Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C SuarezHPC
C SuarezHPC
C SuarezHPC
net/publication/336146725
CITATIONS READS
87 10,249
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Magnetic Characterization and Modeling for High Frequency Converters View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Wilmar H Martinez on 01 October 2019.
Abstract—- This paper intends to establish an overall up to depending on the specific BEV battery capacity, turning the
date review on Fast Charging methods for Battery Electric use of EVs in long distance trips more convenient.
Vehicles (BEV). This study starts from basic concepts involving
single battery cell charging, current and future charging However, charging times do not depend exclusively on the
standards. Then, some popular power converter topologies charger equipment output power, but on the EV’s battery fast
employed for this application are introduced, and finally a charging capability. Therefore, the limitations related to
summary of the industrial solutions available on the market are battery chemistry, its state of Health (SoH), State of Charge
presented, as well as the ongoing projects related to the extreme (SoC) and temperature management system establish the
fast charging (XFC) network expansion. Practical insights, maximum power levels that can be reached [12]. This means
considering the current EV scenario, are employed to get a that the charging process could not be done at full rated
better understanding of this topic. Special attention is given to charger power, or even at constant power [13].
the modular design approach, analyzing its advantages and
some of the factors that influence the number and size of Accordingly, fast EV charging process and the related
modules that conform a fast charger solution solutions must consider different aspects beyond a high output
power. Some of these specific application characteristics are
Keywords— Ultra Fast Charging, Extreme Fast Charging, DC addressed in this document, giving a better approach to this
EV charging, CHAdeMO 2.0, CCS 2.0, BEV. topic.
This paper is organized as follows. Section II describes the
I. INTRODUCTION concepts related to battery charging and fast chargers. Section
Currently, global warming and its consequences represent III presents some common power converter topologies
a big concern for the society. In 2015, road transportation employed for EV charging. Section IV introduces the modular
represented the 18,8% of the total EU-28 greenhouse gas EV charger design approach. Section V summarizes some of
emissions [1]. Agreements between EU countries look for the main fast charger manufacturers and extreme-fast
reducing these values by 80% by 2050, and Battery Electric charging infrastructure network ongoing projects. Finally,
vehicles (BEV) are a promising alternative to obtain the section VI presents our conclusions.
decarbonization of the Light Duty Vehicle fleet [2].
According to [3], the Electric Vehicle (EV) market has had II. BEV CHARGING PROCESS, FAST CHARGING STANDARDS
an aggressive development in the last years, and some AND PROTOCOLS
European based car companies have pledged to go all electric
over the next four years [4]. However, there are still some A. Charging
important social barriers that must be overcome to get the According to the IEEE Standard “Technical Specifications
expected BEV market penetration, mostly related to the cost, of a DC Quick Charger for Use with Electric Vehicles”,
distance range capacity, charging time and infrastructure [5]. charging corresponds to the process of supplying direct
current form an external power source to a battery, causing a
Although, the distance range capability can vary a lot chemical reaction which leads to store electrical energy as
among different car models, starting from the Hyundai IONIQ chemical energy [14].
Electric´s 200 km [6], passing through the Chevy Bolt´s 383
km [7], up to the 540 km of Tesla model S [8] it is possible to A typical charging process of a single lithium battery cell
conclude that current EVs in the standard segment suit is shown in Fig. 1. It consists of two stages. During the first
properly to cover almost 95% of the vehicle trips made in the one a constant current (CC stage) is applied to the cell, having
U.S. This corresponds to distances of less than 53 km [9]. as result a voltage increase from 3,0 V, associated with a
Despite this, interurban trips are still a big concern for depleted state, up to 4,2 V which corresponds to the nominal
potential EV buyers in some regions [10], turning fast cell voltage. At this point the cell voltage is controlled to
charging technology and its infrastructure availability a key remain constant (CV stage) until the current reaches a value
point for BEV wide acceptance. close to zero.
As EVs range distance capacities get larger, the industry The battery charging time can be reduced increasing the
works in parallel to reduce the charging times. The technology value of the current employed at the CC stage, but high
employed for this purpose has been referred as Quick, Fast or currents can reduce the time of life of the cell or cause
Ultra-Fast charging, involving power levels up to 120 kW. permanent damage [15]. A simple analysis using a rough
Recently, Extreme Fast Charging (XFC) was introduced, battery model as the one presented in Fig. 2, shows that
reaching power levels around 350 kW [11]. Its main goal is to employing higher current, results in higher loses due to the
recharge a depleted battery bank up to 80% in 15 min or less, internal resistance of battery cell. These loses are basically
expressed as a temperature rise in the cell as described in [16]. charging protocol that guaranties a safe charging process and
Therefore, fast charging requires an adequate thermal interoperability with different BEV manufacturers.
management, maintaining the battery temperature within its
safe operating area. B. Fast Charger
The purpose of EV charger is to transfer energy from the
CC CV grid to the battery in a controlled way. This process can take
place inside de vehicle using an on-board charger, which
restricts it to a low power, or externally through an off-board
4,2 0,8 charger also known as DC charger.
On-board charger’s power is limited because of the space,
Voltage (V)
Current (A)
Voltage weight and cost restrictions to some few tens of kilowatts. This
Current
equipment let the vehicle be charged directly from
conventional 1-phase or 3-phase AC systems, making use of
an AC/DC converter controlling the DC output current and
3,0 0,0 voltage.
t0 t1 t2 Meanwhile, Off-board chargers are not limited by space or
Fig. 1. Single lithium battery cell charging process, based on [16] weight, its power levels can reach some hundreds of kilowatts.
Fig. 3. shows a conventional fast charger topology composed
by an AC/DC converter, a DC/AC converter, a high frequency
Determining the right moment to end the CC stage of the transformer and a rectifier. As depicted, the output of the
charging process is another important aspect to be considered charger is connected directly to EV on-board battery, keeping
at fast charging. A high current implies a high voltage drop at a communication link between the charger and the BMS to
the internal resistance of the battery, meaning that the actual control the charging process and safety procedures.
voltage of the cell could be still far from its maximum. This
could result in a premature beginning of the CV stage, Power
line (+)
increasing the overall charging time. On the other hand,
extending the duration of CC stage could lead to an EV Charger Vehicle
FC50 50 (500 V x 100 A) high number of switches handle high power ratings, which
HPC150 150 (500 V x 300 A, 920 V x 163 A) helps to overcome possible semiconductor limitations in high
HPC250 250 (500 V x 500 A, 920 V x 271 A) power applications. However, it is recommended to use the
HPC350 350 (500 V x 500 A, 920 V x 380 A) minimum number of switches as possible [20]. In this context,
isolated Full Bridge (see Fig. 4) based topologies have been
Recently, CHAdeMO and CCS have defined power proposed as common solution for DC chargers.
charging levels above 350 kW and output voltages up to 1 kV, Isolated Full Bridge topology is employed in [21] and [22],
beginning the standardization process for heavy duty vehicles obtaining output powers of 20 kW and 50 kW respectively. In
fast charging, like buses and trucks. This could also improve [23] a three-phase dual active bridge converter is presented,
the charging times of light vehicles. It also means that reaching 50kW, suggesting a power upgrade up to 100 kW.
theoretically, a Tesla Model S battery could be recharged from Losses and noise can be reduced using soft switching
0 to 80% in less than 14 minutes, but as mentioned before, the techniques, in [24] and [25] an LLC full bridge ZVS converter
charging time depends on the battery characteristics and its is developed, achieving output powers of 10 kW and 20 kW.
capacity to handle high charging currents according to the
thermal management system capabilities present at the BEV.
As seen in Table II, there is not any commercial passenger
BEV capable of charging at 350 kW or even above 200 kW
yet. However, Porsche claims its all electric sport car, the
Taycan, to be released in 2019 will achieve this milestone,
introducing another major change, an 800 V battery pack
[17,18].
600
500 Imin=5 A
Imax=500 A
400
300 OP1 OP5
Vmin=200 V
200
100
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Current [A]
Fig. 5. CCS HPC350 power class- voltage and current range [29]
RB TABLE III.
+ FAST CHARGER DEPLOYMENTS IN LEADING MARKETS
-
TABLE IV. FAST CHARGER MANUFACTURERS- ORIGING,VOLTAGES, POWER LEVELS AND MODULARITY
Manufacturer Country Output Power (kW) Modular Module Power (kW) Output Voltage (V) Cooling
and Experimental Verifications," in IEEE Transactions on Power [48] Siemens “High power charging for current and future ecars” Siemens
Electronics, vol. 24, no. 6, pp. 1463-1474, June 2009. Mobility2018[Online].
[29] CHARIN “Combined Charging System Specification” CharIN e. V Available:https://www.siemens.com/global/en/home/products/mobilit
[Online]. Available: https://www.charinev.org/ccs-at-a-glance/ccs- y/road-solutions/electromobility/ecars-high-power-charging-
specification [Accessed:22-Dec-2018]. infrastructure.html [Accessed:22-Dec-2018].
[30] Inside EVs “Jaguar I-PACE Tested At 350 kW Ultra-Fast Charger” [49] Siemens “Sinamics DCP” Siemens AG 2019 [Online]. Available:
[Online]. Available: https://insideevs.com/jaguar-i-pace-tested-350- https://w3.siemens.com/drives/global/en/converter/dc-drives/dc-dc-
kw-fast-charger [Accessed:22-Dec-2018]. converters/pages/sinamics-dcp.aspx [Accessed:22-Dec-2018].
[31] M. Alatalo “Module size investigation on fast chargers for BEV” [50] PRE “12.5 kW Charger Module” PRE 2018 [Online].
Swedish Electromobility Centre, 2018 [Online]. Available: Available:http://www.pr-
http://emobilitycentre.se/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Module-size- electronics.nl/media/documenten//12k5W_Charger_datasheet_V11.18
investigation-on-fast-chargers-for-BEV-final.pdf [Accessed:22-Dec- 0417.194409.pdf [Accessed:22-Dec-2018].
2018]. [51] PRE “25 kW DC/DC Charger Module” PRE, 2018[Online]. Available:
[32] J. Rajagopalan, K. Xing, Y. Guo, F. C. Lee and B. Manners, "Modeling http://www.pr-
and dynamic analysis of paralleled DC/DC converters with master- electronics.nl/media/documenten//25kW_Charger_datasheet_V13.180
slave current sharing control," Proceedings of Applied Power 417.194545.pdf [Accessed:22-Dec-2018].
Electronics Conference. APEC '96, San Jose, CA, USA, 1996, pp. 678- [52] Phihong “Phihong EV Chargers” Phihong 2017 [Online]. Available:
684 vol.2 https://www.phihong.com.tw/newcatalog/2017%20EV%20Chargers
[33] V. J. Thottuvelil and G. C. Verghese, "Analysis and control design of %20%E5%86%8A%E5%AD%90_20170420_EN.pdf [Accessed:22-
paralleled DC/DC converters with current sharing," in IEEE Dec-2018].
Transactions on Power Electronics, vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 635-644, July [53] Ies “Charger Module” IES Synergy [Online]. Available:
1998. http://www.ies-synergy.com/en/products/keywatt-charging-stations-
[34] K. Siri, C. Q. Lee and T. -. Wu, "Current distribution control for parallel power-modules/charger-module [Accessed:22-Dec-2018].
connected converters. I," in IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and
Electronic Systems, vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 829-840, July 1992.
[35] C. Hou, "A Multicarrier PWM for Parallel Three-Phase Active Front-
End Converters," in IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, vol. 28,
no. 6, pp. 2753-2759, June 2013
[36] C. Pan and Y. Liao, "Modeling and Coordinate Control of Circulating
Currents in Parallel Three-Phase Boost Rectifiers," in IEEE
Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 54, no. 2, pp. 825-838,
April 2007.
[37] Young-Kwang Son, Seung-Jun Chee and Seung-Ki Sul, "Analysis on
current flowing through deactivated modules in parallel connected
AC/DC converters," 2016 IEEE 8th International Power Electronics
and Motion Control Conference (IPEMC-ECCE Asia), Hefei, 2016,
pp. 761-767.
[38] M. Nicholas,D. Hall, “Lessons Learned on Early Vehhicle Fast-
Charging Deployments”, International Conuncil on Celan
Transportation, July 2018 [Online]. Available:
https://www.theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/ZEV_fast_char
ging_white_paper_final.pdf [Accessed: 20-Dec-2018].
[39] D. Steen and L. A. Tuan, "Fast charging of electric buses in distribution
systems," 2017 IEEE Manchester PowerTech, Manchester, 2017, pp.
1-6.
[40] D. Steen and L. A. Tuan, "Impacts of fast charging of electric buses on
electrical distribution systems," in CIRED - Open Access Proceedings
Journal, vol. 2017, no. 1, pp. 2350-2353, 10 2017.
[41] Idaho National Laboratory, “Considerations for corridor and
community DC Fast Charging Complex System Design” May 2017
[Online].Availabe:https://avt.inl.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/reports/DC
FCChargingComplexSystemDesign.pdf [Accessed: 20-Dec-2018].
[42] Tritium “VEEFIL-RT 50KW DC FAST CHARGER”, Tritium Pty Ltd
2019 [Online]. Available:
https://www.tritium.com.au/product/productitem?url=veefil-rt-50kw-
dc-fast-charger [Accessed: 20-Dec-2018].
[43] Tritium “LAUNCHING SOON- VEEFIL-PK DC ULTRA-FAST
CHARGER 175 kW- 475 kW”, Tritium Pty Ltd 2019 [Online].
Available: https://www.tritium.com.au/veefillpk [Accessed:22-Dec-
2018].
[44] EVBOX “LAUNCHING SOON- VEEFIL-PK DC ULTRA-FAST
CHARGER 175 kW- 475 kW” EvBox 2019 [Online].
Available:https://www.evbox.fr/produits/borne-recharge-rapide
[Accessed:22-Dec-2018].
[45] ABB “High Power Charging” ABB 2019 [Online]. Available:
https://new.abb.com/ev-charging/products/car-charging/high-power-
charging [Accessed:22-Dec-2018].
[46] ChargePoint “ChargePoint Express Plus” ChargePoint 2019 [Online].
Available:https://www.chargepoint.com/products/commercial/express
-plus [Accessed:22-Dec-2018].
[47] EVteQ “ SET-QM EV Charging Module”Evteq 2017 [Online].
Available http://www.evteqglobal.com/product-details/set-qm-ev-
charging-module [Accessed: 22-Dec-2018].