Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Koob2008 - HARVARD GLASS FLOWERS
Koob2008 - HARVARD GLASS FLOWERS
To cite this article: Stephen P. Koob, Scott E. Fulton & Susan M. Rossi-Wilcox (2008)
'BOTANICAL WONDERS': THE CONSERVATION AND EXHIBITION OF THE HARVARD GLASS
FLOWERS, Studies in Conservation, 53:sup1, 44-49
Article views: 40
Download by: [Florida Atlantic University] Date: 21 March 2016, At: 22:49
‘BOTANICAL WONDERS’: THE CONSERVATION AND EXHIBITION OF THE
HARVARD GLASS FLOWERS
Stephen P. Koob, Scott E. Fulton and Susan M. Rossi-Wilcox
ABSTRACT
The exhibition ‘Botanical Wonders’, presented at The Corning Museum
of Glass in 2007, showcased the exquisite and accurate glass models
of plants made by the Bohemian flameworkers, Leopold and Rudolf
Blaschka. New conservation techniques and materials were developed for
the stabilization, repair and packing of the models, which were shipped
from their home at the Botanical Museum of Harvard University to
Corning, New York. The museums’ curators and conservators collaborated
with Corning’s registrar in an effort that stressed the utmost care and
minimal handling to ensure the safety of the objects. A small conservation
‘laboratory’ was included in the exhibition, supplemented by a two-minute
video on treatments carried out on some of the glass models. A display
panel and audio tour of the show explained the importance of conservation
for the long-term preservation of these objects.
INTRODUCTION
The exhibition ‘Botanical Wonders: The Story of the Harvard
Downloaded by [Florida Atlantic University] at 22:49 21 March 2016
44
institution), which guaranteed that the models would be returned
in a better condition than before they traveled. In the initial plan-
ning of this exhibition, conservation was discussed as an integral
element in the loan agreement. The curators and directors of
both museums determined that only models stable enough to
travel could be loaned for the exhibition. However, models that
required complicated repairs (such as delaminated examples) or
raised difficult restoration issues were also considered so that
treatments could be recommended for conditions that affected
the collection in general. The collaborative goal was to maximize
this opportunity and develop conservation strategies that could
be employed in a larger conservation project being planned by
Harvard University. The selection of models was based on a joint
examination and evaluation by the authors of this paper. The
museum directors agreed that staff time and expertise would
be devoted to stabilizing the models before they traveled. The
more extensive treatments would be done at the conservation Fig. 2 Surface delamination and damage to Blaschka model.
laboratory in Corning. These decisions became part of the loan
agreement between CMoG and BMHU, ensuring minimal risks
and optimal benefits for the models and the exhibition.
Downloaded by [Florida Atlantic University] at 22:49 21 March 2016
45
applied to areas that already had been consolidated — but
had larger losses (not just cracks) — in order to provide addi-
tional strength. Another advantage of the slurries was that they
improved the aesthetic appearance of the damaged areas and hid
exposed wires or sharp glass fractured edges. B-72 was chosen
because of its stability, ease of application, and easy reversibility
in acetone [3], which would not affect any of the original water-
based Blaschka construction should such reversibility ever be
required.
Some isolated areas of unstable decorative detail responded
well to local consolidation with the synthetic cellulose deriva-
tive Ethulose (ethylhydroxyethylcellulose) in a water: ethanol
solution. This treatment was derived from earlier experimenta-
tion with the Blaschkas’ magnified cross-sections to identify a
method of relaxing and re-attaching the lifting edges of applied
gelatin [4].
Ethulose consolidation was carried out on three magnified Fig. 4 Completed packing of a plant model, showing details of supports
models of transverse and longitudinal plant ovary sections. While and cushioning.
the glass substrates all appeared stable on these models, the
applied gelatin and animal glue details were lifting or peeling.
The sections were placed in a high relative humidity (80–90%) CONSERVATION AT THE CORNING MUSEUM OF
Downloaded by [Florida Atlantic University] at 22:49 21 March 2016
chamber for 30 minutes to soften the lifting areas. The Ethulose GLASS
was then carefully applied by brush and the lifting areas gently Additional conservation work was carried out once the models
laid down using a spatula and light pressure. In some cases, more had arrived at Corning, in the museum’s climate-controlled ware-
pressure could be applied using small weights on top of silicone house, which contains a small conservation laboratory. This also
release paper, which was used as a separating, protective barrier. allowed for a more relaxed time schedule to perform the work
After 20 to 30 minutes, the adhesive was dry enough to remove that needed to be done; only one model was later moved from
the weights. Ethulose was chosen for its compatibility with the the warehouse to the museum laboratory because it required
water-sensitive gelatins used by the Blaschkas and because of much more extensive restoration work. Preprinted conservation
its flexible response to environmental changes, expansion and report forms were used to assess condition of the collection after
contraction. the long truck ride. Digital photographs of the models were also
made. These condition and treatment records were later entered
PACKING AND TRANSIT into the conservation records database.
When conservation stabilization measures had been completed,
the models were carefully packed, following guidelines that were Cleaning
established for a shipment of models to Avignon, France, for Some of the models had already been cleaned and stabilized
display in the exhibition ‘La Beauté’ in 2000 [5]. in preparation for ‘La Beauté’, the French Millennium Exhibit
The models were mounted on faced polystyrene foam board in Avignon, France in 2000 [5]. The remaining models were
(Gatorfoam®) pallets, which were intended to double as exhibit disfigured by a layer of accumulated dust, cotton fibers, miscel-
mounts. Small cushions of white high-density polyethylene laneous debris and a blackish deposit (probably soot from early
foam (Plastizote) were attached to the pallet to support the coal-fired heating seasons).
structural backbone and heavier model parts like the branches The structural fragility of the models, and the sensitive nature
and fruits. These primary supports were considered permanent of many of the surface coatings, complicated cleaning efforts.
and would remain in place throughout transit as well as during The paints and organic coatings used by the Blaschkas restricted
exhibition. the use of water. Using other solvents of high polarity like
Temporary Plastizote supports were positioned to prevent the acetone or ethanol could also have been problematic. It was help-
shifting of large and heavy elements, such as the life-size fruits. ful that previous cleaning tests conducted both at Harvard and
These were labeled with color-coded dots, to indicate that they at Corning had indicated that petroleum distillates (Stoddard’s
could be removed when the models were unpacked. For the final solvent, naphtha, ligroine, or petroleum ether) were safe and very
cushioning, custom-made ‘pillows’ of varying sizes were tucked effective for light cleaning and the removal of oily soot deposits.
under and around leaves, flowers, and any other parts of models Soft sable or sable/synthetic brushes were used either dry, or with
that were subject to vibration. These pillows were made of very mineral spirits. Fine tweezers were used to remove bits of cotton
thin, high-density polyethylene sheeting filled with polyester lint and other debris.
batting and closed with a heat sealer, Fig. 4. These were all
made to be removable and proved successful in preventing any Repairs of damaged models
movement and damage. Some of the models had been damaged in the past, and many had
A double-crating approach to packing the glass models was undergone previous repairs, some of which are known to have
also considered to be good protection against thermal shock been made by the Blaschkas themselves. However, most of the
while the collection was in transit. Each pallet containing models repairs of broken leaves, stems, and flowers were of more recent
was supported with an inner foam-core box lined with closed- date (the 1960s and 1970s), when the models had been stabilized
cell polyethylene foam (Ethafoam®). This box, in turn, was with various adhesives including epoxy and cellulose nitrate.
nested in a cushioned enclosure of an outer box lined with Three types of conservation treatment were carried out at
polyurethane packing foam of the appropriate to absorb shock Corning: the re-attachment of previously broken fragments;
and vibration, see Fig. 4. The models were transported in an filling of significant losses and; extensive re-treatment and gap-
air-ride, climate-controlled truck, and arrived at the Corning filling of one large magnified plant part (the flower of a variety
warehouse. of grass common in New England).
46
Fig. 5 Application of Hxtal-NYL-1 epoxy to repair the broken stem of
a magnified fungus model.
using B-72 adhesive, after first cleaning off any previous adhesive
such as animal glue or cellulose nitrate. Hxtal NYL-1 epoxy
was used only on one model, in order to repair the broken long
glass rods that made up the stalk of a fruit fungus, magnified
200 times, Fig. 5.
The surface losses on the models were generally small
(approximately 1 × 2 mm), and they were filled with the B-72
slurries described above. Experiments with various mixtures of
solvents led to the conclusion that a higher proportion of ethanol
provided more working time, less stickiness and a more even Fig. 6 Dicanthelium xanthophysum, ‘panic grass’, magnified flower.
application than mixtures with higher acetone concentrations. Model 774 (1923), Botanical Museum, Harvard University
The resulting mixture of 80% acetone and 20% ethanol seemed Herbaria; after treatment.
to work best.
An extensive conservation effort was made in re-treating the
magnified grass flower. This had been previously poorly repaired
with cellulose nitrate and required complete re-treatment as well
as loss compensation. Three small losses in the glass leaf were
filled with detachable plaster fills [3, 6], which were then molded
in silicone rubber and cast with tinted epoxy (Hxtal NYL-1).
When finished, these small fills were adhered in place using
B-72 adhesive, before reassembling the flower leaf, Fig. 6. Part
of this treatment was included in the conservation video that was
shown in the exhibition.
EXHIBIT
All of the models were displayed in individual cases that
required no artificial environmental buffering because the CMoG
Fig. 7 Display of Blaschka pencil, ink and watercolor drawings in the
is climate-controlled at 20–23°C with a relative humidity of gallery.
40–55%. The exhibition gallery was illuminated with ceiling-
mounted track lights, all with ultraviolet filters. There were no
internal case lights. The overall ambient lighting in the gallery
was kept low while the models were illuminated to a level of 11–13 October 2007, featured lectures about nature in glass,
c. 10 footcandles (or 100 lux) to allow the objects to ‘stand out’. including the work of the Blaschkas, naturalism and Art Nouveau,
To safeguard the original light-sensitive pigments used by the and reflections of nature in contemporary glass.
Blaschkas in their pencil, ink and watercolor drawings, the 30 Weekly public tours of the exhibition were presented by Dr
‘flat’ works were framed with UF-3 plexiglass (Perspex) glazing Whitehouse, the museum’s executive director and co-curator
and placed along one wall with light levels set at a lower 4–5 of the exhibit. Glass modeling demonstrations, using some
footcandles (40–50 lux), Fig. 7. conventional nineteenth-century flameworking techniques that
would have been used by the Blaschkas, were given several
EDUCATIONAL COLLABORATION times a day.
Sixty exceptional drawings from the more than 900 examples An audio self-guided tour of the exhibition included a detailed
in the joint museums’ collections were selected for a compan- history of the Blaschkas, explanations of manufacturing tech-
ion book, Drawing Upon Nature: Studies for the Blaschkas’ niques, and observations on the glass models. It also incorporated
Glass Models, written by Susan M. Rossi-Wilcox and David interviews with curators and conservators, who detailed the
Whitehouse. The CMoG’s 46th annual Seminar on Glass, held challenges faced in restoring and exhibiting the fragile models.
47
The exhibition was extensively covered both nationally and
internationally by print and broadcast media.
Risk Management
In the course of preparing for the exhibition, all projected risks
to the models were discussed, assessed and kept to an absolute
minimum. The preliminary stabilization done at Harvard, along
with the expert planning, mounting, and packing of the models,
ensured their safe travel to Corning. The authors believed that
the greatest risks would be mishandling or excess vibrations,
most notably during the transportation by truck and within the
museums. Therefore, the handling of the models was restricted
to the conservators and curator of the Ware Collection, which
Fig. 8 On the right: Conservation laboratory mock-up, with video, in addressed the first concern, and the careful mounting and protec-
the gallery; on the left: ‘Draw Like the Blaschkas’ set-up. tive ‘pillowing’ kept the models free of damage from vibration.
Only one leaf, and two small petals became detached during
transit, and these were previous repairs that failed, not new
Conservation Display damage.
A small but realistic conservation laboratory was re-created as During the installation of ‘Botanical Wonders’, access to the
the concluding exhibit. It illustrated and explained the types exhibit gallery was restricted to the staff members who were
of materials, equipment and rationale for conservation of the working with the models. Design, lighting and photographic
Downloaded by [Florida Atlantic University] at 22:49 21 March 2016
Blaschka models, Fig. 8. The display included a microscope, personnel were allowed in the exhibition space only after the
typical conservation tools, adhesives, consolidants, pigmented cases had been closed.
slurries, and other materials that were used during the treatment
of the models. A continuous video loop of some of the conser- MATERALS AND SUPPLIERS
vation treatments was shown on a screen, behind the laboratory Fumed colloidal silica (Aerosil 202): Degussa Corporation, 65
Challenger Road, Ridgefield Park, NJ 07660, USA.
mock-up. The following explanatory label was posted alongside
the display: Ethulose (ethylhydroxyethylcellulose): Conservators Emporium, c/o
Museum Services.
THE FUTURE: PRESERVING THE GLASS FLOWERS Corporation, 385 Bridgepoint Drive, South St Paul, MN 55075, USA.
Along with research, conservation and preservation of the Ethafoam®, Plastizote, polyester fiber, urethane foam: United Foam
collections are an important part of a museum’s stewardship. Plastics, 172 E. Main Street, Georgetown, MA 01833, USA.
This video and laboratory set-up provide a glimpse into the Gatorfoam®: Charrette Office Supply, PO Box 4010, Woburn, MA
world of conservation where two conservators Stephen P. 01888-4010, USA.
Koob, from The Corning Museum of Glass, and Scott E.
Fulton, from Harvard University, are collaborating on the REFERENCES
1 Pantano, C.G., Rossi-Wilcox, S., and Lange, D., ‘The Glass Flow-
stabilization, cleaning and repair of the flowers. One of ers: Prehistory and History of Glassmaking Technology’, American
the treatments in the video is the repair and restoration of Ceramic Society 8 (1998) 61–78.
the magnified grass flower on view in the previous gallery.
2 Smith McNally, R., and Buschini, N., ‘The Harvard glass flowers:
A conservation lab is being planned by Robert E. Cook, the materials and techniques’, Journal of the American Institute for
director of the Harvard University Herbaria, and will be Conservation 32 (1993) 231–240.
housed near the Harvard Museum of Natural History where 3 Koob, S.P., Conservation and Care of Glass Objects, Archetype
the Ware Collection of Blaschka Glass Models of Plants (The Publications, in Association with The Corning Museum of Glass,
Glass Flowers) is on permanent exhibition. Corning, New York (2006).
The conservation display offered the public a ‘behind-the-scenes’ 4 Peschken, S., and Fulton, S., Examination and treatment report for
the structural repair of Harvard Botanical Museum Glass Flower
look at some of the details required in preparing the models model # BM-303, “Gynandropsis speciosa”, conservation treatment
for the exhibition. Surveys from visitors confirmed that the report, Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology (1995)
subject was very well received and that viewers wanted more (unpublished).
information [7]. 5 Fulton, S.E., and Rossi-Wilcox, S., ‘Harvard’s glass flowers: a case
study in traveling a fragile collection’, Journal of the American
Drawing like the Blaschkas Institute for Conservation 47 (2008) 15–26.
On a long table that was set up opposite the conservation 6 Koob, S.P., ‘New techniques for the repair and restoration of ancient
display, visitors were invited to ‘draw like the Blaschkas’. The glass’, in Tradition and Innovation: Advances in Conservation,
table was stocked with paper, pencils and a variety of modern ed. A. Roy and P. Smith, International Institute for Conservation,
London (2000) 92–95.
flowers, shells, and other objects to serve as inspiration. Visitors
took their drawings home to remind them of their experience, 7 Podany, J.C., and Maish, S.L., ‘Can the complex be made simple:
informing the public about conservation through museum exhib-
see Fig. 8.
its’, Journal of the American Institute for Conservation 32 (1993)
101–108.
CONCLUSIONS
The ‘Botanical Wonders’ exhibition required an extensive AUTHORS
collaboration involving conservation, exhibition, design, educa- Stephen P. Koob received an MA (1976) in classical archaeology from
tion, curatorial and registration departments of the two muse- Indiana University, and a BSc (1980) in archaeological conservation
and materials science from the Institute of Archaeology, University of
ums. Despite the demands on staff time and expertise, this co- London. From 1986 to 1998 he worked as conservator, specializing in
operative venture resulted in one of the most popular and highly ceramics and glass, at the Freer Gallery of Art and Arthur M. Sackler
acclaimed shows ever offered at The Corning Museum of Glass. Gallery, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC. In 1998 he took up
48
the position of conservator at The Corning Museum of Glass. Address: 11 Divinity Ave, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA. Email: sfulton@fas.
The Corning Museum of Glass, One Museum Way, Corning, NY, 14830, harvard.edu
USA. Email: koobsp@cmog.org
Susan M. Rossi-Wilcox retired in June 2007 as the administrator for
Scott E. Fulton received a BA following studies in printmaking methods the glass flowers collection and curatorial associate at the Botanical
and art history at Middlebury College, Vermont and at Berea College, Museum, Harvard University. She received a BA from the University of
Kentucky (1971). He completed graduate level training in objects North Carolina, Chapel Hill (botany, 1976), and an ALM from Harvard
conservation (artifacts stream) at Queen’s University, Ontario (MAC University Extension School (history of science, 1991). She co-curated
1988). He is currently conservator of objects at the Peabody Museum of Botanical Wonders at the CMoG, and co-authored Drawing upon
Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University where he has served Nature: Studies for the Blaschkas’ Glass Models. She served on the
since 1988. His association with Harvard’s glass flowers began in board of directors of the Glass Art Society where she is currently the
1996 as a collaborative effort between the Botanical Museum, Harvard journal editor. Address: 1604 Belle Terre Ave., Niles, OH 44446, USA.
University, and the Peabody Museum to preserve the collection. Address: Email: srossiwilcox@att.net
Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University,
Downloaded by [Florida Atlantic University] at 22:49 21 March 2016
49