Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Carrier Digital Communications Agility and Innovation Will Maximize Service Provider Opportunities.
Carrier Digital Communications Agility and Innovation Will Maximize Service Provider Opportunities.
Carrier Digital Communications Agility and Innovation Will Maximize Service Provider Opportunities.
Carrier digital
communications
Agility and innovation will
maximize service provider
opportunities
Reference Code: ML00022-007
WWW.MARKETLINE.COM
MARKETLINE. THIS PROFILE IS A LICENSED PRODUCT AND IS NOT TO BE PHOTOCOPIED
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Summary
•OTT messaging leaders evolve their key mobile messaging application interfaces to new voice and video
communications, with revenue dilution implications for carriers worldwide.
•Although RCS pre-dates the OTT messenger threat, the technology is still one of the best available competitive offset
tools available to the carrier community today, and new ecosystem partners have emerged to accelerate the inclusion of
the pre-IMS carrier community.
•Despite initial sluggish uptake, carriers are now reconsidering the Rich Communications Services (RCS) opportunity as
arguably a best-bet OTT competitive offset in the digital communications space.
•Ecosystem maturity is assisting the RCS story, particularly in the light of a far broader availability of RCS-native devices
from a larger number of OEM providers. A broader availability of RCS-native devices skirts the need for carriers to
market and encourage the take up of RCS story via downloadable apps.
•Simultaneously, carriers are moving ahead with early VoLTE and Wi-Fi Calling projects, but the prerogative to
differentiate these digital communications services from OTT interfaces in terms of value-added service features is still
some ways away. Few operators have managed to market differentiation in terms beyond ‘better quality voice’.
•Carriers are struggling to find their place in the WebRTC value-chain, and clearly find it difficult to perceive the
opportunities in a B2B2C context. Nevertheless, a few carriers are starting to explore the various innovation avenues,
from opening an enhanced calling API for WebRTC to developers to allow third parties to provision browser-based voice
and video services alongside their own online Web interfaces, to launching a B2C brand, to learn more about customer
WebRTC uptake and behavior trends.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Catalyst............................................................................................................................................................................ 2
Summary ......................................................................................................................................................................... 2
Global carrier mobile messaging volumes and revenues threatened by OTT messenger apps ...................................... 5
Leading OTT messaging apps dominate in video calling feature functionality ................................................................. 7
Digital communications technology taking stepping into voice and data network ................................................................ 9
Wi-Fi access points gaining importance in supporting voice and video calls ................................................................. 10
Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................................................ 17
Carriers evolve mobile messaging application interfaces to incorporate new voice and video communications offerings
...................................................................................................................................................................................... 17
Appendix ........................................................................................................................................................................... 18
Definitions ...................................................................................................................................................................... 18
Disclaimer ...................................................................................................................................................................... 19
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
In Africa and the Middle East, average voice MoU is predicted to continue growing, with imperceptible losses in Asia
Pacific, Latin America and Central and Eastern Europe.
Despite average monthly voice MoU stability, global average voice ARPS are predicted to fall by 23% from 2015-2020.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
The Google Project Fi multi-carrier cellular/WiFi MVNO model with automatic steering to public WiFi for a ‘network of
networks’ experience sets out an aggressive model for OTT voice. Others like Whatup, Facebook, Jott or Open Garden
are sure to follow.
The new WhatsApp Voice feature allows the app’s circa 800 million users to mobile VoIP call friends nationally and
internationally, over cellular or WiFi at no extra charge beyond data access.
Facebook is constantly experimenting with app bridges between its key communications interfaces Facebook Messenger
and WhatsApp. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg claimed Facebook Messenger drives 10% of all global mobile VoIP
calls (Q1 2015). In the same results call, Zuckerberg talked up the high quality of mobile VoIP, even claiming that it is
superior to standard cellular voice quality in many cases.
New mesh networking apps such as Jott report swift uptake for a messaging experience which requires no data access.
In July 2015, Open Garden achieved private messaging, and is gunning to affect a voice feature.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
First introduced together with the iPhone 4, FaceTime is Apple’s flagship video chat app for free person-to-person mobile
VoIP calls. Although initially limited to WiFi access, from iOS 6 on, FaceTime for iPhone and iPad supports video chat
over cellular (3G or LTE).
Tango was an early front-runner in video chat, primarily positioning itself as a simple and strong Apple FaceTime
alternative for Android users. Like many OTT apps, Tango has steadily extended its social networking and commerce
capabilities.
Google Hangouts is a culmination of several different Google IP communications efforts, from Google Talk to Google+,
and is designed to be ‘the future’ of the OTT’s flagship telephony product Google Voice.
Viber video chat entered the market as a strong competitor to Apple FaceTime in 2010, and in February 2014 was
acquired by Japanese e-commerce giant Rakuten for $900 million.
After an initially slow-roll to 18 markets, Facebook introduced video calling to its flagship Facebook Messenger app in
May 2015. According to Facebook, Messenger users made over one million video calls during the first two days after the
feature’s launch.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Using the IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) network, VoLTE allows mobile operators to evolve their 2G/3G circuit switched
voice service to IP data flows within an LTE environment. With this step, VoLTE has the propensity to deliver up to three
times more voice and data capacity than 3G UMTS, and up to six times more than 2G GSM, according to leading
vendors.
VoLTE delivers enhanced voice quality, often referred to as high definition (HD) voice, or carrier marketed terms which
capture this value proposition. This requires the setup and teardown of dedicated voice bearers from the network core
through to each subscriber in order to protect IP-based voice traffic from disruption by unpredictably "bursty" mobile
broadband data traffic.
Signaling traffic has been steadily ramping up in 3G networks with smartphone volumes and app signaling increasing.
Simply attaching to an LTE network unleashes a sequence of Diameter signaling messages; VoLTE takes the signaling
load to a new level.
For carriers moving to VoLTE, a Diameter Signaling Controller (DSC) investment is often undertaken to load balance and
manage the Diameter traffic.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Like VoLTE, Voice-over-WiFi (VoWiFi) is IP-based and reuses a carrier’s existing IMS/VoLTE core network infrastructure
to support HD voice and video calls. Both use the same phone number, client and native dialer and naturally complement
one another, providing an operator with expanded coverage.
Introducing VoWiFi necessitates additional security mechanisms to support handover between Wi-Fi, 2G/3G and LTE.
The Trusted Wireless Access Gateway (TWAG) is required for the carriers’ own 3G or LTE access networks (including
small cells) and the untrusted/Evolved Packet Data Gateway (ePDG) is required to authenticate access from home and
public Wi-Fi hotspots.
Also like VoLTE, VoWiFi needs a way to give voice packets higher priority than data packets. For the highest quality
voice both the terminal and Wi-Fi access network should implement Wi-Fi Multimedia (WMM). Additionally, the carrier
can define network policies for enabling voice handover between LTE and Wi-Fi using the 3GPP defined Access Network
Discovery and Selection Function (ANDSF) feature.
Native Wi-Fi Calling brings an out-of-the-box, dialer experience which is hard for OTT app interfaces to match.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
WebRTC is an open project supported by Google, Mozilla, and Opera within the Internet Engineering Taskforce (IETF).
WebRTC provides a capability to initiate and receive real time IP-based communications from within Web browsers using
standard JavaScript APIs. WebRTC, however, is a framework rather than a service and does not include a signaling
protocol, relying instead on negotiation between end points.
While WebRTC can operate in peer-to-peer mode over the public internet, carriers can also use WebRTC as a means of
extending their reach, providing value-added consumer and business services integrated with their existing voice and
video services.
In order to provide “carrier grade” quality of service, WebRTC needs to be enhanced with improved security,
interoperability and reliability. This is normally provided by a WebRTC Session Controller (WSC) working in conjunction
with a Session Border Controller (SBC).
In addition to supporting value-added services, WebRTC also provides carriers with a developer-friendly style of network
exposure interface which can be used to open up its network capabilities to third-party developers.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
RCS is now native on around 40 Android devices, skirting the former user app download requirement, and operators are
starting to rethink RCS’ value in the light of VoLTE and as enabler for new market verticals, such as the connected car.
Carriers in the US, APAC and Europe are looking to align VoLTE capabilities (i.e., simultaneous voice and data and
video calling) with RCS for more advanced IP comms services.
Carriers are investigating the alignment of third-party APIs with VoLTE and RCS. API evolution will allow carriers to stay
relevant by enabling the provision of richer services for OTT partners and enterprise-focused developers requiring
higher-quality features for services such as video conferencing.
Recent RCS carrier launches have eschewed the GSMA’s former customer-facing brand recommendation, ‘Joyn’ brand.
Most new deployments now use carrier branding.
Apple’s commitment to RCS could be the make or break of the entire project. The GSMA, together with leading RCS
carrier proponents, is attempting to put pressure on Apple to rethink its stance towards RCS.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Several carriers are now exploring the way RCS, as a native dialer experience, can expedite the exploration of new
communications use cases and applications for IoT, starting with the connected car and smart home.
Carriers have tended to market new Wi-Fi calling services as a cellular coverage enhancement value-add, especially for
indoor calling.
Cable operators, on the other hand, are positioning Wi-Fi calling more aggressively as a solution for cellular calling
substitution, both at home and abroad, to avoid high roaming costs.
A new generation of MVNOs, spearheaded by Google Project Fi, are looking to Wi-Fi calling to effect competitive access
propositions via steering to the lowest cost available access option. Call handover between Wi-Fi and cellular is still very
much a work in progress, and for the most part unavailable today, or missing from the majority of commercially available
services. A set of new partnerships at the MVNE and MVNA level have emerged to expedite the provision of Wi-Fi calling
at the MVNO level.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
AT&T is one of the first to introduce an Enhanced WebRTC API program that includes several enhancements to the API
standard, such as a signaling path to enable phone calls to fixed and mobile lines, plus calling capabilities; caller ID and
virtual numbers. The AT&T Enhanced WebRTC API program emerged from beta in August 2015, to allow developers to
add real–time voice/video communications to any Website or online application. Key targets include conference
solutions, contact centers, telemedicine and collaboration applications.
Telefonica has aligned its multi-device calling and messaging application TU Go with WebRTC, to allow users to place
and receive calls from within compatible web browsers, without the need to download an application for desktop use.
Telefonica acquired video platform TokBox in 2012, and has evolved the company to be a leading Platform-as-a-Service
provider for enterprise WebRTC, via the OpenToK API. In 2014, Telefonica evolved its Spanish mobile social network
brand, Tuenti, with a multi-device VozDigital app, including browser-based calling. In early 2015, Telefonica enhanced its
flagship multi-device mobile IP Comms service TU Go with WebRTC capability, to allow users to in-browser calling from
a Firefox or Chrome browser using the same Tu Go credentials. The launch was a first mobile carrier channel B2C
implementation for WebRTC. In October 2015, TokBox struck a partnership deal with x-Mobility, the MVNA for 3
Hutchison in the UK and Ireland to allow its x-Mobility’s own set of MVNO customers to launch new voice and video
communications services using the device, OS and browser-agnostic WebRTC service delivered by TokBox.
Still in its infancy, mesh networking allows OTTs to establish crowdsourced and hyper-local connectivity for potentially
millions of users and ‘dead devices’ (devices with WiFi and Bluetooth features, but no cellular SIM) in a daisy-chain
mode, allowing large groups Internet connectivity where access is limited or restrained.
The app’s fundamental premise has the potential to cut carriers out of the one user-one SIM connectivity equation for
new wearable form factors and other WiFi-enabled devices.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Open Garden’s FireChat app has been used widely at public demonstrations and festivals, from the Occupy Central
Hong Kong uprising in 2014 to multiple music and community festivals.
Jott, the company behind the Jott mesh networking app amassed more than 500,000 monthly users and one million app
installs in its first three months of commercial service earlier in 2015. The app targets teens with ‘dead devices’ in school.
Open Garden has launched a hardware GreenStone product, marketed as ‘the first messaging beacon’ to allow peer-to-
peer connections to spread even further, enabling free messaging anywhere.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Several global OTTs such as LINE and even Facebook are starting to describe mobile VoIP as ‘better voice quality’, in
comparison to cellular voice. Without a set of strong VoLTE value-added services to point to, carriers risk seeing their
own headline ‘HD voice’ for VoLTE end user value message challenged.
In emerging APAC markets, handset OEMs getting into the data sponsorship game, and this trend – should it spread –
could effectively cut carriers out of the device upgrade process, particularly those carriers in markets which have now
turned to device financing as a subsidy alternative. In APAC, sponsored data for a wide area of apps, including mobile
VoIP and IM interfaces.
To date, the isolated community nature of messaging OTT platforms has been the key drawback for consumers looking
to migrate all communications to their favorite app interface. The requirement to provision off-platform calling to non-
community users has been a drain on OTT resources and development time. But that could easily change. Some of the
largest global app interfaces could start building ‘bridges’ between communities; Facebook has already piloted such
features between its key Facebook app and WhatsApp.
Any rise in mesh networking technological progress and app adoption could significantly challenge carrier IoT
connectivity ambitions, besides the anticipated loss in access revenue as early adopters use mesh networking to hook
‘dead’ devices (Internet enabled, without a SIM or Wi-Fi access) to daisy chain to community connectivity platforms. To
date, only a small handful of app developers have tested market appetite for community connectivity, but the impact on
the IoT market has yet to be fully explored.
Carriers should consider following AT&T’s lead in creating a simple, easy-to-access API program to allow a wide range of
enterprises to enhance their own Websites, applications and online stores with WebRTC voice and video calling in-
browser experiences. WebRTC could prove to be a valuable boost to the telco wholesale business.
With RCS native device choice now reasonably broader, carriers should re-focus their calling innovation efforts on the
dialer experience, and innovate dialer incentives to dissuade users against going to a dedicated app for a
communications experience. All carriers should also be watching SK Telecom’s T Phone 2.0 innovation carefully, to
understand the external monetization opportunities in opening calling KPIs to third parties. OTT messaging players are
significantly ahead of carriers in IP Comms product feature excellence, yet few have invested much in the area of new
connected devices, such as wearables. Carriers should consider honing their communications efforts in this area, for
entirely new services around voice and video calling differentiation.
All carriers have to re-think the boundaries of traditional one-to-one communications to fully grasp the digital
opportunities for value-added experiences, as both a B2C service and a wider B2B2C two-sided business model
opportunity with partners.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
RCS has struggled to acquire broad mobile carrier community acceptance, but the dearth of success stories in the carrier
app-based IP comms camp points back to the benefits of backing a cross-network, cross-carrier communications
interface.
Carriers need to recognize that the same technology, in another player’s hands, can be bent to an entirely different set of
unfriendly strategic objectives. Carrier Wi-Fi Calling, for example, is frequently positioned as a cellular coverage
improvement. OTTs and MSOs will likely leverage the same technology to challenge on basic service pricing terms.
Early RCS deployments that have been reliant on a downloadable app have demonstrated weak initial take-up. The
choice and variety of available native RCS devices is now broad enough for carriers to consider a more ambitious
strategy for rich communications services.
Carriers need to enhance their VoLTE services with end-user benefits and value-added service features which are more
compelling than merely 'better voice quality'. OTTs will be quick to claim the same for mobile VoIP; several are already
doing so.
Although RCS is often thought of as a primarily B2C communications tool, carriers can also stay relevant by enabling
richer services for OTT players and enterprise-focused developers requiring higher-quality features for services such as
video conferencing.
Few carriers are giving enough thought to the B2B2C opportunities implicit in WebRTC. Far too many continue to view
the technology as a threat to their existing calling business, as opposed to an opportunity for external monetization.
Provisioning easy-to-access developer tools and WebRTC APIs for in-browser communications has the potential to
revolutionize the carrier wholesale business on a whole new digital level.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
Caller ID - A value-added telephone service that allows a subscriber to identify a caller before answering by viewing the
displayed caller's telephone number which appears on the recipient’s screen.
GSMA - The GSM Association, formed in 1995, is an association of mobile operators and related companies supporting
the standardization, deployment and promotion of the GSM mobile telephone system.
IoT - The Internet of Things, a current movement imbibing ‘ordinary objects’ with both sensors and Internet connectivity,
and the ability to report information for a wide range of scenarios and use cases.
P2P - Peer-to-peer computing or networking is a distributed application architecture that partitions tasks or work loads
between peers.
RCS - Rich Communication Services program is a GSM Association (GSMA) program for the creation of inter-operator
communication services based on IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS).
VoLTE - Voice over LTE, which is based on the IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) network, with specific profiles for control
and media planes of voice service on LTE defined by GSMA in PRD IR.92.
WebRTC - Web Real-Time Communication is an API definition drafted by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) that
supports browser-to-browser applications for voice calling, video chat and P2P file sharing without the need of either
internal or external plugins.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016
About MarketLine
At MarketLine, we deliver accurate, up-to-date insights on over 30,000 companies, 300 industries, and 215 countries, as
well as the latest news and financial deal information from within your market and across the globe.
Established in 1997 when the Internet was in its infancy, we recognized the need for a convenient and reliable data
service to help our clients understand local and global markets and the companies operating within them.
In today’s information-rich world, sifting fact from fiction to pick out what’s relevant and what’s up to date has become the
new ‘holy grail’ in business information provision.
Our 170 dedicated research professionals aggregate, analyze, and cross-check facts in line with our strict research
methodology, ensuring a constant stream of new and accurate information is added to MarketLine every day..
Disclaimer
All Rights Reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form by any means,
electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher, MarketLine.
The facts of this report are believed to be correct at the time of publication but cannot be guaranteed. Please note that
the findings, conclusions and recommendations that MarketLine delivers will be based on information gathered in good
faith from both primary and secondary sources, whose accuracy we are not always in a position to guarantee. As such
MarketLine can accept no liability whatever for actions taken based on any information that may subsequently prove to
be incorrect.
Carrier digital communications: Agility in innovative use cases will maximize service provider opportunities ML00022-007/Published 04/2016