OT3bIB HA JJMCCEPTALMIO BATAEBA BJIAMMMMPA AXCAPOBHYA, [IPEJI- CTABJIEHHYIO HA COMCKAHVME YYEHOM CTEMEHU KAHJIMJIATA IOPHMUE- CKHX HAYK B COBET Jf 212.232.04 TO 3AIJMTE JIOKTOPCKMX MW KAHJIMJIAT- CKMX JMCCEPTALMM TPH CAHKT-IIETEPBYPTCKOM TOCYJ]APCTBEHHOM ‘YHHBEPCHTETE, HA TEMY «(IPHOBPETEHHE HEJIBHOKAMOLO MMYLIECT- BA 110 JABHOCTH BJIAJEHHA 110 POCCHIICKOMY HM ABT JIMMCKOMY TIPA- BY» (CTI6., 2014. 224 c.) Sammra zMecepraniin HasHaseta Ha 27 HosGps 2014 r. (Orsorp zai na snexrporttsii paprtarrr aicceprauian http //spbu rw/disser2/disser/Bagaev.Dissert pdf e-mail intlaw@jurfak.spb.ru nouTosbtii agpec 199034, Cankr-Merep6ypr, 22 mss B.O. 11.7 C nueumedi cropoubi aliccepranmontioe coumHerme Baanummpa Axcaposiaa Baraesa ompevaer TpeGORAHHAM, Npe/TBARILIeMBIM K akaleMHUeCKM pa6oTaM COOTBETETEYIOLLeTO YPOB- a, Yucnias crerieHs KaRMMara H joke CTeMTeH JOKTOpa iOpILINIeCKHX Hayk IIpHCy ANAC aB- ‘TopaM, KOTOPEIe KAK CBOH COGCTHEHHGIe SAILIALIKLIT BbICKAIAHHIe IPyTHMH WIeH, KOTOpHIE ce- ToaHA He OSraIAIOT KaKOH-NHGO HOBHSHO!L. OjHAKO CTeneHH HM BCE 2 MPHCYATEHBI H TON ‘TRepxyeHB! Baicmieli arrecraumoHHoit KoMuccHeli. [ostomy OyseT HenpaBILIBHBIM OTKasaTS B ncKomoi crenenm Baaaumupy Axcapomsy Baraey. JIuccepraniio ero npoects no.testi0. Onwerum xocronnersa paGorst Heeworps Ha 10, ro axrilicxuii mucrutyr adverse possession ve BocxomuT k prMCKOt yayxamun (usucapio), Baaauvmp Axcapopis Baraen riepenomurr adverse possession TepMuviont npuofpemamenoiaa dasHocm, coobILas, OMaKO, 4TO alIuIiickHe 1OpHCTSI KOHTHHEHTANBHYtO Tphobperaremsiyto aBHOCTS HMeHYIOT acquisitive prescription, Agrop noguepkuBaeT KOHLIeT- ryambHoe pasiuane Mexkny adverse possession W npuodpemamenonoti Oasnocmoio. Kornenry- aIbHOe pa3miTHe, yTBEpATaeT COHCKATENIB, Hevaer cpanHenve Gone HATepecHBIM. CpaBHenHe OSMOXKHO, ronopuT B. A. Baraes, nockombky HHCTHTyTHI BEINOMEMCT OMBY GYEKUTTO.Sto oven nepenexHpHbtii MpHeM, HOCKOIBKY 2KHA H OGOBHMLA BEITOMESOT ony Gymnayn0, nposmnuor sa6ory 1 BHHMAHNE K XOSAHHY, TO MOxHO cMeNO HasEIBATE sHOGORKHIY 2xeHOl, a KeHY moGoBHHelt. Tak Goce mrtepecto. Konesto xe, 270 ommOxa, 1locKObKY, (pYHKIINH KeHBI He COBNANOT c YHKIIMIE s10- Gosnmuts, Vi scaxnli pas, Korma Thi morraciisex cuuTaTs 2KeHy mOGoBHALel, a MOGOBHAY —xe- ‘Hii, BOSHHKaIOT 3aMeuaHHs, Ho B uaysinx nen, Haneprioe, TAKHIM NpHEMOM MOXKHO MOM2OBATKCH, OCOGeHHO, B Tpy- aX 110 cpaBHTTeMMbHOMY NpaRoBeeHINO H MCTOpHKO-TPADOBLIX COUMHEHHSR: HMeHOBATS LBIraHt- Koro 6apora — 6aporioM. VW sosnkator 3ameyanns. 3ameyanua OTHOCHTeIbHO TesHCOB. He o6nanas onsrrom nparraeckoii paGorsi B CoueTaHHH ¢ Xopomteli TOITOTORKOH B O6- snacTH rocysaperseHHioli perveTpANIN Mpan Ha HesIIKHMOe HMYLNECTEO, He BOSBMYCD CYT 06 OpHIMHAIBHOCTH, HOBIEIHe Hi HaysHO!t sHasmocrH TeaucoB, KoTopHie Buaaumup Axcaposme Baraes npererapnt na sanyrry. Ho ect sameuanna. Tlepssili reac Kacaetea onpasmenesmst pernictpanionlibnx Moneseit (aBrop mx uMeHyeT cnicremam) va nosmTHBHble H HeraruBHLte. CouckareNs oTcTaHRAET NOSHUMIO, COrtacHO KOTO- Poli “npH oueHKe CTeNEHH HayeoKHOCTH saperucTPHpORAHHBIX [Ipab B MOMTHBHIX cHCTeMAX He- O6xonHMO YHTBIRATS OcHOBAHHA Jui HeTpaBeHHa peectpar (c. 9 amecepramum). ‘ro HaNOME- act APY KecKuii Cover, a ne Tesuc, nperenzyionsuii Ha HaysHocTs. JIpyxxeckuii coner, KoTOpstit Baayummp Axeaponiy Baraen jaer cnenpamicry, KoTopbtii zamuMaetes devo —Oumidorcene, 10 CT OMeHHBAeT JUIN HYBOPHINe!! HHBECTAIIUOHHEIe pricKH pH NpHOGpeTeHME HeNBHAEIMOCTH B Aura. Hyxcnaeres st anramiicxuti wopucr B Takom conere? Yro ects dctenienb HaexocriDy? B.A. Baraes npexynperkaer, 470 arnuiickas perucrpanyonnas cucrema cunTaetes TosuTHB- Holi, Ho B Heli or maMeriers peectpa no oMIMOKe SANIUIINeHBI AMINE HexoTOpEle OGpocoRECrIe Brarenbubl, Spsleres JIM ITOT TesHe HOBBIM JIA au-MulicKHX YopHCTOR?Omnocutessi0 rpersero Tesrica (¢. 9-10 jyeceprarwm) Hao crpocus y axttopa, He BLA eTea JI Tperuit TesHe OOuleNPHUSITHIM [List aNTAniicKoil surrepatypss no real property, Ist cTpanu, na Koropsrx onuesraeren adverse possession? 3amesanns otHociTenbHo meroxa Bo pene asrop oGeuaer Hcriom30RaTS epastHTeNsHO TpaBonoi! NeTON H 31k 2Ke KOHCTATHpyeT, 4TO OOIeNpUsHAHAbIX H Hay4HO OGOCHOBAHHBIX TIOZXOTOR K cpaBHeHHro mpaBo- Bux cnicTeM He cymectayet (c. 8 amecepranum). Bostinkaer neppssit nompoc, Kaku o6pasom as ‘Top Henonsayer cpanHiTensHo-npaBosoit MeToR, ecII He CytecTayeT OOUIeMpHaHAKHOTO HHA YaHo OGocHOBAHHOTO HloHUMAHEA Toro, $10 370 3a MeTo;? B omer Baaaumup Axeaposua Baraer ronopir, uo nomsyeres tpamHuHOHnol! Moe bio, «aIpesimonaraouyas HOOMepemHoe OLCAHHe peryaMpORAHHA B KAKO! HB Crpalt Ht Tlocme- Aytontee mx cpannerey (c. 8 quceepranu). Hi ornera exeayer, 4ro aBrop He BuluT past UbI Me*KIly HayaHBIM MerouoM H MeToqoM dbuKeaumn / HT0‘eHHA / onHeaHHA xoxa (alro~ PHTMa) Heene{ORAHMA H AOCTHTHYTEIX pesy1bTATOB. Yb auccepranwionnsn uecnezoRanuii pasnsix covcKateneli cena BerBOR, 410 MeTOR CPaBHUTeMbHOTO MpapoRe/(eHHs sak MOYAeTCH NO MpEHMYLLeCTBY B COMOCTABNEHHK TeKCTOR 3a- Xoug (HOpMaTHBABIX NpABOBEIX TIpeIHcaHi), IPHHATHIX B pasHBXX rocysaperBax. Ho yes1o- BieM A418 cpaBHeHust MpanoBbIX HopM (rekcToR) pasitbIx CrpaH siBAsMOTeH NpAKTHKA Ue- eaeyopaTens B eYAX PAYHbIX CTPAH H ETO cyMeCTBEHHBIe MosHAMNs B cdhepe npanonoii ax1BH (lopuaWecKoro Getta) H IpaBoBoll KysISTYpb pasHbIx rocysapers. K psxjoBoMy He caeqoRaTemo Tax TpeGoRanHii mpeybaBnere HemB3. | " Axryampisim Mer BA copa II, Jlerpana: «IOpucr 13 KonTHHénTanbHol Esporibt BuKorya He cMo- 2KeT MORATD auLMHICKHH TOpHANeCKHI OMEIT mak, KaX anenuicKuil opucm, HGO OH He MOET NOsHATs sro usiyTpH Kymérypst, TlonMMaNMe MoxeT OBITS, HO O10 LOmKHO ObITs HEN HOMMMAHHeN, TaK KaK KOHTHHEHTAUIbHEIH OPUCT HE MOXXET MPOHHKHYTD B aITANHicKyIO MpanoByIO KybTypy: aurauiicKoe pa- BO ~ 910 TO, FO KoUTHMeHTaNbHDI opHCT HaGmoslaeT, a aHlicKuil lopHeT MepeRHBaer B ce6e (live through)». Llwr.: Cronwenxos B. A. Meronst cpaniitesibHoro npaponeneHis: saMevaniia 0 KyTBTYpOO- TuNeeKom noxoe K epannHTenbuomy mpany // ExcrostHHk cpaaitensHoro upasa. 2011 / Thon pen. J. B. Jloxesa, M., 2011. C. 18, cuocka N° 6.3ameyanne 0 x06poconecrHocrn - 1 Ha ctparnue No 136 rosopures, uo » pocentickoli noxrpune asHocTHoe wrayteHHMe pH staeTer LOGpocoRECTHBIM, COTA BNANETEH He SHALTH He NOIDKEH OBUL3HATE O TOM, HTO He mBILAeT- ca coOcTBEHIIHKOM. B npuesanun No 576 cxasaro: «Hexoropsie poccuickne ricenenonaresn tpe6yi0r, uro- 611 noGpoconectiers cymecTsonaa Ha npoTHReHHM NCETO cpoKA nABHOCTH .... Tepesess- JoTos mMeHa HecHenoBareltelt H HanMeHoRaEa Hx commenti, Cpemu Hux ecTe 1 Most haMHLTHA, Tance cxasano, wo Taxoe Tomkowase yOouuTe:IbHO oNpoREprHyTo. B camsn c oTHM cKa>ky, 470 OHO HHKEM He MoxeT ObITb OMpOBEPrHYTO, NocKONIBKY O6pO~ CORECTHOCTE JABHOCTHOTO MpHOGpETATETA He ToxNecTREHHA HOGpocoBecTHOCTH OTBETHKA To BHHIUUKANOHHOMY UcKy, KovOpsili «ate SHAT H He Mor 3HaTB». Jlobpocosecmnetii yaykanuenm ecm npuofpemamens, Komopeiti woncem Boum u 21a1, uMO eet *yDICAK, UMO on He donoIcen o6paujame ee ¢ ceoto cobemsennocme, Ho He nposeua ocoBoll aioemHocm Hu 6 MoMenm npuoB- Pemenw 4yIC020, Mut Ha eceM NpomaMcenut dasHocmHoco anadents. Toro HoaHca 1 Buy up Axcaposn4 Baraen He ysuTemaer, Cre7opatenbito, uiTasl OH MOKO paGory He CAMLKOM sunwaTenbHo, Hovemy? ro norssmaet nogospesue. Moxxer couekarest, m ApyrHx ropucroR HeBHMMATebHO “TTA? Bamesanne 0 206poconecrHocrn - 2 Tyner 15 Tlocraxonnenus Texywos BC PO 1 BAC Po No 10/22 ropoputr nam 0 TOM, ‘NTO joOpoconecTHOCTY 970 (Are SHAN H He MOP SHars B MoMeHT Hara Basen. Ho rue Te cy- J1bI, Nou THICHYMBI NpHHUMaM TaKoe peweHue? OuMH 3 HUX ypagMHeH, 2pyTolt coGpaHt B HO- BOM coctane. Hoste cyzb1 nomoryr orrparmnts no6pocopectHbXx y3ykanMeHTOB OT HejOGpocoHeCT- HBIX mpHoOperateneii, Boe onM stam, To NpHOGpeTAOT KpazeHoe, Spam «Bce, To TEIOXO sTe- 2akutD». Ho OsIHHL HS HUX He copepmnattH Ipyrax mpectynuieHt 310CTHO, a pyre conepmmam. Os HIL 1B HHX TpeyMHoxann npHOoOperentice zOGpo, pyre pacrosam ero. OmuH HOMUMa, "70 He Gortee eM BDICOKOOCTABIEHEBIe YnPABLAIOIINe, APyrHe nosarame ces XosHeBAMEL H CTPE- MMIC BCTaTS Hay rocys{apcrBoM.3ameuanne 0 ,06pocosecrHocru — 3 Baaaunmp Axcaponn4 Baraes yseper, 410 pexBisur 10GpocowecTHOCTH 218 MpHOpe- ‘TarenbHOli AaBHOCTH Oyler OTMEeHeH, B TOM 4HiCHIe H NOTOMY, 4TO HO criopaM OG HMYLeeTBe, KO- ‘Topoe MpuBaTiTsnponanio B 1990-e rol, cy OTKASEIRAIOTeA NpUMeHSTE npHOGperaTesTBHYIO AapHocts. Moxxer GbITs OHO H TaK. Ho ao6poconectiocr ecT MpHFIHAN 3aNHTTBI rpakNAKICKEX MIpaB, MPHAUAM Hx ocymIecT BICHHA H CTAHapr OLIEHKH TOBE eHHAL CTOPOH! B MpOLIeCce, AOGPOCOBeCTHOCTE HLTH HeOGPOCO- BECTHOCTS CTopOHI NAOT eys1be HSTHAUATBHYIO YeTAHOBKY pH OLIEHKe JoKasaremECTS, HosTOMy SALIMMaTECH MpoTuB vicKa 06 HcTpeGOBANHH HENBIKUMOCTH ccBLIKOli Ha TipHOGperarembHyIO JaBHOCTE HAO HOGpocopeCTHO, JAIlHTA JOSBONLAETES TOsIsKO OOPocoBecTHOMY yaykarerTy. Ha ero MloReveHHe OT npHoBpeTeHHA HMyIecTHA ZO BLINeCeHHA pemeHUA cys Gysler emoTpeTs Ccknosb CTaHiapT JOGPOCOBECTHOCTH HERAAHCHMO OT TOTO, ECT B 3aKOHIE TAKOH PeKCHBITT jABHIO- CTHOTO BiLANeHHs HIM ero HT, NOCKONIBKY Y KONIEKCOB ecTb MpHALHTbI. Bepio, 470 eer MpHATU- nib HY cyzeli. ‘Yimepxaior, 470 y Hac He SaLIUINaIOT BNATeHH, HOITOMY HeT SKOHOMMYecKOTO pocTa. Yirpepaaaior roxloctOBHO, He NOKASBIBAS CBASH MEK 3ALLUITOH BANEHHs H GnarococrostieM. Mexky rem, He 3artummeres HMeHHO mpectymice BrazeHHe, mIaeHe H He JomEHO aanyETE- Ca, ECIIM CONPoROXKIAeTCs 3OCTHBIMH MpaBoHapyiieHHaMH. Tlonarato, 110 Baraes Baasuwmp Axcaposns sacayauaer npueyanenus yuenoii crenientenm kanuiaTa topuamHeckHx Hayk Ho cHeumaabuoer 12. 00. 03, ero AMecepranvon- Hoe HccmeORAHHe OTBCyaeT MperBABITeMEIM TpeGoNAuHIM. [TpuanaTeeH ey sa astopebepar, KoTopstié 0 cHx nop He saGpat¢ Kadempsi cye6u0ro npana JOM HY. xaynar topamerseckux Hayk (12. 00.03) AoteHT Karhenpsr rparksiaHickoro mpasa 1 mpontecca MplOH () PLA Munocta Pocorm B.D. Hecrosmii 3ABEPAIO neuwannct no kanpam 10.E. Bessepuienko