Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vinay Ie (I) 2011
Vinay Ie (I) 2011
Vinay Ie (I) 2011
-unemploymenL
-oor
-CasL sysLem
-opulaLlon
Industry-InstItute InteractIon Ior SustaInabIe DeveIopment: A Journey towards ExceIIence
Pagc 4 of S
SCENARIO OF TECHNICAL EDUCATION IN INDIA
Enginccring cducaiion in India Ias sccn ircmcndous growiI ovcr iIc asi dccadc; loiI in
numlcr of siudcnis and numlcr of collcgcs (scc Tallc I}. TIis sccms iIai an cnougI worl
forcc is lcing gcncraicd io mcci iIc indusirial nccds (figurc. 3-6}. Unforiunaicly iIcrc is no
daia availallc rcgarding iIc numlcr of cnginccring sircams availallc in iIcsc collcgcs and
numlcr of siudcnis cnrollcd in iIcm. As cr iIc discussion madc wiiI diffcrcni acadcmic
fricnds and collcgc ii is found iIai maimum numlcr of siudcnis roducc arc from IT and
comuicr scicncc followcd ly Elccironics. TIis is mainly duc io iIc amouni of
infrasiruciurc nccdcd io sciu iIcsc dcarimcnis arc quiic lcss. Morc ovcr duc io iIc loom
in IT indusirics in 2000-2004 lois of siudcnis arc moiivaicd io cnrol iIcmsclvcs iowards
iIcsc courscs. TIc Siruciurc 0f TccInical cducaiion in India is sIown in Fig2.
In iIc lalor marlci, firms and graduaics loiI lnow iIc qualiiy of a graduaic from a
ariicular collcgc. Ii is io lc undcrsiood iIai low qualiiy cnginccrs and iIc rolifcraiion of
low qualiiy cnginccring cducaiion in India, is noi iIc rcsuli of crfcci marlci forccs.
Enginccring collcgcs arc iyically allc io asccriain iIc qualiiy of scIooling iIai iIcy
rovidc, c.g. ly iracling alumni or communicaiions wiiI indusirial lodics. Siudcnis,
Iowcvcr, arc noi allc io malc sucI dcicrminaiions. Siudcnis will only cnicr iIc lalor
marlci uon comlciion of iIcir siudics, and so musi malc a dcicrminaiion of qualiiy
wiiIoui a dircci icsi. Morcovcr, iIcy arc scldom wcll informcd cvcn wIcn ii comcs io jol
ooriuniiics in iIc ncar fuiurc, namcly, aloui jols and carnings lilcly io awaii iIcm wIcn
iIcy comlcic iIcir scIooling. TIis is a gcncral rocriy of cducaiional marlcis, sincc
almosi ly dcfiniiion, siudcnis arc unsurc of iIcir ialcni, and only discovcr iIcm ly going io
scIool.
As argucd ly Alcrlof (1970}
|4|
, duc io iIc informaiional asymmciry lciwccn collcgcs and
siudcnis, iIc ricc iIai siudcnis arc willing io ay is dcicrmincd ly iIc avcragc qualiiy of
iIc cnscmllc of cnginccring collcgcs raiIcr iIan ly iIc qualiiy of iIc ariicular cnginccring
collcgc iisclf. TIis ricing siruciurc, Iowcvcr, will drivc IigI qualiiy scIooling (wiiI
rcsumiivcly IigIcr cosis} oui of iIc marlci, and low qualiiy scIooling will rcdominaic.
TIis advcrsc sclcciion rollcm will also drivc siudcnis looling for IigI qualiiy scIooling
oui of iIc marlci aliogciIcr.
Aari from iIis iIc avcragc qualiiy of iIc collcgcs and graduaicd siudcnis is quiic infcrior.
A survcy of Iuman rcsourcc rofcssionals ai muliinaiional cororaiions in India rcvcalcd
iIai only onc quaricr of cnginccring graduaics wiiI a suiiallc dcgrcc could lc cmloycd
irrcscciivc of dcmand (Farrcll ci al., 2005} }|4|. TIc main rcasons iIai graduaics arc
unsuiiallc for iIc jol marlci arc iIc lacl of ncccssary languagc slills; iIc low qualiiy of
significani oriions of iIc cducaiional sysicm and iis limiicd aliliiy io imari raciical
slills; and a lacl of culiural fii, wIicI can lc sccn in inicrcrsonal slills and aiiiiudcs
iowards icamworl and flcillc worling Iours" (Farrcll ci al., 2005}.
AnoiIcr survcy of cmloycrs sIows iIai only a Iandful of iIc 1400 cnginccring scIools in
India arc rccognizcd as roviding world-class cducaiion wiiI graduaics woriIy of
considcraiion for cmloymcni (Clolalizaiion of Enginccring Scrviccs, 2006} }|4|. TIcsc
rcsulis suggcsi iIai cnginccring dcgrccs from mosi Indian collcgcs do noi rovidc signaling
valuc in iIc cnginccring lalor marlci. Ii is woriI oiniing oui a lcy diffcrcncc lciwccn iIc
cducaiion marlci and a marlci sucI as for uscd cars. Unlilc iIc uscd car marlci, wIcrc
iIc qualiiy of ariicular car is ficd, iIc qualiiy of a ariicular scIool can lc modificd. Dy
rcducing iIc qualiiy of faculiy and faciliiics, wiiI a rcsumally commcnsuraic rcduciion in
cosis, an cnginccring collcgc may rcducc iIc cosi and qualiiy of cducaiion rovidcd. TIis
diffcrcncc clains wIy iIcrc is only dcgradaiion in iIc qualiiy of cducaiion on iIc marlci,
Vinay SIarma, Aiul Anand
Pagc of S
raiIcr iIan a rcduciion in iIc numlcr of vcndors in iIc marlci; in faci, iIcrc Ias lccn an
incrcasc in iIc numlcr of vcndors in iIc cnginccring marlci.
FIgure 2: EducatIonaI System In IndIa
An uniraincd worlcr may Iavc valuallc naiural ialcnis, lui iIcsc ialcnis musi lc ccriificd
ly iIc 'cducaiional csiallisImcni' lcforc a comany can afford io usc iIcm. TIc ccriifying
csiallisImcni, Iowcvcr, musi lc crcdillc. Craduaics from iIc io Indian scIools ranl
cccllcnily in cmloymcni suiialiliiy, lui iIcrc is a sicc dcclinc in qualiiy lcyond iIcsc
io-iicr scIools. 'Many so-callcd 'dcgrccs' jusi do noi Iavc iIc rigIi fundamcnial
cducaiion lcIind iIcm,'" according io onc Iuman rcsourccs rofcssional (Farrcll ci al.,
2005}. Mosi olscrvcrs agrcc iIai Indian univcrsiiics, wiiI a fcw ccciions, do noi
crform iIis signaling cffcci. A dcgrcc from any of iIcsc univcrsiiics could mcan anyiIing
in icrms of qualiiy". Onc furiIcr iccc of cvidcncc of collcgc dcgrccs noi roviding signaling
funciions is iIc significani cansion of ccriificaiion rograms from comanics sucI as
Microsofi in India TIc widc Icicrogcnciiy in qualiiy of univcrsiiics clains wIy only 25% of
Indian cnginccring graduaics arc considcrcd suiiallc for cmloymcni.
A consicuous camlc is FoIan MuriIy, son of Infosys's lcadcr Narayana MuriIy, wIo
wanicd io siudy ai an IIT, lui couldn'i gci in; Ic wcni io Corncll Univcrsiiy insicad, raiIcr
iIan an Indian collcgc (SiaIl, 2003}
|4|
. Enicring forcign cnginccring collcgcs ccmlifics iIc
cii from iIc Indian cnginccring marlci ly siudcnis willing io ay for IigI qualiiy
scIooling, iIc sccond ari of iIc advcrsc sclcciion rollcm. TIis rollcm Ias significani
lcalagc cicrnaliiy rollcms for India, as ii rcsulis in a so-callcd lrain drain. As noicd ly
Favindran (2005}, wiiI iIc dcmand and valuc Indian siudcnis lacc on Amcrican IigIcr
cducaiion, and wiiI iIc grcaicr availaliliiy of siudcni loans in India, iIcrc is lound io lc a
sicady incrcasc in siudcnis going io iIc Uniicd Siaics, as iIc invcsimcni will lc wcll woriI
ii in icrms of carccr ooriuniiics.
cncc, low qualiiy (in iIc lalor marlci scnsc} cnginccring scIooling Ias comc io
rcdominaic in iIc cducaiion marlci. TIc currcni siiuaiion, wiiI an alundancc of low
qualiiy cnginccring scIooling, is rojccicd io siiflc growiI of iIc Indian cconomy
(Clolalizaiion of Enginccring Scrviccs, 2006} |4|.
Industry-InstItute InteractIon Ior SustaInabIe DeveIopment: A Journey towards ExceIIence
Pagc 6 of S
TabIe 1: Growtb oI EngIneerIng coIIege In IndIa
Ycar Numlcr of Dcgrcc Collcgcs Numlcr of Incoming Siudcnis
199?-199S 562 134298
199S-1999 644 153151
1999-2000 755 179647
2000-2001 821 209115
2001-2002 1057 293814
2002-200 1195 356258
200-2004 1263 380803
2004-200 1358 450954
200-2006 1478 508595
FIgure : TOTAL NUMBER OF UNIVERSITIES
FIgure 4: TOTAL NO. OF COLLEGES & POLYTECHNICS
FIgure : TOTAL NUMBER OF STUDENTS ENROLLED IN PG LEVEL [(
28
222
17
104
3
33
409
0 30 100 130 200 230 300 330 400 430
CenLral unlverslLy
SLaLe unlverslLy
rlvaLe unlverslLy
ueemed unlverslLy
lnsLlLuLlon esLabllshed under sLaLe leglslaLure acL
lnsLlLuLlon of naLlonal lmporLance
LoLal
14146
3864
3284
2466
2230
1742
A81S SClLnCL CCMML8CL L1C
C1PL8
LuuCA1lCn
LnClnLL8lnC
MLulCAL
CL?1LCPnlCS
660316
382619
189603
123002
93183
78388
44430
31023
23696
11623
11461
C A81S
C SClLnCL
C CCMML8CL
C MAnACLMLn1 L1C
C LnCC/ A8CPl1LC1u8L
hu/ M hlll
C C1PL8S
C MLulClnL
C LuuCA1lCn
C LAW
C AC8lCuL1u8L
Vinay SIarma, Aiul Anand
Pagc ? of S
FIgure 6: TOTAL NUMBER OF STUDENTS ENROLLED IN UNDERGRADUATE LEVEL [(
STEPS FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT:
TIis dcvclomcni of oor qualiiy of cducaiion sysicm and lrain drain is duc io iIc lacl of
rocr olicy maling for Indian cducaiion sysicm. Ii was found iIai cvcry ycar ciiIcr wc
arc roducing a largc volumc of uncmloycd youiI (fig.6} wIo arc unsurc of iIcir fuiurc (as
wcll as unawarc of iIc imoriancc of iIcir dcgrcc} or a largc volumc of infcrior qualiiy
roduci Iaving IigI qualificaiion. Duc io iIis unlanncd dcvclomcni of cducaiion sysicm
iIc comlcic Indian sociciy is lcing affccicd. TIis Ias lcd iIc cducaicd youiI io aiiraci
iowards iIc casy way of carning moncy ly involving iIcm sclf in aniisocial aciiviiics.
Ii is iIcrcforc ncccssary iIai a rocr lanning of iIc cducaiion sysicm csccially iIc
TccInical cducaiion is rcquircd. In iIis rcgard iIc indusiry can lay a major rolc.
Somc of iIc major sics io lc ialcn arc.
1. A loiiom u aroacI raiIcr iIan io down aroacI is rcquircd, i.c. iniroduciion
of ncw collcgcs and coursc io lc madc lascd on iIc rcscni dcmand and cccicd
rcquircmcnis raiIcr iIan gcncraiing a largc volumc of uncmloycd youiI.
2. A lalanccd aroacI of Covcrnmcni iowards io dcvclomcni of all iIc diffcrcni
rcquircmcnis of iIc sociciy. As can lc sccn in figurc 6 wc arc Iaving fcwcr collcgcs
of mcdicinc, agriculiurc comarcd io aris and commcrcc.
3. Morc numlcr of vocaiional courscs as wcll as suori from indusiry and
govcrnmcni for dcvcloing sclf cmloymcni olicics
4. Indusiry io lc aciivc mcmlcr in all accrcdiiaiion and lanning commiiicc
5. Faciliiics of Educaiional Insiiiuic io lc madc availallc io indusirics (sccially
coiiagc and small scalc indusirics } io suori iIcm, wIicI can madc iIc uiilizaiion
of rcsourccs (macIinc & cquimcnis} io lc 100%
6. TIc ccriisc of Faculiics and siudcni sircngiI io lc uiiliscd io solvc indusirial
rollcms, sucI as.
Indusiry-insircd rojccis in-Iousc. TIcsc arc iIc rojccis, wIicI arc formulaicd
on iIc lasis of olscrvaiions of indusiry raciiccs, lui arc ncvcriIclcss noi
suoricd ly indusiry.
Indusiry-insircd and indusiry-sonsorcd rojccis. TIcsc arc iIc rojccis, wIicI
Iavc lccn rooscd and aciivcly suoricd ly indusiry. Suori may lc in iIc
form of funding iIc rojcci ly casI and lcnding in-lind suori ly allowing iIc
usc of manufaciuring faciliiics and acccss io ccri advicc. In somc cascs
siudcnis arc rcmuncraicd.
AnyiIing in-lciwccn. Ii is ossillc iIai indusiry may roosc rojcci idcas
wiiIoui commiiiing iisclf io funding suori. Similarly, acadcmics may iniiiaic
3108233
2000374
1699263
1663619
460490
273366
203377
181277
142728
81330
A81S
SClLnCL
CCMML8CL
LnCC/ A8CPl1LC1u8L
LuuCA1lCn
MLulClnL
LAW
MAnACLMLn1 L1C
C1PL8S
AC8lCuL1u8L
Industry-InstItute InteractIon Ior SustaInabIe DeveIopment: A Journey towards ExceIIence
Pagc S of S
rojccis on iIc lasis of iIcir own crcciions of sulsianiial mcrii of rojccis for
indusiry wiiIoui Iaving rocurcd indusiry suori. TIc laiicr oficn rovc io lc of
considcrallc valuc dcsiic ossillc iniiial misgivings as io iIcir valuc and
rclcvancc io indusiry in cconomic icrms.
ReIerence:
1. Majumdar SIyamal, Indusiry-Insiiiuic Inicraciion io Pullic-Privaic ParincrsIi. A Journcy io
Eccllcncc, Inicrnaiional Confcrcncc on Pullic Privaic ParincrsIi in TVET. CIallcngcs, Ooriuniiics
and Dcsi Praciiccs organizcd ly CPSC in collaloraiion wiiI InWcni (Ccrmany} & UNESCO-UNEVOC,
Dcccmlcr 1-2 , 2008, Manila, PIiliincs.
2. zdcmir Cl, Andrcw Nafalsli and Kcvin McDcrmoii, TIc Folc of Indusiry-Insircd Projccis in
Enginccring Educaiion" 31si ASEE/IEEE Froniicrs in Educaiion Confcrcncc, Ociolcr 10 - 13, 2001
Fcno, NV.
3. Siaiisiics of IigIcr & iccInical cducaiion (As on 30iI Scicmlcr, 2008}, Covcrnmcni of India, Minisiry of
uman Fcsourcc Dcvclomcni , Durcau of Planning, Moniioring & Siaiisiics, Ncw DclIi , 2011.
4. Lav F. VarsIncy, Privaic Enginccring Educaiion in India. Marlci Failurcs and Fcgulaiory Soluiions,
Scicncc, TccInology, and Pullic Policy, MassacIusciis Insiiiuic of TccInology, Novcmlcr 29, 2006.