Gouri, [19-10-2023 20:17]

Principles Governing International Investment Law and Their Interrelationships

International investment law is a specialized field of law that deals with the rights and obligations of
foreign investors and host states in the context of international investments. It is primarily governed
by a set of key principles and rules that have evolved through bilateral investment treaties (BITs),
multilateral agreements, and customary international law. As a practicing law student pursuing an
LLM degree in India, it is essential to understand these principles and their interrelationships in the
context of international investment law.

The principles that primarily govern international investment law and its implementation can be
broadly categorized into the following:

Promotion and Protection of Foreign Investment: A core principle of international investment law is
the promotion and protection of foreign investment. This principle is primarily achieved through the
following sub-principles:

Non-Discrimination: The principle of non-discrimination ensures that foreign investors are treated no
less favorably than domestic investors or investors from other countries. This principle is often
expressed through the concept of national treatment and most-favored-nation treatment.

Fair and Equitable Treatment (FET): FET is a fundamental principle that obliges host states to provide
foreign investors with a stable and predictable legal and business environment. It ensures that
investors are not subjected to arbitrary or discriminatory measures that could harm their
investments.

Full Protection and Security: Host states are obligated to provide full protection and security to
foreign investors and their investments. This principle implies that states must take measures to
prevent physical harm or damage to investments and ensure that investors are not exposed to undue
risks.

Expropriation and Compensation: The principle of expropriation governs the circumstances under
which a host state may take measures that effectively deprive an investor of their investment. States
are generally allowed to expropriate for public purposes, but compensation must be prompt,
adequate, and effective.
Free Transfer of Funds: Foreign investors should be able to transfer their capital and profits in and
out of the host state without undue restrictions. This principle ensures that investors do not face
obstacles in repatriating their earnings.

Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS): Another crucial aspect of international investment law is
the mechanism for resolving disputes between foreign investors and host states. This principle
encompasses various sub-principles, including:

Arbitration: The majority of investment treaties provide for international arbitration as the preferred
method for resolving disputes. This allows investors to bring claims against host states before
impartial arbitral tribunals.

Consent to Arbitration: The principle of consent is fundamental in ISDS. A foreign investor must have
the host state's consent to initiate arbitration, which is usually granted through the treaty's dispute
settlement provisions.

Enforceability of Awards: Investment arbitration awards are generally enforceable in national courts
of other countries, which adds to the effectiveness of ISDS.

State Sovereignty and Regulatory Autonomy: While international investment law promotes and
protects foreign investment, it also acknowledges the sovereignty and regulatory autonomy of host
states. These principles interact with the promotion and protection of foreign investment as follows:

Right to Regulate: Host states have the right to regulate and legislate in the public interest, including
for environmental, health, and social reasons. However, the exercise of this right must be done in a
non-discriminatory and proportionate manner.

Investor Obligations: Foreign investors are expected to comply with the laws and regulations of the
host state.

Gouri, [19-10-2023 20:17]

This means that while they are entitled to certain protections, they are also subject to the host
state's legal framework.

Sustainable Development: The principle of sustainable development is increasingly being

incorporated into international investment law. It recognizes that investments should contribute to
the economic, social, and environmental well-being of the host state. This principle influences
various aspects, including:

Environmental Standards: Investments should adhere to environmental standards, and states are
encouraged to adopt measures for environmental protection without unduly burdening investors.

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR): Investors are encouraged to engage in CSR practices that
promote social and environmental sustainability.

Public Interest: The host state's right to regulate in the public interest is balanced with the promotion
of sustainable development, ensuring that investment activities do not harm the welfare of its
citizens or environment.

Interrelationships Between Principles Governing International Investment Law

The principles governing international investment law are interconnected and interdependent. They
create a framework that seeks to balance the interests of host states in regulating their territories
and the interests of foreign investors in securing their investments. The interrelationships between
these principles can be explored as follows:

Non-Discrimination, FET, and Sustainable Development:

Non-discrimination, as embodied in national treatment and most-favored-nation treatment, supports

the principle of fair and equitable treatment (FET). By ensuring that foreign investors are not treated
less favorably than domestic investors, these principles contribute to a stable and predictable
investment environment, which is a core component of FET.

The principle of sustainable development underlines the importance of responsible and balanced
investment. Sustainable development can be seen as a component of FET, as it necessitates that
investments do not cause harm to the environment or public welfare. The host state's efforts to
promote sustainability can align with the objectives of non-discrimination and FET.

State Sovereignty, Regulatory Autonomy, and Investor-State Dispute Settlement:

The principle of state sovereignty and the right to regulate is not incompatible with ISDS. Host states
retain their regulatory autonomy, and ISDS is designed to address exceptional cases where the state's
actions adversely affect foreign investors. ISDS serves as a mechanism to hold states accountable
when their conduct breaches the standards established in investment treaties.

The consent to arbitration principle, a key element of ISDS, ensures that states maintain control over
whether they will be subjected to arbitration. By agreeing to include ISDS provisions in investment
treaties, states affirm their willingness to resolve disputes through arbitration, thereby reconciling
their regulatory autonomy with a dispute resolution mechanism.

Expropriation and Compensation, and Right to Regulate:

The principle of expropriation and compensation intersects with the right to regulate. While
expropriation is permissible under international investment law, it must be carried out for a public
purpose and with prompt, adequate, and effective compensation. This principle acknowledges the
host state's legitimate need to expropriate for the public interest.

The right to regulate is respected even in cases of expropriation, as long as it complies with the
principles of necessity and proportionality. The host state may expropriate in pursuit of public policy
objectives, such as health and safety, as long as it meets the criteria of international law and provides
fair compensation.

Promotion and Protection of Foreign Investment, and Sustainable Development:

The principle of promoting and protecting foreign investment should be seen in light of sustainable
development objectives.

Gouri, [19-10-2023 20:17]

While the former focuses on the interests of investors and their investments, the latter encompasses
a broader perspective that considers the impact of investments on the environment and society.

Sustainable development principles can be integrated into investment treaties to encourage

investments that contribute positively to the well-being of the host state. This integration seeks to
balance investor rights with the host state's responsibility to safeguard public interest and
sustainability.

In summary, international investment law is guided by a set of interconnected principles that aim to
create a balanced framework for the promotion and protection of foreign investments. These
principles interact with each other, with state sovereignty, and with the objectives of sustainable
development. Understanding the interrelationships between these principles is crucial for legal
practitioners and scholars in the field of international investment law. As a practicing law student in
India, this knowledge is valuable, as India is both a host state for foreign investments and a party to
numerous investment treaties, making the principles of international investment law highly relevant
in practice and academic research.