Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Perry 1975
Perry 1975
To cite this article: John Weir Perry (1975) Jung and the New Approach to Psychosis, Psychological
Perspectives: A Quarterly Journal of Jungian Thought, 6:1, 37-49
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the
“Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis,
our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to
the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions
and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors,
and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content
should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources
of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims,
proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever or
howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising
out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any
substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,
systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms &
Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-
and-conditions
CENTENARY ESSAYS
mind. The discovery is being made in many quarters today that when
this labeling judgment is lifted from the so-called patient, in certain
kinds of psychosis the signs and symptoms of insanity lift very soon
without the need of medical treatment. From that point on, the ques-
tion becomes what to do with a highly activated visionary state.
A most eloquent expression of this issue is made by Theodore Roszak
in Where the Wasteland Ends:
To be mad, as the world judges, is to be trapped in a narrow and lonely
reality. To be sane, as the world judges, is to be trapped in a reality no less
narrow, but heavily populated. But there is also the higher sanity, which is
neither the going consensus nor the latest compensatory excess. Its health
is freedom from all traps; its sign is the knowledge of many realities. All
realities are real: but [the higher] sanity’s reality is vaster, more various,
more vividly experienced in all its sectors, and more judiciously ordered.
Jung, of course, always maintained the position that schizophrenia
was a psychopathology, and never refrained from regarding it as a men-
tal disorder, with possibly a chemical basis. However, he was the first
to state that it contained nature’s efforts to heal, that what one witnessed
on the wards was largely an artifact of hospitalization and its methods,
and that schizophrenia was amenable very frequently to psychotherapy.
His early essays on various aspects of psychology all laid the ground-
work for the present-day trends in formulation and management of the
acute episode. It is always to be borne in mind that Jung’s life work
sprang at first out of his explorations of schizophrenia, and his first
masterworks were both on that topic.
My own special appreciation of these early insights and their psy-
chological quality is an outcome of my studies of madness and vision-
ary states. At this time our view of psychosis is beginning to change
toward regarding the acute episode not as a psychopathology but as an
“altered state of consciousness,” a “crisis in growth and development”
of such proportions as to throw the psyche into a “high arousal state.”
38 John Weir Perry
This shift in attitude toward the episode occasions a choice in the han-
dling of it, whether to stifle the episode by medication because it is an
undesirable and destructive process, or to release it as a potentidly
valuable move of nature to reorganize the self.
In the Jungian model, these high arousal states are regarded as acti-
vations of the deeper functions of the psyche, that is, the archetypal
affect-images. These are the dynamic foci of meaning and emotion that
Downloaded by [Memorial University of Newfoundland] at 22:32 05 March 2015
are activated when the stresses of the personality or of the culture are
such as to create an urgent need for a new orientation. Those that we
see in our ordinary practice are lesser versions of states that are written
in the large in the careers of the great visionaries and prophets in various
cultures in times of crisis, In their “visionary states,” these exceptional
individuals experience and express new myth forms that often become
capable of renovating their cultures, which have fallen into the s -ess
state of cogniuve and affective dissonance.
This’picture of altered states and visionary states in the intense ex-
perience of rapid cuiture change has given me a new impression of what
is happening in the myth forms experienced in the acute schizophrenic
states. The reorganization that has presented itself again aud again in
these forms that I have encountered has basically consisted of a &a-
matic shift from affect-images of power and the Logos principle to those
of relatedness and the Eros principle. This same shift is found in the
great myth and ritual forms of archaic cultures we are familiar with,
which first produced the urban revolution with its heavy power mode
and shortly later the age of the great prophets and philosophers who
proclaimed the virtues of the Eros way of life and its spiritual cultivation.
The history of visionary and mystical states in the more developed
cultures suggests that they activate this “receptive mode” that motivates
us to relate sensitively and caringly toward our fellow beings.
The processes occurring in depth in the psyche can only be under-
stood within the framework of the general historical setting. Jung made
a point of this in his studies of medieval nature philosophy. In Psychol-
ogy and Alchemy, he says about psychotherapy:
Even when the patient believes himself quite unprejudiced [in respect to
philosophical outlook] the assumptions underlying his thought, mode of life.
morals, and language are historically conditioned down to the last detail.
The same holds true €or the investigator of psychology. Jung stood
New Approach to Psychosis 39
ing in order to gain mastery and control over nature and power over her
processes. For example, Locke urged that “figurative speech serves but
to insinuate wrong ideas, move the passions, and thereby mislead the
judgement.” Descartes, too, maintained that “whether awake or asleep,
we ought never’to allow ourselves to be persuaded of the truth of any-
.
thing unless on the evidence of our reason . . ‘reason’, not of our
imaljlation or our senses.” Imagination in this instance meant forming
images to combine and synthesize the data of our senses-that faculty
that Einstein later found indispensable in creative scientific thought
process. All this Descartes declared despite his own experience of discov-
ering the new laws of mathematics through a visionary state, that is,
as a revelation from the visitation by an angel!
The romantic era registered its protest against such constraints of the
mind. Roszak reminds us what a standard-bearer Blake was, proclaiming
that “Enthusiasm is the All in All!”and that “Enthusiastic Admiration
is the First Principle of Knowledge and Its Last.” Imagination for Blake
was a divine principle.
The splendid culmination of this cultural shift came in the person
of the poet-scientist Goethe. Over against the “domineering analysis”
of the rationalistic hard science he preferred a “passive attentiveness,”
that which we would recognize as the “receptive” mode. As Roszak
puts it, “he had a sharp eye for the unique moment, the astonishing
insight, crowning perhaps years of watchful waiting . . . getting into the
.
swing . . gradually, patiently, receptively, even as we get to know-by-
loving and love-by-knowing.” With an ‘‘inner eye that sees the under-
lying ideas” in nature, Goethe said of his way:
.
By contemplation of an ever-creative nature . . had I not myself ceaselessly
pressed forward to the Archetype, though at fmt unconsciously. from an inner
urge; had I not even succeeded in evolving a method in harmony with Na-
ture?”
40 John Weir Perry
Early in his career Jung revealed the many affinities he had with
Goethe, who he thought might be his biological ancestor but was at
least his spiritual forebear. In the two years after his break with Freud,
he published four essays which delineated his basic p i n t of view and
his method of observation and of therapy. I consider it to be these that
made possible his whole new look at the problem of schizophrenia and
also our own quite Merent way of viewing and handling it today.
Downloaded by [Memorial University of Newfoundland] at 22:32 05 March 2015
the seat of active and directed functioning, with the faculties of speech
and logical processing of data, and with sharply differentiated percep-
tion. The right is the area handling the receptive mode, which processes
data in a holistic manner, and the paralogical thought process, i.e.,
thinking via image, symbol, and metaphor.
Jung’s validation of the subjective viewpoint in his initial discourse
Downloaded by [Memorial University of Newfoundland] at 22:32 05 March 2015
was enlarged and amplified in an essay following soon upon it. “On
Psychological Understanding” was written together with his first at-
tempt at dealing with the problem of defining an energic concept of
the libido, “On Psychic Energy,” and they were meant at first to be
companion pieces. Both are highly sophisticated approaches to the prob-
lems of theory by way of examining the standpoint of the observer. The
only possible hope for generally valid theories is to take account of the
psychology of the psychologist’s viewpoint.
Jung pointed to two opposing but fundamental ways of viewing psy-
chological experience, the prospective and the retrospective views. Where
the retrospective deals with material in an “analytic-reductive” fashion,
the prospective does so in what Jung termed a “synthetic-constructive”
method. The former, for example, seeks to reduce a symbolic state-
ment, like a poem, to its determining factors, whereas the latter wants
to discover what the poet means by his metaphorical expressions.
Where the reductive explanation analyses the complicated symbolic
product to its simple basic causes and general principles, the construc-
tive way explains by observing the living effect of the symbolic ex-
pression upon the subject, and it keeps it alive and creative as it builds
toward higher and more differentiated forms moving toward unknown
but individual goals. The analytic view has the satisfaction of achieving
a more objective understanding, whereas the other gives special validity
to the subjective meaningfulness.
Jung cites the delusional system of Schreber, about which Freud had
written his famous formulation of the paranoid mechanism from the
reductive point of view. Jung presented the other way of understanding
this from the constructive viewpoint, which does not look upon the
imagery as infantile or pathological only. He saw Schreber as consumed
by a desire to create world systems, which can be understood as efforts to
enable the individual to assimilate newly activated unknown psychic
42 John Weir Perry
phenomena and thus to find a way of adapting to his own inner psychic
world, a subjective adaptation. It amounts to a stage on the way to adapt-
ing the personality to the world, a stage that is characteristic of the type of
personality that needs a previous conceptual formulation of the world,
a preliminary philosophy, before feeling at home in it.
About the necessity to such an individual of having his visionary
experience validated, Schreber himself was eloquently forceful: after
Downloaded by [Memorial University of Newfoundland] at 22:32 05 March 2015
stating that the person in the normative state is “mentally blind” com-
pared with him who is not and who receives “supernatural impressions,”
he writes in his Memoirs: “He is therefore as little likely to persuade
the visionary of the unreality of his visions as a person who cau see
will be persuaded by a really blind person that there are no colors. .. ”
Jung’s essay first keynoted the approach that has since become char-
acterized as the “growth” or “developmental crisis” model, which is the
current trend in the formulation and treatment of the schizophrenic
episode. That is, this model views the activation of non-rational and
unconscious contents and the consequent turmoil as part of the psyche’s
effort to reorganize for further growth.
The companion piece to this essay on psychological understanding-
also first written in 1914 but not published until years later-dealt with
the sticky problem of how to assess the energies of the psyche and
formulate them in a way that did them justice. Here again Jung noted
that the standpoint of the observer leads him to the selection of what he
sees and to the conclusions that he draws. Thus a preference for the
objective viewpoint leads one to conceive energy in concretized form
as it is embodied in the play of “forces,” such as a specifically sexual
libido or a power drive. The subjective outlook, however, requires that
one perceive energy as primarily a mental concept, as a pure system of
relations of energetic values, thus framed in a quantitative mode rather
than the qualitative one that sees only specific energic forces. Conver-
sions and transformations of energy can be well accounted for in this
conceptual framework that deals with pure energic relations and with
the symbols and processes that effect these changes. The role of the
symbol then is to operate as a device for transforming energy. This is a
statement that can be made only in a context that sees purposive
and aimful activity in the unconscious processes. From this point of
view, also, energy can be seen to be generated by the play of opposites
New Approach to Psychosis 43
down by the delusional system itself. The thoughts of the Patient must be
taken seriously and followed out to their logical COnCldon; in that Way the
investigator himself takes over the standpoint of the psychosis.
what a wildly daring and what a true directive for m i n g and validat-
ing the efforts the psyche is making in the psychotic state to solve its
problems! What could be more like Goethe’s way of approaching nature,
whereby “The knower must blend with the known unobtrusively,” by
Downloaded by [Memorial University of Newfoundland] at 22:32 05 March 2015