Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Celebrating The Dead Sea Scrolls A Canadian Collection
Celebrating The Dead Sea Scrolls A Canadian Collection
a canadian collection
Society of Biblical Literature
Editorial Board
Mark J. Boda
George J. Brooke
Esther G. Chazon
Steven D. Fraade
Martha Himmelfarb
James S. McLaren
Jacques van Ruiten
Number 30
a canadian collection
Edited by
with
Twenty-Five Contributions by
Scholars of the Dead Sea Scrolls and Related Literature
All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form
or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or
by means of any information storage or retrieval system, except as may be expressly
permitted by the 1976 Copyright Act or in writing from the publisher. Requests for
permission should be addressed in writing to the Rights and Permissions Office, Society
of Biblical Literature, 825 Houston Mill Road, Atlanta, GA 30329 USA.
Celebrating the Dead Sea Scrolls : a Canadian collection / edited by Peter W. Flint,
Jean Duhaime, and Kyung S. Baek.
p. cm. — (Early Judaism and its literature ; no. 30)
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 978-1-58983-603-7 (paper binding : alk. paper)
1. Dead Sea scrolls. 2. Qumran community. I. Flint, Peter W. II. Duhaime, Jean.
III. Baek, Kyung S.
BM487.C425 2011b
296.1'55—dc23
2011042790
18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 5 4 3 2 1
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix
Terms, Sigla, and Abbreviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xv
Preface
Peter W. Flint and Jean Duhaime . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xxxvii
PART I
SURVEY OF CANADIAN SCHOLARSHIP AND PROJECTS
PART II
“BIBLICAL” SCROLLS AND TRANSMISSION
OF THE SCRIPTURES
9. The Biblical Dead Sea Scrolls and Second Temple Hebrew Syntax
Martin G. Abegg, Jr. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 163
PART III
THE QUMRAN COMMUNITY
16. The Motif of the Eschatological Battle in the War Scroll (1QM)
Ted M. Erho . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 359
PART IV
QUMRAN AND SECOND TEMPLE JUDAISM
editors
Peter W. Flint
Trinity Western University
Jean Duhaime
Université de Montréal
Kyung S. Baek
University of Manchester
authors
Martin G. Abegg, Jr., is Ben Zion Wacholder Professor of Dead Sea Scroll
studies at Trinity Western University. His most recent major publication is The
Dead Sea Scrolls Concordance III: The Biblical Texts from the Judaean Desert
(Leiden: Brill, 2009), with Edward Cook and James Bowley.
-ix-
x CONTRIBUTORS
critical translation of the Pesharim for the new bilingual edition of the Dead Sea
Scrolls, La bibliothèque de Qumrân (Paris, Cerf, 2008–).
Peter W. Flint is Canada Research Chair in Dead Sea Scrolls Studies, Trinity
Western University. He is the editor of over twenty-five Dead Sea Scrolls, most
recently, Eugene Ulrich and Peter W. Flint, Qumran Cave 1.II: The Isaiah Scrolls.
Part 1: Plates and Transcriptions; Part 2: Introductions, Commentary, and Textual
Variants (Oxford: Clarendon, 2010). He is currently preparing The Great Psalms
Scroll: A Full Edition for “Dead Sea Scrolls Editions” (Leiden: Brill), The Book
of Psalms: A New Edition, with Textual Notes and Commentary for the Oxford
Hebrew Bible, and The Book of Psalms for the series Biblia Qumranica (Leiden:
Brill).
Methods and Categories (Peabody, Mass.: Hendrickson, 2009); and Flavius Jose-
phus: Translation and Commentary. Vol. 1b: Judean War 2 (Leiden: Brill, 2008).
Benjamin H. Parker graduated with the M.A. degree, Trinity Western Univer-
sity. He was lead researcher for Ben Sira in English (Accordance module), trans-
lated by Benjamin H. Parker and Martin G. Abegg, Jr. (OakTree Soft ware, 2008).
Chad Martin Stauber is doing Ph.D. studies in the Department of Near and
Middle Eastern Civilizations at the University of Toronto. His areas of research
include the histories of First and Second Temple Palestine, with a concentration
on prophetic and apocalyptic literature. He is writing a dissertation on the War
Scroll (ca. 150 b.c.e.).
For most terms, sigla, and abbreviations of ancient authors, journals, reference
works, and other secondary sources, see The SBL Handbook of Style for Ancient
Near Eastern, Biblical, and Early Christian Studies, ed. P. H. Alexander et al.
(Peabody, Mass.: Hendrickson, 2009). For Qumran sigla, see also J. A. Fitzmyer,
A Guide to the Dead Sea Scrolls and Related Literature. Revised & expanded edi-
tion (Studies in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Related Literature; Grand Rapids: Eerd-
mans, 2008).
Several entries are grouped together: most notably, Classical and Patristic
(Greek and Latin) authors, Dead Sea Scrolls, Greek (Septuagint) manuscripts and
editions, works by Josephus and Philo, and Rabbinic writings.
-xv-
xvi TERMS, SIGLA, AND ABBREVIATIONS
Curtius Rufus
Hist. Alex. Historiae Alexandri Magni (Histories of Alexander the
Great)
Dionysius of Halicarnassus
Ant. rom. Antiquitates romanae (Roman Antiquities)
Epiphanius
Pan Panarion (Medicine Chest). Also known as Adversus
haereses (Against Heresies)
Eusebius
Onom. Onomasticon (On the Place-Names in Holy Scripture)
Praep. ev. Praeparatio evangelica (Preparation for the Gospel)
Galen
Antid. De Antidotis (On Antidotes)
Comp. med. De compositione medicamentorum per genera (On the
Composition of Drugs according to Kind)
Pis. ther. De theriaca ad pisonem (On Theriac to Piso)
Simpl. med. temp. De simplicium medicamentorum temperamentis ac
facultatibus (On the Powers of Simple remedies)
Sympt. caus. De symptomatum causis (On the Causes of Symptoms)
Herodotus
Hist. Historiae (The Histories)
Horace
Ep. Epistulae (Epistles)
Lactantius
Div. inst. Divinarum institutionum libri VII (The Divine Institutes)
Lucian
Nigr. Nigrinus (Nigrinus)
Peregr. De Morte Peregrini (On the Passing of Peregrinus)
Marcus Aurelius
Med. Meditations
Musonius Rufus
Diss. Dissertationum a Lucio digestarum reliquiae (Remains of
Discourses Reported by Lucius)
Petronius
Sat. Satyricon
Ovid
Ars amat. Ars amatoria (The Art of Love)
Plato
Resp. Respublica (The Republic)
Pliny the Elder
Nat. Naturalis historia (Natural History)
Pliny the Younger
Ep. Epistulae (Letters)
xviii TERMS, SIGLA, AND ABBREVIATIONS
Plutarch
Ages. Agesilaus
Brut. Brutus
Lyc. Lycurgus
Mor. Moralia (Moral Writings)
Porphyry
Vit. Pyth. Vita Pythagorae (On the Life of Pythagoras)
Pseudo-Scylax
Peripl. Periplus (A Sailing Around)
Quintillian
Inst. Institutio oratoria (Institutes of Oratory)
Seneca
Dial. Dialogi (Dialogues)
Epp. Epistulae morales (Moral Epistles)
Soranus of Ephesus
Gyn. Gynaeciorum (Gynaecology, or On Midwifery and the
Diseases of Women)
Suetonius
Tit. Divus Titus (The Divine Titus)
Tacitus
Agric. De vita et moribus Iulii Agricolae (On the life and
character of Julius Agricola)
Ann. Annales (The Annals)
Tibullus
El. Elegiae (Elegies)
Xenophon
Ages. Agesilaus (Agesilaus)
Lac. Respublica Lacedaemoniorum (Constitution of the
Spartans)
Dead Sea Scrolls (Scrolls from the Judean Desert)
(For a complete list, see the Index of Dead Sea Scrolls and Related Texts)
From the Cairo Genizah:
CD The Damascus Document (or, Damascus Rule)
From Qumran:
1QHa Thanksgiving Hymns (1QHodayot)
1QpHab Pesher Habakkuk
1QIsaa The Great Isaiah Scroll
1QS Community Rule (or, Serek Hayahad, 1Q28)
1QSa The Rule of the Congregation (1Q28a, Appendix a to 1QS)
1QSb (The Rule of the) Blessings (1Q28b, Appendix b to 1QS)
1Q2 Exodus
1Q8 The Hebrew University Isaiah Scroll (1QIsab)
1Q13 Phylactery (1QPhyl)
TERMS, SIGLA, AND ABBREVIATIONS xix
4Q139 Phylactery L
4Q140 Phylactery M
4Q141 Phylactery N
4Q142 Phylactery O
4Q143 Phylactery P
4Q144 Phylactery Q
4Q145 Phylactery R
4Q146 Phylactery S
4Q147 Phylactery T
4Q148 Phylactery U
4Q158 Reworked Pentateuch (4QRPa)
4Q159 Ordinances (Orda)
4Q160 The Vision of Samuel (VisSam)
4Q161 Pesher Isaiaha (pIsaa)
4Q162 Pesher Isaiahb (pIsab)
4Q163 papyrus Pesher Isaiahc (pap pIsac)
4Q164 Pesher Isaiahd (pIsad)
4Q165 Pesher Isaiahe (pIsae)
4Q166 Pesher Hoseaa (pHosa)
4Q167 Pesher Hoseab (pHosb)
4Q168 Pesher Micah? (pMic?)
4Q169 Pesher Nahum (pNah)
4Q170 Pesher Zephaniah (pZeph)
4Q171 Pesher Psalmsa (pPsa)
4Q172 Pesher Unidentified (pUnid)
4Q173 Pesher Psalmsb (pPsb)
4Q174 Florilegum (or, MidrEschata?)
4Q175 Testimonia
4Q176 Tanhumim
4Q176a Jubileesi?
4Q177 Catena A (or, MidrEschatb?)
4Q178 Unclassified fragments (or, MidrEschatd? Duhaime: fragments de
pesharim non identifiés)
4Q179 Lamentations Apocryphon A (apocrLam A)
4Q180 Ages of Creation A (AgesCreat A)
4Q181 Ages of Creation B (AgesCreat B)
4Q182 Catena B (or, MidrEschatc?)
4Q183 Historical Work (MidrEschate?)
4Q184 Wiles of the Wicked Woman
4Q185 Sapiental Work
4Q186 Horoscope
4Q196 papyrus Aramaic Tobita (papToba ar)
4Q197 Aramaic Tobitb (Tobb ar)
xxii TERMS, SIGLA, AND ABBREVIATIONS
8Q3 Phylactery
11Q1 Leviticus (11QpaleoLeva)
11Q5 The Great Psalms Scrolla (Psa)
11Q10 Targum of Job (tgJob)
11Q11 Apocryphal Psalms (apocrPs)
11Q12 Jubilees
11Q13 Melchizedek
11Q14 Sefer ha-Milhamah
11Q17 Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice (ShirShabb )
11Q18 Aramaic New Jerusalem Text (NJ ar)
11Q19 Temple Scrolla (Ta)
11Q20 Temple Scrollb (Tb)
XQ1–4 Four Phylacteries from (an) uncertain cave(s) at Qumran
From Murabba‘at:
Mur 1 Genesis (MurGen)
Mur 4 Phylactery
Mur 88 Minor Prophets Scroll (MurXII)
From Naḥal Ḥever or Wadi Seiyal:
5/6Ḥev/Se 1a Numbers scroll from Caves 5–6 (5/6Ḥev Numbersa)
5/6Ḥev/Se 1b Psalms scroll from Caves 5–6 (5/6Ḥev Psalms)
8Ḥev 1 The Greek Minor Prophets Scroll from Cave 8 (8ḤevXII gr)
XḤev/Se 2 Numbers scroll from an uncertain cave (XḤev/Se Numbersb)
XḤev/Se 3 Deuteronomy scroll from an uncertain cave (XḤev/Se Deut)
XḤev/Se 5 Phylactery from an uncertain cave
34Se 1 Phylactery from Cave 34 at Wadi Seiyal
From Masada:
Mas1b Leviticus (MasLevb)
Mas1d Ezekiel (MasEzek)
Mas1e Psalmsa (Psa)
Mas1k Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice (ShirShabb)
diss. dissertation
DSS Dead Sea Scrolls
DSSB-M Dead Sea Scrolls Biblical Texts, Manuscript Order (Accordance
Bible Software)
ed(s). edition, editor(s), or edited
e.g. exempli gratia, for example
ET English translation
et al. et alii, and others
frg(s). or frag(s). fragment(s)
Greek (Septuagint) Manuscripts and Editions
G (or LXX) The old Greek (as in the Göttingen editions)
G* The (recontructed) original reading of the Old Greek
GB (see also Q) Codex Vaticanus
xxviii TERMS, SIGLA, AND ABBREVIATIONS
This volume has its origin in a Symposium held October 11–13, 2007, at Trinity
Western University in Langley, British Columbia, to celebrate the sixtieth anni-
versary of the discovery of the first Dead Sea Scrolls at Qumran in 1947, and to
discuss the current work that Canadians are doing on these texts. Over three
days, papers were presented by thirteen scholars on a broad range of topics.
From the outset, it was the intention that the papers would be published. With
the encouragment of several colleagues, and appreciating this rare opportunity,
the editors determined to produce a wider volume showcasing Dead Sea Scrolls
scholarship throughout Canada. As a result, invitations were issued to several
more colleagues teaching at Canadian universities and colleges whose main
focus of research is the Dead Sea Scrolls, or who make use of the scrolls in related
research areas. Virtually every invitation was accepted.
As may be seen in the Table of Contents, Celebrating the Dead Sea Scrolls: A
Canadian Collection comprises twenty-five essays by twenty-eight scholars (three
being joint works). These include prominent Dead Sea Scrolls specialists, others
who use the scrolls in their research, senior scholars, more junior scholars, and a
few graduate students (whose essays were carefully vetted before being accepted).
Most contributors teach at universities and colleges across Canada, with the fol-
lowing provinces represented (from east to west): Nova Scotia, Quebec, Ontario,
Alberta, and British Columbia. It seems fitting at this point to offer regrets to
other scholars teaching at Canadian institutions who use the scrolls in their
research, for not extending an invitation to them. Our intention was to be as
inclusive as possible, but even as the volume goes to press one or two eligible
names come to mind.
Readers will note that several contributors are from institutions outside of
Canada, which merits an explanation. The inclusion of Emanuel Tov (Hebrew
University) and Eugene Ulrich (University of Notre Dame) is a boon to any Dead
Sea Scrolls publication, in their respective capacities as Editor-in-Chief and Chief
Editor of the Biblical Scrolls. Jason Kalman (Hebrew Union College, Cincinnati,
and University of the Free State) and Jaqueline S. du Toit (University of the Free
State) were invited in view of their recent book on Robert B. Y. Scott and McGill
University’s purchase of many Cave 4 scrolls. Cecilia Wassen was teaching at
Wilfrid Laurier University when her paper was submitted; she has since moved
to Uppsala University in Sweden. Daniel K. Falk (teaching at the University of
Oregon) is from Abbotsford, B.C., and is a prominent member of the West Coast
Dead Sea Scrolls Study Group, with members from British Columbia, Oregon,
-xxxvii-
xxxviii PREFACE
and California. Finally, following his M.A. degree at Trinity Western University,
Ted M. Erho is now completing the Ph.D. program at Durham University.
The twenty-five essays have been grouped under four headings. In the first
section, “Survey of Canadian Scholarship and Projects,” Eileen Schuller chron-
icles several aspects of Canadian scholarship on the scrolls from the early 1950s
to the present: acquisition, research, publication, teaching, and public dissemina-
tion. Her panoramic view is supplemented, on the one hand, by further details
on the pioneering work of Robert B. Y. Scott provided by Jason Kalman and
Jaqueline du Toit and, on the other hand, by Jean Duhaime’s description of a
new edition of the Dead Sea Scrolls, La Bibliothèque de Qumrân, being prepared
by an international team that includes scholars and graduate students from the
province of Quebec.
The seven essays of the second section discuss issues related to the “biblical”
scrolls and the transmission of “Scripture.” Providing a preliminary new edi-
tion of Reworked Pentateuch (4Q158), Andrew B. Perrin demonstrates how texts
already available in the official Discoveries in the Judaean Desert (DJD) series
can benefit from an analysis that fully integrates information from all available
witnesses to the biblical text. Benjamin H. Parker identifies a group of tefillin
from various locations around the Dead Sea and concludes from their shared
characteristics that they most likely were the product of the same specialized
scribal school. Peter W. Flint and Kyung S. Baek discuss the various photogra-
phers of the Great Isaiah Scroll from Cave 1 and the images that were considered
and used for the new critical edition in the DJD series (vol. 32). Eugene Ulrich
examines and assesses the contribution of all the Isaiah Scrolls to the study of
the Old Greek translation of Isaiah. Manuel Jinbachian compares the Masoretic
Text of the book of Micah with the Greek rendering in the Septuagint in order to
establish the text underlying the latter and to find out how other ancient transla-
tions, if they indeed had the same basic text, understood and rendered it. On the
basis of a careful study of five types of variations from the Masoretic Text among
the biblical Hebrew manuscripts from the Judean Desert, Martin G. Abegg, Jr.,
explains how these scrolls can teach us much about the syntax of Post-Biblical
Hebrew. In the chapter concluding this section, Emanuel Tov explains and illus-
trates an innovative didactic presentation of his own showing the differences
among various groups of biblical Dead Sea Scrolls in relation to the Masoretic
Text, the Samaritan Pentateuch, and other ancient sources.
The third section combines nine essays focused on the Qumran community
and texts specific to it. The archaeological site of Qumran and the scrolls found
nearby are often associated with the Essenes described by Philo of Alexandria,
Flavius Josephus, Pliny the Elder, and the orator Dio. In the most detailed essay
of the book, Classics scholar Steve Mason rather holds that a fresh look at these
ancient notices, studied in their own right, leads to challenging conclusions.
Daniel K. Falk offers a systemic description of the religious way of life at Qum-
ran as revealed by its mythology, ritual practices, ethics and relationships, and
PREFACE xxxix
website, which is widely known to contain many resources essential for bibli-
cal scholarship and is frequently visited by scholars. This publisher also has the
capacity to include the photographs and pages with colored transcriptions that
feature in the volume. Finally, the editors and the SBL believe that this publica-
tion will strengthen the already firm ties between the Society of Biblical Litera-
ture and its many Canadian members.
Two contributions presented special challenges of a technical nature. First,
Emanuel Tov’s essay on many biblical scrolls breaks new ground with respect to
technology, since the author includes thirty-eight pages with multiple colors that
are essential to his discussion. Eight of these are published in the Appendix to his
essay, and all thirty-eight are on the Bookpage for the volume at www.sbl-site.
org. Second, in light of the publication of the Cave 1 Isaiah Scrolls as the final vol-
ume (32) in the DJD series, the essay by Peter Flint and Kyung Baek includes eight
photographs of the Great Isaiah Scroll, most of them in color. Incorporating color
photographs in any academic publication is rare because of the expense involved,
but in this case the editors were successful in collaboration with the SBL.
Four of the essays are in French, as well as abstracts of all the English arti-
cles. The editors are committed to publishing a French edition of the entire vol-
ume, which is in preparation and under contract with Médiaspaul Publishers in
Montreal. A complete set of French abstracts for all twenty-five essays is featured
on the Bookpage on the SBL website, as well as further information on the French
edition.
*****
Several organizations and individuals have our lasting gratitude. The 2007 Sym-
posium that gave rise to the volume was sponsored by the Canada Research Chair
in Dead Sea Scrolls Studies, Trinity Western University, and the Canadian Bible
Society. Funding for the volume was provided by the Canada Research Chair.
In addition, a portion of the grant from the Social Sciences and Humanities
Research Council of Canada that supports the research team based in Montreal
was allocated to publication of the essays by Francis Daoust, Robert David with
Éric Bellavance, Marie-France Dion, and Jean Duhaime. We also extend thanks
to the Society of Biblical Literature, both for including the volume in the EJL
series and for their help and patience in bringing it to publication: especially
Series Editor Judith H. Newman, Managing Editor Leigh Andersen, and Edito-
rial Director Bob Buller. Finally to our research assistants, without whom the
entire academic enterprise would be far more difficult: Kyung Baek for over-
seeing much of the project, as well as Kyle Biersdorff, Dan McClellan, Matthew
Whitehead, and Michael Johnson.
*****
We are proud to present this Canadian collection, which exemplifies the impor-
tance of the Dead Sea Scrolls for our understanding of the formation and trans-
mission of the Hebrew Scriptures and our knowledge of religious groups and
PREFACE xli
ideas during the Second Temple period. In the seventh decade since the discovery
of the first scrolls, this book is offered as a tribute to the pioneers who first dared
to explore this new area of research, and to the numerous scholars who followed
them over the next six decades. It also serves as an invitation to the next genera-
tion of students of early Judaism to bring their fresh expertise to this rich and
fascinating area of research.
Peter W. Flint
Religous Studies
Trinity Western University, British Columbia
Jean Duhaime
Théologie et sciences des religions
Université de Montréal
31 August, 2011