Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Answers 02
Answers 02
Answers 02
EXERCISE SET B
1. factually correct? NO 9. factually correct? YES
valid? YES valid? NO
sound? NO sound? NO
2. factually correct? NO 10. factually correct? YES
valid? YES valid? YES
sound? NO sound? YES
3. factually correct? NO 11. factually correct? NO
valid? YES valid? YES
sound? NO sound? NO
4. factually correct? NO 12. factually correct? NO
valid? NO valid? YES
sound? NO sound? NO
5. factually correct? YES 13. factually correct? NO
valid? NO valid? NO
sound? NO sound? NO
6. factually correct? YES 14. factually correct? can't tell
valid? NO valid? NO
sound? NO sound? NO
7. factually correct? YES 15. factually correct? can't tell
valid? YES valid? YES
sound? YES sound? can't tell
8. factually correct? NO 16. factually correct? can't tell
valid? YES valid? YES
sound? NO sound? can't tell
Chapter 1: Basic Concepts 27
EXERCISE SET C
Original Argument Counterexample
1. all dogs are reptiles valid; admits no counterexample
all reptiles are Martians
/ all dogs are Martians