in the governed position of a heavy diphthong (cf. (3»,
nor does it represent a simplex charmless segm~ntlexical+y syllabified in an
onset position (cf. (5». Therefore, postvocalic glides are not lexically
present in SF.
We propose that postvocalic glides in SP are derived from a sequence of
strictly adjacent nuclear positions, where the far left nuclear position is
filled with any BP vowel and the far right one is filled with either of the
simplex charmless segment i/O.. In (7) we illustrate the lexical representation
of postvocalic glides, i.e. vowel-glide sequences, in. BF.
(7) 0 R 0 R
I I
I I
N N
I I
I I
X X
I I
I I
V 1/11
(7) illustrates a sequence of strictly adjacent nuclear positions. Recall that
adjacent nuclear positions are subject to government (cf. Chapter 1). In a
governing domain the governing position must be filled with a segment which
has the adequate charm value to govern the segment associated to the governed
_pos.ition.__Let _us.then __consi.deL.the ..g.ov.erning_prop-ert i.es Qf.the .segment.s w_htcll
occupy the adjacent nuclear positions in (7).
The far left nuclear position in (7) is filled with any BP vowel and the far
right nuclear posi tion is filled with a simplex charmless segment. Recall that
simplex charmless segments may be governed by any other nuclear segment (cf.
Chapter 1). Therefore, the far left nuclear position in (7) - which is filled
with the vowel - is the governor and the nuclear position to the right - which
is filled with either of the simplex charmless segment i/11 - is the governee.
A left-headed internuclear governing domain is established.
In Chapter 5 we proposed that the establishment of a left-headed internuclear
governing domain yields a branching nucleus formation. That is, the governed
nuclear position dissociates from its nuclear constituent and relinks to the
governing nucleus. This process is illustrated in (8).
(8) .
a. Government b. Constituent c.Branchinq nucleus
dissociation under formation
government
! I
I !
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I
I I I I
N N N N N
I J. I
I "T I \
~ X ~ X ~ X
I I I I I I.
I 1 I I I I
V i/11 V. i/11 V i/11
104
.: .
glide sequence must be realized, e.g. [gajta] 'tin fife' but *[gaita]. We will
determin the conditions under which a vowel-glide sequence alternates or fails
to alternate with a sequence of vowels.
105
CHAPTER 7: POSTVOCALIC GLIDES AND POSTVOCALIC HIGH VOWELS
II ~I I
I
II ~I II ~I
X X X X X X X
I I I I I I I
I
~--l
I .l I
P t-.-r-+---------- ----
A+ 1°
(11 )
a. / \ / \
I w
I 1 s s W
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R b. 0 RI 0 R 0 R
I I I I I I I I t I I I
I I I I I I
N I I I I
I
N N I N N I N I N
II I
I
~
I
I
II I
I
II I
I
I
I
I
I \ II I
I
II I
I
X
I
X
I
X
I
X
I
X
I
X
I
xI --) x
I
xI xI x
I
xI xI X
I
J. I I I J.
I
k
I
a 1 p i r
I
a
I
k a 1
I
p !
1
I
r
I
a
A+ 1° A+ 1°
-4'
12 Recall that primary stress is lexically assigned (cf. Chapter 2).
Secondary and word level stress are assigned after phonological processes
apply. The final metrical structure is built onto derived forms. The
phonological expressions which appear below the segments associated to the
nuclear positions in (10) correspond to the internal representation of these
segments.
106
"' "
CHAPTER 7: POSTVOCALIC GLIDES AND POSTVOCALIC HIGH VOWELS
(12)
w
/'- s word tree level
~
I
I
S S w foot level
I I I
J. J. J.
R R R nuclear projection
I I I
I I I
0 R 0 R 0 R
I f I I I
I f I I I
I I
I N I N N
I I I
I I \ I
X X X X X X X
I I I I I
I I I I I
k a i p i r a
A+ 1°
Let us now consider the derivation of the form [kaipira] in which a sequence
of vowels (rather than a vowel-glide sequence) occurs. We have to explain why
in the process of deriving the form [kaipira] (from the lexical representation
illustrated in (10)), the pretonic nuclear posi tion filled wi th the high vowel
remains associated to a nuclear head position. This occurs rather than the
pretonic nuclear position filled with the high vowel being incorporated into
the structure of a branching nucleus (cf. (11)). We propose that in order to
allow a preton{c high vowel to occur as a nuclear head, the ATR element ++ is
added to the internal representation of th~ simplex charm ss segments [i,u].
Thus, yielding the positively charmed segments [i,u]. This process is 11
illustrated in (13).
(13) / \ / \
s w s w
a.O R 0 R 0 R 0 R b. 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
. I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I ,
I I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I I I
I N N N N I N N N I N
I
I
I
I
I
I ,
I I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
X X X X x· x X --> x X X X X X X
I I I f I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I I I I
k a i p i r a k a i p i r a
A+ 1° A+ 1° I
1+
+
In (13b) we have a sequence of adjacent nuclear positions where both nuclear
positions are filled with positively charmed segments, i.e. [i,a]. Given that
positively charmed segments cannot be governed (cf. Chapter 1), no governing
relation holds between the adjacent nuclear positions in (13). Thus, a
sequence of nuclear position is allowed to occur and a sequence of vowels is
107
CHAPTER 7: POSTVOCALIC GLIDES AND POSTVOCALIC HIGH VOWELS
w~s
(14 )
word tree level
1---- :~
s w s w foot level
I I I I
..!. I 1 I
R R R R nuclear projection
I I I I
1 I I I
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I I
I 1 I I I 1
I I
I N N I N N
I I I I I I
I I I I I 1
X X X X X X X
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
k a i p i r a
A+ 1°
I
1+
~
7.4. Conclusion
In this Chapter we have considered the derivation of forms which present
postvocalic glides, and forms which present postvocalic high vowels. We have
seen that whether a postvocalic glide or a postvocalic high vowel is
manifested depends on whether or not a left-headed internuclear governing
relation is established.
Cases in which a postvocalic glide occurs illustrate instances where a left-
headed internuclear governing relation is es..t,ablished, yielding a heavy
diphthong formation. Cases in which a postvocalic high vowel occurs illustrate
instances where a high vowel acquires the ATR element, appearing thus as a
positively charmed segment, Le. [i,u]. A sequence of adjacent nuclear
positions is allowed to occur since a positively charmed segment cannot be
governed. In the following Chapter we consider forms which present
intervocalic glides and forms which present a sequence of high vowels.
108
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES OF HIGH VOWELS
CHAPTER 8
INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES
OF HIGH VOWELS
8.0. Introduction
In this Chapter we will analyse forms in which a glide is flanked between two
vowels, e.g. [meja] 'half', and forms presenting sequences of high vowels. In
the first section we determine how intervocalic glides are phonologically
interpreted in BP. In the remaining sections we consider forms which present
sequences of high vowels, determining which of the high vowels in the sequence
may be phonetically manifested as a glide.
[ananidewa] 'Ananindeua (town)' [piawi] " [pjawi] 'Piaui (state) and [kawe]
I
the gender suffix vowel, i.e. the final vowel of the noun (cf. Chapter 3).
111
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES OF HIGH VOWELS
(3) a. 0 RO
1
N
,
N
R b. 0 R0
N
I
I
R
I
I
N
I
l\ I
I
I
X X X X X
I I I I
\
_ _.....
I
V 1°
I I
V V
I
It V
,- ... " .. , ..•..._.-......._.. .. _. -., .. _--- .. ', .....
The assumption that intervocalic palatal glides are derived from a nuclear
position filled with the element 1° accounts for the distribution of primary
stress in forms which present intervocalic glides. We have seen that BP does
not allow for antepenultimate stressed forms in which a posttonic palatal
glide occurs, Le. *[lakajii] and *[g6jaba]. The lack of antepenultimate
stressed forms presenting'posttonic intervocalic glides is accounted for by
assuming that the intervocalic glide corresponds to the element 1° lexically
associated to a nuclear head position.
Thus, in a form such as /lakaiu/ --) [lakaju] 'lackey' primary stress falls
on the nuclear position which immediately precedes the glide, because
otherwise stress would fall on the fourth-to-last nuclear position, Le.
112
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES OF HIGH VOWELS
S a 1 a s a 1 a
A+ 1° vo A+ 1° vo
I 1
I I
A+ A+
115
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES OF HIGH VOWELS
Ina governing domain one of the positions is the governor (or the head) and
the other -posi tion .is thegovernee (or the complement)._ The ~proper"ty _of .a
skeletal position to govern or to be governed is given by the charm value of
the segments which are linked to the skeletal positions.
We argued that the underlying representation of high vowels in BP corresponds
to the lax high vowels 1 and y - which are simplex charmless segments (cf.
Chapter 3). We have seen that simplex charmless segments may be governed by
positively charmed segments and complex charmless segments (cf. Chapter 1).
A charmless segment governs another charmless segment if it has a complexity
greater than its governee. That is, the charmless segment which has a greater
number of elements in its internal representation is' the governor. It follows
from this that neither of the simplex charmless segments 1 and g (which have
the same degree of complexity since their internal representation consists of
the elements 1° and UO respectively) should govern the other.
However,. as we will see in the following pages, a simplex charmless segment
may govern another simplex charmless segment. Evidence that this occurs
follows from light and heavy diphthong formation in BP. That is, whether a
prevocalic glide, i.e. a light diphthong, or a postvocalic glide, i.e. a heavy
diphthong, is manifested depends on the governing properties of the simplex
charmless segments 1 and y.
c. [siumera] 'jealousy'
d. [miudeza] Ilittleness'
Forms in (9a-b) illustrate cases in which a pretonic high back vowel is
immediately followed by a pretonic high front vowel, i.e. [ui]. Forms in (9c-
d) illustrate cases in which a pretonic high front vowel is immediately
followed by a pretonic high back vowel, i.e. [iu]. Forms in (9) have also the
following pronunciations:
116
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SBQUENCES OF BIGH VOWELS
b. / \
s w
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I 1 I I I
1 1 I 1 I 1 I
,I I I
I N N I N 1 N
I I 1 I I 1 I
I I I I I I I
X X X X X X X
I I I I 1 1 I
I I I I I 1 1
m i a d e z a
1° UO
Both adjacent pretonic nuclear positions in (11) are filled with a simplex
charmless segment, i.e. i/a. We have seen that pretonic nuclear heads must be
filled with a positively charmed segment (cf. Chapter 3). Therefore, the
pretonic nuclear positions in (11) should be filled with a positively charmed
segm~t, i.e. [i,u]. We propose that the ATR element is added to the internal
representation of one of the pretonic nuclear positions in (11) so that it is
filled with a positively charmed segment. When the far left pretonic nuclear
position in the sequence of adjacent nuclear positions is filled with a
positively charmed segment, a left-headed internuclear governing relation
holds. This is because the governing position filled with the positively
charmed segment governs the immediately following nuclear position which is
filled with a simplex charmless segment. A branching nucleus is formed. The
117
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES OF HIGH VOWELS
b. / \ / \
I
I ! s w s w
ORO R o R 0 R o R o R 0 R
I
I
I
I
f
I I
r I
I
I
I
I
I ,
I I
J
I
I
I
I
I N N : N N I
I N I
I N I
I N
I I I I
I
I I I I \ I
I I
I
I I
X X X X X X X --> X x X X X X X
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
f
I
I
I
I
I ,
I
m i ii d e z a m i ii d e Z a
When the far right pretonic nuclear position in the sequence of adjacent
nuclear positions is filled with a positively charmed segment, a right-headed
internuclear governing relation is established. This is because the nuclear
position filled with the positively charmed segment governs the immediately
preceding nuclear position which is filled with a simplex charmless segment.
A light diphthong is formed. Forms presenting pretonic glide-vowel sequences,
i.e. [~wizadii] and [mjudeza], are derived in (13).
(13)
a. I
/ \ / \
1 I s w s w
oI , o
R R
I
o
I
R
I
0
I
R
I
0
I
R
I
ORO
I I I
R
I
I N f
I I I I I N I I I I
Ir I
I
N
I
I
II ~I II ~I II I
I
II ~I II N
I
I
X X X X X X X --> X X X X X X
I
I
~
I
1
U
I
I
i
I
I
Z
I
I
a
I
I
d
I
1
U
I
I
~
L \.1
u
I
~
I
...~ d I I
1
U
118
.: .
b. / \ / \
I
1 I S W S W
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I
I N N I N I N I N I N I N
II I
I
I
I
II I
I
II I
I
II I
I
II I
I
I
I
I
I
X X X X X X X --> X X X X X X
I
I
m
J.
1
I
u
I
I
I
d
I
I
e z
I
I
a
I
I
m
I
I t1 \-u
I
I
d
I
I
e
I
I
z
I
I
a
1° u<>
I
1°
I
yo
- -_--i+__ ...., .,., ..... ,_. _.._..__..• _. ....1+_-_.-
--- ----_... __ ............. ,......... ,..•
When both adjacent pretonic nuclear positions are filled with positively
charmed segments, no governing relation holds (because positively charmed
segments cannot be governed). Forms presenting a pretonic sequence of vowels,
i.e. [~uizadu] and [miudeza], are derived in (14).
(14)
a. / \ b. / \
s w s w
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
f I I I. I I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I I I I I I
I I I I I
I N N I N I N f N N I N N
I I I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I I I
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
I I I I I I I f 1 I I I
I 1 I I I I I I I I I I
~ u i z a d u m i u d e z a
11:0 1° 1° yo
I I I I
I
1+ I I
...+ ... ...+ ...+
119
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES OF HIGH VOWELS
(16 ) a.
I
! I
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I I r
I I 1 I I 1 I
I I
N I N N I N N
I I I
I I I
X X X X X -->x x x X
I
I ,
I I
I
I
I
I
I ,
I I
1
I
/ \
I
S a b i a s a b i a
1° nO 1° nO
b.
I
! I
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I
I ,
I I
I
I
I
r
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I I I
I N I N N N I N
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
X X X X X -->x x x X
r I I I I f f f
I I I I I I I I / \
t e n a i t e n a i
nO 1° nO rO
In the governing domain illustrated in (16a) the high back vowel y governs the
high front vowel i. In the governing domain ill~strated in (16b) the high
front vowel i governs the high back vowel y. Given this, we predict that a
left-headed internuclear governing relation may also hold between posttonic
nuclear positions filled with high vowels. We have seen that the establishment
of a left-headed internuclear governing relation yields a heavy diphthong, so
that a vowel-glide sequence occurs (cf. (8». Therefore, the establishment of
a left-headed internuclear governing relation between posttonic nuclear
positions filled with a high vowel would yield vowel-glide sequences. Forms
such as [sabiw] and [tenuj] - which present posttonic vowel-glide sequences -
would illustrate cases in which a left-headed internuclear governing relation
holds between a posttonic sequence of high vowels.
Nevertheless, forms such as *[sabiw] and *[tenuj] do not occur in BP. The lack
-.
of-fo-rIlfs--pr-el;jelftili9'--p-osnbnn::--vbwel~grfde--seqllEmCeS is accounted-fC>r-bytl'fe---
fact that heavy diphthong nuclear heads must be filled either with a
positively charmed segment or with a complex charmless segment (c.f. Chapter
7) •
Posttonic nuclear heads filled with a high vowel in BP must be filled with the
simplex charmless segments 1 and y. This is to fulfil charm requirements which
define that posttonic nuclear heads must be filled with a charmless segment
(cf. Chapter 3). Being that the segments 1 and yare simplex and charmless
they are unable to head a heavy diphthong governing domain. Thus, we predict
that posttonic vowel-glide sequences should not occur in BP, i.e. [sabiw] and *
*[tenuj]. This is exactly the case.
In (16) we discussed the derivation of forms which present posttonlc sequences
of different high vowels. That is, one of the high vowels is back and the
other is front. Sequences of identical high vowels may also occur in BP.In
the following pages we will show that a posttonic sequence of identical high
vowels is realized as a single vowel. Let us then analyse sequences 0i
adjacent nuclear positions filled with identical high vowels. Consider (17).
(17) 0 R 0 R
,, ,.
I
N N
I I
I I
X X
I I
I I
i i
(17) presents a sequence of adjacent nuclear positions which are both filled
wi th the simplex charmless segment 1. Sequences of adjacent nuclear posi tions
are subject to government according to the governing properties of the
segments which occupy the adjacent nuclear positions. We have seen that a
nuclear position filled with the simplex charmless segment 1 may govern a
nuclear position filled with another simplex charmless segment, i.e. y (c.f.
(l6b». Let us assume that a nuclear position filled with t'he simplex
charmless segment 1 may also govern another nuclear position filled with the
simplex charmless segment 1. That is, the simplex charmless segment 1 governs
Jf N N
I
1 I
I
I
t X ---> x
I
1 I / \
···i - -i -
ii -
b. [miudii]
/ \ / \
s w s w
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I
I I
I N N N I N N N
I 1 I I I
I I I I I
X X X X x --> x x x x, X
I I I I I I I I
I I 1 I I I I I I
m i u d ii m i u d ii
1° !f, 1°
I
!f
I
I I
...1+ ...+ ...+
c. [swisa]
/ \ / \
! 5 W 5 W
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
,
1
I
I
1
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
·1
1
I I I I
N N N N N
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
X
I
I
X
I
I
....,
X
I
, X,
X
I I
-->x
I
I
x
/ \ 1
x
I
X
I
I
5 ii i 5 a s ii i s a
nO 1° nO 1°
I I
I I
...+ ...+
124
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES OF HIGH VOWELS
d. (mjlidii]
/ \ / \
! s w s w
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I I I I 1
I I I I 1 I I I I
I I I I
I N N I N I N I N
I I I I I· I I I I
I I I 1 I I I 1 I
X X X X X -->X X X X
I I I I I I
I I I I 1 I / \ II II
rn i u d· -0. -m . . i-u . d· ...0.
IO !f I O !f
I I
I
1+
J.+ J.
(23) a.
I
I !
S W
0 R 0 R 0 R
I I I I I
I I I I I
I
I N N I
I N
I I I I
I I I I \
X X X -->x x X
I I I I I
I I I I I
h i u h i u
rI
~ r
I
~
I
1+
~ +
b.
I
I ! / \
S W S W
0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 R
i\ I
I
I
I
I
I :\ i\ I
I
I
I
I
I \: N N N I
I \ N\ I
I N
I I I I I
I \ I I I \ \ I
X X X X X x ---) x x x x x X
I I I I I I I I I I
I I I I I I I I f r
f 1 u i d u f 1 u i d u
~ 1° ~ 1°
f I
I I
*+ ~
126
CHAPTER 8: INTERVOCALIC GLIDES AND SEQUENCES OF HIGH VOWELS
In (25) we have a sequence of adjacent nuclear positions where the far left
nuclear position (which is filled with the positively charmed segment !) has
. the property of governing the immediately following nuclear position (which
is filled with the simplex charmless segment y). Therefore, a governing
relation - more precisely a left-headed internuclear governing relation -
should hold between the adjacent nuclear positions in (25). This is not the
case.
The reasons why a governing relation does flot hold between the adjacent
nuclear positions in (25) are still obscure. What is important to mention
. .
is that such a property, i.e. a simplex charmless segment not governed by a
posi ti vely charmed segment, is restricted to sequences of adjacent. high
vowels. Forms presenting posttonic postvocalic glides where the glide is
8.3. Conclusion
In this Chapter we considered forms presenting intervocalic glides. We showed
that intervocalic palatal glides are derived from a nuclear position filled
with the simplex charmless segment [i]. We also considered forms presenting
a sequence of high vowels, and showed that whether a high vowel or a glide is
phonetically manifested depends on the governing relations established between
adjacent nuclear positions.
We have seen that the simplex charmless segment 1 may govern the simplex
charmless segment y and vice-versa (cf. [sabju] and [tenwi] in section 8.2.2).
Considering the definition of government, i.e. a binary, asymmetric relation
between adjacent positions~. we do not. expect a governing segment to be
governed. This is because if a given segment may either govern or be governed,
the aSYmmetric nature of government is violated. Further research is still
needed for a better understanding of the governing properties of simplex
charmless segments and the asymmetric nature of government. The process of
vowel-glide alternations presented in this Chapter aims to throw some light
on the distrussion of this issue.
CONCLUSION
In this thesis we have considered phonological phenomena involving nuclear
positions. Specifically, we considered vowel coalescence in BP with emphasis
on the processes of vowel-glide alternations. .
129
.: .
CONCLUSION
130
REFERENCES
131
Harris, J. & Kaye, J.D. (1988a). "A Tale of Two Cities: London Glottalling and
NYC Tapping". London Phonology Seminar. SOAS_
Harris, J. & J. KAYE. (1988b). "A Government-Based Approach to Lenition".
London Phonology Seminar. SOAS.
Harris, J. (1990). "Segmental Complexity and Phonological Government".
Phonology Yearbook 7.2. 255-300.
Head,B.F. (1964). A Comparison of the Segmental Phonology of Lisbon and Rio
de Janeiro. Ph.D. dissertation. Austin. Texas.
Istre, G.L. (1971). A Phonological Analysis of a Portuguese Dialect. Louisiana
State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College. Ph.D.
dissertation.
Jeroslow, E.H.M. (1974). Rural Cearense Portuguese: A Study of the Variety of
Non-standard Brazilian Speech. Ph.D. dissertation. Cornell University.
Kaye, J.D. (1982)."Harmony Processes in Vata". in The Structure of
Phonological Representations (Part II). H. van der Hulst & N. Smith
(eds). Foris Publications.
Kaye, J.D. (1985). "On the Syllable Structure of Certain West African
Languages". in D. Goyvaerts (ed.), African Linguistics: Essays in
Memory of M.W.K. Semikenke, 285-308. Amsterdam, J. Benjamins.
Kaye, J.D. (1989a). "Raddopiamento Sjntattico Norwegian Style". Paper
presented at the London Phonology Seminar. SOAS. London.
Kaye, J.D. (1989b) .. Phonology: a Cognitive.View Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,
Publishers. N.J.
Kaye, J.D. (1989c). ""Coda" Licensing".Phonology Yearbook:7.2. 301-330.
Kaye, J.D. (1989d). "On the Interaction of Theories of Lexic~l Phonology and
Theories of Phonological Phenomena". Phonologica 1988.
Kaye, J.D. (198ge). "Current Issues in Phonology". SOAS Lectures. London.
Kaye, J.D. (1990a). "Government in Phonology: The Case of Moroccan Arabic". The
Linguistic Review, 6: 131-160. "1986/1987" (1990).
Kaye, J.D. (ed). (1990b). Phonology Yearbook 7.2.
Kaye, J.D. & J. Lowenstamm (1984). "De la Syllabicite". in Forme sonore du
langage. F. Dell, D. Hirst et J .. -R. Vergnaud (eds.). Paris, Hermann.
Kaye, J.D., Lowenstamm, J. & J-R. Vergnaud (1985). "The Internal Structure of
Phonological Elements: A Theory of Charm and Government". Phonology
Yearbook 2 (1990). 305-328.
Kaye, J.D., Lowenstamm, J. & J.-R. Vergnaud. (1990). "Constituent Structure
and Government in Phonology". Phonology Yearbook. 7.2. 193-231.
132 . -
..... '
".-.
- :... ...:.:~~
Kaye, J.D. & J-R Vergnaud (1990). "On the Interaction of Theories of Lexical
Phonology and Theories of Phonological Phenomena" Paper presented at
GLOW -Cambridge. To appear in Phonologica 1988. Cambridge University
Press.
Kean, M.-L. (1974). "The Strict Cycle in Phonology". Linguistic Inguiry 5.
Kenstowicz, K. & J. Rubach. (1987). "The Phonology of Syllabic Nuclei in
Slovak". Language, 63. 463-497.
Leben, W. (1973). Suprasegmenta1 Phonology. Ph.D. dissertation. MIT.
,.
Lopez, B.S. (1979). The Sound Pattern of Brazilian Portuguese (Cariocan .......,~
Dialect). Ph.D. dissertation. University of California. Los Angeles.
Lowenstamm, J. (1986). "A Propos dtune Hypothese sur la Forme Primitive du
Type B en Amharique". in Revue Quebecoise de Linguistigue. 16. 157-180.
Madureira, E.D. (1987). Sobre as Condicoes da Voca1izacao da Lateral Palatal
no Portugues. Master Thesis. UFMG. Belo Horizonte.,-_
Maia, E.A. (1981). Hierarquias de Constituintes em Fonologia. Anais do V
Encontro Nacional de Linguistica. PUC. RJ.
'.
Major, R. (1985). Stress and Rhythm in Brazilian Portuguese. LanqUage~ 61,
Number 2.
Major, R (1981). Stress-timing in BP. Journal of Phonetics. Number 9.
Marota, G. (1978). The Italian Diphthongs and the Autosegmenta1 Framework. In
Bertinetto,P.M. and Loporcaro, M. (ed). Certamen Phonologicum. Papers
from the 1987 Cortona Phonological Meeting. Rosenberg and Sell ier.
Turin.
McCarthy, J. (1986). "OCP Effects: Gemination and Antigemination". Linguistic
Inquiry. Number 17.
Naro, A.J. (1971). "Resolution of the Vocalic Hiatus in Portuguese: Diachronic
Evidence .for.. .Binary Feat.ures" .• Language. Volume.A 7. Number 2..
Nunes, J.J. (1951). Compendio de Gramatica Hist6rica. 4. Editora Lisboa.
L~vraria Classica Editora.
Odden, D. (1988). "On the Obligatory Contour Principle". Language. Number 62.
Oliveira, M.A. (1983). "Phonological Variation and Change in Brazilian
Portuguese: The Case of the Liquids". Ph.D. Thesis. University of
Pennsylvania.
Redenbarger, W. J. (1976). Portuguese Vowel Height and the Phonological
Theory: A Generative Re-analysis Based on Tongue-root Features. Ph.D.
Harvard University.
Segundo, s.o. (1990) "On Empty Nuclei and Metrical Structure in Brazilian
Portuguese". SOAS Working Papers in Linguistics and Phonetics. Number
1. University of London.
133
·: .
134