Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nguyen Nhat Nhan - s3480570
Nguyen Nhat Nhan - s3480570
Semester 1, 2019
expand their business worldwide. Base on the industrial production index and
and talented labor market. By recognizing that, many MNCs are establishing the
British technology company that eager to take those benefits by planning to move
1. Introduction..........................................................................................................4
2. Brief background.................................................................................................4
3. Main arguments................................................................................................... 5
3.1.1.Labor market......................................................................................................5
3.1.2.Legal factors.......................................................................................................6
b. Corporatetax ..............................................................................................6
3.2.1.Labor market......................................................................................................7
3.2.2.Legal factors.......................................................................................................8
b. Corporate tax..............................................................................................8
4. Conclusion........................................................................................................... 9
5. Reference list....................................................................................................... 9
1. Introduction
This report will address the overview of Asia as the centre of consumption and
production in the globe. To elaborate, this report will identify some key figures about
Asian outlook, including population, production output, regional GDP and
expenditure in 2018. Then, it will demonstrate some key findings about the labor
market and legal factors in comparison between Singapore and Hong Kong, in order
for SMEs to consider in the process of relocating their regional headquarters.
2. Brief background
At the end of 2018, the industrial production index of emerging and developing Asia
and Asia Pacific were estimated at 161.2 and 150.8, whereas the industrial
production index of Western European and Eastern European countries was
estimated at 115.9 and 135.3 (RMIT Euromonitor n.d.). This indicates that Asia is
considered as the center of production in the world. According to RMIT Euromonitor
(n.d.), the total consumer expenditure in Asia Pacific and developing Asia was
roughly 21.9 trillion USD, which nearly doubled the total European consumer
expenditure – 12.1 trillion USD in 2018. This indicates that Asia is considered as the
center of consumption in the world.
Base on the above information, MNCs should move their headquarters to Asia to
take the advantages of the region’s economy. Dyson is the British technology
company which was founded in July 1991, under the name Barleta Ltd. From
September 1991 to January 2001, Barleta Ltd changed its name to Dyson
Appliances Limited. Since then, Dyson Appliances Limited has been renamed as
Dyson Limited (Companies House n.d.).The company is manufacturing and trading
variety of household appliances, including hair care, vacuum cleaners, hand dryers,
fans and purifier fan. Recently, Dyson has its operation in over 65 countries with over
1,000 engineers around the globe (Dyson n.d.). In the first quarter of 2019, Dyson
has moved the majority of its production headquarter to Singapore (Neate 2019). In
addition, Dyson (cited in Pratley 2019) has proposed that the company will move
their head office to Singapore in the future.
3. Main arguments
There are two main countries in Asia where responsible for different parts of Asia
that MNCs should take into consideration when relocating their regional
headquarters. The research found by Perry et al. (2001) asserted that while the
regional headquarters in Singapore are responsible to manage subsidiaries in South-
East Asia, the regional headquarters in Hong Kong are responsible to control
subsidiaries in East Asia.
European Chamber & RolandBerger (2011) found that Singapore was one of the
most developed and attractive nations in Asia Pacific in several key criteria, such as
legal environment, business environment, tax environment and access to talent.
a. Literacy rate
The literacy rate among Singapore’s residents- aged over 15 years old account for
more than 97% of the total population in 2018.Among those literate residents, the
total numbers of Singaporeans who have graduated from university were estimated
at 908,700 people in 2018 – occupied 16.2% of the total literate people (Singapore
Department of Statistics 2019).For those university graduates, more than 80% get
the full-time permanent jobs with monthly salary exceeding $3000 in 2017 (Ministry
of Education 2019). Although there are a small proportion of university graduates in
Singapore, the quality of graduation outcomes is remained high.
b. Employment rate
According to RMIT Euromonitor (n.d.), Singapore employment rate in 2017 was
remained at a higher rate– 81.1%, compared to other countries in the region such as
Japan – 75.3%, China – 75.7%, and Vietnam – 77.2%. Due to the high quality of
university graduation outcomes, the quality of employed persons in Singapore’s
labor market is significantly high. To further explain, among those Singapore
employed persons, 56.1% are working in the top-ranking positions such as
professionals, managers, executives and technicians in 2017 (Cheng 2017).
Base on the above statistics, Singapore is the country where has a huge
number of educated and skillful workers, where can provide Dyson a lot of
benefits when relocating their head offices to.
All of the imported goods that used directly for Singapore’s local consumption must
be levied on Singapore’s current tax rate of 7% (Singapore Customs 2015). In
comparison with other Asian countries, the imported tax of Singapore is lowered than
China - 9.3% (Government of Canada 2018), Japan – 8% (Japan Customs n.d), and
Thailand – 8% (Societe Generale 2019). Nevertheless, due to the Free Trade
Agreement (FTA), Singapore has exempted 99% of imported tax for all imported
goods from the ASEAN country members, excluded wine, tobacco products, motor
vehicles and petroleum products (International Trade Administration 2018).
Secondly, Singapore Customs (2019) has mentioned that ‘goods exported from
Singapore are not subjected to Goods and Services Tax’. Therefore, by moving the
regional headquarters to Singapore, Dyson can take the tax advantages when export
and import goods from other countries in Asia.
b. Corporate tax
Firstly, the corporate tax of Singapore is setting at 17% in 2019, which rank in the
middle compared to the countries with highest and lowest corporate taxes in the
region. For example, the Asian country with the highest corporate tax in 2019 is India
– 35%, follow by United Arab Emirates with the lowest corporate taxes in 2019 – 0%
(Trading Economics n.d.).
Secondly, the newly established enterprises in Singapore also benefit from corporate
tax incentives. To further explain, there is 75% tax exemption applying for the first
$10,000 of corporate income and 50% tax reduction applying for the next $290,000
of corporate revenue (KPMG 2018).
Finally, there are several tax incentives applying for payments to the enterprise’s
expatriates in Singapore. For example, there is 22% of corporate taxis exempted for
payment of company director’s remuneration, followed by 17% reduction of
corporate tax forpayment of management, technical assistance, and service fees
(KPMG 2018).
European Chamber & RolandBerger (2011) found that Hong Kong was considered
as an attractive country for relocation of regional headquarters through some key
criteria, including business environment, legal environment, and highly competitive
corporate tax rate.
3.2.1. Labor market
According to RMIT Euromonitor (n.d.), Hong Kong employment rate in 2018 was
remained at a high level – 70.3%, compared to other countries in the region such as
Philippines – 58.1%, Malaysia – 65.9%, and Thailand – 73.3%. Among those Hong
Kong employed persons, 46.6% are working in financial services, tourism, trading
and logistics, and professional services, which are the four key industries of Hong
Kong (Census and Statistics Department 2018). On the other hand, the report from
ManpowerGroup (cited in South China Morning Post n.d.) states that there still be a
shortage in skilled labor supply in Hong Kong’s labor market, especially in sale
department, engineering department, and information technology department. Due to
the skilled labor deficit, the government of Hong Kong has issued the ‘Talent List’
containing 11 in-demand professions that are essential for the economic
development of the country (Hong Kong Business 2018).
Despite the fact that Hong Kong has high employment rate in 2018 compared to
other Asian countries, there still be a shortage in skilled labor supply in the labor
market.
b. Corporate tax
At the end of 2018, the corporate tax of Hong Kong was setting at 16.5%, which
significantly lower than other potential countries in the region. To elaborate, in 2019;
the corporate taxes of Japan are 30.86%, followed by China – 25%, Vietnam – 20%,
and Singapore – 17% (Trading Economics n.d.). In addition, through the government
taxation policies for national economic development, the corporate tax is being
reduced by a half to 8.25% for the first HK$2 million of profit (KPMG 2018). Thus, by
moving the regional headquarters to Hong Kong, Dyson can save a huge amount of
tax expenses for their business activities.
4. Conclusion
In conclusion, Singapore and Hong Kong are the two potential countries that Dyson
should take into consideration when relocating their regional headquarters to Asia.
Both Singapore and Hong Kong are the two countries where providing tax incentives
for import/export and corporate tax payment. In contrast, while Singapore and Hong
Kong are having high employment rate in the region, there still be a shortage in
skilled labor supply in Hong Kong’s labor market. Therefore, Dyson should take that
problem into consideration by using both parent countries nationals and host country
nationals when relocating their headquarters to Hong Kong.
5. Reference list
Census and Statistics Department 2018, ‘The Four Key Industries and Other
Selected Industries’, Census and Statistics Department, viewed 25 March 2019,
<https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp80.jsp?
tableID=191&ID=0&productType=8>
Cheng, K 2017, ‘Locals form about 75% of PMET employment growth over last
3 years: Swee Say’, TODAY, Mediacorp Press Ltd., 06 November, viewed 22
March 2019, <https://www.todayonline.com/singapore/locals-form-about-75-
pmet-employment-growth-over-last-3-years-swee-say>
Japan Customs n.d., ‘Outline of Tariff and Duty Rates System’, Japan Customs,
viewed 24 March 2019,
<http://www.customs.go.jp/english/summary/tariff.htm#c_consumption_tax >
KPMG 2018, ‘Hong Kong introduces two tiered profits tax rate marking a push
towards a more competitive tax environment’, Hong Kong Tax Alert, January,
no. 1, pp. 1-5.
KPMG 2018, ‘Singapore Tax Facts 2018 – Corporate Tax’, Singapore Tax
Facts 2018, July, p. 1.
Pratley, N 2019, ‘Come on Sir James, future-proof Dyson against what?’, The
Guardian, viewed on 31 March 2019,
<https://www.theguardian.com/business/nils-pratley-on-finance/2019/jan/22/
come-on-mr-dyson-future-proof-your-company-against-what>
South China Morning Post n.d., ‘Hong Kong third-hardest place in the world to
find skilled workers: report’, South China Morning Post, viewed 25 March 2019,
<https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/economy/article/1846149/hong-kong-
third-hardest-place-world-find-skilled-workers>
TMF Group 2018, ‘Hong Kong: Importing And Exporting Rules And Regulations
In Hong Kong’, mondaq, viewed 25 March 2019,
<http://www.mondaq.com/hongkong/x/691946/Export+controls+Trade+Investm
ent+Sanctions/
Importing+and+exporting+rules+and+regulations+in+Hong+Kong>
Trade and Industry Department 2018, ‘The European Union And Hong Kong
Some Important Facts’, Trade and Industry Department, viewed 23 March
2019,
<https://www.tid.gov.hk/english/aboutus/publications/factsheet/eu.html>
Executive Summary
Vandenberg & Trinh’s research (cited in Vandenberg et al. 2016) showed that 97%
of the Asian enterprises are represented by SMEs. This indicates that SMEs are
high employment rate and GDP generation. For employment, SMEs accounted 96%
of the total employed person in the region. For region’s GDP, SMEs contributed 30%
- 50% of the total GDP in the region. Secondly, SMEs play a significant role in
Base on the above figures, Asian SMEs are considered as the cornerstone of Asia
Table of Contents
1. Introduction........................................................................................................19
2. Brief background...............................................................................................20
3. Main arguments................................................................................................. 20
5. Reference list..................................................................................................... 24
1. Introduction
This report will address the overview of SMEs as the cornerstone of business and
employment in Asia. To elaborate, this report will identify the main contributions of
Asian SMEs to the regional employments and GDP. Then, it will demonstrate the
roles of Asian SMEs in the development of international business and trades.
2. Brief background
In 2018; there was a trade surplus for Asian economy in goods traded between Asia
and United States. According to Census Bureau (n.d.), while Asian enterprises
imported totally 509 billion USD of goods from United States in 2018, there were
over 1.1 trillion USD of goods exported from Asian enterprises to the US market.
Through the high merchandise trade volume between US and Asian nations, Asian
SMEs are playing an important role in enhancing the international business and
trade growth among regions.
3. Main arguments
3.1. SMEs contribute to the Asian economic development
To begin with, the employment rate in Asia is estimated at approximately 65% of the
total population in 2018. Specifically, Vietnam’s employment rate occupied 77.4% of
the country’s population, followed by Malaysia – 65.9% and Philippines – 58.1% in
2018 (RMIT Euromonitor n.d.). To elaborate, the survey from Asian Development
Bank (cited in Yoshino &Hesary 2018) has demonstrated that 96% of the employed
persons in the region are employed by SMEs.
Secondly, Asian SMEs also contribute intensively to the future job creation in the
Asia’s labor market. Business & Sustainable Development Commission (cited in HR
In Asia 2017) predicted that230 million jobs in Asia will be created by Asian
enterprises by 2030.
This indicates that Asian SMEs are playing a key role in contribution not only to
the employment in the region, but also in the global labor market.
As clearly stated above that 96% of the employees in Asia are employed by SMEs,
which means that SMEs have contributed heavily to Asian’s GDP. According to
Vandenberg & Trinh (cited in Vandenberg et al. 2016), SMEs made up from 30% to
50% of the region’s GDP. Particularly, in Vietnam, SMEs has created 1.2 million jobs
which contribute over 40% of the country’s GDP (Ministry of Finance, cited in Viet
Nam News 2019). The high amount of GDP contribution from SMEs is due to the
reason that there was an increase in worker’s wages among those firms.
International Labour Organization (2017) reports that the full-time permanent
workers who have been provided formal training from SMEs, are having 14% higher
wages.
For direct share of exports, SMEsin Developing Asia accounted for 8.7% of the total
manufacturing sales among developing regions (World Trade Report 2016).
For indirect share of exports, SMEs in Developing Asia accounted for 3.7% of the
total manufacturing sales exported indirectly among developing regions (World
Trade Report 2016).
Overall, Asian SMEs are playing a key role in contribution to the development of
international business and trade around the globe.
4. Topic Conclusion
To sum up, SMEs play a significant role for business and employment in Asia. For
regional economy, SMEs account mostly for both employment ad regional GDP
generation. For international trade, SMEs contribute significantly to the regional GDP
through exportation. It is clear that SMEs are playing an important role for the growth
of international business and trade around the globe.
5. Reference list
APEC Securities 2015, VIETNAM CONTAINER SHIPPING CORPORATION,
APEC Securities, viewed 31 March 2019, APEC database.
Fact-Link 2018, ‘Company Profile’, VIETNAM CONTAINER SHIPPING
CORPORATION, viewed 31 March 2019,
<https://www.fact-link.com.vn/mem_profile.php?
id=00000292&page=00000366&lang=en>.
HR In Asia 2017, ‘Businesses in Asia Poised for Growth, To Create 230mn Jobs
by 2030’, HR In Asia, 8 June, viewed 31 March 2019,
<http://www.hrinasia.com/news/businesses-in-asia-poised-for-growth-to-create-
230mn-jobs-by-2030/>.
Nhan Dan Online 2013, ‘Ten Vietnamese companies among Asia’s best SMEs’,
Nhan Dan Online, August 5, viewed 29 March 2019,
<http://en.nhandan.org.vn/business/companies/item/1912102-ten-vietnamese-
companies-among-asia%E2%80%99s-best-smes.html>.
Reddington, K 2018, Global is the new local: How small businesses in Asia are
harnessing technology to drive exports worldwide, FedEx Business Insights, 12
July, viewed 30 March 2019, <http://fedexbusinessinsights.com/en/sme/asias-
smes-are-harnessing-technology-to-drive-exports-worldwide/>.
Reddington, K 2018, ‘Global is the new local: How small businesses in Asia are
harnessing technology to drive exports worldwide’, Supply Chain Asia, 6 August,
viewed 28 March 2019, <http://supplychainasia.org/global-new-local-small-
businesses-asia-harnessing-technology-drive-exports-worldwide/>.
RMIT Euromonitor n.d., ‘Economies and Consumers Annual Data’, Passport,
viewed 27 March 2019
VICONSHIP n.d., About Us, homepage, VICONSHIP, Hai Phong City, viewed
31 March 2019, <http://www.viconship.com/en/about>.
Viet Nam News 2019, ‘Ministry proposes lowering CIT for SMEs’, Viet Nam
News, 28 March, viewed 30 March 2019,
<https://vietnamnews.vn/economy/507898/ministry-proposes-lowering-cit-for-
smes.html#0ddT9vMA5d09mOVO.97>
World Trade Report 2016, ‘SMEs in international trade: stylized facts’, World
Trade Report, pp. 1-28.