ûý õ #

#
<$<7
<700337#
#
#

Authorized for use only in the course COMMERCE 4PA3 at McMaster University taught by Nick Bontis from 8/9/2023 to 12/22/2023.
#
#
6$%
6$%(1$
1$##%(/*,
%(/*,$1
$1#:25/'#$,5/,1(6
,5/,1(6=##
=##
:(<7-(16*#
:(<7-(16 *#),567
),567## $66,*10(17 #
#
#
#
0DU\# &URVVDQ
0DU\# &URVVDQ## DQG# %DUEDUD
%DUEDUD## 3LHUFH
3LHUFH## SUHSDUHG# WKLV# FDVH FDVH## VROHO\# WR WR## SURYLGH# PDW
PDWHULD
HULDOO# IRU# FODVV# GLVFXVVLRQ
GLVFXVVLRQ1# 1# # 7KH#
DXWKRUV# GR# QRW # LQWHQG# WR
WR## LOOX
LOOXVWUDWH
VWUDWH##HLWKHU
HLWKHU## HIIHFWLYH
HIIHFWLYH## RU# LQHIIHFW
LQHIIHFWLYH LYH# KDQGOLQJ# RI# D# PDQDJHULDO# VLWXDWLRQ
VLWXDWLRQ1## 7KH#DXW
1##7KH DXWKRUV
KRUV#
PD\## KDYH#GLVJXLVHG#FHUWD
PD\ FHUWDLQ LQ##QDPHV#DQG#RWKHU#LGHQWL LGHQWLI\LQJ
I\LQJ#LQIRUP
LQIRUPDWLRQ
DWLRQ##WR WR##SURWHFW
SURWHFW##FRQILGHQW
FRQILGHQWLDOLW\
LDOLW\1#
1#
#

Use outside these parameters is a copyright violation.

,YH\## 0DQDJHPHQW
,YH\ 0DQDJHPHQW## 6HU 6HUYYLFHV
LFHV## SURKLELWV# DQ\ # IRUP IRUP## RI# UHSURGXFW
UHSURGXFWLRQ LRQ/#/# VWRUDJH# RU# WUDQVPLWW
WUDQVPLWWDO DO# ZLWKRXW# LWV # ZULW
ZULWWHQ
WHQ##
SHUPLVVLRQ1#
SHUPLVVLRQ 1# # 7KLV
7KLV## PDW
PDWHULDO
HULDO## LVLV## QR
QRWW# FRYHUHG
FRYHUHG## XQGHU# DXWKRUL]DWLRQ# IURP# &DQ&RS\# RU# DQ\# UHSURGXF UHSURGXFWLRQWLRQ# ULJKWV#
RUJDQL]DWLRQ1# # 7R7R## RUGHU# F RSLHV# RU# UHTXHVUHTXHVWW# SHUPLVVLRQ# WR WR## UHSURGXFH# PDWHU PDWHULDOV
LDOV/#
/# FRQ
FRQWDFW
WDFW## ,YH\ # 3XEOLVKLQJ
XEOLVKLQJ/#/# ,Y
,YH\
H\#
0DQDJHPHQW## 6HUYLFH
0DQDJHPHQW 6HUYLFHV V/# F2R# 5LFKDUG
5LFKDUG## ,YH\
,YH\## 6FKRRO
6FKRRO## RIRI## %XVLQHVV
%XVLQHVV/# /# 7KH
7KH## 8QLY
8QLYHUVLW\
HUVLW\# RI# :HVWH
:HVWHUQ UQ## 2QW
2QWDULR
DULR/#
/# /RQGRQ
/RQGRQ/# /#
2QWDULR/#
2QWDULR &DQDGD/#
/#&DQDGD 19$#6.:>#SKRQH#+84<,#9940653;>
/#1 #+84<,#9940653;>##ID[ ID[#+84<,#99406;;5>#
#+84<,#99406;;5>#H H0PDLO
PDLO##FDVH
FDVHV#LYH\
V#LYH\11XZR XZR11FDFD1#
1#
#
&RS\ULJKW##
&RS\ULJKW ‹##4<<7/#
##‹ ,YH\##0 DQDJHPHQW
##4<<7/#,YH\ DQDJHPHQW##6HUYL 6HUYLFHV
FHV## 9HUVLRQ=#+
9HUVLRQ $,#533503<036
=#+$ ,#533503<036##
#
#
#
$V# KH# DSSURDFKH
DSSURDFKHGG# WKH WKH## GRRU# WR WR## KLV# QHZ# RIILFH
RIILFH## (ULN
(ULN## :H\
:H\WMHQVWMHQV## WKRXJK
WKRXJKWW# WRWR## KLPVHOI
KLPVHOI=# =#
³7KLV# LV# LW>#>#,,# KRSH# ,¶Y
,¶YHH# PDGH
PDGH## WKH
WKH## ULJKW
ULJKW## GHFLVLRQ1´# ,W# ZDV# -XO\ -XO\## 4<<5/# DQG# :H\ WMHQV/#/#
:H\WMHQV
ZKR## RQ
ZKR O\## WKH
RQO\ WKH## ZHHN
ZHHN## EH IRUH## FRPSOH
EHIRUH FRPSOHWHG WHG# KLV# 0%$
0%$## GHJUHH
GHJUHH## DWDW## ,1
,16 6($
($' '# LQ# )UDQFH
)UDQFH/#/#ZDV
ZDV##
VWDUWLQJ## D# QHZ# MRE# ZLWK# 6DEHQD# %HOJ
VWDUWLQJ %HOJLDQLDQ## :RUO
:RUOGG# $LUOLQHV
$LUOLQHV1# 1# 7R
7R## VRPH
VRPH/#/# ZRUNLQJ
ZRUNLQJ## IRU#
6DEHQD##ZD
6DEHQD ZDVV#WKHWKH##KHLJKW
KHLJKW##RI#IROO
IROO\\1#1#7KH
7KH##FRPSDQ\
PSDQ\##ZDV#EDUHO\ EDUHO\##VXUYLYLQJ
VXUYLYLQJ1#1#,Q ,Q#WKH#SDVW#\HDU#
DQG## D# KDOI
DQG KDOI## LW# KDG# IDFHG# WKH# LPSDFW# RI# WKH# *XOI# :DU# RQ# DL DLUOL QH# WUDYHO/# GHFO
UOLQH LQLQJ#
GHFOLQLQJ
HFRQRPLF## FRQGLWLR
HFRQRPLF FRQGLWLRQV QV## LQ# PDQ\# FRXQWULH
FRXQWULHVV# LW LW## VHUYLFHG
VHUYLFHG/#/#DQG
DQG## ZKDW# FRXO FRXOGG# RQO\# EH# FDOOHG
FDOOHG##
VXLFLGDO##SULFH
VXLFLGDO SULFH##FRPSH WLWLRQ##LQ#WKH#JORED
FRPSHWLWLRQ JOREDOO#DL DLUOL
UOLQHQH##LQ GXVWU\\1#1#$Q
LQGXVWU $Q##LQIXVLRQ
LQIXVLRQ##RI#JRYHU QPHQW##
JRYHUQPHQW
PRQH\## DQG# ILQDQFLD
PRQH\ ILQDQFLDOO# UHVWUXFWXULQJ
UHVWUXFWXULQJ## KDG# UHVFXHGUHVFXHG## 6DEHQD# LQ LQ## WKH# VSULQJ
VSULQJ## RI# 4<<4/# EX EXWW#
WKH## FRP
WKH FRPSDQSDQ\\# ZDV
ZDV## VWLOO
VWLOO## QRW# JHQHUDW
JHQHUDWLLQJ QJ## VXIILFLH
VXIILFLHQQW# LQF RPH# IURP
LQFRPH IURP## RSHUDWLRQV
RSHUDWLRQV##WR# DFKLHYH
DFKLHYH##
ELOLW\1#1# 0DQDJHPHQW# IDFHG# DQ# HQRUPRXV# FK
SURILWDELOLW\
SURILWD DOOHQJH## WR# JH
FKDOOHQJH QHUDWHH# SURILWV# IURP#
JHQHUDW
WKH##RSHUD
WKH WLRQ##RI
RSHUDWLRQ RI##DQ
DQ##DLUOLQ
DLUOLQHH1#
#
WMHQV## ZDV# ZHOO# DZDUH
:H\WMHQV
:H\ DZDUH## RI# WKHWKH## VHULRXV
VHULRXV## SURE
SUREOHPVOHPV## IDFLQJ
IDFLQJ## 6DEHQD
6DEHQD## EXW/# OLNH# RWKHUV#
ZKR# KDGKDG## MRLQHG
MRLQHG## WKH# FRP FRPSDQSDQ\\# VLQFH# WKH# DUULYDO
DUULYDO## RI# 3LHUUH
3LHUUH## *RGIU
*RGIURLG RLG/# 6DEHQD
6DEHQD¶V ¶V## QHZ
QHZ##
FKDLUPDQ# DQG DQG## &(
&(2 2/#/#KH
KH## ZDV# H[ FLWHGG# E\
H[FLWH E\## WKH# SURVSHFWV# RI# WKH# FKDOOH QJH1#1#+H
FKDOOHQJH +H## NQHZ
NQHZ## LW
LW##
ZRXOG# EH# KDUG KDUG## ZRUN/# XQFHUWDLQ
XQFHUWDLQ## WLPHV
WLPHV## DQG
DQG## WKHUH
WKHUH## ZRXOG# EH# IHZ IHZ## UHZDUGV
UHZDUGV## DORQJ
DORQJ## WKH#
ZD\/#EXW# KH# FRXOGFRXOG## QRW# KDYH# DVNHG# IRU IRU## D# EHWWHU
EHWWHU## RSSRUWXQLW\
RSSRUWXQLW\## WR# WHVW# DQG# WR# VWUHWFK# KL KLVV#
PDQDJHPHQW
PDQDJ HPHQW##DELOL
DELOLWLHV
WLHV1#1#
#
#

2385578 - CEI ©
3DJH#5#
3DJH#5# <$<7
<70
0337
337##
#
#
$#1(
1(:
:#7$
7$.(
.(00 2))#)25#6$
6$%(1$
%(1$##
#
:KHQQ#3LHUUH
:KH 3LHUUH## *RGIURLG#WR RN##RY
WRRN RYHUHU## DV#&KDLUPDQ#RI#6DEHQD 6DEHQD##%HOJ
%HOJLDQLDQ##:RU
:RUOG OG##$LUOLQHV
$LUOLQHV##LQ LQ##
-DQXDU\/#/# 4<<4/# WKH# FRPSDQ\# ZDV# GDQJHURXVO\# FORVH# WR# EDQNU
-DQXDU\ XSWF\1#1#7KH
EDQNUXSWF\ 7KH## FRPSDQ\
FRPSDQ\##
KDG##QRW
KDG QRW##PD
PDGHGH#PRPRQHQH\#IURP
IURP##RSH UDWLRQV##LQ
RSHUDWLRQV LQ##RY
RYHUHU##VHYHQ
VHYHQ##\HDUV#DQG#ZDV#IDFLQJ IDFLQJ##LWV#ODUJHVW#

Authorized for use only in the course COMMERCE 4PA3 at McMaster University taught by Nick Bontis from 8/9/2023 to 12/22/2023.
GHILFLW# HYHYHUHU## ²# RYHU
RYHU## WKUHH# ELOOLRQ
LOOLRQ## %HOJLDQ
%HOJLDQ## )UDQ)UDQFV #+86
FV#+ '<;#PLOO
86'<;# PLOOLRQ ,1## ,Q
LRQ,1 ,Q## DGGLWL
DGGLWLRQ RQ/# /# LW
LW##
KDG# YLUWXDOO\# QR# ILQDQFLDO#FDSDFL FDSDFLW\ W\#DV# LWV# HTXLW
HTXLW\\# ZDV# VHULRXVO\#GHSOHWHG# DQG# LWV# GHEW#
ORDG##RQ
ORDG HURXV1#1#7KH
RQHURXV 7KH## VLWXDWLRQ
VLWXDWLRQ##ZDV ZDV## JUD
JUDYHYH1#1#7KH
7KH#JRYHUQPHQW#DVNHG# WKDW WKDW## *RGIURLG¶V#ILUVW#
SULRULW\## EH# WKH#GHYHORSP
SULRULW\ GHYHORSPHQW HQW# RI#D# SODSODQQ#WRWR##WXUQ
WXUQ## DURXQG
DURXQG##WKHWKH## FRPSDQ\
FRPSDQ\/#/# ZKLFK# *RGIURL *RGIURLGG#
SURGXFHG##ZLWKLQ
SURGXFHG ZLWKLQ##WZR#PRQWKV
PRQWKV##RI#WDN QJ##RYH
WDNLLQJ RYHUU1#
#
7KH## UHVXOWLQJ
7KH UHVXOWLQJ## GRFXP
GRFXPHQW HQW/#/# HQWL WOHG# ³$# 1HZ# 7DNH0RII# IRU# 6DEHQD
HQWLWOHG 6DEHQD//´# DGGUHVVHG# WKUHH#
PDMRU## DUHDV# RI# FKDQJH1# )LUVWO\/# WKH# FRPSDQ\
PDMRU FRPSDQ\## ZRXOG# DJJUH DJJUHVVLYVVLYHO\HO\# SXUVXH#
ELOLW\1#1# 7KH# FRP
SURILWDELOLW\
SURILWD SDQ\¶V# 45# VXEVLGLD
FRPSDQ\¶V VXEVLGLDULHV ULHV## ZRXOG# EH# EU RXJKW# WRJHW
EURXJKW WRJHWKHUKHU## XQGHU
XQGHU## RQHRQH##
UHVWUXFWXUHG## RUJDQL]
UHVWUXFWXUHG DWLRQ## DQG
UJDQL]DWLRQ DQG## IRFX
IRFXVV# DWWH QWLRQ# RQ# LWV# FRUH
DWWHQWLRQ FRUH## EXV
EXVLLQHVV# RI RI## DL
DLUU# WUDYHO1#
ILWDELOLW\\# ZRXOG# EH# LQFUHDVHG
3URILWDELOLW
3UR LQFUHDVHG## E\ E\## UDWLRQDOL]
UDWLRQDOL]LQJ LQJ## URXWHV
URXWHV/# /#ZHHGLQJ
ZHHGLQJ## RXW RXW## XQSU RILWDEOH##
XQSURILWDEOH

Use outside these parameters is a copyright violation.

GHVWLQDWLRQV
GHVWLQDWLR QV/# UHGXFLQJ# WKH WKH## ZRUNIRUFH
ZRUNIRUFH## E\ E\## 43# WR# 48# SHU# FHQW# DQG# PDN PDNLQJLQJ## D# FRQFHUW
FRQFHUWHG HG##
HIIRUW# WRWR## FXW# FRVWV# ZKHUHYHU# IHDVLE IHDVLEOH OH1#1#,,QIRUPDWLRQ
QIRUPDWLRQ## V\ VWHPVV# ZR
V\VWHP XOG# EH# LQWU
ZRXOG RGXFHG# WR
LQWURGXFHG WR##
LPSURYH##ILQDQFLDO#FRQWURO#DQG#WR#WUDFN#UHVXOWV1#
LPSURYH
#
6HFRQGO\/#/# WKH# FRPSDQ
6HFRQGO\ FRPSDQ\\# ZRXOG# HVWDE HVWDEOLVKOLVK## D# QHZ
QHZ## FDSLWDO
FDSLWDO## EDVH
EDVH## WR# UHSODFH
UHSODFH## LW LWVV# GH
GHSOHW
SOHWHG HG##
HTXLW\1#1# 6DEHQD# DVNHG# IRU# DQ# LQIXVLRQ# RI# JRYH
HTXLW\ UQPHQW## IXQGLQJ
JRYHUQPHQW IXQGLQJ## WR# V WDELOL]
WDELOL]HH# LWV#
ILQDQFLDOO# FRQGLWLR
ILQDQFLD FRQGLWLRQQ# DQDQGG# WR WR## SURYLGH
SURYLGH## WKHWKH## QHFHVVDU
QHFHVVDU\\# FDVK# WR# IX QG# WKH# UHFRYHU\
IXQG UHFRYHU\## SODQ SODQ1#1#
7KH##SODQ
7KH SODQ##FDOOHG
FDOOHG##IRU
IRU##6DEHQD#WR#LV VXH##D#VW
LVVXH RFN##RIIHULQJ
VWRFN RIIHULQJ##ZKLF
ZKLFKK#ZRXO
ZRXOGG/# /#KRSH IXOO\/#DWWUDF
KRSHIXOO\ DWWUDFWW#
SULYDWH#FDSLWDO# DV# SURILWDELOLW
SURILWDELOLW\\#LQFUHDVHG
QFUHDVHG## DQG# WKH WKH## FRPSDQ\
FRPSDQ\## EHFDP
EHFDPHH# PRUH#LQWHUHVWLQWHUHVWLQJ LQJ##
WR## RXWV
WR LGH## LQYHVWRUV1# 7KLU
RXWVLGH 7KLUGO GO\\/# WKHUH# ZDV# D# SRVVLE LOLW\## RI# RXWVLGH# HTXLW\
SRVVLELOLW\ HTXLW\## LQIXVLRQ# LI LI##
6DEHQD# FRXOGFRXOG## DWWUDFW# DQDQ## DOOLDQFH
DOOLDQFH## SDUWQHU
SDUWQHU1# 1# 6DEHQD# KRSHG# WR WR## FRPSOH
FRPSOHWH WH## QHJRWL DWLRQV##
QHJRWLDWLRQV
ZLWK##%U
ZLWK LWLVKK#$L
%ULWLV UZD\V## DQG2RU#./
$LUZD\V ./0 0# WRWR##HVWDEOLV
HVWDEOLVKK#DQ DQ##DOOLDQFH
DOOLDQFH##DJUHHPHQW
DJUHHPHQW1#1#$OWK $OWKRXJKRXJK## QR QRWW#
DQ## LPPH
DQ LPPHGLDWHGLDWH##SULRU LW\/#/# WKH#FRPS
SULRULW\ FRPSDDQ\ Q\## DOVR# KRSH
KRSHGG# WRWR##LQWHUHVW#WKLV
WKLV##IXWXUH
IXWXUH## SDUWQH
SDUWQHUU#LQ LQ## WKH
WKH##
LVKPHQW##RI
HVWDEOLVKPHQW
HVWDEO RI##D#(XURSHDQ#³KXE´ ³KXE´##DW#=DY =DYHQWH
HQWHP P#DLUSRUW1#
#
#
7+(##),1$/#%$
7+( %$,/
,/00287 #
#
2Q# WKH
WKH## VWUHQJWK# RI# WKH
WKH## 7DNH
7DNH00RII# 3ODQ
3ODQ## DQG# WUXVW
WUXVW## LQ# *R
*RGIURL G¶V## DELO
GIURLG¶V LW\## WR# PDQDJH
DELOLW\ PDQDJH## D#
WXUQDURXQG## RI# WKLV# PDJQLWX
WXUQDURXQG PDJQLWXGH GH/# WKH# JRYHU QPHQW## DGYDQFH
JRYHUQPHQW DGYDQFHGG# 6DEHQD# WKH WKH## IXQG
IXQGLQJ LQJ## LW
LW##
QHHGHG## WR# V WDELOL]
QHHGHG WDELOL]HH# RS
RSHUDW LRQV1# 7K
HUDWLRQV 7KHH# %HOJLD
%HOJLDQQ# JRYHUQPHQW
JRYHUQPHQW## PDGH PDGH## LW# FOHDU
FOHDU## WKLV# ZDV
ZDV## WKH
WKH##
ODVW#WLPH#LW# ZRXO
ZRXOGG#³EDLO0RXW´#WKH# ILUP1#$V#IDU# DV#WKH# JRYHUQPH JRYHUQPHQW QW##ZDV
ZDV##FRQFHUQHG
FRQFHUQHG/# /#WK
WKHH#
LRQ# RI# QHZ# IXQGV# SODFHG# WKH# DL
LQIXVLRQ
LQIXV UOLQHH# RQ# VWDE
DLUOLQ OH## JURX
VWDEOH QG## DQG
JURXQG DQG## LW# ZDV
ZDV## XS# WR#
HPHQW#WR
PDQDJHPHQW
PDQDJ WR## PDNH# WKH
WKH## DLUOLQH
DLUOLQH## VHOI
VHOI00VXS SRUWLQJ1#1#*RGIURLG
VXSSRUWLQJ *RGIURLG## ZDV
ZDV## JLYHQ# WKHWKH## DXWKRU
DXWKRULW\ LW\##
WR##WDNH
WR WDNH##WRWDO
WRWDO##FRQW URO##RI#WKH
FRQWURO WKH##DLUOLQH¶V
DLUOLQH¶V##IXWX
IXWXUHUH1#1#7KH
7KH## JRYHU QPHQW##DOVR
JRYHUQPHQW DOVR## SURP LVHG## LW
SURPLVHG LW##ZRXOG
ZRXOG##
QR## ORQJHU
QR ORQJHU## LQWHUIHUH# ZLWK# WK WKHH# GD\0WR0GD\
GD\## RSHUDWLRQV
RSHUDWLRQV1#1#*RGIURLG
*RGIURLG# ZDV# DZDUH# WK WKDWDW# DORQJ#
ZLWK# WKH
WKH## WUDQVIHU
WUDQVIHU## RI# FRQWURO
FRQWURO## FDPH
FDPH## WKH
WKH## UHVSRQVL ELOLW\## IRU
HVSRQVLELOLW\ IRU## VXFFHVVIXO
VXFFHVVIXOOO\# LPSOH PHQWLQJ##
LPSOHPHQWLQJ
WKH# WXUQ# DURXQG
DURXQG## SODQ1# 7KH# JRYHUQPHQW# ZDV# DQ[LRXV# WR WR## VHH# 6DEHQD# EHFRPH EHFRPH##

2385578 - CEI ©
3DJH#6#
3DJH#6# <$<7
<70
0337
337##
#
#
SURILWDEOH# VR
SURILWDEOH VR## LW# FRXOG
FRXOG## HYHQWXDOO\# SULY DWL]H# WKH# DLUOLQH
SULYDWL]H DLUOLQH1#1# ,W
,W## ZDV
ZDV## WLPH
WLPH## IRU
IRU## 6DEHQD# WR
WR##
VHYHU#WLHV
WLHV##ZLWK
ZLWK##WKH
WKH##SDVW#DQG
DQG##WR
WR##VWDQG
VWDQG##RQ#LW
LWVV#RZQ
RZQ1#1#
#
#
1(:##0$
1(: 0$1$
1$*
*(0
(0(1
(17
7#

Authorized for use only in the course COMMERCE 4PA3 at McMaster University taught by Nick Bontis from 8/9/2023 to 12/22/2023.
#
*RGIURLG¶V## ILUV
*RGIURLG¶V ILUVWW# PDMRU# WD VN# RI# WKH
WDVN WKH## WXU
WXUQQ# DURXQG# ZDV# WR# EXLOG# D# WHDP# RI# QHZ# VHQLRU#
H[HFXWLYHV1# 7KH 7KH## DLUOLQH# ZRUNHUVZRUNHUV## FRXQFLO# KDG# VW DWHG# WK
VWDWHG DW# DOWKRXJK# WKH\
WKDW WKH\## OL NHG## WKH
OLNHG WKH##
SODQ/#/#WKH
SODQ WKH\\# GLGQ¶W# EHO LHYH# *RGIURLG# FRXOG
EHOLHYH FRXOG## SXOO
SXOO## LW
LW## RII1# ³7KH# SHRSOH
SHRSOH## \R \RXX# KDYH# DURXQG#
\RX## DUH
\RX DUH## WKH
WKH## SHRSOH
SHRSOH## ZKR# EURXJK EURXJKWW# XV# WR WR## GHIHDW
GHIHDW1#1#:K\
:K\## VKRXOG# ZH# EHOLHYH# WKDW# WKLQJ WKLQJVV#
ZLOO# EH# DQ DQ\\# GLIIHUHQW
GLIIHUHQW## LQ LQ## WKH
WKH## IXWXUH"´
IXWXUH"´## 7R 7R## PDNH
PDNH## FKDQJH
FKDQJH## KDSSHQ
KDSSHQ## DQG DQG## WR
WR## VKRZ
VKRZ## KRZ#
VHULRXVO\## KH# ZDV# FRPP
VHULRXVO\ FRPPLWWHG LWWHG# WR# WKH# IXWX
IXWXUH UH# RI# WKH# FR FRPS
PSDQ\ DQ\/# *RGIURLG# VHW# RXW# WR# KLUH#
WKH# EHVW
EHVW## SHRS
SHRSOH OH# KH# FRXOG
FRXOG## DWWUDF
DWWUDFWW1#1#³7KH
³7KH## PRVW
PRVW## GLIIL FXOW## WD
GLIILFXOW VN## ,# KDG
WDVN KDG## ZDV
ZDV## EXLOG
EXLOGLLQJ#D# QHZ#
WHDP11´#,W
WHDP ,W## ZDV
ZDV## GLI ILFXOWW# EHFDXVH#KH#GLG# QRW
GLIILFXO QRW## KDYH#PXFKPXFK##WR# RIIHU#WKH#NLQG#RI# SHRSOH#KH#
QHHGHG1#1#7KH
QHHGHG 7KH## SHRS
SHRSOH OH## KH
KH## ZDV
ZDV## ORRNLQ
ORRNLQJJ# IRUIRU## DOUHDG\
DOUHDG\##KD KDGG# JRRG# MREV MREV/#/# ZRU
ZRUNLQ NLQJJ# FRQGLWL
FRQGLWLRQV RQV#
DQG## VDODU
DQG VDODULHVLHV1#1# ,W
,W## ZDV# KDUG# WR# DVN DVN## VXFK
VXFK## SHRSOH# WR# JLY JLYHH# XS
XS## ZK
ZKDW DW## WKH\
WKH\## KDG# WR# MRLQ# D#

Use outside these parameters is a copyright violation.

FRPSDQ\# IDFLQJ# VXFK# DQ DQ## XQFHUWDLQ
XQFHUWDLQ## IXWXUH1# 1#6ORZO
6ORZO\\/# /#KRZHYHU
KRZHYHU/# /# KH# ZD
ZDVV # DEOH
DEOH## WRWR## PDNH
PDNH##
FKDQJHV1#
FKDQJHV 1# 0RVW
0RVW## RI# WKH# SHRSOH# KH# EURXJK URXJKWW# RQ# ERDUGERDUG## ZHUHZHUH## SHRSOH# ZKR ZKR## MRLQHG
MRLQHG## WKH#
]DWLRQ##EHFDXVH
RUJDQL]DWLRQ
RUJDQL EHFDXVH## WKH\ WKH\##ZHUH
ZHUH## DWWUDFW
DWWUDFWHG HG##E\
E\## WKH# HQRU PRXV##FKDOOHQJHV
HQRUPRXV FKDOOHQJHV## SUHV HQWHG## E\
SUHVHQWHG E\##
ZRUNLQJ# WRZDUG# WKH WKH## 6DEH
6DEHQD QD## WXUQDURXQG
WXUQDURXQG1#1#:LWK :LWKLQ LQ## D# \H
\HDU
DU/#/#*RGIURLG
*RGIURLG## KDG# UHSODFHG UHSODFHG## WZR#
WKLUGVV# RI# WKH
WKLUG WKH## RU LJLQDO# VHQLRU
RULJLQDO VHQLRU## H[ H[HFX
HFXWLY HV1#1#$V
WLYHV $V## QHZ# OHDGHUVKLS
OHDGHUVKLS## MRLQHG
MRLQHG## WKH# FRPSD
FRPSDQ\ /# KH#
Q\/#
VDZ##WKH
VDZ WKH##RUJDQL]
UJDQL]DWLRQDWLRQ#EHJLQQLQJ
EHJLQQLQJ##WR#FKDQ FKDQJH JH1#
#
*RGIURLG¶V## PDQDJH
*RGIURLG¶V PDQDJHPHQW PHQW## DSSURDFK# ZDV# WR WR## VXSS
VXSSRUW RUW# KL
KLVV# HPSOR\
HPSOR\HHV HHV/# QRW# WR WR## FRQWURO
FRQWURO##
WKHP1#1#+LV
WKHP +LV#SUHIHUHQFH
SUHIHUHQFH## ZDV# WR#JL YH# SHRSO
JLYH SHRSOHH# FOHDU
FOHDU##WDUJHWV
WDUJHWV/# /#OHW#WKHP
WKHP##RSHUDWH
RSHUDWH##DV DV## WKH\##VDZ
WKH\ VDZ##
ILW## DQG
ILW DQG## WR
WR##UHZDUG
UHZDUG## WKRVH#ZKR ZKR##SHUIRUPHG
SHUIRUPHG## ZH ZHOOOO1#
1#5HVSRQ VLELOLW\\#KDG
5HVSRQVLELOLW KDG## WR
WR##EH#PRYHG
PRYHG##GRZQ#
WR# WKH
WKH## OHYHO# DW DW## ZKLFK
ZKLFK## LW LW## ZDV
ZDV## PRVW# DSSURSULDWH1# 7KHUH# QHHGHG# WR WR## EH# PXFK
PXFK## OHVV#
GLUHFWLRQ## IURP# WKH
GLUHFWLRQ WKH## ³WRS´
³WRS´## DQG# PX PXFK FK# PR
PRUH UH# LQLWLD WLYH# IURP
LQLWLDWLYH IURP## WKRVH
WKRVH## GRLQJGRLQJ## WKHWKH## MRE1#
³5HDOLW\\# LV# LQ# WKH# ZRUOG/# QRW# LQ# P\# RIILFH/´# VDLG# *RGIURLG
³5HDOLW *RGIURLG1# 1# 7KLV# VW\ OH## ZDV
VW\OH ZDV## VRVR##
GLIIHUHQW## IURP
GLIIHUHQW IURP## WKHWKH## WUDGL LRQDO## PDQDJH
WUDGLWWLRQDO PDQDJHPHQW PHQW# DSSURDFK
DSSURDFK## DW DW## 6DEHQD/# LW LW## ZDV
ZDV## D# GLIILFXOW
GLIILFXOW##
DQG## OHQJWK\
DQG OHQJWK\## SURFHVV # WR# JHW# DOO# PDQDJ PDQDJHPHQW HPHQW# ZLWKZLWKLQ LQ# WKH# RUJDQL]D
RUJDQL]DWLRQ WLRQ## WRWR## RSHU
RSHUDWHDWH## ZLWK
ZLWK##
WKH# VDPH# IUD PH## RI# UHIHUHQFH1# ,W
IUDPH ,W## ZDV# DOVR# WDNLQJ# WLPH# IRU# HPSOR\ HPSOR\HHV HHV## WR
WR## WUXVW
WUXVW## WKDW
WKDW##
PDQDJHPHQW
PDQDJ HPHQW##YDOXHG#LQGHSHQGHQWLQGHSHQGHQW##DFWLRQ1#
#
#
$#1(
1(:
:# 675
675$$7(*<
(*<##
#
7KH# 7DNH0RII RII## 3ODQ## KDG
3ODQ KDG## VHW
VHW## LQ# PRWLRQ# LPPHGLD
LPPHGLDWH WH# FKDQJHV
FKDQJHV## WR# RSHUDWLR
RSHUDWLRQQ V# DW# 6DEH
6DEHQD QD1#1#
)LQDQFLDOO# UHVWUXFWXULQJ
)LQDQFLD UHVWUXFWXULQJ/#/# DWWH PSWV# WR
DWWHPSWV WR## UHWXUQ
UHWXUQ## WR# SURILWD ELOLW\## DQG# WKH# SRWHQW
SURILWDELOLW\ SRWHQWLDOLDO## RI# DQ
DQ##
DOOLDQFH##SDUWQHU
DOOLDQFH SDUWQHU## ZHUH
ZHUH##UHT
UHTXLUHPHQ
XLUHPHQWV WV##IR
IRUU#VX
VXUYLY DO## RI
UYLYDO RI##WKH
WKH##DL
DLUOL
UOLQH1#,W
QH1# ,W##KDG
KDG## EHHQ
EHHQ##LPSRU
LPSRUWDQW WDQW##
WR## IRF
WR XV## RQ
IRFXV RQ## WKHVH
WKHVH## LVVXHV
LVVXHV## WR
WR## MXV WLI\# IXUWKHU
MXVWLI\ IXUWKHU## JRYHUQPHQW
JRYHUQPHQW## VXSSRUW/# EXW# *RGIU RLG## NQHZ
*RGIURLG NQHZ##
WKDW# LQ# RUGHU# WR# SUHSDUH
SUHSDUH## WKH# DL DLUOL QH# IRU# LWV# XQFHUWDLQ# IX
UOLQH WXUH/#/# KH# ZRXOG# QHHG# D#
IXWXUH
PHDQLQJI
PHD QLQJIXOXO## DQG
DQG## VX
VXVWDLQD EOH## EXVLQHV
VWDLQDEOH EXVLQHVVV# VWUDWHJ\
VWUDWHJ\## DV# ZHOO
ZHOO1#1# 7KH# SUHGRPLQDQW# VWUDWHJ\
VWUDWHJ\## LQ#
WKH## DLUO
WKH LQHH# LQGXV
DLUOLQ WU\## ZDV# WR# IRFXV# RQ# ORZ#FRVW1# ,W# ZRXOG# KDYH# EHHQ# YHU\# GLIILFXOW# IRU#
LQGXVWU\
6DEHQD## WR
6DEHQD WR## DGRSW
DGRSW## WK LV## W\
WKLV W\SHSH## RI# VWUDWHJ\
VWUDWHJ\/# /# KRZHYHU/# EHFDXVH# RI# LW LWVV# FOHDUO\
FOHDUO\##

2385578 - CEI ©
3DJH#7#
3DJH#7# <$<7
<70
0337
337##
#
#
XQFRPSHWLWLYH# FRVW
XQFRPSHWLWLYH FRVW## VWUXFWXUH1# 6DEHQD
6DEHQD## ZDV ZDV## VHULRXVO\# RYHUVWDIIHG# DQG# LQHII QHIILFL HQW1#1#
LFLHQW
*LYHQ# WKHWKH## FXUUHQW
FXUUHQW## VWDWH
VWDWH## RI# DIIDLUV
DIIDLUV/# /# LW
LW## ZRXOG
ZRXOG## KDYH
KDYH## WDNHQ
WDNHQ## IDU
IDU## WRR
WRR## ORQJ# WR WR## PDNH
PDNH## WKH
WKH##
QHFHVVDU\##DGMXVWPHQ
QHFHVVDU\ DGMXVWPHQWV /#DQ
WV/# DQGG# WKH# W\ SH# RI# FKDQJH# UHT
W\SH XLUHG# ZRXO
UHTXLUHG ZRXOGG# KDYHKDYH## FDXVHG
FDXVHG## D# JUHDW
JUHDW##
GHDO## RI
GHDO RI## SDLQ
SDLQ## IR
IRUU# WKH
WKH## RUJDQL DWLRQ## DQ
RUJDQL]]DWLRQ DQGG# WKH
WKH## FRXQWU\
FRXQWU\1#1# %\# WKH# WLPH# 6DEHQD# ZDV # LQ# D#
LRQ#WR#FRPSHWH
SRVLWLRQ
SRVLW FRPSHWH##RQ#ORZ ORZ##FRVW
FRVW/# /#WKHUH
WKHUH##PLJKW
PLJKW##QRQRWW#EH#D#FRPSDQ\#OH OHIWIW##WR
WR##RSHUDW
RSHUDWHH1#

Authorized for use only in the course COMMERCE 4PA3 at McMaster University taught by Nick Bontis from 8/9/2023 to 12/22/2023.
#
7KH## LPPHGLD
7KH LPPHGLDWH WH## VROXWL RQ## ZDV# IRU# 6DEHQD
VROXWLRQ 6DEHQD## WR# GLIIHUHQW
GLIIHUHQWLDWHLDWH## LW
LWVV# VHUYLFHV
VHUYLFHV## WR WR## MXVWLI\
MXVWLI\## WKH#
KLJKHU## SULFH
KLJKHU SULFHVV# LWLW## QHHGHG
QHHGHG## WRWR## FKDUJH
FKDUJH## FXVW RPHUV1# $W
FXVWRPHUV $W## WKH
WKH## VDPH
VDPH## WLPH
WLPH/# /# 6DEHQD# EHJDQ# WKH WKH##
SURFHVV## RI# UHGXFLQJ
SURFHVV UHGXFLQJ## FRVWV VWV## DQG
DQG## HOLP
HOLPLQDWL
LQDWLQJQJ# LQHIILFLHQF\
LQHIILFLHQF\## WR# LPSURYH# SUR ILWDELOLW\\1#
SURILWDELOLW
*RGIURLG# IHOW# WKDW WKDW## WKH
WKH## IX WXUHH# RI# WK
IXWXU WKHH# FRPSDQ\
FRPSDQ\## UHVWH
UHVWHGG# RQ RQ## LWV # DEL OLW\# WR
DELOLW\ WR## GHOLYHU
GHOLYHU##
FXVWRPHU## YDOXH# DQG# WR
FXVWRPHU WR## FRQWURO# FRVWV
FRVWV1# 1#6DEHQ
6DEHQDD# ZRXOG# EHFRPH
EHFRPH## NQRZQ# IRU IRU## WZR
WZR## WKLQJV
WKLQJV=# =#
WKH# TXDOLW\# RI# LWV# FXVW RPHU# VHU
FXVWRPHU LFH## DQG# LWV# SXQFWXDOLW\
VHUYY LFH SXQFWXDOLW\1#1# 6DEHQD# ZRXOG# FDSLWDOL]H# RQ#
WKH## H[FHOOHQFH
WKH H[FHOOHQFH## RI# %HOJ LDQ## FXLV
%HOJLDQ FXLVLQHLQH## DQG
DQG## WKH
WKH## VLQFHULW\
VLQFHULW\## DQG
DQG## IULHQG OLQHVV# RI# WKH
IULHQGOLQHVV WKH## %HOJLD
%HOJLDQQ#
SHRSOH# ZK ZKRR# ZRUNHG
ZRUNHG## IR IRUU# WKH
WKH## DL
DLUOL QH## WR
UOLQH WR## LPSURYH# WK WKHH# TXDO
TXDOLW\LW\## DQG
DQG## UHSXW DWLRQ## RI# LWV
UHSXWDWLRQ LWV##
VHUYLFH1#1#,Q
VHUYLFH ,Q##DGGLWLRQ/#RSHUDWL
RSHUDWLRQDORQDO#HIIRUWV
HIIRUWV##ZRXO
ZRXOGG#EH#GLUHFWHG
GLUHFWHG##DW DW##HQVXULQJ
HQVXULQJ##DOO#IOLJKW IOLJKWVV#OHIW
OHIW##

ght violation.
RQ# VFK HGXOH1#1# 6D
VFKHGXOH 6DEHQDEHQD## ZRXOG# EHFRPHEHFRPH## NQRZQ# IRU IRU## WKH
WKH## TXD
TXDOLW\OLW\## RI# LWV# SURGXFW# DQ DQGG#
OLW\## RI#LWV#VHUYLFH1#,Q#WK
UHOLDELOLW\
UHOLDEL WKHH#SDVW/#DW DWWHQW LRQV#RI#PDQDJH
WHQWLRQV PDQDJHPHQW PHQW#KDG KDG##EHHQ
EHHQ##IRFX VHG##RQ#
IRFXVHG
WKH# LQSXWV# WR WR## SURGXF
SURGXFWLRQWLRQ/# RQ# WKH WKH## SURFH
SURFHVVHVVVHV# RI# WKH
WKH## EXVLQHVV1# 8QGHU# *RGIURLG¶V#

copyright
OHDGHUVKLS/#/#DWW
OHDGHUVKLS HQWLRQ## ZR
DWWHQWLRQ ZRXOGXOG## EH# IRF
IRFXVHXVHGG# RQRQ## GHOLYHU\\/# RQ# WKH# RXWS
GHOLYHU RXWSXWVXWV# RI# WK WKHH# EXVLQHV
EXVLQHVVV1#

Use outside these parameters is a copyri

*RGIURLG##VDZ
*RGIURLG VDZ##WKDW
WKDW##KLV
KLV##MR
MREE#ZDV
ZDV##WRWR##FUHDW
FUHDWHH#SUL GH#LQ#WKH#FRPSDQ\#DQG#ZKDW#LW#GHOLYHUHG
SULGH GHOLYHUHG1#1#
3ULGH## DPRQ
3ULGH DPRQJJ# WKH# HPSOR\ HHV## RI# 6DEHQD# ZRXOG
R\HHV ZRXOG## EH# WU WUDQVODW
DQVODWHG HG## LQ WR## D# VXSHULRU
LQWR VXSHULRU##
H[SHULHQFH##IRU#WKH
H[SHULHQFH WKH##FXVWRP
FXVWRPHU HU1#1#
#
#
6DEHQD##&DWHULQJ
6DEHQD &DWHULQJ##6H
6HUYLFHV
UYLFHV##
#
6DEHQD##&D
6DEHQD WHULQJ##6HUYLFH
&DWHULQJ 6HUYLFHVV#+ #+61&6
61&6,# ,#ZD
ZDVV #UHVSRQ VLEOH##IRU
UHVSRQVLEOH IRU##VXSS
VXSSOO\LQJLQJ##DLUFUDIW
DLUFUDIW##ZLWK
ZLWK##IUHVK
IUHVK##
IRRG## DQG
IRRG DQG## VXSSOLH
VXSSOLHVV# VXFK# DV DV## EHYHUDJHV/# GXW\# IUHH# PHUFKDQGLVH/# QHZVSD QHZVSDSHUV SHUV# DQG
DQG##
PDJD]LQHV1#1# &DWHU
PDJD]LQHV LQJ## DOVR
&DWHULQJ DOVR## VXSSOLHG
VXSSOLHG## SL ORW¶V## PDSV
SLORW¶V PDSV/#/# FDELQ
FDELQ## GRF XPHQWV## DQG
GRFXPHQWV DQG## RWKHU
RWKHU##
UHJXODWRU\## IRUPV
UHJXODWRU\ IRUPV## WRWR## 6DE HQD## IOL
6DEHQD JKWV## RULJLQDWL
IOLJKWV RULJLQDWLQJ QJ# LQLQ## %UX
%UXVVHOV
VVHOV1#1# ,Q
,Q## DGGLWLRQ
DGGLWLRQ/#/# 6DEHQD#
ULQJ## VROG# LWV# VHUYLFHV# WR# RWKHU# DLU
&DWHULQJ
&DWH DLUOLQ
OLQHVHV# ZKRVH# IOLJKW OLJKWVV# RULJLQDWHG# LQ# =DYHQWHP
=DYHQWHP##
DLUSRUW1# 7KLV
7KLV## PHDQW
PHDQW## WKDWWKDW## DERXW# 63 63# SHUSHU## FH QW## RI
FHQW RI## LWV# ZR
ZRUNUN# ZDV# RQ RQ## EHKDOI# RI# RWKHU
RWKHU##
DLUOLQHV1#1#
DLUOLQHV
#
$OO# VHUYLFHV
VHUYLFHV## SURYLGHG
SURYLGHG## E\# WKH WKH## &DWHU
&DWHULQJ LQJ## 'LYLVLRQ# ZHUH ZHUH## OR FDWHG## LQ
ORFDWHG LQ## D# UHODWLY HO\\# QHZ#
UHODWLYHO
DQG##ZHOO
DQG ZHOO## GH VLJQHG#EXLOG
GHVLJQHG EXLOGLQJ LQJ##FORVH#WR WR##WKH
WKH##=DY HQWHP##$LUSRUW#+
=DYHQWHP #+VHH
VHH##)LJXUH
)LJXUH#4, #4,1#
1#)RRG
)RRG##DQG
DQG##
RWKHU## SURGXF
RWKHU SURGXFWV WV## ZHUH
ZHUH## SUHSDUHG
SUHSDUHG/#/#DVV HPEOHG## DQG
DVVHPEOHG DQG## ORDG
ORDGHG HG# RQWR# WUX FNV## DW
WUXFNV DW## WKH# SURGXFWL
SURGXFWLRQ RQ##
IDFLOLW\\# DQG# GHOL
IDFLOLW YHUHG## GLUH
GHOLYHUHG FWO\## WR
GLUHFWO\ WR## WKH
WKH## DLUFUDIW
DLUFUDIW1# 1# 8VH
8VHGG# WUD\
WUD\VV/# XQXVHG# SURGXFW
SURGXFWVV# DQGDQG##
DJH## ZHUH
JDUEDJH
JDUE ZHUH## UHWXUQHG# WR WR## WKH
WKH## VDPH# EXLO GLQJ## IRU# FOHDQLQJ
EXLOGLQJ FOHDQLQJ## RU# GLVSRVDO
GLVSRVDO1# 1#7KH
7KH## EXLO GLQJ##
EXLOGLQJ
ZDV## GHVLJ
ZDV GHVLJQHG QHG# VXFK
VXFK## WKDW#RX RXWJRL
WJRLQJQJ## DQG
DQG## LQF RPLQJ# SURGXF
LQFRPLQJ SURGXFWV WV# ZHUH
ZHUH## SK\VLFDOO\
VLFDOO\##V HSDUDWH
HSDUDWHGG#
WR#HOLPLQDWH#WK
HOLPLQDWH WKHH#SRV VLELOLW\\#RI#FRQ
SRVVLELOLW FRQWDPL
WDPLQDW LRQ##RU#FRQIXVLRQ
QDWLRQ RQIXVLRQ1# 1#
#
7KH##&DWHULQJ
7KH &DWHULQJ## 'LYL VLRQ#ZDV# VWUXFWXUHG#LQ# IXQF
'LYLVLRQ WLRQDO# GHSDU
IXQFWLRQDO WPHQWWV=#
GHSDUWPHQ =#$GPLQ
$GPLQLVWUDWLRQ #)#
LVWUDWLRQ#)#
)LQDQFH/#/# 3HUVRQ
)LQDQFH 3HUVRQQHO QHO/#/# 6DOHV
6DOHV## )# )# 0D UNHWLQJ/# 3UR
0DUNHWLQJ GXFW# )#
3URGXFW )# 6WDQGDUG GDUGVV /# 4XDOLW\
4XDOLW\## )# )# &R VW##
&RVW
&RQWURO
&RQWU RO/#/# DQG
DQG## 3URGXF
3URGXFWLRQ WLRQ## +VHH
+VHH## )L JXUH## 5,
)LJXUH 5,1# 2YHU# ;8 ;8# SHU
SHU## FHQW# RI# WK WKHH# GLYLVLRQ ¶V## :;3#
LYLVLRQ¶V

2385578 - CEI ©
3DJH#8#
3DJH#8# <$<7
<70
0337
337##
#
#
HPSOR\HHV## ZRUNHG
HPSOR\HHV ZRUNHG## ZLWK ZLWKLQ LQ## WKH
WKH## 3URGXF
3URGXFWLRQ WLRQ## 'HSDUWPHQW PHQW1# 1#,W
,WVV# UHVSRQVLELO
UHVSRQVLELOLWLHV LWLHV## LQFOX
LQFOXGHG GHG##
WKH## SUHSDUDWLRQ# DQG
WKH DQG## GHOLYHU\
GHOLYHU\## RI# FDW HULQJ# SURGXFWV
FDWHULQJ SURGXFWV## SOXV# WKH WKH## FOHDQLQJ/# UHF\FOLQJ# RU#
GLVSRVDOO#RI#UHWXUQHG
GLVSRVD UHWXUQHG##IRRG IRRG##ZDVWH
ZDVWH##DQGDQG##XQXVHG
XQXVHG##PDWHULD
PDWHULDOV OV1#1#
#
0RVW## HPSOR
0RVW HPSOR\\HHV HHV## DW
DW## 61&6
61&6## ZRUNHG
ZRUNHG## LQ LQ## RQH# RI RI## WZR# PDL PDLQQ# HLJKW LJKW## KRXU# DQG DQG## 4848# PLQX
PLQXWH WH##

Authorized for use only in the course COMMERCE 4PA3 at McMaster University taught by Nick Bontis from 8/9/2023 to 12/22/2023.
VKLIWV# DQDQGG# WKH
WKH## RSHUDWL
RSHUDWLRQ RQ## UDQ
UDQ## VHYHQ
VHYHQ## GD\V# SHU SHU## ZHHN
ZHHN1#1#7KH 7KH## DLUSRUW
DLUSRUW## ZDV
ZDV## FOR
FORVHGVHG## EHWZHHQ
EHWZHHQ##
44=33# S1P1# DQG DQG#8 #8==33# D1P1/# EXW# D# VP VPDOODOO## WKLUG
WKLUG## VKL
VKLIWIW## KDQGOHG
KDQGOHG## UHWXUQLQJ QLQJ## PDWH
PDWHULD ULDOVOV## IURP
IURP##
ODWH# QL JKW## IOLJ
QLJKW KWV# DQ
IOLJKWV DQGG# SUHSDUHG# EUHDNIDVWV# IR IRUU# HDUO\
HDUO\## PRUQLQJ# WDNH WDNH00RIIV1# 7KH# PDLQ#
VKLIWV## HDFK
VKLIWV HDFK## UHTXLUH
UHTXLUHGG# DSS DSSUR[LPDWH
UR[LPDWHO\ O\## 483# HPSOR\
HPSOR\HHV HHV# DQG DQG## VXSHUYLVRU
VXSHUYLVRUVV1# (PSOR\(PSOR\HHV HHV#
ZHUH## DVVLJQHG
ZHUH DVVLJQHG## WR WR## VSHFL
VSHFLILF ILF#IXQFWLRQV
IXQFWLRQV/#/#PDQ\PDQ\## ZRUNLQJ# DW# DVVHPEO\ DVVHPEO\## OLQH# VWDW LRQV# XQGHU#
VWDWLRQV
WKH##VX
WKH SHUYLVLRQ##RI#JURXS
VXSHUYLVLRQ JURXS##OHDGHUV
OHDGHUV##DQGDQG##VHF WLRQ##PDQDJHUV
VHFWLRQ PDQDJHUV1# 1#
#
61&6
61& 6# ZRUNHUV# ZHUH# UHSUHVHQ UHSUHVHQWWHG# E\ E\## WKUHH# SRO LWLFDOO\## EDVHG# ODERXU# XQ
SROLWLFDOO\ LRQV1# 8SRQ#
XQLRQV
LQJ## WKH
MRLQLQJ
MRLQ WKH## FRPSDQ\/#/#DQ DQ## HPSOR\
HPSOR\HH HH# ZDV# UHTXLUHG# WR WR## VHOHFW# D# XQLRQ
XQLRQ## WR
WR## EH# KLVKLV## RU# KHU#
UHSUHVHQWDWLYH
UHSUHVHQWD WLYH1#1# 7KH
7KH## XQLRQV
XQLRQV## DQG DQG## XQ
XQLRQLRQ## GLV
GLVFRQWH
FRQWHQW QW# ZHUH
ZHUH## D# VLJQLI LFDQW# IHDWXUH
VLJQLILFDQW IHDWXUH## RI#

Use outside these parameters is a copyright violation.

6DEHQD¶V# FXOWXUH
FXOWXUH1# 1# 7KH# XQLRQV# EHOLHYHG EHOLHYHG## WK DW## PD
WKDW PDQDJHPH
QDJHPHQW QW# ZDV
ZDV## RQO\# LQWHUH
LQWHUHVWHGVWHG# LQ#
SURILWVV# DQG
SURILW DQG## ZRXOG
ZRXOG## WDNHWDNH## HYHYHU HU\\# RSSRUWXQLW\
RSSRUWXQLW\## WR# H[ SORLW# ZRUNHUV# WR# DWWD
H[SORLW DWWDLQLQ## WKHLU
WKHLU## JRDO
JRDOVV1#
7KH# XQL RQV/# WKHUHIRUH
XQLRQV WKHUHIRUH/#/#QHHGHG
QHHGHG## WR WR## UHPDLQ# YLJL ODQW# WR
YLJLODQW WR## SURWHFW# UL JKWV## RI# WKH
ULJKWV WKH## ZRU
ZRUNHUV NHUV1#1#
1DWXUDOO\## ZLWK# VXFK# DQ# DWPRVSKHUH# RI# ODERXU0PDQDJ
1DWXUDOO\ PDQDJHPHQW HPHQW## GLVW UXVW/#/# 6DEHQ
GLVWUXVW 6DEHQDD#
H[SHULHQFHG# IUHTXHQW
IUHTXHQW## VWULNHV
VWULNHV1#1# 6RPH
6RPH## RI# WKHVH WKHVH## VW ULNHV## ZHUH# EULHI
VWULNHV EULHI## RXWEXU
RXWEXUVWV VWV# SURYLQJ#
RQO\## WURXEOH
RQO\ WURXEOHVRPHVRPH## WR WR## WKH
WKH## FRPSDQ\1#2WKHUV# KRZHYHU/# /#ZHUH
ZHUH## SURORQJ
SURORQJHG HG## DQG
DQG## GLVUXS
GLVUXSWLYH WLYH##
HYHQWV## IHDWXULQJ# XQFRQWU
HYHQWV XQFRQWURROOHG# DQ JHU## DQG# YLRO
DQJHU YLROHQFH
HQFH1# 1# 7KH
7KH## FXPXODW
FXPXODWLLYH YH## RXWFRPH
XWFRPH## RI#
DUVV# RI# FRQIURQWDWLRQ
\HDU
\H FRQIURQWDWLRQ## ZDV ZDV## D# FRPSDQ\
FRPSDQ\## FXOWXUH# IHDWXULQJ# VXVSLFLRQ# DQG# DQLPRVLW\ DQLPRVLW\##
EHWZHHQ## PDQDJHU
EHWZHHQ PDQDJHUVV# DQG# ZRUNHUV1# &XUUHQW# XQLRQ XQLRQ00PD PDQDJH
QDJHPHQW PHQW# UHODWLRQV
UHODWLRQV## ZH ZHUH UH## HYHQ
HYHQ##
PRUH# WHQVH
WHQVH/#/# ZLWK# WKHWKH## XQLRQV# EHOLHYLQJ# WKD WKDWW# HYHQWXDOO
HYHQWXDOO\\# WKH# ZRUNHUV# ZRXOG# KDYH# WR#
SD\#WKHWKH## SULFH
SULFH##RI# GHF OLQLQJ##DLUOLQ
GHFOLQLQJ DLUOLQHH#SUR ILWDELOLW\\#WK
SURILWDELOLW URXJK##H[
WKURXJK H[SHULHQF
SHULHQFLQJ LQJ## OD\
OD\00RIIV/#VDODUVDODU\\#
FXWV/#/#DQG
FXWV DQG## UHGXFHG
UHGXFHG## EHQHILW
EHQHILWVV1# .QRZLQJ# RI# WK WKHH# FRPSDQ
FRPSDQ\\¶V ¶V## HFRQRPLF
HFRQRPLF## SUREOHPV/# PRVW PRVW##
RI# WKH
WKH## ZRUNHUV
ZRUNHUV## ZHUHZHUH## IHDUIXO
IHDUIXO## RI# WKH WKH## IXWXUH
IXWXUH## DQGDQG## IHOW
IHOW## WKH
WKH## XQLRQ
XQLRQ## ZDVZDV## EDWWOL
EDWWOLQJ QJ## DJDLQVW
DJDLQVW##
PDQDJHPHQW
PDQDJ HPHQW##WR#SUR HFW##WKHLU
SURWWHFW WKHLU##MR EV##DQG
MREV DQG##OLYHOLKRRG
OLYHOLKRRG1#1#
#
:RUNHUV
:RU NHUV## ZLWK
ZLWKLQ LQ# WKH# FDWHULQJ
FDWHULQJ## GLYLVLRQ# KDG# D# UHSXWDWL UHSXWDWLRQ RQ## DVDV## EHLQJ
EHLQJ## WKH
WKH## PR
PRVW VW## PLO LWDQW##
PLOLWDQW
DQG## RXWVSRNH
DQG RXWVSRNHQQ# RI# DOO DOO## 6DEHQD
6DEHQD## HPSOR\
HPSOR\HHV HHV1# ,W ,W## ZDV# XQFRPXQFRPPRQ PRQ## IRU# 3URGXFURGXFWLRQ WLRQ## WR
WR##
IXQFWLRQ
IXQFWL RQ# IRU
IRU## PRUH
PRUH## WKDQWKDQ## D# PRQWK
PRQWK## ZLWKRXW# VRP VRPHH# W\ W\SHSH## RI# VWULNH
VWULNH## DFW
DFWLRQLRQ# DIIHFWLQJ#
RSHUDWLRQVV1# $# VW
RSHUDWLRQ ULNHH# FRXOG# EH# FDOOHG
VWULN FDOOHG## DWDW## DQ\# WLPH
WLPH## E\E\## DQ\
DQ\## RQH# RI# WKH# WK UHH## XQLRQV1#1#,I
WKUHH ,I##
WKH# HPSOR\HHV
HPSOR\HHV## ZDQWHG
ZDQWHG## WR WR## PDNH# D# VWDW HPHQWW# DERXW
WDWHPHQ DERXW## ZRUNLQJ
ZRUNLQJ## FRQGLW LRQV# RU# SHUFHLYHG#
FRQGLWLRQV
XQIDLU## WUHDW
XQIDLU PHQW# RI# DQ
WUHDWPHQW DQ\\# RI# WKHL
WKHLUU# PHPEHU
PHPEHUVV/#/#WKH\ WKH\## KDG
KDG## WKH# SRZHU SRZHU## WR# FDOO
FDOO## IRIRUU# ZLOGFDW
ZLOGFDW##
VWULNH## DFWLRQ1# 6XFK# DFWLRQ# KDG# SURYHQ# YHU
VWULNH YHU\\# HIIHFW
HIIHFWLYH LYH# LQ# WKH# SDV SDVWW/# DQG
DQG## WKHWKH## XQLRQV#
NQHZ## WKDW# WK
NQHZ H\## KDG
WKH\ KDG## WKH# SRZHU# WR# FUHDWH FUHDWH## PDMRU# SUREO SUREOHPV HPV## IRU# PDQDJ
PDQDJHPHQW HPHQW1# :RUN :RUN##
VFKHGXOHVV# ZHUH
VFKHGXOH ZHUH## VRVR## SUHFLVH# DQG DQG## WK
WKHH# SURGXFW# WKH\# ZRUNHG# ZL ZLWK WK# VR# SURQH# WR# VSRLODJ
VSRLODJHH/#
VWRSSDJH## IRU# DV# OLWWO
VWRSSDJH OLWWOHH# DV# DQ# KRXU# FRXOG# FDXVH# PDM PDMRU RU## GDPDJ
GDPDJHH# WR WR## RSHUDWLRQV
RSHUDWLRQV1#1#6WULNH6WULNHVV#
DWLQJ## LQ# RWKHU# GLYL
RULJLQDWLQJ
RULJLQ VLRQV# RI# WKH# FRPSDQ\# WHQGHG# WR# DIIHFW# RSHUDWLRQ
GLYLVLRQV RSHUDWLRQVV# DW DW## 61&
61&6 6#
DV## ZHOO/# SDUWLFXODUO\# LI# SLFNHWHUV# RU# EORFNDGH
DV EORFNDGHVV# LQWHUIHUHG
LQWHUIHUHG## ZLWK# DFFHVV DFFHVV## WR# WK WKHH# IOLJKW#
RSHUDWLRQVV1#
RSHUDWLRQ
#
#

2385578 - CEI ©
3DJH#9#
3DJH#9# <$<7
<70
0337
337##
#
#
:(<7-(16¶
:(<7-(16¶##),5
),567
67#$6
$66,
6,*
*10
10(1
(177#
#
%HIRUH## EHJLQQLQJ
%HIRUH EHJLQQLQJ## WKH# 0%$# SURJUDP# DW# ,16 ,16( ($'/# (U (ULNLN## :H\
:H\WMHQVWMHQV## KDG# ZRUNZRUNHG HG# DV# D#
FRQVXOWDQWW# ZLWK
FRQVXOWDQ ZLWK## 0F.LQVH\
0F.LQVH\## DQG# &RPSD &RPSDQ\ Q\1#1#+H
+H# KDG# EHHQ EHHQ## KL UHG## E\
KLUHG E\## 0F.LQVH\# DIWHU#
FRPSOHWLQJ
FRPSOH WLQJ# KLV KLV## 0DVWHUV
0DVWHUV## 'HJUHH
'HJUHH## LQ# 0H 0HFK FKDQL FDO## (QJLQHHULQJ
DQLFDO (QJLQHHULQJ## DQG# KH# KDG# ZRUNHG# IR IRUU#

Authorized for use only in the course COMMERCE 4PA3 at McMaster University taught by Nick Bontis from 8/9/2023 to 12/22/2023.
WKHP##IRU
WKHP IRU##WZR# \HDUV HDUV##EHIRUH#UHWXUQLQJ#WR WR##VFKRRO#IRU#KLV#0%$#GHJUHH1#7RZD 7RZDUG UG##WKH
WKH##HQG
HQG##
RI## WKH
RI WKH## 0%$
0%$## SURJUDP SURJUDP/#/# WKH WKH## SDUWQHUV
SDUWQHUV## DW DW## 0F.LQVH\
0F.LQVH\## LQ# %UXVV %UXVVHOV HOV# KDG# VXJJHVWHG
VXJJHVWHG##
:H\WMHQV
:H\ WMHQV##FRQVLGHU
FRQVLGHU##DFTXLUDFTXLULLQJ QJ##VRPH#OL QH#PDQDJH
OLQH PDQDJHPHQW PHQW##H[SHULHQFH#EHIRUH#UHWXU QLQJ#WR
UHWXUQLQJ WR##
FRQVXOWLQJ
FRQVXOW LQJ1#1#$W $W## ILUV
ILUVWW/# KH# ZRQGHUHG# LI LI## WKLV# ZDV
ZDV## FULWLFL VP# RI# KLV
FULWLFLVP KLV## DELOLW
DELOLWLHVLHV## RU# SUHYLRXV
SUHYLRXV##
SHUIRUPDQFH/# EXW/# XS XSRQRQ# IXUWKHU
IXUWKHU## UHIOHFWLRQ/# KH# UHDOL]HG UHDOL]HG## WKDWWKDW## WKLV
WKLV## DG YLFH## ZDV
DGYLFH ZDV##
JHQXLQHOO\# LQWH
JHQXLQH QGHG##WR
LQWHQGHG WR##KHO
KHOSS# LQ
LQ##WKH
WKH##GHYHORS
GHYHORSPHQW PHQW##RI#KLV KLV##FDUHHU
FDUHHU1#1#7KH
7KH#GHFLVLRQ#KD KDGG# EHHQ#
XS## WR
XS WR## KLP
KLP1# 1#+H+H## FRXOG
FRXOG## UHWXUQ
UHWXUQ## WR WR## 0F.LQV
0F.LQVH\ H\## DQG# UHVX
UHVXPHPH# KLV# FRQV XOWLQJJ# FDUHHU
FRQVXOWLQ FDUHHU/#/# RU# KH#
FRXOG# ILQGILQG## D# SRVLWLRQ# LQ LQ## GLUHFW# PDQDJH
PDQDJHPHQW PHQW## IRU
IRU## D# ZKLOH# DQ DQGG# 0F.LQ
0F.LQVH\ VH\## ZRXOG# SX SXWW#
KLV# MRMREE# RQ# KROGKROG1#1# +H
+H## GHFLGHG
GHFLGHG## WR WR## RS
RSWW# IRU
IRU## PDQDJH
PDQDJHPHQW PHQW# H[SHULHQFH# DQ DQGG# ZDV# LQ LQ## WKH#
PLGGOH## RI# LQWHUYLHZ
PLGGOH LQWHUYLHZLQJ LQJ# ZLWK# D# QXPEHUQXPEHU## RI# %HO %HOJLDQJLDQ## ILUPV
ILUPV## ZKZKHQ HQ## KH# KDGKDG## D# FKDQFH
FKDQFH##
PHHWLQJ##ZL
PHHWLQJ ZLWK WK##/X
/XFF#&ORHWHQV
&ORHWHQV/#/#9LFH 9LFH##3UHV LGHQW##RI
3UHVLGHQW RI##&DWHULQJ
&DWHULQJ##IRU#6DEHQD6DEHQD1# 1#+H#KDG#PHW#DQG#

Use outside these parameters is a copyright violation.

ZRUNHG##ZL
ZRUNHG ZLWK WK#&ORHW
&ORHWHQV HQV##ZKHQ
ZKHQ##6DEHQD#KDG KDG##EHHQ#D#FOLHQW#RI#0F.LQ 0F.LQVH\ VH\1# 1#%HIRUH
%HIRUH##WKH WKH##HQG
HQG##
RI## WKH
RI WKH## PHHWLQJ
HHWLQJ/#/# &O RHWHQV## RIIHUHG
&ORHWHQV RIIHUHG## :H\WMH
:H\WMHQV QV## D# SR VLWLRQ## LQ
SRVLWLRQ LQ## FDWHU
FDWHULQJLQJ## DQG
DQG## :H\WMHQV
:H\WMHQV##
DFFHSWHG1#1#
DFFHSWHG
#
&ORHWHQV
&ORHWH QV# ZDV
ZDV## RQHRQH## RI#WKH#NH NH\\# H[HFXWLYHV# UHFUXLWHG# E\ E\## *RGIURLG#LQ# KLV# HIIRUW#WR#EXLOG#
D# QHZ
QHZ## PDQDPDQDJHPH JHPHQW QW# WHDP
WHDP1# 1# &O RHWHQV# ZDV # D# VHDVRQHG# PDQDJHU
&ORHWHQV PDQDJHU## ZL ZLWKWK## PDQ
PDQ\\# \HDUV\HDUV##
H[SHULHQFH# LQ LQ## WKH
WKH## DL
DLUOL QH## FDWHULQJ
UOLQH FDWHULQJ## EXVLQHVV1# %HIRUH# MRLQLQJ MRLQLQJ## 6DEHQD# KH# KDG# EHHQ# WKH#
PDQDJHU## RI# 61&6¶
PDQDJHU 61&6¶VV# PDLQ# FR FRPSHWLWRU
PSHWLWRU/# /# %HOJDY
%HOJDYLD LD# $L
$LUOL QHV1#1#:H\
UOLQHV :H\WMHQVWMHQV## WKRXJ
WKRXJKW KW## KLJKO
LJKO\\#
RI# &ORHWHQV¶
&ORHWHQV¶## SHRSOH# PD QDJHPHQW## VNLOOV
PDQDJHPHQW VNLOOV## DQGDQG## UHVSHFW
UHVSHFWHG HG# KLV# DELOL WLHV## DV# D# OHDGHU
DELOLWLHV HDGHU1#1#
$OWKRXJK
$OWK RXJK## WKH# FR FRPSD
PSDQ\ Q\# ZDV
ZDV## H[ H[SHU
SHULHQ
LHQFLQ FLQJJ# WRXJK# WLPHVWLPHV/#/#:H\
:H\WMHQVWMHQV## IHOW
IHOW## WK DW## WR
WKDW WR## ZRUN
ZRUN##
ZLWK# &O RHWHQV## DQG
&ORHWHQV DQG## WR
WR## EH# LQYRO
LQYROYHGYHG## LQLQ## D# WXUQDURXQG
WXUQDURXQG## SURFHVV# ZRXOG# EH# DQ# H[FHOOH H[FHOOHQW QW##
OHDUQLQJ##RSSRUWXQ
OHDUQLQJ RSSRUWXQLW LW\\#DQG#SHUVRQDO#FKD FKDOOHQJH
OOHQJH1# 1#
#
7KH# ILUVW# DVVLJQDVVLJQPHQW PHQW## &ORHWHQV# KDQGHG KDQGHG## :H\ :H\WMHQ WMHQVV# ZDV
ZDV## WR# VROYH
VROYH## D# PDMRU# ORJ LVWLFVV#
ORJLVWLF
SUREOHP
SUREOH P# LQ LQ## WKH
WKH## GLVKZDV
GLVKZDVKLQJ KLQJ# GHSDUWPH
GHSDUWPHQW QW1# :RU
:RUNN# LQ LQ## WKH
WKH## GLVK ZDVKLQJJ# DUHD
GLVKZDVKLQ DUHD## ZDVZDV##
FRQWLQXDOO\
FRQWLQXD OO\## EDFNOR
EDFNORJJ JJHGHG1#1# 7UROOH\
7UROOH\VV# FRQWDLQ
FRQWDLQLQJ LQJ## XQF
XQFRQVXP
RQVXPHG HG## IRRG
IRRG## DQGDQG## UHIXVH
UHIXVH## ZDLWHG
ZDLWHG##
IRU## KRXUV
IRU KRXUV/#/#VVRPHWLPH
RPHWLPHVV# GD\V/# WR# EH# SURFHVVHG SURFHVVHG1#1#'LVRUG 'LVRUGHUO HUO\\# WUROOH\
WUROOH\VV# ZRXOG
ZRXOG## SLOHSLOH## XS# RQ#
WKH# XQORD
XQORDGLQJGLQJ# GRFNV1# 7KH 7KH## ZKROH
ZKROH## DUHD# ZDV ZDV## D# FKDRV# RI# FDUWV FDUWV## ZDLWLQJ
ZDLWLQJ## WR# EH# HPS HPSWLHGWLHG#
DQG# FOHDQHG1#1#7KH 7KH## SUREOHP# ZDV ZDV## QR QRWW# GL IILFXOWW# WR
GLIILFXO WR## LG HQWLI\1#1# 'HOD\V# ZHUH# FDXVHG# ZKHQ#
LGHQWLI\
WKH## PDFKLQH
WKH PDFKLQHVV# XVHG XVHG## WR# ZDZDVK VK## WK
WKHH# GLV KHV# EURNH# GRZ
GLVKHV GRZQQ/# DQGDQG## VXFK
VXFK## EUHDNGRZ
EUHDNGRZQQV# ZHUH ZHUH##
KDSSHQLQJ
KDSSHQL QJ##IUHTXHQWO\
IUHTXHQWO\1# 1# 7KH#GLVKZDVK
GLVKZDVKLQJ LQJ## GHSDUWPHQ PHQWW#EO DPHG##WK
EODPHG WKHH#PDLQWHQDQFH
PDLQWHQDQFH## FUHZV#
IRU## VO
IRU RZ## DQG
VORZ DQG## XQUH OLDEOH## UHSDLUV
XQUHOLDEOH UHSDLUV## WR WR## WKH
WKH## PDFK
PDFKLQHV LQHV1#1# 7KH# PDLQWHQDQFH# FUHZV# EODPHG#
WKH##GLVKZDVK
WKH GLVKZDVKLQJ LQJ## GHSDUW
GHSDUWPHQWPHQW#IR IRUU#IDLOL
IDLOLQJQJ##WRWR## SURSHUO\# SUHSDUH#WKH#WUD\ WUD\VV# EHIRUH
EHIRUH##SODFLQJ
SODFLQJ##
WKHP## LQ
WKHP LQ## WK
WKHH# PDFKLQHV
PDFKLQHV1#1#%ODPH %ODPH## KDG KDG## ERXQFH
ERXQFHGG# EDFN# DQG# IR UWK## OL
IRUWK NH## D# ³SLQ
OLNH ³SLQJJ# SRQJ RQJ## EDOO´#
IRU## RYHU
IRU RYHU## WZRWZR## PRQWPRQWKV KV/# EXW
EXW## OLWWO
OLWWOHH# SURJUHVV# KDG# EHHQ# PDGH# WRZD WRZDUG UG# FRUUHFWLQJ# WKH#
SUREOHP
SUREOH P1# 'XUL
'XULQJ QJ## WKLV
WKLV## WLPH
WLPH/# /#UHODWLRQV
UHODWLRQV## EHWZHHQ
EHWZHHQ## WKH WKH## WZR# GHSDUWPHQWV
GHSDUWPHQWV## KDG KDG## ZRUVHQHG
ZRUVHQHG/#/#
DGGLQJ##WH
DGGLQJ WHQVL
QVLRQ RQ#DQG#DQJU\DQJU\##IHHOLQJV#WR#DQ DQ##DOUHDG\
DOUHDG\##XQWHQD
XQWHQDEOH EOH##VLWX DWLRQ1#1#&ORHWHQV
VLWXDWLRQ &ORHWHQV##DVNHG DVNHG##
:H\WMHQV
:H\ WMHQV## WR# FOHDQ
FOHDQ## XS XS## WKH# PHVV# DQG DQG## WR# JHWJHW## WKH
WKH## GLVK ZDVKLQJJ# GHSDUWPHQ
GLVKZDVKLQ GHSDUWPHQWW# EDFN EDFN## RQ#
VFKHGXOH1#1#
VFKHGXOH

2385578 - CEI ©
 #
#
3DJH
3DJH#:#
#:#

2385578 - CEI ©
<$<7
<70
0337
337##

#
Authorized for use only in the course COMMERCE 4PA3 at McMaster University taught by Nick Bontis from 8/9/2023 to 12/22/2023.
Use outside these parameters is a copyright violation.
 #
#

#
#
#
#
3DJH
3DJH#;#
#;#

61&6
61&6##25*
25*$
)LJXUH
)LJXUH#5#
#5#

$1,=$7,21

2385578 - CEI ©
1,=$7,21##&+$
&+$57
57##
<$<7
<70
0337
337##

#
Authorized for use only in the course COMMERCE 4PA3 at McMaster University taught by Nick Bontis from 8/9/2023 to 12/22/2023.
Use outside these parameters is a copyright violation.