Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Professionalism in Nursing Behaviors of

Nurse Practitioners
DONNA ADAMS, DNSC, RN,* AND BARBARA K. MILLER, PHD, RN†

Little research on the level of professionalism of to gain their rightful place in delivering quality and
nurse practitioners has been published to date. These cost-effective care. For many years, scholars in other
nurses are expected to practice relatively autono-
fields identified nursing as a semiprofession because of
mously in delivering client care and therefore must
monitor their own levels of professionalism. At a na- the lack of a university-based education as the entry
tional conference, 502 nurse practitioners completed level, the lack of autonomy, and a paucity of theory and
the Professionalism in Nursing Behaviors Inventory. research to serve as a foundation for the field (Etzioni,
Participants represented all of the states and the 1969). The fact that the nursing profession was com-
most common specialties of nurse practitioners. posed primarily of women hindered its achievement
Nearly 68 per cent had been practitioners less than 5
years and were primarily employed in physicians’ of-
of a full profession as well because it was considered
fices. The majority had received their master’s de- women’s work and therefore less valuable. Nursing re-
grees from schools with nurse practitioner curricula, mains confusing to the public because of the various
and 8 per cent held doctorates. More than one half of ways of gaining entry into the field. As theory and
the practitioners had written a research proposal or research in nursing increased, and women’s worth in
participated in a project within the past 2 years. In
society was realized, nurses, in turn, became more au-
terms of autonomy, nearly 50 per cent of the nurses
had written their own job descriptions. Maintaining tonomous and nursing was generally recognized as a
certification motivated them to engage in some pro- full profession. More recently, the health care climate
fessionalism behaviors. Results indicated these nurse has embraced primary care, and NPs with advanced
practitioners had high levels of professionalism. education have become recognized as valuable mem-
(Index words: Nursing; Professionalism; Behaviors; bers of health care teams. Nurse practitioners provide
Nurse Practitioners) J Prof Nurs 17:203-210, 2001.
Copyright © 2001 by W.B. Saunders Company
comprehensive, effective health care (Garrard et al.,
1990; Nichols, 1992).

T HE THRUST OF NURSING in the new century


will continue to emphasize advanced practice
and the appropriate settings in which it occurs. Nurse
Purpose

practitioners’ extended education, with a basis in the- Little is known about the levels of professionalism of
ory and research, has enhanced their image. The use of nurse practitioners. Therefore, the purpose of this
a scientific foundation for every type of nursing prac- study was to investigate behaviors indicative of profes-
tice has become essential. Thus, more autonomous sionalism in nurse practitioners.
nurses with increased credentials are convincing soci-
ety even further of the value of nursing. As with any
profession, obligations and commitment are inherent. Method
Defining professionalism in nursing has been as dif- SAMPLE
ficult a feat as that achieved by nurse practitioners (NP)
The convenience sample of nurse practitioners was
obtained from attendees at the American Academy of
*Associate Professor, Arizona State University, College of Nurs- Nurse Practitioners Annual Conference held in Phoe-
ing, Tempe, AZ. nix, Arizona, in 1998. Nurses, staff, students, and pre-
†Professor Emeritus, Arizona State University, College of Nurs-
ing, Tempe, AZ.
senters other than nurse practitioners were included in
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Adams: Ar- the 1,624 participants. Only the 502 responses from
izona State University, College of Nursing, Tempe, AZ. E-mail: certified nurse practitioners were used for this study.
donna.adams@asu.edu. Subjects completing the usable questionnaires repre-
Copyright © 2001 by W.B. Saunders Company
8755-7223/01/1704-0012$35.00/0 sented all states.
doi:10.1053/jpnu.2001.25913 Appropriate human subjects review groups ap-

Journal of Professional Nursing, Vol 17, No 4 (July–August), 2001: pp 203-210 203


204 ADAMS AND MILLER

proved the study. At the conference, potential subjects and the ANA Code for Nurses (1985). An instrument
received a research packet and a cover letter stating that was designed to test the Wheel model.
completion and return of the anonymous questionnaire The original tool, the Professionalism in Nursing
to an enclosed box signified consent to participate. Behaviors’ Inventory, was constructed, revised, and
used for various studies (Miller, Adams, & Beck,
INSTRUMENT 1993); then adapted for Nurse Practitioners in 1998 by
The Wheel of Professionalism in Nursing is a model the authors. Forty-eight items comprise the instru-
of professionalism behaviors (see Figure 1). These be- ment, 10 of which question demographics and opin-
haviors previously were identified by sociologists (Flex- ions of professionalism in nursing questionnaires. The
ner, 1972; Freidson, 1983; Hall, 1982; Millerson, nine categories of behaviors representing professional-
1964), nursing leaders (Aydelotte, 1983; Downs, ism are determined by 38 items. The categories include
1978; Styles, 1982), the American Nurses Association educational preparation, autonomy, theory, and ad-
(ANA) policy statement (1980), standards of practice, herence to the ANA Code of Ethics, as well as partici-

Figure 1. Wheel of Professionalism in Nursing. Copyright ©1984 Barbara Kemp Miller.


PROFESSIONALISM IN NURSING BEHAVIORS 205

pation in publication, research, professional organiza- TABLE 1. Demographic Characteristics of


tions, and community service, as well as maintaining Nurse Practitioners
competency. Total N ⫽ 502 %
In previous studies using the tool, Cronbach’s alpha
Sex
has ranged from .64 to .87 (Adams, Miller, & Beck, Women 441 87.8
1996; Miller et al., 1993) and was .74 for the current Men 29 5.8
research. Nurses employed in educational and practice Not responding 32 6.4
Age
areas established the content validity. A total compos- 20–25 3 0.6
ite score of 27 is possible because behaviors are 26–30 18 3.6
weighted within each of the nine categories to equal 3. 31–40 112 22.3
41–50 256 51
51⫹ 112 22.3
DATA ANALYSIS Not responding 1 0.2
Years as RN
Statistical tests in SPSS were used to analyze the 0–5 31 6.2
data. Means were used to identify the scores in the 6–10 49 9.8
11–15 88 17.5
weighted scale for the nine categories, and a composite 16–20 114 22.7
score was derived from the totals in each. 21–25 114 22.7
26⫹ 105 20.9
Not responding 1 0.2
Findings Years as NP
0–5 340 67.7
DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS 6–10 46 9.2
11–15 41 8.2
The sample was composed of 441 (88 per cent) 16–20 42 8.4
women and 29 (6 per cent) men with 32 (6 per cent) 21–25 27 5.4
participants not identifying their sex. Demographic 26⫹ 5 1.0
Not responding 1 0.1
data are presented in Table 1. The demographics of the Place of employment
sample were fairly comparable to those available na- Physician’s office/clinic 229 45.6
tionally for nurse practitioners (U.S. Department of Hospital 65 12.9
Free-standing facility 51 10.2
Health and Human Services, 1996). Male respondents School of nursing 23 4.6
in the study were slightly higher (5.8 per cent) than is Occupational health/industry 9 1.8
represented in the national NP population (4.3 per Self-employed 8 1.6
Nursing home 7 1.4
cent). Overall, 71 per cent of NPs nationally are 40
More than 1 area 24 5.0
years of age or older, whereas 73 per cent of the NPs in Other 83 16.5
this study were in that age group. A limitation of the Not responding 3 0.4
study is that educational backgrounds may differ from
the participants in this study who chose to attend the
convention and NPs who did not attend. Results of the study are explained in relation to each
With the recent emphasis toward educating increas- of the Wheel’s 9 categories. The categories are then
ing numbers of nurse practitioners, it was not surpris- compared with existing standards, roles, and educa-
ing to find that 68 per cent of these individuals had tional needs for nurse practitioners.
been nurse practitioners for 5 years or less. Nationally,
74 per cent of NPs are employed outside hospitals and Education in a University Setting and Scientific
58 per cent list direct patient care as their dominant Background in Nursing
function (U.S. Department of Health and Human Ser- The basic domains and standards of the nurse prac-
vices, 1996). Half of the respondents specialized in titioner have been identified by the ANA guidelines
family or community health clinical practice areas, for advanced practice (ANA, 1980) and by the Na-
whereas the smallest area represented was psychiatric/ tional Organization of Nurse Practitioner Faculties
mental health (n ⫽ 6). The nurse practitioners were (NONPF, 1990). These criteria are congruent with
primarily employed in physician’s offices or clinics (46 the areas depicted in Miller’s model, the Wheel of Pro-
per cent); hospitals and freestanding clinics repre- fessionalism (Lindeke, Canedy, & Kay, 1997; Miller,
sented the next most popular places of employment. 1988). Where the model depicts a university education
Eighty-three marked other without identifying their and an accompanying scientific background as the cen-
place of employment. ter or hub of the Wheel holding all of the eight spokes
206 ADAMS AND MILLER

together, NONPF states nurse practitioner curricular nately, NPs are continuously increasing their research
needs to be grounded in graduate level preparation, efforts on clinical problems in the primary care arena
which includes research and theory. The Academy’s (Bullough, 1995), and this current study supports the
Scope of Practice for Nurse Practitioners (1998) spec- interest of NPs in research.
ifies that a master’s degree is the requisite entry-level Findings indicated that 136 (27 per cent) of the
preparation for a NP. Thus, advanced education in a respondents were currently involved in a research
university setting with its inherent scientific focus is project, with 65 functioning as principal investigators.
generally agreed on as necessary for nurse practitioners The majority of subjects had acquired additional re-
to function effectively. search knowledge by taking a research course or attend-
The majority of respondents (78 per cent) had re- ing a research seminar during the past 2 years. Fifty-
ceived their master’s degrees from schools with nurse two per cent of the nurse practitioner participants had
practitioner curricula. Another 18 possessed other written a proposal or participated in a research project
types of master’s degrees. Doctorates were held by 38 within that time period. The majority of respondents
(8 per cent). Nationally, two thirds of NPs have grad- expressed a familiarity with numerous nursing and ed-
uate degrees (U.S. Department of Health and Human ucational theories as well as nurse practitioner models,
Services, 1996). The remainder of the sample reported and indicated they applied them in their practices.
other types of educational preparation. As a group, the Most respondents (84 per cent) used the nursing pro-
subjects had possessed their highest degree for less than cess to guide the care of clients.
5 years. However, 67 per cent (68 per cent, nationally)
had received their basic RN degree more than 15 years
earlier. Self-Regulation and Autonomy
The knowledge derived from advanced education
provides a foundation for professionals to acquire
Research and Theory Development, Use, authority to make decisions in their area of expertise
and Evaluation (Freidson, 1970). The profession of nursing has cre-
Two spokes of the Wheel represent research and ated and endorsed a licensing method for nurses who
theory issues. NONPF constructed the guidelines for meet requirements for curricular and clinical activities.
nurse practitioner curricula based on the National Possessing a registered nurse (RN) license signifies a
League for Nursing’s criteria for including theory and nurse has successfully completed a standardized na-
the application of theory to practice in practitioner tional examination and can therefore render safe nurs-
programs (National League for Nursing, 1989). NPs ing care to the public. The certified NP has taken an
possessing abilities to identify questions in nursing additional credentialing test, which shows the knowl-
practice as researchable topics is one of the NLN crite- edge gained during advanced education and clinical
ria as well. The Academy’s Scope of Practice document practice. The extra certification contributes to the
includes conducting and participating in research as power of nurse practitioners to self-regulate and to
part of a nurse practitioner’s accountability for the out- practice autonomously. It is now accepted in health
comes of care that is rendered (American Academy of care that nurse practitioners are autonomous and can
Nurse Practitioners, 1998). Graduates of nurse practi- function as direct providers of care in many settings
tioner programs should be able to evaluate and use (American Academy of Nurse Practitioners, 1996;
theory and research as well (American Association of 1997; American Association of Colleges of Nursing,
Colleges of Nursing, 1996). 1996; National Organization of Nurse Practitioner
The close proximity of nurse practitioners to client Faculties, 1990).
and organizational problems places them in a position NP credentials, received from national nursing or-
to test theories and identify problems in practice that ganizations, were held by 427 (85 per cent). One hun-
need to be studied. For many years, however, there was dred and thirty-nine participants were credentialed by
a dearth of research conducted by NPs. The time and more than one entity. In the study, the majority of
energy needed to establish the NP role meant less time respondents were making clinical decisions autono-
to devote to research efforts, especially in the clinical mously, accountable for direct client outcomes, collab-
areas. Thus, researchers in other disciplines conducted orating with physicians, and independently determin-
studies involving NPs that often did not adequately ing what their positions involved. In fact, almost half of
represent the nursing profession’s research require- the nurse practitioners had written their own job de-
ments or client problems (Shamansky, 1985). Fortu- scriptions.
PROFESSIONALISM IN NURSING BEHAVIORS 207

TABLE 2. Autonomous Activities of Nurse respondents were members of the ANA, and 93 per
Practitioners Other Than Direct cent belonged to the Academy, which sponsored the
Patient Care conference. The majority of respondents were mem-
Activity Total N ⫽ 502 % bers in other nursing organizations, including Sigma
Theta Tau International and others. This group of
Self-evaluation 373 74
Quality assurance 326 65 nurses evidenced a high rate of belonging to nursing
Nursing audits/patient audits 283 56 organizations, and more than one-third held an office
Peer review 226 45 or participated on committees in organizations (see
Consultation 165 33
Budgeting 149 30 Table 3).
Performance evaluations 110 22
Hiring personnel 87 17 Competence and Continuing Education
Ethics committee 59 12
A commitment to life-long learning and self-devel-
opment is an expectation for members of any profes-
Other autonomous activities of the NPs included sion (Flexner, 1972; Hall, 1982). Participating in con-
peer review, nursing care/client audits, quality assur- tinuing education activities aids nurse practitioners in
ance activities, agency budgets, and individual or their credentialing and certification efforts as well as
group consultations. Participation in formal ethical de- keeping them informed of new developments that have
liberations concerning practice was the weakest com- an impact on their practices. Thus, the Academy and
ponent in this area. Only 346 subjects answered the other professional organizations encourage, support,
question about participation on an ethics committee, and provide forums for continuing education. In addi-
and, of those, 59 responded yes. Nevertheless, many of tion, achieving and maintaining certification motivates
these nurse practitioners were participating in the des- NPs to continue to develop professionally. Behaviors
ignated autonomous activities that are believed to help measured in this category included attending work-
professionals regulate and guide their practices. Nearly shops relevant to the practice area of the NP, reading or
74 per cent of the NPs regularly engaged in self-evalu- subscribing to professional journals, or purchasing
ation of the way they practiced (see Table 2). books associated with their practices. Educational ses-
sions attended by participants within the past 2 years
Participation in Professional Organizations included content related to clinical issues, promotion
of leadership and management, analyses of health pol-
Professional organizations provide a sense of com- icies, and studying components of the NP role.
munity among nurses as well as furnish resources and During the previous 2-year period addressed by the
guidance for practice. They promote collegiality, professionalism questionnaire, nearly all (98 per cent)
which not only fosters trust and respect with each of the respondents reported attending seminars or
other, but advances the interests of professional nurs- workshops. The NPs (97 per cent) also subscribed to
ing as an entity. The American Nurses Association is and read nursing and related journals. More than 90
the primary referent professional organization for per cent had purchased a book concerning nursing or
nurses and is recognized by the government, health the practice of the NP. Administrative and supervisory
care agencies, and society as the official representative activities were part of some of the subject’s practices,
of registered nurses. ANA defines the scope of practice 38 per cent attended seminars concerning manage-
for registered nurses, formulates and disseminates gen- ment, and 134 had purchased a book on management
eral standards, and promotes a code of ethics as the in the prior 2-year period.
foundation for any nursing practice. In addition to
protecting consumer interests, the ANA and specialty
organizations, such as the American Academy of Nurse TABLE 3. Participation in Professional
Practitioners, lobby for autonomy for nurses in rela- Organizations
tion to the appropriate use of their skills and knowl- Organizational Membership Total N ⫽ 502 %
edge. Membership in these groups allows nurses a fo-
ANA 258 51
rum where they can use the skills gained in NP AANP* 466 93
education to advocate for clients as well as for the nurs- Sigma Theta Tau 317 63
ing profession and to serve as change agents within the Others 264 53
health care arena. Hold office or committee service 169 34

In the current study, more than one half of the NP *American Academy of Nurse Practitioners.
208 ADAMS AND MILLER

Community Service major activity for these respondents, the findings were
One of the original and continuing aspects of pro- congruent with other studies that used the same pro-
fessionalism is the altruistic factor of providing exper- fessionalism tool and involving nurse managers, staff
tise without thought of remuneration. Throughout the nurses, and other types of nurses. Shamansky (1985)
decades, and especially in the nursing community, determined that 73 per cent of a NP’s time is spent
nurses as employees in health care agencies were caring for clients, thus, a lack of time needed to write
“trained” to abstain from discussing wages and salaries articles and papers may hinder nurse practitioners’ ef-
because nurses were to be solely committed to caring forts in this area.
for others (Melosh, 1982). This attitude constituted nurs-
ing altruism, which was based on the fact that nurses were Adherence to the ANA Code of Ethics
educated in hospitals. However, when nursing education The Code for Nurses with Interpretive Statements
moved away from agencies and into higher education, (ANA, 1985) includes behaviors that protect consum-
altruism was not defined in the same manner. A profes- ers and enhance the well being of those individuals as
sional does have an obligation to serve the public, but nursing care is delivered. The Code is a vehicle for peer
primarily as a volunteer in nonprofit situations. and self-evaluation of the quality of care rendered to
In previous studies that used the Professionalism in consumers by RNs. In addition to evaluation, the
Nursing Behavior Inventory, the majority of nurse re- Code guides and assists RNs in all phases of nursing
spondents reported an interest and participation in practice. It forms the ethical framework for any nurs-
community service (Miller, Adams, & Beck, 1993). In ing practice and is the body of work on which stan-
the current study, service was also a priority with 430 dards for practice are based. Unfortunately, not all
(88 per cent) reporting involvement in community ac- nurses are aware the Code exists, whereas others believe
tivities. One third of the respondents functioned as agency and various forms of regulatory bodies are more
leaders in their communities by serving on advisory essential than the profession’s generally accepted ethi-
boards and committees of various organizations. cal code (Beck, Miller, & Adams, 1993). A profession
possessing a code of ethics with well-articulated behav-
Publication and Communication iors that are enforced legally by standards is considered
to have an advanced professionalization process (Bern-
Sharing knowledge with colleagues is a behavior in-
hard & Walsh, 1990). Therefore, students in all types
cluded in the Wheel of Professionalism. Communica-
of nursing programs need to become knowledgeable
tion and dissemination of nursing practice issues and
about the ANA Code for Nurses.
interventions is a method of showing collegiality, col-
Respondents were asked if they used the ANA
laboration, and support for all nurses. Whether the
Code or some other specific ethical framework for
communication is through professional organizations
their practices. Almost half (48 per cent) of the sub-
or publications, this behavior is essential to profession-
jects indicated a positive response. The fact that 52
alism in nursing. Most nurses do not learn the publi-
per cent did not use an ethical framework indicates
cation process until pursuing a graduate degree, so the
more attention needs to be paid to ethics in nurse
skills needed to publish are an outcome of advanced
practitioner curricula.
education. In addition, the mentoring of every RN’s
publication efforts by skilled nursing authors and val-
uing such activities would enhance nursing practice by Total Score
increasing communication among nurses. A composite score of 27 is possible on the Profes-
For many years, NP’s publishing efforts in relation sionalism in Nursing Behaviors’ Inventory. The mean
to clinical research went largely unrecognized because composite score achieved by 279 nurse managers in a
they were subsumed under doctors’ names on articles. similar study using the inventory was 13.4 (Adams et
Now, NPs write about many topics, including client al., 1996). A group of nurses in various practice settings
problems, and are frequently first-listed authors (Bul- obtained a score of 10.13, on average. In other research
lough, 1995). Respondents in this study were asked if using the inventory, 161 nurse executives scored 14.90
they had published or submitted manuscripts to nurs- (Stoltz, 1991). The range for the NPs in this study was
ing or other professional journals. Nearly 100 (20 per 6.5 to the highest, 27. Their mean composite score was
cent) had submitted manuscripts for publication in 16.7, making their levels of professionalism the highest
nursing journals, and 63 had been published in peri- of any group tested with the Professionalism in Nurs-
odicals other than nursing. Although this was not a ing Inventory thus far, except for a group of nurse
PROFESSIONALISM IN NURSING BEHAVIORS 209

educators who averaged 18.7 (Miller et al., 1993). For A major finding of this research is the need to pro-
the nurse practitioners, highest category scores were duce new nurse practitioners because more than half of
obtained in competence, education, and the use of the- the individuals were 41 years of age or older. Another
ories. The lowest category scores were publication and need is for NPs to share information more with col-
research (see Table 4). leagues. As younger nurses become NPs, their levels of
publication and research may increase because of the
Discussion longer period they will have to be socialized into their
roles. Certainly, teaching NPs how to conduct re-
This study serves to identify aspects of nursing pro- search, write articles, and present at conferences needs
fessionalism in nurse practitioners. Though the Profes- to be increasingly emphasized in NP programs to dis-
sionalism in Nursing Behaviors’ Inventory can be used seminate information about practice. NP educators
to determine levels of behaviors indicative of profes- must take more prominent roles as mentors of NP
sionalism in groups of nurses as it was in this research, students and those newly graduated. Knowing that
it is to be primarily used at regular intervals by individ- support and assistance was readily available from on-
ual nurses to help them aim their careers toward the going mentoring could increase productivity with
most productive paths. The specific behaviors of pro- NPs’ research and publication efforts. In addition,
fessionalism, delineated in the Wheel, can help NPs some leadership and management content needs to be
evaluate their career goals by identifying personal included in programs because these NPs indicated they
strengths and weaknesses. were starting to incorporate those elements into their
The use of ethics becomes increasingly important as roles, especially in independent facilities.
the number of patient dilemmas increases during the It was apparent in the study that the NPs delivered
NP’s career. In addition, NPs frequently practice alone care relatively autonomously. At the present time, the
and most monitor their own work, thereby needing autonomy scores on the Professionalism Inventory in-
some consistent framework on which to base their eval- dicate that NPs generally do not hire, evaluate, and
uations. Results from this study indicate a need for dismiss employees, but instead concentrate on care de-
emphasizing ethical frameworks in NP curricula and livery. This behavior may change for some NPs in the
teaching students how to use the frameworks in the future as they establish and administer their own clin-
clinical courses. ics. One result that is relatively new for nursing is the
NPs and other nurses, who need continuing educa- fact that many NPs decide what they will do in practice
tion to meet certain certification and regulatory crite- by writing their own job descriptions. Up until now,
ria, tend to achieve higher levels of professionalism. the only nurses who wrote their own job descriptions
Because they render primary care autonomously and consistently were nurse executives.
aim to deliver quality care to clients, required and con- Like other nurses who completed the Professionalism
tinuous certification and credentialing of NPs appears Inventory, the NPs were active in community service.
to be influencing client outcomes by NPs’ exposure to These activities contribute to the well being of members
new ideas and methods of practice. of society. They show the public that NPs, and nurses in
general, are knowledgeable and can become leaders in
TABLE 4. Professional in Nursing Behaviors’ guiding and determining health policy. Community ser-
Inventory Scores for NPs vice helps NPs gain the trust of other health professionals
as well. Maintaining a high level of professionalism can
Total N ⫽ 502
Professionalism Inventory promote this trust in NPs, nurses, and nursing in general.
Subscales Range Mean* SD

Educational preparation .5–3.00 2.75 .64 Note


Publication .0–3.00 0.37 .75
Research .0–3.00 0.98 .96 For information about the Professionalism in Nurs-
Professional organizations .0–3.00 1.98 .75 ing Behaviors’ Inventory, contact Donna Adams, RN,
Community service 0.–3.00 2.36 .92
Competence 1.0–3.00 2.79 .39 DNSc, College of Nursing, Arizona State University,
Code of ethics 0.–3.00 1.51 1.50 Tempe, AZ, 85287-2602.
Theory 0.–3.00 2.68 .68
Autonomy 0.–3.00 1.40 .76
Total scale score† 6.5–27.00 16.70 3.60 Acknowledgment
*Possible range 0 –3. The authors thank Lori Weaver, MS, Research Assistant, for her
†Possible range 2–27. statistical support.
210 ADAMS AND MILLER

References

Adams, D., Miller, B. K., & Beck, L. (1996). Profession- Arnold, S., Kepferie, L., McDermott, S., & Buchanan, J. L.
alism behaviors of hospital nurse executives and middle (1990). Impact of geriatric nurse practitioners on nursing-
managers in 10 western states. Western Journal of Nursing home residents’ functional status, satisfaction, and discharge
Research, 18, 77-88. outcomes. Medical Care, 28, 271-283.
American Academy of Nurse Practitioners. (1996). Nurse Hall, R. (1982). The Professions, Employed Professionals,
Practitioner as an Advanced Practice Nurse: Role Position and the Professional Association: Professionalism and the Em-
Statement. Austin, TX: Author. powerment of Nursing. Kansas City, MO: American Nurses’
American Academy of Nurse Practitioners. (1997). The Association.
Nurse Practitioner: A Primary Health Care Professional. Aus- Lindeke, L., Canedy, B., & Kay, M. (1997). A compari-
tin, TX: Author. son of practice domains of clinical nurse specialists and nurse
American Academy of Nurse Practitioners. (1998). Scope practitioners. Journal of Professional Nursing, 13, 281-287.
of Practice for Nurse Practitioners. Austin, TX: Author. Melosh, B. (1982). The Physician’s Hand. Philadelphia:
American Association of Colleges of Nursing. (1996). Temple University Press.
The Essentials of Master’s Education for Advanced Practice Miller, B. K. (1988). A model for professionalism in nurs-
Nursing. Washington, DC: Author. ing. Today’s OR Nurse, 10, 18-23.
American Nurses’ Association. (1980). Nursing: A Social Miller, B. K., Adams, D., & Beck, L. (1993). A behavioral
Policy Statement. (Publication No. NP-63.) Kansas City, inventory for professionalism in nursing. Journal of Profes-
MO: Author. sional Nursing, 9, 290-295.
American Nurses’ Association. (1985). Code for Nurses Millerson, G. (1964). The Qualifying Associations. Lon-
with Interpretive Statements. (Publication No. G-56.) Kansas don: Routledge & Regan.
City, MO: Author. National Organization of Nurse Practitioner Faculties.
Aydelotte, M. (1983). Professional nursing: The drive for (1990). Advanced Nursing Practice: Nurse Practitioner Cur-
governance. In N. Chaska (Ed.), The Nursing Profession: A riculum Guidelines (Final Report of the Education Commit-
Time to Speak (pp. 83-84). NY: McGraw-Hill. tee). Washington, DC: Author.
Beck, L., Miller, B. K., & Adams, D. (1993). Use of the National League for Nursing. (1989). Criteria for the
code of ethics for accountability in discharge planning. Evaluation of Baccalaureate and Higher Degree Programs (6th
Nursing Forum, 28, 5-12. ed.). Pub. No. 15-1251. New York: Author.
Bernhard, L. A., & Walsh, M. (1990). Leadership: The Nichols, L. M. (1992). Estimating the cost of underusing
Key to the Professionalization of Nursing. St. Louis: Mosby. advanced practice nurses. Nursing Economics, 10, 343-351.
Bullough, B. (1995). Professionalization of nurse practi- Shamansky, S. (1985). Nurse practitioners and primary
tioners. Annual Review of Nursing Research, 13, 239-265. care research: Promises and pitfalls. Annual Review of Nurs-
Downs, F. (1978). Doctoral education in nursing: Future ing Research, 3, 107-125.
directions. Nursing Outlook, 26, 56-61. Stoltz, C. (1991). Professionalism in nurse administra-
Etzioni, A. (1969). The Semi-Professions and Their Orga- tors. Submitted.
nizations. NY: McMillan. Styles, M. (1982). Society and nursing: The new profes-
Flexner, A. (1972). Medical Education in the United States sionalism. In The Professions, Employed Professionals, and the
and Canada: A Report to the Carnegie Foundation for the Professional Association: Professionalism and the Empower-
Advancement of Teaching. NY: Arno Press. (Original work ment of Nursing (p. 18). Kansas City, MO: American
published in 1910.) Nurses’ Association.
Freidson, E. (1983). The theory of professions. In R. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Health
Dingwall, & P. Lewis (Eds.), The Sociology of Professions (p. Resources and Services Administration. Bureau of Health
11). NY: Martin’s Press. Professions. Division of Nursing (1996). Health workforce
Garrard, J., Kane, R. L., Radosevich, D. M., Skay, C. L., profile. Washington, DC: Author.

You might also like