Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 62

mobilityengineeringtech.

com February 2024

Certified Machine
Learning-Based Avionics
Revolutionizing
Electronic Warfare
Modular Architecture for
Embedded Vehicle Systems
Material Stresses and
System Requirements
for Hypersonic Flight

From the Publishers of


YOUR OPTICAL FILTER
PARTNER FOR LIDAR

alluxa.com
Aerospace & Defense Technology

Contents
FEATURES ________________________________________ 43 Report on Human Factors Issues Likely to Affect Air-Launched
Effects
Avionics 44 Advanced Satellite Communications Research
6 Certified Machine Learning-Based Avionics: Unlocking Safer 45 New Qubit Circuit Enables Quantum Operations With Higher
Aviation Autonomy Accuracy
Electronic Warfare 46 A Perspective on GVSC Crewstation Development and
Addressing Future Ground Combat Vehicle Needs
14 Revolutionizing Electronic Warfare: Unleashing the Power of
High-Performance Software Defined Radios
DEPARTMENTS ___________________________________
Embedded Computing
48 Application Briefs
20 Deterministic and Modular Architecture for Embedded Vehicle
Systems 52 New Products
55 Ad Index
Hypersonic Flight
56 XPONENTIAL Exhibitor Profiles
26 Approximating the Material Stresses and System
Requirements for Hypersonic Flight
ON THE COVER ___________________________________
RF & Microwave Technology
By automating tasks traditionally limited to human
34 Design Approaches for Established and Emerging RF Receiver pilots – like detecting airborne traffic and identifying
Architectures safe landing locations – machine learning-based avi-
39 Rydberg Technologies Shows Potential of Long-Range RF with onics systems can raise safety levels, lower costs, and
increase fleet capacity. To learn more, read the feature
Quantum Sensor at NetModX23
article on page 6.
(Image: Cherezoff)
TECH BRIEFS _____________________________________
42 New Method to Measure Wind Speed Could Unlock Drones’
Potential

2 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


Sponsored Content

I N S I D E S T O RY
Mercury Systems is a technology company that delivers mission-critical processing power to
the edge. The Mercury Processing Platform comprises innovative technologies that convert data
to critical decisions, delivered from silicon to systems, and are uniquely ready for deployment at
the edge. Mercury’s products and solutions are deployed in more than 300 programs, across 35
countries, and in every domain–including space. Space-ready products include radiation-tolerant
VPX boards, NAND memory, microwave components, and solid-state data recorders (SSDRs). In
this interview, Vincent Pribble, Principal Product Manager at Mercury Systems, discusses current
trends and the outlook for data recorders for space.

Aerospace & Defense Technology: What current space trends launch volume and mass, which will drive the need for better
are shaping the requirements for data recorders in space? performance from equipment like data recorders.

Pribble: Due to the decreasing price A&DT: What are some difficulties that designers face in build-
to access space as a result of falling ing space data recorders or products for space in general?
launch costs, one of the largest trends
is the emergence of mega constel- Pribble: SWaP optimization is a difficult problem to solve for
lations for a variety of tasks, such the engineer. For space data recorders, getting to the desired
as earth observation and space-based storage capacity requires fitting many NAND chips into a
internet. These constellations typically small package. This consumes a large amount of board space,
use SWaP-sensitive small satellite ar- immediately causing layout issues for the rest of the compo-
chitectures to achieve their goals by nents inside the system. Trying to fit NAND chips, power, and
aggregating a large amount of data system control all into the same volume is a tough requirement
collected across multiple payloads. Optimizing data recorder to meet. On top of this, robust error correction is required,
performance to meet the SWaP requirements of the small sat- especially for a less than ideal radiation environment. In this
ellite market, while still enabling the needs of larger monolithic environment, radiation-induced bit errors occur much more
satellites, is key. frequently and ensuring that the FPGA has enough on-board
logic to fix these errors, while meeting power and performance
A&DT: There is growing interest in using MRAM (magnetic requirements, tends to force trade-offs. Finally, ensuring the
random-access memory) in Space applications because of system meets mission objections without degrading perfor-
its reliability and durability. Can you talk a little more about mance requires engineers to compare different technologies
this? for their designs, such as using high-density TLC versus
high-durability SLC NAND.
Pribble: MRAM has the potential to radically change the capa-
bility of observation satellites. Since MRAM is magnetic rather A&DT: What SSDR solutions does Mercury currently pro-
than charge based, it is radiation resistant and the projected vide to meet Space requirements and what is on the future
lifespan for these devices is far greater than traditional tech- roadmap?
nologies available today. Additionally, SLC and TLC NAND has
some limitations surrounding read/write cycles (60k, 3k respec- Pribble: Mercury has two flight-proven COTS space data re-
tively), which MRAM does not have. This enables satellites using corders currently available with capacities of 440 GB and 480
MRAM technology to pull data from their payload sensor more GB. With top interface speeds of 3 Gbps, as well as a MTBF of
frequently and send that data for better processing, without over 1 million hours, these data recorders are well suited for
worrying about degrading their storage. applications that need reliable, error-free data retention. These
data recorders have been used for a variety of commercial and
A&DT: What trends do you see in the speed and performance defense earth observation satellites, notably on NASA’s EMIT
of data recorders for future missions? mission, which is measuring methane emissions using in-or-
bit technology. In the near-term, we will be releasing a new,
Pribble: As more satellites are launched into space and satellite next-generation recorder with 4.5 TB of storage capacity. This
capabilities increase due to new launch technologies coming on higher-capacity drive will be offered in multiple variants to meet
orbit (such as Starship and New Glenn), I’d predict that speed the needs of customers across mission classes. Mercury is also
and performance requirements will only increase. Satellites looking at utilizing next-generation controllers and custom-de-
are hampered by trying to fit complicated systems into small signed space fiber interfaces to push speeds significantly higher
fairing volumes, which places strict SWaP constraints on its for future products.
systems. However, in the near future, the payloads going into
these satellites will increase capabilities due to larger available For more information, visit Mercury Systems, at mrcy.com/ssdr.

4 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


Certified Machine
Learning-Based Avionics
Unlocking Safer Aviation Autonomy

O
ver the past few decades, aircraft automation has raising significant barriers to commercial operations.
progressively increased. Advances in digital com- However, there has been rapid progress in this relation
puting during the 1980s eliminated the need for over the last two years. We are currently on the verge of
onboard flight engineers. Avionics systems, witnessing the first real-world ML applications approved
exemplified by FADEC for engine control and Fly-By-Wire, by aviation regulators making their way to the market–
handle lower-level functions, reducing human error. This and Daedalean and Xwing are among the first to
shift allows pilots to focus on higher-level tasks like naviga- deliver them.
tion and decision-making, enhancing overall safety.
Full automation and autonomous flight operations are a Certified Embedded Aerospace Computing:
logical continuation of this trend. Thanks to aerospace Overcoming the Challenges
pioneers, most functions for full autonomy are achievable NNs are extremely computationally demanding –
with legacy technologies. Machine learning (ML), espe- Daedalean’s visual traffic system, for instance, needs about
cially neural networks (NNs), will enable what Daedalean one Tera Operation per Second (TOPS), approximately
terms Situational Intelligence: the ability to understand double the power of the CPU’s integrated GPU or a fully
and make sense of the current environment and situation dedicated CPU core. A serious barrier to designing such
but also anticipate and react to a future situation, includ- high-performance systems for safety-critical applications
ing a future problem. By automating tasks traditionally for civil aerospace is that they need to be certified. A com-
Image: Blacklight_Trace

limited to human pilots – like detecting airborne traffic mon design assurance challenge is establishing determin-
and identifying safe landing locations – ML can raise safety istic behavior and guaranteeing mitigation of all potential
levels, lower costs, and increase fleet capacity. failure conditions. Doing so can be challenging with com-
Despite progress, integrating machine learning into pute-intensive ML algorithms and the highly complex
civilian aircraft cockpits faces certification challenges, devices necessary to process them.

6 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


Avionics

In 2023, Daedalean and Intel Corp.


jointly published the whitepaper “The
Future of Avionics: High Performance,
Machine-Learned, and Certified.” The
document proposes a collaboratively
developed reference architecture for cer-
tifiable embedded electronics. Key com-
ponents include the Daedalean Tensor
Accelerator (DTA) – a certifiable Convo-
lutional Neural Network (CNN) accelera-
tor designed with a DO-254-aligned pro-
cess – and the Intel® Agilex™ FPGA.
Agilex, based on advanced CMOS tech-
nology, offers increased computational
power on a single FPGA and lower power
consumption compared to any other
certifiable options available.
The proposed solution significantly
reduces time-to-market for companies
looking at incorporating Daedalean’s
ML applications for situational aware-
A conceptual view of Daedalean’s Situational Intelligence suite, which provides sensor-based traffic detec- ness. The reference architecture, though,
tion, navigation, and landing guidance. The display UI will vary by application and OEM. is valuable for any firm developing certi-
fiable embedded electronics for aero-
space and defense. Avionics systems
4x
VCU designers implementing ML into safe-
FPGA CoaXPress
Thumbnails IFD ARINC-429 ty-critical aerospace equipment should
GNSS & AHRS
view NNs as a new element. Some FPGA
Switches vendors provide tools automating NN
DDR controller IQM CoaXPress RX/TX
Ethernet controller SSD mapping on FPGAs, with reduced perfor-
mance compared to a bespoke solution.
PCIe bus
FPGA Developing systems subject to safety
AXI bus
assurance requires a handcrafted solu-
DRAM

I/O card
tion, and the proposed reference design
11th Gen
CROP IPP DTA PCIe Data Mover Intel® Core™
Northbridge
ARINC-735 traffic
helps to achieve improved performance
i7 processor
Intel® AgilexTM F-Series FPGA
while opening the way to certifying the
DRAM
ADSB-unit final product.
Daedalean AI Accelerator (DAIA) CPU board

Reference architecture of Daedalean’s mission computer based on the 11th Gen Intel Core™ i7 processor Certifying NNs: A Paradigm Shift in
and Intel Agilex F-Series FPGA. Software Assurance
When developing an ML-based applica-
tion, ‘classical’ code for tracking, monitor-
Safety Assessment Process
Intended Function
Guidelines & Methods
System Design ing, and inference coexists with the neural
is independent allocates Function
of the implementation (ARP 4761)
to Items independent networks. The DO-178C standard applies
of the implementation
Function, Failure System to this classical code. However, the prima-
& Safety Information Design
ry ML-driven function can’t undergo tra-
Functional System
Intended Aircraft System Development Processes ditional verification and validation. ML
Function (ARP 4754A)
model parameters, learned from data,
Functions & Requirements Implementation
Aircraft System
aren’t hand-coded or physics-derived, hin-
Development Process dering direct tracing of requirements to
code lines. This challenge disrupts the cur-
Hardware Development Lifecycle Hardware Lifecycle rent aerospace certification paradigm.
(DO-254) Process
AI Development In 2021, the European Union Aviation
First Usable Guidance
for L1 ML Applications Safety Agency (EASA) proposed AI/ML
Software Lifecycle
Software Development Lifecycle
(DO-178) Process
guidelines, partly informed by two
research studies conducted in collabora-
A reference architecture for the insertion of AI. tion with Daedalean. The 2020 and 2021
8 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Since 1898, we have partnered with the most
innovative companies in the world to solve
complex challenges and advance technology.

Our legacy of decades of expertise and


unrivaled reliability makes us the industry
leader in custom wire and cable solutions.

Manufacturing Custom Wire & Cable Solutions Since 1898

603-838-6624 • newenglandwire.com
Lisbon, New Hampshire USA
Avionics

In December 2023, the two companies


(Sub)system (Sub)system
announced a strategic collaboration to
requirements & design requirements verification share data, knowledge, and processes.
Both companies believe that forming a
Requirements allocated to ML ML requirements
consensus on their assurance approach-
constituent management verification es is the best way to advance the devel-
opment of and harmonize certification
Data Independent data standards and help all stakeholders,
management and learning verification
Learning process including the industry players, regula-
verification
tors, and the public, to speed up the path
Learning process Inference model to certifying AI systems.
management verification & integration

PilotEye: The Unprecedented ML


Model Model Application Set For Historic
training implementation
Certification
The first real-world use case that
The W-shaped development process and approach to developing ML-based avionics software Daedalean is bringing to the market in
partnership with Avidyne is a visual traf-
fic detection application marketed as
System System PilotEye™. The system will serve as an
requirements verification additional visual source of information
on air hazards, supplementing the ADS-B
(1a) Dataset (2b) Dataset and FLARM data. The product is capable
Requirements Verification
of detecting non-cooperative traffic,
such as birds, drones, gliders, and bal-
(2a) Data
Collection loons. Daedalean’s ML-enabled technol-
ogy integrates with Avidyne’s Skytrax™
(1b) Model (4a) Model Traffic Advisory System into the IFD5XX
Requirements Verification flight display series. A tablet screen shows
detailed information on any detected
(3a) Model intruders in the real-time video feed
Training
from three aircraft-mounted cameras.
(1c) Runtime (4b, 4c) Runtime
Collecting and presenting information
Requirements Verification from cameras, radars, and other types of
sensors is not enough for the task
(3b, 3c) Inference described above: it requires interpreting
Implementation
the data, i.e., recognition and categoriz-
ing, performed by a machine-learned
The 3-stage verification process of neural networks. model – a CNN.
The role of the CNN here is in answer-
joint reports explored adapting software the field. By functionally decomposing ing the question for each of the frames
design assurance for ML, introducing system-level requirements into ones relat- obtained from each of the cameras: is
Concepts of Design Assurance for Neural ed to the dataset and the learning algo- there an intruder (such as an aircraft or
Networks (CoDANN). A crucial insight rithm, Statistical Learning Theory meth- bird) on this image or not, and if yes,
was the W-shaped development process, ods can provide assurance on the system’s then categorizing it and evaluating its
modifying the classical V-shaped cycle behavior in its operational domain. size and the distance between the own-
and demonstrated using the example of This approach aligns with the modi- ship and an intruder.
Daedalean’s Visual Traffic Detection fied V-diagram independently proposed It is important to emphasize that no
application. In 2021, the FAA, in collabo- by Xwing in 2021. The verification is in-flight learning process occurs. Despite
ration wit h Daedalean, assessed decomposed here into similar stages: the common misconception, the pro-
CoDANN’s applicability to a real applica- data set, model, and inference. cess of training the CNN (tuning the
tion (Daedalean’s Visual Landing Guid- In October 2023, Xwing published weights of a statistical model processing
ance system), leading to a 2022 joint “Formal and Practical Elements for the the images of a training dataset present-
FAA-Daedalean report. Certification of Machine Learning Sys- ed to it) happens exclusively “in the lab.”
This process ensures that ML-based soft- tems,” with a more complete process and After the satisfactory performance (in
ware adheres to required safety standards an example certification argument for a terms of the percentage of errors in the
and maintains an acceptable error rate in runway detection model. answers compared to the known truth)
10 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Avionics

is achieved, the model is frozen, at which So, the process of exploring how to a rigid list of checkpoints to pass to
point it goes into production. So, the certify ML-learning-based software obtain the TC or STC doesn’t exist – so,
algorithm performed in the flying prod- systems by the regulators, using this no estimations of when the certifica-
uct may be considered deterministic, first case, is going at full speed. The tion may be granted can be stated, but
meaning that given the same input, it DO-178C compliance audit has always the effort of the regulators and their
will always produce the same output. been object-oriented and flexible, and commitment to put the full attention
PilotEye is poised to become EASA’s –
and possibly the world’s – first certified
civil aviation cockpit application with a Version Control
machine-learned component. The appli- Real-world
data
cation will be certified to the DAL-C level Data
Metadata Datasplit
Training logs
Software
Architecture
Hyperparameters Deployment Metrics Reqmts
configuration reports
by the FAA and to the “advanced pilot Annotations Dependencies Weights

assistance” level according to EASA’s clas-


sification of the levels of autonomy.
In December 2021, Avidyne submitted Raw
Labeling Indexing
Train./Val.
Training
Failure
Data Data Model Inference Evaluation Probability
an STC application for the product to
the FAA with concurrent validation by
EASA. In 2023, EASA’s delegation made a Synthetic
several-day visit to Daedalean as a part of data
Test
the stages-of-involvement (SOI) audit – a Data

key component of the DO-178C certifi-


cation process, which ensures that soft-
ware development is conducted in com- Xwing’s model-agnostic and tool-independent framework applicable to a wide variety of use cases, data
pliance with the standard. types, and ML architectures (Image: Xwing)

Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 11


Avionics

Tablet
optional IFD5XX

r
we
+ Po
ta
Da
VXS Daedalean Camera 3
looking sideways

Camera 1
looking forward
er eo
ow Vid am
+P e
ta str
Da

Camera 2 Skytrax
looking sideways Avidyne

The principal scheme of the system integration for PilotEye.

on the case is apparent. We will see this system enabling fully uncrewed opera- onboard to monitor the system, Xwing
product launched to the market not tions since 2016. In March 2023, Xwing is the only player in this space currently
before the regulators are fully assured submitted the world’s first certifica- cer t if ying an autonomy system
of its safety and fitness for purpose, and tion plan for a normal category type enabling the removal of the pilot from
we expect it to happen only as swiftly as cer tified air plane UA modification the cockpit. The Xwing system not only
the process allows. (STC) . The system is currently getting handles nominal cases, but is also capa-
FAA-certified on a Cessna Grand Cara- ble of covering all contingencies that a
Xwing Superpilot: Leading the Charge van aircraft. human pilot would be required to. On
on Uncrewed Aircraft Certification While a variety of other companies top of that, the human now sits in a
Xwing has been developing Super- are developing safety-enhancing fea- ground station and oversees the flight,
pilot, an aircraft agnostic autonomy tures that require the pilot to remain thereby adding yet another safety layer.
Xwing decided to pursue this full auton-
omy direction to maximize safety and
offer an enticing product to the com-
mercial, non-transport aviation indus-
try, especially cargo operations.
The Xwing system is designed to be
aircraft agnostic, can autonomously fly
the full mission of the plane, and can
deal with contingencies to get the air-
craft to the ground, even in rare cases
where the remote pilot is unable to com-
municate with the aircraft.

ML-based Systems Will Revolutionize


Aviation Safety
The g radual increase in aircraft
autonomy, marked by advances in avi-
onic systems, has laid the groundwork
for the logical progression toward auto-
Visual traffic detection – the development application view. mation and fully autonomous flight
12 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Avionics

operations. Close collaboration of the


industry with regulators is critical to lead
this transformative journey that prom-
ises to revolutionize safety, efficiency,
and autonomy in aviation. As certified
ML applications become integral to avi-
ation, the industry stands on the thresh-
old of a new era where technology and
safety converge to redefine the possibili-
ties and potential of autonomous flight.
Auto Taxi Detect and Avoid
Daedalean and Xwing are proud to be
among those helping the industry stride
across that threshold and deliver on the
promise of a revolutionary future.

This article was written by Luuk van


Dijk, Ph.D., CEO, Daedalean; Yemaya
Bordain, Ph.D., President of the Ameri-
cas, Daedalean; Jean-Guillaume Durand,
Ph.D., Head of Perception, Xwing; and
Arthur Dubois, VP of Engineering and
Emergency Handling Vision Based Landing
Programs, Xwing. For more informa-
tion, visit www.daedalean.ai and
Xwing’s Superpilot autonomy system. (Image: Xwing) www.xwing.com.

MACHFORCE
Aerospace half page adTechnology,
& Defense Jan24.indd 1 February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 1/4/2024 1:59:36 PM 13
Image: ZinetroN

14 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


Revolutionizing
Electronic Warfare:
Unleashing the Power
of High-Performance
Software-Defined Radios

I
n the ever-evolving landscape of electronic warfare (EW),
the imperative for technological prowess has never been
more pronounced. At the vanguard of this evolution stands
a technological marvel— high-performance software
defined radios (SDRs). This article provides on an in-depth
exploration of the transformative potential embedded in SDRs,
focusing on their remarkable attributes of very high band-
widths, wide tuning ranges, and high channel counts. From
the foundational principles of SDRs to their nuanced applica-
tions in modern warfare, this narrative endeavors to unravel
the complexities and possibilities presented by these cut-
ting-edge systems.

Background to Software Defined Radios (SDRs)


The traditional architecture of radio systems, bound by fixed
functionalities and hardware constraints, has given way to a new
era defined by the flexibility of software defined radios. At its
core, an SDR replaces hardware-defined functions with software
applications, affording engineering and research facilities
unprecedented flexibility and adaptability in electronic environ-
ments. This transformative approach ensures rapid adjustments
and real-time reconfigurations, aligning seamlessly with the
unpredictable nature of modern electronic warfare.
At the forefront of their design is the radio front end, a criti-
cal component that directly interfaces with the analog signals.
High performance SDRs boast high-quality, wideband RF front
ends, equipped with advanced analog-to-digital converters
(ADCs) and low-noise amplifiers; with digital-to-analog con-
verters (DAC) for transmit functionality. This ensures a broad
frequency coverage and excellent signal reception sensitivity.
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 15
Electronic Warfare

quencies concurrently, surpassing the


limitations of traditional radio sys-
tems. Enhanced sig nal recept ion,
rapid analysis, and the ability to adapt
to diverse communication protocols
in real-time characterize the versatility
unleashed by high bandwidth SDRs. In
an era where the ability to maneuver
swiftly is paramount, these systems
Cyan is an example of a high bandwidth software defined radio. (Image: Per Vices Corporation) emerge as force multipliers, providing
military forces with a distinct advan-
tage in the dynamic theatre of elec-
tronic warfare.

Real-Time Adaptability: Wide Tuning


Ranges in Action
The real-time adaptability of SDRs,
particularly those equipped with wide
tuning ranges, marks a significant stride
in countering the dynamic and sophis-
ticated nature of electronic threats.
Wide tuning ranges empower these sys-
tems to swiftly navigate across a broad
frequency spectrum, ensuring that mil-
itary forces can adjust and respond in
real-time to emerging threats. This agil-
ity plays a pivotal role in enhancing the
effectiveness of electronic countermea-
sures, presenting a proactive stance
against adversaries employing agile
As systems become more interconnected, this improves communication, but can also cause cybersecurity electronic tactics.
risks. (Image: Shutterstock) Consider a scenario where an adver-
sary rapidly changes communication
The radio front end is meticulously engi- A key aspect of high performance SDRs frequencies to evade detection. Tradi-
neered to handle various signal types, architecture is the meticulous attention tional systems may struggle to keep
allowing users to adapt the SDR to differ- to timing precision. Accurate timing is pace, but an SDR with a wide tuning
ent applications seamlessly, from spec- paramount in SDR applications, especial- range can seamlessly adapt, ensuring
trum monitoring to signal jamming. ly in scenarios where synchronization is that the military force maintains aware-
In the digital domain, high perfor- critical, such as in multi-antenna and ness and control in the face of these
mance SDRs showcase a robust architec- phased arrays. High end SDRs incorpo- dynamic challenges.
ture that maximizes processing power rate advanced timing synchronization
and efficiency. The digital component of mechanisms, leveraging precision clock- Maximizing Information Capture: The
SDRs is usually characterized by powerful ing and synchronization protocols. This Role of High Channel Counts
field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) ensures that multiple SDRs can operate In the realm of electronic warfare,
and high-speed digital signal processors seamlessly together, synchronized to a information is power. SDRs equipped
(DSPs). These components enable real- common clock reference. The precision with high channel counts play a pivotal
time processing of incoming signals, pro- in timing enhances the overall reliability role in maximizing information capture.
viding users with the ability to implement and coherence of the SDR system, mak- These systems can process numerous sig-
complex algor it hms, modulat ion ing it well-suited for the demands associ- nals simultaneously, leading to an expo-
schemes, and demodulation techniques. ated with EW applications. nential increase in situational aware-
The flexibility of the digital architecture ness. Military commanders are thus
empowers users to customize their SDRs Foundation of Versatility: Very High provided with a comprehensive under-
for specific tasks, making them suitable Bandwidths standing of the electronic battlefield,
for a wide range of applications within The linchpin of SDRs’ effectiveness allowing for more infor med deci-
EW including electromagnetic attack lies in their ver y high bandwidths. sion-making and effective allocation of
(EA), electromagnetic warfare support This attribute enables these systems to resources in response to complex elec-
(ES), and electromagnetic protection (EP). process an extensive spectrum of fre- tronic scenarios.
16 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Electronic Warfare

Imagine a scenario where a military force faces a multifacet-


ed electronic attack involving jamming, communication inter-
ference, and radar deception. An SDR with high channel counts
can effectively discern and prioritize these disparate signals,
empowering the military to formulate a targeted and precise
counter-strategy.
The integration of high-performance SDRs into military
operations marks a paradigm shift in electronic warfare strate-
gies. The agility and adaptability offered by these advanced sys-
tems provide a crucial edge in countering electronic threats,
ensuring that military forces can stay one step ahead of adver-
saries. As electronic systems become increasingly integral to
military operations, the role of SDRs in shaping and executing
effective strategies continues to grow.
Consider the scenario of a dynamic electronic battlefield
where an adversary deploys sophisticated electronic warfare
tactics. High-performance SDRs empower military forces to
rapidly assess the threat landscape, adapt countermeasures in
real-time, and maintain a proactive stance, ultimately tipping
the scales in favor of the defending force.
Rivetless Nutplates
Looking Ahead: The Trajectory of Electronic Warfare Go from three holes to one.
As we look to the future, the trajectory of electronic warfare
points towards continual advancements in SDR technology.
The refinement of these systems will likely result in even great-
er bandwidths, wider tuning ranges, and more sophisticated
functionalities. This trajectory will solidify high-performance
SDRs as indispensable assets on the modern battlefield, under-
lining their pivotal role in ensuring military superiority in the
complex and dynamic landscape of electronic warfare.
Consider the prospect of future SDRs equipped with artificial Surface Mounts
intelligence (AI) capabilities, enabling autonomous decision-mak- Rivetless Nutplates
Go from one hole to none.
ing in response to electronic threats. These intelligent systems Go from three holes to one.
could revolutionize the speed and efficiency with which military
forces counter electronic adversaries, ushering in a new era of war-
fare characterized by unprecedented levels of adaptability and
sophistication.
The symbiotic relationship between technology and strategy
is evident in the integration of high-performance SDRs into
electronic warfare frameworks. Military strategies are evolving
to leverage the capabilities offered by these advanced systems, Sleeves
with a focus on proactive threat assessment, real-time adapt- Holes?
ability, and comprehensive information superiority. The inter- If you’ve got ’em, protect ’em.
section of technology and strategy becomes the crucible where
the potency of SDRs is fully realized, paving the way for a more
agile, responsive, and effective military force.
Consider a scenario where a military force, armed with
high-performance SDRs, engages in a complex electronic bat-
tle. The strategy involves rapid analysis of incoming signals,
dynamic adjustment of communication frequencies, and pre- Adhesive-Bonded
cise countermeasures tailored to the specific electronic threats Assembly Technology
encountered. This synergy between technology and strategy
exemplifies the transformative impact of SDRs on the modern WWW.CLICKBOND.COM/AD40
battlefield.
#NoMoreHoles
While the advantages of high-performance SDRs in electronic
warfare are undeniable, it is crucial to acknowledge the challeng-
es and considerations inherent in their implementation. Cyber-
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 17
Electronic Warfare

security concerns, spectrum manage- tage in the competitive landscape of the ability to navigate the complexities
ment, and the need for interoperability electronic warfare. of contemporary warfare with unparal-
with existing systems are among the fac- The geopolitical significance of tech- leled adaptability. As we venture into an
tors that demand careful attention. The nological superiority in this domain era where the intersection of technolo-
trajectory of SDR development must nav- extends beyond individual conflicts to gy and strategy defines the battlefield,
igate these challenges to ensure seamless shape the broader balance of power high-performance SDRs emerge as the
integration into military operations. among nations. vanguard of innovation, shaping the
Consider the challenge of securing Consider the geopolitical scenario future of warfare on a global scale.
SDRs against cyber threats. As these sys- where two technologically advanced Consider the profound implications
tems become increasingly intercon- nations engage in a strategic competi- of a future battlefield where electronic
nected and reliant on software applica- tion. The nation with superior SDR threats are met with real-time adaptabil-
tions, the risk of cyber vulnerabilities capabilities not only holds an advan- ity, comprehensive information superi-
escalates. Robust cybersecurity mea- tage in electronic warfare scenarios but ority, and strategic agility. High-perfor-
sures and constant vigilance are imper- also asserts its technological prowess on mance SDRs, with their transformative
ative to safeguard the integrity and the global stage, influencing diplomatic capabilities, stand at the forefront of
effectiveness of SDRs in the face of negotiations and alliances. this evolution, heralding a new era
evolving cyber threats. In conc lusion, t he mar r iage of where technological prowess is the key
high-performance software defined to triumph in the complex and dynamic
Global Implications: SDRs in radios with very high bandwidths, wide landscape of electronic warfare.
International Security tuning ranges, and high channel counts
The global implications of SDRs in the represents a pivotal moment in elec- This article was written by Brandon
realm of international security are pro- tronic warfare. Military forces leverag- Malatest, COO, Per Vices Corporation. For
found. Nations equipped with advanced ing these technological advances gain more information, visit www.pervices.
SDR capabilities gain a strategic advan- not only a decisive advantage but also com.

deltron.com
Linear Motion Specialists 800-245-5013

Standard & Custom


Engineered
Linear Motion
for the
Aerospace &
Defense Industry
Del-Tron manufactures standard and
custom slides and products for use in
aircraft interiors, imaging systems, missile
systems, pilot helmets and surveillance
systems to name a few and are a US based
Custom Engineered Linear Slides DL Linear Actuators
company making us a domestic source Linear Slides Ball & Crossed Roller Lead Screw/Ball Screw Driven
manufacturer for linear motion projects
that require materials and manufacturing
to be sourced within the United States.

Order Today! 800.245.5013 • deltron.com MADE IN USA ISO 9001:2015/AS9100D CERTIFIED

18 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


Cutting-edge Reliable and customizable
solutions for mission
Connectivity critical unmanned applications

We offer:

Board-Level Ferrites Radio


Components and Frequency
Waveguides Filters

Isolators and RF Cable Rugged


Circulators Assemblies Embedded
and Harnesses Transceivers

Please visit us at AUVSI/Xponential more > smithsinterconnect.com


San Diego, CA Booth #3549
Deterministic and
Modular Architecture
for Embedded Vehicle Systems

T
he next generation of Army Traditional Ethernet based networks and complements them with embedded
ground vehicle systems aim are unable to satisfy the strict safety and virtualization technologies to enhance
to provide the warfighter with functional requirements for Army vehicle the safety and security of the system.
advanced capabilities while systems due to this lack of determinism. The seL4 microkernel is used to deploy
ensuring cyber resiliency. One key tech- Modular Open System Approach (MOSA) virtualized guests and containers on a
nology, Ethernet, has enabled the mod- initiatives such as the Ground Combat target representative of an embedded
ernization of military ground vehicles System Common Infrastructure Architec- platform for ground vehicle electron-
by providing a broad range of beneficial ture (GCIA) seek to leverage open-stan- ics, the ARMv8. By utilizing seL4 and
features. The scalability and high band- dards such as Time Sensitive Networking virtualized guests, a system designer
width of an Ethernet based system pro- (TSN) to achieve real-time, deterministic can now combine the isolation provid-
vides the ability to process large volumes communication over Ethernet. TSN pro- ed by hypervisors with the logical seg-
of sensor data with low latency, how- vides enhancements to regular Ethernet mentation provided by TSN to create a
ever its inherent lack of determinism which enable logical segmentation of partitioned architecture that increases
represents a significant disadvantage. deterministic and traditional best-effort system assurance. Aspects of this archi-
A deterministic network requires that network traffic while simultaneously be tectural approach and technology
Image: U.S. Army

communication assurance is provided transmitted on the same physical media. have already been adapted across mul-
through bounded message latency, and This research presents a reference tiple programs within the U.S. Army
this is required for many ground vehicle architecture which incorporates key DEVCOM Ground Vehicle Systems Cen-
weapon and crew stations functions. elements from GCIA, including TSN, ter (DEVCOM-GVSC).
20 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Embedded Computing

Background One response to these demands in in a mathematical language called high-


In the last decade a key enabler for recent years is hypervisor-based tech- er order logic (HOL). The HOL specifi-
next generation automotive and indus- nology, however traditional enterprise cation in this case is represented by the
trial system hardware/software designs hypervisors do not provide the assur- abstract model in Figure 1.
has been virtualization. Modern embed- ance or real-time performance needed to The C implementation is then a
ded systems that utilize the ARM, x86, support mixed criticality applications. refinement of the abstract model, mean-
or RISCV architectures are now equipped The seL4 microkernel can serve as an ing that the possible behaviors of the
with virtual extensions. These exten- embedded hypervisor that can support C code are a subset of those allowed by
sions were the response to market pres- the deployment of high assurance soft- the abstract model. Kernel behavior is
sures to minimize size, weight, power, ware through its unique and compre- expressed by the abstract specification,
and cost (SWaP-C). hensive formal verification. thus preventing the kernel from behav-
Software designers are now able to Formal proofs of correctness make ing in ways that are not allowed by the
architect a system capable of enforcing seL4 a strong candidate for building safe- specification. A kernel that is formally
isolation of disparate compute domains ty-critical and secure systems. Figure 1 verified, such as seL4, can then shield
while executing on the same hardware. illustrates the seL4 proof chain. The core itself from attacks such as stack smash-
They’re also able to provide a system capa- of seL4’s verification is the functional ing, nullpointer dereference, and any
ble of rapidly scaling and updating with correctness proof, which claims that the code injection or control flow-hijacking.
an existing DevSecOps pipeline and adapt C implementation is free of implemen- As a part of the formally verified proof,
to new industry best practices by deploy- tation defects. The formal specification seL4 also provides a way to additionally
ing improved capabilities (i.e. TSN). of the kernel’s functionality is expressed verify the executable binary produced by
the compiler. Verifying the executable
binary is an additional security-critical
Confidentiality Integrity Availability
step to prevent malicious compilers from
performing such actions such as build-
ing a Trojan that opens a back door to
Proof Proof Proof
the OS. Specifically, the binary is proved
to be a correct translation of the proved
correct C code.
Abstract The proof chain illustrated in Figure 2
Model is an automatic process that happens in
multiple stages. A formal model of the
Proof processor’s Instruction Set Architecture
(ISA) formalizes the binary in the theo-
rem prover. The formalized ISA feeds the
C Implementation disassembler, written in the HOL4 the-
orem prover, to translate the low-level
representation into a higher-level rep-
Proof resentation in a graph language that
represents control flow. The formalized
C program is then translated into the
same graph language which allows for
Binary Code
comparison of two programs to assess for
equivalent representation.
Figure 1: An architecture showing a seL4 Proof Chain. One of the goals of this project was
to provide documented and reusable
software modules that can be ported
Formalized to various hardware platforms. Various
C Code C Code
Formal
C Semantics hardware platforms can take the form of
Rewrite a different architecture alltogether (x86,
Rules
ARM, RISCV, etc.) or it can mean a dif-
Compiler Graph
SMT Solver
Graph
ferent platform within the same family
Language Language of architecture. For example, this effort
Disassembler
utilized a total of four development kits
Formal ISA Specification
to develop the software capabilities dis-
Binary Code Formalized cussed in this research. The four devel-
Binary
opment kits used were all based on the
Figure 2: Translation validation proof chain. Zynq architecture.
22 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Embedded Computing

Security Properties and Hypervisor and support the kinds of logical seg- mented with technologies such as CAN,
Design mentation identified as a key objective MIL-STD-1553, RS-422, and/or point-to-
Figure 1 illustrates the proofs between in the DoD’s Zero Trust Strategy that point discrete signals. These interfaces
t he abstract specificat ion and t he was released in November 2022. Tradi- are all prime candidates to be integrated
high-level security properties: confiden- tionally, military ground vehicle control with, and eventually replaced with, this
tiality, integrity, and availability. These applications and functions are imple- emerging architecture.
properties are subsets of the abstract
specification and build in security to the
kernel. seL4 provides the ability for a sys-
tem architect to implement a hypervisor
and virtual machine monitors (VMMs)
capable of deploying isolated virtual
machines (VMs) as notionally illustrated
in Figure 3.
The design paradigm depicted in Fig-
ure 3 demonstrates a high-level overview
of the type of hardware and software
configuration designed to meet SWAP-C
requirements. At the lowest level of this
architecture is the target hardware. In
this case the target hardware used for
this effort was the ARMv8, however,
it can be applied to x86 and RISC-V as
well. Software abstraction is applied to
achieve a Type 1 hypervisor model. This
type of software abstraction enables log-
ical partitioning of compute domains in
the form of guest VMs.

Army Use Cases and Objectives


The current state of combat ground
vehicle design is undergoing a paradigm
Turning ideas into solutions
shift. Capabilities in the form of sen- drive systems from one single source
sors, processors, and effectors are now
At maxon, we develop and build high precision electric drive systems that are
designed to share hardware and com- among the best in the world. We combine brushed and brushless DC motors,
pute resources all while maintaining a gearheads, sensors, and controllers into complete mechatronic drive systems.
continuous update/upgrade cycle. Fig-
Our drives provide high torque, high efficiency and are extremely compact.
ure 4 illustrates major elements of the For more information, please visit: www.maxongroup.us
GCIA including the relevant network,
I/O adapter, crewstation, and common
compute components.
The scope of effort in this research
enables GCIA, as the SmartIO platform
to be used as a Crewstation, Common
Compute or I/O Adapter and is TSN-en-
abled. SmartIO converts discrete I/O sig-
nals to TSN messages to be distributed
to multiple end nodes. The end nodes
in this case include both the virtualized
guests executing in disparate compute
domains — example given in Figure 3 — maxon precision motors, inc.
and other TSN end stations connected 125 Dever Drive, Taunton, MA 02780
Telephone: 508 677 0520
to the TSN bridge. www.maxongroup.us
The military ground vehicle use-cases email: info.us@maxongroup.com
and scenarios where this type of mod- Precision Drive Systems
ern, partitioned, and deterministic
architecture is applicable are numerous
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 23
Embedded Computing

A ground vehicle system is entirely process, transmit, and receive sensor out the entire system. Another benefit
made up of complex subsystems. The data distributed throughout the vehi- of conforming I/O with virtual interfac-
reference architecture developed in this cle. Distributed processing and I/O es is the reusability and portability of
effort utilized a combination of virtu- in this context mean that the system that software across different comput-
alized I/O interfaces and TSN to enable must have the ability to route hardware ing architectures (i.e. x86, RISC-V, etc.).
the common compute i.e., SmartIO, to peripheral data, such as CAN, through- Vir tualized conformant I/O also
enables security enhancements for a
more hardened posture. seL4 provides
great access control of hardware com-
ponents within VM(s) to prevent any
Critical Non-Critical Non-Critical undesired access from one subsystem
to another. Finally, virtualized confor-
RTOS OS OS mant I/O provides a lower attack sur-
face by virtue of SWAP-C requirements.
VMM VMM VMM With one common compute platform
the lower physical footprint results in a
smaller attack surface for an Intrusion
Software Abstraction Detection System (IDS) to monitor.

Future Improvements
TSN benchmarking indicated that
seL4 there is a need to investigate how to
obtain performance gains within the
Target Hardware seL4 microkernel. Naturally, due to vir-
tualization, there is an expectation of
some performance degradation with
respect to TSN benchmarking; howev-
Figure 3: The seL4 Hypervisor Mode is outlined here. er, the results indicate that beyond the

Sensors/ Controllers Effectors/


Receivers Transmitters Portable Software Applications

GCIA OSS
360 CIS CDS
Interface Capability
GCIA FACE Portable Components Segement (G-PCS)
Components
GCIA TS Interface
Software
Common Time GCIA FACE Transport Services Segment (G-TSS)
Infrastructure GCIA OSS
Interface
GCIA TS Interface

CIS CDS GCIA OSS


Vehicle Network/ GCIA FACE Platform-Specific Services Segment (G-PSSS) Interface
Data Sharing
Software GCIA IOS Interface
I/O Infrastructure
Adapter Network GCIA FACE I/O Services Segment (G-IOSS)
Switch GCIA OSS
Interface
GCIA FACE Operationg System Segment (G-OSS)

*Data
Storage Common Infrastructure
Common
Computing
Crew Station
Computing
Display/HMI (GCIA 2.0)
Automotive Saftey Infrastructure
Subsystems Cybersecurity Infrastructure
& Actuators

GCIA Network

Legacy
*To be further defined in future revisions
Platform

Figure 4: The GCIA architecture.

24 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


Embedded Computing

effects of virtualization there are perfor- interrupt framework is the likely candi- One improvement to this design could
mance degradations because of the seL4 date to start such work. include the option to boot from eMMC
kernel. It is currently up for investigation As of now this implementation does not with the option to include a fallback image
to determine the root cause and initial provide a way to boot into a failsafe mode in the event of authentication failure. In
discussions seem to indicate that the if authentication fails during secure boot. the same vein, the addition of a Trusted
Platform Module (TPM) would provide
the ability for a system architect to deploy
measured boot. Measured boot enables the
embedded system to have a configurable
secure boot mode that allows for the log-
ging of failures to authenticate with the
option to halt/proceed boot. A TPM also
provides a system designer the means to
implement advanced health monitoring
techniques: remote attestation and real
time introspection, to executing processes.

This article was written by Michael


Doran, Embedded Software Engineer,
DornerWorks, and Mark Russell, Embed-
ded Systems Branch Chief, U.S. Army
DEVCOM Ground Vehicle Systems Cen-
Figure 5: The UEI SmartIO platform, which is based on the AMD Zynq architecture was the target platform ter. For more information, visit www.
for this research effort. usarmygvsc.com.

Ruggedized micro-miniature LAND


$u-1hbm]!-7-uv
W AT E R
!-7-u†b7;7bvvbѴ;v
AIR
uo-71-v|
S PAC E
bvvbѴ;)-umbm]
COMMAND
"†b7;7uঞѴѴ;u‹

bm|;u1omm;1|voѴ†ঞomv=ou -v;u -ŒŒѴ;u


-v;u†b7;7†mbঞom
! ";mvouv
-v;uollv
!-7-u 
 "b]m-Ѵv
SATCOM
$"b]m-Ѵv
ISR
!†b7;7bvvbѴ;v
b]_o‰;ub1uo‰-ˆ;v

_b]_u;Ѵb-0bѴb|‹-rrѴb1-ঞomvĺ
lm;ঞ1vĽ1omm;1|ouv-u;ruoˆ;m|o7;Ѵbˆ;u
;Š1;rঞom-Ѵr;u=oul-m1;bm;Š|u;l;;mˆbuoml;m|v
=oulbvvbomŊ1ubঞ1-Ѵ-rrѴb1-ঞomvĺ

MICRO - D NANO - D

NANO STRIP HIGH SPEED

 $   " ĺ   
" "Š $"ĺ

Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 25


Approximating the Material Stresses
and System Requirements for
Hypersonic Flight
T
he flow fields around a flight called “The Heat Barrier.” Real gas effects creating a condition where the pressure
vehicle at hypersonic speeds are come into play at hypersonic speeds due waves stack up very close to the flight
markedly different from those to these high temperatures, and include body. These stacked up pressure waves
at both subsonic and supersonic vibrational excitation, dissociation, form a bow shock very close to the flight
speeds. The hypersonic regime is not at a chemical reactions, and ionization. The body, where viscous heating occurs due
discrete speed but evolves over a contin- underlying cause of this change in the to shear forces. These high-temperature
uum as speed increases, but is generally flow fields is that the pressure waves cre- gases close to the flight body surface lead
defined as a speed of Mach 5 or higher. ated by the body moving through the to the high heat fluxes and high surface
The flow fields around a vehicle cause atmosphere can only travel at the speed temperatures found in hypersonic flight.
the resultant high temperatures and of sound. The flow fields near the surface are
high heat fluxes for the flight system/ It is these pressure waves that travel plagued by nonequilibrium and/or
materials during hypersonic flight, and ahead of the body and shape the flow chaotic thermodynamic conditions,
these stressors in hypersonic flight are field far from the body of a subsonic where the temperature of the surfaces
vehicle. At hypersonic speeds, the pres- affects the flow field, thus affecting the
sure waves have virtually no time to temperature and so on. The problem
propagate away from the flight body, of hypersonic flight is an exceeding-
ly complex dynamic process, in that
there is an interplay among the chem-
ical changes to the surfaces, the chang-
es in emissivity, surface temperatures,
impact damage, and the flow fields,
which all interact and feed back on one

(Image: U.S. Army)

26 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


The big name in miniature components.
Transformers & Inductors,
DC-DC Converters, AC-DC Power Supplies
The most demanding applications require the world’s most reliable components. For over 50 years PICO
Electronics has been providing innovative COTS and custom solutions for Military, Commercial, Aerospace
and Industrial applications. Our innovative miniature and sub-miniature components are unsurpassed in any
industry. PICO Electronics’ products are proudly manufactured in the USA and are AS9100D Certified.
To learn more about our products and how you can benefit from our expertise
visit our website at picoelectronics.com or call us today at 800-431-1064.
think...
low profile
from
TRANSFORMERS & INDUCTORS
Think Pico Small - .18" ht.

Over 5000 Std Ultra Miniature


• Ultra Miniature Designs
• MIL-PRF-27/MIL-PRF-21038
• QPL Approved DSCC


Audio/Pulse/Power/EMI Multiplex Models Available
For Critical Applications, Pico Continues to
Surface Mount & Thru Hole
Be the Industry Standard Certified to
AS9100D Military • COTS • Industrial
ISO 9001:2015

DC-DC CONVERTERS
2V to 10,000 VDC Outputs —
1-300 Watt Modules
• MIL/COTS/Industrial Models
• Regulated/Isolated/Adjustable
Programmable Standard Models
• New High Input Voltages to 900VDC
• AS9100D Facility/US Manufactured
• Military Upgrades and Custom Modules Available

PICO Electronics Inc.


143 Sparks Ave, Pelham, NY 10803
Call Toll Free: 800-431-1064
E Mail: Info@picoelectronics.com • FAX: 914-738-8225

VISIT OUR EXCITING NEW WEBSITE: www.picoelectronics.com


Hypersonic

another. Although computer modeling bulence and lead to greater heat trans- This should make clear that the con-
has made great advances, this inter- fer (aerodynamic heating) than what ditions along the surface of a hypersonic
play cannot be accurately modeled cur- would be found in the same structure in body are specific to that object’s geome-
rently. Also, there are no experimental an atmospheric test flight. try and defects. Further, even the abla-
facilities that can simulate all the flow Manufacturing variations can also lead tion process itself can lead to sufficient
conditions that are experienced during to changes in the gas flow over surfaces and structural changes that alter the gas
hypersonic flight. Even in cases where alter localized aerodynamic heating creat- flow over the surface, thereby altering
the flight conditions can be achieved, ing unexpected hotspots. The ablative heat the deposition of heat to the structure,
it is well known that the acoustic noise shield tiles on the shuttle had to be hand which in turn alters the ablation rates,
from the walls of the wind tunnel can mounted to insure an exacting degree of thus requiring intensive computer mod-
alter the formation of shock waves. 2 uniformity. It was found that the pro- eling and, in particular, actual flight
This results in increased turbulent flow trusion of a single tile by as little as 1 mm testing to truly evaluate how a particular
on the different areas of the surfaces would result in distortions of the shock design will perform.
being tested depending on how these wave downstream and resulted in unex-
acoustic waves interfere, constructively pected hot spots that caused significant The Mach Cone
or destructively. This can increase tur- changes in the ablation rates of the tiles. In 1936, Maccoll conducted experi-
ments to image the Mach cone of anti-
tank rounds traveling at supersonic
velocities. Some of the photographs
captured by Maccoll are shown in Figure
1. In the image on the top left, labeled
Mach 1.06, the bow shock wave can be
clearly observed to be out in front (left)
of the point of the anti-tank round.
There is a significant separation between
the shock wave and the tip of the round.
Also, the large radius of curvature of the
shock wave results in a large volume
of air in between the anti-tank round
and the shock wave. In the next photo
(top right), labeled Mach 1.16, the bow
shock appears very close to the apex of
the round. In addition, the radius of
curvature has significantly decreased
in comparison with Mach 1.06 and the
shock wave has taken on the shape of
a very blunt cone. With the progres-
sion to higher speeds, the angle of the
bow shock, to the axial direction of the
round, continues to decrease from Mach
1.231 to Mach 1.321 and then to Mach
1.576. Finally, at Mach 1.794, we see the
smallest angle of the bow shock to the
round’s axial direction.
Figure 2 shows the annotated photo of
the anti-tank round at Mach 1.794. The
tilting angle (θ) of the bow shock is with
respect to the centerline (dashed white
line) of the anti-tank round. The compo-
nents of the free stream velocity (V∞) are
shown, where VPerp is the component
perpendicular to the shock front and
VPar is the component along or parallel
to the shock front.
The angle at which the perpendicular
component (VPerp) is equal to Mach 1
Figure 1: Images of bow shock at different speeds of an anti-tank round. is the angle at which the Mach cone or
28 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Hypersonic

Figure 2: Annotated image of bow shock at Mach 1.794 showing the bow shock angle and components of
free stream velocity.

shock front forms. In Eq. 1, the angle tile. This causes a trapped region of gas
(θ) of the Mach cone can be solved for between the shock wave, where gases are
a given free stream velocity (V∞), where decelerated (heated), and the body of
VPerp is set to 1. This equation, Eq. 1, for the projectile. The stagnation tempera-
the shock front cone angle is applicable ture of this gas tends to be very high at
to slender bodies: θ= sin−1 (Vperp/V∞). hypersonic speeds. The close proximity
For the case of the projectile in Figure of these hot gases, and the resultant heat
2 with a free stream velocity of Mach load, to the flight vehicle is the main
1.794, the predicted Mach cone angle is material and engineering challenge to
49.2°. From a cursory visual inspection, hypersonic flight.
one can readily see that this is in reason-
able agreement with the experimental Aerodynamic Heating
angle of the shock wave in Figure 2. The ideal gas law consists of three
This decreasing tilt of the Mach cone main components, where P is the pres-
with increasing free stream velocity is sure; V is the volume; n is the number
a major factor in driving the character- of mols; R is the ideal gas law constant,
istics of hypersonic flight, specifically which is the product of the Boltzmann
aerodynamic heating. In Figure 3, a plot constant and Avogadro’s number; and
of Eq. 1 is shown where the x-axis is finally T is the temperature, represented
the Mach number and the y-axis is the as PV = nRT. The ideal gas law is derived
respective Mach cone angle (as shown by assuming a gas has 3 degrees of free-
in Figure 2). As hypersonic speeds are dom. Shock-induced heating that occurs
attained, the Mach cone angle becomes during hypersonic flight causes the gases
very small. For a slender body at Mach to deviate from this law. The underlying
5, the Mach cone angle is predicted to cause is the fact that R is dependent on
be 11.5 °. Clearly at the speed of Mach 5, Boltzmann’s constant. Implicit in the
the Mach cone or shock wave will come calculation of Boltzmann’s constant are
very close to the surface of the projec- the degrees of freedom that a gas mole-
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 29
Hypersonic

Monteverde et al. examined t he


mechanical properties of zirconium
diboride–silicon carbide (SiC) matrix
composites. The density of the compos-
ites was found to be between 5.51 and
6.09 g/cm3 dependent on the SiC weight
percent (5 to 20 wt). The modulus E was
found to be between 518 and 477 GPa,
the fracture toughness was between 4.49
and 5.42 MPaM 1/2, the hardness was
between 19.3 and 21.7 GPa, and Pois-
son’s ratio was between 0.103 and 0.117.
It should be noted that at these high
Mach numbers, as a droplet transits the
shock wave, it will tend to dissipate due
to sheer forces and heating. Droplets
will also tend to become elongated per-
pendicular to the direction of motion,
becoming disc-like and spreading any
force out over a larger area thus reduc-
ing damage. Additionally, the angle
between the water disc and the pro-
jectile’s surface will affect the area the
impacting disc is spread out over as well
as reduce the normal component of the
impact force. This indicates that a lead-
ing edge that is very “sharp” will suffer
less impact damage.
Figure 3: Plot of the Mach cone angle as a function of Mach number.
Conclusion
cule has and consequently the number 16, another thermochemical effect The challenges associated with hyper-
of quantum mechanical energy states begins to take place, nitrogen dissoci- sonic flight are significant in that the
available (or the density of states) the gas ation. At this point, both oxygen and drag forces, temperatures, and heat flux
molecules can occupy. nitrogen radicals can land on surfaces put large demands on materials. First
The shock-induced temperatures and cause thermochemical-induced and foremost is managing the expo-
and frictional forces that gases under- reactions with the surfaces. Finally, at sure to high temperatures that will be
go during hypersonic rates raise the speeds near Mach 30, plasma will begin in excess of 1,000 °C. The high heat
kinetic energy high enough to enable to form a conductive sheath around the flux to the flight body can result in very
additional degrees of freedom, spe- flight object. This plasma sheath has high temperatures of the entire vehi-
cifically the vibrational modes of the sufficient electrical conductivity to act cle during flight. Mechanisms to carry
diatomic gas are activated. This means as a Faraday cage, leading to the block- away heat, such as increased emissivi-
that the heat capacity of the gas is not ing of both the transmission and receipt ty of leading-edge materials, should be
constant but changes due to the addi- of electromagnetic communication sig- explored. The use of cooling in the form
tional energy states available. These nals (i.e., a “blackout”). of water vaporization may be a route
vibrational states are initially activated that can be used to increase rocket fuel
in the Mach 3 to 4 range and lead to Erosion efficiency and provide a mechanism
measurable deviations from the ideal At hypersonic speeds, the kinetic ener- for throttling a solid fuel rocket. As the
gas law at hypersonic speeds. This gy in a collision between vehicle surfaces effects of erosion are unavoidable at
increased ability to carry heat con- and dust/raindrops can result in erosion hypersonic speeds, the use of materials
sequently leads to an increased heat due to impact damage. A theoretical equa- with high Young’s moduli could miti-
transfer to the flight body. tion for the damage threshold velocity gate this effect.
In the Mach 9 range at altitudes in the from is represented as: Vthreshold = (K1C 2
lower stratosphere (~10,000 m) range, cR/ρw2cw2dw)1/3. The fracture toughness This article was written by Thomas
oxygen dissociation begins to take is KIc, the Rayleigh surface wave speed cR, Parker, Materials Engineer, U.S. Army
place. This oxygen dissociation is also density of water ρw, the compressive wave Research Lab. It has been edited. For
referred to as one of the “thermochem- speed of water cw = 1,500 m/s, and the more information, visit arl.devcom.
ical effects.” At speeds around Mach diameter of the raindrop dw = 1.5 mm. army.mil.
30 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
eroTech
M a rc h 1 2-1 4 , 2 024 | Ch a r l o t te , N o r t h C a ro l i n a
®

SAE International’s Premier Professional Conference


on Aerospace Technology Is Coming to Charlotte!
The aerospace technical community will Grow your skills and net work with engineers,
come together as an industry March 12–14 in executives, regulators, researchers, scientists,
Charlotte, NC to share information on the academia, and other decision makers from
latest technical achievements, learn about across the global ecosystem at AeroTech.
the practical application of technologies,
discuss challenges and opportunities, and AeroTech is once again co-located with ASM
develop personal and business relationships International’s AeroMat, so you’ll have even
to move the industry forward. more opportunities to meet the industry’s
leading professionals powering aerospace,
defense and materials science.

sae.org/aerotech
P231361520

Secure your spot today—prices increase February 28. SAE Members save over 35% off registration!
Sponsored Content

Anritsu
490 Jarvis Drive Target Markets
Morgan Hill, CA 95037
Phone: 1-800-Anritsu (1-800-267-4878) Federal Agencies, Aerospace & Prime, Military Branches, and
E-mail: Peter.Alexander@Anritsu.com Universities/Research Labs.
www.anritsu.com

Products/Services Offered
About Our Company
Anritsu manufactures RF test and measurement equipment that
Anritsu offers a broad spectrum of products spanning re- fully supports the unmanned systems community, primarily in the
search, development, conformance testing, optimization, and key areas of reliable communications and precision performance
service assurance. Renowned for crafting exceptionally reliable in contested environments. Compensating for highly dynamic RF
instruments, backed by an extensive global support network, activity requires detailed, real-time understanding of the contested
we are unwavering in our commitment to delivering unparal- zone of operations. Anritsu T&M tools provide situational aware-
leled customer experiences. With a rich legacy, Anritsu has ness and knowledge in lightweight, rugged, and reliable packages
pioneered RF & Microwave technologies across communication, that are field deployable. From commercial to battlespace RF envi-
aerospace, defense, and education. This legacy endures, which ronments — generally congested, often complicated by EW actions
is evident in our current leadership across key domains, ranging and targeted degradation ­signal strength and security are funda-
from LTE to Vector Network Analysis. mental to mission success. Anritsu’s extensive experience assess-
Benefiting from our extensive expertise, Anritsu provides ing and measuring dynamic networks — from 5G / 6G + through
distinctive solutions derived from our proficiency in these multi-asset non-terrestrial networks — provides operators with the
realms. Collaborations with global telecom leaders and en- assurance that Anritsu is dedicated to enabling the full potential of
gagement in standards organizations empower us to present unmanned systems across contested environments. Don’t launch
the most comprehensive array of test, measurement, and ser- into the unknown alone — take Anritsu with you.
vice assurance solutions available. Our portfolio encompasses
wireless, optical, microwave/RF, and digital instruments cou-
pled with operational support systems. These solutions find
utility throughout the R&D, manufacturing, installation, and
maintenance phases.

www.anritsu.com

32 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


Empowering Unmanned
Systems with Cutting-edge
Connectivity Solutions.

Better. Faster. Smarter.

MS2850A MT8000A
Spectrum Analyzer/Signal Analyzer Radio Communication Test Station
How it applies: It has amplitude and phase How it applies: Platform that supports
flatness performance over a wide 1 GHz analysis Frequency Range 1 (FR1) and Frequency
bandwidth that exceeds other signal analyzers. Range 2 (FR2). It can be integrated with
It has a high ADC clipping level over the analysis SmartStudio software so various functional
bandwidth to obtain a wider difference from the tests can be performed via GUI without
DANL. This improved dynamic range performance requiring difficult scenario development, so the
helps obtain more accurate EVM values when MT8000A can be easily enhanced to address
measuring 5G signals. future military system designs.

READ MORE HERE


or contact us at 1-800-ANRITSU
© 2024 Anritsu Company
RF & Microwave Technology

Design Approaches
for Established and Emerging
RF Receiver Architectures
T
raditionally, heterodyne architectures have been the ing improved selectivity, dynamic range, and effective rejection of
preferred choice for radio frequency (RF) and millime- unwanted signals.
ter-wave (mmWave) receiver architectures, excelling in The conversion to an IF significantly enhances signal process-
noise performance, dynamic range, frequency cover- ing. It establishes a stable and standardized processing frequency,
age, selectivity, and reduction of EMI. However, recent advance- enabling the use of lower frequency, simple to integrate fixed fil-
ments in high sample rate analog to digital converters (ADCs) ters for a narrower band. This is crucial for isolating the desired
and embedded signal processing have prompted a reassessment signal in crowded RF environments. Additionally, signal ampli-
of both architectures. A thorough examination of the compo- fication and gain control are more efficiently executed at the IF,
nents in the channel design is essential to minimize distortion minimizing the impact of noise and interference. Furthermore,
into the differential ports of the ADC, guaranteeing optimal because you are grouping up and down converting the spectrum
signal integrity and dynamic bandwidth for the system. This
article will overview the design approach as well as when to use
a particular component type depending on performance and
signal requirements.

Comparison of the Direct Sampling and Heterodyne


Architecture
The development of high sample rate ADCs, broadband high
frequency components, and embedded signal processing has
enabled the development of direct sampling RF receivers. In this
architecture, the RF signal is sampled directly and is down convert-
ed digitally by the ADC without the intermediary step of analog
down conversion via a mixer. This brings several advantages. First
and foremost, the elimination of mixer stages results in a simpler
to implement signal path with fewer components in the RF chain,
reducing the overall receiver complexity, translating into benefits
such as reduced power consumption. A smaller system allows for
utilization of more channels on the ADC, which increases the
processing power of the whole system.
However, challenges arise, including heightened susceptibility to
interference due to the absence of filtering at a fixed low frequency
IF, requiring advanced filtering and shielding. Additionally, lim-
itations in dynamic range, especially at higher frequencies, pose
challenges for direct sampling architectures, narrowing the gap but
facing inherent constraints compared to heterodyne architectures.
In contrast, heterodyne RF receivers rely on a mixer to down
convert the RF signal to a lower intermediate frequency (IF), offer-

Direct Sampling Heterodyne


Mixer

RF RF IF
Rx ADC Rx ADC

LO

Figure 1. Simplified direct sampling vs heterodyne receiver architectures.

34 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


RF & Microwave Technology

to a fixed and low IF frequency for process- • A nalog Front End/Data Converter ity, broadband LNA with sufficient gain.
ing, ADC requirements have changed such Interface Since the RF Front End may handle mul-
that you can use a lower frequency, higher In modern multi-antenna, multi-chan- tiple channels, opting for a broadband
linearity ADC, offering a clearer and more nel systems, a versatile RF Front End is component is necessary. Ideally, the LNA
organized view of your spectrum. crucial. Comprising a limiter and a low- should amplify the signal level without
Heterodyne architectures will typically noise amplifier (LNA), the limiter, typical- distortion. However, as the LNA manages
be the choice for ultra-broadband, high ly the first component after the antenna, multiple channels concurrently, strategic
frequency RF and mmWave systems where shields the LNA and subsequent stages switching of the amplifier may be neces-
one needs to sample signals above the ADC from high-power signals, preventing dam- sary based on the incident spectrum to
sampling range or where high selectivity age and nonlinear distortions. Maintain- maintain linearity in the signal chain.
and sensitivity is demanded, such as in EW ing low signal levels is vital to preserve Positioned at the front end, a low noise
scanners or precision test equipment. sensitivity and ensure linear operation. figure is crucial to maintain a high sig-
Key limiter considerations include inser- nal-to-noise ratio (SNR), while a high flat
Component Selection and Channel tion loss, flat leakage, spike leakage, and gain enhances cascaded noise figure and
Design recovery time, requiring engineers to bal- dynamic range without compromising
To understand the RF signal chain, let’s ance protection and minimize impact on any AM information.
examine its blocks: desired signals.
• RF Front End Following the limiter, the next chal- Signal Conditioning
• Signal Conditioning lenge is to amplify the incoming signal With the receiver protected and the
• Frequency Conversion without distortion using a high-linear- incident signal boosted distortion-free,
the next challenge is to prevent adjacent
signals from obstructing the detection of
the desired tone. This block comprises a
filtering stage, automatic gain control,
and equalization to address frequency-
dependent losses.
For receivers operating across multiple
frequency bands or adapting to changing
frequency requirements, a highly config-
urable filter (e.g., tunable filter, switched
filter bank, or switched capacitor bank)
proves advantageous. Key considerations
for a configurable filter include out-of-
band rejection, rejection steepness, pass-
band insertion loss, switching time, and
control logic. For applications demanding
high channel counts, factors such as size,
weight, power (SWaP), and repeatability
should be taken into account. In such sce-
narios, MMIC filters are an ideal solution,
offering substantial size reduction with
high repeatability from unit-to-unit.
After selecting the channel, providing
variable gain/attenuation and equaliza-
tion becomes imperative. The variable
attenuator and variable gain amplifier (i.e.
automatic gain control - AGC), serve as a
feedback mechanism to adjust the signal
level to an optimal power range for usabil-
ity without causing damage to subsequent
stages. Following AGC, an equalizer is
Image: Audrius Merfeldas

employed to level out a signal affected by


frequency-dependent losses.

Frequency Conversion
This block is specific to heterodyne
architectures and utilizes a mixer block to
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 35
RF & Microwave Technology

convert the RF signal to a lower IF signal, erate and amplify the LO for proper mixer reducing system dynamic range. When
enhancing selectivity by allowing easi- operation. There’s a risk of LO signal leak- choosing a mixer, considerations should
er filtering of unwanted signals outside ing into the IF output, contributing to include bandwidth, conversion loss, isola-
the converted IF range. However, using a distortion. Conversion introduces signal tions, and linearity.
mixer introduces complexities. It requires losses, and as mixers are built from non- In direct sampling architectures, the RF
a local oscillator (LO) signal, necessitating linear devices such as diodes or transistors, signal is digitized without analog down
additional components like multipliers, their operation can introduce harmonic conversion, bypassing mixers and their
filters, and an LO driver amplifier to gen- distortion and intermodulation products, associated distortions and losses. While
direct sampling simplifies the signal path,
it shifts some distortion challenges to the
ADC interface.

Analog Front End/Data Converter


Interface
The aim of this block is to optimize
headroom for maximum linearity at the
differential ADC interface. The differen-
tial interface enhances the data convert-
er’s dynamic range by rejecting common
mode noise, reducing the noise floor, and
minimizing second harmonic distortion.
Achieving this involves a low-loss
single-ended to differential mode con-
verter and a broadband match to the
ADC. This block consists of either a pas-
Figure 2. (a) Direct sampling system channel design vs (b) Heterodyne system channel design. sive balun or a differential amplifier for
mode conversion, feeding into a differ-
ential limiter and a differential resistive
RF Front End matching circuit. The choice between a
balun or differential amplifier depends
on the application. For applications
requiring more power gain from the
mode converter, a differential amplifier
is likely needed, with trade-offs of added
noise, degraded linearity, and increased
system complexity. This is suitable for
low-bandwidth applications. In con-
Limiter Switchable LNA trast, for broadband, high-linearity
systems, a passive balun offers the best
wideband performance in terms of bal-
Figure 2. (b) The RF Front End signal path. ance, noise, linearity, and simplicity.
After selecting a mode converter,
matching it to the ADC is crucial to avoid
Signal Conditioning introducing second-order harmonic dis-
tortion (HD2) as the match can affect
the performance of the mode convert-
Variable er, reducing dynamic range. Designing
Attenuator Equalizer this matching circuit involves a trade-
fc off between return loss and bandwidth.
Given the requirement for a broadband
match and the impossibility of achieving
BW this lossless, a resistive match is needed
Variable to stiffen impedance, reduce passband
Configurable Filter ripple, and enhance mode converter
Gain Amplifier
performance. Finally, as a protective
measure, a differential limiter is placed
Figure 3. The signal conditioning signal path. before the data converter to protect the
36 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Find the Right Part
Faster
OUTLINED

MAG Pro
TM

MagPro
TM

MAGProDesigned by Engineers for Engineers, our


TM

RF Inductor and Choke Finder helps you find the optimal parts for your
desired L@frequency or Z@frequency quickly, reducing your design cycle time.

Coilcraft’s MAGPro suite of online inductor a full range of performance graphs including
analysis tools are designed to enable L, Q and ESR at frequency.
inductor selection and circuit optimization For RF choke applications, the Z @ Frequency
based on sound engineering principles and tool searches thousands of part numbers
measured data. for your desired impedance and lets you
The RF Inductor Choke Finder and Analyzer select the desired choke based on size,
offers two search options. The L @ Frequency performance, or a combination of the two.
option identifies inductors suitable for your Reduce your design cycle time with
L, Q, and current requirements and displays confidence at www.coilcraft.com/tools

WWW.COILCRAFT.COM
RF & Microwave Technology

ADC Interface
Frequency Conversion Mixer Gain Block Filter

Resistive Match
Balun

LO Source Multiplier Filter ADC


LO Driver
X4
Differential Limiter

Figure 4. Frequency conversion block for heterodyne architectures. Figure 5. ADC Interface signal path.

expensive ADC from any jamming tones Conclusion sion. This streamlined design reduces
that may have made it all the way to the The simplicity and cost reduction power consumption, enhances porta-
ADC interface. enabled by direct sampling receivers are bility, and potentially lowers costs. Yet,
In the context of direct sampling ultimately the goal for modern RF sys- challenges arise, including susceptibility
receivers, the development and avail- tems but have their limitations. Direct to interference, limited dynamic range at
ability of high frequency broadband sampling architectures simplify the sig- higher frequencies, and a shift of distor-
baluns is enabling the usage of high sam- nal path, digitizing RF signals without tion challenges to the ADC interface.
ple rate ADCs. implementing a mixer for down conver- Each block of the signal chain and
t he inherent challenges discussed
become more difficult at higher fre-
quencies. For frequency plans that
prevent the use of direct sampling,
heterodyne architectures excel in noise
performance, dynamic range, leverag-
ing mixers for down conversion. This
approach offers standardized frequency
processing, effective filter designs, and
optimized gain control at the interme-
diate frequency. However, it introduces
complexity, potential signal distortion,
LO signal leakage, and increased power
consumption.
The choice between these architec-
tures necessitates a delicate balance,
weighing the proven track record of
heterodyne architectures against the
streamlined simplicity of direct sam-
pling. Engineers must consider appli-
cation-specific needs and performance
requirements, making decisions based
on the unique trade-offs inherent in
each approach. Ultimately, the optimal
choice depends on a thorough analy-
sis of the advantages and drawbacks of
each architecture within the context of
the application’s demands.

This article was written by Cameron


Sheth, Product Manager, Marki Micro-
wave. For more information, visit
www.markimicrowave.com.
38 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
RF & Microwave Technology

Rydberg Technologies Shows Potential of Long-Range RF


with Quantum Sensor at NetModX23

R ydberg Technologies, an Ann Arbor,


Michigan-based quantum technolo-
gy startup, demonstrated the use of an
Generation Combat Vehicle and Soldier
Lethality,” according to the Army. A major
goal sought by the C5ISR Center with
the company described it as a histor-
ic demonstration of the “world’s first
long-range radio communications with
atomic receiver for long-range RF appli- NetModX is to take technologies that an atomic quantum sensor.”
cations during the NetModX23 event are nearing maturity from research labs According to Rydberg Technologies
hosted by the U.S. Army Combat Capa- directly into operational environments CEO David Anderson, the company
b i l i t i e s D e ve l o p m e n t C o m m a n d for assessments by active warfighters. “demonstrated the smallest ever atomic
(DEVCOM) C5ISR Center in December. One such technology is the proto- receiver at frequencies and long-range
The 2023 edition of NetModX featured type Rydberg atomic receiver devel- communication distances that show
10 weeks of experimentation spanning oped by Rydberg Technologies, which a clear path for transitioning Rydberg
62 different technologies across 17 focus has been refining the performance, atom quantum technologies from labo-
areas and five modernization priorities design and form-factor aspects of its ratory to real-world applications.”
including “Future Vertical Lift, Long- device over the last decade. In a press Anderson has also compiled several
Range Precision Fires, Network, Next release following the NetModX event, in-depth research papers about specif-
ic elements of quantum sensing, the
advantages of Rydberg atom-based RF
measurement and other related topics
available on the company’s website.
Shortly after the completion of the
NetModX event, Aerospace & Defense
Technology caught up with Anderson
to discuss the demonstration of their
atomic receiver prototype and the future
potential of quantum sensing in real-
world military RF applications.
(Top Image: BPawesome)

A&DT: Why was the demonstration


of your atomic receiver at NetModX23
such a historic and significant mile-
An image of an atomic RF sensor, the Rydberg field and measurement system. This was not the atomic
receiver demonstrated during the NetModX event. No images of the receiver were available for this article. stone for the use of quantum sensing
(Image: Rydberg Technologies) in military RF applications?
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 39
RF & Microwave Technology

Dave Anderson: In quantum tech- heads that contain the sensing atoms, Anderson: Traditional RF anten-
nologies and quantum sensing, the tran- for example, may require alternative nas and devices are generally based on
sition of laboratory research outcomes designs and adaptations to address driving electric currents in conductive
into practical solutions requires realizing application-specific use cases. Also, for structures to detect or generate RF elec-
physical devices and sensor hardware deployment of these receivers in harsh tromagnetic waves. Rydberg atom sen-
to validate technological capabilities operational environments with military sors operate based on fundamentally
and establish a path for deployment in RF systems in use today, further rugge- different physics principles, in which
real-world applications. In recent years, dization will be needed. the loosely bound electron of an atom
we have been focused on not only the serves as a highly sensitive sensor of RF
advancing capabilities of our atomic A&DT: What do you see as some of the electromagnetic waves that can be read
receivers but also to substantially reduc- main advantages of using a quantum out using light. Leveraging the prop-
ing the size, weight and power of atomic sensor in comparison to traditional RF erties of Rydberg atoms, these atomic
receiver hardware for deployment in real- antennas and devices in use today? quantum sensors provide several per-
world applications. As a reference point,
in 2018 our atomic RF field measurement
prototype, the first of its kind, was about
the size of a refrigerator. Since then, we
have been able to miniaturize our systems
into a field-deployable device about the
size of a briefcase.
At NetModX, we deployed this next
generation atomic receiver device in an
operationally relevant outdoor envi-
ronment and demonstrated a host of
capabilities afforded by this new type of
atomic antenna.
In our own tests of the atomic receiv-
er device, we have demonstrated a long-
range RF signal communication over a
kilometer range with an atomic sensor
for the first time, as well as wideband fre-
quency coverage from HF to SHF bands
with a single compact atomic sensing ele- Army DEVCOM C5ISR Center researchers work with radios during the Network Modernization
ment. It’s important to note however that Experimentation 23 at Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst, New Jersey. (Image: U.S. Army)
we are still far from both practical and
fundamental limits of atomic receivers,
including fundamental quantum limits of
sensitivity that we have not yet reached.

A& DT: H ow we r e yo u a bl e to
achieve that reduction in size to
develop a field-deployable prototype
atomic receiver?
Anderson: One major element was to
leverage smart engineering of laser sys-
tems that are needed for an atomic receiv-
er of this size. We also had to incorporate
new hardware components and subsys-
tems developed at Rydberg to get to the
smaller design. It is important to note that
the supply chain for quantum technolo-
gies generally is still evolving and growing.
We are continuously improving the
design and engineering of our devices,
and demonstrations such as these pro-
vide invaluable data that help guide Another image of Army DEVCOM C5ISR Center researchers performing demonstrations and experimenta-
those improvements. The detector tions with radios during the Network Modernization Experimentation 23 event. (Image: U.S. Army)

40 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


RF & Microwave Technology

An Army DEVCOM C5ISR Center arranges a radio for a demonstration atop an Army ground vehicle during the Network Modernization Experimentation 23 event.
(Image: U.S. Army)

formance advantages compared to tra- A&DT: Are there any specific aero- performance improvements that you
ditional RF sensor technologies. One space and defense applications that want to make to the atomic receiver
advantage lies in the inherently small you have envisioned for the atomic moving forward?
size of atoms. receiver to enable in the future?
An atomic receiver can be made sig- Anderson: We are far from the fun-
nificantly smaller than the size of tra- Anderson: I think the application damental limits of performance of
ditional RF antenna receivers, whose possibilities are expansive, especially atomic sensors, and we are still look-
size generally scales proportionally to considering that the capabilities of the ing to push capability further. That
the wavelength of the RF electromag- technology continue to advance. Sev- includes everything from advancing
netic signal of interest. Atomic sensors eral aerospace and defense application performance in sensitivity, selectivity
break this proportionality requirement, areas that atomic receivers could enable and other metrics, to exploiting the
enabling the prospect of compact detec- in the future include advanced resilient quantum nature of these atomic RF
tors operational across large swaths of communication systems, low probabili- systems into new technology domains.
the radio spectrum from long-wave- ty of detection/intercept (LPD/LPI) and On the hardware side, it’s driving fur-
length RF to millimeter-wave and even anti-jamming applications, spectrum ther miniaturization and ruggediza-
THz bands. On the long-wavelength monitoring, and situational awareness tion and operation in harsh real-world
portion of the spectrum, the function in EW systems. environments and to address a broader
of large antennas often used for recep- When you look at resilient commu- set of applications with even smaller
tion of very long wavelength RF signals, nications specifically, the atomic sensor form factors.
for example in long-distance commu- presents an entirely new modality dis- In addition to deployment, hard-
nications systems, could be drastically tinct from traditional antenna technolo- ware development in quantum
reduced in size. gy. As we advance the capabilities of the and photonics also ties critically to
There are also major advantages in technology, we also greatly benefit from enabling new capabilities with quan-
performance capabilities in terms of sen- working with partners in the aerospace tum sensors. Going for ward, we’ ll
sitivity and selectivity. When you start and defense industry and actively seek also continue to carry out more field
considering real-world operationally rel- feedback and expertise from the indus- demonstrations and development ini-
evant scenarios, in which there can be try to guide development of the technol- tiatives with early adopters, as getting
significant electromagnetic interference ogy to address other specific application user feedback remains critical in guid-
and congested RF spectrum environ- needs and future capabilities. ing a path to deployment.
ments, atomic quantum sensing opens
new possibilities for more resilient com- A&DT: Now that you have com- This article was written by Woodrow
munications as well as significantly pleted the NetModX demonstration, Bellamy III, Senior Editor, SAE Media
smaller form factors. are there any design, form factor or Group.
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 41
Tech Briefs

New Method to Measure Wind Speed Could Unlock


Drones’ Potential
A fundamentally different approach to wind estimation using unmanned aircraft than the vast major-
ity of existing methods. This method uses no on-board flow sensor and does not attempt to estimate
thrust or drag forces.
Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, Daytona Beach, Florida

T raditionally, remotely piloted


aircraft systems, or drones, have
used onboard flow sensors to mea-
“The very nature of wind makes
it a difficult quantity to measure,”
Compere said. “But our simulation
s u re w ind e ffe c t s, p roduci n g provides an ability that no experi-
in-flight metrics on which opera- mental approach can provide: We
tors rely. Leveraging GPS instead, can simulate wind with exact
however, might provide more known inputs and test the method
robust measurements, leading to with exact known outputs.”
safer, more efficient flights, accord- Currently, the team uses expen-
ing to Embry‑Riddle Aeronautical sive, custom-built aircraft outfitted
University researchers. with onboard flow sensors to col-
As most drones weigh less than lect weather data, but the process is
55 pounds, even mild gusts of wind complex and time-consuming.
can disrupt their flight, which Those problems go away with the
makes finding creative solutions Dr. Avinash Muthu Krishnan, assistant professor of Aeronautical use of GPS, though, and GPS tech-
to monitor and predict hyperlo- Science; graduate researcher Jeremy Copenhaver; and Dr. Marc nology comes standard in store-
cal weather conditions essential Compere, associate professor of Mechanical Engineering, work bought drones.
on a weather-sensing drone that uses GPS, instead of onboard
to flying without disruption or flow sensors, to measure wind speed. (Image: Embry‑Riddle/David “Scaling and simplicity is what
unplanned landings. Massey) measuring wind with just a GPS
Dr. Marc Compere, associate pro- and a compass provides,” Compere
fessor of Mechanical Engineering at flight reliability and help advance the said. “All drones already have these sen-
Embry‑Riddle’s Daytona Beach Campus, technology throughout the industry, sors. They’re built-in from the factory.”
recently described a new approach to from drone-based package delivery all Adkins added that the GPS approach
measuring wind effects — in the interna- the way to urban air mobility, or “air also opens the possibility of crowdsourcing
tional, peer-reviewed Drones journal — taxis.” weather data from multiple users at once.
along with Drs. Kevin Adkins and Avi- But the implications of wind on “The sheer number of potential obser-
nash Muthu Krishnan, both professors uncrewed aircraft systems (UAS) extend vations can produce a far superior prod-
of Aeronautical Science. far beyond piloting requirements. Scien- uct, especially in urban environments
“The GPS method does not attempt to tists need accurate wind measurements where things change more quickly,” he
estimate thrust or drag forces,” said to research atmospheric conditions and said. “The use of GPS makes both busi-
Compere, principal investigator on the air quality; wind can offer emergency ness and safety sense.”
project. “Using only GPS and orienta- workers clues as to a wildfire’s growth In previous work, the team simulated
tion sensors, our new strategy estimates patterns; and wind affects the weather. UAS routes along the Daytona Beach
wind vectors in an Earth-fixed frame “Sensing wind is a critical part of soci- Campus to help push drone-delivery
during turning maneuvers.” ety that not many people are aware of,” tech forward. They also used UAS to
“It’s all about safety,” Adkins added. Compere added. monitor and improve air quality, among
“The lower atmosphere is a new and The Wind-Arc method, as it’s called to many other projects.
incredibly dynamic portion of the envi- leverage GPS data in UAS flights, is not Next, they’re hoping to commercial-
ronment for sustained aviation opera- new to the industry, but the Embry‑Rid- ize the Wind-Arc Method. A patent is
tions; traditionally, this is an area we dle research team has made the tactic pending.
have passed through quickly during more viable through the incorporation This work was performed by Kevin
ascent and descent. Wind poses unique of computer simulations. Software is Adkins, Marc Compere and Avinash
challenges to controllability and the air- used to forecast flight conditions — Muthu Krishnan for Embry-Riddle
craft’s range and endurance.” including heading angle, airspeed and Aeronautical University. For more
Ultimately, the team’s goal is to wind speed trends — and then produce information, download the Technical
make the flight of uncrewed aircraft real-time statistics of how an aircraft Support Package (free white paper) at
more predictable in locations that have would respond to nuanced changes in mobilityengineeringtech.com/tsp
never seen UAS flight, which will boost the environment. under the Electronics category.
42 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Tech Briefs

Report on Human Factors Issues Likely to Affect Air-


Launched Effects
This report reviews human factors research on the supervision of multiple unmanned vehicles (UVs)
as it affects human integration with Air-Launched Effects (ALE).
U.S. Army Combat Capabilities Development Command Analysis Center, Fort Novosel, Alabama

A ir-Launched Effects (ALEs) are a con-


cept for operating small, inexpen-
sive, attritable, and highly autonomous
unmanned aerial systems that can be
tube launched from aircraft. Launch
from ground vehicles is planned as well,
although Ground-Launched Effects are
not yet a requirement. ALEs are envi-
sioned to provide “reconnaissance, sur-
veillance, target acquisition (RSTA), and
lethality with an advanced team of Figure 1: Raytheon’s Coyote Block 3 (left) and Area-1’s Altius 700 (right) are exemplars of the ALE to
manned and unmanned aircraft as part be developed.
of an ecosystem including Future Attack
and Reconnaissance Aircraft (FARA) and launched, demonstrating the “flood the operator attention such as targets, UVs
ALE.” A primary purpose of ALEs is to zone” capability envisioned by Brigadier might be controlled out of call centers,
extend “tactical and operational reach General Rugen, head of the moderniza- taking advantage of load balancing to
and lethality of manned assets, allowing tion team for Future Vertical Lift (FVL). increase the UV to operator ratio. This
them to remain outside of the range of As the Army moves toward increas- option also has the advantage of rely-
enemy sensors and weapon systems ingly complex Multi-Domain Opera- ing largely on COTS drone technology
while delivering kinetic and non-kinet- tions, the ability to effectively deploy with map and first person displays for
ic, lethal and non-lethal mission effects large numbers of unmanned systems whic h t here is already a body of
against multiple threats, as well as, pro- becomes crucial. This research analyzes research and experience requiring only
viding battle damage assessment data.” human–autonomy interaction through protection from electronic warfare to
Key features of the ALE are adherence the prism of scalability to better under- be fielded.
to the Modular Open Systems Architec- stand how unmanned systems might be Automated coordination can take var-
ture so that components rely on nonpro- deployed and supervised at scales need- ied forms, each of which present differ-
prietary interfaces and the Scalable ed to impact modern warfare. Our anal- ent human control issues. Simple forms
Control Interface, an application pro- ysis finds three broad categories of con- of coordination, such as consensus algo-
gramming interface intended to allow trol: autonomous coordinat ion in rithms (swarms), are fully scalable,
control through any command device which UVs are controlled as a team, immune to attrition, but limited in
adhering to the protocol, including both quasi-independent control in which behavior. Rule or optimization-based
air and ground forces. UVs are controlled largely independent- coordination is limited in scale and may
Over the past three years, in a series of ly of one another, and coordinated con- be brittle but can produce complex coor-
experiments and demonstrations known trol in which operator(s) must directly dinated behaviors. A useful way of think-
as Experimentation Demonstration coordinate UVs. We conclude that ing about this problem is to use pre-opti-
Gateway Event (EDGE) and Project Con- direct coordination is infeasible for real- mized behaviors or “plays” for recurring
vergence (Convergence), ALE prototypes istic applications, leaving automated locally coordinated behaviors, such as
have demonstrated increasing sophisti- coordination and quasi-independent Battle Damage Assessment, while coor-
cat ion and capability. At Conver- control as feasible options. dinating larger groups through scalable
gence-20, six ALEs covered a range of 62 Quasi-independent control, in which methods, such as consensus algorithms.
km relaying RSTA information back to operator(s) direct one or more UVs at This work was performed by Jami-
manned assets at standoff distances. largely independent tasks, such as area son Hicks, DEVCOM Analysis Center;
Four were air launched while two search with minimally overlapping pat- Michael Lewis, University of Pitts-
demonstrated a new ground launch terns, offers many advantages in that burgh; and Katia Sycara, Carnegie
capability. In EDGE-21, Altius 600 ALE multiple UVs can be controlled in Mellon University. For more informa-
prototypes were launched as a small sequence and scaled beyond a single tion, download the Technical Support
swarm and controlled from a Blackhawk operator’s limits, simply by adding Package (free white paper) at mobili-
helicopter. By EDGE-22, four waves of additional operators. Depending on tyengineeringtech.com/tsp under the
seven ALEs each (28 total) were ground the arrival rates of events requiring Electronics category.
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 43
Tech Briefs

Advanced Satellite Communications Research


The impact on wireless communication system performance was investigated for five channel condi-
tions, which included (1) additive white Gaussian noise, (2) flat Raleigh fading, (3) frequency selective
Raleigh fading, (4) flat Rician fading, and (5) frequency selective Rician fading.
Wichita State University, Wichita, Kansas

N ew algorithm strategies and diverse


communication techniques are con-
stantly emerging in the telecommunica-
tion under a line-of-sight (LOS) and an
Additive White Gaussian Noise (AWGN)
environment. Since the transmit power,
used to model the estimated BWE of a
W/V-band channel under Rayleigh and
Rician fading. Both flat fading and fre-
tions realm that consumers, commercial, PT, and the distance, dTR, between a quency selective fading were considered
government, and military demand in transmitter (TX) and a receiver (RX) are for both types of fading (i.e., Rayleigh
order to push the boundaries of data known, the free space path loss, Ppath = and Rican). Measured data from the
throughput to receive information as (λ⁄4πdTR)2 , can be precalculated for a W/V-band Terrestrial Link Experiment
quickly as possible. Currently, the Ku/Ka given wavelength λ = c/fc, i.e., a given car- were used to model the communications
satellite band (20–30 GHz) becomes con- rier frequency fc where c is the speed of channel. Simulations were conducted
gested during peak service. There has been the light. Hence, the channel attenua- using adaptive code modulation (ACM)
a strong demand for a wider bandwidth tion, Pattn due to the channel medium methods included in the Digital Video
and higher data rate in both cellular and can be obtained as Pattn = PT – PR – Ppath Broadcasting – Second Generation (DVB-
satellite communication service. As the by measuring the received power PR at S2) communications protocol. Simula-
carrier frequency increases, a wider band- the RX for a given transmitted power PT. tions and analysis was accomplished
width can be made available, and a higher These channel attenuation data can be using Matlab tools. The DVB-S2 satellite
data rate can be obtained with beamform- obtained more economically than by link protocol has been in existence since
ing or precoding. Particularly, the V band sending a modulated signal. Data enables 2014 and includes 28 possible combina-
(50–75 GHz) and W band (75–110 GHz) an RF communication system engineer tions of forward error correction (FEC)
offer unprecedented broadband capabili- to determine the appropriate transmit coding and modulations, depending on
ties and extremely large contiguous allo- power, antenna type, antenna size, mod- the channel conditions.
cations of bandwidth. This is the reason ulation type, forward error correction Models and simulations were developed
NASA and AFRL have been investigating coding type, code rate, and data rate. to compare the performance for an addi-
these bands for civilian and military use. The technical objective of this project tive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) chan-
At W/V-band, the wavelength is on was to investigate bandwidth efficiency nel, a Rayleigh fading channel, and a Rician
the order of 3 to 4 millimeters. Thus, of wireless communication waveforms fading channel. Both flat and frequency
receivers can be implemented via very under Rayleigh and Rician fading envi- selective channels were considered for the
small devices. Further, a W/V-band sys- ronments, in addition to additive white later two models. Simulations were per-
tem can have a very narrow beam angle- Gaussian noise, for satellite communi- formed using channel attenuation data
spread, which can significantly reduce cation links. Initial research, simula- measured at 72 GHz from the W/V-band
the interference among beams and tions, and analyses are presented in this Terrestrial Link Experiment. Analysis was
recover propagation loss. report, but the entire scope of work was presented using the DVB-S2 protocol.
When a new wireless terrestrial or sat- not completed due to limitation of Results suggest that multipath fading sig-
ellite communication system is planned, funds and premature termination of the nificantly deteriorates performance.
the channel path attenuation data is typ- program. Models and simulations were developed
ically collected first by transmitting a car- In this work, the same bandwidth effi- that implemented orthogonal frequency
rier frequency signal without modula- ciency (BWE) conversion methods were division multiplexing (OFDM), similar to
that used by 5G wireless commercial net-
work s. Implement at ion of OFDM
Packet BBFrame BCH LDPC
Interleaver
Adaptive improved performance against severe mul-
Generator Buffering Encoding Encoding Modulator
tipath fading environments. However, the
Data Transmission bit error rate performance was worse than
Measured
Measured Bit
under a no-fading, AWGN channel.
Packet Error
Rate
Error Rate
(BER) AWGN
Measured Es/N0
(dB)
This work was performed by Hyuck
(PER) Fading M. Kwon and Richard T. Lahman for
Data Received the Air Force Research Laboratory,
BBFrame BCH LDPC Adaptive
Space Vehicles Directorate. For more
Buffering Decoding Decoding Deinterleaver
Demodulator information, download the Technical
Support Package (free white paper) at
mobilityengineeringtech.com/tsp
A block diagram for a digital video broadcasting communications channel. under the Electronics category.
44 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Tech Briefs

New Qubit Circuit Enables Quantum Operations With


Higher Accuracy
The advance brings quantum error correction a step closer to reality.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts

I n the future, quantum computers may


be able to solve problems that are far
too complex for today’s most powerful
supercomputers. To realize this prom-
ise, quantum versions of error correc-
tion codes must be able to account
for computational errors faster than
they occur.
However, today’s quantum computers
are not yet robust enough to realize such
error correction at commercially rele-
vant scales.
On the way to overcoming this road-
block, MIT researchers demonstrated a
novel superconducting qubit architec-
ture t hat can per for m operat ions
between qubits — the building blocks of
a quantum computer — with much
greater accuracy than scientists have pre-
viously been able to achieve.
They utilize a relatively new type of This artist rendering shows the researchers’ superconducting qubit architecture, with the fluxonium
superconducting qubit, known as fluxo- qubits in red and the blue transmon coupler in between them. (Image: Krantz Nanoart)
nium, which can have a lifespan that is
much longer than more commonly used Ding wrote the paper with several implement these codes. Furthermore,
superconducting qubits. industry and university researchers and pushing the fidelities far beyond this
Their architecture involves a special staff scientists from MIT Lincoln Labora- threshold reduces the overhead needed
coupling element between two fluxoni- tory. The research appears in Physical to implement error correcting codes.
um qubits that enables them to perform Review X. For more than a decade, researchers
logical operations, known as gates, in a In a classical computer, gates are logi- have primarily used transmon qubits in
highly accurate manner. It suppresses a cal operations performed on bits (a series their efforts to build quantum computers.
type of unwanted background interac- of 1s and 0s) that enable computation. Another type of superconducting qubit,
tion that can introduce errors into quan- Gates in quantum computing can be known as a fluxonium qubit, originated
tum operations. thought of in the same way: A single more recently. Fluxonium qubits have
This approach enabled two-qubit qubit gate is a logical operation on one been shown to have longer lifespans, or
gates that exceeded 99.9 percent accura- qubit, while a two-qubit gate is an opera- coherence times, than transmon qubits.
cy and single-qubit gates with 99.99 tion that depends on the states of two Coherence time is a measure of how
percent accuracy. In addition, the connected qubits. long a qubit can perform operations or
researchers implemented this architec- Fidelity measures the accuracy of run algorithms before all the information
ture on a chip using an extensible fabri- quantum operations performed on these in the qubit is lost.
cation process. gates. Gates with the highest possible “The longer a qubit lives, the higher
“Building a large-scale quantum com- fidelities are essential because quantum fidelity the operations it tends to pro-
puter starts with robust qubits and gates. errors accumulate exponentially. With mote. These two numbers are tied togeth-
We showed a highly promising two-qubit billions of quantum operations occur- er. But it has been unclear, even when
system and laid out its many advantages ring in a large-scale system, a seemingly fluxonium qubits themselves perform
for scaling. Our next step is to increase the small amount of error can quickly cause quite well, if you can perform good gates
number of qubits,” says Leon Ding PhD the entire system to fail. on them,” Ding says.
’23, who was a physics graduate student In practice, one would use error-cor- For the first time, Ding and his collab-
in the Engineering Quantum Systems recting codes to achieve such low error orators found a way to use these lon-
(EQuS) group and is the lead author of a rates. However, there is a “fidelity thresh- ger-lived qubits in an architecture that
paper on this architecture. old” the operations must surpass to can support extremely robust, high-fidel-
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 45
Tech Briefs

ity gates. In their architecture, the fluxo- fluxonium outperforming transmons researchers from MIT, and funded in
nium qubits were able to achieve coher- on the single-qubit level,” says Hays. part by the U.S. Army Research Office.
ence times of more than a millisecond, “Our work shows that this performance For more information, download the
about 10 times longer than traditional boost can be extended to interactions Technic al Support Package (free
transmon qubits. between qubits as well.” white paper) at mobilityengineer-
“Over the last couple of years, there This work was performed by Leon ingtech.com/tsp under the Electron-
have been several demonstrations of Ding in collaboration with other ics category.

A Perspective on GVSC Crewstation Development and


Addressing Future Ground Combat Vehicle Needs
The U.S. Army Combat Capabilities Development Command (DEVCOM) Ground Vehicle Systems
Center (GVSC) has been developing next generation crew stations over the last several decades. In
this research, the problem space that impacts design development and decisions is discussed.
U.S. Army DEVCOM GVSC, Warren, Michigan

T he interact ion of soldiers wit h


advanced combat vehicle systems
grows more complex with: 1) Advance-
maintainability and enable more rapid
integration into existing and emerging
vehicle systems; 5) The unique shock
to bring the crew under armor instead of
head out of hatch.
The potential for a smaller crew size
ments and adaptation to emerging and vibration experienced by ground to a c c o m m o d a te re d u c e d ve h i c l e
technology; 2) Increased sharing and combat systems; 6) Weight of the vehi- weight is a difficult challenge in itself; a
proliferation of data and information; cle must be considered for transportabil- reduced vehicle crew must achieve the
3) Changing tactics and requirements ity, which drives the vehicle size, that in same level of performance as its prede-
of where and how these systems are to turn impacts the crewstation volume, or cessor larger crew, which implies exist-
be used to gain battlefield dominance; the space soldiers occupy to operate the ing tasks must be allocated across team
4) The goal to standardize software and platform; 7) Survivability and safety of members to successfully accomplish
hardware components to reduce costs/ the crew is also essential, so it is desirable the mission. Now add that these tasks
must be performed under armor, which
requires vision systems be utilized that
take 360 degrees of sensor input and
present the visuals on a two-dimen-
sional display within a reduced crew-
station volume…we begin to appreciate
some of the difficulties that drive suc-
cessful soldier interactions with pro-
posed vehicle systems. Reduced vol-
ume, under-hatch operations are only
one consideration. When we contem-
plate the additional complexities iden-
tified above, the challenge becomes
significant. Let’s look at each identified
challenge and its impact.
New technologies bring great oppor-
tunity to increase soldier-system perfor-
mance, but they also bring complica-
tions. First this new system or service
must be properly integrated into a crew-
station to maximize useability and
increase task efficiency. Secondly, a sol-
dier must learn how to properly use a
new system or service, as well as trust
A prototype crewstation developed for the GSVC’s “Crewman’s Associate” initiative features flat panel displays
providing indirect vision to the operator, and programmable bezel buttons to interact with multifunctional that the technology provides the desired
displays for mission function. level of capability. An example here
46 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Tech Briefs

would be a new target recognition system that provides the


user with a list of battlespace objects that it detects and recog-
nizes. If an object is not what is expected (i.e., a false positive),
the soldier must manually validate this object and then cor-
rect, which reduces trust in this new technology as well as cre-
ating more work for this crewman.
Secondly, there are enormous volumes of data available to
be used for decision making. Sources include network commu-
nications, sensor data, systems data, and verbal interactions
with team members to name a few. Greater information is crit-
ical to making better and faster decisions, but only if the data is
useful and relevant to the decision maker. With advancements
in computing, machine learning and artificial intelligence,
there are promising tools that can be applied to sort, priori-
tize, and automate data delivery, but again the user must trust
these tools to provide the information in a timely, accurate
and helpful manner.
Thirdly, changing tactics and requirements of where and
how these systems are to be used also drive soldier-system
design. An example is maneuverability in small villages or
towns. Bridges have weight limits and street widths are nar-
rower, so the vehicle must be smaller to successfully operate
and maneuvering in various formations is difficult. Also,
there is the potential for top attack from multi-storied build-
ings as well as improvised explosive devices and distinguish-
ing enemy combatants from the civilian population. Con-
trast this with open and rolling terrain. Also, the future www.hunterproducts.com
Multi Domain Operations focus will have a significant
impact on distribution of forces and concepts for organiza-
tion. Traditional Army operational concepts must change to
address this, which will impact individual combat vehicle
designs. Fourthly, vehicle modernization will impact sol-
dier-system design. To aid in reducing cost, shorten upgrade
timelines, simplify maintenance, increase modularity and
interoperability, and standardize data definitions and inter-
faces, vehicles of tomorrow with utilize a common infra-
structure architecture. This modernization is very helpful in
the long run but will require time for both hardware and
software suppliers to comply, which currently limits avail- MICRO-METALLIZER PLATING PENS MIL & QQ
able design options. Standards GOLD 14K, 18K, 24K, SILVER, RHODIUM,
PALLADIUM, NICKEL, COPPER, TIN, BLACK
Lastly, ground combat vehicles experience unique environ-
NICKEL, AND CHROME COLOR PENS AVAILABLE.
mental factors due to traversing severe off-road terrain, weather
conditions, and exposure to biohazards to name just a few.
Environmentally friendly, these low-cost disposable applicators
Also, vehicle induced aspects such as shock from weapon fir-
permit instantaneous selection from a variety of plating
ing, and vibration from engine and track operations impact possibilities without the preparation of solutions. Specially
how soldiers must interact with crewstation systems and influ- formulated compounds and can be used for contact repair,
ence design considerations to optimize soldier system perfor- prototype development work, electronic instrument repair,
mance. Many of the complexities outlined above have been medical instrument repair etc.
addressed by GVSC in past activities. Many more must still be
developed to take advantage of technological advances and Hunter Products, Inc.
meet emerging vehicle requirements. 36 Madison Ave
This work was performed by Terrance Tierney for the U.S. Flemington, NJ 08822
Army Combat Capabilities Development Command 908 526 8440 • Fax: 908 526 8348
(DEVCOM) Ground Vehicle Systems Center (GVSC). For hunter@hunterproducts.com
more information, download the Technical Support Pack-
age (free white paper) at mobilityengineeringtech.com/tsp
under the Electronics category.
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 47
Application Briefs

Autonomous Navigation Kits


Defense Innovation Unit
Washington D.C.
info@DIU.mil
www.DIU.mil

T he Department of Defense (DoD) operates a vast array of


military vehicles crucial for both sustainment and combat
operations. Traditionally, these vehicles have been reliant on
human operators, who face natural limitations such as the
need for rest, vulnerability to fatigue, and variability in train-
ing. In an effort to leverage significant advancements in the
commercial autonomous vehicle sector and reduce risk to sol-
diers and their missions, the U.S. Army, in collaboration with
the Defense Innovation Unit, has selected three vendors to
develop autonomous navigation kits for the Ground Expedi- “Commercial industry has revolutionized autonomous vehi-
tionary Autonomous Retrofit System (GEARS) project. cle technology over the past 5-10 years,” said Major Will Ryan,
Falling under the Army’s Autonomous Transport Vehicle Autonomy Project Manager at the Defense Innovation Unit.
System (ATV-S) program and PEO Combat Support and Com- “Incorporating these sophisticated systems into military con-
bat Service Support, this innovative prototyping initiative will texts not only bolsters our tactical strengths but also paves the
retrofit 41 Palletized Load System (PLS) vehicles with autono- way for innovative strategies and operational efficiencies that
mous kits, with the option to expand to other military vehi- save lives, reduce cognitive burdens, and free up soldiers to exe-
cles in the future. cute more complex missions.”
“Commercial technologies and economies of scale exist that Following a rigorous down-select process, a panel of Army
will enable the Army to close technological gaps,” said Kyle Brun- leaders and technical experts selected three vendors from an ini-
er, Project Manager for Force Projection at PEO CS&CSS, reinforc- tial group of 51 contenders to spearhead the GEARS project pro-
ing the importance and urgency of the GEARS project. “Now is an totyping phase: Carnegie Robotics, Neya Systems, and Robotic
opportune time to modernize with ATV-S in support of Multi Research. Over the next year, these companies will develop and
Domain Operations in contested environments.” test viable prototypes during operational, safety, cyber, and
The integration of cutting-edge commercial autonomous other critical component evaluations, with a goal of fielding an
technology represents a strategic move to extend the opera- initial fleet of 41 vehicles across operational units before moving
tional reach of Army forces, while simultaneously reducing into larger scale production.
risks for soldiers operating in dangerous environments. www.DIU.mil

Advanced Air Mobility Digital Operations Center


Air Force Research Lab
Wright Patterson Air Force Base, OH
937-522-3252
www.afrl.af.mil

A FWERX is partnering with NASA to develop a digital oper-


ations center for future Advanced Air Mobility (AAM)
efforts through the Civilian Commercialization Readiness
Pilot Program, or CCRPP, awardee, ResilienX.
With the fast-growing field of AAM technology, AFW-
ERX’s Airspace Innovation and Prime Partnerships program
has partnered with NASA and the Federal Aviation Adminis-
tration to fill in technological and administrative gaps as
they occur. The CCRPP is a NASA Small Business Innovation This system is intended to enhance base security, special
Research and Small Business Technology Transfer program forces efforts, emergency disaster response, and passen-
which takes mission-relevant technologies in development ger and cargo transportation planning. It is further being
a n d i n f u s e s t h e m w it h f u n d i n g i n te n d e d to fo ste r developed to include other technologies necessary for air
commercialization. domain awareness.
48 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Application Briefs

“CCRPP is a true example of public-private partnership “We are thrilled with the trust AFWERX has put in us to
where government stakeholders and an industry consortium lead this consortium,” said Ryan Pleskach, CEO of ResilienX.
are working together on the airspace efforts,” said Darshan “Through a dedicated systems engineering approach, we
Divakaran, Head of AFWERX Airspace Innovation and Prime intend to develop a dual-use solution to the core digital
Partnerships. infrastructure needed for advanced air mobility that is inher-
ResilienX is a company focused on the holistic safety ently scalable and extensible. Through this pioneering effort
assurance of AAM ecosystems and is leading the way with an and with support of all the federal stakeholders that AFW-
industry consortium to create a digital system for AAM oper- ERX is bringing to the table, we believe this solution will be
ations. The project intends to define and perform initial turnkey and available to government and commercial mar-
integration of an AAM Operations Center that is scalable, kets in late 2024.”
tactical and enables verification and validation of the vari- Utilizing the research expertise of NASA and AFWERX’s
ous systems and sensors involved in uncrewed aerial systems, subject matter experts, this collaborative project will attempt
electric vertical take-off and landing operations, and other to meet the needs of the emerging field of AAM operations. It
advanced aviation technologies. The initial AAM Operations is informed by the U.S. Air Force AAM Operations Center
Center will be built out in collaboration with NUAIR at the requirements through testing and operator interactions.
Syracuse Hancock International Airport, with an aim to test The first phase of development will include a detailed
and transition it to additional locations by 2025. need and task assessment, feature development with user
Each company in the consortium contributes their industry interviews and observations, initial integration of baseline
expertise and technological advancements to create the most technologies, and testing. The second phase will see user
robust system possible. As additional requirements are includ- testing of human factors, safety development, prototype
ed by military and other government stakeholders, AFWERX testing, and a live demonstration of the system.
plans to bring in additional industry partners in the next phase. www.afrl.af.mil

Predictive Engine Maintenance


U.S. Army
Redstone Arsenal, AL
703-697-9603
www.army.mil

T he Army has designed the T901 Improved Turbine Engine to


be compliant with Prognostic and Predictive Maintenance
(PPMx) technologies. PPMx, a predictive maintenance strategy
based on relevant data, helps to increase operational readiness
by identifying potential maintenance issues and part failures
before they occur. An extensive array of sensors which enable
this technology outfit the T901’s many components. The T901
is the new 3,000 shaft horsepower engine designed to fit within
the current engine mounting, nacelle and installation envelope
of the AH-64E Apache and the UH-60M Black Hawk helicopters. PPMx features of T901 also support the Army Climate Strate-
It will replace the current T700-GE-701D engine and will also gy (ACS) Line of Effort 2: Acquisition and Logistics. T901 engines
power the Future Attack Reconnaissance Aircraft (FARA). contain components that provide self-diagnosis and automated
The T901, with its onboard PPMx system known as Engine maintenance alerts. This capability is a key driver for employing
Health Management System, or EHMS, supports DoD Instruc- the advanced technology of anticipatory logistics in reducing
tion (DoDI) 4151.22: Condition-Based Maintenance Plus for sustainment demand. Additionally, associated Greenhouse Gas
Materiel Maintenance. DoDI 4151.22 describes Condition Based emissions will be reduced by optimizing parts inventories and
Maintenance Plus (CBM+) as a shift in maintenance behavior gaining supply chain efficiencies brought about by using PPMx.
and practices enabled by technology that focuses on condition The T901 engine’s PPMx system allows increased technology
monitoring, proactive predictions and automated failure analy- and added functionality, which will enable Army Aviation the
sis as well as future data-driven insight. With CBM+ (now necessary capability to apply, integrate and improve reliability
known as PPMx), Army maintainer personnel are better and maintenance effectiveness on both the enduring and future
equipped to anticipate future component failures. They can per- fleets of helicopters. PPMx will enable proactive engine mainte-
form proactive and predictive maintenance at the most oppor- nance that is planned around critical missions. This will increase
tune times and locations using the correct parts and tools, while Army Aviation’s capability in the form of maximized reliability.
prolonging the time on wing for specific components. www.army.mil
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 49
Application Briefs

Next Generation Air and Missile Defense Radar


Raytheon
Arlington, VA
202-384-2474
www.raytheon.com

R aytheon recently completed another successful live-fire


demonstration of the advanced, 360-degree Lower Tier Air
and Missile Defense Sensor (LTAMDS). This tactical ballistic
missile live fire represents the latest in a series of test event suc-
cesses, closely following the cruise missile live fire test and the
recently completed contractor verification testing. All mile-
stones validate the radar’s performance and progression
through developmental testing.
For this test event, conducted in partnership with the U.S. Army,
a tactical ballistic missile surrogate was launched, flying a threat-rep- and future threats – and we will achieve that goal with LTAMDS.”
resentative trajectory. The target was acquired and tracked by Six LTAMDS radars are currently progressing through integra-
LTAMDS, its track data was passed to the Integrated Battle Com- tion and test activities simultaneously at multiple government
mand System (IBCS) for launch command, and LTAMDS guided a and Raytheon test sites. Formal testing will continue in 2024.
PAC-3, Cost Reduction Initiative (CRI), missile to intercept. LTAMDS is the next generation air and missile defense radar
“With each test, we’re putting the radar up against realistic threats for the U.S. Army. A 360-degree, Active Electronically Scanned
that our forces could face on the battlefield. And with each success, Array radar, powered by Raytheon-manufactured Gallium
we see capability improvement for this transformational radar,” Nitride, LTAMDS provides dramatically more performance
said U.S. Army COL Jason Tate, STARE Project Manager for PEO against the range of threats, from manned and unmanned
Missiles and Space. “From the start, the goal was to design a aircraft to cruise missiles, ballistic missiles and hypersonics.
next-generation radar capable of outpacing the full range of current www.raytheon.com

Cold Spray Technology


Naval Air Systems Command
Naval Air Station North Island, CA
619-545-3415
www.navair.navy.mil

I n the realm of naval aviation maintenance, repair, and over-


haul, a transformative technology is taking flight. At the heart
of this revolution is Fleet Readiness Center Southwest (FRCSW),
where a team of dedicated engineers is pioneering the use of cold
spray technology. This innovative approach is not only enhanc-
ing the repair capability for aging aircraft but also paving the way
for substantial cost savings, an increase in readiness, and envi-
ronmental benefits. Luc Doan, a Senior Materials Engineer with
nearly three decades at FRCSW, alongside fellow F/A-18 Senior
Engineer, Conrad Macy and Materials Engineers, Stoney Middle-
ton and Matthew Chu spearheaded this initiative.
Cold spray, a subset of thermal spray technologies, stands out for
its unique method of depositing metallic powder. Unlike other
thermal techniques that rely on heating the powder to its melting
point, cold spray propels the metal powder at high velocities, cre-
ating a solid-state process without the need for melting. This tech-
nique creates a metallurgical bond with the substrate, resulting in
a robust and durable repair. What distinguishes FRCSW in this
field is not just the technology itself but also the scale and sophis-
tication of its implementation. The Materials Engineering Depart-
50 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024
Application Briefs

ment boasts an array of cold spray and ancillary equipment, the technology has led to significant cost savings and avoidance.
including multiple low-pressure cold spray systems manufactured These repairs range from individual components to on-aircraft
by Centerline and Inovati as well as a high-pressure VRC cold spray repairs. For instance, the repair of the F/A-18 APG-73 Radar Rack
system, which has just been added to FRCSW’s repair toolbox. Aft Bulkheads alone saved millions of dollars. To date, FRCSW
These systems are capable of both hand-held and robotic has repaired 51 Aft Bulkheads with another 6 Aft Bulkheads
spray operations. Hand-held spraying accounts for over half of scheduled to be repaired in 2024. A stark contrast to the high
their repairs. This capability has led to over 35 approved repairs costs and long lead-times associated with procuring new parts.
and the restoration of 400 parts, a testament to the technology’s Additionally, the F/A-18 AMAD gearbox and associated repairs
growing significance in maintaining and extending the life of have saved multiple millions of dollars and prevented fleet sup-
naval aircraft. None of the Cold Spray repaired parts has ply shortfalls because of lengthy lead times for new gearbox cast-
returned to the depot because the repair failed in service so we ings. Another example is the on-aircraft repairs that were per-
know the technology is working. formed in the last ten months. The cold spray technology also
Financially, the impact of cold spray at FRCSW is profound. repaired 1 CH-53 for corrosion damage, 4 E-2Ds for gouge dam-
With over 35 approved repairs across various platforms like the age, and 5 UH-1Y for corrosion damage at Camp Pendleton.
F/A-18A-F, EA-18G, MV-22, E-2C/D, C-2A, AH/UH-1 and CH-53, www.navair.navy.mil

Hybrid Electric Aircraft Demonstrator


Airbus
Toulouse, France
+33 6 34 78 14 08
www.airbus.com

A fter several years of travelling between Tarbes and Tou-


louse on a regular basis to oversee EcoPulse’s develop-
ment, Airbus Project Leader William Llobregat found himself
back onsite in November 2023 with his team, and those of
Daher and Safran. The occasion? The first EcoPulse test flight.
“This project was launched in 2019,” says Llobregat, a
next-generation propulsion architect. “It’s really exciting to
have reached the concrete stage of the project where we are
flight testing the technologies we have developed.”
The first flight marks the beginning of an eight-month
flight testing campaign of the distributed hybrid-propulsion
systems and the associated technologies, led by Daher. A All aspects of the different systems, from the way the aircraft
hybrid-electric propulsion system combines a high-voltage responds to the way the power sources are used, were previously
battery with a turbomachine equipped with an electrical gen- simulated digitally and tested by the pilots on the ground. This
erator, and the distributed aspect means there are multiple theoretical data can now be compared with the real flight test data
propulsion “pods” spread along the wings. to help the teams better refine the simulator and improve the per-
Hybridization is an important investment area for Airbus as formance of the different innovative technology components.
estimates show that it could reduce an aircraft’s environmen- Which technology components, you may ask? Airbus, Daher
tal footprint up to 5 percent. The EcoPulse first flight, with and Safran divided the responsibilities of developing the differ-
the functional hybrid-propulsion system aboard, thus marks a ent EcoPulse technologies based on their complementary exper-
major, concrete step in advancing the company’s electrifica- tise. Airbus’ contributions to the demonstrator are the develop-
tion roadmap. ment of the high-energy-density battery that powers the
EcoPulse took off for its inaugural test flight from the propulsors; the aerodynamic and acoustic integration of the
scenic Tarbes–Lourdes–Pyrénées Airport, nestled at the distributed-propulsion system; and the development of a flight
foot of the Pyrénées mountain range in southwest France. control computer system.
Two experimental Daher pilots were onboard the demon- “Technological demonstrators like Ecopulse play a key role in
strator, a modified Daher TBM 900 turboprop aircraft. advancing our industry’s decarbonisation roadmap,” says Llo-
While take-off and landing used the traditional propulsion bregat. “The demonstrators themselves are not intended to ever
engine, the hybrid-propulsion system was activated at enter into service, but they allow us to evaluate, mature and
cruising altitude, where the pilots spent around 20 min- validate individual technologies that can then be integrated
utes running test sequences on the battery while it was into future aircraft.”
powering the flight. www.airbus.com
Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 51
New Products

Short Wave IR Integrated Connector


Cameras Modules
SWIR Vision Systems Bel Fuse Inc. (Santa Clara,
(Durham, NC), a suppli- CA) announced the expan-
er of short-wavelength sion of its single port, 10G,
infrared (SWIR) imaging N B a s e -T, 6 0 W a n d 10 0 W
technology, announced power over Ethernet (PoE),
the release of a new gen- MagJack® integrated connec-
eration of SWIR Cam- tor modules (ICMs). Suitable
eras, powered by the company’s state-of-the-art quantum dot based for a wide range of uses, such
image sensors. The company’s new 4 MP and 6 MP cameras set an as industrial controllers, video
industry benchmark for high resolution SWIR imaging, and provide a cameras, Wi-Fi access points, or any applications requiring a single port
new set of tools for industrial, scientific, security, and defense imaging Ethernet connector. The new ICM products are aimed at customers
applications. looking to upgrade product performance for maximum speed at 60W
www.swirvisionsystems.com or 100W of power.
www.belfuse.com
Tactical Cable Assemblies
Fischer Connectors (Saint- Radar Flight Testing
Prex, Switzerland) released an Simulator
expanded set of cable assem- Mercury Systems, Inc.
blies for the KEYSTONE tactical (Andover, MA) introduced
hub, including three cables for t he first commercially
L3 Harris, Silvus and Bittium available flight testing sim-
tactical radios and two device ulator for air-to-ground
cables for Safran Vectronix’s synthetic aperture radar
MOSKITO TI target locator (SAR) systems. The ARES-
and STERNA True North Find- SAR product builds on
er. Designed to US Army Next more than 25 years of test
Generation Hub (NGH) stan- and train technology from the Mercury Processing Platform to enable
dards, Fischer KEYSTONE™ gives government and commercial organizations to save time and costs by
dismounted soldiers an easy way to manage the flows of data (USB 2.0 reducing the need for actual flight testing through the simulation of
and SMBus) and power (100 W – 5 A max) between sights, sensors, night realistic SAR scenarios on the ground.
vision devices, radios and digital equipment. www.mrcy.com
www.fischerconnectors.com
3U OpenVPX Switch
3U VPX Single Board Annapolis Micro Systems
Computer (Annapolis, MD) now has a HD
Interface Concept (Quimper, switch and chassis that are the
France) the brand-new IC-INT- industry’s first COTS products to
VPX3l, a 3U VPX Single Board integrate high density VITA 91 con-
Computer based on the Intel® nectors that double the available
Xeon® W processor and aligned backplane density. The WILDSTAR
with the SOSA™ Technical Stan- 3U OpenVPX Switch (WP3E20)
dard. The IC-INT-VPX3l board offers up to 128 diff pairs of Ether-
design places the Intel® Xeon® W net. The WILD100 13-Slot 3U Open-
processor as the cornerstone of VPX Chassis (WC31DH) offers up to
the architecture. Ideally suited 64 lanes of Ethernet or PCIe, or 128 LVDS pairs. The rugged WP3E20
for mil-aero and edge applications, the security-enhanced IC-INT- Switch is the next-gen version of Annapolis’ best-selling SOSA™-aligned
VPX3l board-level product improves its processing performance with WP3E10 Switch.
the rich-featured Intel® Xeon® W-11000E Series processor: 8 cores oper- www.annapmicro.com
ating at 2.6GHz providing a spectacular performance per watt ratio,
an advanced Intel® Xe graphics engine, new hardware and software Elastic Network Generator
security devices. Software
www.interfaceconcept.com Keysight Technologies, Inc. (Santa
Rosa, CA) introduced a first in its class
FPGA and SoC Solution advancement in network testing with
Stacks the new Keysight Elastic Network
Microchip (Chandler, AZ) has Generator (KENG) software – an agile,
updated it software design tools composable network test platform
to include High Level Synthesis based on open vendor-neutral API and
(HLS) for system designers who designed for continuous integration
can implement C/C++ based (CI). The KENG software supports the
design, Software Development OTG API, integrates with several net-
Kits (SDKs) for implementing vector-based processing used for AI/ML work emulation platforms, and drives
inferencing and solution stacks for industrial automation and smart a range of Keysight network infrastruc-
embedded vision. New partners, including BeagleBoard, will feature ture test software and hardware products. This includes containerized
prominently in showcasing hardware and solutions as part of Micro- Ixia-c software and the new white box composable UHD400T line-rate
chip’s extensive Mi-V Ecosystem. 400GE traffic generator.
www.microchip.com www.keysight.com

52 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


New Products

Analog over Array™ Reference Designs Clicker 4 Starter Board


Samtec, Inc. (New Albany, IN) has enhanced its
open-pin-field arrays to simultaneously run ana-
log, digital, and power signals. New reference
designs allow Samtec’s proven high-performance
connector arrays, such as the SEARAY™, to support
analog signals. Intended for use in high-density
RF applications, the new Analog over Array refer-
ence designs allow dense, open-pin-field connectors to support digital and analog differential or
single-ended signaling, as well as power.
www.samtec.com

100G Ethernet Switch


Curtiss-Wright’s Defense Solutions Division (Ashburn, VA)
introduced the VPX3-6826, a SOSA aligned 100G Data Plane Mik roElektronika (Belg rade, Serbia)
and Control Plane Ethernet Switch for foundational next-gen- unveiled CLICKER 4, the first in the series of
eration rugged processing systems. Designed and optimized to MIKROE starter boards with the advanced
provide the low-latency, high-speed Ethernet backbone CODEGRIP programmer/debugger on board.
required by modern fiber-distributed aerospace and defense Clicker boards support development using
sensor processing architectures, the new Ethernet switch max- MIKROE’s Click™ board add-on development
imizes connectivity and simplifies system building with both boards. Currently, the company offers more
high-speed copper VPX backplane ports and field proven rug- add-on Click boards than any other compa-
ged optical ports. ny in the world - and calculates that there are
www.curtisswright.com 188, 544, 549, 285 unique combinations that
can be made from the 1,460 boards available.
170 GHz Power Sensors www.mikroe.com
Rohde & Schwarz (Munich, Germany) is launching the new R&S
NRP170TWG(N) thermal power sensor for precise power level mea-
surements in the D-band. It is the only RF power sensor on the mar-
ket that offers full traceability to national metrology institutes
(NMI) in the frequency range from 110 GHz to 170 GHz, an important
Product Spotlight
prerequisite for commercializing the frequency band. The R&S
NRP170TWG(N) hardware is designed to reduce measurement noise and MULTIPHYSICS
drift, while remaining very accurate and easy to use. MODELING AND
www.rohde-schwarz.com SIMULATION
COMSOL Multiphysics 6.2
APPLICATIONS
COMSOL (Burlington, MA) announced the release of COM- COMSOL Multiphysics ® is a
SOL Multiphysics® version 6.2, adding data-driven surrogate software environment for creat-
model functionality for efficient standalone simulation apps ing physics-based models and standalone simulation
and multiphysics-based digital twins. It also features high-per- apps. Add-on products provide specialized func-
tionality for electromagnetics, structural, acoustics,
formance multiphysics solvers for the analysis of electric motors,
fluid flow, heat transfer, and chemical simulations.
up to 40 percent faster turbulent CFD simulations, and an order Interfacing products offer a unified workflow with
of magnitude faster impulse response calculations for room and all major technical computing and CAD tools. COM-
cabin acoustics. Additionally, it is now up to 7 times faster to perform boundary element analysis SOL Compiler™ and COMSOL Server™ are used
(BEM) for acoustics and electromagnetics when running on clusters. for deploying simulation applications to colleagues
www.comsol.com and customers. https://www.comsol.com/products

Nakamura-Tome Machine Tools COMSOL, Inc.


Flexxbotics (Boston, MA) has announced robot machine
tending connectivity compatible with the full range of Nakamu-
ra-Tome machinery and equipment. With Flexxbotics next gen- TOUGHENED,
eration machining environments using robotics with Nakamu-
ra-Tome machine tools achieve higher yields, greater throughput ONE PART EPOXY
and increased profit per part. Flexxbotics’ patent-pending Flexx- WITH HIGH TG
CORE technology enables robots to securely connect and communicate with Nakamura-Tome Master Bond Supreme
machinery in the smart factory to provide more powerful, flexible and open robot connectivity 17HTND-2 is a one part,
than previously possible. toughened epoxy for bonding and sealing. It is not
www.flexxbotics.com premixed and frozen and features an unlimited
working life at room temperature. Supreme
Quantum Processing Unit 17HTND-2 is thermally stable, featuring a high glass
Rigetti Computing, Inc. (Berkeley, CA) a pioneer in full-stack quantum-classi- transition temperature (Tg) of 410°F (210°C). It
cal computing, announced today the launch of its Novera™ QPU, a 9-qubit quan- also meets NASA low outgassing specifications per
tum processing unit (QPU) based on the company’s fourth generation Ankaa™- ASTM E595 testing. https://www.masterbond.com/
class architecture featuring tunable couplers and a square lattice for denser tds/supreme-17htnd-2
connectivity and fast 2-qubit operations. The Novera QPU is manufactured in
Rigetti’s Fab-1, the industry’s first dedicated and integrated quantum device
manufacturing facility. Master Bond
www.rigetti.com

Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 53


Upcoming...

Webinars
Advancing Software Development for the Future of
Autonomous Military Vehicles
Thursday, February 29, 2024 at 12:00 pm U.S. EST
Recent industry breakthroughs in self-driving vehicles are enabling the potential use of autonomous
ground vehicles in military operations. The use of software to control navigation by fusing data from
multiple sensors is a key enabler to the use of autonomous ground vehicle technology in military
operations. This 60-minute Webinar from the editors of Aerospace & Defense Technology will analyze
the maturity level of current software that can enable autonomous ground vehicle navigation.
Speaker:
Kevin O’Brien, Ph.D.
Technical Director,
Defense Innovation Unit,
U.S. Department of Defense

Please visit www.techbriefs.com/webinar426

Webinars on Demand!
SOSA and the Future of Military Computing
The future of military computing will involve a lot more commonality and standardization, both
within each branch of the armed forces and among the various branches. The Sensor Open
Systems Architecture (SOSA) is not a new concept, as the standard and approach has existed
for decades, but SOSA’s widespread adoption is new. This 60-minute Webinar from the editors
of Aerospace & Defense Technology highlights some of the lessons learned as SOSA moves
towards program requirements and the goal we are aiming for.
Speakers:
Jacob Sealander Justin Moll
Chief Architect, Vice President of Sales and
C5ISR Systems, Marketing,
Curtiss-Wright Pixus Technologies

Please visit www.techbriefs.com/webinar372

Maximize Fleet Availability With Virtual Twins


Aerospace companies must maximize the availability of their fleets while anticipating and
mitigating costly disruptions. Data is the key. Extracting the full value of exponential amounts of
complex data in the context of its usage can help reduce support costs and downtime, providing
a competitive advantage. This 60-minute Webinar demonstrates how aerospace companies can
implement predictive analytics to achieve continuous improvement with data science.
Speakers:
Camille Chimot Stephan Erben
Senior Industry Process Portfolio Senior Manager,
Consultant, Data Science Experiences,
NETVIBES, Dassault Systèmes
Dassault Systèmes

Please visit www.techbriefs.com/webinar397


Ad Index
Advertiser Page Web Link Publisher. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Joseph T. Pramberger
Director, Editorial and Digital Content Strategy. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chitra Sethi
Senior Editor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Woodrow Bellamy
Alluxa................................................................................. 1........................................................................... alluxa.com
Associate Editor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Edward Brown
Annapolis Micro Systems, Inc..................................... 38.............................................................annapmicro.com Digital Content Editor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Andrew Corselli
Production Manager. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Adam Santiago
Anritsu ............................................................................. 32, 33...............................................................anritsu.com
Production Coordinator. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . James Rodriguez

Arnold Magnetic Technologies.................................. 11.....................................................arnoldmagnetics.com Creative Director. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lois Erlacher


Graphic Designer. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . John McCarthy
Click Bond, Inc................................................................ 17..................................................................clickbond.com
Marketing Director. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kaitlyn Sommer

Coilcraft............................................................................ 37....................................................................coilcraft.com Senior Marketing Coordinator. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sam Mills


Marketing/Event Coordinator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chris Kendrick
COMSOL, Inc..................................................................... 53, Cover 4.....................................................comsol.com Editor, Custom Content. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Amanda Hosey
Audience Development Director. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Christine Oldenbrook
Create The Future Design Contest............................ Cover 3.............................createthefuturecontest.com
Audience Development Manager . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Erykah Davis
Del-Tron Precision, Inc.................................................. 18.......................................................................deltron.com Subscription Changes/Cancellations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ADT@OMEDA.com
1-866-351-1125
Fluid Line Products, Inc................................................ 29...................................................fluidlineproducts.com
SAE MEDIA GROUP
261 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1901, New York, NY 10016
General Micro Systems, Inc......................................... Cover 2.........................................................gms4sbc.com (212) 490-3999
Executive Vice-President. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Luke Schnirring
Highland Technology, Inc............................................ 2............................................... highlandtechnology.com
Technology Director . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oliver Rockwell
Hunter Products, Inc..................................................... 47......................................................hunterproducts.com Director of Digital Products. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Howard Ng
Digital Media Associate. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Md Jaliluzzaman
LEMO USA, Inc................................................................. 7, 56...................................................................... lemo.com
Digital Media Assistant. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rowena Pagarigan

Master Bond Inc............................................................. 47, 53...................................................... masterbond.com Digital Media Assistant. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Zita Zhang
Digital Production Associate. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Andrew Greenberg
maxon................................................................................ 23, 58........................................................maxongroup.us Digital Production Associate. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Symba Wong
Credit & Collection Manager . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stacie Pointek
Mercury Systems........................................................... 4, 5............................................................mrcy.com/space
Budget & Forecasting. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Felecia Lahey
New England Wire Technologies................................ 9...................................................... newenglandwire.com Accounting/Human Resources Manager. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sylvia Bonilla
A/R Clerk. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Crystal Ortiz
Omnetics Connector Corporation............................. 25, 58...........................................................omnetics.com
Office Manager. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Alfredo Vasquez

Opal Kelly Incorporated............................................... 3.....................................................................opalkelly.com


ADVERTISING ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES
PIC Wire & Cable............................................................. 13.......................................................................picwire.com MA, NH, ME, VT, RI, Eastern Canada. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Brian Hines
(647) 296-5014
Pickering Interfaces...................................................... Cover Flap.......................................... pickeringtest.com CT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stan Greenfield
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (203) 938-2418
Pico Electronics.............................................................. 27......................................................picoelectronics.com NJ, PA, DE. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . John Murray
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (973) 409-4685

SAE AeroTech® 2024...................................................... 31.............................................................sae.org/aerotech TX, OK, LA, AR, MS, AL, TN, FL, SC, NC, GA, DC, WV, VA. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ray Tompkins
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(281) 313-1004
NY, OH. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ryan Beckman
Smiths Interconnect..................................................... 19, 57........................................smithsinterconnect.com . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (973) 409-4687
MI, IN, WI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chris Kennedy
Viking Technology......................................................... 21....................................................vikingtechnology.com . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (847) 498-4520 ext. 3008
MN, ND, SD, IL, KY, MO, KS, IA, NE, Central Canada. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bob Casey
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(847) 223-5225
CA, WA, OR, AZ, NM, Rocky Mountain States. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tim Powers
Aerospace & Defense Technology, ISSN 2472-2081, USPS 018-120. Periodicals postage paid at . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (908) 892-2838
New York, NY and at additional mailing offices. Copyright © 2024 in U.S. is published in Europe. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sven Anacker
February, April, May, June, August, September, October, and December (8 issues) by Tech . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49-202-27169-11
Briefs Media Group, an SAE International Company, 261 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1901, New York,
NY 10016. The copyright information does not include the (U.S. rights to) individual tech Integrated Media Consultants. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Patrick Harvey
briefs that are supplied by NASA. Editorial, sales, production, and circulation offices at 261 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (973) 409-4686
Fifth Avenue, Suite 1901, New York, NY 10016. Subscription is free to qualified subscribers Rick Rosenberg
and subscriptions for non-qualified subscribers in the U.S. and Puerto Rico, $100.00 for 1 (973) 545-2565
year. Digital Edition: $24.00 for 1 year. Single copies: $30.00. Foreign subscriptions, one-year
Todd Holtz
U.S. Funds: $195.00. Remit by check, draft, postal, express orders or VISA, MasterCard, (973) 545-2566
and American Express. Other remittances at sender’s risk. Address all communications for
subscriptions or circulation to NASA Tech Briefs, 261 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1901, New York, NY Jason Setti
10016. Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY and at additional mailing offices. (973) 874-0271
POSTMASTER: Send address changes and cancellations to Aerospace & Defense Daniel Barrett
Technology, P.O. Box 3525, Northbrook, Il 60062. (973) 409-4762
February 2024, Volume 9, Number 1

Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 55


XPONENTIAL EXHIBITOR PREVIEW Sponsored Content

LEMO USA, Inc.


635 Park Ct. Target Markets
Rohnert Park, CA 94928
Phone: 707-578-8811 Because our high-quality Push-Pull connectors are used in
E-mail: info_us@lemo.com a wide range of challenging application environments, LEMO
www.lemo.com/en serves multiple target markets.

About Our Company Products/Services Offered

With over seven decades of experience, LEMO® has estab- LEMO offers interconnect solutions that meet your specific
lished itself as the industry leader in designing and manufactur- requirements, including special materials, personalized layouts,
ing precision custom interconnect solutions. LEMO high-quality and cable assembly.
Push-Pull connectors are used in a wide range of challenging LEMO’s portfolio enables you to select the ideal connector
application environments, including medical, test & measure- configuration to suit almost any specific requirement in most
ment, research, defense & military, information systems, aero- markets, including medical, test & measurement, research, de-
space & autonomous vehicles, robotics, automotive, industrial fense & military, information systems, aerospace & autonomous
control, nuclear, broadcast & audio-video, and communications. vehicle, robotic, automotive, industrial control, nuclear, broad-
LEMO® takes pride in offering an extensive range of products, cast & audio-video, and communications applications.
with over 90,000 combinations available. This selection contin- LEMO takes great pride in the meticulous design and man-
ues to expand through customer-specific designs, ensuring that ufacturing processes, which adhere to strict quality control
LEMO meets the unique needs of every client. LEMO’s com- measures. Every product undergoes thorough inspection and
mitment to innovation, quality, and customer satisfaction has traceability procedures to ensure compliance with its high stan-
solidified its position as a trusted partner in various industries. dards. This commitment to excellence has earned LEMO several
As a result, LEMO® and its affiliated sister companies, REDEL®, accolades within the
NORTHWIRE®, and COELVER®, have successfully served more industry, solidifying
than 100,000 customers in over 80 countries around the world. its reputation as a
trusted provider of
top-quality intercon-
nect solutions.
When you choose
LEMO, you can have
confidence in the re-
liability and perfor-
mance of its prod-
ucts, backed by un-
wavering dedication
to quality and cus-
tomer satisfaction.

XPONENTIAL Booth 4710

56 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


Sponsored Content XPONENTIAL EXHIBITOR PREVIEW

Smiths Interconnect
3477 SE Willoughby Blvd, Suite 103 Target Markets
Stuart, FL 34994
E-mail: focom.uscsr@smithsinterconnect.com Aerospace and defense, electronics, test and measure,
www.smithsinterconnect.com medical, semiconductor test, and industrial markets.

About Our Company Products/Services Offered

Smiths Interconnect is a leading provider of high reliability We offer a breadth of highly reliable, quality interconnect
connectivity products and solutions serving segments of aero- solutions proven in the harshest military environments. Our
space and defense, medical, semiconductor test, and industrial application expertise ensures the design, manufacture and sup-
markets. It designs and manufactures technically differentiated ply of cost-effective, high-volume products and complete tai-
electronic components, microwave, optical and radio frequency lored solutions. Our technically differentiated products consist
products, and sub-systems that connect, protect and control of board-level components incorporating advanced resistive
critical applications. and signal distribution technologies for a broad range of fre-
quency spectrum applications, high performance microwave
cable assemblies and coaxial components and embedded opti-
cal transceiver modules and backplane connectors.

XPONENTIAL Booth 3549

Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024 mobilityengineeringtech.com 57


XPONENTIAL EXHIBITOR PREVIEW Sponsored Content

Target Markets

Medical, Industrial Automation, Aerospace, and e-Mobility

maxon
125 Dever Drive Products/Services Offered
Taunton, MA 02780
Phone: 508-677-0520 Offering solutions that fit your customized needs
E-mail: info.us@maxongroup.com maxon’s line of products include DC brushed and brushless
www.maxongroup.us motors, gearheads, encoders and controllers – these products
are easily combined into complete mechatronic drive systems.
As a global leader in the design, manufacturing, and engineering
About Our Company services of high precision drive systems, maxon works closely
with you to develop innovative product solutions that precisely
maxon develops and builds high precision electric drive sys- meet the unique operating parameters of your individual system
tems that are among the best in the world. Specialists in com- in your industry. But, did you know that we also offer contract
bining electric motors, gears and DC motor controls into manufacturing
high-precision, intelligent drive systems that can be cus- services? Consider
tom-made to fit the specific needs of customer applications. partnering with us
maxon helps provide innovative solutions at competitive prices on your next proj-
for numerous applications in various markets. ect. We have the
experience and in-
dustry-specific
solutions that will
get your product
to market faster.

XPONENTIAL Booth 4938

Target Markets

Our connectors are highly sought after by designers working


in the medical, military, aviation, aerospace, and other lead-
Omnetics Connector Corporation ing-edge industries.
8840 Evergreen Blvd
Minneapolis, MN 55433
Phone: 763-572-0656 Products/Services Offered
E-mail: sales@omnetics.com
www.omnetics.com Omnetics understands
the rigorous operating
conditions mission-critical
About Our Company applications endure and
our solutions include EMI
Omnetics Connector Corporation is a leading global provider of shielding, IP sealing, polar-
precision and high-reliability electronic connectors and intercon- ization, rugged materials,
nect systems. For more than 30 years, we have engineered an ex- and other elements that
tensive portfolio of ensure connectivity under
innovative products, pressure. We maintain a large inventory of off-the-shelf products.
with a special focus Our high-reliability portfolio includes:
on nano-miniature Micro and nano strip connectors; Micro and nano circular con-
interconnects. Our nectors; Nano-D/Bi-Lobe®; Polarized nano connectors; Squeeze-
connectors are latching nano connectors; MIL-DTL-32139 Nano-D connectors;
among the small- MIL-DTL-83513 Micro-D connectors; Micro-D and latching Micro-D
est on the market connectors; Hybrid connector configurations; Cable assemblies.
and deliver excep- We take great pride in the products we build for you. Omnetics
tional performance is a privately held company and we exist to advance innovation
in challenging work wherever it is needed next.
environments.
XPONENTIAL Booth 4828

58 mobilityengineeringtech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, February 2024


ARE YOU READY
TO LEAD
THE FUTURE?

MARCH 1, 2024
CreateTheFutureContest.com

P L AT I N U M S P O N S O R S GOLD SPONSOR
Simulate real-world
designs, devices, Innovate
and processes faster.
with COMSOL Test more design iterations
before prototyping.

Multiphysics®
comsol.com/feature/multiphysics-innovation Innovate
smarter.
Analyze virtual prototypes and
develop a physical prototype
only from the best design.

Innovate with
multiphysics
simulation.
Base your design decisions
on accurate results with
software that lets you study
unlimited multiple physical
effects on one model.

You might also like