Time For Investors To Reevaluate Their China Exposures 1677614604

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

A reprinted article from January/February 2023

It’s Time for Investors to Reevaluate


Their China Exposures
By Dambisa Moyo, PhD

© 2023 Investments & Wealth Institute®. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
JANUARY
FEATURE FEBRUARY
2023

It’s Time for Investors to Reevaluate


Their China Exposures
By Dambisa Moyo, PhD

D
eglobalization is well under- Figure CHINA’S AVERAGE GROWTH
way, evident in numerous trends
1
20
including the retrenchment of
10
GDP Growth (%)
global trade, unwinding of capital flows,
0
new barriers to migration, and weak-
–10
ened influence of traditional multilat-
–20
eral institutions such as the World Bank,
International Monetary Fund (IMF), and –30

World Trade Organization.


20
Annual Change

10
Alongside these trends, tensions continue
0
to grow between the United States and
–10
China. So, as competition between the
–20
two countries intensifies in an increas-
1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020
ingly deglobalized, zero-sum world,
investors face a difficult decision—how Source: https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/CHN/china/gdp-growth-rate

should they approach investing in China?


Against the backdrop of high inflation, Arguments for global investment have
As the world transforms from a slowing global growth, and war in pointed to the importance of portfolio
globalized win-win framework to a Ukraine—and atop deepening fissures diversification, and arguments for
deglobalized, zero-sum structure, many between the United States and China— investing in China have pointed to
long-held investment assumptions it’s vital to consider whether to tip the country’s strong economic growth
about global portfolios will be upended. investment strategies toward or away (see figure 1). China’s massive invest-
A zero-sum world is one that necessar- from China. ment inflows have been supported by
ily has a winner and a loser, where one its enormous population, the rise of
side’s gain equals the other side’s loss. The new investment landscape, shaped its middle class, and its popularity as
The trends of deglobalization are forcing by rising geopolitical tensions, differing a low-cost production destination for
asset managers, private investors, and economic and social ideologies, and global corporations.
business leaders and corporations to an evolving world order, will impact
reassess how they allocate capital and investor understanding of risk and Today China stands economically, tech-
other resources. return. It also will force investors to nologically, and militarily as a formida-
decide whether to continue investing in ble competitor to the United States.
In this case, a zero-sum world frame China—a stark choice that did not exist Over several decades the country also
pits China against the United States. just a few years ago. has made huge inroads as a global
This leaves investors making a critical player. It stands as the largest trading
call about whether to invest their CONSIDERATIONS BEHIND partner, foreign investor, and lender to
marginal dollars in China versus the THE INVESTMENT DECISION the emerging markets. Specifically, since
United States. Bluntly put, it is about For more than a decade, a compelling 2014 China has been the largest creditor
whether China will continue to offer the narrative has spurred broad investment to the developing world—larger than the
risk-adjusted returns above the cost of across the global economy, especially IMF, World Bank, or Paris Club (see
capital that investors expect and are in China—but that narrative now is figure 2). Furthermore, China is among
competitive on a global level. changing. the largest foreign lenders to the U.S.

INVESTMENTS & WE ALTH MONITOR 7

© 2023 Investments & Wealth Institute. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
JANUARY
FEBRUARY FEATURE | It’s Time for Investors to Reevaluate Their China Exposures
2023

Figure CHINA IS THE LARGEST OFFICIAL CREDITOR TO THE as outlined by China’s policy-makers
2 DEVELOPING WORLD in previous plans.

400
In recent months, investors have been
Aggregate Public Debt ($M USD)

spooked by a series of announcements


300
from China’s political class. In addition
to the strict COVID restrictions, markets
also have reacted to China’s “common
200 prosperity” stance and the affirmation
of President Xi Jinping for a third term.

100 The Chinese government took signifi-


cant steps to scale back COVID restric-
tions in December 2022, including
0
2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015 2018 relaxing quarantine rules and deactivat-
ing the state-run Communications

Debt to China ■
Debt to IMF ■
Debt to all Paris Club governments ■
Debt to World Bank
Itinerary Card app for tracking people’s
Source: S. Horn, C. M. Reinhart, and C. Trebesch, “China’s Overseas Lending,” Journal of International Economics 133
movements. Although this could bolster
(November 2021), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jinteco.2021.103539 China’s growth, the broader political
climate, including a new “common
prosperity” policy that aims to redistrib-
government, providing it with consider- In technology and climate transition, ute more of China’s wealth to its poor,
able leverage on global policy. China increasingly is seen as a global will remain a concern for investors.
actor. In addition to its technological
China’s demand for U.S. Treasuries has leadership ambitions in quantum comput- Although compelling in its attempts
helped keep U.S. interest rates low, ing and artificial intelligence (AI), China to redress inequality, the common
which has allowed the U.S. government has laid out an explicit plan for reaching prosperity policy prompted a sell-off
to borrow relatively cheaply to fund net zero emissions by 2060. in the domestic stock market, particu-
spending for U.S. economic growth. larly in Chinese A-shares, when it
If China stops buying U.S. government China already has established domi- was announced in 2021, as well as
bonds, it raises the cost of borrowing, nance in areas such as 5G and quantum a massive repricing of valuations in
placing additional upward pressure information science.1 Furthermore, other Chinese investments. The overall
on U.S. borrowing costs. In this sense, China is on course to overtake the China MSCI Index fell just less than
keeping China as a creditor is a distinct United States in AI, semiconductors, 22 percent in 2021.2
advantage to the U.S. economy, thereby biotech, and green energy in the next
granting China some leverage on the 10 years. These measures have been seen as anti-
U.S. economy. business and placing a brake on robust
Nevertheless, from an investor’s economic activity. In the month of Xi’s
Additionally, China is aggressively perspective, fundamental questions affirmation alone, foreign investors
pursuing its strategic goals and global are arising about investing in China. pulled US$8.8 billion from Chinese
ambitions. stocks and bonds, according to the
As of October 2022, the IMF is fore- Institute of International Finance.3
Through billions of dollars of invest- casting growth in China’s GDP from
ment, China’s Belt and Road initiative is 3.2 percent in 2022 to 4.4 percent Over the long term, China’s demograph-
connecting trading regions and financial in 2023. In the short term, however, ics, debt burden, and questions around
markets. In 2021, China also became a investors lack clarity given the the sustained strength of a highly central-
signatory to the Regional Comprehensive economic impact of the country’s strict ized political system are all headwinds for
Economic Partnership, the largest free- zero-COVID policy and its relatively jittery investors. At a high level, accord-
trade trading bloc in history, with low-inflation environment. ing to the United Nations, India soon
15 members, including Indonesia, Japan, will surpass China as the world’s most
and South Korea, that together represent These two factors are seen as hindering populous nation.4
about 30 percent of the world’s popula- China’s strategy of generating economic
tion and 30 percent of the world’s gross growth by shifting from an export-led Meanwhile, China’s working-age
domestic product (GDP) ($29.7 trillion). economy to a consumer-led economy, population is shrinking; it peaked

8 INVESTMENTS & WE ALTH MONITOR

© 2023 Investments & Wealth Institute. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
JANUARY
FEATURE | It’s Time for Investors to Reevaluate Their China Exposures FEBRUARY
2023

at 69 percent of the population in Figure CHINA’S WORKING-AGE POPULATION IS SHRINKING


2010 (see figure 3). The working-age
3
1.1B
proportion is predicted to fall below

Total Poopulation (Million/Billion)


1.0B
50 percent by 2050.5 In short, China is 900M
on course to get old before it gets rich. 800M
700M
China’s ratio of national debt to GDP 600M
at 70 percent is below that of many 500M
400M
western countries, but the growth rate in
300M
China’s recorded debt is a deep economic 200M
concern. For example, in 2010, China’s 100M
national debt to GDP stood at just 0
34 percent. In 2021, however, it was

10

18

26

34

42

50

58

66

66

66

66

66

66

74

82

90

98
20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20
71.5 percent, and it is forecast to break
100 percent in 2027 (see figure 4).6 ■ 15–64 ■ 65+

Source: Shanghai Academy of Social Science, https://theconversation.com/chinas-population-is-about-to-shrink-


Then there is the perennial, if not for-the-first-time-since-the-great-famine-struck-60-years-ago-heres-what-it-means-for-the-world-176377

theoretical, question about how long


a highly centralized system of political Figure NATIONAL DEBT OF CHINA IN RELATION TO GDP 2010–2027
governance can survive in China, 4
especially when the economy is slowing 120%
and restrictions on daily life remain 103%
100% 95%
in place.
90%
80% 84%
77%
For now, it is clear that President Xi 68%
has a consolidated grip on the Chinese 60%
54 %
Communist Party and, by extension, the 48%
34% 40%
country. In November 2022, for exam- 40% 34%
ple, the Chinese Communist Party was
20%
able to quickly reassert control by mobi-
lizing police to quash protests about 0%
continued lockdowns in several major
*

*
15
16
17
18
19
20
10
11
12
13
14

21

22

23

24

25

26

27
20
20
20

20
20
20
20
20
20
20

20

20

20

20

20

20
20

20
Chinese cities. Furthermore, rising
tensions over Taiwan are leading many ■
National Debt to GDP Ratio

policy commentators and investors to Source: https://www.statista.com/statistics/270329/national-debt-of-china-in-relation-to-gross-domestic-product-gdp


become increasingly concerned about * Forecasted

the risk of outright conflict between the


United States and China, if not militar- Even beyond Hong Kong, China clearly supply-chain networks to allies and
ily, then technologically. has become more aggressive politically, friendly countries, U.S. Treasury
fueling economic and geopolitical Secretary Janet Yellen said, “We cannot
THE IDEOLOGICAL AND fissures with the United States. allow countries to use their market posi-
INVESTMENT DIVIDE Ideological differences with the West tion in key raw materials, technologies,
We are at a pivotal point in which also are becoming more entrenched or products to have the power to disrupt
geopolitics and long-standing ideologi- as Xi’s grip on power has strengthened our economy or exercise unwanted
cal differences are now forcing investors in recent months. geopolitical leverage.” These comments
to rethink allocations in China. were widely interpreted as directed
Meanwhile, the U.S. administration has toward China and Russia.
Apart from the enormity and scale of explicitly ramped up its seemingly anti-
this decision for financial markets, China policy and regulatory stance. This More generally, in October 2022,
(China attracted $181 billion of foreign increases the risk of remaining invested President Joe Biden launched a new
direct investment in 2021, according to in China. National Security Strategy aimed
UNCTAD7),the decision on whether to at the threat posed by China, saying,
remain invested in China is urgent for In an April 2022 speech advocating “The People’s Republic of China harbors
three reasons. “friend-shoring,” or the limitation of the intention and, increasingly, the

INVESTMENTS & WE ALTH MONITOR 9

© 2023 Investments & Wealth Institute. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
JANUARY
FEBRUARY FEATURE | It’s Time for Investors to Reevaluate Their China Exposures
2023

capacity to reshape the international announcement has been seen in board- threat of a CFIUS divestment order for
order in favor of one that tilts the global rooms and by investors as a sign of TikTok over concerns that U.S. user data
playing field to its benefit.” Export further anti-Chinese investment and an could be passed on to China’s govern-
controls form a part of the strategy. extension of anti-China sentiment. ment. U.S. Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO)
National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan wrote to CFUIS chair Janet Yellen
has said controls of exports of tech– One area for potential restrictions, if requesting enforcement in September
nology, including semi-conductors, United States-China tensions escalate 2022.10 However, any deal between the
can “impose costs on adversaries and further, is the deployment of U.S. state U.S. government and TikTok is now on
even, over time, degrade their battlefield pension assets. There is unlikely to be hold, having run into delays over further
capabilities.”8 regulation from on high, such as at the national security concerns.11
federal level, but more stringent guide-
lines are expected for how assets of state In December 2022, Alabama and Utah
pension funds, U.S.-based institutional followed Texas, Maryland, and South
Recent action by state investors, and even company investment Dakota in banning TikTok from being
governors and attorneys assets are deployed. used on state devices due to security
general across the United concerns.12
Recent action by state governors and
States reminds investors attorneys general across the United Not only should Chinese investors be
how political power can States reminds investors how political worried about how aggressive the United
supersede financial power can supersede financial argu- States could become toward Chinese
ments and imperatives. If the political investments, but U.S. investors also
arguments and imperatives. sentiment becomes more fervent, it is should worry about retaliatory responses
plausible that state-run pension funds, by the Chinese to these U.S. actions.
in line with an increasing anti-China
Some argue that this starker anti-China stance in the United States, could ban If China was to place extra restrictions
stance was first observed in 2019 when investments in China. on capital being invested in China,
the United States restricted sales of it would lead to changes on two fronts.
products made by Chinese technology For example, in February 2022, the It would discourage new capital invest-
company Huawei. That move is now Texas state pension fund was the first ments into China, and it would prompt
seen as a prelude to the more aggressive to ban asset managers that boycott existing investors to worry about their
anti-China pivot investors increasingly the oil and gas industry, and at least capital investments getting trapped and
are worrying about today. 10 other states followed by October lead them to withdraw.
2022. Florida, Oklahoma, Kentucky,
In 2022, new regulations and enforcement and West Virginia also banned state INVESTORS’ THREE OPTIONS
of disclosure rules led to a delisting of pension funds from participating in Against this magnitude and speed of
major Chinese companies from the New environmental, social, and governance change in the investment landscape,
York Stock Exchange (NYSE). In August (ESG) investments.9 it is clearly time for investors to reeval–
2022, five Chinese corporations, includ- uate their China exposures.
ing China Life Insurance Company, Business leaders are interpreting some
PetroChina Company Limited, and China decisions and policies as hostile moves There must be no doubt that widening
Petroleum & Chemical Corporation, said aimed at restricting and disincentivizing fissures in the China-U.S. relationship,
that they would delist from the NYSE. Chinese companies from investing in along with notable trends of deglobaliza-
Negotiations between these Chinese the United States. tion, will transform how global busi-
enterprises and the U.S. Public Company nesses operate. In particular, global
Accounting Oversight Board on sharing These measures highlight another risk, corporations must place under review
audited review data are ongoing. that of a tit-for-tat response by the how they finance themselves, hire across
Chinese authorities, specifically the borders, centralize procurement and
Furthermore, in September 2022, possibility of Chinese capital restrictions supply chains, and allocate capital.
President Biden issued an executive that would leave foreign assets trapped
order that “explicitly ties CFIUS’ inside Chinese borders. How investors react to these trends
[Committee on Foreign Investment in clearly depends on their unique portfo-
the United States] role, actions, and For example, business leaders and inves- lios and their distinctive needs for diver-
capabilities with the Administration’s tors are acutely concerned about how sification, risk appetites, and investment
overall national security priorities.” This China might respond to the continued horizons. But ultimately investors have

10 INVESTMENTS & WE ALTH MONITOR

© 2023 Investments & Wealth Institute. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
JANUARY
FEATURE | It’s Time for Investors to Reevaluate Their China Exposures FEBRUARY
2023

three options: hold, sell, or double down A third option is for an investor to both down. One warning to investors is
on their China positions. hold and grow its China exposure with that traditional metrics likely will
new capital. In this case, an investor have limited value in such a volatile
First, investors can sell down their entire would look to capitalize on low valua- environment. Conventionally investors
China exposure. As a practical matter, tions and market weakness to expand will evaluate macroeconomic data such
exiting publicly traded Chinese stocks its presence in China. as growth and inflation, as well as price
or private investments, such as a factory earnings multiples, internal rate of
or a private equity investment, will most Doubling down and expanding a China return, Sharpe ratios, and market
certainly be protracted as sellers try to investment brings risks in the prevailing volatility measures. These will likely,
find reasonable prices in a challenged market climate. Therefore, foreign inves- however, prove less reliable in such
economic environment. tors might want to consider forming a fast-moving and unpredictable markets.
joint venture with a local partner, help-
Beyond this, exiting China will have ing them to hedge their investments and CONCLUSION
meaningful consequences in tax, intel- any risk of outright expropriation. Asset allocators and investors may be
lectual property rights, transfer pricing, wholly dissatisfied that this article does
and any possible stranded costs. In Any corporation cementing its China not recommend, for example, that an
addition, taking Chinese investments position will be well-advised to consider investor buy or sell China outright.
to zero means investors are left without creating a standalone China subsidiary
optionality to benefit from a sustained to house its Chinese operations. This Our deliberately balanced approach
improvement in the country’s invest- leaves corporations facing more finan- reflects the unique decisions that invest-
ment climate. To reenter China after a cial reporting and regulation, and ment managers must make, taking into
complete exit likely would mean incur- coping with rising trade protection- consideration the different horizons and
ring high reentry costs. ism. However, it would mitigate the risk appetites across different sectors
disruption of trying to run operations that drive risk-reward calculations.
A second option is for investors to in an otherwise politically and economi-
write down the value of their Chinese cally volatile environment. Of course, Investors that have used a global portfo-
investments but to still retain the assets taking this path involves establishing lio allocation approach for decades must
on their (financial) books and records. governance and board oversight struc- recognize how disruptions in all aspects
The investor would not add any material tures of new entities that likely are listed of geopolitical, economic, and sociologi-
new capital to grow or enhance the and regulated independently only on cal trends are impacting their decisions
investments. local Chinese stock exchanges. on China. This article is more of a
caution to investors that tend to reach
Writing down an equity portfolio would Already, there are signs that some inves- for familiar patterns and past trends
lead to actual recorded market-to-market tors are taking positions. when placing bets and making long-
losses. Choosing to write down the value term investment decisions.
of the stocks rather than selling the posi- On the “buy” side, Microsoft Chief
tion down to zero means the investor Executive Officer Satya Nadella stated in The world is changing rapidly but also
retains some optionality if the positions a November 2022 announcement that he fundamentally. The sea changes we are
rebound. is “very, very, bullish” on Asia including seeing in the global economy, particu-
China and “absolutely committed to larly in China, are era-defining. They
For a company, writing down the China.”13 are the most far-reaching shifts in more
value of the assets means scaling than 70 years, and they will reshape the
back operations as opposed to shutting Tiger Global has taken a sell and pause investment landscape for a generation.
down completely. For example, a corp– option, with reports in November 2022
oration might write down the asset that the investment manager scaled back The choices outlined above will result
value of a factory that would continue its hedge fund investment in China as in a fundamental disruption to the
to function with only investments geopolitical tensions rose ahead of the way businesses and investors have
to support ongoing maintenance. Chinese Communist Party Congress. approached China for decades. This
That is, the investor would make no The report also stated that Tiger paused disruption also reflects the reality of a
new expansionary investments or capital new investments amid concern about deglobalized world as China and the
commitments. Again, this allows the President Xi’s consolidation of power.14 United States compete for economic, tech-
investor to participate if an improved nologic, and military preeminence.
investment climate was to lead to a Obviously, financial metrics will matter
sustained market recovery. in the choice to sell, hold, or double Continued on page 59

INVESTMENTS & WE ALTH MONITOR 11

© 2023 Investments & Wealth Institute. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
JANUARY
FEATURE | It’s Time for Investors to Reevaluate Their China Exposures FEBRUARY
2023

IT’S TIME FOR INVESTORS TO REEVALUATE …


Continued from page 11

Dambisa Moyo, PhD, Baroness Moyo of 5. “Share of Population Aged 15 to 59 Years JDH%20Letter%20to%20Yellen%20re%20
Knightsbridge, Member of the House of Lords, in China from 1950 to 2020 with Fore- TikTok_0.pdf.
is co-principal of Versaca Investments, a casts until 2100” (October 6, 2022), 11. J. McKinnon, A. Viswanatha, and S. Woo,
family office. She is also a global economist Statista, https://www.statista.com/ “TikTok National-Security Deal Faces More
statistics/1102729/china-share-of- Delays as Worry Grows Over Risks,” Wall
and author who analyzes international affairs
working-age-persons/. Street Journal (December 6, 2022), https://
and the macroeconomy. She earned a PhD in 6. “National Debt in Relation to Gross www.wsj.com/articles/tiktok-national-
economics from Oxford University, an MPA from Domestic Product (GDP) in China from security-deal-faces-more-delays-as-
Harvard University, and an MBA in finance and 2010 to 2020 with forecasts until 2027,” worry-grows-over-risks-11670342800.
a BS in chemistry and finance from American Statista (October 17, 2022), https:// 12. “Alabama, Utah Become the Latest U.S.
University. Contact her at office@versaca.com. www.statista.com/statistics/270329/ States to Ban TikTok on State Devices,”
national-debt-of-china-in-relation-to- Reuters (December 13, 2022), https://www.
gross-domestic-product-gdp/. reuters.com/world/us/alabama-utah-
7. “Foreign Investment in Developing Asia become-latest-us-states-ban-tiktok-state-
ENDNOTES Hit a Record $619 Billion in 2021,” UNCTAD devices-2022-12-13/.
1. “The Great Rivalry: China vs. the U.S. in the (June 9, 2022), https://unctad.org/news/ 13. S. Chiang, “Microsoft’s Satya Nadella Says
21st Century” (December 7, 2021), https:// foreign-investment-developing-asia-hit- He Is ‘Very, Very Bullish’ on Asia, Especially
www.belfercenter.org/publication/great- record-619-billion-2021. China and India,” CNBC (November 16,
rivalry-china-vs-us-21st-century. 8. A. Fujita, “Why US Tech Controls on 2022), https://www.cnbc.com/2022/11/17/
2. MSCI China Index (USD) Fact Sheet, China Could End Up Hurting American microsoft-satya-nadella-is-very-bullish-
https://www.msci.com/documents/10199/ Semiconductors,” Yahoo Finance on-asia-china-and-india. html.
aa99c3a4-d48b-44ac-8caa-49522caa9021. (October 22, 2022), https://finance.yahoo. 14. J. Chung and J. Yang, “Tiger Global Halts
3. E. Curran, “Foreigners Pulled $8.8 Billion com/news/why-us-tech-controls-on- New Chinese Equities Investments,”
From China’s Markets Last Month,” Bloomberg china-could-end-up-hurting-american- Wall Street Journal (November 3,
(November 8, 2022), https://www. semiconductors-193354968.html. 2022), https://www.wsj.com/articles/
bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-11-08/ 9. M. Carter, O. Porter, M. Filosa, N. Tamarin, tiger-global-halts-new-chinese-equities-
foreigners-pulled-8-8-billion-from-china- and A. Fitch, “Who’s Down With ESG? The investments-11667510261.
s-markets-last-month. U.S. Midterm Elections & The Future of ESG
4. S. Kimball, “World Population Reaches Investing,” Teneo (November 28, 2022),
8 Billion People, with India Expected to https://www.teneo.com/whos-down-with-
Surpass China as Most Populous Nation,” esg-the-us-midterm-elections-the-future-
CNBC (November 15, 2022), https://www. of-esg-investing/. CONTINUING EDUCATION
cnbc.com/2022/11/15/world-population- 10. Letter from Josh Hawley to Janet Yellen
To take the CE quiz online, go to
reaches-8-billion-people-with-india- (September 19, 2022), https://www.hawley.
www.investmentsandwealth.org/IWMquiz
expected-to-surpass-china-.html. senate.gov/sites/default/files/2022-09/

2021–2022
COURSE
CATALOG

INVESTMENTS & WE ALTH MONITOR 59

© 2023 Investments & Wealth Institute. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
®

5619 DTC Parkway, Suite 600


Greenwood Village, CO 80111
Phone: +1 303-770-3377
Fax: +1 303-770-1812
www.investmentsandwealth.org

© 2023 Investments & Wealth Institute®. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.

INVESTMENTS & WEALTH INSTITUTE® is a registered mark of Investment Management Consultants Association Inc. doing business as Investments & Wealth
Institute. CIMA®, CERTIFIED INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT ANALYST®, CIMC®, CPWA®, CERTIFIED PRIVATE WEALTH ADVISOR®, RMA®, and RETIREMENT MANAGEMENT
ADVISOR® are registered certification marks of Investment Management Consultants Association Inc. doing business as Investments & Wealth Institute.

You might also like