Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ubc 1996-090442
Ubc 1996-090442
by
MOEZ M. BOURAOUI
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
in
December 1995
DE-6 (2/88)
Abstract
Raman spectroscopy was used to study the protein structure in raw and
salted surimi from Pacific whiting, and in gels formed by setting (32°C),
cooked and set-cooked gels. A smaller increase was found in the gels that
cooking. The set and cooked gel had a better gel strength and fold score
than the cooked gel which, in turn, had better properties than the set gel.
strength, fold score and color, (whiteness index), and a minimized gel
expressible liquid. Cooking temperature was the variable that had the
ii
a global optimization method, gave essentially the same results as a gradient
based optimization method. The results obtained by these two methods were
surimi, the kamaboko obtained had similar gel strength and elasticity as a
roe herring on its gel making ability (GMA) were investigated. Frozen storage
at around -45°C maintained the GMA for seventy days while storage at -83°C
simple model which takes into consideration the effects of both shear rate and
temperature.
iii
Table of Contents
Abstract ii
Table of contents iv
List of Tables iv
List of Figures xi
Acknowledgments xiv
Chapter 1: Introduction 1
iv
Chapter 2: Investigation of the Protein Structure of Pacific
2.1 Introduction 13
2.2.1 Materials 18
2.4 Conclusions 45
3.1 Introduction 46
v
3.1.2 The Gradient based optimization methods 50
Salmon 75
4.1 Introduction 75
4.2 Objectives 77
4.3.1 Materials 78
vi
4.3.2 General procedures 79
4.5 Conclusions 92
5.1 Introduction 94
Nomenclature 132
vii
Bibliography 136
viii
List of Tables
residues 34
conditions 52
variable 60
variables 61
Table 10. Regression results where "F " is the response variable
s 62
ix
Table 14. Optimization of individual response variables using the
method 69
Table 19. Curve fitting results of the second ISR rheograms 110
Table 21. Results of the curve fitting of the yield stress 119
Table 22. Yield stress values from the first ISR rheograms 120
Table 23. Curve fitting results of Theological data by the ST model 122
x
List of Figures
instrument 23
Figure 10. Raman spectra of surimi and gels in the 1220-1275 cm" 1
xi
Figure 11. Raman spectra of surimi and gels in the 2500-3400 cm" 1
Figure 12. Variation with treatment of the intensity and of the area of
frozen storage 84
strength, 87
fold score 89
xii
Figure 28. DSR rheograms and the predictions of the ST model 124
Figure 29. Second ISR rheograms and the predictions of the ST 125
model
xiii
Acknowledgments
Bowen and Dr. Shuryo Nakai, for their invaluable supervision, help and
special thanks go to Dr. Tim Durance and Dr. Ken Pinder, my committee
members, for their contributions to this project and their guidance. I also
thank Dr. Eunice Li-Chan for her great help with the Raman spectroscopy, Dr.
Jaouad Fichtali for his contributions to this project and Mr. Dragan Macura for
wife, Amna, my sister, Hella, and all my family members for their great love,
xiv
Chapter 1. Introduction
Chapter 1
Introduction
deboned and water-washed fish flesh (Okada, 1992; Lee, 1984). It is often
upon cooking, an elastic and chewy texture that can be made to resemble that
of shellfish (Lee, 1984). For centuries, the Japanese have been producing
surimi mainly from Alaska pollock. Around the twelfth century, Japanese
fishermen discovered that when surimi was salted, ground and steam or broil
cooked, the end product, called kamaboko, could be kept longer (Lee, 1984).
Surimi technology has evolved to produce such shellfish analogs as crab and
especially since it is the major producer of Alaska Pollock. Table 1 shows the
The table demonstrates that surimi production in the USA jumped from none
Norway and the UK have also started to produce surimi from under-utilized
1
Chapter 1. Introduction
Production (1,0001)
1985 490 0 20 10
1987 480 20 30 20
1989 390 80 30 20
2
Chapter 1. Introduction
fish species (Hastings and Currall, 1989). In Japan, apart from pollock, other
fish species are being used for surimi production. These species include
sardine mackerel, atka mackerel and horse mackerel. Surimi of good quality
1988, New Zealand produced 22,800 metric tons of surimi from this species
has recently been used for surimi production. It is very abundant on the West
1993). The allowable catch of this species in the USA ranges between
140,000 and 250,000 metric tons per year (Yongsawatdigul et al., 1995).
available to humans; about half of the harvested fish in the world in 1986 was
reduced to animal feed (Pigott, 1986). Because of the high nutritional and
develop and improve the production of shellfish analogs as well as other non-
3
Chapter 1. Introduction
washing out the water soluble components from the minced fish and adding
1992) . This was a threshold for the production of frozen surimi. The main
which decreases the displacement of water from protein surfaces and hence
The process starts with deboning and gutting to remove the head, viscera and
most of the backbone. The product is then minced and washed with water.
such as blood. It is usually carried out in three to four cycles (Ohshima et al.,
scales, small bones, etc. The soft meat is selectively forced through the
mm (Toyoda et al., 1992)]. The excess water due to the washing process is
content of the refined mince from 90% to around 80% (wet basis). The
4
Chapter 1. Introduction
\1/
mincing
refining
dewa ering
blending of additives
(i.e., cryoprotectants)
freezing
5
Chapter 1. Introduction
product is then mixed with cryoprotectants in a silent cutter. Then, the surimi
blocks are then frozen at -25°C or lower (Toyoda et al., 1992). The surimi
yield is between 20 and 30% (raw material weight basis); it varies with the fish
(Toyoda et al., 1992). Surimi is popular because of its high nutritive value,
high protein content and low fat. For example, surimi produced by Alaska
tripolyphosphate, and 1.0% fat and ash (Nicklason and Pigott, 1989).
Most of surimi-based products are gelled surimi. The Japanese have been
producing surimi-based products for centuries. The washed fish flesh, when
combined with certain ingredients, mixed and kneaded, and steamed, forms a
fish gel called kamaboko (Pigott, 1986). To name but a few, there is steamed
More recently, shellfish analogs have been produced from surimi. These
include imitations of crab, lobster, scallop and shrimp (Lee, 1984). Crab
imitation has gained popularity not only in Japan and Korea but also in the
6
Chapter 1. Introduction
plunged from 185 million pounds in 1980 to less than 40 million pounds in
1982 (Gwinn, 1992). It has continued to fall further in succeeding years. This
shortage of crab meat, along with its high price, has created a significant
Lee et al. (1992b) stated that the texture of surimi-based products composed
quality and water binding capacity as well as the product stability for frozen
distribution, other ingredients are added. These include starch (i.e., wheat or
potato starch), egg white, etc., which become entrapped within the gel matrix
thereby improving its strength and texture (Lee et al., 1992b). Modified starch
was reported to improve the gel freeze-thaw stability (Lee et al., 1992b).
Other ingredients may also be added depending on the final product desired.
Frozen storage of fish products is widely used by the industry to prolong the
7
Chapter 1. Introduction
tempering to -8 to -4°C
slitting
bundling
coloring
wrapping
4
cut mg
packaging
I
pasteurization
si,
coo mg
freezing
8
Chapter 1. Introduction
deterioration of the texture, the flavor and the color of the fish. Several
mechanisms have been postulated to explain the causes of the loss of fish
The formation of ice crystals could cause damage to fish proteins. These ice
crystals are larger when the product is frozen at slow freezing rates or when
the storage temperature fluctuates (Wheaton and Lawson, 1985). Ice crystals
can break cells, rupture membranes and cause drip loss upon thawing of the
product at fast rates allowing the passage of every part of the product through
the critical freezing zone (-0.8 to -5°C) within five to ten hours (Wheaton and
Lawson, 1985).
Matsumoto (1980) and Matsumoto and Noguchi (1992) explained that the
the protein molecules. This phenomenon triggers the denaturation of the fish
9
Chapter 1. Introduction
As water in the fish freezes out, the salt concentration increases. This
increase can cause protein aggregation. Connel (1964) reported that a salt
poor packaging) can increase lipid oxidation during frozen storage of fish.
Shenouda (1980) reported that the oxidized products of lipids interact with the
with storage time and with the fat content of the fish.
During the frozen storage of some fish species, especially the gadoid family
10
Chapter 1. Introduction
There are still many uncertainties regarding the mechanisms responsible for
fish protein denaturation during frozen storage, and especially concerning the
This thesis was motivated by the need to provide alternative value-added fish
study of the various processing factors that play a role in the overall surimi gel
production cycle.
study the proteins in intact pastes and gels without having to isolate or extract
The effects of setting and cooking conditions on the quality of the final
product (Pacific whiting surimi gel) are studied in Chapter 3. The optimal
11
Chapter 1. Introduction
setting and cooking temperatures and times were determined by finding the
conditions that maximize three and minimize one gel texture quality variable.
Surimi production from two under-utilized species, pink salmon and roe
on the gel making ability as well as the effects of gel improving ingredients on
the gel texture are discussed. An optimal formulation for the production of
12
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Chapter 2
2.1 Introduction
temperatures (usually above 70°C). The formed gel has an elastic and chewy
texture that can be made to resemble the texture of shellfish flesh (Lee,
1984).
would be useful for the improvement of gel quality and texture. Niwa (1992)
indicated that grinding surimi with salt causes the formation of actomyosin
and contains over 40 sulfhydryl residues but no disulfide bonds (Nakai and Li-
Chan, 1988). Actin has a molecular weight of about 42,000 to 47,000 and
and Li-Chan, 1988). During the setting stage {suwari in Japanese), Gill and
13
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Conway (1989) found that heavy meromyosin (HMM S-2) and light
meromyosin (LMM) fragments of the cod myosin tail region were inaccessible
When isolated, only the LMM fragments formed a gel (Sano et al., 1990).
1992; Niwa, 1992; Stone and Stanley, 1992). Many studies have
or actin fractions, actomyosin, meat sols or salt extracts (Nakai and Li-Chan,
14
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
dissolving the gel. A great deal of uncertainty, therefore, still exists regarding
linked together by peptide bonds. The function of each protein depends on its
knowledge of its secondary structure can be used to predict its overall three-
random coil. Branden and Tooze (1991) explained that, for the a-helices, the
cp and \\t angles for the consecutive residues are around -60° and -50°,
respectively. (q> is the angle of rotation around the N-Ca bond, whereas vy is
the angle around the C a - C bond from the same Ca-atom.) An a-helix has 3.6
residues per turn. On the other hand, p-sheets are composed of several
regions, p-strands, of the polypeptide chain. Each strand contains from five to
ten residues. The strands are aligned adjacent to each other. The p-sheet is
called parallel when the amino acids in the aligned p-strands run in the same
15
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
acids in successive strands run alternatively once from the amino terminal to
the carboxy terminal and once from the carboxy terminal to the amino
its ability to analyze solids as well as solutions, and therefore, has great
has been used to study the myosin substructure (Carew and Asher, 1975) and
the Raman spectra of intact muscle fibers and internally perfused fibers.
lysozyme (Li-Chan and Nakai, 1991) and the gelation of whey proteins
(Nonakaetal., 1993).
broad bands from overlapping components, many attempts have been made
16
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
seismology, etc.) where spectral peaks are overlapping and are therefore
1990):
17
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
P=l 1 u exp[- —j ]
1 = i -42noi 2<jt
where {y y
1( 2l y„} is a measured data set, {CH, O ,2 o } is a more resolved
n
peak shape function. To our knowledge, these techniques have not been
spectroscopy, a method that offers the major advantage of being able to study
2.2.1 Materials
Frozen surimi made from Pacific whiting was donated by Ucluelet Seafood
studied: raw surimi, salted surimi (ground with 3% salt in a vacuum cutter
18
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
[Stephan, Model VCM-5, Columbus, OH]), set gel (32°C for 19 min), cooked
gel (86°C for 12 min) and set-cooked gel (setting at 32°C for 19 min followed
The Raman spectrum of each sample was measured on a Jasco Model NR-
excitation from the 488-nm line of a Spectra-Physics Model 168B argon ion
separates the scattered light depending on its frequency. Then, the Raman
conditions: laser power, 100 mW; slit height, 4 mm; spectra resolution, 5 cm"1
19
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Collection
optics
Detector
Computer
20
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
at 19,000 cm" ; sampling speed, 120 cm" min" with data collected at every
1 1 1
the nature of our samples (surimi paste and gels). Duplicate samples were
Spectral smoothing (to improve the signal to noise ratio), baseline correction,
peaks), integration (to determine peak areas) and other computations were
performed using LabCalc (Galactic Industries Corp., Salem, NH) with Square
amide I region was carried out using the Raman spectral analysis package
published literature (Tu, 1986; Colthup et al., 1990; Li-Chan et al., 1994).
21
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
The quality of the surimi gels obtained after setting alone, cooking alone, and
the Raman spectroscopy results. The surimi gel quality tests performed were
the compression test and the fold test. The compression test is an indicator
of the gel cohesiveness. It was carried out using an Instron Universal Testing
variation of force with time was recorded. The gel strength was the product of
the force and the distance at the point of rupture (Lee, 1984) (see Figure 4).
The distance at the point of rupture was calculated by multiplying the time of
rupture by the cross head speed. The fold test indicates gel elasticity. It was
slowly in half lengthwise and then in half again while examining it for
structural failure. A rating score from 1 to 6 was used. The rating system is
22
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
23
C h a p t e r 2. R a m a n spectroscopy o f surimi
24
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
The set gel had a gel strength of 246 ± 35 N.mm (n=4) and a fold score of 3
while the cooked sample had a gel strength of 2972 + 87 N.mm (n=4) and a
fold score of 4. The set and then cooked gel had the best properties
consisting of a gel strength of 3897 + 104 N.mm (n=4) and a fold score of 6.
sample. These regions were 450-600 cm' (to assess S-S stretching of
1
disulfide bonds), 610-2000 cm" (to estimate secondary structure and various
1
side chain vibrations) and 2500-3400 cm" (to evaluate C-H stretching
1
reproducible.
region
Figure 5 shows the Raman spectra of the five types of samples studied. A
major peak was found at 529 cm" (raw, salted and set samples) or at 531 cm"
1 1
25
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Wavenumber ( c m " ) 1
26
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
1994). Although the normalized intensity of this band increased only slightly
after salting and setting, a considerable increase was observed in the cooked
gel and especially in the set-cooked gel (Figure 6). This may be attributed to
around 528 cm" was previously observed upon gelation of hen egg white
1
stretching bands near 508 cm" (Nonaka et al., 1993). An increase in disulfide
1
bonds due to gel strengthening of fish proteins was proposed by Itoh's group
(1979) who found that the sulfhydryl content of carp actomyosin solution
2.3.2 Backbone and side chain vibrations in the 610-2000 cm' region 1
Further detailed analysis of selected bands in this region was carried out.
27
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
2.5
Treatment
28
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
CO
to
CD
Wavenumber ( c m 1
)
29
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
wavenumber (cm" ) 1
assignment
761 Trp
879 Trp
940 a-helix
1005 Phe
1062 p-sheet
1450 C H bending
2
1658 Amide I
30
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
The original and the deconvoluted Raman spectra in the wavenumber region
from 820 to 912 cm' for the five types of samples are shown in Figures 8a
1
and 8b, respectively. Special attention was given to the bands located near
ring which are affected by the environment and the involvement of the
residues which are exposed to the aqueous or polar environment and act as
intensity ratio of the doublet bands (Uso/sa)) usually ranges from 0.90-1.45, but
can be as high as 2.5. On the other hand, U50/830 values for tyrosine residues
hydrogen donors usually range between 0.7 and 1.0, and can be as low as
The intensity ratio ISSO/KJO of raw and salted surimi were 1.18 and 1.14,
mainly exposed. The ISSO/KJO ratios decreased to 0.59 and 0.22 for the set and
31
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Figure 8. Raman spectra of surimi and gels in the 820-912 cm" region,
1
32
C h a p t e r 2 . R a m a n spectroscopy o f surimi
strong hydrogen bond donors after these samples were processed by setting
as well as setting followed by cooking. On the other hand, the sample which
received only the cook treatment had a high USO/KJO ratio of 3.1, indicating that
and were involved as strong hydrogen bond acceptors on the surface of the
proportions of the buried and the exposed tyrosine residues. The equation is:
0.5 N buried
+ 1.25N exposed ~ '850/830
where N is the mole fraction (N b uhed +N exposed = 1). The numerical constants
in this equation were obtained by fitting the general form to the X-ray
diffraction data of Kannan et al. (1975). Table 4 lists the proportions of the
buried and the exposed tyrosine residues (TR) estimated by Tu's equation.
This table shows that the TR of the raw and the salted surimi were mainly
numbers shown for the cooked and the set-cooked samples show the
limitations of Tu's equations at too high or too low values of USO/KIO- However,
these numbers might be an indication that all the TR of the cooked sample
were exposed whereas all the TR of the set-cooked gel were buried.
33
C h a p t e r 2. R a m a n spectroscopy o f surimi
34
C h a p t e r 2. R a m a n spectroscopy o f surimi
bands
The -CO-NH- amide or peptide bond has several distinct vibrational modes,
with the amide I band near 1650 cm" and the amide III band near 1250 cm'
1 1
being most easily identified in the Raman spectra of proteins. The exact
polypeptide chain, and these features are therefore useful for estimating
from the solvent water in the amide I region and from miscellaneous C-H
Raman spectra of the surimi and gelled samples were, therefore, measured in
The amide I band arises primarily from in-plane peptide C=0 stretching
vibrations and also has contributions from in-plane N-H bending vibrations.
Generally, proteins with high a-helical content show an amide I band centered
35
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
undefined or random coil structure have the amide I band centered near 1660
cm' . The original and the deconvoluted Raman spectra in this region are
1
shown in Figures 9a and 9b, respectively. For the raw surimi, a major band at
1656 cm" suggestive of a-helical structure and a minor band near 1679 cm"
1 1
typical of 3-sheet structure are present. The salted surimi indicates a trend
towards uncoiling of helices with the major band centered near 1661 cm' , 1
while the minor band near 1683 cm" is suggestive of p-sheet or turns. For
1
using the RSAP program for least squares analysis of the amide I region are
36
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Figure 9. Raman spectra of surimi and gels in the 1590-1720 cm" region
1
37
C h a p t e r 2. R a m a n spectroscopy o f surimi
38
C h a p t e r 2. R a m a n spectroscopy o f surimi
cooking after setting, while the cooked gel without prior setting showed an
content. Similar trends were noted by examining the amide III band in the
Raman spectra of the different samples. The amide III band results primarily
from the C-N stretching and N-H in-plane bending vibrations of the peptide
bond. It is less intense and located in a broad region from 1260-1300 cm" for1
lead to a more intense band near 1238-1245 cm" while random coil structures
1
deconvoluted Raman spectra in the region which includes the amide III bands
from 1230-1300 cm" . Detailed inspection of the bands suggests that raw and
1
salted samples contain several bands in the amide III region typical of high a-
helical contents. The heat-set sample has increased the intensity of the
p-sheet structures. The trend towards higher p-sheet structure at the expense
of the a-helical content is even more evident in the cooked and set-cooked
gels. The cooked gel shows two main component bands in this region, while
the set-cooked gel shows only one major band at 1247 cm" with smaller
1
39
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Figure 10. Raman spectra of surimi and gels in the 1220-1275 cm" region
1
40
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
The Raman spectra in the amjde I and III regions thus collectively indicate a
upon setting, which became more pronounced after the cooking treatments.
unraveling of the coiled helical structure of fish myosin after heating to 50°C,
Figure 11 shows the Raman spectra of the five samples in this region, which
residues. For each sample, a major peak is shown between 2932 and 2939
cm" . A slight increase in wavenumber of the Raman shift was observed in the
1
gelled samples compared to the raw and salted surimi. However, information
41
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Raw
Salted
-.-<
W Set
<D
a
i—i
(D
>
-<-( Cooked
-•->
cd
«—i
CD
I 1 I 1 1
3250 3000 2750 2500
Wavenumber ( c m - 1
)
Figure 11. Raman spectra of surimi and gels in the 2500-3400 cm" region
1
42
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
The normalized intensity as well as the area of the peak assigned to C-H
and salted surimi (Figure 12). Again, the interpretation of these results is not
clear, due to the scarcity of information in the literature on the study of amino
acid C-H stretching vibrations. One may speculate that the higher Raman
shifts and decrease in the intensity of the vibrations of the C-H stretching
by surimi gelation. Larsoon and Rand (1973) also found that the intensity of
the 2930 cm' peak increased with increased degree of polar environment of
1
43
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
Treatment
Figure 12. Variation with treatment of the intensity and of the area of the
~2935 cm' peak
1
44
Chapter 2. Raman spectroscopy of surimi
2.4 Conclusions
changes in the protein structure of intact surimi and gels from Pacific whiting.
increased slightly after the setting treatment and considerably after the
sheet content. This trend was more pronounced after the cooking treatments.
The gel properties, gel strength and fold score of the set and cooked gel were
higher than those of the cooked gel. The properties of the latter gel were
better than those of the gel that was subjected to the setting treatment alone.
45
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
Chapter 3
3.1 Introduction
One of the most important functional properties of surimi is its gelation property.
When surimi is chopped with salt (usually between 2 and 3% of surimi paste
weight), its myofibrillar proteins become soluble in water (Lee, 1984). When salt
is introduced, the salt ions bind to the oppositely charged groups exposed on the
protein surface and the proteins dissolve because of their increased affinity for
water (Niwa, 1992). When salted surimi is heated, it forms a fish gel structure
called kamaboko. The formation of a three dimensional gel network requires the
temperatures. This results in a stronger gel than cooking without a slow set
(Lee, 1984).
46
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
For instance, Douglas-Schwartz and Lee ( 1988) tested the effect of setting for
20 minutes at four temperatures; 40, 60, 80 and 90°C. They found that setting of
Alaska pollock surimi and red hake surimi at 40°C resulted in gels with the best
cohesiveness and water holding capacity. For testing the quality of surimi gels,
Lanier (1992) suggested varying setting time and temperature but cooking
information about the combined effects of setting time and temperature as well
as cooking time and temperature on gel quality especially for surimi made from
obtain this information, an experiment was designed to study the individual and
combined effects of setting and cooking conditions on the gel quality variables.
" Then optimization was performed to determine the processing conditions which
What follows is a brief description of some the optimization techniques that were
47
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f p r o c e s s i n g c o n d i t i o n s
Reflection
P* = ( 1 + a ) C - a P H
where C is the centroid of the points other than P H , a > 0 is the reflection
coefficient (i.e., a = 1/2, 2/3, or 1). If Y < Y* = f(P*) < Y , [Y = min (Yi), 1 < i <
L H L
Expansion
48
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
P E =YP* + ( 1 ^ ) C
where y > 1 is the expansion coefficient (i.e., y = 1.5). If Y E = f(P ) < Y , then
E L
Contraction
defined as the old P or P* selecting the point that has the lower Y value. Let us
H
define P as:
c
P C = P P H + (1-P)C
where p < 1. If Y = f(Pc) > min (Y ,Y*) then replace all the values of Pj with
c H
(Pi + P )/2 and restart the process. Otherwise, replace P with P and restart.
L H C
49
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
These optimization methods use the partial derivatives of the objective function
in order to find the direction of search. For a minimization problem and when the
gradient vector at a point gives the direction of the greatest decrease in the
objective function and, therefore, guides the transition from one point to another
until an optimal value is found (Edgar and Himmelblau, 1988). The NLPQLO
(Vaessen, 1984).
The simplex method and the gradient based method are local optimization
methods, e.g., they are only able to find a single minimum even though other
minima having lower objective function values may also be located in the
constrained search field. A global optimization method was used to assess the
results obtained by the two local techniques. This global method is the Level
The fact that LSP is a global optimization technique is very useful when dealing
with problems having many local optima. The LSP theory was initially presented
50
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f processing c o n d i t i o n s
the direct search category. It does not need gradient evaluations and is mainly
based on the determinations of the objective and constraint (if any) functions at
having objective functions less than or equal to a pre-selected value called the
level set value (LSV). The mean of these values defines a new LSV and hence
decreasing LSV until the convergence criteria are satisfied. Then, the global
The objective of this study was to determine the optimal setting time and
temperature and cooking time and temperature resulting in Pacific whiting surimi
gel with the best combination of gel strength, fold score, color and expressible
liquid.
The Response surface methodology (RSM), central composite design was used
51
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
Factors CODES
-2 -1 0 1 2
X, setting temperature (°C) 20 30 40 50 60
X2 setting time (min.) 0 10 20 30 40
X3 cooking temperature (°C) 70 75 80 85 90
X4 cooking time (min.) 5 15 25 35 45
X1 X2 X3 X4
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
-2 0 0 0
2 0 0 0
0 -2 0 0
0 2 0 0
0 0 -2 0
0 0 2 0
0 0 0 -2
0 0 0 2
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
52
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
2 (16) factorial settings, 2x4 (8) axial settings and 6 center point replicates
4
(Khuri and Cornell, 1987). The four independent variables were setting
temperature (X^, setting time (X ), cooking temperature (X3) and cooking time
2
(X4). Experiments were carried out on Pacific whiting surimi donated by Ucluelet
conditions, surimi was mixed with 3% salt (total weight basis) before being set
and cooked as in section 4.3.2.2. The setting and cooking conditions are
depicted in Table 6. The quality of the obtained surimi gels was tested by
This test is an indication of gel cohesiveness (Lee et al., 1987). The procedure
This test indicates gel elasticity (Lee, 1984). It was performed according to the
53
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f processing conditions
0-100 scale from black to white in shades of gray, a denoting redness (if
blueness (if negative). The "whiteness" index, C, for the overall color evaluation
is (Lanier, 1992):
C = 100-[(100-L) +a + b ] 2 2 2 05
Expressible liquid is a measure of the water binding ability of the gel. It was
1.9 minutes and absorbing the expressed moisture in two pieces of filter paper
for five minutes. Free water is more easily expressed upon compression than
54
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f p r o c e s s i n g c o n d i t i o n s
E, (%)=(Wi-W )x 100/ Wi f
where Wj is the weight of the surimi gel before compression while W is the f
(Arteaga, 1992), the NLPQLO gradient based method (Vaessen, 1984) and the
Level Set Programming method (Yassien, 1993). Xi had a lower limit of 22°C
and an upper limit of 45°C. X and X 4 varied between 10 and 40 minutes. The
2
Table 7 summarizes the results of the optimization experiments. For each set of
temperature (X3) and cooking time (X4), it shows the corresponding response
variables, namely gel strength (G ), fold score (F ), color (C) and expressible
s s
liquid (Ei). G values were higher for cooking temperatures of 80°C and above.
s
The fold score values were also better at these cooking temperatures. A lower
55
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
E,
(°C) (min.) (°C) (min.) (N.mm) Fs (%)
1 30 10 75 15 130 2.0 55.7 18.1
2 50 10 75 35 940 3.5 55.1 16.0
3 30 30 75 35 230 3.0 56.4 16.7
4 50 30 75 15 330 2.5 55.6 16.2
5 30 10 85 35 2860 5.0 55.8 19.1
6 50 10 85 15 3080 4.5 55.6 13.0
7 30 30 85 15 3950 6.0 57.6 19.3
8 50 30 85 35 720 3.0 55.2 14.5
9 40 20 80 25 2540 5.0 55.9 19.5
10 40 20 80 25 2160 5.0 56.3 19.5
11 30 10 75 35 520 4.0 56.5 16.5
12 50 10 75 15 150 2.5 54.1 17.4
13 30 30 75 15 110 1.5 56.9 18.9
14 50 30 75 35 720 3.0 56.8 14.4
15 30 10 85 15 3680 5.0 56.8 21.1
16 50 10 85 35 1470 3.5 55.6 14.9
17 30 30 85 35 3640 3.5 55.5 20.3
18 50 30 85 15 1270 3.0 55.4 14.3
19 40 20 80 25 2120 5.0 54.9 18.8
20 40 20 80 25 2940 6.0 59.1 12.4
21 20 20 80 25 3050 6.0 68.1 13.2
22 60 20 80 25 3050 6.0 65.4 12.7
23 40 0 80 25 2920 4.0 59.6 13.1
24 40 40 80 25 2800 6.0 59.9 12.1
25 40 20 70 25 340 2.0 67.2 16.7
26 40 20 90 25 1620 3.0 67.0 14.8
27 40 20 80 5 2810 6.0 58.3 10.4
28 40 20 80 45 2150 5.0 53.5 19.1
29 40 20 80 25 2960 6.0 60.7 12.5
30 40 20 80 25 2960 6.0 61.4 13.0
fold score, however, was observed for surimi cooked at 80°C without previous
setting. This shows the effect of setting on the gel elasticity and supports the
findings of Lanier et al. (1982) who reported that surimi gels prepared by setting
prior to cooking were more elastic than those that were directly cooked. Setting
weaker and less elastic gels than were obtained under the same cooking
due to the gel softening phenomenon, called modori in Japanese, which usually
range may be the cause of gel softening. Most of the C values were higher than
Lanier (1992). (Grade 1 corresponds to C > 60.0.) Seven out of eight of the
moisture. This supports the deduction of Tagagi (1973) that the more elastic the
surimi gel the lower the expressible moisture. The six center point replicates
in high E, whereas the other points gave low E, values. Since these six points
resulted in high fold scores, it is thought that the high values of E observed for
t
three points could be due to experimental error. In most of the cases, less
moisture was expressed from gels that were cooked at 80°C and above.
57
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f p r o c e s s i n g c o n d i t i o n s
Y = Bo + £/3iXi + f BnXi j
2
+2 ^PaXiXj
i=l i=l i=l ;'=i+l
where X 4 are the input variables which influence the response variable Y
while Po, Pi(i=1,...,4) and Py (i=1,...,3; j=i+1,..., 4) are the model parameters. This
is the second order model (SOM) used in the Response Surface Methodology
Curve fitting was carried out using the Systat 1990 (Systat, Inc., Evanston, IL)
regression of the measured gel strengths are shown in Table 8. Only the terms
that significantly affected the model (P < 0.05) are included in the table and were
taken into account in the optimization procedures which are discussed in section
3.3.2. The logarithm of the gel strength was used in the regression analysis as
range (from 110 to 3950 N.mm), yielded poor regression results (R < 0.50). 2
Table 8 shows that cooking temperature had the strongest influence on gel
58
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
Coefficient R z
Standard Error of
Estimate
01 0.284
p 3
2.606
P4 0.285
Pl3 -0.004
P33 -0.014
P34 -0.004
59
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f processing conditions
strength while setting temperature and cooking time had less effect on G . s
However, setting time, at least in the range of 10 to 40 minutes, did not affect G . s
Ei, also demonstrates that the G s data were well fitted by the SOM. The
experimental data of F were also reasonably well fitted by the SOM (Tables 9
s
and 10). F was mainly dependent on the cooking temperature. The three other
s
independent variables affected F only slightly. Table 11 shows that the curve
s
fitting results for the color variable were worse than those of the other response
variables. The higher the setting temperature and/or the cooking temperature,
the lower the whiteness index of the surimi gel. Setting time and cooking time
did not affect color. Measured E, data were well fitted by the SOM (Tables 9 and
12). The model parameters listed in Table 12 demonstrate that the higher the
cooking temperature and/or time, the lower the expressible liquid. For all four
response variables, the quadratic parameters had very little influence on the
overall fit.
The fact that cooking temperature was the variable that had the most influence
on the gel cohesiveness, elasticity and water holding capacity shows the
importance of the cooking stage on the gel texture. At the cooking stage, as
found in Chapter 2, more disulfide interactions take place and the p-sheet
60
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
61
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
Table 10. Regression results where "F " is the response variable
s
Coefficient R 2
Standard Error of
Estimate
Pi 0.631
p 2
0.243
p 3
8.211
P4 0.848
Pl3 -0.008
P22 -0.007
P33 -0.047
P34 -0.011
62
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f p r o c e s s i n g c o n d i t i o n s
Coefficient R 2
Standard Error of
Estimate
Pi -4.776
p 3
-6.602
Pl3 0.063
P33 0.029
P44 -0.001
63
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f p r o c e s s i n g c o n d i t i o n s
Coefficient R 2
Standard Error of
Estimate
P3 -5.1
P4 -1.868
P11 0.013
Pl3 -0.016
P33 0.034
P34 0.010
P44 0.020
64
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
The generated equations for the response variables were then used to
Using the empirical equations found for each variable as objective functions,
setting/cooking times and temperatures in each case. These were the Nelder-
Mead Simplex method, the Level Set Programming method, and the NLPQLO
Gradient method.
C, and minimizing Ei) using the Simplex method are shown in Table 13. This
table contains the optimal processing conditions (Xj, i=1,2 4) along with the
corresponding values for the four response variables. The optimized values of
log (G ), F
s S| C and E, were 4.08, 6.41, 70.8 and 12.3, respectively. Apart from
the Ei value, the other optimized values were better than the best experimental
resulted in a negative F value. This is a further indication that SOM fit of the
s
65
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
Simplex method
Variable Maximize G s
Maximize F s Maximize C Minimize Ei
X (min.)
2
36.1 21.1 40.0 24.3
log (G ) s
4.08 4.00 2.23 3.40
F s
3.98 6.41 -4.80 4.26
66
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
Table 14 depicts the results of optimizing the response variables using the
values of log (G ), F , C and Ei were 4.08, 6.64, 72.7 and 12.3, respectively. The
s s
maximized F and C values were higher than those obtained by the Nelder-Mead
s
Simplex method indicating that the Simplex optimizer likely found only local
maxima for these two response variables. In addition, the processing conditions
The optimization results obtained using this method were almost the same as
those obtained by the NLPQLO gradient method (see Table 15). The optimal
setting time values for G , C and Ei were considerably different from those
s
over the range from 10 to 40 minutes. Hence, the results of the global LSP
method confirmed the results of the local gradient method for the independent
67
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
Gradient method
X (min.)
2 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0
log (G ) s
4.08 3.99 3.14 3.40
F s
6.34 6.64 3.13 4.53
68
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
Table 15. Optimization of individual response variables using the LSP method
X (min.)
2 23.8 17.4 30.8 28.0
F s
6.09 6.68 1.94 3.80
69
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
As can be seen in Tables 13 to 15, the optimal conditions for the optimization of
one response variable (e.g., G ) did not give satisfactory results for the other
s
transformed into a single objective problem. This was achieved by dividing each
1990). Each variable was normalized in this fashion in order to put all the
where Wi,...,w are weights that are chosen arbitrarily taking into consideration
4
for all the four response variables. The terms involving gel strength, fold score
and color were added because they were to be maximized. However, the
(1993).
70
C h a p t e r 3. O p t i m i z a t i o n o f processing conditions
along with the corresponding results are shown in Table 16. Those results were
obtained using the LSP method. Emphasis was put on maximizing gel strength
and fold score without excessively compromising color or the expressible liquid.
In most cases, the color variable was assigned a low weight, 0.1, because its
objective function was not well fitted to the measured color data. The Z values
could not be compared because the weights in each row were different. The row
in the bold font seems to give satisfactory results for all four response variables.
These results consisted of a gel strength of 3980 N.mm, a fold score of 5.4, a gel
setting at 39.2°C for 17.4 minutes followed by cooking at 82.8°C for 14.7
minutes.
71
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
w 2 W 3 w 4 Xi x 2 Xa X4 log G s F s
c E, z
1 6 0.1 3 36.6 17.4 83.5 11.3 3.6 5.8 59.7 18.2 4.4
1 5 0.1 3 39.2 17.4 82.8 14.7 3.6 5.4 60.5 15.6 3.4
1 6 0.1 3.5 38.5 17.8 83.0 14.1 3.6 5.5 60.3 16.1 4.0
1 6 0.1 4 40.9 17.4 82.6 16.8 3.5 5.2 61.0 14.5 3.6
1 8 0.1 5 40.3 17.4 82.6 15.9 3.5 5.3 60.7 14.9 4.7
1
9 0.1 5 38.9 17.5 83.1 14.1 3.6 5.5 60.6 16.0 5.6
72
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
quality showed that high cooking temperatures (80°C and above) resulted in
better gel cohesiveness, elasticity and water holding capacity. They also
were well fitted by a second order model which allowed four objective functions
to be generated for the four response variables; gel strength, fold score, color
The results obtained using the latter method appeared to be closer to the global
optima than those of the Simplex method. The results obtained using a global
optimize the four response variables. It gave a set of setting and cooking times
and temperatures which led to satisfactory values for all four response variables.
whiting kamaboko sausages having the size used in this project. The same
73
Chapter 3. Optimization of processing conditions
The ingredients used for this work were Pacific whiting surimi and salt. For
(GTII) such as starch, egg white or whey protein concentrate be taken into
optimized. This will allow a comprehensive study of the effects of setting and
cooking temperatures and times along with the effects of the GTII on the surimi
gel characteristics.
74
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
Chapter 4
4.1 Introduction
Alaska pollock has been the most popular species for the production of
surimi. This is due to its accessibility, subtle flavor and relatively large size,
among other characteristics (Holmes et al. 1992). However, with the increase
dramatically. For instance, the pollock biomass in the eastern Bering Sea
was estimated at 5.3 million metric tons in 1989, a 47% decline since 1986
(Holmes et al., 1992). This situation has encouraged the use of other species
British Columbia, Canada. Its annual harvest is between 15,000 and 40,000
tons. The catch is almost exclusively aimed at collecting herring roe, a very
75
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
popular commodity in Japan. The male fish and the remainder of the female
fish, after roe collection, are either wasted or reduced to fish meal. Making
good alternative. Kamaboko of average quality was obtained from fresh North
Sea herring (Hastings et al., 1990). The quality of kamaboko was worse
when North Sea herring was frozen at -30°C for six months. Nakai (1993)
found that no kamaboko could be made from herring surimi that was frozen at
products from herring that was frozen at different conditions in the form of raw
fish. However, due to the limited availability of roe herring and because its
small size makes surimi production difficult, another species was also tried.
large size and relatively low cost. Therefore, Pink salmon was also utilized to
the texture tends to be rubbery and freeze-thaw stability is often poor (Lee et
al., 1992). To improve the texture of the final product, several ingredients can
be added. In this study, the ingredients used were salt, whey protein
76
C h a p t e r 4. P r o d u c t i o n o f s a l m o n and herring k a m a b o k o
concentrate and wheat starch. Salt was used to improve the solubility of
surimi myofibrillar proteins. Kim and Lee (1987) explained that starch is
mainly used as a filler ingredient. Upon heating, it swells and increases water
uptake. This improves the firmness and the cohesiveness of the surimi gel
matrix. Wu et al. (1985) reported that starch does not directly interact with the
surimi protein matrix nor significantly influence its formation. Several studies
surimi-based products (Burgarella et al., 1985; Chung, 1990; Lee and Kim,
1986). It is also used as a filler. Its gel strengthening effect has been
reported by Lee et al. (1992b). Thus, there was a need to investigate the
4.2 Objectives
concentrate and wheat starch for kamaboko made from pink salmon surimi
77
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
4.3.1 Materials
Frozen, whole, roe herring was purchased from a local fishing company (Sung
Fish Company, Vancouver, B. C.) on May 17, 1994. The company kept this
fish frozen at -40°C for approximately one month (since mid-April 1994). It
was transported to our laboratory where 11 pounds (lb) were stored at -83°C,
70 lb at -45°C and 70 lb at -35°C. The fish comprising the last sample were
soaked in glycerol (10% solution) for 24 hours before further frozen storage.
Noguchi (1992).
Due to the limited quantity of herring in our possession, pink salmon was
selected for the tests relating to the optimization of the kamaboko formulation.
Pink salmon is suitable for this type of study because the surimi preparation
optimize the kamaboko formulation with salmon surimi and to use the
salmon was purchased at the end of July 1994. It was kept frozen at -35°C for
78
C h a p t e r 4. P r o d u c t i o n o f s a l m o n and herring k a m a b o k o
two months before salmon surimi was made from it. After four months of
storage at -35°C, the salmon surimi was then used in the optimization
ingredients were used. These are salt, modified whey protein concentrate
(WPC) (Alaco Surimi Plus), wheat starch (WS) and water. The ingredient
Hanpen-L), which were made from Alaska pollock, were used as commercial
target products.
The fish was filleted, minced, washed 4 times in a 0.3% salt solution (the
volume of the solution was five times the volume of the fillets), and mixed with
Manufacturing Co., Model 84142, Don Mills, Ontario) for 5 minutes. These
procedures were performed at 4°C. The surimi was stored frozen at -35°C.
79
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
Surimi, partially thawed at room temperature for one hour, was chopped, in a
vacuum cutter (Stephan, Model VCM-5, Columbus, Ohio), at low speed for
two minutes. Then 3% salt (total weight basis) was added and the mixture
was mixed at low speed for three minutes. Finally, mixing was performed
under vacuum (to prevent oxidation) at high speed for one minute. Circulating
and WPC were used, the mixing procedure was different. Surimi chopped at
low speed for two minutes, was mixed with salt at low speed for two additional
minutes. The paste was then blended with WS (premixed with water) and
WPC for two more minutes at low speed. The paste was finally mixed at high
speed and under vacuum for one minute. Using a meat stuffer (Kitchenaid,
Model K5-A, Troy, Ohio) the paste was stuffed into sausage casings having a
subjected to setting at 45°C for thirty minutes in a Blue M water bath (Model
MW-1120A-1, Blue Island, IL) and then cooking at 90°C for half an hour (in a
second Blue M water bath). The end product, kamaboko sausages, were
immediately cooled in ice for fifteen minutes and kept at room temperature
overnight before testing. The setting and cooking conditions were selected in
80
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
The quality of the kamaboko sausages was tested by performing the punch
and die test and the fold test. The punch test provides an indication of the gel
firmness, while the fold test measures the elasticity of the product (Lanier,
1991). The punch tests were performed using an Instron Universal Testing
plunger (5 mm diameter). The plunger goes through the sample and then
The variation of the penetration force with time was recorded. The gel
strength is the product of the force and the distance at the point of rupture
(see Figure 4). The fold test was carried out according to the description
On May 18,1994 surimi was made from about 30 pounds of whole herring
(one day after its purchase). The surimi was stored frozen at -35°C. On the
81
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
following day, kamaboko was made from this surimi and its quality was
evaluated by performing the punch and the fold tests. Surimi and kamaboko
were made from herring stored at -35°C and at -45°C for forty days. Fish
stored at the latter temperatures for 130 days was used to produce surimi and
kamaboko. Finally, surimi and kamaboko were made from frozen fish stored
After 40 days of storage at -35°C the glycerol soaked roe herring gave a
punch test score of 51 N.mm and a fold score of 3. The sample which was
stored at -45°C for the same period of time resulted in a punch test score of
herring before the cold storage was initiated (i.e., at the time when the frozen
herring was purchased from Sung Fish Co.) gave a punch test score of 61
N.mm and a fold test value of 3. From these results it appears that the fish
stored at -45°C without the use of glycerol gave the same gel strength and
fold test values as the sample before prolonged frozen storage. These results
82
C h a p t e r 4. P r o d u c t i o n o f s a l m o n and herring k a m a b o k o
are similar to the findings of Fukuda (1991) in which he concluded that freeze
damage of surimi made from cod, salmon, sardine and mackerel and frozen
for six months could be reduced at cold storage temperatures lower than
-AO°C.
However, Figure 13 shows that after 130 days of storage, the sample stored
at -45°C had a gel strength of 43 N.mm and a fold score of 2 while the sample
soaked in glycerol and stored at -35°C had a gel strength of 37 N.mm and a
40 and 130 days of frozen storage. After 190 days of frozen storage, the
sample stored at -83°C had a gel strength of 57 N.mm and a fold score of 3.
This sample had maintained reasonable gel quality. By comparison, the gel
strength values of the samples stored at -45°C and at -35°C for 190 days
a fold score of 2. Hastings et al. (1990) also found that the frozen storage of
whole herring for six months at -30°C resulted in a kamaboko having a gel
The deterioration of the gel making ability of roe herring after prolonged
83
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
70 - x — 3 5 C + glycerol
—I 45 C
-83 C
20 4-
10 4-
Time [days]
Figure 13. Variation of roe herring kamaboko gel strength with frozen storage
84
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
-83°C for 190 days maintained the gel firmness and elasticity. These findings
are similar to those of Watabe and Hashimito (1987) who reported a decrease
surimi at -20°C and at -30°C. This decrease, however, did not occur for the
investigate the changes that take place during the freeze denaturation of fish
proteins.
17. Figure 14 shows the variation of gel strength with whey protein
concentrate and wheat starch. The combined effects of the latter ingredients
85
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
1 SS S
0 0 0.00 58.9*+ 5.5" 3 71.8
14 HS h
2 5 7.00 74.4* ±3.3 6 NM"
15 MKS m
99.7*+8.6 6 74.2
16 KH-L k
84.2* ±2.3 6 71.5
8
Salmon surimi plus 3 % salt
h
Herring surimi plus 3 % salt
0
Optimal formulation
m
Maruu Kamaboko Shiro
k
Kibun Hanpen-L (Boiledfishcake)
" Not measured
* Arithmetic mean (n=5-7)
* Arithmetic mean (n=3)
** Standard deviation
86
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
Figure 14. Combined effects of WPC and WS on salmon surimi gel strength
87
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
7.8% water, gave a gel strength of 86.2 N.mm and a fold score of 4.
a fold score of 6. Since the objective was to maximize both the gel strength
and the fold score, formulation 3 was chosen to be the optimal formulation.
The characteristics of the gel obtained from this optimal formulation are very
close to those of commercial Kibun Hanpen-L (Boiled fish cake) (see Table
17). However, the gel strength of kamaboko produced from this optimal
formulation was 20% lower than that of Maruu Kamaboko Shiro, the second
(i.e., formulations 7, 9 and 10), the corresponding fold score values were very
good but the gel strength values were low. The individual gel texture
12. These results confirm the findings of Kim and Lee (1987) who reported
the gel strengthening effect of starch and Lee et al. (1992b) regarding the
88
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
Figure 15. Combined effects of WPC and WS on salmon surimi gel fold score.
89
C h a p t e r 4. P r o d u c t i o n o f s a l m o n and herring k a m a b o k o
The amount of added water was calculated in a way that the final product
moisture content had to be around 70% (wet basis). The moisture contents of
the ingredients used are shown in Table 18. Although the addition of water
The optimal formulation (formulation 3) which was developed for surimi was
applied to surimi made from fresh herring. The product had a gel strength of
74.4 N.mm and a fold score of 6. These gel quality values are close to those
because the composition of roe herring (i.e., fat content, protein content,
proportion of dark muscle) is different from that of pink salmon, the optimal
formulation for salmon is not necessarily the optimal formulation for herring.
90
C h a p t e r 4. P r o d u c t i o n o f s a l m o n and herring k a m a b o k o
Sample % Moisture
WPC 5.1
WS 14.1
Salt 0.2
91
C h a p t e r 4. P r o d u c t i o n o f s a l m o n and herring k a m a b o k o
4.5 Conclusions
gave gel strength and fold score values close to those of Kibun Hanpen-L
(Boiled fish cake), which was used as a target product. When this formulation
was applied to surimi made from fresh herring, similar gel characteristics were
obtained.
Roe herring frozen at -40°C for one month and then at -45°C for forty days
maintained its gel making ability. Further storage for ninety more days
denaturation due to frozen storage. However, when roe herring was frozen
at -40°C for one month and then at -83°C for 190 days, the gel making ability
was preserved.
products. Using pink salmon to make crab analogs, for instance, could be
more profitable than using it for canning. Because of its darker color, roe
require a white color. The problem of its small size can be overcome by using
92
Chapter 4. Production of salmon and herring kamaboko
equipment that is designed for producing surimi from under-sized fish species
93
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
Chapter 5
5.1 Introduction
The viscous properties of surimi are among the physical properties that need
particular importance during the pumping and the extruding operations that
40°C and of the additions of Na P20 and MgCI on the viscosity of carp
4 7 2
36°C and then rapidly decreased. Owusu-Ansah et al. (1988) also observed
94
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
similar trends of viscosity variation with temperature for sucker myosin. They
(1983) and Borderias et al. (1985) stated that the apparent viscosity of
proteins from frozen fish isolated in high ionic strength solutions can be used
as a quality index for frozen fish proteins. Groninger et al. (1983) used
test for the viscosity of surimi diluted (599% by weight) in a 3.5% salt solution
was used as a Japanese standard test for the quality evaluation of frozen
surimi protein (Hamann and MacDonald, 1992). The apparatus to be used for
this test is a Brookfield viscometer (Tokyo Keiki Type C). Scott et al. (1988)
found that the viscosity of Alaska pollock surimi, diluted in accordance with
the Japanese standard test, decreased with frozen storage time of the headed
and gutted Alaska pollock up to 128 days. The effects of incubation time and
temperature on the viscosity of a surimi paste (30% surimi, 2% salt, 1.2% beef
plasma protein and 66.8% water) were studied by Park et al. (1994). The
viscosity of the paste incubated at 5°C remained close to 40 Pas. When the
paste was incubated at 25°C, the viscosity increased to 80 Pa.s after 20 hours
95
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
ingredients (i.e., salt, starch, etc.) in a silent cutter. The resulting viscous
paste is then pumped before being cooked and extruded (Wu, 1992). Hence,
The objective of this work was to study the viscous properties of a salmon
results should help to clarify the flow behavior of this minced fish muscle.
The surimi used was the same salmon surimi described in Chapter 4. The
optimal formulation, which was selected in section 4.4.2, was used to make
the surimi paste for the Theological studies. As in section 4.3.2.2, partially
thawed surimi was cut in a vacuum cutter (Stephan, Model VCM-5, Columbus,
Ohio) at low speed for two minutes. Then 3% salt (total weight basis) was
added and the mixture was chopped at low speed for two minutes. Then 5%
96
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
(1992). The ingredients were blended at low speed for two minutes. Finally,
mixing was performed under vacuum and at high speed for one minute.
There are several methods for the measurement of viscosity. The glass
capillary method is based on the measurement of the time for a known volume
measuring the time needed for a volume of fluid to flow through an orifice.
This method, however, is less accurate than the glass capillary method
(Bourne, 1982). Other instruments include the capillary viscometer, the falling
ball viscometer and the coaxial rotational viscometers. The latter type of
Theological behavior of the fluid, permits the continuous variation of the shear
rate, can handle Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids and can be equipped
with a temperature control feature. For these reasons, the viscous properties
of the salmon surimi paste (kept in ice) were studied using a rotational
with a profiled cup and spindle, SVP, was used to reduce slippage. The inner
cylinder (rotor) has a radius of 10.65 mm and a height of 31.45 mm, while the
outer cylinder has a radius of 11.55 mm. Experiments were carried out at five
97
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
temperatures; 1,6, 11, 21 and 26°C. For each temperature, the paste was
put in the cup and kept there for ten minutes to come to temperature. Then,
the sample was sheared at shear rates increasing linearly from 0 to 400 s" in 1
ten minutes. After that, the shear rates decreased from 400 to 0 s" in ten 1
minutes. Finally, the sample was sheared again for ten minutes at rates
personal computer to which the viscometer was interfaced was used to vary
The Systat 1990 (Systat, Inc., Evanston, IL) software was used for the
regression analysis.
and 26°C, respectively. Each figure shows an increasing shear rate (ISR)
rheogram. For all the temperatures, the first ISR rheogram was not smooth or
reproducible. This could be due to the fact that the paste was initially at rest
or that the structure was being ruptured by the applied shear, possibly
98
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
600
• Increase D, 1st T=1 C •* •••
• Decrease D • • • ••••
550 4- A Increase D, 2nd
500 A .OS
A A A A A A A N A
450
A A A n
400 A *
A * °
350 4- A A
• A •
A O
A a
n°
£ . 300 A •
(0 A n D
A •
A C D
250 4-
200 4-
150 4-
100
50
H h
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
99
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
650
+ Increase D, 1st T = 6C
a Decrease D
•••• ^ —6'
600
A Increase D, 2nd • ^rW 3
550
450 • • A AAA
400
„ 350
2A A
10
Q.
A6 k
(0 300 AD
•
A
250 •
200
150 +
100
50
•+-
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
100
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
650
• Increase D, 1st T = 11 C
• Decrease D ,fio n
600
A Increase D, 2nd
A
•o
A A
A A
A
550 AA
A A
A A A A
D A A A " A-A-AA-
A
D nO A A
D
A A
500 A A A
•
450 •• •
_D2 a A
8A
0°
O A
0
400
•a
• A
A A
350 AD
CO
(0
300
250 4-
200
150
100 4-
50
+
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
101
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
650
• Increase D, 1st
• Decrease D
600 A Increase D, 2nd
• • •
550 A* U
•A A •
¥
*Aa = D
• A A A A A AA A
500 A A
D dO A A ^ A A
A
A
HO
A A^
450 +
A A A
H D
400
A "
A °
350
(0
0.
(0
300
250 +
200 +
150
100
50
+ +
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
102
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
500
400
••••
350 •
• •
A A
A
300 nrf 3
A A A
A A
n 0 0
AA A A A
A A A
A A A
co
D D D A A A A
A
<L 250 D A A A
A
W CP
• " A A
° A A
200
A° A
AA&V
•
150 4-
100
50
04 H h
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
103
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
rheogram and the second ISR rheogram became relatively smooth and
monotonic. These rheograms show that shear stress did not vary linearly with
Moreover, a yield stress [shear stress at zero shear rate, or the shear stress
required for the material to flow (Tung, 1989)] was observed. This yield stress
increased with increasing temperature (for T < 21 °C). For all the
temperatures and for shear rates lower than 220 s" , the DSR rheograms and
1
11°C and above and for shear rates higher than 220 s' , the shear stress
1
values of the second ISR rheograms became considerably lower than those of
the DSR rheograms. This hysteresis could be due to the loss of structure of
the paste that could occur at higher temperatures and especially after
shearing at higher rates for more than 25 minutes. It can be deduced that this
surimi paste behaved as a shear thinning fluid with a yield stress. The
existence of hysteresis despite the low ramp speed (40 s" / min) that was
1
used to increase and decrease the shear rate, demonstrates that the paste
Park et al. (1994) found that the viscosity of a Pacific whiting surimi paste
started to increase after 20 hours of incubation at 25°C, and did not increase
104
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
studied. (The surimi concentration of the paste used in this project is 83% by
weight.)
The DSR rheograms for the five temperatures used are shown in Figure 21
while the second ISR rheograms are depicted in Figure 22. Both of these
figures demonstrate that for the same shear rate, provided D < 200 s" , shear
1
could be less thermally stable than actomyosin from species living in warmer
waters. This increase of shear stress with temperature differs from the results
high concentration of surimi used in this study. Shear stress values at 26°C
were the lowest. This is possibly due to the fact that the paste started to gel
and the shear stress readings could have been influenced by slippage or by
the rupture of gel structure near the cup wall. It was attempted to run the
experiment at 31 °C but the spindle could not rotate because the required
torque was above the operating range for the rheometer. The gelling effect
on the sample was apparent when it was taken from the cup.
105
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
650
600 mA—A
A
A
W wXX*
MT~ •
.A A wX* •
Decreasing D
A A
**
550
500 X**
***A N
•P ••••
w * A A A
A
no 0
450 4- X* A A •
X* A
•
X A A • •
AA
400 X A
A
A D
A •
350
co
CL x
*A
A n °o • •••
CO
300 | A •
250 4- •
• T= 1 C
•
•
•••
200 - • T= 6C
• AT=
XT =
11 C
21 C
150 - -
• • T = 26 C
100 4-
50 4-
0 4 + +
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
106
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
600
550 Increasing D
*XX * A A A
A A
A * A A £ : W a
* *°T
***X X A A A
x »H »rV
B
8 D
*\
500
X X A A A A
A BpD • # j;
w X . .A • • ^ • %
x x* *
• ° * •••••• * \
X A A
¥
450 4- x x> A
0*. •
AA
XX .A ••• ** D W
400 A • »
X AA D D ™ / •
X A A
350 A • • • *
A D D
ra
£L 300
••••
co • • ••••
•
250 +
•
200 • T = 1 C
• T = 6C
A T = 11 C
150 + X T = 21 C
• T = 26 C
100 4-
50 +
+ -+• +
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
107
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
Since the first ISR rheograms were affected by the time dependency of the
paste, only the yield stress values were calculated for these curves. The
Theological data for the DSR rheograms and the second ISR rheograms were
only half of the results are shown, all the Theological data including the
replicate results were used in the curve fitting.) These models were explained
by Bourne (1982). The appropriate model should represent the flow behavior
of the fluid over the shear rate range to which the fluid will be subjected
also accurately fit the experimental data. The following is a brief description
of the two models which were found to best represent the data.
This model is also called the power-law plastic model. It is different from the
suitable for fluids having a yield stress. The equation of this model is:
S = S + KD
0
n
108
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
n is the flow behavior index and S is the yield stress. The parameters of this
0
squares method.
Casson model:
This model was originally developed to simulate the flow of printing inks
(Bourne, 1982). It is appropriate for some foods with a yield stress, such as
tomato catsup and molten chocolate (Bourne, 1982). The equation for this
model is:
S 05
= So 05
+ (Kc D ) 05
first plotting the square root of shear stress against the square root of shear
rate and then finding the equation of the straight line which provides the best
Table 19 shows the curve fitting results of the second ISR rheograms. The
data were well fitted by both models (R > 0.94). The values of n, the flow
2
behavior index in the HB model, were close to 0.5. For both models, yield
109
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
HB model T[C] R 2
So K n Note
110
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
stress values increased with temperature up to 21 °C. The yield stress values
These trends were also observed for the curve fitting results of the DSR
rheograms (Table 20). These rheograms were also very well fitted by the HB
model and by the Casson model (R > 0.96). The curve fitting results of the
2
DSR rheograms were slightly better than those of the second ISR rheograms.
Figures 23 to 27 show the DSR rheograms along with the predictions of the
fitted models for the five temperatures used. The curve fitting results obtained
with the HB model demonstrate the existence of a yield stress that increased
with temperature up to 21 °C. The yield stress values of the second ISR
The yield stress values, S 0 [Pa], predicted by the HB model for various
So = C Ty
m
where C and m are the equation parameters, and T < 21 °C. A logarithmic
y
111
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
HB model T[C] R 2
So K n
112
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
150 4-
100 4-
50 4-
0 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
113
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
114
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
700
650
• Deacrease D T= 11 C
H.B. model
Casson model
600
550
500
450 +
400
n
SL 350
(0
300 | D
250
200 4/
150
100
50
— i —
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
115
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
• Decrease D T = 21 C
H.B. model
Casson model
450 +
400 +
200 +
150 4-
•+-
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
116
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
50 4-
0 -I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
117
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
The results obtained by fitting the above logarithmic equation to the S values 0
predicted by the HB model for both the second ISR and the DSR rheograms
are listed in Table 21. The fit was good for both the second ISR and the DSR
However, for the pumping of surimi paste, the yield stress value that must be
overcome at the beginning of the process is the yield stress determined at the
first increasing shear rate rheogram. Table 22 lists these yield stress values
for different temperatures. These were the recorded shear stress values
value was observed at 26°C. Moreover, for each temperature the initial
yield stress was much higher than that of the DSR rheograms and the second
ISR rheograms.
The Herschel-Bulkley and Casson models depend only on the shear rate.
118
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
Rheograms Cy m R 2
119
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
Table 22. Yield stress values from the first ISR rheograms
(°C) (Pa)
1 371
6 462
11 457
21 522
26 329
120
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
C is a constant.
T
A new model, taking into consideration both the shear rate effect and the
S =eD + gT f h
where S is the shear stress in Pa, T is the temperature in °C, D is the shear
equation derives from the fact that only the yield stress appears, in most
most fluids decreases with temperature (Streeter and Wylie, 1985). The
For temperatures ranging from 1 to 21°C, the DSR rheograms and the second
ISR rheograms were fitted by the above 'shear and temperature (ST) model"
Table 23 summarizes the curve fitting results. The model parameters show
121
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
Rheograms e f g h R
122
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
that shear stress increases with increasing temperature and shear rate.
fitted ST model. The second ISR rheograms along with the predictions of the
ST model are depicted in Figure 29. Curve fitting by the ST model was better
for the DSR rheograms (R > 0.96). The curve fitting was also better for shear
2
rates from 0 to 200 s" . The time dependency of the paste was mainly present
1
for typical residence times of the paste as it is pumped between the mixing
123
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
150 4-
100 4-
50 4-
0 -1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
D [1/s]
124
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
600
D [1/s]
Figure 29. Second ISR rheograms and the predictions of the ST model
125
C h a p t e r 5. S u r i m i v i s c o u s properties
5.4 Conclusions
whey protein concentrate and wheat starch were studied using a rotational
thinning fluid with a yield stress. For the same shear rate, shear stress
protein interactions that were facilitated by grinding the surimi with salt. The
yield stress values also increased with temperature up to 21 °C. The DSR
rheograms and the second ISR rheograms, after surimi had undergone shear
for sufficient time, were well fitted by the Herschel-Bulkley model and by the
Casson model.
A new model taking into account the shear rate effect and the temperature
effect has been developed. For temperatures up to 21 °C, the DSR rheograms
and the second ISR rheograms were well fitted by this new model. Predicted
Finally, it is important to mention that the paste used in this study was similar
the paste was not first diluted with water as in most previous Theological
126
Chapter 5. Surimi viscous properties
engineering design of the equipment needed for the pumping and extruding
operations that immediately follow the mixing process. However, the results
obtained here apply only for a salmon surimi paste having a specific
surimi pastes.
127
Chapter 6. Conclusions and future work
Chapter 6
6.1 Conclusions
grinding with salt as well as setting and cooking on the protein structure of
raw surimi, surimi paste and surimi gels. The disulfide bond stretching
intensity increased slightly after setting and greatly after cooking at higher
temperature. These results explain the importance of the disulfide bonds and
the stages at which they occur. Secondary structure analysis showed that
place. Studies of gel properties also showed that cooking, whether preceded
by setting or not, resulted in a better surimi gel texture than the setting
128
Chapter 6. Conclusions and future work
cooking resulted in a higher disulfide peak intensity and in stronger and more
at 80°C and above resulted in surimi gels with the best gel texture
individually maximized gel strength, fold score and color, and minimized
concentrate and wheat starch has been developed. The final product,
kamaboko sausage, had gel strength and fold score values close to those of a
to roe herring surimi. Freezing roe herring at around -45°C maintained the gel
making ability for up to seventy days. Freezing at -83°C preserved the gel
making ability for a longer period of time. However, this temperature is too
low to be used by the industry. Using male herring for surimi-based products
129
Chapter 6. Conclusions and future work
made from the formulation optimized in Chapter 4 and containing pink salmon
surimi, salt, whey protein concentrate and wheat starch. This paste had a
viscosity and yield stress increased with temperature up to 21 °C. This could
temperature. A new model taking into consideration the effects of shear rate
could also be used to assess the changes of protein structure caused by the
More work needs to be done in order to commercialize the use of herring, pink
130
Chapter 6. Conclusions and future work
The viscous properties of raw surimi and of surimi paste should be studied
could handle very viscous materials and hence could allow higher incubation
temperatures.
131
Nomenclature
Nomenclature
a redness index
b yellowness index
C whiteness index
Ei expressible liquid, %
F s fold score
132
Nomenclature
P Likelihood function
Pc contracted vertex
PE expanded vertex
P* reflected vertex
R 2
regression coefficient
S shear stress, Pa
So yield stress, Pa
T temperature, °C
setting temperature, °C
x 2
setting time, min.
X3 cooking temperature, °C
Wj weighting coefficient
133
Nomenclature
WS wheat starch, %
Z multiobjective function
134
Nomenclature
Greek letters
a reflection coefficient
0 contraction coefficient
Y expansion coefficient
a standard deviation
viscosity, Pa.s
® convolution
135
Bibliography
Bibliography
136
Bibliography
137
Bibliography
Hastings, R. J.; Currall, J. E. P. Effects of water, oil, egg white and starch on
the texture of cod surimi gels by response surface methodology. J.
Text. Stud. 1989, 19, 431-451.
Itoh, Y.; Yoshinaka, R.; Ikeda, S. Behaviour of the sulfhydryl groups of carp
actomyosin by heating. Bull. Jap. Soc. Sci. Fish. 1979, 45, 1019-
1022.
Kannan, K. K.; Nostrand, B.; Fridborg, K.; Lovgren, S.; Oilsson, A.; Petef, M.
Crystal structure of human erythrocyte carbonic anhydrase B. Three
dimensional structure at a nominal 2.2-A resolution. Proc. Nat. Acad.
Sci. 1975, 51. Quoted by Tu (1982).
138
Bibliography
Lee, H. G.; Lee, C. M.; Chung, K. H.; Lavery, S. A. Sodium ascorbate affects
surimi gel-forming properties. J. Food Sci. 1992a, 57, 1343-1347.
Luu, C ; Luu, D. V.; Rull, F.; Sopron, F. Etude par effet Raman de la
perturbation structurale de I'eau liquide par une substance etrangere.
J. Mol. Struct. 1982, 81, 1-10.
139
Bibliography
Morrissey, M. T.; Wu, J. W.; Lin, D.; An, H. Protease inhibitor effects on
torsion measurements and autolysis of Pacific whiting surimi. J. Food
Sci. 1993, 58, 1050-1054.
Nakayama, T.; Niwa, E.; Hamada, I.; Shin, C. Viscosity changes in carp
actomyosin solutions. J. Food Sci. 1979, 44, 1106-1109.
140
Bibliography
Pigott, G. M. The high tech"raw materials from minced fish flesh. Food Rev.
Int. 1986, 2, 213-246.
Scott, D. N.; Porter, R. W.; Kudo, G.; Miller, R.; Koury, B. Effect of freezing
and frozen storage of Alaska pollock on the chemical and gel-forming
properties of surimi. J. Food Sci. 1988, 53, 353-358.
141
Bibliography
Toyoda, K.; Kimura, I.; Fujita, T.; Noguchi, S. F.; Lee, C. M. 1992. The surimi
manufacturing process. In Surimi Technology, T. C. Lanier and C. M.
Lee, Ed.; Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, N. Y., 1992; pp 79-112.
Tung, A. T.; Speers, R. A.; Britt, I. J.; Owen, S. R.; Wilson, L. L. Yield stress
characterization of structured foods. In Engineering and Food, v.1, W.
E. L. Spiess and H. Schubert, Ed.; Elsevier Applied Science, New
York, N. Y , 1989; pp 79-88.
142
Bibliography
Yongsawatdigul, J.; Park, J. W.; Kolbe, E.; Abu Dagga, Y.; Morrissey, M. T.
Ohmic heating maximizes gel functionality of Pacific whiting surimi. J
Food Sci. 1995, 60, 10-14.
143