Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Effect of Hyaluronidase On Depth of Necrosis in Hyaluronic Acid Filling-Related Skin Complications
The Effect of Hyaluronidase On Depth of Necrosis in Hyaluronic Acid Filling-Related Skin Complications
The Effect of Hyaluronidase On Depth of Necrosis in Hyaluronic Acid Filling-Related Skin Complications
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00266-020-01759-2
Abstract 20–90 days. The affected and necrosis areas were large.
Aim In this clinical study, 16 female patients with vascular The cause of ischemia depended both on occlusion and on
compression and occlusion-related ischemia and skin compression. While four patients healed with a scar, the
necrosis after hyaluronic acid filling injection were ana- remaining 12 patients healed without any significant scar.
lyzed retrospectively. Dose, timing, and efficacy of hya- Conclusions Hyaluronidase injection provides earlier
luronidase use in skin necrosis are discussed. recovery of limited skin necrosis. Immediate hyaluronidase
Patients and Methods In a total of 841 cases, aged between injection allows small damage to heal in a short time;
18 and 60 years, hyaluronic acid filling injections were however, it does not completely eliminate large necrosis,
performed. All patients were followed up for 3–24 months. although it limits the necrotic area.
Filling injected areas include nasolabial (391 cases), lip Level of Evidence IV This journal requires that authors
(225 cases), glabella–forehead (90 cases), infraorbital (46 assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full
cases), malar region (25 cases), chin (24 cases), and nose description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings,
(40 cases). Skin complications occurred in four cases please refer to the Table of Contents or the online
during the application and in 12 cases 6–24 h after the Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266.
procedure. Only palliative treatment was performed in six
cases, while hyaluronidase was used in 10 cases in addition Keywords Hyaluronic acid Hyaluronidase Skin
to palliative treatment. Hyaluronidase injection was per- necrosis Nitroglycerin Aesthetic filling Filler
formed 30 s after filling injection in four cases and 6–24 h complication
after the injection in the remaining six cases. A total of
1500 units of hyaluronidase was applied to each case in
average. Introduction
Results Recovery period of the patients who received
palliative treatment only lasted 40–60 days. The area of Hyaluronic acid (HA) filling is one of the most common
necrosis was limited in these patients who did heal well non-surgical procedures in facial aesthetic applications
only with some change of pigmentation and no obvious [1–4]. HA is frequently applied to nasolabial, nasal,
scar. In the patient group who received hyaluronidase in glabellar areas, jaw line, jowl line, lip, as well as malar,
addition to palliative treatment, a large necrosis area was temporal, and infraorbital regions. It is frequently preferred
observed at the same time in four patients. Despite the by patients due its immediate results, outpatient treatment,
hyaluronidase treatment in this group, recovery period was low cost, and reproducibility. Patients generally consider
HA application as a simple procedure with no serious side
effects due to social media coverage and other various
& Safvet Ors factors. For this reason, in some centers, filling injections
saffetors@gmail.com
are performed even by individuals who are not physicians.
1
SO-EP Aesthetic & Plastic Surgery Clinic, Hunat Mah. Nuh Although it is a simple procedure, the rate of encountering
Naci Yazgan Caddesi No:21, 38050 Kayseri, Turkey complications increases every day [5–8]. As with any
123
Aesth Plast Surg
123
Aesth Plast Surg
6 6 - 40–60 - - ? - 6 -
10 6 4 20–90 4 1500 IU first 4 h ? 4 6 4
4–6th h
123
123
Table 2 Demographic data of patients
Case Ages Sex Ethnicity Filler volume Skin type Treatments Filler area Smoking Additional disease/ Additional filler/ Hyaluronidase
number (ml) allergy botox allergy
Fig. 2 a A 50-year-old female patient HA filler injected to the neighboring tissue with superficial necrosis is epithelialized. A scar is
glabellar region. Four doses of hyaluronidase (1200 IU) were applied observed in the deep necrosis region, c 4 months after procedure. The
6–24 h after complication onset. Ten days later, a deep necrosis is glabellar region has healed with a scar
observed in the midline with surrounding superficial necrosis; b the
123
Aesth Plast Surg
hyaluronidase injection may cause damage to the vascular Considering the length of recovery time, surgical inter-
endothelium [28]. Diagnosis methods such as conventional vention may be considered, but this will deteriorate heal-
ultrasound, Doppler ultrasound, scintigraphy, and MRI ing, and more scar will remain.
could be used and are very valuable in the observation of In an experimental study, various doses of arterial
necrosis effects. hyaluronidase were applied after HA injection into the
After hyaluronidase injection, limited necrosis areas artery of the rabbit ear [14]. Similar to our study, the
heal in a short period of 3–4 weeks on average; however, researchers observed that hyaluronidase did not completely
the area with large necrosis heals in a longer time such as prevent necrosis occurrence as a result of arterial occlusion
3 months (Figs. 1 and 2). This suggests that hyaluronidase but reduced the necrosis area. It is recommended to start
123
Aesth Plast Surg
hyaluronidase application within the first 4 h after com- lip, chin, and malar region are a little safer. In HA fillings
plication onset [9, 14]. Considering the four cases reported to the infraorbital area, most commonly observed compli-
here in which hyaluronidase injection was applied at 30th cations are edema and overfill. Hyaluronidase is most
second of complication onset, for which the affected areas commonly used in the infraorbital region for excess filling.
healed with a significant scar, it can be observed that even Therefore, this region should be kept in mind as the region
the effect of immediate hyaluronidase application is limited with more frequent complications. Although the filler
in large necrosis. Still, in such cases, we strongly recom- injection procedures seem quite simple, serious complica-
mend immediate hyaluronidase application, since we tions could occur during the procedure. Therefore, we
believe that hyaluronidase limits the expansion of necrosis suggest untrained doctors or other personnel shouldn’t
and helps adjacent small area necrosis to recover faster. perform these applications. Hyaluronidase should be kept
The end branches of the supraorbital and supratrochlear ready at the table in the room where HA filling is applied.
arteries are positioned superficially in the glabella Hyaluronidase use might cause several very serious side
[21–23, 25]. Even in intradermal HA filling applications, effects such as anaphylactic shock. Therefore, its applica-
arterial occlusion and compression can occur. In four cases tion must be performed in a medical setting and by the
where we administered intradermal glabellar HA filling, medical staff. The treatment of skin complications should
the leakage of filling into the artery confirms this. We have be done by doctors who are experts on wound healing.
observed more skin complications significantly in patients Therefore, the patients should be referred to medical cen-
with oily and porous skin. Almost half of the 16 cases ters with great expertise.
reported here had this type of skin (Figs. 1, 3, 5, and 7).
Therefore, they are more affected by HA filling, which Acknowledgements The authors declare no financial interest in any
of the products, devices, or drugs mentioned in this manuscript.
suggests extra caution for such cases. In some studies, it
was reported that tissue damage did not disappear com- Compliance with Ethical Standards
pletely even though vascular occlusion was eliminated in
the early period with hyaluronidase [29]. Tissue damage Conflict of interest The authors declare that they have no conflicts of
interest to disclose.
may be caused by the chemical structure of HA in addition
to vascular pressure and occlusion. During HA filling Ethical Approval Ethical approval of the retrospective clinical study
application, negative pressure could be applied to the was granted by the research ethics committee.
injector to test if the injector tip is located inside the vein or
not, which is a routine practice we perform in all of our Informed Consent Informed consent form was used for this study.
patients. However, this does not always give correct
results.
References
1. http://www.plasticsurgery.org/document/News/Statistics/2018/
Conclusions plastic-surgery-statistics-report-2018.pdf
2. Narins RS, Jewell M, Rubin M, Cohen J, Strobos J (2006)
Skin complications due to pressure to the artery or intra- Clinical conference: management of rare events following dermal
fillers-focal necrosis and angry red bumps. Dermatol Surg
arterial injections could be observed after HA filling 32(3):426–434
applications. Hyaluronidase injection can provide faster 3. Hirsh RJ, Cohen JL, Carruthers JD (2007) Successful manage-
recovery of limited, small area necrosis in such cases. ment of an unusual presentation of impending necrosis following
Although immediate hyaluronidase injection allows this a hyaluronic acid injection embolus and a proposed algorithm for
management with hyaluronidase. Dermatol Surg 33(3):357–360
small area damage to heal in a short time, as well as lim- 4. King M, Convery C, Davies E (2018) This month’s guideline: the
iting the large necrosis area, it cannot completely eliminate use of hyaluronidase in aesthetic practice (v2.4). J Clin Aesthet
necrosis. Patients with large area necrosis who received Dermatol 11(6):E61–E68
hyaluronidase treatment have smaller remaining scars 5. Sito G, Manzoni V, Sommariva R (2019) Vascular complications
after facial filler injection: a literature review and meta-analysis.
compared to necrosis area. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol 12(6):E65–E72
In case of complication onset, hyaluronidase injection 6. Beleznay K, Carruthers JDA, Humphrey S, Carruthers A, Jones D
should be performed immediately if possible. While the (2019) Update on avoiding and treating blindness from fillers: a
complication rate is 1.9% in all facial HA filling applica- recent review of the world literature. Aesthet Surg J
39(6):662–674
tions in our center, the observed complication rate is much 7. Thanasarnaksorn W, Cotofana S, Rudolph C, Kraisak P, Chana-
higher in glabella. Glabella and nasal areas should be sumon N, Suwanchinda A (2018) Severe vision loss caused by
considered as the high-risk regions and should be avoided cosmetic filler augmentation: case series with review of cause and
if possible. The most high-risk areas in HA filling appli- therapy. J Cosmet Dermatol 17(5):712–718
cations are glabella–forehead, nose and nasolabial area, but
123
Aesth Plast Surg
8. Loh KTD, Phoon YS, Phua V, Kapoor KM (2018) Successfully 20. Yang Q, Qiu L, Yi C, Xue P, Yu Z, Ma X, Su Y, Guo S (2017)
managing impending skin necrosis following hyaluronic acid Reversible alopecia with localized scalp necrosis after accidental
filler injection, using high-dose pulsed hyaluronidase. Plast embolization of the parietal artery with hyaluronic acid. Aesthet
Reconstr Surg Glob Open 6(2):e1639 Plast Surg 41(3):695–699
9. Zhang L, Feng X, Shi H, Wu WTL, Wu S (2019) Blindness after 21. Coleman SR (2002) Avoidance of arterial occlusion from injec-
facial filler injections: the role of extravascular hyaluronidase on tion of soft tissue fillers. Aesthet Surg J 22(6):555–557
intravascular hyaluronic acid embolism in the rabbit experimental 22. Woodward J (2016) Review of periorbital and upper face: per-
model. Aesthet Surg J. https://doi.org/10.1093/asj/sjz280 tinent anatomy, aging, injection techniques, prevention, and
10. Han SW, Park MJ, Lee SH (2019) Hyaluronic acid-induced dif- management of complications of facial fillers. J Drugs Dermatol
fuse alveolar hemorrhage: unknown complication induced by a 15(12):1524–1531
well-known injectable agent. Ann Transl Med 7(1):13 23. Lin CH, Chiang CP, Wu BY, Gao HW (2017) Filler migration to
11. Ansari ZA, Choi CJ, Rong AJ, Erickson BP, Tse DT (2019) the forehead due to multiple filler injections in a patient addicted
Ocular and cerebral infarction from periocular filler injection. to cosmetic fillers. J Cosmet Laser Ther 19(2):124–126
Orbit 38(4):322–324 24. Snozzi P, van Loghem JAJ (2018) Complication management
12. Chen H, Wang H, Yang Z (2018) A case of hyaluronic acid following rejuvenation procedures with hyaluronic acid fillers-an
induced blindness with ophthalmoplegia and ptosis. Ophthalmic algorithm-based approach. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open
Plast Reconstr Surg 34(6):e184–e186 6(12):e2061
13. Rivers JK, Mistry BD (2018) Soft-tissue infection caused by 25. Han J, He Y, Liu K, Yang Q (2018) Necrosis of the glabella after
streptococcus anginosus after intramucosal hyaluronidase injec- injection with hyaluronic acid into the forehead. J Craniofac Surg
tion: a rare complication related to dermal filler injection. Der- 29(7):e726–e727
matol Surg 44(Suppl 1):S51–S53 26. Wang Q, Zhao Y, Li H, Li P, Wang J (2018) Vascular compli-
14. Lee W, Oh W, Oh SM, Yang EJ (2020) Comparative effective- cations after chin augmentation using hyaluronic acid. Aesthet
ness of different interventions of perivascular hyaluronidase. Plast Surg 42(2):553–559
Plast Reconstr Surg. https://doi.org/10.1097/prs. 27. Schanz S, Schippert W, Ulmaer A, Rassner G, Fierlbeck G (2002)
0000000000006639 Arterial embolization caused by injection of hyaluronic acid
15. Lee W, Oh W, Ko HS, Lee SY, Kim KW, Yang EJ (2019) (Restylane). Br J Dermatol 146(5):928–929
Effectiveness of retrobulbar hyaluronidase injection in an iatro- 28. Wattanakrai P, Jurairattanaporn N, Rojhirunsakool S, Visessiri Y,
genic blindness rabbit model using hyaluronic acid filler injec- Suwanchinda A, Thanasarnaksorn W (2018) The study of histo-
tion. Plast Reconstr Surg 144(1):137–143 logical changes of the arterial vascular structure after hyalur-
16. Grunebaum LD, Bogdan Allemann I, Dayan S, Bauman L (2009) onidase exposure. J Cosmet Dermatol 17(4):632–636
The risk of alar necrosis associated with dermal filler injection. 29. Oh B-L, Jung C, Park KH, Hong YJ et al (2014) Therapeutic
Dermatol Surg 35(Supp 2):1635–1640 intra-arterial hyaluronidase infusion for ophthalmic artery
17. Ohen JL (2008) Understanding, avoiding, and managing dermal occlusion following cosmetic facial filler (hyaluronic acid)
filler complications. Dermatol Surg 34:S92–S99 injection. Neuro-Ophthalmology 38:39–43
18. Vasquez RAS, Park K, Braunlich K, Aguilera SB (2019) Pro-
longed periorbicular edema after injection of hyaluronic acid for
nasojugal groove correction. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
12(9):32–35 jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
19. Kleydman K, Cohen JL, Marmur E (2012) Nitroglycerin: a
review of its use in the treatment of vascular occlusion after soft
tissue augmentation. Dermatol Surg 38(12):1889–1897
123