Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Heissler 1994
Heissler 1994
0ncology
E. Heissler ~, H. J. Steinkamp 2,
Value of magnetic resonance 1". Heim 2, C. Zwicker 2, R. Felix 2,
J, Bier ~
Clinics for 1Maxillofacial Surgery and
imaging in staging carcinomas of 2Radiology, University Clinic Rudolf Virchow,
Free University of Berlin, Augustenburger
Platz 1, D-13344 Berlin, Germany
For determination of the most appropri- propriate evaluation and assessment of infiltration of vascular structures,
ate therapy for a squamous cell carci- the stage of the tumor is mandatory. It is nerves, and bone and to assess the ex-
noma (SCC) of the oral cavity, an ap- particularly important to assess possible tent of the tumor. It is also necessary to
M R I in oral c a r c i n o m a s 23
know whether a tumor in the oral cavity tected. Tumor distribution and the T classifi- curred upon administration of Gd-
crosses the midline, as this can signifi- cation can be seen in Tables 1 and 2. dTPA. The intrinsic tongue muscles (in-
cantly influence the choice of treatment ferior and superior longitudinal
and the prognosis s. Clinical examin- MRI examinations muscles, etc.) absorbed the contrast me-
ation alone is often inadequate. Accord- dium well ( + + ) ; the extrinsic muscles
ing to LENZ et al. s, a correct appraisal lmages were obtained from 46 patients at a of the tongue and floor of the m o u t h
full-body MRI unit (1.5 Tesla Magnetom,
of the t u m o r (T) stage attained by clin- (genioglossus muscle, hypoglossus
Siemens). A spin-echo image was made for
ical and endoscopic examination alone each patient. Tl-weighted images were done muscle, digastric muscle, stylohyoid
was m a d e in only 82/174 cases. This is in the 1.5 Tesla Magnetom with a repetition muscle) showed only low enhancement
an accuracy of only 47%. time (TR) of 500 ms and an echo time (TE) ( + ) (Fig. 4A). Healthy tonsil tissue,
With a claimed accuracy of of 15 ms. Proton density-weighted (TR: 2500 with a high blood flow, showed good
80°/o-90% 5'9'11, computerized tomo- and TE: 22) and T2-weighted (TR: 2500 and contrast medium absorption ( + + ) .
graphy (CT) has gained recognition as TE: 90) images were also made. The T1- Therefore, small tumors could not be
a noninvasive T-staging procedure for weighted scans (TR: 500 and TE: 15) were distinguished from healthy tissue after
diagnosing orofacial tumors. However, repeated after the application of contrast me- G d - d T P A administration.
dium with 0.1 mmol/1 gadolinium (Gd)-
errors in j u d g m e n t with C T frequently The blood vessels of the oral cavity
dTPA/kg body weight (Schering AG, Berlin,
result when metal artifacts are present; Germany). The imaging was performed in appeared only with weak signals. In the
for example, those caused by tooth fill- the axial, sagittal, and coronal planes with a body of the tongue, the lingual artery
ings, or when no distinction in radio- layer thickness of 6 mm. A 256 x 256 matrix was usually distinguishable.
density can be made between tumor and was used, with 1.2 x 1.2 mm picture points. The bony structures of the mandible
surrounding tissue 4'8'12. Muscle, particularly the sternocleidomas- and maxilla presented with varying sig-
Magnetic resonance imaging ( M R I ) toid muscle, and fat were used as a basis of nal intensity. Structures containing mar-
is a noninvasive tomographic method comparison for interpreting the MRI images row appeared as signal-intensive zones;
in regard to the signal density of the tumor. the cortex showed only faint signals
which, on the one hand, provides axial,
Only spin-echo sequences were used. The
sagittal, and coronal images, and, on (Fig. 1).
scans were assessed according to the follow-
the other hand, is not affected by arti- ing scale: The SCCs of the oral cavity com-
facts caused by tooth fillings 1'6'11 13 The I) hypointense relative to muscle prised carcinomas of the tongue ( n =
purpose o f this study is to determine 2) isointense relative to muscle 11), floor of the m o u t h ( n = 11), hard
whether M R I meets these requirements. 3) slightly hyperintense (+) relative to palate (n = 1) and alveolar process (n =
muscle 1). Tumors of the oropharynx orig-
4) hyperintense (+ +) relative to muscle inated in the base of the tongue ( n =
Patients and methods 5) very hyperintense ( + + + ) relative to 9), tonsils (n = 10), posterior pharyngeal
In 46 patients with proven SCC of the oral muscle. wall ( n = 1) and anterior surface of the
For evaluation, the MR images were as-
cavity or oropharynx, the T-stage findings soft palate including the uvula ( n = 1).
sessed by three clinicians. These results were
obtained with MRI were compared prospect- Table 3 shows the frequency of the cor-
compared with the results of the clinical
ively with those obtained through clinical and rect T-stage identification by clinical
examinations and the final histopathologic
endoscopic examination. To ensure objec- examination (including endoscopy), as
reports. The tumors were classified by the
tivity, we compared these findings with the
TNM system acording to the U I C C 7. compared with M R I and the histopath-
postoperative pathohistologic findings,
which classified the size and extent of the ologic results. Altogether, the correct T
tumor, according to the tumor-node-meta- stage was identified by M R I in 40/46
Results
stasis (TNM) system, as well as the number
and size (maximum diameter to transverse Topography
diameter) of lymph nodes. The histology of Table 2. T categories: oral cavity and oropha-
In the region o f the oral Cavity and the rynx
the primary SCC and lymph nodes was also oropharynx, muscle appeared with me-
described. Forty-two patients were surgically TI: tumor measures at its maximum diam-
dium signal intensity, with individual
treated, including local resection along with eter 2 cm or less
neck dissection. The postmortem results for muscle tracts separately distinguishable
T2: tumor measures at its maximum diam-
four patients with extensive T4 tumors were because of the fat and fascial tissue sur- eter more than 2 cm but not more than
incorporated into the study. In the 46 pa- rounding each tract. In the tongue, a 4 cm
tients, SCC of varying degrees could be de- diverse signal intensity increase o c - T3: tumor measures at its maximum diam-
eter more than 4 cm
T4: tumor infiltrating neighboring structures
Table 1. Primary tumor location in 46 oral cavity and oropharynx carcinomas examined by
MRI
Table 3. Comparison of correct identification
Tumor Primary location Number of patients
of T stage achieved by clinical examination
Oral cavity Body of tongue 11 (CE) and MRI with histopathologic results
(n = 24) Floor of mouth 1l
T stage CE MRI Histology
Alveolar process 1
Hard palate 1 T1 3 2 4
T2 10 9 12
Oropharynx Ton sils 10
T3 15 19 20
(n = 22) Base of tongue 9
T4 8 10 10
Soft palate 2
Posterior wall of oropharynx 1 Totals 36 (78%) 40 (87%) 46
24 Heissler et al.
Table 4. T stages wrongly identified by MRI gions of the intrinsic tongue muscles
Patient T stage CE T stage MRI T stage pathology Deviation of MRI and the tonsils, led, in the case of seven
patients, to an overestimation of tumor
L.S. T1 TO Tl - Superficial tumor (tonsil)
L.G. T1 T2 T1 + Tumor spread > 2 cm size in the axial, sagittal, and coronal
H.M. T2 T3 T2 + Tumor spread > 4 cm planes. Thus, there was more than a l-
L.J. T2 T3 T2 + Depth of infiltration >4 cm cm difference in size from the tumor size
RG. T3 T3 T2 + Carcinoma in base of tongue found in the histopathologic specimen.
with probable infiltration of In six cases, the T2-weighted se-
posterior wall of pharynx quences did not show the high signal
R.S. T3 T4 T3 + Tongue carcinoma with (Fig. 2) intensity ( + + ) expected in the
massive depth of tumor (Fig. 4B). However, the tumor
infiltration still appeared in these cases as clearly
CE = clinical examination. hyperintensive ( + ) relative to the
+ = additional tumor infiltration found by MRI. musculature. Particularly with the tonsil
= structures not picked up by MRI but shown by pathologic findings. tumors (n = 7), the tumor in four cases
could not be clearly identified because
of the increased signal intensity of the
cases (87%), but by clinical examination the oropharyngeal tongue base ap- healthy tonsil tissue. In this situation,
and endoscopy in only 36/46 cases peared to be present on the same side the tumor had to be diagnosed from
(78%). By analysis according to the indi- on MRI. This was not confirmed, either the indirect evidence mentioned earlier.
vidual T1 T4 stages, it can be seen that intraoperatively or in the pathologic Clear demarcation of the tumor area
clinical examination gives poorer results findings of the tissue removed during was visible in the T2-weighted sequence
in the T3 and T4 stages (23/30) than operation. in 38/46 cases - more so than in the
MRI (29/30). On the other hand, clin- All T4 tumors were correctly iden- Gd-dTPA-supported, Tl-weighted se-
ical examination (13/16) showed better tified by MRI. Whereas clinical examin- quence (Figs. 2, 4B). In the T2-weighted
results in the stages T1 and T2 than ation was more effective in identifying sequence, considerable overestimation
MRI (11/16). the stages T1 and T2, 7/30 T3/T4 tu- of tumor size occurred because of in-
Table 4 shows the T stages wrongly mors were incorrectly graded clinically. flammation and adjacent swelling i n
classified by MRI. MRI correctly In all cases, the stage of the tumor was neighboring tissuel
graded only two T1 tumors. One T1 underestimated. The proton-density images show a
tumor was diagnosed as a T2 tumor MRI can present the depth of infil- slight hyperintensity ( + ) of the tumor
because the tumor size was described as tration of the tumor clearly because of in relation to muscle (Fig. 1C). Al-
gr~eater than 2 cm. However, the patho- its good soft-tissue contrast, particu- though ~he proton-density images
logic and endoscopic findings revealed larly after Gd-dTPA administration. yielded no additional information, they
a tumor with a maximum size less than The MRI multiplane imaging presents did give sati~fact.ory contrast with the
2 cm. a relatively accurate picture of tumor tumor, fat, muscle, and other structures.
A superficial T1 tonsil tumor was not extension (Figs. I ~ D ) . Anatomic relationships were easily dis-
recognized on MRI because the tumor cernible. The good presentation of bone
could not be distinguished from the structures in this sequence is noteworthy
Value of examination sequences
healthy lymphatic tonsil tissue sur- (Fig. 1C).
rounding it, either after Gd-dTPA ad- Native Tl-weighted examination pro-
ministration or in the T2-weighted se- duced good tumor-fat contrast (Fig.
Image planes
quence. 1A), but it did not allow sufficient dis-
With all three incorrectly graded T2 tinction of the tumor from surrounding MRI allows the presentation of the oral
tumors, the T stage was graded too high muscle and blood vessels. Relative to cavity and oropharynx in the axial, cor-
(Table 4). Particularly in the T2- muscle, SCCs appeared to vary from onal, and sagittal planes. For carci-
weighted sequence, tumor volume in slightly hypointense to isointense. nomas of the tongue and the floor of
one case was estimated too high because In only 36/46 cases did Gd-dTPA- the mouth, images in both the axial and
of the nondistinction between tumor aided, Tl-weighted sequences provide the coronal planes are indispensable.
and accompanying inflammation. After adequate tumor identification and clear These make it possible to detect or dis-
the administration of Gd-dTPA, how- demarcation from muscle, blood ves- count tumor extension across the mid-
ever, the edema was seen as a hypointen- sels, and bone structures. In 34/46 line, in order to select the appropriate
sive structure which could then be dis- cases, the tumors showed heterogeneous therapy (Figs. 1D, 3, 4). The coronal
tinguished from the hyperintensive tu- contrast medium uptake. These were all scan is particularly suited for judging
mor area. Nevertheless, after Gd-dTPA hyperintense ( + - + + ) in relation to the the craniocaudal extent of tumors of the
administration, the tumor was insuf- muscle (Fig. 1B). Within the richly vas- tonsils.
ficiently distinguishable from the neigh- cularized, contrast-medium-absorbent In our series, sagittal and axial scans
boring tissue in 8/46 cases; thus, only tumor tissue, tumor necrosis was seen have proved to be very useful for the
by the T2-weighted examination could as hypointensive structures (Fig. 1B). In detection of oropharyngeal carcinomas,
the tumor be unambiguously dis- 8/46 cases, the tumor showed no signifi- as they reveal any infiltration of the epi-
tinguished from adjacent structures. cantly increased concentration over the glottis, the preepiglottal soft tissue, and
In the case of the wrongly classified surrounding tissue. The absorption of the hypopharynx. Axial imaging is es-
T3 tongue tumor, further infiltration of contrast medium, particularly in the re- sential, as it allows assessment of poss-
M R I in oral carcinomas 25
Fig. 2. Forty-two-year-old patient with cervical swelling noticed 3 weeks previously. MRI: T2-weighted native examination. Clear hyperintensity
is seen in tumorous mass in right side of floor of oral cavity (arrows). However, there is no infiltration or restriction of oropharynx. T2 stage.
T stage identified by pathologic findings after operation: T2.
Fig. 3. Demonstration of T2 tumor of right tongue in enhanced Tl-weighted MRI: after administration of Gd-dTPA, in coronal scan there
is clear demarcation of tumor (broad arrowheads) as hyperintensive structure in posterior third of tongue without exceeding midline (thin
arrow).
tumors, a stronger increase o f signals necrotic tumor, because of their nonper- which do not absorb contrast medium,
than the surrounding area 16. fusion, appear as hypointense (Figs. 1B and tumor recurrence, which shows
However, tumor absorption of con- and 5). Contrast medium also allows marked enhancement 8.
trast medium is not uniform. Areas o f distinction between scarred structures, Tumors of the tonsils often show no