Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 33

PERFORMANCE MENU

JOURNAL OF HEALTH & ATHLETIC EXCELLENCE

RED MEAT
THE SNATCH
MINDFULNESS
OVERHEAD STABILITY
ISSUE 194 MARCH 2021

ENVIRONMENT VS PROGRAMMING
INTERVIEW: FRED LOWE
The Performance Menu is published monthly in digital format by
Catalyst Athletics, Inc.

Subscriptions
Subscriptions to the Performance Menu are available at
www.performancemenu.com/subscribe/
On the Cover
Back Issues
Amanda Braddock
Purchase back issues at www.performancemenu.com/issues/
Editor in Chief
Individual Articles
Greg Everett
Individual articles from the Performance Menu can be purchased
online at www.performancemenu.com/articles/
Managing Editor
Yael Grauer
Copyright Notice
All content copyright Catalyst Athletics, Inc and its respective
Design
authors. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution is prohibited
Greg Everett
by law.
Issue Layout
Excerpts
Alyssa Sulay
Catalyst Athletics authorizes the publication of brief excerpts
(500 words or less) along with easily visible attribution to the au-
thor and The Performance Menu. Attributions for online excerpts
Catalyst Athletics, Inc.
must include a hyperlink to www.performancemenu.com, option-
catalystathletics.com
ally but preferably directly to the article excerpted.

Disclaimers
The statements and comments in the Performance Menu are
those of the authors and not of the Performance Menu or Cata-
lyst Athletics, Inc. Catalyst Athletics, Inc. and its contributors
do not make any claim or warranty regarding the safety of any
exercise or nutrition information contained herein. Readers are
encouraged to consult with their physicians before engaging in
any physical activity or nutritional practices. The appearance of
advertising in this publication is not necessarily an endorsement
of the products or services being advertised.
PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194 VOLUME 17

MARCH 2021
FEATURES
8 Environment vs. Programming: Which is More Important?
14 Mindfulness in Olympic Weightlifting: A Practical Guide, Part 3
17 Overhead Stability: How To Get It & How To Keep It Once You Have It
21 Red Meat is NOT Bad for You: Part 1
25 Observations of The Snatch and Different Body Types

REGULARS
6 Ask Greg
29 Interview
CONTRIBUTORS
Matt Foreman is the football and track & field coach at Mountain View High School in Phoenix, AZ. A competitive weightliter for
twenty years, Foreman is a four-time National Championship bronze medalist, two-time American Open silver medalist, three-
time American Open bronze medalist, two-time National Collegiate Champion, 2004 US Olympic Trials competitor, 2000 World
University Championship Team USA competitor, and Arizona and Washington state record-holder. He was also First Team All-
Region high school football player, lettered in high school wrestling and track, a high school national powerlifting champion, and
a Scottish Highland Games competitor. Foreman has coached multiple regional, state, and national champions in track & field,
powerlifting, and weightlifting, and was an assistant coach on 5A Arizona state runner-up football and track teams.

Greg Everett is the owner of Catalyst Athletics, publisher of The Performance Menu and author of Olympic Weightlifting: A
Complete Guide for Athletes & Coaches.

Cheng Xu is a Catalyst Athletics Level II certified coach and nationally ranked competitive athlete. He has served for nine and
a half years as an infantry officer and paratrooper in the Canadian Armed Forces. He is currently pursuing his PhD and is the
head coach and owner of RX Weightlifting Club in Toronto, Canada. He can be reached on Instagram @Liftingproblems or @
Rxweightliftingclub.

Hannah Gray is a certified personal trainer, writer, and strength athlete (weightlifting and powerlifting). When she isn’t in the
gym working with clients or training herself, she is hanging with her two teenage daughters, writing, playing music or engaging
in bizarre experimental cooking. You can find her on IG @grayareastrength, on Facebook (Hannah Gray), or online at www.
grayareastrength.com.

Andrew Aussem holds a Bachelor of Science in Kinesiology and has held several professional positions requiring ongoing
knowledge of a range of medical conditions. A personal change in his lifestyle seven years ago led Andrew to pursue his Master
of Science in Holistic Nutrition. With only his thesis remaining, he looks forward to starting his own practice. Andrew also
operates the wellness blog thebarefootgolfer.com, where he combines many of his passions in articles covering everything from
ancestral nutritional to exercise to golf.

Jenny Lutkins is a USA Weightlifting Advanced Sports Performance Coach, Certified CrossFit Trainer (Level 3), and Tennessee
State record holder for Women’s 87+, 40-44 age group. She is currently the head coach at Anchor Weightlifting Club at Whole
Strength CrossFit.
ASK GREG
Send your questions to Greg Everett at ask@performancemenu.com

Paula Asks: Why do my knees come in when resistance, is a simple way to help without
the bar is above the knees before I extend in adding any time to your workouts.
snatch?
Next, pay attention to your lifts as you
Greg Says: It’s usually a combination of transition from first to second pull—often
weak hips and slack in the system. Include athletes relax and slow down a bit as if
accessory and prep work that strengthens they’re winding up for a harder acceleration,
transverse abduction (moving the knees but this creates slack, which can allow the
out with a flexed hip) and external rotation knees to move inward. We need continuous
(rotating the upper leg outwardly)—to keep tension—never let up on the effort to drive
it simple, exercises that put the body in a against the floor and maintain position.
position similar to that position in the middle When you accelerate into the second pull,
of the pull and moving the knees outward. just push harder—don’t lift your foot off the
Throwing a mini band around the knees gas pedal to then stomp on it.
during any hip extension exercises like glute
bridges, RDLs/SLDLs, good mornings, and You can work on this most easily during pulls
all of your pull and deadlift variations, and rather than snatches because there will be a
actively pushing the knees out against its lot less going on to worry about. Slow the first

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 6


pull down significantly so you can feel that
leg and hip tension and focus on maintaining
it as you accelerate at the top of the pull.
Again, throw a mini band around your knees
also to feel that lateral hip engagement.
Remember that we’re not trying to push the
knees way out, but to maintain that tension
to keep them in place.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 7


Environment vs.
Programming: Which
is More Important?
matt foreman

This is one of those articles where the title Stop for a second and think about your own
basically explains the main idea. We’re weightlifting life with these two things. First,
going to take a look at two of the most think about your training program. Do you
significant factors in a weightlifter’s success: get your program from a coach, or do you
programming and training environment. And program for yourself? How long have you
we’re going to figure out which one is more been following the same program, and what
important. kind of results have you had with it? If you’ve
been doing the same thing for two to three

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 8


years, you’ve got enough time invested with questions like this. Weightlifting is a routine
it to answer the only question that really sport, and it’s very easy to get sucked into
matters to an athlete…does it work? a routine for years without ever stopping to
analyze if it’s a good one. I’ve had moments
Ask some additional questions. Are other in my career where I realized I’d been in a
athletes using this same program and crappy situation for a very long time, without
having success? Is it battle-proven? If you’re even really noticing it. The crappy stuff wasn’t
getting it from a coach, does the coach really visible because it was so normal. I
have a legitimate track record of athlete didn’t snap out of it and realize how lousy
production? Have you been injured on this it was until I branched out and saw some
program? If so, how many times? I know, I different situations and realized how much
know…so many questions to think about! better they were. And this applies to both
But take a second and analyze all of them. programming and gym environment.
You’d be surprised how much you can figure
out just from looking at the answers. I’m not going to give you some fence-sitter
“Well, they’re both important, and neither is
We’ll get back to this stuff later. Let’s take a more important than the other” answer at the
hard right turn and do the same kind of Q&A end of this. I absolutely think there’s a clear
thing with your training environment. Do you winner in the programming vs. environment
train in a gym with other lifters, or do you matchup. But you’ll have to read on to find
train alone? If you train alone, do you like it out what it is.
that way? If so, why?

If you train with other lifters, what’s the daily Programming first
atmosphere like? Is there a good team vibe
in the gym? Is your coach a good leadership Let me give you a little personal experience
figure? Do you like the people you train with? to illustrate this part of the equation. I
Are there any toxic twits in the place? Anybody spent two years training for a certain coach
you’d like to light on fire? Is it a hard-working when I was a junior (18-19 years old). This
program where toughness and discipline coach was one of those guys with a good
are expected? Anything about it you have a sales pitch, you know? He sold himself as a
problem with? veteran expert, breeder of champions, that
kind of thing. It was all bullcrap, basically.
It’s amazing how valuable it is to stop every Truth be told, he had very little experience
once in a while and really take a hard look at with training an Olympic weightlifter. But I

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 9


didn’t know any better. I was a teenage kid Weightlifting Club in Washington) had lots
and he had a strong authoritative presence, of elite national lifters, and we all trained
so he seemed like the real deal to me. using the same basic program. But on the
other side of the country, the Gayle Hatch
For two years, I progressively got worse. My Weightlifting Club in Louisiana also had a
total plateaued for a long time, and then big gang of top national competitors, and
it actually started going down. On top of their programming was different from ours.
that, I was getting injured all the time. I was Then you had the Wesley Weightlifting Club
completely obedient to his programming in Missouri. They were cranking out tons
every step of the way. Everything he said to of national medalists, and they had their
do, I did it. And it basically put my results in own unique style of programming that was
the toilet. No improvement and getting hurt different from anybody else’s.
all the time. That’s not how it’s supposed to
work, especially when you’re talking about a The list goes on. The longer you stay in this
young kid with talent. sport, the more you’ll realize the fundamental
truth of programming: there are many ways
Eventually, I made a switch. I joined a to skin a cat. Lifters can be trained using
different program with a different coach, and a wide range of approaches, and many of
the programming was totally different from those approaches will produce success.
what I had been doing. In the first year with Anybody who tells you there’s only ONE way
this new coach, my total went from 265 kg to train great weightlifters is an idiot. You
to 300 kg. That’s 35 kg of improvement in can even branch this out to the international
eleven months, at the same bodyweight. No level. Chinese lifters train vastly different
more injuries. No more frustration. I went from Russian lifters. And guess what? The
from a scrub ass national lifter to a silver lifters from both countries win gold medals
medal at the American Open under this new and break world records.
coach’s approach. So yes, programming is
important. But it’s very important that you stop short
of thinking EVERYTHING works. Think about
However, I learned something interesting as I the beginning of my personal example. Good
became a regular on the national scene and programming can look a lot of different
started making friends with other top lifters ways, but there’s definitely such a thing as
from around the country. Not everybody BAD programming. The programming looks
trained the same way, but we all had different at the Calpian club, and the Gayle
success. The club I was training for (Calpian Hatch club, and Wesley Weightlifting, and

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 10


East Coast Gold, and Team Florida, and on and international teams, so I was basically
goes the list. But each of these programs the bottom-feeder as soon as I joined the
produces great weightlifters. Then you’ve got program. Every day, I came to the gym and
the situations like my two years with my first the other guys lifted more than me (and
coach. Athletes who have the ability to do talked shit to me about it every step of the
well in this sport, but they never go anywhere way). And every few months, they got to go
because they’re not being trained properly. compete in national meets I couldn’t qualify
for.
If you’ve been using the same program for
three years and you’ve been kicking ass and Needless to say, this wasn’t much fun. And
staying healthy the whole time, you’ve got a I went on a kamikaze mission to work my
solid methodology. If you get hurt a lot and way up to the top of the pack. Yes, the
your total won’t budge, something is wrong. programming was outstanding. Yes, that
Think about these things. made a world of difference. But when I think
back about that time, I realize the main
reason I put 35 kg on my total in that first
And then there’s environment year was simply my desire to be one of the
best lifters in the gym on a daily basis. It was
Let me return to my personal example for peer pressure, plain and simple. Everybody
a moment. Remember when I was training else was good, so I had to be as good (or
with that bad coach for two years? Oddly better) than they were.
enough, I was the best lifter in the state at
the time. It wasn’t because I was anything We were also a family, which is a huge part
remarkable. There just wasn’t a lot of high- of the environment conversation. Aside from
level weightlifting going on in my state. I was the competitive atmosphere that drove us
in the old 90kg weight class with a 265 kg all upwards, we were also having a lot of
total. Nothing amazing, but I was the god of success because our team was something
my local scene. special. Sure, we had squabbles. It wasn’t
always one big happy family. But at the end of
Then I moved to Washington and joined the the day, we were a true team. We supported
Calpian club, and my time of dominance each other. We liked training together every
went flying out the window. All of a sudden, day. We had each other’s backs. Lazy people
I wasn’t even the fifth best lifter in the GYM! and toxic twits were pushed out of the mix.
Almost everybody on the Calpian team at They just didn’t fit in. The strength of our
that time was competing for national medals program wouldn’t allow it.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 11


So let’s think about your environment. How than a lifter with great programming and a
competitive is it? How supportive is it? Is your mediocre environment.
coach a good leader? These are big questions,
and they’re big players in your own personal Notice I said the word “mediocre.” That was
results as a weightlifter. At this point, I’ve very intentional. You can’t really go anywhere
been in weightlifting for over 30 years. I’ve with BAD programming. If you’ve got bad
been a part of many programs, both as an programming and a great environment,
athlete and a coach. And obviously I’ve had everybody is just going to get hurt. They all
a good look at lots of gyms, coaches, and love and support each other, but they still
teams. You don’t really understand this sport wind up broken because the plan they’re
until you truly understand the power and following is destined for failure. They want
potential of a winning environment. It can to get better, so they push hard, but they’re
literally be the difference between greatness pushing hard with poor methodology. Recipe
and failure. for disaster.

BUT what about those elite weightlifters who Likewise, you can have the best programming
train alone in their garage full time? They’re in the world, and if you drop it into a gym full
out there, for sure. They don’t need a team to of wet noodles, nothing is going to happen.
be great. They don’t need daily atmosphere
to train well. You can just put them in a room I’ve seen these scenarios play out in real
with a platform, bar, and bumpers, and they’ll life. Over the years, I’ve seen several gyms
win championships. This is possible, but it’s with the following combination: a competent
rare. Most of the time, lifters are going to coach with adequate basic programming,
do their best work when they’re training with and hard-charging lifters with team spirit
other people. That’s why most lifters do it and hunger for progress. Trust me, this is
that way. a lethal equation. Gyms like this often turn
into powerhouses. Work ethic and hunger
outweigh genius in this sport.
The answer is...
A lot of it has to do with leadership. Many of
In my opinion, environment is more you are coaches, and this is where you come
important than programming. Why do I in. Brilliant programming doesn’t make a
say that? Because 99% of the time, a lifter great coach. It’s part of the package, but it’s
with mediocre programming and a great not the whole enchilada. The ability to inspire,
environment is going to be more successful motivate, and drive athletes to new heights

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 12


is where the greatness comes from. And let get. Medals, records, and championships
me throw in a cautionary note as well. I’ve will flow from that combination. But when
seen some good gyms with good people that you’re ranking the components for success
turned into toilets because the coach was and trying to figure out which ones are most
a dysfunctional loser. It’s entirely possible. important, my experience has taught me that
If the leadership is bad, absolutely nothing the daily atmosphere and gym environment
is going to be accomplished, no matter how are the top of the list. You just can’t beat a
much talent is in the room. collective vibe of enthusiasm, camaraderie,
and hunger. Keep this in mind as you continue
When you have great programming, great your journey, and especially if you’re ever the
coaches, and great athletes, it’s not hard one in charge.
to see what kind of results you’re going to

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 13


Mindfulness in Olympic
Weightlifting:
A Practical Guide Part 3
The What and the How of Mindfulness, Bringing it All Together

CHENG XU

In this last article in the three-part mindfulness skills together and carve out the pathways to
series, I want to bring both the what (observe, reaching that mystical place of mindfulness
describe, and participate) and the how (non- and the proverbial nirvana state of mind in
judgmentally, one-mindfully, and effectively) Olympic weightlifting—a state called Wise
Mind.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 14


We live in a culture where we see emotion we should cast aside our emotion mind and
and reason as diametrically opposed to one rely purely on our rational mind?
another. We sometimes say a person is overly
emotional and that causes them to make bad You absolutely need emotions to be good at
decisions. We also sometimes say a person Olympic weightlifting. The best weightlifters
is too rational, cold, and calculating, and I have ever met and coached are passionate
it’s a person that’s difficult to relate to. Yet, people. People who love the sport that
ironically, our society makes us think that they’re willing to put themselves at such
the pathway to effectiveness is to disavow inconvenience and discomfort just to train.
emotional decision making and act with They’ll battle pains and injuries and absorb
pure reason (thanks Western philosophy). huge financial costs year after year just to
In weightlifting, we often believe that our put themselves on the platform. Tell me this
emotion gets in the way of lifting, and that we isn’t someone you want to work with and train
need to reasonably, and rationally breakdown alongside. The trick, is to be able to control
what we need to do in order to be successful. and regulate your emotions when you need it
This I believe is a mischaracterization that so that they serve your purposes, rather than
does a disservice to the important functions prevent it.
of both. Your two states of mind, emotional,
and reasonable, exist synergistically, and to On the flip side, the reasonable state of
get yourself to a place of mindfulness, is mind, which we often put on a pedestal, can
to dialectically find ways for them to work get us into a lot of trouble in the effective
together. practice of Olympic weightlifting. Ever heard
of analysis paralysis? You can do all of the
Allow me to illustrate with the most basic technical learning you want about the sport,
example of how emotion and reason do about each movement, about biomechanics,
not necessarily work antagonistically: if anatomy, physiology, and kinesiology and all
you are walking through the forest at night, of that information can make you overthink
and you hear a rustling in the bushes, the the simplest task of executing a pull from
fear you experience triggers your fight or the floor. I personally think there is too much
flight response for self-preservation. Is that information out there to reasonably expect
an emotional or rational response? The someone to be able to absorb it all and
only correct interpretation is that it’s both. effectively incorporate it into their practice.
The emotion, fear, is activated for rational After all, all you have to do is go online and
purposes, survival. So why do we think that start a debate about the most effective school
in order to be effective in other areas of life, of training, Chinese, Korean, Russian, or

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 15


Bulgarian, and you’ll get legions of internet maximize both your performance and your
coaches coming out of the woodworks, all ultimate sense of enjoyment and fulfillment
offering their, often very reasonable, rationale in the sport.
about why one is superior to the other. But
how does that help you improve as an athlete I want to conclude this series by leaving
if that’s not what’s going to work for you? you with two thoughts. The first, is that the
philosopher Nietzsche once famously said,
How you’re going to figure out what works “those who have a reason for why, can handle
for you is to walk the middle path, to bring almost any how.” To me, this beautifully
yourself to the place of Wise mind with your encapsulates what it means to be in Wise
mindfulness skills. You need to be able to Mind. If you are clear in your own purpose
acknowledge your emotions as well as see and your own direction, you will be able to
the reason in your participation in this sport. do the most effective thing, and make the
After all, why are you here? Why are you best decisions on getting yourself there. The
reading my words? Tap into that emotional second, and I hope you truly take this to
self, and ask what you are getting out of the heart, is that a world without pleasure and
sport, then tap into your rational self, and passion is a bleak one. I wish that you are
ask what you need to do, and what the cost all doing this sport because you ultimately
and benefits to doing those things are. This enjoy it, and find it pleasurable and fulfilling.
is how you’re going to find your own wisdom Because not only are you making this sport
in your weightlifting practice. You’ll be able better for yourself, but you’re making it better
to recruit your passion, your joy, and even for everyone around you. Looking around at
your anguish and sorrows (and I know there the state of the world, I’m sure we all wish
are a lot of those), and synergize it with your for it to be a little less bleak. So exercise your
knowledge, your technical skills in order to mindfulness and let’s all be a little wiser.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 16


Overhead Stability:
how to get it and how
to keep it once you
have it
hannah grey

Lots of people can’t put their arms over their that’s maybe not an awesome idea, let’s talk
heads by the time they hit 30, and then about shoulders. Every shoulder is a special
they join a CrossFit gym and get hurt doing snowflake and they are all a little different,
500 snatches for time. Without sounding even when two of them belong to the same
like a hater or getting into the reasons why person. A stable overhead position looks

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 17


slightly different for everyone. Here are the finally the scapulothoracic joint, where the
basic governing principles and what to try if scapula joins with the rib cage. The four
the basics aren’t working for you. joints together form a ball-and-socket system
whose strength and flexibility we depend
If you are a North American weightlifter, you on for flexion, extension, adduction, and
probably started in early adulthood, after rotation. With a complex series of tendons
your shoulders were starting to show signs and ligaments in close proximity, there’s not
of age. Most of us discovered weightlifting by much room for things to go wrong - even five
watching the Olympics or following the great milliliters of extra fluid in the joint can really
weightlifters on social media, or maybe it was impede motion. So it’s no wonder that when a
through CrossFit or a weightlifting club at person who spends many hours sitting every
your local gym. A lucky few were introduced day, shoulders rounded and head forward,
to weightlifting by good college strength decides they want to put a loaded barbell
coaches who included the snatch and the over their head, things can get...interesting.
clean and jerk in sport-specific programs. The
bad news is that early adulthood is usually Generally when new weightlifters start
too late to build a good weightlifter— years learning the overhead position, they are
of sitting too much, forward head posture, taught to pull their shoulder blades up and
and rounded shoulders have already taken a together to create stability, with the bar over
toll on the structure of the shoulder girdle. the back of the neck and the head forward.
This is the most mechanically sound position
Now, I’m not telling you that all is lost - but and the best way to go IF the shoulders are
you will need to take care of those shoulders healthy and mobile. If the shoulders are
and make sure that your overhead position is habitually rounded and flexion and external
solid so that you can continue to lift over the rotation is limited, for example if you sit in a
long term. chair hunched over a computer keyboard all
day, your shoulder mobility may be a little
The shoulder is made up of four joints: the tied up and this position can give way to a
glenohumeral joint, where the humerus, or host of other issues.
upper arm, joins with the glenoid fossa on
the scapula; the acromioclavicular joint, If this sounds like you, try this quick
where the clavicle, or collarbone, joins with assessment: find a convex corner or door
the acromion process on the scapula; the frame in your house or your gym, and line it
sternoclavicular joint, where the proximal up with your spine so that you can feel the
end of the clavicle with the sternum; and corner between your shoulder blades. Bend

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 18


your elbows to 90 degrees and externally shoulder blades around that roller with each
rotate your shoulders. Can you feel your rep. Finish with moving the foam roller to the
shoulder blades squeeze that corner? If wall. Lean against it standing up, and do a
the answer is yes, can you reach your arms set of overhead presses - maintaining that
overhead and do the same thing? IF you can good scapular position you had on the floor.
still feel your shoulder blades squeezing the Do 20 reps of each of these exercises and
corner then you are probably in good shape you will be on your way to developing strong
to get a barbell over your head comfortably. rhomboids, good scapular positioning, a
If not, you have some work to do. happier neck, and better posture.

Here are the two most common errors in the


overhead position and how to correct them. 2. Torso is too far forward and
shoulders are cranked too far
into external rotation
1. Shoulders are shrugged up aro-
und the ears and the shoulders We’ve all seen those lifters that look like their
are internally rotated arms are going to snap off at the shoulders
like Mr. Potatohead in their catch positions.
If your neck disappears when you catch If you are one of them this is something that
a snatch or a jerk, you need to work on needs fixing pronto because if you don’t
scapular retraction. But don’t worry; you have shoulder pain now, you are going to!
aren’t alone. Lots of strong athletes can’t feel The shoulder joint is not all that structurally
the difference between scapular elevation stable in that dumped-forward position
and retraction. It’s a fairly easy imbalance to and loading there can lead to irritation and
correct but it takes some patience and some tearing.
focused work in your warm up.
To correct this, two things need to happen.
Start lying supine on a foam roller that’s lined First, you need to develop sufficient thoracic
up with your spine. Keeping the shoulders extension to support the weight with a more
away from the ears, pull your shoulder blades vertical torso. Do this by spending some extra
around the foam roller. Maintain that hug warm-up time on a foam roller, working into
while you circle your arms overhead. Next, extension under control, one vertebra at a
add a light resistance band and do a set time. This is NOT a relaxation exercise; focus
of pull aparts in the same position, paying hard and work at it. (Click HERE for video.)
attention to the sensation of squeezing the Second, work on strengthening the muscles

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 19


that depress the scapula (the serratus maintain. Extra time spent warming up your
anterior, lower trapezius, and latissimus shoulders will always pay off by keeping
dorsi). Add a wide variety of pulling exercises them strong and healthy over the long term.
to your accessory work. Focus on retracting It will also help you maintain good posture
the scapulae with horizontal pulls and and stay injury free in the rest of your life,
depressing the scapulae with vertical pulls. just in case you like doing things outside the
gym like having a family, career, and maybe
Once you’ve established a good overhead even other hobbies. It still doesn’t mean that
position, it’ll still require some work to 500 snatches for time is a good idea!

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 20


Red Meat is NOT Bad for
You: Part 1
Andrew Aussem

Red meat increases your risk of dying, red science and media coverage of this topic
meat is as bad as smoking, red meat causes makes things very confusing for the general
heart disease, red meat causes cancer. public. Whether or not someone eats meat
These are the type of headlines that get all is an individual choice that I support either
the attention over the years for reasons I way. However, we all have a right to accurate
cannot understand other than the fact that and complete information so we can make
controversy generates views. Other reasons properly informed choices. That is what this
seem to fall to factors like biased scientific series of articles is about.
funding, political motives, corporate motives,
and many other things that I am not an There are many people out there who are
expert in. Regardless, the result is that the vegetarian or vegan for no other reason than

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 21


the fact that they believe it is their healthiest humans, why is it classified as “probably
option because that is the message they get carcinogenic” and why does the media so
from the media, friends, and many healthcare often say it “is” carcinogenic? The scientists
professionals. Regrettably, most people do labeling red meat as probably carcinogenic
not have the time to do the research necessary aren’t even convinced; no wonder the general
to find out that this belief is not true. The public is confused.
information on this topic can be complicated
but the bottom line is the science is far from Now let’s have a look at some of the current
conclusive. science and dive into why many scientists
don’t agree with the belief that red meat is
In this article, I will try to unpack the different bad for our health.
lines of evidence used to demonize red meat
and make it as simple and understandable as
possible. I will not be discussing the ethical Understanding Relative Risk
or environmental considerations of meat
consumption; there are many more qualified Before going any further, understanding how
people out there to do that. risk is reported is very important. I am not a
statistician, but here is my best explanation
of relative and absolute risk. When you see
Red Meat and the World Health headlines like “an extra serving of meat
Organization increases the risk of cancer by 18 percent”
(otherwise written as 1.18) it is an example
Around 2015, the World Health Organisation’s of relative risk. Obviously, 18 percent doesn’t
International Agency for Research on Cancer sound unimportant when you see it; however,
classified red meat as group 2A, meaning they reporting findings in this way appears to
believe it is probably carcinogenic to humans. enhance the impact. Hypothetically, let say
However, the report specifically states that the risk of cancer in a vegetarian population
“There is limited evidence in humans for is 2 out of 100 people. Next, let’s say the
the carcinogenicity of the consumption of risk of cancer in those who eat meat is 18
red meat” but then goes on to say “Positive percent (1.18) higher than the vegetarian
associations have been observed between population. Although the relative increase in
consumption of red meat and cancers of risk is 18 percent, the absolute increase is 2
the colorectum, pancreas, and prostate.” x 1.18 = 2.36. An 18 percent increased risk
Given that the report admits there is limited sounds much worse than an increase from 2
evidence that red meat causes cancer in in 100 people to 2.36 in 100 people.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 22


Another consideration is that in other areas recent meta-analysis looked at 27 individual
of epidemiology, for a relationship to be studies since 1994 and determined that the
considered possibly causal (one thing causes relative risk of colon cancer equated to only
the other), the relative risk must be at least 11 percent (remember we need at least 100
100 percent, more commonly 300 percent percent to even think about considering a
or higher. Going back to the above example, causal relationship). Furthermore, when this
instead of 1.18, we would be looking at study only included individual studies that
somewhere between 2 and 3. However, for specified fresh red meat, the relative risk
some reason, in nutritional epidemiology, dropped to only 5 percent.
articles that report relative risks of much
less than 100 percent are taken to support a Additionally, study quality is consistently
causal relationship even though with relative brought into question with epidemiological
risks that low, the results cannot truly be studies on red meat. Study quality can be
separated from chance. impacted by controllable and uncontrollable
factors. Earlier studies appear to show a
higher relative risk of cancer than more
Epidemiological Studies on Red recent studies and this is thought to be due to
Meat better study design in more current research.
This would include more comprehensive
Although many epidemiological studies food questionnaires, properly controlling
report an increased risk of cancer/disease for processed versus fresh red meat, and
with increased meat consumption, the results including controls for other confounding
are not without significant criticism. The lifestyle factors.
relative cancer risk reported in most studies
is well below the 100 percent requirement Another issue is researcher bias and conflicts
for a causal relationship and many studies of interest. Because the results of these
have methodology issues including small studies are based on calculations from the
sample size, not separating fresh red meat data in the food questionnaires, it is quite easy
from processed meat, and not controlling for for bias and conflict of interest to influence
sufficient variables. how the questionnaires are interpreted.

Meta-analysis studies are studies that take the Finally, because there are so many diet and
results of multiple individual studies on the lifestyle factors that can impact our health,
same topic and combine the data into a single it is near impossible for a study to control for
study, creating a larger sample size. A more every factor aside from red meat intake. In

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 23


health studies, this problem goes by the name
Mechanistic Evidence
of the healthy user bias. Since not eating
meat is considered healthy, vegetarians and
Now that we have discussed the issues with
vegans are much more likely to be otherwise
epidemiological studies and that relative risk
health-conscious while those who eat meat
reports do not really indicate red meat is a
are much less likely to be health-conscious.
cause for concern, let’s look and what’s called
mechanistic evidence. Typically, when it is
A few studies have tried to address the
determined via epidemiological studies that
healthy user bias by isolating health-
factor A is a likely cause of factor B, studies
conscious omnivores and comparing them
begin to look at possible mechanisms for how
to vegetarians, the results of which show
A might cause B. Since the epidemiological
no difference between the two groups and
evidence on red meat is far from conclusive,
both groups are healthier than the general
you would think that there would be limited
population. Ultimately, because of the high
to no investigation into mechanisms for
probability of confounding factors and
why red meat may be detrimental to our
the low relative risks that are consistently
health; however, this is not the case. There
reported, it should be considered quite an
are several suggested mechanisms for
embellishment to conclude that red meat
why red meat might cause cancer and be
causes cancer.
otherwise detrimental to our health including
saturated fat content, polycyclic aromatic
The above is just the criticisms regarding
hydrocarbons, heterocyclic amines, TMAO,
red meat and cancer, but the connection
mTOR activation, and heme iron content.
between red meat and heart disease is
just as controversial and criticized for the
The second article in this series will focus
same reasons. Such factors include low
on revealing why the above mechanistic lines
to nonexistent relative risks, lack of food
of evidence against red meat are also far
questionnaire detail, food questionnaire
from conclusive and discuss the nutrients
inconsistency, food questionnaire
meat provides that are either impossible or
interpretation, and inability to control for all
difficult to get from other foods.
health-related variables making the healthy
user bias a major limiting factor.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 24


Observations of The
Snatch and Different
Body Types
Jenny Lutkins

The snatch is very dependent on joint mobility Weightlifting Federation as, “The barbell is
and precise technique. However, people placed horizontally in front of the lifter’s legs.
of many different body types have been It is gripped, palms downwards and pulled
successful with variances in that technique. in a single movement from the platform to
Differences in limb length and hip anatomy the full extent of both arms above the head,
call for slight changes in coaching cues. while either splitting or bending the legs.”
There is a lot of room for variances in a
The snatch is defined by the International “legal” snatch, and I would like to highlight

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 25


some of my weightlifting friends to point out you will see is that Jennifer and Jana (the
those variances. first two videos in the clip, respectively) must
start with that more acute back angle than
I have two tall, friends that have a noticeably Liz (third video in the clip). Jennifer and Jana
different snatch technique than mine, or some also have slightly different setups as well, as
of my shorter lifters. The main difference Jana’s torso is longer than Jennifer’s. Jana
is in the back angle. Long femur-ed lifters can afford to sit up a little higher and still
have to be able to stand up with maximum create tension in her posterior chain and
power in the posterior chain without hitting move the knees out of the way of the bar.
their knees with the bar during the first pull. The second difference to be noticed is with
Therefore, they have to lean their shoulders the second pull to the hips. This takes longer,
over the bar farther than is normally taught, obviously since the femur is longer, so the
with the back and thighs at a more acute snatch can look segmented or slow compared
angle. In this photo, we see Jennifer on the to a shorter-limbed athlete.
left with a deeper angled torso than Liz, on
the right. In the receiving position, longer femurs mean
that the torso must lean forward more to have
the bar balanced over the center of mass.

Beyond the setup, you can watch three


differently proportioned lifters here. What

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 26


This is, of course, if the athlete isn’t better sits in the hip crease. Next, with the barbell
suited to receiving the bar in a split snatch. on the floor, place the feet hip-width under
My adaptive athlete recently discovered that the bar so that the large joint of the big toes
if she splits, she can receive the bar lower and (or first laces of the shoes) are directly under
with more stability, as her narrow hips and the barbell. Without moving the feet from that
use of only one arm make it difficult to get position, lower into a squat straight down,
low enough in an overhead squat position. placing the hands in the grip position found
earlier. If this procedure is followed, the
knees should be at or past the elbows and the
athlete’s back angle will be appropriate for
his or her limb length and center of mass. If
the athlete executes the first pull by exerting
force through the feet, pushing against the
floor, without changing the back angle, the
knees will stay back out of the way of the
upward trajectory of the bar, no matter the
femur length of the athlete.

While there is no argument that some body


types are better suited to snatching, athletes
with long femurs, long torsos, long arms,
or the opposite can find success with the
snatch by making small adjustments to the
grip and back angle. The key to efficient
Arm length variations are simply addressed performance is first, to exert the most force
by adjusting the grip width on the bar. As possible against the ground. Finding the
long as the barbell makes contact on the position of the back relative to the thighs
hips when fully upright, a successful second in order to fully activate the hamstring and
pull can be achieved. gluteal muscles is paramount. Second, the
grip needs to be such that continued upward
For most athletes, a little trick I learned for force can be exerted on the bar at full hip
optimal snatch set-up is to first, find the extension, so not too high or too low as to
appropriate grip width by standing upright miss the hips in the second pull. Finally, a
and making sure the bar makes contact with balanced catch position relies on the torso
the hip, so that if bent forward, the barbell to thigh angle once again, making sure the

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 27


barbell is directly over the athlete’s center of coaching and maybe even video analysis,
mass. This may mean a more forward leaning any body type can find the positioning for a
torso for taller athletes. With appropriate successful snatch.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 28


interview:
Fred Lowe
Matt Foreman

We do athlete interviews every month in this he went on to make three Olympic Teams
magazine, and we’re always happy to do (1968, 1972, and 1976). There’s only a
them with many of the biggest names in USA small handful of three-time Olympians in
weightlifting. But it’s not very often that we our sport’s history, and he’s one of them.
get to interview a living legend. That’s exactly He also made four World Teams, won eight
what Fred Lowe is. National Championships, and broke multiple
American records along the way.
Most of you aren’t historians, so you don’t
know anything about him. I’ll start by blowing Veterans of this sport will often tell you one
you away with his list of accomplishments. of the most amazing performances they’ve
Fred started weightlifting in 1965, and ever seen was at the 1981 Nationals. Fred

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 29


had stepped away from competition after occupation, family life, what kind of sports
making his third Olympic Team in 1976, and background do you have outside of lifting, etc.
many thought his phenomenal career was
over. But in 1981, he returned to the platform I am originally from Lambertville, MI, in
and won the National Championship, where the extreme Southeast corner of Michigan.
he became the first US lifter in the 165 kg I currently live in DeWitt, MI, which is the
class to clean and jerk 400 lbs. (at the age Northern suburb of Lansing, the state Capitol.
of 34). I’m currently teaching at the Community
College in Lansing, supervising a fitness lab
And after that, he simply never stopped. for adults of all ages. I’ve been on furlough
Most people don’t know this, but Fred is the since 3/16/20. I’m married to Chrisann (33
only weightlifter in history to compete in years this coming May) and she qualified
the National Championship in six different for sainthood long ago. My two main sports
decades (1960s, 70s, 80s, 90s, 2000s, and growing up were baseball (ages 10-18) and
2011). That means he was still competing at wrestling (ages 13-17).
the national level when he was in his sixties.
And I don’t mean the masters national level. Describe your weightlifting history. When/how
I’m talking about the REAL national level. did you start? Who have your coaches been?
What are your proudest accomplishments?
But don’t worry…he’s done okay in the
masters division, too. He’s won fifteen I started weightlifting at the urging of an
Masters Nationals, nine Masters Worlds, and older cousin, Jim Bearinger, on 7/8/65. He
he’s been inducted into eight Halls of Fame. was my first coach 1965-1967, but I got a lot
Folks, there’s simply nobody like Fred Lowe. of information for print sources during that
His longevity in the sport eclipses absolutely time as well. The only direct supervision I had
everybody who’s ever done it. You could make during my career was Mike Huszka’s coaching
a very strong case for him being the greatest at the Duncan Y in Chicago from September
weightlifter in American history. He’s been 1967-June 1968. After that, I continued to
one of my biggest inspirations throughout draw information from numerous sources
my entire career, and I’m overjoyed at the throughout my career.
tremendous honor of sharing his story with
you. As far as accomplishments go, I’m most
proud of representing in three Olympiads,
Tell us about your background. Where are you six U.S. records, eight Senior National wins,
from, where do you currently live, what’s your and nine World Masters wins. Those I would

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 30


consider the high points, but there are a lot Describe some of the obstacles you’ve faced, or
of others as well. As a Master, the best meet maybe some things that frustrated you in your
I’ve ever had was the Pan Am Masters in weightlifting life. What kinds of changes would
Savannah in June 2001. The clean and jerk you like to see, either personally or with the
(130) and total (230) are still World Masters sport in general?
records after nearly 20 years.
Pursuing anything as demanding as
Unlike most lifters, you continued to have weightlifting is strewn with obstacles, and my
success on the platform in your older years. career has been no different. I had to decide
Describe how your training changed as you if the self-actualization outweighed other
aged into the masters division. What advice difficulties. For the most part, it did. I did
would you give to older lifters? what I did and I’m happier for it than I am
sorry. As an elite level athlete, I would have
Training –that’s an interesting topic. When profited greatly from a residential program
I was younger, my training frequency was completely dedicated to the sport. None
three days per week for the first two years. existed at the time.
The third year under Huszka, it was six days
per week with an average intensity of 72%. I Changes I’d like to see - that’s a complicated
got married after Mexico City and during the one. Firstly, total eradication of drugs from
rest of my Senior career, it was three days the sport would be nice. Since all this stuff
per week due to work, school, and family began 67 years ago, you had no way of
commitments. I didn’t compete 1984- knowing who the best athlete really was.
1992 and decided to return only after the Some international lifters were no better
masters program came under PED testing than a clean state champion when they were
requirements in 1993. As a master, I’ve off the stuff. Who was really the best? The
always trained three days per week. athlete who could take one more pill or shot
than someone else of equal ability? The
My advice to master lifters is the same as athlete whose body responded the best to
I give to everyone: train at a frequency and pharmaceutical compounds? Willingness to
intensity that you can recover from and stay work was never an issue in weightlifting. But
healthy with. Work hard on your mobility; who was really the best on their own? No one
you’ll need it long after your joints will tolerate will ever know.
doing lifts. Don’t execute poor movements
just to get a few more kilos up. That’s about
it.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 31


What are your plans and goals for your of state tuition my third year of college
weightlifting career? How do you see your future
in the sport? Mihaly Husza- 1960 and 1964 Olympian
for Hungary and my coach Sept 1967-
My goals for the remainder of my career June 1968. He taught me the value of
include training moderately and competing undulating programming and speed
occasionally, continuing to execute
assignments as an IWF Technical Official, Bob Hoffman- founder of York Barbell
promote local meets, and coach others to Company. He provided the only significant
find the fulfillment and benefit this sport has sponsorship during my career from 1969-
given me. 1981

Who are some of your major influences, people Lou DeMarco- one of the best platform
you look up to, etc.? Who are the people you coaches ever, he handled my efforts at
want to thank for your success? the 1967 Teenage Nationals, 1972 Srs/
Olympic Trials, 1981 Senior Nationals, and
There’s always a laundry list of people who 1983 National Sports Festival
helped you and sacrificed along with you in
pursuit of your dreams. I will actually make Carl Miller- his newsletters in 1973 were good
a list: information and his two books are excellent

Jim Bearinger- my cousin who introduced Tommy Kono- provided an example of what
me to the sport class looks like in an athlete and official. His
coaching tips were excellent as well.
Harland Lowe- my father who, in addition to
providing a work ethic model, drove me to Bill Starr - the promoter of my very first
New Jersey in his 11-year old car so I could meet. He later became the managing editor
lift in my first Teenage Nationals of Strength and Health magazine. He
eventually wrote two books, both of which
Chuck Never- my former brother-in-law, who are excellent.
drove me to Indiana for my second meet
Maureen McBride-Russakof- my first wife and
Bob Gajda- 1966 AAU Mr. America, who mother of my two children. We got married
brought me to Chicago to compete for Duncan young and didn’t last long. She made a lot
Y and whose YMCA foundation paid my out of sacrifices.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 32


Stephanie Davis- my second wife who Lastly, I have drawn, and continue to draw,
assumed the difficult role of stepmother for inspiration from lifters of all ability levels
my kids. She made a great many sacrifices. by viewing their dedication and devotion to
their pursuit of “the white moment.” We are
Chrisann Lowe- my third wife. I was not a very diverse group in pursuit of one thing.
competing when we got married; five To me, that’s a very good thing.
years later I became a Master. She too knows
this sport has many demands. Fred, on behalf of everybody in the sport of
weightlifting, thank you and congratulations on
Casey Larose and Frederick Lowe- my your career. You’re a hero to anyone who picks
daughter and son. Both competed in up a barbell and works to be successful in this
weightlifting, coming to it later in their 20s. sport, and we appreciate everything you’ve
They got to find out firsthand what the big done. Catalyst Athletics wishes all the best to
deal was. I am sure their perceptions of you and your family!  
being my son and daughter would be worthy
of a book.

PERFORMANCE MENU ISSUE 194/ MARCH 2021 33

You might also like