Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ablation Casting of Thin-Wall Ductile Iron
Ablation Casting of Thin-Wall Ductile Iron
J. Campbell
School of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering, The University of Birmingham, Edgbaston B152TT, UK
Abstract
An unalloyed thin-wall ductile cast iron with the chemical microstructure of the 1 mm thick cast section. In the 2-mm-
composition of C = 3%, Si = 4.15%, Mn = 0.36%, Mg = thick specimen, ablation increased the nodule count from
0.04%, and carbon equivalent of 4.39% was cast by both 497 to 1484 and graphite nodularity from 76 to 93%. In the
conventional and ablation casting in sections of nominal 8 mm section, the tensile yield strength increased from 539
thickness 1, 2, 4, 8 mm. The effect of various commercial to 624 MPa and elongation was increased from 4.9 to
inoculants (based on Zr, Sr, and Ba) on microstructure and 10.2%.
mechanical properties of the samples was investigated. In
the ablation casting, the mold is eroded away by water, and Keywords: ablation casting, thin-wall casting, ductile iron,
the water becomes responsible for the heat transfer from inoculation, tensile properties
the casting. In our work, ablative cooling could not be
applied quickly enough to have any influence on the
Thermal Analysis
Experimental Procedure
Figure 2 shows the cooling curves of both 4 mm thick
In this work, an induction furnace with 500 kg capacity ablation and conventionally cast specimens inoculated with
rammed with silica-based refractory was charged with steel the Ba-containing inoculant.
scrap, low-sulfur oil coke, and ferrosilicon. The final
chemical composition was determined by optical spark The cooling curves and the first derivative curves of each
spectroscopy. The sample was taken from the melt. specimen were investigated in an effort to extract the
Elements Si% Al% Ca% Ba% Sr% Zr% Mg% Ce% Fe%
Figure 2. The cooling curve of the 4-mm specimens in both ablation and
conventional casting.
critical solidification parameters such as cooling rate, ini- initiation of some solidification before ablating away the
tiation and end times of solidification, and nucleation times mold. This time effectively reduces the average solidifi-
of graphite, austenite, and eutectic phases. However, it was cation rate. However, when the water reaches the sample,
found the cooling rates were severely influenced by vari- the instantaneous cooling rate jumps to approximately 12
ations in the rate of cooling by the powerful cooling effect °C/s. Figure 3 illustrates the difference in the average
of the water jets. Thus, reliable and repeatable cooling cooling rate.
curves were not found to be achievable with the 4 mm
casting section. A better result might have been achieved Cooling rate was determined by dividing the temperature
for the 8 mm section, but in view of the potentially over- of nucleation of graphite at hypereutectic temperature
powering influence of fluctuations in the water cooling, this down to nucleation of eutectic reaction to time interval of
was not pursued. this period. Grassi and Campbell et al.11 found out that in
ablation casting, the cooling rate of their aluminum alloy
For ablation casting, after pouring the liquid metal, it is down to 400 °C was between 2.8 and 5 °C/s. They attrib-
sometimes appropriate for a short delay before the appli- uted the enhancement of cooling rate in ablation casting to
cation of the ablating water. This allows time for the the removal of the ’air gap.’
The two main aspects of the microstructure which were The higher nodule count is most likely the result of the
studied were (i) possible formation of inter-cellular car- increased number of nuclei activated by undercooling,
bides12 as a result of the segregation of elements like Cr, assuming a nucleation and growth model for nodule for-
Mn, and P in the matrix; and (ii) the size, nodularity, and mation. Adding to this effect is also, of course, the reduced
number of graphite nodules. time available for both growth and coarsening of nodules.14
The highest nodule count of 1470 nodule/mm2 in the 2 mm
Figure 4 shows the microstructures of the range of thin section is achieved by combining ablation casting with the
walls. Nodule count clearly appears to be increased by Ba-containing inoculant.
increasing cooling rate from both (i) reduced thickness and
(ii) the ablation process. The most dramatic changes were The reason for the Ba-containing inoculant having the most
observed in the sample inoculated by the Ba-containing influence on improving nodule count seems likely to be
inoculant and are therefore presented here. associated with its content of 2.5 wt.% Ba.
Figure 5 illustrates the microstructural changes of the We can speculate that barium sulfides may be formed and
specimens concerning specimen thickness, in all of the may act as preferred sites for the nucleation of nodules.15
casting methods. It was found that for all casting conditions,
by decreasing thickness, nodularity and carbide phases
increase while pearlite, ferrite, and graphite decrease. Nodularity
These results match with numerous earlier studies. Cho et al. The mechanical properties of thin-wall ductile cast iron,
found out that reducing the thickness of the inoculated spec- especially strength and toughness, are directly related to
imens leads to decreasing ferrite and increasing carbides13. the nodularity and nodule count.16
Figure 8 shows the unetched microstructures of the un- indicate that stress concentration sites in the graphite–fer-
inoculated and Ba-inoculated castings for 4 mm in both rite interface have been removed so that the strength and
casting conditions. ductility both benefit. The results of Alghanmi et al. on the
effect of nodularity on the strength of the ductile iron are
Conventional received wisdom would consider nodularity typical of those quoted to support this claim.17
to be important because high nodularity is thought to
In terms of the new concepts involving the presence of planar) advance along the surface of the bifilm. The spread
bifilms in suspension in the liquid iron, the bifilm is a of the graphite over its surface straightens or flattens the
favored substrate for the growth of graphite.18 If, therefore, bifilm, converting it from a fairly harmless convoluted,
a growing nodule contacts a bifilm, its growth is likely to compact inclusion into the semblance of an engineering
change from spherical advance to a linear (or rather, crack. The presence of invisible bifilms is indicated by a
lack of nodularity, and the presence of the bifilms is It is interesting to note that the nodule size has reduced
responsible for the associated loss of properties.7 uniformly (not crowded near the cast surface, for instance,
where cooling might be assumed to be highest), and
The loss of nodularity with increase in section size shown inoculation further reduces size but also has a strong effect
in Figure 7 is the result of the evolution of the structure of on nodularity. Overall, the result is an excellently uniform
the bifilms. Immediately following pouring the bifilms are microstructure.
Figure 8. Optical microstructure of the 4-mm specimens which were inoculated with the Ba-
containing inoculant: (a) ablation, (b) conventional.
Mechanical Properties
Tensile Properties
Figure 9. Mean diameter of nodules in all conditions.
The tensile test data are shown in Figures 11, 12.
Matrix Phases
Ablation is clearly useful for tensile properties, increasing
both strength and toughness. However, interestingly, of all
Figure 10 shows two types of ferrites. First, a ferrite shell
the inoculants, the Ba containing variety performs best,
surrounding the nodule, and second as a ’free’ or inter-
especially when used in conjunction with ablation. These
dendritic phase. Clearly, in ablation castings, the ferrite
findings apply to both the 4 and 8 mm thick sections.
around the graphite is the dominant phase, generally
Table 3 summarizes the differences between conventional
resulting in higher elongation after fracture but lower
and ablated 4 mm thick castings.
strength.19 In conventional casting, interdendritic ferrite,
pearlite, and carbide are the dominant phases. In addition,
According to small size of the shells in microstructure all
at the lower cooling rate, carbon has more time to diffuse
indents necessarily positioned exactly on each phase, so
out of the austenite, forming more graphite.20
each indent would not influence nearby phases. Therefore
applied Hv 0.05 for 15s on surface of each specimen. An
The shell microstructure of ferrite halos in a pearlite matrix
essential factor improving the mechanical properties is the
is created by the higher cooling rate. The reduced time for
formation of shell microstructure. As has been shown in
the general diffusion of carbon out of the matrix to the
Figure 10. The optical image and SEM micrograph of 4-mm specimen which is inoculated by the Ba-
containing inoculant in: (a), (c) ablation and (b), (d) conventional condition.
many studies, this microstructure leads typically to 36% Another parameter affecting the mechanical properties is
enhancement in tensile properties in specimens over those fine pearlite. Finer pearlite enjoys the benefit of enhanced
structures which have the same kind and number of nod- constraint between its layered phases so that dislocation
ules but have free-ferrite microstructure.19 Additionally, a movement is limited, and strength is raised.
reduction in ferrite hardness (see Table 3) favors elonga-
tion, as confirmed by Al-ghonamy et al.17 In general, it is well known that the refinement of the
SDAS (secondary dendrite arm spacing) of cast alloys
Conventional Ablation
increases strength. In this study, taking the 4-mm- thick sharp knife edges demonstrate the extreme ductility of the
specimen as a single example, ablation has reduced the matrix, which has, microscopically, necked down perfectly
SDAS from 12.1 to 7.9 lm. for each specimens, SDAS to 100% R.A. (reduction in area).
measured for 6 times.
Figure 13a contrasts with the slower freezing conditions of
the conventional casting shown in Figure 13b. This unique
Fractography structure is appraised in detail in the Discussion.
The fracture surfaces of the tensile samples are examined Figure 14 shows the decohesion of some nodules during the
by SEM. fracture process. It is assumed that those that are not
completely detached and lost will still be present on the
In Figure 13a, the ductile dimple pattern is typical of opposite half of the fracture21,22.
ductile failure in an alloy with a population of decohering
or fracturing phases. It seems the nodules decohere from
the matrix, so with the continuing strain, the matrix Hardness
between nodules subsequently neck down, shearing on
45-degree maximum shear planes. The planes shuffle to Figure 15 reveals the Brinell hardness of the Ba-inoculated
form steep slopes, terminating in knife-edge arets where specimen. The hardness has not changed in 1-mm-thick
they meet the shear slope from the neighboring nodule. The specimens representing ablation cast specimens.
Figure 13. The fracture surface of 4-mm specimen which is inoculated by the Ba-
containing inoculant in: (a) ablation and (b) conventional freezing.