4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw

eries Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

Olympus Industrial Resources

Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC)
Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw
Detectors

Contemporary digital ultrasonic flaw detectors calculate commonly used parameters for reflector position in angle beam
testing, typically including sound path length, flaw depth, surface distance, and beam leg. These calculations are based o
a measured pulse transit time, calibrated material sound velocity and probe zero offset, and entered values for test piece
thickness, beam angle, and beam index point. By default, calculations assume a flat test piece. In the case of
circumferential inspection of tubular parts, the calculations must be adjusted for the effects of test piece curvature. This is
done by means of a mathematical correction based on entered outside and inside diameters of the test piece. The follow
topics will be reviewed.

1. Mathematical Theory
2. Previous Approaches
3. Implementation of Curved Surface Correction in EPOCH series flaw detectors
4. Measurement examples
5. Use of contoured wedges

1. Mathematical theory
In the case of common flat plate tests and axially-oriented tests of pipes and similar products, leg length and reflector de
and surface distance can be calculated through simple trigonometry through the formulas below. But when testing a curv
part in the circumferential direction, these formulas become inaccurate due to the curvature that effectively causes
reflectors to drop away from the probe, which lengthens the sound path and changes the reflection angle at the inside
surface of the part. For example, compare similar conditions for a 45° beam in flat and curved plates both 20 mm thick. T
signal obtained at a 35mm sound path length in a flat plate corresponds to a reflector located at a depth of 15.2mm,
24.8mm from the exit point. But the same 35 mm sound path in a 100mm diameter pipe corresponds to a reflector 19.2 m
deep from the OD surface and 31.7mm along the test surface from the exit point to the point over the reflector.

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 1/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

To correct for curvature, a number of mathematical relationships can be applied, based on the angles, measured sound
path and dimensions defined below. Utilizing these formulas with leg management enables proper calculation of surface
projection and vertical depth of flaws.

Legend for equations:

S = Surface Distance
Β = Angle of Refraction
Α = Sound path distance
t = Thickness
R1 = Inside Radius
R2 = Outside Radius
Βmax = Maximum angle of refraction
Ε = Angle of reflection at ID
Φ = Projection angle
D = Depth of reflector
1. Projection angle at ID (first leg)
Φ = sin-1(R2/R1 sinΒ)

2. Sound path distance Α, half skip

Α = R1∗sin(Φ_Β)/sin(Β)

3. Depth of reflector D
D = R2 – √Α2 + R22 - 2R2ΑcosΒ

4. Surface distance S
S = ΠR2/180[sin-1(R2/R1 sinΒ)-Β] Note: for first leg test, R1 = t-D

5. Maximum angle of refraction for a given wall thickness (angle of impingement)

Βmax = sin-1(R1/R2)

2. Previous approaches
Traditional analog flaw detectors measured sound path length only and could not automatically calculate reflector depth o
surface distance, or count skip legs. Live automatic displays of these additional dimensional parameters, based on
trigonometric calculations, were introduced with the development of digital instruments. However early model digital flaw
detectors calculated depth for flat test pieces only. Both with these instruments and analog flaw detectors, operators
performing circumferential testing on pipes and similar curved test pieces used graphs and nomograms such as the ones
below to calculate dimensions.

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 2/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

The graph at left is used to determine a correction factor k that is based on refracted angle and the ratio of wall thickness
and outside diameter. The nomogram at right is used to determine the actual reflected angle at the inside of the curved
surface, which because of the curvature is less than the refracted beam angle at the sound entry point.

Once k and the refracted angle Β have been determined, it is possible to calculate the actual leg length AB from the
formula:

AB = tk cosΒ

Once the leg length is known, a reflector can be accurately placed within the first or second leg of the sound path based
the measured sound path length. Further calculations of flaw depth and surface position must be done manually. As an
https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 3/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

alternative to calculations, look-up tables have been published that relate these geometrical corrections to test piece
diameter, wall thickness, and inspection angles.

In the absence of software for curved surface correction, another alternative to manual calculations or look-up tables was
empirically set up flaw detectors with the aid of a reference standard representing the tube wall in question and
incorporating a series of side drilled holes. Reflections from the multiple reference holes can be identified with respect to
horizontal position and a screen overlay can be used to mark their vertical depth and surface projected positions on the
display. The resulting screen display is horizontally non-linear, but reflector positions can be extrapolated from it by
referencing the overlay.

3. Implementation of Curved Surface Correction in EPOCH series flaw detectors

The Curved Surface Correction (CSC) software in the EPOCH series flaw detectors performs calculations automatically
based on setup information input by the user.

These calculations assume that initial probe calibration for sound velocity and zero offset have been performed as usual
an IIW-type block or similar flat reference block. Following that calibration, the operator enters the probe angle, the
thickness of the test piece, the “X value” (the distance between the beam index point and front edge of the wedge), and t

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 4/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

part diameter. The EPOCH software then uses that information plus the measured sound path length to calculate and
display the following, based on the equations in Section 1.

sound path length

Projected surface distance from front of probe (or beam index point if no X-value is input) along outside of the test piece

depth of reflector
Assuming proper calibration and setup, these measurements will be as accurate as those on a flat test piece in a given
setup. The example screens below show a typical measurement of a first leg reflector in a thick wall reference sample,
shown with and without CSC correction. When the correction is applied, the flaw depth measurement is shallower (1.13”
versus 1.31”) and the surface distance or projection is farther from the probe (1.39” versus 1.07”).

CSC correction off

CSC correction on
Additional notes:

In all tests that involve circumferential probe alignment it is very important to hold the probe normal to the surface
rather than tilting it. Tilting will skew the sound beam and effectively change the refracted angle in the test piece.
In cases where the ratio of wall thickness to diameter is large, the sound beam at a given angle may not reflect off
the ID, instead continuing straight across to the OD without a skip. (See section 1, equation 6.) In these cases CS

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 5/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

calculations are not valid and the EPOCH will not report dimensional information.

4. Example measurements using EPOCH 600

First leg measurements of pipe section with 0.1” side drilled holes as shown in photograph, using EPOCH 600 flaw detec
and A543S-RM transducer with ABWM-4T-45 wedge. Diameter is 5.0”, wall thickness 0.470”. Reflectors are 0.1” diamete
side drilled holes with centerline depths of 0.160” and 0.310” from OD (1/3 and 2/3 thickness).

The SDH diameter factor causes a small offset in the reading. When establishing the physical location of the reflector wit
the part it is important to measure depth and surface projection to the normal of the outer radius tangent. The measured
sound path displayed is not affected by CSC correction status. Proper calibration of zero offset and material velocity are
required. In the examples below:

Physical measurement of sound path to hole OD

Surface projection is measured from the beam index point (X Value=0)

First leg measurements

FIRST LEG CSC Off CSC ON Physical Measurement

Sound Path 0.47 0.47 0.46

Depth 0.33 0.31 0.31

Surface distance 0.33 0.38 0.40

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 6/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

CSC off

CSC on

Second leg measurements

SECOND LEG CSC Off CSC ON Physical Measurement

Sound Path 1.14 1.14 NA

Depth 0.14 0.27 0.22

Surface distance 0.8 1.04 1.03

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 7/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

CSC off

CSC on

Third leg measurements of pipe section with 0.1” side drilled holes.

THIRD LEG CSC Off CSC ON Physical Measurement

Sound Path 1.78 1.78 NA

Depth 0.32 0.16 0.160

Surface distance 1.26 1.54 1.50

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 8/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

CSC off

CSC on

5. Use of contoured wedges

As the diameter of a cylindrical test piece become smaller, circumferentially oriented coupling of conventional wedges
becomes progressively more challenging, due to reduced contact area and the increased possibility of rocking. For that
reason, special cylindrically contoured wedges are sometimes used on smaller diameter test pieces. As a guideline, the
International Institute of Welding recommends contouring whenever test piece radius R is less than the length of the wed
W squared divided by four:

The SDH diameter factor causes a small offset in the reading. When establishing the physical location of the reflector wit
the part it is important to measure depth and surface projection to the normal of the outer radius tangent. The measured
sound path displayed is not affected by CSC correction status. Proper calibration of zero offset and material velocity are
required. In the examples below:

R W2 / 4

ASTM standard E-164, Standard Practice for Ultrasonic Contact Examination of Weldments, calls for use of radiused
wedges whenever the part diameter is less than 20 inches or 500 mm. Olympus NDT experience suggests that this is a
conservative recommendation, especially when using small angle beam assemblies, but it is up to the user to determine
applicability to specific test.

The minimum outside diameter for which a wedge of a given size can be cylindrically contoured depends on mechanical
considerations related to wedge size and angle. The following chart lists the approximate minimum contouring diameter f
three common Panametrics-NDT wedge types.

Mi i OD f l t 45 d 60 d 70 d

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 9/10
4/3/24, 1:19 PM Theory and Use of Curved Surface Correction (CSC) Software in Olympus NDT EPOCH Series Flaw Detectors | Olympus IMS

Subscribe to the Evident email

Home | Resources | White Papers | Theory and Use of Curved Surface…

Print

Thickness and Flaw Inspection Solutions

Videoscopes and Borescopes

Industrial Microscopes

XRF Analyzers

Online Store

Support

Resources

Copyright EVIDENT, All rights reserved.

Terms Of Use | Privacy Notice | Cookies | Cookies Settings | About Us | Careers | Sitemap

https://www.olympus-ims.com/en/resources/white-papers/theory-and-use-csc/ 10/10