Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pre Print 0297
Pre Print 0297
1088/1741-4326/aa5d01 OV/3-3
1
JT-60SA Project Team and 3JT-60SA JA Home, National Institutes for Quantum and
Radiological Science and Technology, 801-1 Mukoyama, Naka, Ibaraki 311-0193, Japan
2
JT-60SA EU Home Team, Fusion for Energy, Boltsmannstr 2, Garching 85748, Germany
Abstract. The JT-60SA Project has been implemented since June 2007 under the framework of the Broader
Approach (BA) agreement and the Japanese national fusion programme for the purpose of an early realization of
fusion energy. With variable heating and current drive profiles by powerful NBI and ECRF system, flexible plasma
shaping capability, and various kinds of in-vessel coils to suppress MHD instabilities, JT-60SA is sure to play an
essential role to address key physical and engineering issues of the ITER project and to promote DEMO design
activities. It aims to achieve long sustainment of high integrated performance plasmas under the high N condition
required in DEMO. Fabrication and installation of components and systems of JT-60SA procured by the European
and Japanese implementing agencies, F4E and QST, are steadily progressing. Assembly of toroidal field coils
around the vacuum vessel will start soon in the torus hall. Commissioning of the cryogenic system and power
supply system has been implemented in the Naka site. The first plasma of JT-60SA will be achieved in 2019. The
JT-60SA research plan covers a wide area of issues in ITER and DEMO relevant operation regimes, and has been
regularly updated on the basis of intensive discussion among European and Japanese researchers.
1. Introduction
The mission of the JT-60SA (Super Advanced) Project [1-3] is to contribute to an early
realization of fusion energy by addressing key physical and engineering issues for ITER and
demonstration fusion reactors (DEMO) [4,5] by utilizing JT-60SA, a superconducting tokamak
being constructed in Naka Fusion Institute of the National Institutes for Quantum and
Radiological Science and Technology (QST). Figure 1 is a schematic view of the JT-60SA
tokamak. The JT-60SA project has been implemented since 2007 under the framework of the
Broader Approach (BA) agreement as well as the Japanese national fusion programme (NA).
Overall implementation of the BA activities is directed and supervised by the BA Steering
Committee (SC), and examined by the Project Committee from the technical point of view. EU
and Japan each designates an Implementing Agency, which substantially carries out pertinent
activities for the project provided in the BA agreement. The European Implementing Agency
(EU-IA) is Fusion for Energy (F4E) and the Japanese Implementing Agency (JA-IA) is QST.
The Project Team (PT) coordinates the implementation
of the project between the EU-IA and the JA-IA.
The principle of the Japanese fusion research and
development activities is laid down in the “Third Phase
Basic Program of Fusion Research and Development”
[6] formulated by the Atomic Energy Commission,
which was released in June 1992. Achievement of self-
ignition condition, demonstration of long pulse (1,000
sec) burning plasma and development of fundamental
fusion technology necessary for DEMO are the main FIG. 1. Schematic view of JT-60SA
targets. In 1992 ITER EDA and the operation of tokamak
2 OV/3-3
upgraded JT-60 (JT-60U) started to achieve the above goals. JT-60U left remarkable records
such as DT equivalent fusion energy gain factor of 1.25 and fusion triple product of 1.53x1021
keV s m-3, and was shut down in 2008 to make way for JT-60SA, which opens up prospect
toward DEMO.
During past decades understanding of plasma physics has become deeper through intensive
research by using worldwide tokamaks. At the same time, lots of critical issues have become
clear, which may have strong influence on DEMO design. Under these circumstances, the
“Joint-Core Team for the Establishment of Technology Bases Required for the Development
of a Demonstration Fusion Reactor” was organized in the Working Group on Fusion Research
under the Nuclear Science and Technology Committee in Japan, and they summarized a report
on the basic concept of DEMO as well as physical and engineering issues to be solved with a
timeline chart [7, 8]. This report clearly defined that outputs from both JT-60SA and ITER play
critical roles to resolve issues related to the DEMO design and decide its construction.
The first plasma of JT-60SA will be achieved in 2019, which is much earlier than that of ITER.
Therefore JT-60SA can address expected issues of ITER in advance.
The JT-60SA Project has three major objectives. The first objective is to provide supporting
research for the ITER project to accomplish its technical targets. In order to realize a stable
steady-state (300~500 sec) Q=10 operation in ITER, lots of critical issues have to be addressed:
disruption avoidance and mitigation, ELM control for heat pulse reduction, heat load mitigation
by radiative divertor, and so forth. JT-60SA can operate in the ITER-like configuration
inductive mode under the break-even-equivalent condition. Thereby operation boundary of
ITER high integrated performance plasmas without disruption or serious MHD instabilities will
be investigated. Controllability of the plasmas due to the characteristics of superconducting
coils is also examined.
The second objective is to provide complementary research to ITER in order to promote DEMO
design activities. Although ITER will demonstrate 500 MW steady-state DT burning and handle
substantial amount of tritium, it will be operated at the normalized plasma pressure, N
(=20aP/(IpBt)), up to about 3. Since the fusion power is approximately proportional to N2,
DEMO should be operated in a higher N (~5) regime as an economically competitive power
plant. Thus such high N operation region will be investigated in detail by using JT-60SA.
The third objective is to foster scientists and technicians in the younger generation, who are
expected to play leading roles in ITER and DEMO. Quite a long period of time is necessary for
fusion research and development. JT-60SA
experiments provide opportunities for these people
to build up their knowledge, skills and experiences.
JT-60SA will examine and optimize operation
scenarios in the ITER and DEMO parameter region.
For that purpose, JT-60 has several distinct
characteristics for flexible operation in a wide range
of plasma parameters. Major parameters of JT-
60SA are shown in Table I. Large value of shape
factor S=q95Ip/(aBt) enables JT-60A to flexibly
change the shape of the plasma cross section. The
4.6 MA operation with ITER-like configuration is
beneficial in exploring ITER operation scenarios. TABLE I: PARAMETERS OF JT-60SA
3 OV/3-3
There are several research phases in the JT-60SA operation: (i) the Initial Research phase (~5
years), (ii) the Integrated Research phase (~5 years) and (iii) the Extended Research phase
(thereafter). The NBI and ECRF power will gradually increase toward the later phases, which
corresponds to the upgrade of diver target components for higher tolerable heat load.
During the first half of the Initial Research phase, hydrogen operation is carried out to conduct
full commissioning of the entire system. Plasma controllability is examined and operational
region is gradually expanded. The plasma current is increased up to 5.5 MA. Although P-NBI
and ECRF are not in full power, full-power N-NBI is available. The partially mono-block target
is installed with lower single null (LSN) divertor configuration. During the second half of the
Initial Research phase, deuterium operation is carried out. With additional NBI power, high N
scenario, high p scenario for fully non-inductive operation, and high density operation above
nGW are tried. Performance of profile control of the plasma current, the plasma pressure and the
plasma rotation is confirmed.
In the Integrated Research phase, almost full power heating is available. The LSN divertor
target is upgraded to the full mono-block type to withstand the heat load up to 15 MW/m2,
which enables establishment of high power and long pulse operation scenario necessary for
DEMO. Commissioning of the remote handling system is completed during the first half of the
Integrated Research phase in order to prepare for the second phase with higher annual neutron
production.
In the Extended Research phase, full power heating of 41 MW for 100s is available. Double
null divertor configuration for further reduction of the divertor heat load is also available. In
this phase, DEMO operation scenario with N ~5 and high integrated performance operation
will be demonstrated.
Originally the carbon divertor target will be replaced by the metallic one in the Extended
Research phase after the principal mission of JT-60SA is accomplished. Now the possibility of
replacement in the second half of the Integrated Research phase is under consideration in order
to address issues such as compatibility of metallic divertor with integrated high performance
plasmas as early as possible. Thereby obtained physical and engineering outcomes from JT-
60SA would be of great use for ITER and DEMO.
4. Research Collaboration
The JT-60SA Project is implemented by close collaboration between the EU and Japan. The
Integrated Project Team (IPT) was organized to promote collaboration, which consists of the
EU Home Team (EU-HT), the JA Home Team (JA-HT) and the PT. The EU-HT consists of
staff of F4E and European Voluntary Contributor designated institutes (VC), i.e. CEA,
CIEMAT, Consorzio RFX, ENEA, KIT and SCK-CEN. The JA-HT consists of QST staff.
In addition, European and Japanese researchers from universities and institutes come to join the
JT-60SA Project through EUROfusion via F4E in Europe and also through Fusion Energy
Forum in Japan to examine JT-60SA research items in detail. All of these researchers together
with IPT members compose “JT-60SA Research Unit” as shown in Figure 6.
On the basis of a wide operational range of JT-60SA, essential issues to be addressed for ITER
and DEMO are examined in eight major research areas: (i) operation regime development, (ii)
MHD stability and control, (iii) transport and confinement, (iv) high energy particle behavior,
(v) pedestal and edge physics, (vi) divertor, scrape off layer and plasma-material interaction,
(vii) fusion engineering, and (viii) theoretical models and simulation codes. They are
5 OV/3-3
Procurement of JT-60SA components and systems is made up of the BA part and the NA part.
In the BA part, 27 procurement arrangements (PAs) in total (JA: 14 PAs, EU: 13 PAs) were
established as of the end of September 2016, which cover about 95% value of the in-kind
contributions of STP. The EU-HT is responsible for the procurements assigned to EU, in
particular their manufacture and quality assurance. The JA-HT is responsible for procurements
assigned to Japan, and also integration and quality assurance of NA contributions. Existing JT-
60U facilities, e.g. transformer substation, motor generators, etc., are also reused as much as
possible in order to suppress the overall project cost. Progress meetings and technical meetings
are held quite frequently among IPT members. They identify and settle problems in the early
stages and develop strategies to keep momentum of the project. Such strong collaboration
among IPT members is a powerful driving force of this project.
5.1.Magnets
All of the major coils of JT-60SA are superconducting coils. Eighteen Toroidal Field (TF) coils
and six Equilibrium Field (EF) coils use NbTi strand, and four Central Solenoid (CSs) modules
use Nb3Sn strand.
Twenty D-shaped TF coils including two spare coils with a height of 7.4m and a width of 4.5m
are being fabricated in EU. Rectangular shaped steel-jacketed NbTi cable-in-conduit
conductors (CICC) (outer dimensions: 22x26 mm2) are used for the TF coils. One conductor is
wound to form one D-shaped double pancake (DP). Six DPs are stacked up and connected to
form a winding pack (WP) for a TF coil. Fabrication of WPs and their impregnation are being
carried out in France and Italy. In parallel, TF coil casings are being manufactured. Impregnated
6 OV/3-3
5.3.Vacuum Vessel
Figure 13 shows the Vacuum Vessel (VV) of JT-60SA procured by Japan. It is a double-walled
structure made from SUS316L having 18mm shell thickness and a cavity of about 160mm wide
between the shells [14]. This cavity is filled with borated water to reduce the neutron budget
during deuterium operation. It also allows heated nitrogen gas flow for baking of the VV at
200°C after draining the borated water.
The VV was divided into ten VV sectors: seven 40° sectors, two 30° sectors and one 20° sector.
The inboard side and the outboard side of each VV sectors were manufactured separately in the
factory and welded together in the Naka site. Then they were carried onto the Cryostat base
(CB) one by one. Careful grooving processing was performed during welding of adjoining VV
sectors. The end faces of each VV sector were
locally corrected by applying pressure of jacks
and heat input in order to avoid misalignment.
The direct-joint welding and the welding with a
splice plate were adopted. The degree of
contraction observed during the welding R&D
was taken into account when deciding the width
of the splice plates [15]. Welding work and
radiographic testing were carried out alternately
to avoid formation of voids in the welded part.
Finally they were welded to form a 340° torus
structure in September 2015. The measured
displacement of the VV sectors from the
designed value is +5mm/-5mm horizontally and FIG. 13. Vacuum vessel, ports and bellows
8 OV/3-3
up to -4mm vertically, which are within the tolerance of +30mm/-30mm and +6mm/-4mm,
respectively.
Various shapes of fifty-five ports and port bellows were fabricated for the VV. The largest port
opening is 1.83m vertically and 0.66m horizontally. They cleared the dimensional tolerance of
+2mm/-2mm. Nine VV Gravity Supports with spring plates and oilless bearing were also
fabricated, which not only support the VV but also allow displacement of VV by thermal
expansion due to the various operational modes.
5.4.Thermal Shields
Several kinds of thermal shields procured by Japan are set up to cover major structures of JT-
60SA to keep them at low temperatures against the radiation from warm components. They are
the Vacuum Vessel Thermal Shield (VVTS), the Cryostat Thermal Shield (CTS) and the Port
Thermal Shield. Thermal Shields are normally cooled at 80K by gaseous helium and are of
great use to reduce the electricity consumption of the cryogenic system. All the VVTS and
lower port TS were already fabricated and delivered to the Naka site in March 2016. Designing,
drawing and trial manufacturing of the other TS are being carried out.
5.5.In-Vessel Components
Components such as cryopanels, divertor cassettes, the inboard first wall, the stabilizing baffle
plate with outboard first wall will be installed inside the vacuum vessel. In addition, magnetic
diagnostic coils including magnetic field probes, Rogowski loops, one turn loops, diamagnetic
loops and saddle coils as well as control coils such as FPPCC, EFCC and RWMCC for high N
plasmas will be installed.
The lower divertor consists of a divertor cassette frame and plasma facing components mounted
on it. Coolant pipes for each component are connected to the main coolant pipes of the cassette
frame, and a remote handling (RH) maintenance pipe is connected to the coolant headers in the
VV [16]. A mono-block type Carbon Fiber Composite (CFC) is adopted for the divertor target
plates, which are bolted on cooled heatsinks and allows a heat load of 15 MW/m2 [17]. All the
36 divertor cassettes were manufactured in 2013 and delivered to the Naka site.
5.6.Cryostat
The cryostat of JT-60SA is made up of the cryostat base (CB) [18] and the cryostat vessel body
cylindrical section (CVBCS) procured by the EU [19] as well as the cryostat top lid (CTL)
procured by Japan (Figure 14(a)). The cryostat provides a vacuum boundary to insulate heat
load from outside at room temperature to the components operated at cryogenic temperature
such as superconducting coils. The CB with a diameter of 11.95m, a height of 2.84m and a
weight of 260 ton
installed in the torus
hall in March 2013
becomes a gravity
support for the
vacuum vessel and
superconducting
coils. Careful
fabrication of CB
provides remarkable
flatness of its top FIG. 14. (a) Structure of JT-60SA cryostat, (b) sectors of CVBCS
9 OV/3-3
5.7.Cryogenic System
The Cryogenic System procured by the EU is composed of six gaseous helium storage vessels,
eight warm compressors, four helium compressors, a Refrigerator Cold Box (RCB) for
producing helium at cryogenic temperature, an Auxiliary Cold Box (ACB) for distribution of
the cryogenic flows as shown in Figure 15 [20].
The Cryogenic System supplies helium to the magnet system (4.4K), cryopumps (3.7K), HTS-
CLs (50K) and the thermal shields (80K). The total equivalent power at 4.5K is about 9kW. It
is the largest refrigerators for a nuclear fusion facility before ITER. The ACB and RCB were
delivered to the Naka site in April 2015 and the helium storage vessels in May 2015.
Commissioning of the Cryogenic System with various operation modes related to the actual
experimental condition (operation, baking, stand-by, etc.) were completed in October 2016.
5.8.Power Supplies
Most of the power supply systems of JT-60SA have been newly manufactured due to the
adoption of superconducting magnet system [21]. Additional power supply systems for in-
vessel normal conductor coils have been also fabricated.
The Super Conducting Magnet Power Supplies (SCMPS), a procurement shared by France and
Italy, are based on ac/dc thyristor converters: one unit for TF coils (25.7 kA, 80 V, steady state)
and ten units for PF coils (±20 kA, ±1 kV, 100s/1800s duty cycle). About half of SCMPS were
delivered to the Naka site in June 2016 and were installed (see Figure 16). All the remaining
SCMPS will be delivered by autumn 2017.
The Quench Protection Circuits (QPC) protect the SC coils (TF coils, EF coils and CS modules)
in case of quench by fast extraction of the
stored energy. The QPCs made up of
three units (25.7 kA, 2.8 kV) for TF coils
and ten units (±20 kA, ±3.8 kV) for PF
coils are based on dc hybrid mechanical-
static circuit breakers. They were
developed and fabricated in Italy and
FIG. 16. SCMPS installed in the Naka site
10 OV/3-3
delivered to the Naka site in September 2014. The commissioning and final acceptance tests of
the QPC were completed in June 2015.
The Switching Network Unit (SNU) for CS modules which produces high voltage for the
plasma break down and current ramp-up were manufactured in Italy in 2015 and delivered to
the Naka site in September 2016. Two SNUs for EF3 and EF4 procured by Japan were delivered
to Naka in 2015. All the SNUs are rated for 20 kA and 5 kV and implement dc hybrid
mechanical-static circuit breakers too.
The PS for the upper/lower FPPCC (±5 kA and ±1 kV) are ac/dc thyristor converters which
control the vertical and horizontal position of the plasma against small plasma perturbations
such as a minor disruption. They are procured by Italy and were delivered to the Naka site in
June 2016. The PSs for the RWMCC, EFCC and ECRF are also being manufactured.
The Magnet Power Supply Water Cooling System (MPS-WCS) procured by Japan for the PS
of TF coils and PF coils was installed on the Naka site. On-site work and commissioning were
completed in March 2015.
Electric power supply system in the Naka site has been also carefully reconsidered. Former JT-
60 used three motor generators (MGs) to accumulate and supply electric power to the coils and
heating system in order to mitigate perturbation to the commercial power grid. JT-60SA will
reuse two motor generators: H-MG with 400MVA/2.6GJ and T-MG with 215MVA/4.0GJ, as
well as electric power directly from 275kV power grid. All of them in total cover 100 sec
operation with 41 MW heating and current drive. H-MG was overhauled and component parts
were carefully examined in 2015. No serious damage was spotted after the Great East Japan
earthquake in 2011.
The design of the supervisory control system and data acquisition system (SCSDAS) is also
under development. It has roles of human machine interface, discharge sequence control, plant
monitoring, plasma real-time control, power supply control, device protection and discharge
result data acquisition/storage as well as database management roles.
Auxiliary heating systems for the long pulse plasma operation has been developed. Performance
of a gyrotron enabling operation at two frequencies (110 and 138 GHz) was remarkably
enhanced up to 1 MW for 100 sec in 2014 [22]. In 2015 an additional frequency of this gyrotron
at 82 GHz was demonstrated for 1 sec at 1 MW, which is applicable for plasma start-up assist
and wall cleaning. Modification of the magnetic structure of the negative ion source to extract
a uniform beam and control of the plasma grid temperature for stable negative ion generation
allowed 500 keV, 15A beam for 100 sec [23]. Final goal of 22A beams for 100 sec is to be
fulfilled. Positive ion beam acceleration with 2MW (80 keV, 25A) for 100 sec was already
demonstrated for one unit in 2015 by the careful control of arc power and gas injection rate.
Twelve units of P-NBI ensure 24MW heating power.
6.1.Assembly Work
Assembly work in the torus hall started in January 2013. First of all the cryostat base (CB) was
placed right in the middle. Three lower EF coils (EF4, EF5 and EF6) were temporarily set on
the CB. The assembly frame surrounding the CB was installed in May 2014.
11 OV/3-3
6.2.Assembly Coordination
In order to implement the successive assembly works in the torus hall listed above while
keeping the tight schedule, detailed assembly procedures have been examined beforehand. In
order to avoid rework or serious matters which may cause a great impact on the schedule, design
coordination meetings have been held in QST on a regular basis. In the meeting, interface issues
arising from updated design of components, improvement of assembly procedures to promote
work efficiency and schedule compression, reconsideration of in-factory work and on-site work
for a component, and so on are discussed and optimized. The solution is surely shared among
the people concerned in EU and Japan. Such close communication and information exchange
established between EU and Japan is one of the reason of steady progress of the JT-60SA
Project.
After the installation work, commissioning of each component and system will be carried out
individually. Then data linkage test including transmission of interlock signal between systems
such as power supply system, superconducting system, heating system and so forth will be
carried out. The supervisory control system and data acquisition system (SCSDAS) is utilized
for this purpose.
Integrated Commissioning (IC) will be implemented thereafter. A detailed plan of the IC among
multiple systems is being arranged: the list of test items for IC is complied, sequence of test
12 OV/3-3
items is decided, necessary implementation time, workforce, consumables are examined and
defined for each test item. The IC plan covers both machine operation and plasma operation,
and the first plasma in 2019.
7. Summary
The JT-60SA Project has progressed quite well since 2007. Procured components and systems
of JT-60SA have been manufactured and delivered to the Naka site one after another. Assembly
of 340° VV and VVTS is almost completed, and installation of TF coils will start soon. In
parallel, commissioning of cryogenic system, power supply system and so on has been carried
out in the Naka site. Thanks to the strong cooperative spirit between EU and Japan, the first
plasma will be achieved in 2019. The collaborative work on JT-60SA is also quite active. The
JT-60SA Research Plan which covers a wide range of research area by using JT-60SA has been
developed on the basis of intensive discussion among European and Japanese researchers. The
JT-60SA Research Plan is periodically updated to fully support the ITER project and DEMO
design activities.
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge members of EU-IA, JA-IA, PT and VC for their strenuous
efforts to get over a lot of technical difficulties and persistently proceed with the JT-60SA
Project. The authors also appreciate the members of the European and Japanese fusion
communities who have made great contribution to update the JT-60SA Research Plan in order
to bring out capability of the JT-60 facility to the maximum.
References
[1] KAMADA, Y., et al., Nucl. Fusion 53 (2013) 104010.
[2] DI PIETRO, E., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 89 (2014) 2128-2135.
[3] BARABASCHI, P., et al., Proc. 25th Fusion Energy Conf. (St. Petersburg, 2014) OV/3-2.
[4] HIWATARI, R., et al., Nucl. Fusion 45 (2005) 96-109.
[5] TOBITA, K., et al., Nucl. Fusion 49 (2009) 075029.
[6] OGAWA, Y., Journal of Physics, Conference Series 717 (2016) 012003.
[7] http://www.jspf.or.jp/2015/genkeiro/140718en.pdf
[8] http://www.jspf.or.jp/2015/genkeiro/150119_v6.pdf
[9] KAMADA, Y., et al., Nucl. Fusion 51 (2011) 073011.
[10] http://www.jt60sa.org/pdfs/JT-60SA_Res_Plan.pdf
[11] KOIDE, Y., et al., Nucl. Fusion 55 (2015) 086001.
[12] HELLER, R., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 86 (2011) 1422-1426.
[13] YOSHIDA, K., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 88 (2013) 1499-1504.
[14] MASAKI, K., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 87 (2012) 742-746.
[15] ASANO, S., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 86 (2011) 1816-1820.
[16] HAYASHI, T., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 89 (2014) 2299-2303.
[17] HIGASHIJIMA, S., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 84 (2009) 949-952.
[18] RINCON, E., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 86 (2011) 623-626.
[19] BOTIJA, J., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 88 (2013) 670-674.
[20] LAMAISON, V., et al., AIP Conf. Proc., 1573 (2014) 337-344.
[21] NOVELLO, L., et al., Fusion Eng. Des. 98-99 (2015) 1122-1126.
[22] KOBAYASHI, T., et al., Nucl. Fusion 55 (2015) 063008.
[23] KOJIMA, A., et al., Nucl. Fusion 55 (2015) 063006.