Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fetish Source #3
Fetish Source #3
Fetish Source #3
INTRODUCTION
palpable facts that can be offered as proof (Samuels, 1996; Marocco, 1997;
Rivera, 1997; Eby, 1999; David, 1999; Schkolnik, 2000; Bass, 2001).
Among the objects frequently sought as fetishistic are shoes, bras, and
panties, etc. Sometimes in a search for fetishist objects housebreaking occurs as
the individual searches for women’s used bras or panties. This will be discussed
in crimes associated with fetishes.
Among treatment approaches used to combat fetishes are aversive condi-
tioning including nausea inducing drugs and mild electric shock associated with
the object of the fetish or the fantasy of it. Many fetishists are impotent without
the use of their “object” or procedures leading to excitement. Without fetishist
objects being present erectile failure frequently results. As already mentioned
theft is often involved as the fetishist seeks clothing from washing lines or from
houses where a female resides.
The exact incidence of this need for fetishist objects is not known and
frequently kept secret by individuals. It tends to begin during adolescence or
even before. It persists for most of the individual’s life. Frequently such indi-
viduals are shy and socially withdrawn. They may well be ashamed of their
dependence on their particular fetish, and hence attempt to keep their fetish
secret.
EARLIEST RESEARCH
LATER RESEARCH
1. Types of fetishes.
2. Causes of fetishes.
a) Explanation via psycho-analytic theories.
b) Causes explained on the basis of non psycho-analytic theories.
3. Criminality and fetishes.
Fetishes and Their Associated Behavior 137
TYPES OF FETISHES
Transvestite-type Fetishes
Disabled Fetishes
It appeared that disabled women and girls were a common focus of fetishism
for men due to their relative immobility making them especially vulnerable to
sexual abuse (Elm, 1997). A study by Waxman-Fiduccia (1999) focused on still
photographs of physically disabled women who had involved themselves in erotica
and pornography as sex workers, entrepreneurs, and relationship seekers. The
photographs were described as both perverse and exploitative of these women.
Amputee fetishism and genital mutilation fetishists were noted by Wise and Ka-
lyanam (2000). A case was presented of a 49 year old man who amputated his penis
following instructions that he had obtained from the internet. The individual had a
long-standing amputee fetish which evolved into eroticized genital mutilation. The
transformation of the preferred fetish occurred in the setting of a depression due to
environmental stressors. The literature about amputee fetishism, also called “apo-
temnophilia,” contains other cases of genital mutilation.
Aguilera (2000) discussed sexual attraction to disabled individuals by de-
votees, that is, individual who were sexually aroused or interested specifically
in people with disabilities, and responses to that attraction. Countless Internet
websites, many run by females, sell devotee material, such as photographs,
videos and used crutches for fetishists in that area.
Finally Elman (2001) suggested that because disabled women and girls
inherited ascriptions of pasivity and weakness, pornographers and others some-
times selected them to portray as ultimate compliance sex objects.
Other Fetishes
ally transmitted diseases and foot fetishism. An exponential increase was noted
during the period of the current AIDS epidemic. Pantyhose fetishes are also
very common as noted by Lothstein (1997). He suggested that the wearing of
pantyhose by males served a range of functions including, but not limited to,
“repairing psychic structures,” and expression and defence against underlying
aggression, enabling the development of symbol formation, allaying anihilation
and separation anxiety. Pantyhose was considered a “second skin” for protec-
tion purposes. It was even considered a “magic skin” approach and inherent
within it a psycho-analytic theory viewpoint.
Anal and sadomasochistic sadism were noted by Schteingart-Gitnacht
(1998). Here again was a psycho-analytic study which considered anal fetish-
ism a form of chaotic anality based on the “social evils of our time.”
In the past decade, fetishism has been increasingly applied to a wide vari-
ety of behaviour and mentation and is not limited to males. The author drawing
on a lengthy analysis of a female patient suggests a fetish is not always an
inanimate object. Living objects such as cats can become fetishes. He further
offers the idea that fetishism belongs on a continuum with a whole gamut of
phenomena which involves the need for a transitional object which is given the
endowment of magical properties. All these phenomena have in common the
use of an outside object bestowed by magic and illusion to control anxiety. A
combination of fetishes were studied by Furnham and Haraldsen (1998). They
studied four types of paraphilia; fetishism, paedophilia, sexual sadism and voy-
eurism. A factor analysis of this study revealed a clear and logical factor struc-
ture for aetiology and cure items. It was vital to know the cause according the
these investigators in order to have success in the treatment. This view is likely
to be contradicted by behaviourists who consider the immediate situation with-
out the need for knowing causes as a primary objective in therapy.
A study by Eby (1999) indicated that Hemingway, the famous fiction writer
had a lifelong erotic obsession with hair. Consumer capitalism has also been
ignored as a possible fetish by Billig (1999). He re-examined Marx’s notion of
“commodity fetishism” and argued that this concept offered much for an under-
standing of the psychology of consumer capitalism. This has been studied in some
detail by the author of this paper (Lowenstein, 1996, unpublished stud). The term
“onomania” has been used to describe this type of fetish.
CAUSES
Psychoanalytic Approaches
fantasies to reassure themselves that they were not hurting a real partner (Weiss,
1998). Fetishes it was noticed were almost totally permanent once established.
Such fetishes were developed in early childhood and led to early sexual arousal
(Munroe & Gauvain, 2001). A case of foot fetish and shoe fetish in a 6 year old
girl was studied by Hopkins (2000). The cause of such a fetish was that she had
been a victim of terrifying, life threatening assaults by her father who had died
before she was 4 years of age. It seemed probable that she had had, possibly
only in fantasy, an incestuous relationship with him. She also as a matter of
course identified herself with a male figure.
TREATMENT OF FETISHES
Problem
As one who has worked as an Expert Witness and clinical, forensic psy-
chologist for some years, one has had referred cases of fetishism. These persons
came into conflict with the law for various reasons. Unfortunately a number of
individuals were given a prison sentence despite the fact that some form of
Fetishes and Their Associated Behavior 143
therapy was recommended by the psychologist. Others were given the oppor-
tunity of receiving treatment outside the prison system.
Subjects
Over a 15 year period 20 consecutive referrals were made, all males aged
18–47 by solicitors and the courts (Table 1). The object of the referral essen-
tially was to obtain why the particular fetish was manifested and to give some
idea on how to deal with it via therapy.
Procedure
Case Illustration
Example 1
Mr S was attracted to the feet, and shoes worn by young women and children. He
was arrested by the police following a number of complaints about his touching and
feeling the feet of the complainants or the complainants’ children.
The psychologist discovered in the course of his interview with him, that he had as
a young child often sat at the feet of his mother while she stroked and fondled his head.
During this process of affection he often caught glimpses of her vaginal area from time
to time when his mother was in a short nightdress and was not wearing panties. He
became aroused by this but did not masturbate or touch his genitals.
Example 2
Mr W was arrested when a number of panties and a number of other female gar-
ments which had been reported missing in the neighbourhood were found in his posses-
sion. He had stolen these garments during the night and early morning hours from wash-
ing lines near where he lived and had been seen by one of the persons to whom the
panties belonged. He traced this fetish back to his childhood when he became aroused by
handling and smelling a pair of panties his sister had made him sniff.
Treatment
The diagnosis used, following the in-depth interview and objective and
projective testing, combined cognitive and behaviour therapy. Rational emotive
therapy also played a significant role. The individual was encouraged to engage
in his fetish with a partner who agreed to participate with him, or enjoyed the
excitement it produced in the subject. This excitement was then translated into
more acceptable procedures including dactile or oral of coital sexual behaviour.
In the case of the panty fetish, the individual was encouraged to buy these
and other relevant garments, rather than steal them, and he utilised these for the
purpose of mutual sexual gratification. In the case where there was no partner
available, the treatment consisted of rational, cognitive discussions as to the
avoidance of behaviour likely to lead to further attention by the police. No
efforts were made to de-condition the fetish object, but rather to avoid police
involvement as a result of the fetish behaviour. It was very much encouraged
that the individual develop an appropriate relationship with a partner ready to
accept the need for his fetish, and to make this a part of their sexual relation-
ship (Table 3).
Fetishes and Their Associated Behavior 145
CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES
Bass, A. Difference and disavowal: The trauma of eros. Stanford University Press. (2001). ix,
309pp.
Bhugra, D; de Silva, P. Uniforms—Fact, fashion, fantasy and fetish. Sexual and Marital Therapy.
1996 Nov; Vol 11(4): 393–406.
Billig, M. Commodity fetishism and repression: Reflections on Marx, Freud and the psychology of
consumer capitalism. Theory and Psychology. 1999 Jun; Vol 9(3): 313–329.
Carignan, L. The secret: Study of a perverse trasference. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis.
1999 Oct: Vol 80(5): 909–928.
Cole, G W. A slave to femininity: A relational view of the fetish. Gender and Psychoanalysis. 1999
Spr; Vol 4(2): 143–166.
Eby, C P. Hemingway’s fetishism: Psychoanalysis and the mirror of manhood. SUNY series in
psychoanalysis and culture. New York, NY, US: New York University Press. (1999). xv, 366
pp.
El-Badri, S R; Robertshaw, B A. Sexual fetishism associated with temporal lobe dysrhythmia and
learning disability: Two case studies. British Journal of Learning Disabilities. 1998 Aut; Vol
26(3): 110–114.
Elman, R A. Disability pornography: The fetishization of women’s vulnerabilities. Violence Against
Women. 1997 Jun; Vol 3(3): 257–270.
Elman, R A. Mainstreaming immobility: Disability pornography and its challenge to two move-
ments. Renzetti, C M (Ed); Edleson, J 1 (Ed); et al. (2001). Sourcebook on violence against
women (pp. 193–207). Thousand Oaks, CA, US: Sage Publications, Inc; Thousand Oaks, CA,
US: Sage Publications, Inc. xii, 539pp.
Freund, K; Seto, M C; Kuban, M. Two types of fetishism. Behaviour Research and Therapy. 1996
Sep; Vol 34(9): 687–694.
Furnham, A; Haraldson, E. Lay theories of etiology and “cure” for four types of paraphilia: Fetish-
ism, paedophilia, sexual sadism, and voyeurism. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 1998 Aug;
Vol 54(5): 689–700.
Giannini, A J; Colapietro, G; Slaby, A E; Melemis, S M; Bowman, R K. Sexualization of the
female foot as a response to sexually transmitted epidemics: A preliminary study. Psychologi-
cal Reports. 1998 Oct; Vol 83(2): 491–498.
Greenacre, P. Fetishism. Rosen, I (Ed). (1996). Sexual deviation (3rd ed.). (pp. 88–110). New York,
NY, US: Oxford University Press, xii, 496 pp.
Hopkins, J. A case of foot and shoe fetish in a 6 year old girl. Lubbe, T (Ed). (2000). The bor-
derline psychotic child: A selective integration (pp. 109–129). Philadelphia, PA, US: Taylor &
Francis; Philadelphia, PA, US: Taylor and Francis, xv, 218 pp.
Hotchkiss, S. The child as fetish: Theoretical considerations of the etiology of Munchausen by
Proxy syndrome. Clinical Social Work Journal. 1997 Fall; Vol 25(3); 315–322.
Junginger, J. Fetishism: Assessment and treatment. Laws, D R (Ed); O’Donahue, W T (Ed); (1997).
Sexual deviance: Theory, assessment, and treatment (pp. 92–110). New York, NY, US: The
Guilford Press. xii, 514 pp.
Kaplan, L J. Clinical manifestations of the perverse strategy. Psychoanalysis and Psychotherapy.
1997; Vol 14(1): 79–89.
Lothstein, L M. Pantyhose fetishism and self cohesion: A paraphilic solution? Gender and Psycho-
analysis. 1997 Jan; Vol 2(1); 103–121.
Lowenstein, L F. Onomania (Compulsive Shopping): Recent Research 1989–1995. Unpublished
study (1996).
Marshall, W L; Fernandez, Y M. Cognitive behavioral approaches to the treatment of the par-
philias: Sexual offenders. Caballo, V E (Ed); (1998). International handbook of cognitive and
behavioural treatments for psychological disorders (pp. 281–312). Oxford, England: Per-
gamon/Elsvier Science Ltd. xiv. 698pp.
Marucco, N C. Edipo, castracion u fetiche: Una revision de la teoria psicoanalitica de la sexu-
alidad./ Revision of the psychoanalytic theory of sexuality: Oedipus, castration and fetish.
Revista de Psicoanalisis. 1996 Jul–Sep; Vol 53(3): 677–687.
Marucco, N C. Edipo, castacao e fetiche: Ume revisao da teoria psicanalatica da seualidade./
Oedipus, castration and fetish: A revised psychoanalytic theory of sexuality. Revista Brasileira
de Psichanalise. 1996; Vol 30(3): 547–553.
Fetishes and Their Associated Behavior 147
Marucco, N C. The Oedipus complex, castration and the fetish: A revision of the psychoanalytic
theory of sexuality. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis. 1997 Apr; Vol 78(2): 351–355.
Marucco, N C. Oedipuskomplex, Kastration und Fetisch: eine Revision der pscyoabalytischen Sex-
ualtheorie./Oedipus complex, castration and fetish: a revision of the psychoanalytic theory of
sexuality. Jahrbuch der Psychoanalyse. 1997; Vol 38: 65–76.
Massie, H; Szajnberg, N. The ontogeny of a sexual fetish from birth to age 30 and memory pro-
cesses: A research case report from a prospective longitudunal study. International Journal of
Psycho-Analysis. 1997 Aug; Vol 78(4): 755–771.
McCann, J T. Borderline personality dynamics, fetishism and burglary in adolescence. American
Journal of Forensic Psychology. 2000; Vol 18(3): 5–15.
Munroe, R L; Gauvain, M. Why the paraphilias? Domesticating strange sex. Cross Cultural Re-
search: The Journal of Comparative Social Science. 2001 Feb; Vol 35(1): 44–64.
Nersessian, E. A cat as fetish: A contribution to the theory of fetishism. International Journal of
Psycho-Analysis. 1998 Aug; Vol 79(4): 713–725.
Rachman, S J. Sexual fetishism: An experimental analogue. Psychological Record. 1966. No 16:
pp. 293–296.
Rachman, S J; & Hodgson, R J. Experimentally induced sexual experimental fetishism: Replication
and development. Psychological Record. 1968, No 18: pp. 25–27.
Rivera, T. O fetiche, subversao de simbolo./ The fetish as a subversion of the symbol. Percuso:
Revista de Psicanalise. 1997; 10(19)[2]: 13–20.
Samuels, R. Theoretical and psychoanalytic approaches to the culture of addiction. Journal for the
Psychoanalysis of Culture and Society. 1996 Fal; Vol 1(2): 165–167.
Sawyer, D. An attempt to repair: The meanings of fetish in the case of Mr A. Issues in Psycho-
analytic Psychology. 1996; Vol 18(1): 21–35.
Schkolnik, F. Comentario sobre el articulo de Norberto C. Marucco./ Comments on an article by
Norberto C. Marucco. Revista de Psicoanalisis, 2000 Jan–Mar; Vol 57(1): 27–30.
Schlesinger, L B; Revitch, E. Sexual burglaries and sexual homicide: Clincal, forensic, and investi-
gative considerations. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 1999; Vol
27(2): 227–238.
Schteingart-Gitnacht, A. Le probleme economique de l’analite: A propos d’analite./ The economic
problem of anality: Regarding anality. Revue Francaise de Psychanalyse. 1998 Nov–Dec; Vol
62(5): 1701–1748.
Skogerbo, A. Human sexuality and its diagnosis. Scandanavian Journal of Sexology. 1990 Dec; Vol
2(4): 203–206.
Twohig, F; Furnham, A. Lay beliefs about overcoming four sexual paraphilias: Fetishism,
paedophilia, sexual sadism and voyeurism. Personality and Individual Differences. 1998 Feb;
Vol 24(2): 267–278.
Waxman-Fiduccia, B F. Sexual imagery of physically disabled women; Erotic? Perverse? Sexist?
Sexuality and Disability. 1999 Fal; Vol 17(3): 277–282.
Wise, T N; Kalyanam, R C. Amputee fetishism and genital mutilation: Case report and literature
review. Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy. 2000 Oct–Dec; Vol 26(4); 339–344.
Zucker, K J; Blanchard, R. Transvestic fetishism: Psychopathology and theory. Laws, D R (Ed);
O’Donahue, W T (Ed). (1997). Sexual Deviance: Theory, assessment, and treatment (pp. 253–
279). New York, NY, US: The Guilford Press. xii, 514 pp.
Copyright of Sexuality & Disability is the property of Springer Science & Business Media B.V. and its content
may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express
written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.