Title: Mastering the Art of Crafting a Literature Review for Software Sustainability Measures

In the realm of academia and research, literature reviews serve as the cornerstone of scholarly
inquiry, providing a comprehensive overview of existing knowledge and insights in a particular field.
When it comes to delving into the realm of software sustainability measures, the task of compiling a
systematic literature review can be both daunting and intricate. It requires meticulous attention to
detail, extensive research, and adept analytical skills to synthesize diverse perspectives and findings
into a cohesive narrative.

Embarking on the journey of crafting a literature review for software sustainability measures entails
navigating through a vast sea of scholarly articles, research papers, conference proceedings, and
other academic sources. Each piece of literature offers unique insights, methodologies, and findings,
adding layers of complexity to the review process. Furthermore, the evolving nature of technology
and sustainability discourse demands staying abreast of the latest developments and emerging trends
in the field.

One of the primary challenges encountered in writing a literature review for software sustainability
measures is the sheer volume of available literature. Sorting through an extensive array of sources
requires a discerning eye to identify seminal works, key themes, and relevant methodologies.
Moreover, synthesizing diverse perspectives and reconciling conflicting findings necessitates critical
thinking and analytical prowess.

Another hurdle faced by researchers is ensuring the rigor and comprehensiveness of the literature
review. This entails establishing clear inclusion and exclusion criteria, conducting systematic searches
across multiple databases, and rigorously assessing the quality and relevance of selected studies.
Additionally, synthesizing findings from disparate sources while maintaining coherence and
objectivity requires adept organizational skills and attention to detail.

In light of these challenges, seeking professional assistance from reputable academic writing services
can prove invaluable. ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔ offers expert guidance and support in crafting literature
reviews for software sustainability measures. With a team of experienced researchers and writers, we
are committed to delivering high-quality, meticulously crafted literature reviews tailored to your
specific requirements.

By entrusting your literature review needs to ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔, you can rest assured that your
work will be handled with the utmost professionalism and expertise. Our dedicated team will work
tirelessly to ensure that your literature review meets the highest standards of academic excellence,
positioning you for success in your research endeavors.

In conclusion, writing a literature review for software sustainability measures is a complex and
challenging task that requires careful planning, diligent research, and adept analytical skills. By
leveraging the expertise of ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔, you can streamline the process and ensure the
quality and rigor of your literature review. Take the first step towards mastering the art of scholarly
inquiry and order your literature review today.
Sustainability aims to tackle epidemic issues, such as environmental waste, economic inefficiencies,
and potential health and safety threats to humans and living things that could occur as a function of
the activities of product and service systems (PSSs). However, traceability is based on strong
connections between different SC partners, which perform processes that affect the ownership,
physical movement, position, or condition of traceable units (external traceability events). However,
a well-established, systematic and methodical literature review would better serve its purpose to gain
a more detailed knowledge on the current state-of-the-art. In particular, Figure 2 shows a year-by-
year analysis of the selected papers. Narrative synthesis focuses on how studies addressing a
different aspect of the same phenomenon can be narratively summarised and built up to provide a
bigger picture of that phenomenon. This temporal perspective suggests embracing a strategic focus to
study Industry 4.0. In any case, it is clear that for the authors, attention to Industry 4.0’s external
context and its implications, is very relevant. More information on different sub-types of the method
can be found in (3). These improvements are explained in the analysis report, which also highlights
which dimensions, themes and objectives are impacted. If an agreement is not possible, minority
opinions must be noted and justified for further sensitivity analysis. Values of 1, 2 and 3 are used to
qualify the significance of a given PSPP objective: (1) Desirable objective: Achieving this objective is
deemed unimportant, or it has low value to fulfill identified needs; (2) Important objective:
Achieving this objective is deemed important but is not directly associated with identified needs
regarding the PSPP; and (3) Essential objective: Achieving this objective is deemed essential and will
contribute directly to the satisfaction of identified needs. This perspective often originates from the
school of thought, vocation or ideological standpoint in which the reviewer is located. E-VSM had
strong emphasis on environmental performance with partial focus on the economic pillar. In addition,
in a global marketplace where counterfeiting and recalls are on the rise, modernised manufacturing
regulations are more important than ever to improve value chain traceability. A Systematic Literature
Review of Blockchain-Enabled Supply Chain Traceability Implementations. Figure 11 compares the
SDC’s and MAPT’s overall assessment. For a blockchain’s components to be deemed trustworthy,
testers need to verify that they all function correctly and interact with the blockchain in a
trustworthy manner. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health (IJERPH).
The analysts also suggested improvements for each objective to complete the evaluation ( Figure 7 ).
Using the SDAG allows for a complete interpretation of the results, including looking at the
equilibrium between the dimensions and the themes, prioritizing the objectives to be improved as
well as a mechanism to prioritize the steps to be implemented and a brief feasibility report. Subscribe
to receive issue release notifications and newsletters from MDPI journals. A combination of all
manufacturing industry-related articles (including the automotive industry) accounted for almost
50% of papers, while combination of service and education sectors drew limited attention from
researchers. It can also be linked to a program such as the “Plan Nord” in Quebec—aiming to
develop the Northern areas—a Climate change mitigation strategy and to a policy such as Quebec’s
“Loi sur le developpement durable”—Quebec SD law. In this paper, we present an overview of
modern frequent pattern mining techniques using data mining algorithms. Frequent pattern mining in
data mining takes a lot of data base scans. The authors use the Ethereum blockchain platform in
conjunction with the InterPlanetary File System (IPFS) (, accessed on 10 December 2021)
decentralised storage to create a reliable, traceable, transparent, and auditable solution for the
forward and waste management of COVID-19 medical equipment. Sustainability relates to multiple
objectives pertaining to various dimensions. A Systematic Literature Review for Better
Understanding of Lean Driven Sustainability. The framework consisted of various KPIs for TBL
dimensions with assigned weights to construct benchmarking matrix. For each principle, theme and
objective, explanations, justifications and examples are available directly in the file for ease of use
(accessed by a commentary window in each cell) ( Figure 3 ). 2.2. Assessment Methodology
Sustainability being normative and dynamic, the SDAG should above all be considered as an asset
in a continuous improvement process. The system allows inspection entities to check food quality
before uploading traceability-related information on the blockchain. Selected results from the study
illustrate the tool potential and will be presented as material for discussion. 3. Results This section
presents selected results to support further discussion on sustainability assessment with the SDAG
based on the case study of the Apatite Arnaud mine in Sept-Iles (QC, Canada).
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research (JTAER). The application of the
framework will provide benefits as part of a whole-institution approach (that targets education,
research, operations, administration, community relationships) in formal education settings (e.g.,
Higher Education institutions, primary and secondary schools, educator training organisations),
where the learning and training environments are aligned to the sustainability vision, and where
institutional changes are taking place to facilitate the sustainability transformation. A Systematic
Literature Review for Better Understanding of Lean Driven Sustainability. Previous Article in
Special Issue Overcoming Catch Data Collection Challenges and Traceability Implementation
Barriers in a Sustainable, Small-Scale Fishery. For example, a project such as Mine Arnaud assessed
with the SDAG can be followed through future evaluations and implementations over time. Issued
from a qualitative method, they have no “scientific” or “absolute” value, but significance is based on
inter-subjectivity. Application of these criteria, in addition to removing duplicate articles, reduced the
number of papers for analysis to 68. These data are also confirmed by the distribution of the authors
not only on the basis of their geographical origin, but also in relation to the position taken in the
paper. There is a cost incurred for smart contract deployment, function calls in the smart contract,
and each transaction initiated by the smart contract. Journal of Experimental and Theoretical
Analyses (JETA). They found that JIT delivery is superior to traditional methods during the
construction of high-rise condominiums in Korea, although the fabrication of rebar at a JIT-
implemented plant was initially expected to generate slightly more material scrap than the one with
batch production. Section 3 displays the descriptive results of the SLR, divided into publication year,
journal, and article topics, after which Section 4 gives an overview of the thematic results.
Evaluation of the five Dimensions for the Mine Arnaud project by the Sustainable Development
Assessment Committee (SDC). Articles belonging to LM-LSCM-sustainability category accounted
for only 8.60% of total number of articles included in the study. Journal of Otorhinolaryngology,
Hearing and Balance Medicine (JOHBM). International Journal of Translational Medicine (IJTM).
This approach avoids the pitfalls of unnatural comparison or rating in the absolute. Start with three
to five IRIS metrics as your core impact or sustainanbility measurement KPIs, then grow and assess
from there. This perspective often originates from the school of thought, vocation or ideological
standpoint in which the reviewer is located. Note that from the first issue of 2016, this journal uses
article numbers instead of page numbers. Comparison of the different features extracted from the
generic supply chain literature. Similar to SASB, GRI Standards are designed for large global
organizations. IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards The IFRS Sustainability Disclosure
Standards come from the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB), a new working group
within the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) Foundation. Villeneuve, C.; Tremblay,
D.; Riffon, O.; Lanmafankpotin, G.Y.; Bouchard, S. On-boarding and maintenance expenses are also
significant. Concerning the sustainability perspective, most of the selected literature fails to identify
specific economic, environmental, and social objectives fulfilled by the proposed blockchain-related
SC traceability solutions. Search results were filtered to cover articles from 1990 to February 2018,
since 1990 is the year when lean philosophy was introduced to the Western world. From the
perspective of a firm, there are a number of drivers that could motivate and reward the
implementation of practices associated to circularity. The proposed system collects and processes
inventory data in real-time while safeguarding the security and redundancy of the available data.
Traceability systems provide the means for SC networks to meet regulatory requirements, connect
with and understand the various actors upstream in the SC, inform consumers about the provenance
and origin of products, enhance consumer confidence, and meet customer requirements.
The authors concluded that social sustainability was among the limitations of the proposed
framework, while observing that waste elimination, supply chain risk management, and cleaner
production practices had a significant impact on all pillars of TBL within the context of SCM. Of
course, the selected literature may still be biased and heavily depends on the research and selection
criteria, but if this process is properly reasoned and documented, the bias may be reduced compared
to a non-systematic review. The latter refers to issues with interdisciplinarity, bureaucracy,
competition, lack of collaboration and incentives to cooperate, overcrowded curriculum, and
academic silos. This tool and process is part of the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals
Acceleration Toolkit; it is one of the most adaptable, addresses all 17 SDGs and is fully accessible
for free. Ratings are first order indicators of the performance of PSPPs regarding dimensions or
themes. Therefore, it is becoming more difficult to trace every step of a product’s journey back to its
production source. Blockchain is still in its infancy, and its penetration is limited in many sectors.
Interoperability across blockchain networks is essential because it allows data and value to be
exchanged smoothly. Dasaklis, Thomas K., Theodore G. Voutsinas, Giannis T. However, are the
tools aforementioned able to address the complexity of a systemic representation of sustainability.
However, Systematic Literature Reviews were long viewed as second-class studies within Academia,
since they did not yield primary data. In an educational environment, this process could be used to
relate educational outcomes to the enabling conditions for the localised vision of sustainability to
emerge. Such actions have triggered increased interest by researchers and professionals in discoveries
related to synergies, divergences, and two-way permeability between these concepts. In all three
streams, a high majority of publications were based in Europe and yielded a total number of 195
studies, which was followed by the US and Asia with 96 and 95 articles, respectively. Investors,
customers, and governments are all looking for products and processes that are more environmentally
friendly, and certifications that back up these claims are becoming increasingly common. The PSPP
can be revisited periodically as needed, e.g., an organization could decide to make its assessment
every three to five years. As decisions are generally made on short term perceived issues in order to
satisfy political agendas or quarterly results, long term issues and complexity have a limited
influence on everyday management. Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Analyses (JETA). It
provides real-time communication and thus, problems could be instantaneously resolved before the
issues passed on to further processes, which is highly associated with less material and energy use,
as well as environmental waste and hazard. In fact, Scholar is a search engine and not a database, so
it does not allow precise identification and selection of research characteristics. Therefore, it was able
to offer a partial benchmarking perspective with the GPI. The authors concluded that while
integration of economic and environmental impact assessment of manufacturing and logistics
operations is feasible, it is very complex due to the interactions among different dimensions of
sustainability. Such firms seek not just to have a visible sustainability platform, but they apply
sustainability to change and positively benefit their stakeholders, industry and communities.” Issues
brought up by authors could be pointing out to the necessity for re-tailoring the current performance
measures to ensure intra- and inter-sectoral comparability and benchmarking of TBL performance
among all organizations and supply chains. The model intrinsically leaned towards keeping
continuous track of material and energy usage, as well as carbon emissions and waste generation
associated with consumption rates. The SDC committee, based on the SDAG analysis, assessed that
the Mine Arnaud project should not be implemented as such, without considering some important
improvements. The data collection step helps to determine the assessment committee composition, to
identify analysts or to select experts for the evaluation. An assessment is an iterative process and
analysts, with the Committee, are free to make adjustments throughout. Many companies have
already adopted lean, while others are still in a discovery phase. In addition, results also indicate that
potential of LSCM-sustainability stream and importance of spreading Lean and Sustainable practices
along the entire supply chain were discovered by scientists and increased its popularity in this
decade, as can be seen in Figure 3. Ex-post evaluations allow validating the overall direction of the
development resulting from the implementation of the PSPP.
Some of these proposed frameworks had macro-level metrics, while others focused on shop-floor-
level activities. These tools were evaluated based on three criteria namely, holistic sustainability
(TBL) strength, sustainability benchmarking capability, and the involvement of lean tools. Current
literature lacks a systematic way to evaluate the sustainability perspective of their solutions, as
authors mainly focus on the performance of the technology. Contribution of lean and six-sigma tools
to environmental and social performance were also discussed to identify the TBL effectiveness of
these paradigms. The need for sustainability performance assessment systems, frameworks and
models were emphasized along with some limited focus on application of frameworks in SMEs and
service industry. The system allows the actors to verify that good hygiene practices are followed,
essential for maintaining a sanitary environment to meet the Hazard Analysis and Critical Control
Point (HACCP) requirements. However, shortcomings too were identified, such as the non-
integration of particular fields and biological areas as requested by some stakeholders. We are quite
sure sustainability is related to quality We need to define, formally, sustainability (similarly to quality
definition). This indicates that the importance of compliance to existing regulations, as well as public
involvement in the control processes and planning of the mine over its lifespan, are regarded as a
minimum requirement by stakeholders. Several authors proposed food SC traceability solutions for
specific products. Finally, for many authors, cost-benefit analysis was applied as security analysis
(mostly informal security analysis). Currently, a majority of the existing literature is being dominated
by theoretical papers that are followed by empirical studies with multi-sectoral focus. It also allows
comparison between weights and evaluation and helps to identify differences and similarities.
Unnecessary Motion Human motions that are unnecessary or straining, carrying work in process
(WIP) long distances, transport More energy use for transport. Being 'systematic' means being
reproducible and goes along with an a priori specified, dedicated research design and an explicit
documentation of the steps taken during the research (3, see Normativity). Contemporary SCs are
organically diverse, with multi-echelon, geographically dispersed companies that struggle to service
clients. Articles studying automotive sector led others in terms of intra- or inter-organizational focus
with 45 and 16 articles, respectively. For the dialog to be productive, the analysts must be trusting,
open-minded, practice active listening and should benefit from an adequate accompaniment. To be
admitted as actual or projected action, it needs to be defined in a written description or results from
a commitment from a qualified authority. All articles published by MDPI are made immediately
available worldwide under an open access license. No special. Suppliers, third-party logistics
providers, distributors, and manufacturers who participate in a SC network will be responsible for
the cost of hosting a node (energy spent) inside a blockchain consortium. Another shortcoming of
some frameworks was the lack of a clear definition of a deployment plan. The two weakest themes
are “Individuals integration” with 39% and “Freedom and responsibilities” with 40%. As seen in the
reviewed literature, most of the works provided performance indicators of their proposals (e.g.,
executing tests to measure the latency of their transactions to provide scalable solutions and the cost
of the different smart contract operations). Many reviews consists a combination of information on
the specific topic, the conceptual foundation, methodological approaches, and relevant scales that
are associated to the available literature. Complex operational processes and interest-conflicting
participants exist in real life SC scenarios. International Journal of Turbomachinery, Propulsion and
Power (IJTPP). It is also possible, in the ecological dimension, to underline priority objectives “Act”
and “React”. Visual Factory refers to use of signs, indicators, displays and controls coded to
convenience of visual perspective to promote effective communication of information. However,
how to calculate and document sustainability performance of supply chains remained unexplained
throughout the studies. However, within the scope of this study, the term “sustainability” is used to
comprehend all three pillars.
Measuring the ESD relevance of teacher training programmes in Germany, results demonstrated that
student competences can be measured in a reliable way. The only difference between the preferred
methods, by which competencies are created, is the level of the target staff in organizational
hierarchy. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare no conflict of interest. Evaluation of the five
Dimensions for the Mine Arnaud project by the Sustainable Development Assessment Committee
(SDC). In this paper, we have presented a systematic literature review of the available blockchain-
enabled SC traceability implementations. However, Systematic Literature Reviews were long viewed
as second-class studies within Academia, since they did not yield primary data. SC management is
considered a critical inter-organizational mechanism for creating a competitive advantage,
particularly in the context of supplier and consumer alliances and networks. Sustainable
Development Goals Acceleration Toolkit. Being 'systematic' means being reproducible and goes
along with an a priori specified, dedicated research design and an explicit documentation of the steps
taken during the research (3, see Normativity). Obviously, these perfect predispositions are not
always attainable without a trained moderator. Finally, a weak social sustainability component of the
proposed frameworks was observed for some of the concepts, which is a clear sign of a lack of a
holistic TBL perspective. International Journal of Translational Medicine (IJTM). Traceability systems
can reduce the size of a recall from millions to just a few hundred units. These categories were
supported by classification groups of geographical contexts, target industry segment, publication
year and database origin. However, our overall approach presents some limitations worth noting. To
deepen the sustainability assessment, more steps must be performed after the analysis process.
Transition management for sustainable development: A prescriptive, complexity-based governance
framework. Priorities must be set, as every weighted and evaluated objective in the assessment
process will justify actions to be implemented in a world with limited resources. According to the
outcomes of a case study conducted in an ISO 9000 certified facility, ErgoVSM was effective at
identification of space, workforce capacity, productivity, work-in-process, and mental work load
inefficiencies. Further developing green product preferences and long-time horizons in business and
consumer culture will therefore be a major challenge if firms and SCs are to move towards CSCs and
business models that integrate the other identified SCs configurations. 6. Conclusions This paper has
systematically reviewed the body of CE literature to identify common ground in CE definitions and
understandings, and scrutinize the implementation of the concept in the form of its three SC
configurations. LM-sustainability topic received, and is expected to continue to receive more
attention from researchers. For example, for the Governance dimension, 95% of the objectives were
weighted to “3” (Essential) as compared to 59% in the Ethical dimension. Theme’s evaluation (
Figure 9 ) also allows underlining particular strengths and weaknesses in each dimension. The
relationship of sustainability with lean manufacturing and lean supply chain management varied
significantly from one region to another, as can be observed in Figure 4. The difficulties surrounding
smart contracts, such as usage, deployment, and enforcement, are significant. Note that from the first
issue of 2016, this journal uses article numbers instead of page numbers. Systemic Sustainability
Assessment is part of ongoing research by the Eco-Advising Chair at UQAC in partnership with the
OIF and numerous users in industrial, state and municipal agencies. Sustainability relates to multiple
objectives pertaining to various dimensions. Gout, Urate, and Crystal Deposition Disease (GUCDD).
In one study, the value uncaptured concept was developed and tested in six case studies to ensure
validity of concept, whereas, in the next study, the concept was turned into a sustainable value
analysis tool that would aid organizations with identification of value uncaptured along the life cycle
of a product.