Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Western Region PS 24 15817 Rev 3
Western Region PS 24 15817 Rev 3
Western Region PS 24 15817 Rev 3
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
6.5 Main Switchboard and Control Panels 14
6.6 Power Cabling 15
6.7 Fire Alarm System 15
6.8 Station Lighting 16
6.9 Crane System 16
6.10 Items for Further Investigation 16
8. Recommendations 18
Figure Index
Figure 1 Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3
Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3 3
Figure 2 Pump Room Building 5
Figure 3 Pump Setup 7
Figure 4 Measurement Point Locations 8
Figure 5 Vibration at Location 2 on Pump 2 9
Figure 6 Acoustic Spectrum from Pump 1 10
Figure 7 Water Storage Tank 10
Figure 8 Pump Floor Layout 11
Figure 9 Mimic Panel Grain Al Ayeseh 13
Figure 10 Transformer Location 13
Figure 11 MSB - Right Hand End 14
Figure 12 Cable Way beneath MSB 15
Figure 13 Cable Rise to Motor 15
Figure 14 Fire Alarm Panel 16
Figure 15 Mimic Panel 16
Appendices
A Pump Station Schematic
B Site Safety Assessment
C Civil and Infrastructure Assets
D Mechanical Assets
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
E Electrical Assets
F Pumps and Motors – Temperature, Noise, Vibration and Alignment
G Water Storage Tanks
H OEM vs Pump Performance
I Thermographic Images
J Vibration Spectrum
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
1. Introduction
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
1.5 ADDC Supplied Information
Not all information to conduct the full scope of the pumping station survey was available from ADDC or
from GHD’s research of equipment suppliers and their websites.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
2. Pump Station Overview
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
3. Pump Station Assessments
Water Pumps;
Pump Room Overhead Cranes;
Pump Room, Switchboard and Control Room Air Conditioning; and
Pump Room Ventilation.
GHD’s condition assessment schedules for mechanical assets is attached as Appendix D
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
main switchboard and pump control panels;
power cabling;
room and exterior lighting; and
fire alarm systems.
GHD’s condition assessment schedules for electrical assets are attached as Appendix E
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
3.7 Concrete Water Storage Tanks Condition Assessment
GHD’s site team conducted a visual inspection of the concrete storage tank, both internal and external.
The inspection was carried out in accordance with GHD’s “Procedure for Structural Inspection of
Concrete Water Tanks” as attached in Appendix G.
The inspection aims to identify and record defects such as:
Cracks;
Leaks;
Honeycombed or drummy concrete;
Excessive or abnormal deflection;
Ground settlement;
Internal lining failure; and
External protective coating failure (if there is an external coating).
GHD’s condition assessment schedules for concrete water storage tanks are attached in Appendix G.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
4. Civil and Infrastructure Assessment
Storage Tank
Round concrete storage tank, 5 Ml capacity.
Tank level indicator is not working on the mimic (does not correspond to the mechanical indicator).
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
5. Mechanical Assets Assessment
5.2 Vibration
Vibration measurements were taken from the points shown on Figure 4 below. Individual measured
levels are shown in the enclosed inspection schedule. OEM levels were not available for correlation. All
measured velocity levels were below the accepted maximum level of 2mm/sec expected for such pumps
and indicate the pumps to be in good mechanical condition.
Vibration velocity levels were recorded as narrow band FFT levels with the data graphed as below with
all the graphs presented in the Appendix to this report.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Figure 5 Vibration at Location 2 on Pump 2
The pumps and motors were well secured using have bases and concrete under the base. This quality
of mounting is reflected in eh low vibration levels.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Figure 6 Acoustic Spectrum from Pump 1
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
6. Electrical Assets Assessment
The station features a separate control room housing a full mimic and control panel.
The pumps and motors are located in a 2m well in the pumping room. Access is via individual ladders to
each pump location as the manifold and piping layout precludes access ‘pump to pump’
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
6.2 Motor Description and Condition
Manufacturer: Siemens
Rating: 34 kW @ 415V
Insulation Class F
Serial Numbers
Motor 1 2 3 4
Motor Condition
Local Controls An upstand adjacent to the motor provided Start/stop, Valve open/close,
emergency stop controls and pilot indications fro on/off/trip.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Figure 9 Mimic Panel Grain Al Ayeseh
While testing at a different station of this series a lock out condition was encountered when pumps could
not be started. There was no indication as to what condition was not satisfied or how to overcome the
situation. When available the operator adjusted pressure switch operating points and bled air from the
supply pipe. One of these actions restored function. This control action should be taken up with the
system designer and an indication provided of the lockout condition.
Station voltages are above the nominal setting. The transformer tapping should be adjusted to give the
correct voltage. It was noted that the gates to the transformer were not secured.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
6.5 Main Switchboard and Control Panels
The main switchboard features dual incoming supplies with a bus coupler. The board is mirror imaged
about the bus coupler; pump 1 & 2 MCC to the left and 3 &4 to the right. One supply is provisioned and
the unused supply isolated. The bus coupler is operated. The incoming breakers are rated at 1250A
and are marked as being adjusted to 800A. With a maximum load from all four pumps of approximately
250 amp and a typical running load of 125 amp the board is operating at approximately 10% of its rating.
The on board switched current meter does not read reliably below 160A and is therefore ineffective. The
supply transformer is rated at 666A and is therefore unprotected from long tern overload by the incoming
MCCB. However, as stated the connected load can’t provide this overload.
There is no earth – neutral link at the main switchboard. 380 E-N was measured. A conspicuous link
should be provided at the main switchboard.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
6.6 Power Cabling
Cable Tray
In good condition, firmly mounted, fully earth bonded. Within the pump room trays are above the floor
level and are two layer beneath the walk way. Cable trays are 3 layers beneath the main switchboard.
Cables are in good order although covered with dirt/dust and mud. Power supply cables for the motors
are steel wire armoured (SWA).
Cable Layout
Pump power cables acceptably laid out. Cables fully secured as they enter the pump room from the
control room with access holes foam filled. The rises to the individual motors are not completely secured
but as these cables are SWA there is not potential risk of major damage. Actual connection to the motor
terminal box is well done with protective boots and clear labels.
Cleanliness
Dried mud on the cables, trays and floor of the trench.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Figure 14 Fire Alarm Panel Figure 15 Mimic Panel
Pump Room
4 x Ceiling HID fittings. Fittings still have remains of plastic construction covers. Plastic to be removed.
Fittings are supplemented with wall mounted fluorescent fittings, most of which have emergency packs
fitted.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
7. Concrete Water Storage Tanks Assessment
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
8. Recommendations
Safety
1. PPE including hearing and eye protection should be provided to all operators.
2. Safety signs should be installed at the entrance to the station (and pump room). - Safety Shoes,
Hard Hat, Hearing Protection and Eye Protection).
3. Install locks or padlocks on tank access hatches.
4. Install dedicated air conditioning system into pump room. This system should be used by
maintenance personnel for service or repair works carried out during hot summer period.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix A
Pump Station Schematic
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix B
Site Safety Assessment
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
SITE SAFETY ASSESSMENT
Comments
It is recommended that proper safety signs should be installed at the entrance to the station (and pump room): Safety Shoes, Hard Hat, Hearing Protection, Eye
Protection.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix C
Civil and Infrastructure Assets
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Buildings & General Infrastructure
Pumping Station Name Grain Al Ayesh-3 Pump Station - Mirfa LEGEND - Asset Condition Assessment
Assessment Date 14 July 2009 Description Life Remains Rating
Time: IN / OUT "As New" 100% 1
GPS Position (Entry Gate) N 24° 4.025' E 53° 9.247' Good 75% 2
ADDC GIS Object No: 8453 Fair 50% 3
Poor 25% 4
Inspection Personnel Failure Imminent 0% 5
John John (GHD) Failed / Derelict Un-useable 6
Roger Hawkins (Palmer Acoustics)
Padalchai P.
Comments
NOTE: 'NA' or 'Blank' = Not Applicable or Data Not Available.
- No accommodation facilities and amenities for pump station operators within the compound.
- Office housed in control room, no dedicated office space available with necessary amenities and facilities.
- This pump station is otherwise in very good conditi
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Storage/ Transfer Water Tanks
Comments
NOTE: 'NA' or 'Blank' = Not Applicable or Data Not Available.
1) Painted storage tank walls make harder for earlier leaks detection
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Pipework & Valves (Suction Side)
Flexible Coupling
Flexible Coupling Diameter (mm) 150 150 150 150
Condition Rating (1 to 6) 2 2 2 2
Isolation Valve
ADDC GIS Object No: 302721 302724 302722 302723
Isolation Valve Type Butterfly Butterfly Butterfly Butterfly
Isolation Valve Diameter (mm) 150 150 150 150
Condition Rating (1 to 6) 2 2 2 2
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Pipework & Valves (Delivery Side)
Delivery Header Pipework Pipe 1
Pipe Material STEEL
Pipe Diameter (mm) 400
Condition Rating (1 to 6) 2
Flexible Coupling
Flexible Coupling Diameter (mm) 150 150 150 150
Delivery Side
Condition Rating (1 to 6) 2 2 2 2
Non-Return Valve
ADDC GIS Object No: Not shown Not shown Not shown Not shown
Isolation Valve Type Pump flow control Pump flow control Pump flow control Pump flow control
Isolation Valve Diameter (mm) 150 150 150 150
Condition Rating (1 to 6) 2 2 2 2
Isolation Valve
ADDC GIS Object No: 302725 302726 302727 302728
Isolation Valve Type Butterfly Butterfly Butterfly Butterfly
Isolation Valve Diameter (mm) 150 150 150 150
Condition Rating (1 to 6) 2 2 2 2
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix D
Mechanical Assets
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Pump and Motor Data
Pump Data Pump 1 Pump 2 Pump 3 Pump 4 Pump 5 Pump 6
ADDC GIS Object No: 4841 4842 4843 4844
Year of Installation 2003 2003 2003 2003
Supply to Shiekh Palace Supply to Shiekh Palace Supply to Shiekh Palace Supply to Shiekh Palace
Purpose / Function
& plantations. & plantations. & plantations. & plantations.
Brand KSB KSB KSB KSB
Type Horizontal Split Casing Horizontal Split Casing Horizontal Split Casing Horizontal Split Casing
Model No OMEGA-100-375A OMEGA-100-375A OMEGA-100-375A OMEGA-100-375A
Serial No 5-L-61-732 593/3 5-L-61-732 593/4 5-L-61-732 590/2 5-L-61-732 590/1
Impeller Design Size (mm) unknown unknown unknown unknown
Speed (rpm) 1479 1479 1479 1479
Pumping Design Power (kW) unknown unknown unknown unknown
Pump Design Efficiency (%) unknown unknown unknown unknown
Duty Point Flow (l/s) 50 50 50 50
NPSHR (kPa) unknown unknown unknown unknown
Duty Point Pressure (kPa) 420 420 420 420
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Water Pumps
Overall Condition Pump 1 Pump 2 Pump 3 Pump 4 Pump 5 Pump 6
Pump Body Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory
Pump Shaft Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory
Pump Shaft Coupling Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory
Pump Base Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory
Springs / Anti Vib. Mat. NA NA NA NA
Pump Plinth Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory
Pump Motor Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT - Water Pump Duty Point
Comments
NOTE: 'NA' or 'Blank' = Not Applicable or Data Not Available.
1) Level indicator is not correct in mimic
2) Clock in mimic is not working
3) Light at the back door of the mimic is not working
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
PERFORMANCE CURVES - Water Pumps
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Other Mechanical Equipment and Systems
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix E
Electrical Assets
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Pump Motors
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT - Pump Motors
Performance Parameters Motor 1 Motor 2 Motor 3 Motor 4 Motor 5 Motor 6
R Y B R Y B R Y B R Y B R Y B R Y B
Voltage (V) 430 430 430 430 430 429 430 430 429 429 429 428
Current (A) 57 56 55 59 58 57 58 57 56 58 57 56
Power Factor 0.424 0.438 0.429 0.43 0.44 0.43 0.42 0.43 0.4 0.43 0.44 0.43
Average Voltage (V) 430.0 429.7 429.7 428.7
Average Current (A) 56.0 58.0 57.0 57.0
Overall Power Factor 0.750 0.740 0.740
Dielectric Absorption Insulation Insulation Insulation Insulation
(30sec / 60sec) >4G >4G >4G >4G
Polarisation Index (1min/10min) Not measured Not measured Not measured Not measured
Hours Run 2008 2004 2000 2000
Power Measured (kW) 32.2 32.0 32.0 32.0
Total Power (kVAr) 28.4 28.0 28.0 28.0
Total Power (KVA) 43.4 42.0 43.0 43.0
RPM
Temperature ºC (Hot > 68ºC) 59.0 36.0 36.0 34.0
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Main Switchboard & Motor Control Panels
Main Switchboard LEGEND - Asset Condition Assessment
Year of Installation Description Life Remains Rating
Clear Labelling? Yes "As New" 100% 1
Logical Layout? Yes Mirror image, dual supply Good 75% 2
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
CONDITION ASSESSMENT - Other Electrical Equipment and Systems
Electrical Equipment Description Comments Asset Condition Assessment
Schedule Parameters Rating
Power Transformer Externally accessed room in main building / On trolly base Good Elect. Equip. A-I
2
Rating 500 earthing. Transformer room well lit. Voltage too high.
Pump Station Earthing Elect. Equip. A-I
Neutral / Earth Link No 2
Resistance (Earth /Neutral) 185
Lightning Protection Multi rod earthing system. Apparently joined by earthing strap not Elect. Equip. A-I
Strap and rod system on tank, pump house cable. No test of earth resistance. 2
Lightning Protection
and security hut.
Pump Room Crane Electric cranes in pump house (5 ton) and valve room (1 ton) Elect. Equip. A-I
2
Electrics Operating fully
Pump Control Panel Occasional mis read - up to 50% of meter reading 24 volt DC Elect. Equip. A-I
Clear Mimic (Y/N) Yes supplies cool. ABB PLC Controls - AC 800M. All surfaces dusty.
2
Fully Operational (Y/N) No Internal light not operating - plan pocket on door loose
Thermal Imaging (Y/N) Ok
Power Cabling All pump floor cabling on above floor cable trays, not good Elect. Equip. A-I
2
Main SB to Motors Well supported on trays. protection.
Room Lighting Elect. Equip. A-I
Overlit. One fitting has fallen from ceiling
Control Room Lighting 2
and is hanging by its supply cable.
Emergency/ Exit Lighting --
Exterior Site Lighting Reported to be fully working. Generous layout, approx 10m Elect. Equip. A-I
2
Exterior Site Lighting Ok masts.
Fire Alarm System 8 Zone configuration. Fireray beam system. Not maintained well Elect. Equip. A-I
Manufacturer Wormald 4
Detector Types Beam and ionisation
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix F
Pumps and Motors – Temperature, Noise,
Vibration and Alignment
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
TEMPERATURE, NOISE & VIBRATION - Pumps & Motors
Temperature Deg C
Pump Room 34.2
Control Room 23.5
Outside (Ambient) 42.2
Vibration (mm/s) / Frequency (Hz) Pump-Motor 1 Pump-Motor 2 Pump-Motor 3 Pump-Motor 4 Pump-Motor 5 Pump-Motor 6
Vibration Limit = 2mm/sec V (mm/s) w (Hz) V (mm/s) w (Hz) V (mm/s) w (Hz) V (mm/s) w (Hz) V (mm/s) w (Hz) V (mm/s) w (Hz)
Point No 1 = Motor - Top Front Bearing 0.165 125 0.142 100 0.124 57.5 0.183 172.5
Point No 2 = Motor - Rear Foot 0.166 100 0.236 125 0.170 125 0.096 125
Point No 3 = Motor - Top of Motor 0.307 125 0.276 100 0.242 100 0.356 122.5
Point No 4 = Pump - Top Front Bearing 0.197 125 0.106 65 0.161 65 0.212 75
Point No 5 = Pump - Top Rear Bearing 0.751 77.5 0.377 125 0.262 125 0.207 65
Point No 6 = Pump - Rear Foot 0.520 125 0.197 125 0.344 125 0.077 75
Point No 7 = Pump - Inlet 0.822 125 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
Point No 8 = Pump - Outlet 0.079 125 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
ALIGNMENT - Pumps & Motors
Pump Shaft Alignment (mm) Pump-Motor 1 Pump-Motor 2 Pump-Motor 3 Pump-Motor 4 Pump-Motor 5 Pump-Motor 6
Angular Limit = 0.08mm/100m
mm mm mm mm mm mm
Linear Limit = 0.10mm
Angular Displacement - Horizontal 1.15 0.14 0.14 0.10
Linear Displacement - Horizontal 0.04 0.12 0.02 0.00
Angular Displacement - Vertical 0.16 1.12 0.18 0.98
Linear Displacement - Vertical
Comments
NOTE: 'NA' or 'Blank' = Not Applicable or Data Not Available. LEGEND - Asset Condition Assessment
Pumps and motors in reasonable condition "As New" 100% 1
Noise within the station is an issue of concern Good 75% 2
Pipework flexible connectors in good condition Fair 50% 3
Pump flexible couplings OK Poor 25% 4
Failure Imminent 0% 5
Failed / Derelict Un-useable 6
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix G
Water Storage Tanks
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Procedure for Structural Inspection of Concrete Water Tanks
The following procedure is to be used when carrying out visual inspections of concrete water tanks for
ADDC.
1. Safety
Read the Safety Plan and be aware of all of the safety issues relating to the inspection procedure.
Consider each tank and site individually and identify the risks that are present for that tank.
Carry out the procedures of the Safety Plan with regard to isolation of water, working at heights,
entering confined spaces, preparations and methodology of rescue etc.
2. Recording
All defects shall be recorded, photographed and given a condition grading in accordance with the
attached matrix.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
4. Visual Inspection – Interior
Inspect the tank interior surface as far as it is accessible, including at floor and roof soffit.
– Linings
If the tank has a lining then inspect the lining and determine what material is used. Note colour,
hardness, thickness if possible,
Note and photograph the condition of the lining and identify any defects such as holes, tears,
cracks, delamination etc.
Record the extent of the lining around the walls and if the roof soffit is lined.
Inspect all penetrations where pipes pass through the lining, record condition and any defects.
5. General
Make sure that all photos have a scale reference clearly visible in them, such as ruler or pen.
Tools required:
– Crack graduation gauge,
– Lightweight hammer,
– Metal hand scraper.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Structures Rating Matrix Includes all tanks, buildings, wells, pits, platforms, access bridges
Distress
Assessment Component Mode Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating
Parameter
1 2 3 4 5
Structural Cracking Structure sound - Some minor Cracking becoming Cracking evident that Significant cracking evident that
Integrity / no cracking cracking evident more evident has impacted on the presents a high probability of
A Function evident. that has little impact however still little assets structural the structures collapse or
on the structures impact on structural integrity or function. failure.
strength or function. integrity or function.
Movement No movement Some minor Asset has moved Movement has Movement has severe impact
evident. movement evident significantly however impacted on the on structural integrity or
B that has little impact structural integrity assets structural function with a high likelihood of
on the structures and function are integrity or function. failure.
strength or function. retained.
Surface Deterioration Surface appears Some minor surface Surface Surface deterioration Severe deterioration of surface
as new with little wear evident that deterioration evident that has presenting a high probability of
or no signs of has little impact on becoming more impacted on the the structures collapse or
C deterioration. the structures evident however still assets structural failure.
strength or function. little impact on integrity or function.
structural integrity or
function.
Operational Loss of Asset able to Some minor Minor operational Significant Asset provides very little of its
Performance Function/Costs perform it elements of the difficulties or costs operational intended function and requires
D intended current assets function are being presented by difficulties or costs enhancement to correct.
function. not able to be the loss of function. presented by the
provided. loss of function.
Foundation Ground No movement/ Some minor Significant ground Movement/ erosion Movement/erosion has severe
Movement/ erosion evident. movement/ erosion movement or has impacted on the impact on structural integrity or
Erosion evident that has erosion, however asset's structural function with a high likelihood of
E
little impact on the asset structural integrity or function. structural failure.
structure's strength integrity and function
or function. are retained.
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Fixings Cracking / Fixing sound - no Some minor Cracking/corrosion Cracking/corrosion Significant cracking/corrosion
Corrosion cracking/corrosion cracking/corrosion becoming more evident that has evident that presents a high
evident evident that has evident however still impacted on the probability of the fixings failure.
F
little impact on the little impact on structural integrity. Crane cannot be used.
fixings strength or structural integrity.
function
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 - Internal
Crazing in patch repair surface in wall Deformed section of joint sealant in wall
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 - External
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Leakage marks in wall Crack and staining in wall
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix H
OEM vs Pump Performance
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix I
Thermographic Images
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Thermal Imaging
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 04
Mimic Panel
7/14/2009 4:43:21 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Thermal Imaging
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 03
Pump Set No. 1 Motor Control Panel
7/14/2009 2:15:14 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 06
Pump Set No. 1 Motor Bearing
7/14/2009 2:16:43 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 09
Pump Set No. 1 Motor
7/14/2009 2:17:28 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Thermal Imaging
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 04
Pump Set No. 2 Shaft
7/14/2009 2:33:17 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 07
Pump Set No. 2 Shaft
7/14/2009 2:33:42 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 10
Pump Set No. 2 Motor Control Panel
7/14/2009 2:35:19 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Thermal Imaging
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 03
Pump Set No. 3 Pump Bearing
7/14/2009 3:00:17 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 06
Pump Set No. 3 Shaft
7/14/2009 3:00:38 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 09
Pump Set No. 3 Motor Control Panel
7/14/2009 3:01:24 PM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Thermal Imaging
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 04
Pump Set No. 4 Motor
7/16/2009 9:33:39 AM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Visible Light Image
TI 07
Pump Set No. 4 Motor Control Bearing
7/16/2009 9:35:14 AM
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Appendix J
Vibration Spectrum
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Pump Set No. 1
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Pump Set No. 2
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Pump Set No. 3
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
Grain Al Ayesh 3 Pumping Station – Pump Set No. 4
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3
GHD Global Pty Ltd CLN 1001592
Document Status
76/10239/15817 Condition Assessment and Energy Management Survey of ADDC Water Pumping Stations Including Water
Prev 11390 Tank Internal Inspection
Western Region PS 24 - Grain Al Ayesh No. 3 Pumping Station DW-GSH-WPS3