12/6/23, 4:05 AM ‘Bait and switch’: Liz Cheney book tears into Mike Johnson over pro-Trump January

ro-Trump January 6 brief | Books | The Guardian

Books

‘Bait and switch’: Liz Cheney book tears into

Mike Johnson over pro-Trump January 6
brief
Oath and Honor, obtained by the Guardian ahead of release, says
House speaker snuck baseless claims of electoral fraud past
Republican signatories

Liz Cheney’s book accuses Mike Johnson of ‘being less than honest’. Photograph: Mark Makela/Reuters

Martin Pengelly in Washington

@MartinPengelly
Wed 29 Nov 2023 10.32 EST

In a new book, the anti-Trump Republican Liz Cheney accuses Mike

Johnson of dishonesty over both the authorship of a supreme court brief
in support of Donald Trump’s attempt to overthrow the 2020 election and
the document’s contents, saying the congressman, who is now US House
speaker, duped his party with a “bait and switch”.

“As I read the amicus brief – which was poorly written

– it became clear Mike was being less than honest,” Cheney writes. “He
was playing bait and switch, assuring members that the brief made no
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2023/nov/29/speaker-mike-johnson-dishonest-january-6-brief-liz-cheney-book 1/9
12/6/23, 4:05 AM ‘Bait and switch’: Liz Cheney book tears into Mike Johnson over pro-Trump January 6 brief | Books | The Guardian

claims about specific allegations of [electoral] fraud when, in fact, it was

full of such claims.”

Cheney also says Johnson was neither the author of the brief nor a
“constitutional law expert”, as he was “telling colleagues he was”. Pro-
Trump lawyers actually wrote the document, Cheney writes.

In a statement to the Guardian, a spokesperson for Johnson said Cheney

was “not presenting an accurate portrayal”.

As Trump’s attempts to overturn his defeat by Joe Biden progressed

towards the deadly January 6 attack on Congress, Cheney was a House
Republican leader. Turning against Trump, she sat on the House January 6
committee and was ostracised by her party, losing her Wyoming seat last
year.

Her book, Oath and Honor: A Memoir and a Warning, will be published
next week. The Guardian obtained a copy.

Johnson became speaker last month, after McCarthy was ejected by the
Trumpist far right, the first House speaker ever removed by his own party.

On Tuesday, CNN ran excerpts from Cheney’s book, quoting her view that
Johnson “appeared especially susceptible to flattery from Trump and
aspired to being anywhere in Trump’s orbit”.

CNN also reported that Cheney writes: “When I confronted him with the
flaws in his legal arguments, Johnson would often concede, or say
something to the effect of, ‘We just need to do this one last thing for
Trump.’”

But Cheney’s portrait of Johnson’s manoeuvres is more comprehensive

and arguably considerably more damning.

The case in which the amicus brief was filed saw Republican states led by
Texas attempt to persuade the supreme court to side with Trump over his
electoral fraud lies.

It did not. As Cheney points out, even the two most rightwing justices,
Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas, who wanted to hear the case, said
they would not have sided with the complainants.

Cheney describes how Johnson, then Republican study committee chair,

emailed GOP members on 9 December 2020 to say Trump had

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2023/nov/29/speaker-mike-johnson-dishonest-january-6-brief-liz-cheney-book 2/9
12/6/23, 4:05 AM ‘Bait and switch’: Liz Cheney book tears into Mike Johnson over pro-Trump January 6 brief | Books | The Guardian

“specifically” asked him to request all Republicans in Congress “join on to

our brief”.

Johnson, Cheney says, insisted he was not trying to pressure people and
simply wanted to show support for Trump, by “affirm[ing] for the court
(and our constituents back home) our serious concerns with the integrity
of our electoral system” and seeking “careful, timely review”.

“Mike was seriously misleading our members,” Cheney writes. “The brief
did assert as facts known to the amici many allegations of fraud and serious
wrongdoing by officials in multiple states.”

Johnson, she says, then told Republicans that 105 House members had
expressed interest. “Not one of them had seen the brief,” Cheney writes.
She also says he added “a new inaccurate claim”, that state officials had
been “clearly shown” to have violated the constitution.

“But virtually all those claims had already been heard by the courts and
decided against Trump.”

Calling the brief “poorly written”, Cheney says she doubted Johnson’s
honesty and asked him who wrote it, as “to assert facts in a federal court
without personal knowledge” would “present ethical questions for
anyone who is a member of the bar”.

The general counsel to McCarthy, then Republican minority leader, told

Cheney that McCarthy would not sign the brief, while McCarthy’s chief of
staff also called it “a bait and switch”. McCarthy told her he would not
sign on. When the brief was filed, McCarthy had not signed it. But “less
than 24 hours later, a revised version … bore the names of 20 additional
members. Among them was Kevin McCarthy.

“Mike Johnson blamed a ‘clerical error’ … [which] was also the rationale
given to the supreme court for the revised filing. In fact, McCarthy had
first chosen not to be on the brief, then changed his mind, likely because
of pressure from Trump.”

It took the court a few hours to reject the Texas suit. But the saga was not
over. Trump continued to seek to overturn his defeat, culminating in the
deadly attack on Congress on 6 January 2021 by supporters whom he told
to “fight like hell”.

Cheney takes other shots at Johnson. But in picking apart his role in the
amicus brief, she strikes close to claims made for his legal abilities as he

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2023/nov/29/speaker-mike-johnson-dishonest-january-6-brief-liz-cheney-book 3/9
12/6/23, 4:05 AM ‘Bait and switch’: Liz Cheney book tears into Mike Johnson over pro-Trump January 6 brief | Books | The Guardian

grasped the speaker’s gavel last month. Johnson “was telling our
colleagues he was a constitutional law expert, while advocating positions
that were constitutionally infirm”, Cheney writes.

Citing conversations with other Republicans about Johnson’s “lawsuit

gimmick” (as she says James Comer of Kentucky, now House oversight
chair, called it), Cheney says she “ultimately learned” that Johnson did
not write the brief.

“A team of lawyers who were also apparently advising Trump had in fact
drafted [it],” she writes. “Mike Johnson had left the impression that he
was responsible for the brief, but he was just carrying Trump’s water.”

A spokesperson for Johnson said: “Unfortunately, Ms

Cheney is not presenting an accurate portrayal of those events. And while
he does not plan to purchase a copy of Oath and Honor, Speaker Johnson
wishes former representative Cheney and her family the best in whatever
her future endeavours may be.”

Earlier, responding to CNN, a Trump spokesperson said Cheney’s book

belonged “in the fiction section of the bookstore”.

Cheney also considers the run-up to January 6 and the historic day itself.
Before it, she writes, she and Johnson discussed mounting danger of
serious unrest. He agreed, she says, but cited support for Trump among
Republican voters as a reason not to abandon the president. Such support
from Johnson and other senior Republicans, Cheney writes, allowed
Trump to create a full-blown crisis.

Two and a half years on, notwithstanding 91 criminal charges, 17 for

election subversion, Trump is the clear frontrunner for the Republican
presidential nomination. He polls close to or ahead of Biden.

In certain circumstances, close elections can be thrown to the House –

which Mike Johnson now controls.

$0 $1,500,000
contributions our goal

I hope you appreciated this article. Before you move on, I wanted to ask if you
would consider supporting the Guardian’s journalism as we prepare for one of the

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2023/nov/29/speaker-mike-johnson-dishonest-january-6-brief-liz-cheney-book 4/9
12/6/23, 4:05 AM ‘Bait and switch’: Liz Cheney book tears into Mike Johnson over pro-Trump January 6 brief | Books | The Guardian

most consequential news cycles of our lifetimes. We need your help to raise $1.5m
to fund our reporting in 2024.
From Elon Musk to Rupert Murdoch, a small number of billionaire owners have a
powerful hold on so much of the information that reaches the public about what’s
happening in the world. The Guardian is different. We have no billionaire owner or
shareholders to consider. Our journalism is produced to serve the public interest –
not profit motives.

And we avoid the trap that befalls much US media – the tendency, born of a desire
to please all sides, to engage in false equivalence in the name of neutrality. While
fairness guides everything we do, we know there is a right and a wrong position in
the fight against racism and for reproductive justice. When we report on issues
like the climate crisis, we’re not afraid to name who is responsible. And as a global
news organization, we’re able to provide a fresh, outsider perspective on US
politics – one so often missing from the insular American media bubble.
Around the world, readers can access the Guardian’s paywall-free journalism
because of our unique reader-supported model. That’s because of people like you.
Our readers keep us independent, beholden to no outside influence and accessible
to everyone – whether they can afford to pay for news, or not.
If you can, please consider supporting us with a year-end gift from $1. Thank
you.

Betsy Reed
Editor, Guardian US

One-time Monthly Annual

$5 per month $7 per month Other

Continue Remind me on New Years Eve

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2023/nov/29/speaker-mike-johnson-dishonest-january-6-brief-liz-cheney-book 5/9