RESEARCH TITLE: “EXPLORING THE ROLE OF FORENSIC SCIENCE

IN INDIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM”

- PRAPTI KOTHARI

I. ABSTRACT

Forensic science encompasses various scientific disciplines, including DNA analysis,

fingerprint examination, ballistics, toxicology, and digital forensics, among others. These
disciplines play a crucial role in crime scene investigation, evidence collection, analysis, and
presentation in court. In recent years, there has been growing recognition of the importance of
forensic science in the Indian ‘Criminal Justice System’ (CJS). It plays a crucial role in the
CJS by providing scientific evidence to aid in the investigation and resolution of criminal
cases. The application of forensic science in the Indian criminal justice system faces several
challenges that affect the quality and reliability of forensic evidence. These challenges
include outdated forensic infrastructure, limited standardization and accreditation of forensic
laboratories, lack of comprehensive forensic training programs for law enforcement
personnel, and the absence of clear guidelines for the collection, preservation, and analysis of
forensic evidence. These issues can lead to the mishandling of evidence, contamination, and
unreliable results, which may adversely affect the outcome of criminal cases and lead to
miscarriages of justice. Overcoming these challenges can enhance the quality and credibility
of forensic evidence, strengthen the Indian criminal justice system, and ensure that justice is
served in a fair and reliable manner. Thus, there is a need to evaluate and enhance the
application of forensic science in the Indian criminal justice system to ensure that it is robust,
reliable, and adheres to international best practices. This research paper aims to explore
various fields of forensic science, the current legal framework & related judicial precedents in
the Indian criminal justice system, by identifying challenges, and proposing recommendations
for further improvement.
Keywords – Forensic Science, Scientific Disciplines, Criminal Justice System,
Challenges India

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

II. INTRODUCTION

Forensic science, as a multidisciplinary field that involves the application of scientific

methods to investigate and solve crimes, has gained significant importance in the criminal
justice system worldwide. It provides critical support in the collection, analysis, and
interpretation of evidence, which can help establish facts, identify suspects, and bring
criminals to justice. In the Indian context, forensic science has also been recognized as a
crucial component of the criminal justice system, with its application in investigations and
court proceedings.

However, despite the recognition of the importance of forensic science, there are challenges
that impact its effectiveness and reliability in the Indian criminal justice system. These
challenges include issues related to infrastructure, training, standardization, and the
admissibility of forensic evidence in courts. Additionally, the evolving nature of crimes and
advances in technology pose new challenges to forensic science in India. The lack of
standardized practices and guidelines, inadequate training and resources for forensic experts,
and limitations in forensic infrastructure can all impact the quality and reliability of forensic
evidence, potentially leading to wrongful convictions or acquittals.

Therefore, there is a pressing need for comprehensive research to critically analyze the
current state of forensic science in the Indian criminal justice system, identify challenges, and
propose evidence-based recommendations for its improvement. This research can help
address the gaps and limitations in forensic science practice in India, enhance the quality and
credibility of forensic evidence, and ensure that the criminal justice system operates in a fair
and reliable manner, upholding the principles of justice and due process.

III. CHAPTERIZATION

A. UNDERSTANDING FORENSIC SCIENCE VIS-À-VIS INDIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE

SYSTEM

Forensic science, the captivating realm that unlocks the enigmas of crime through scientific
investigation, has become an integral part of the Indian Criminal Justice System (CJS). This

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

multidisciplinary field encompasses a wide array of scientific techniques and methodologies
that aid in the collection, preservation, analysis, and presentation of evidence in courts of law.
1
From fingerprint analysis to DNA profiling, forensic science plays a pivotal role in the
investigation and prosecution of crimes in India, shedding light on the truth in the most
intricate cases. It has become a powerful tool in identifying perpetrators, linking them to the
crime scene, and presenting evidence in courts of law.

B. FIELDS OF FORENSIC SCIENCE UNDER INDIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM

The field of forensic science in India is extensive and diverse, encompassing various
specialized areas that contribute to the criminal justice system. These fields include but are
not limited to2:

1. Fingerprint Analysis: Fingerprint evidence is often considered the gold standard in

forensic science. Fingerprint experts use scientific methods to analyze fingerprints found
at crime scenes, on weapons, and other objects, and compare them with known prints to
identify suspects.3

2. DNA Profiling: DNA profiling, is a cutting-edge technique that involves the analysis of
DNA samples to establish the identity of individuals, determine familial relationships, and
link suspects to crime scenes. DNA profiling has revolutionized criminal investigations in
India and has been instrumental in solving numerous complex cases45.

3. Ballistics and Firearms Examination: This field involves the analysis of firearms,
ammunition, and ballistics evidence to determine the type of weapon used in a crime, the

1 Shali, Sonia Kaul, Applicability of Forensic Science in Criminal Justice System in India With Special
Emphasis on Crime Scene Investigation (June 25, 2018). Medico-Legal Desire Media and Publications, Medico-
Legal
Reporter, Inaugural Issue, June 2018 ISSN NO: 2347-3525, Available at
SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3220169
2 Gowsia Khan and Sheeba Ahad, “Role of Forensic Science in Criminal Investigation: Admissibility in Indian
Legal System and Future Perspective” 7(4) IJARSE pp. 220-34 (2018).
3 Aditya Jain, Evidentiary value of Fingerprints in Indian Criminal Justice System (2021),
https://articles.manupatra.com/article-details/Evidentiary-value-of-Fingerprints-in-Indian-Criminal-
JusticeSystem (last visited Apr 24, 2023).
4 Rebant Juyal, Regulation & Use of DNA Profiling in India, QMLJ 2(1), pp. 36-66 (2021) DOI:
5 .26494/QMLJ3940

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

 trajectory of bullets, and other critical information that helps reconstruct the sequence of
events. It serves as a crucial pillar in the quest for truth and justice, shedding light on the
hidden dangers that lurk within the realm of ballistics, and providing insights that help
6
unravel mysteries and bring perpetrators to justice.

4. Questioned Document Examination: This field involves the analysis of documents,

including handwriting, signatures, paper, ink, and other features to determine their
authenticity and link them to suspects in cases involving forgery, fraud, and other
document-related crimes.

5. Forensic Entomology: It is a burgeoning field in India that concerns itself with the study
of insects and arthropods in the context of criminal investigations. It aids in determining
the time and location of events, identifying drugs and poisons, and uncovering neglect or
injury timelines.7 Although in its early stages, it is witnessing continuous research and
experimentation, paving the way for advancements in criminal jurisprudence.

6. Forensic Toxicology89: It is the study of the effects of poisons and drugs on living
organisms. Forensic toxicologists analyze blood, urine, and other bodily fluids to detect
the presence of drugs, alcohol, and other toxic substances, and determine their role in
criminal cases such as poisoning and drug-related offenses.

7. Forensic Psychiatry10: It is a unique blend of medicine and law, and delves into the
intricate realm of mental health in the context of legal proceedings in India. With its
specialized knowledge, Forensic Psychiatry assesses the mental state of the accused,
provides expert opinions, and assists the judiciary in making informed decisions. From
evaluating criminal responsibility to determining fitness to stand trial, it brings clarity to
complex issues at the intersection of psychiatry and law, aiding in the pursuit of justice
with its profound insights and expertise.

6 G. Keerthna, FORENSIC EVIDENCE IN RESPECT OF BALLISTICS: AN INTERNATIONAL

PERSPECTIVE, 120 (5), IJPAM pp. 61-73, (2018)
7 Heli Dubey and Siddhi Nigam, FORENSIC ENTOMOLOGY IN INDIA: A ROAD LESS TRAVELLED, 1(1)
JLFJ pp.15-21 (2022)
8 Santhy, and Dr. K.V.K., The Realm of Forensic Toxicology in Criminal Justice System of India (February 18,
9 ). IJLPSR, 5 (1), 2023, pp. 42-46, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4367707
10 Shubha Deshpande, A MEDICO-LEGAL STUDY OF FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY IN INDIA, 2(1), pp. 1-9
IJLLR (2021)

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

8. Forensic Anthropology11: It is the scientific study of human skeletal remains in a legal
context, is gaining prominence in India's forensic realm. With its interdisciplinary
approach, utilizing techniques from anthropology, anatomy, and archaeology, Forensic
Anthropology aids in the identification of human remains, determination of age, sex,
stature, and ancestry, and reconstruction of events leading to death. It plays a crucial role
in unraveling mysteries and shedding light on the past in the pursuit of justice in India's
legal system.

9. Forensic Odontology10: It’s the application of dental knowledge in legal investigations, is

emerging as a valuable tool in India's forensic landscape. Through dental evidence
analysis and identification of bite marks, dental records, and dental remains, Forensic
Odontology assists in solving criminal cases and identifying human remains.

10. Cyber Forensics: It entails the skilful deployment of sophisticated investigation and
analysis techniques to collect and safeguard evidence from digital devices in a manner
that is admissible in a court of law. The overarching goal of cyber forensics is to conduct
a systematic examination while upholding the integrity of the chain of custody, in order to
unveil the truth behind the events that occurred on a digital device and identify the
responsible party. It can be aptly described as a meticulous and scientific approach to
preserving, acquiring, extracting, analyzing, and presenting evidence from digital sources,
such as computers, mobile devices, cameras, and other digital mediums.12

C. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK RELATED TO FORENSIC SCIENCE IN INDIA

The Indian criminal justice system has incorporated various legal provisions that govern the
admissibility and use of forensic evidence in courts. These provisions ensure that forensic
evidence is collected, preserved, and analyzed in a scientifically valid and reliable manner.
The following are some of the key legal provisions related to forensic science in India:

11 Baryah N., Krishan K., Kanchan T. The Development and Status of Forensic Anthropology In India: A
Review of The Literature and Future Directions. Med. Sci. Law. (2019);59:61–69. doi:
10.1177/0025802418824834. 10 Jeddy, N., Ravi, S., & Radhika, T. (2017). Current trends in forensic
odontology. Journal of forensic dental sciences, 9(3), 115–119. https://doi.org/10.4103/jfo.jfds_85_16
12 Lovanshi, M. and Bansal P. (2019), “Comparative Study of Digital Forensic Tools” in Springer Nature
Singapore, 2019. 2(1), pp. 195-204. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-6351-1

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

a. The Indian Evidence Act, 187213 (IEA):
It provides the legal framework for the admissibility and evaluation of forensic evidence in
Indian courts. The Act and forensic science share a significant relationship, as the Act lays
down the rules governing the admissibility, relevancy, and weight of evidence in Indian
courts, including forensic evidence. Whereas, the ‘forensic experts’ play a crucial role in
providing expert opinions, interpretations, and analysis of forensic evidence, assisting the
courts in arriving at just and fair conclusions in criminal cases. Some of the relevant
provisions of the Indian Evidence Act that are closely related to forensic science are:
• Section 4514: It deals with the opinion of experts. It allows for the opinion of experts,
including forensic experts, to be admissible as evidence in court. Forensic experts may
provide opinions on a wide range of matters such as handwriting analysis, fingerprinting,
DNA profiling, ballistics, and other scientific or technical matters.

• Section 4715: It deals with the opinion of the examiner of electronic evidence. It allows
for the opinion of experts in digital forensics or other related fields to be admissible as
evidence in cases involving electronic records, such as computer-generated documents,
emails, or other digital evidence.

• Section 7316: It deals with the comparison of signatures, handwriting, or finger

impressions. It allows for the admissibility of expert opinions in cases involving the
comparison of signatures, handwriting, or finger impressions, which may be crucial in cases
where identity or authenticity of documents is in question.

• Section 16517: This section deals with the power of the court to ask questions from
witnesses. The court may ask questions from forensic experts or other witnesses to clarify or
elucidate technical or scientific matters related to the evidence presented.

b. The Code of Criminal Procedure, 197318 (CrPC):

13 The Indian Evidence Act, 1872, No. 1, Acts of Parliament, 1872 (India).
14 See The Indian Evidence Act, 1872, §45.
15 See The Indian Evidence Act, 1872, §47.
16 See The Indian Evidence Act, 1872, §163.
17 See The Indian Evidence Act, 1872, §165.
18 The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, No. 2, Acts of Parliament, 1974 (India).

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

The CrPC and forensic science work in conjunction to ensure that forensic evidence is
‘collected, analyzed, and presented’ in a proper and legal manner in criminal cases. They
share a significant relationship, as the CRPC provides procedural guidelines for the
investigation, prosecution, and trial of criminal cases, including those where forensic
evidence plays a crucial role. Some of the relevant provisions of the CRPC that are closely
related to forensic science are:
• Section 4619: It deals with the power of the police to make arrests and the procedures
to be followed during arrests. Forensic techniques such as fingerprinting, DNA profiling, and
other forms of identification may be used to establish the identity of the accused during the
arrest process.

• Section 5320: This section pertains to the examination of accused persons by medical
practitioners, including the collection of bodily samples for forensic analysis. Forensic
examination of bodily fluids, DNA samples, or other physical evidence may be conducted to
establish the guilt or innocence of the accused.

• Section 20721: It deals with the supply of copies of documents and statements to the
accused. Forensic reports, laboratory findings, and other relevant documents may be provided
to the accused as part of the due process, allowing them to challenge or rebut the forensic
evidence presented against them.

• Section 29322: This section pertains to the admissibility of reports of government

scientific experts. Forensic reports or scientific analysis conducted by government experts
may be admissible as evidence in court, subject to certain conditions and requirements.

c. The Indian Penal Code, 1860 23(IPC):

The Act is a comprehensive criminal code that outlines various offenses and their
punishments in India. Forensic science, on the other hand, employs scientific methods and
techniques to collect, analyze, and interpret evidence in criminal investigations. The Act and
forensic science are closely intertwined, with forensic analysis often playing a crucial role in

19 See The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, §46.

20 See The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, §53.
21 See The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, §207.
22 See The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, §293.
23 The Indian Penal Code, 1860, No. 45, Acts of Parliament, 1860 (India).

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

investigating and prosecuting crimes. The relevant provisions in the IPC provide a legal
framework for the use of forensic evidence in criminal cases, helping to establish guilt or
innocence and ensuring justice is served. Several provisions in the IPC pertain to forensic
science, such as:
• Section 32824: It covers offenses related to causing hurt or injury by means of poison,
corrosive substances, or other noxious substances, and the punishment for such offenses.

• Sections 272 to 27825: These sections deal with offenses related to adulteration of food
or drink, spurious drugs, and spreading infection, which may require forensic analysis to
determine the presence of harmful substances.
• Sections 19526 and 46327: These sections pertain to forgery and document tampering,
which may require forensic examination of handwriting, signatures, or other document-
related evidence.

• Sections 304B28 and 498A29: These sections deal with offenses related to dowry deaths
and cruelty to married women, which may require forensic investigation of injuries, causes of
death, or other forms of evidence.

d. The Information Technology Act, 200030 (IT Act):

It is a crucial legislation in India that governs various aspects of Information technology and
cybersecurity. It provides a legal framework for digital evidence collection, preservation,
investigation, and prosecution, as well as safeguarding data protection and privacy. For
instance - Section 65B30 of the Act deals with ‘Admissibility of electronic record’ - It
provides the conditions under which electronic records can be admissible as evidence in
court, including the requirement for electronic records to be certified by a person occupying a
responsible official position. Forensic experts can play a crucial role in ensuring the
admissibility of electronic records by following the prescribed procedures and providing
expert testimony in court.

24 See The Indian Penal Code, 1860, §328.

25 See The Indian Penal Code, 1860, §272-278.
26 See The Indian Penal Code, 1860, §195.
27 See The Indian Penal Code, 1860, §463.
28 See The Indian Penal Code, 1860, §304B.
29 See The Indian Penal Code, 1860, §498A.
30 The Information Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008, No. 21, Acts of Parliament, 2000 (India).
30
See The Information Technology Act, 2000, §65B.

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

e. The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 198531 (NDPS Act):
The NDPS Act in India has a symbiotic relationship with forensic science, as the former deals
with offenses related to narcotics, drugs, and psychotropic substances and the latter plays a
crucial role in the investigation, prosecution, and conviction of such offenses. Some of the
relevant provisions of the NDPS Act that are closely related to forensic science are:
• Section 5032: This section deals with the power of an authorized officer to search and
arrest without a warrant, and the procedures to be followed during such searches. Forensic
science techniques such as drug identification, analysis, and weighing of seized substances
are essential in establishing the nature and quantity of the narcotics or drugs.

• Section 6733: This section deals with the punishment for publishing or transmitting
material that promotes the use of narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances. Forensic
examination of digital or printed material may be necessary to establish the content and
nature of such material.

f. The DNA Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Bill, 201934:

It is currently pending in the Indian Parliament, aims to regulate the use of DNA technology
in forensic analysis and establish a national DNA database. The bill provides guidelines for
the collection, analysis, and preservation of DNA evidence, and sets forth procedures for
DNA profiling and matching in criminal investigations.

D. NAVIGATING FORENSIC SCIENCE CHALLENGES IN THE INDIAN LEGAL

SYSTEM

Forensic science, the scientific application of knowledge and techniques to investigate crimes
and analyze evidence, plays a pivotal role in the Indian criminal justice system. The
utilization of forensic science has revolutionized the way crimes are solved and justice is
delivered. From fingerprint analysis to DNA profiling, forensic science has become a

31 The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (Amendment) Act, 1985, No. 61, Acts of Parliament, 1985
(India).
32 See The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, §50.
33 See The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, §67.
34 The DNA Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Bill, 2019, 128 of 2019

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

powerful tool in identifying perpetrators, linking them to the crime scene, and presenting
evidence in courts of law. However, despite its significance, forensic science in the Indian
criminal justice system faces numerous challenges that impact its effectiveness and reliability.

Challenges:

• Lack of Standardization: One of the primary challenges in the field of forensic science
in India is the absence of standardized protocols and procedures. 35 The lack of uniformity in
evidence collection, preservation, and analysis can lead to inconsistencies and errors in the
forensic examination process, thereby compromising the reliability of the results.

• Limited Infrastructure and Resources: Forensic laboratories in India often face issues
of inadequate infrastructure, outdated equipment, and a shortage of trained personnel. 36 This
can hinder the timely and accurate analysis of evidence, resulting in delays in investigations
and court proceedings.

• Quality Control and Accreditation: Ensuring the quality and reliability of forensic
evidence is crucial in the criminal justice system. However, many forensic laboratories in
India lack accreditation and quality control mechanisms, leading to concerns about the
accuracy and integrity of forensic findings.

• Backlog of Cases: The backlog of cases awaiting forensic analysis is a persistent

challenge in the Indian criminal justice system. Due to the limited capacity of forensic
laboratories and the increasing number of cases, evidence often remains unanalyzed for
prolonged periods, leading to delays in investigations and trials.37

• Lack of Awareness and Education: Another challenge is the limited awareness and
education about the importance of forensic science among law enforcement agencies, legal

35 Prachi Kathane, Anshu Singh, J.R. Gaur, Kewal Krishan, The development, status and future of forensics in
India, Forensic Science International: Reports, 3, (2021) 100215, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fsir.2021.100215.
36 Pioneer, T. (2023, April 24). INADEQUATE FORENSIC LABS DELAY JUSTICE. The Pioneer.
https://www.dailypioneer.com/2022/columnists/inadequate-forensic-labs-delay-justice.html
37 Indulia, B., E., & A. (2022, December 10). Integrating Forensic Techniques in Indian Criminal Justice
System SCC Blog. https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2022/12/10/integrating-forensic-techniques-in-indian-
criminaljustice-system/

10

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

 38
professionals, and the general public in India. This can result in improper evidence
collection, mishandling of evidence, and lack of effective utilization of forensic techniques in
investigations and trials.

E. LANDMARK JUDICIAL DECISIONS SHAPING FORENSIC SCIENCE IN INDIA

The Indian judiciary has delivered several landmark decisions that have shaped the
admissibility and use of forensic evidence in courts. These decisions have established legal
precedents and provided guidance on the importance of forensic science in the Indian
criminal justice system. Some of the significant judicial decisions related to forensic science
in India are:

• In the case of Selvi v. State of Karnataka,39 the Apex Court laid down guidelines for the
admissibility of narcoanalysis, brain mapping, and lie detector tests as evidence in court.
The court held that these tests are violative of the right against self-incrimination under
Article 20(3)39 of the Constitution of India and cannot be conducted on an accused
without their consent.

• The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Tomaso Bruno and Anr. v. State of Uttar
Pradesh,40 opined that the progressive realm of information technology and scientific
acumen must seamlessly permeate the investigative process, for electronic evidence has
the potential to be an invaluable ally to law enforcement agencies in establishing
irrefutable facts. The Court judiciously upheld the admissibility of electronic evidence,
while also laying down appropriate safeguards to ensure its authenticity and credibility.

• In the notable case of Sandeep v. State of Uttar Pradesh42, the distressing circumstances
unfolded as the accused, against the wishes of the victim, compelled her to undergo an
abortion, and upon her refusal, resorted to the heinous act of murder. Subsequently, the

38 Yadav P. K. (2017). Ethical issues across different fields of forensic science. Egyptian journal of forensic
sciences, 7(1), 10. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41935-017-0010-1 39 Selvi v. State of Karnataka, (2010) 7 S.C.C.
263 (India).
39 INDIA CONST. art. 20, cl. 3.
40 Tomaso Bruno and Anr. v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2015) 7 S.C.C. 178(India).
42
Sandeep v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2012) 6 S.C.C. 107 (India).

11

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

 fetus that was recovered from the womb of the deceased was subjected to meticulous
DNA analysis, which unequivocally established the accused as the biological father of the
unborn child. The esteemed Court aptly acknowledged the pivotal role played by DNA
evidence, in conjunction with other evidentiary facets, in conclusively proving the
accused's motive for committing the crime at hand.

• In the notable case of State of Tamil Nadu v. Nalini 41, which gained widespread
recognition as the Rajiv Gandhi Assassination case, DNA evidence played a crucial role
in linking the accused with the crime and identifying the victims and the assailant. Despite
the destruction of material evidence due to the explosion and dismemberment of bodies,
DNA tests were adeptly employed to establish vital connections in this landmark case.

• In the case of S.P.S. Rathore v. CBI & Anr.,42 the court deliberated upon the evidentiary
value of hand writing expert opinion in the context of a disputed signature. It emphasized
that expert evidence on handwriting is merely an opinion and cannot be held as
conclusive evidence. Relying solely on a handwriting expert's testimony is insufficient to
establish authenticity or identification. It highlighted the need for caution when evaluating
hand writing expert opinions in forensic document examination.

• In the riveting case of Sushil Kumar v. State (N.C.T of Delhi), 43 the circumstances were
chillingly grim. The accused, Sushil Sharma, callously perpetrated the murder of his wife,
Naina Sahni, through the use of firearm, and sought to conceal his heinous act by
attempting to incinerate her body in a tandoor. The diligent efforts of the investigating
authorities led to the recovery of a revolver and blood-stained clothing, which were
astutely subjected to forensic analysis. Furthermore, the blood samples of the victim's
parents were obtained, and the consequential DNA report irrefutably confirmed the
identity of the charred remains as that of their (deceased) daughter.

• In the distinguished case of Surendra Koli vs State of U.P.,46 which is famously known as
the Nithari case that was eventually unraveled through the meticulous application of

41 State of Tamil Nadu v. Nalini (1999) 5 S.C.C. 253 (India).

42 S.P.S. Rathore v. CBI & Anr, (2017) 5 S.C.C. 817 (India).
43 Sushil Kumar v. State (N.C.T of Delhi), (2014) 4 S.C.C. 317(India).
46
Surendra Koli vs State of U.P., (2011) 4 S.C.C. 80 (India).

12

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

 forensic science. The accused were subjected to a comprehensive array of forensic
techniques, including "narco-analysis," which involved the use of polygraph tests,
narcoanalysis drugs and brain mapping. Forensic experts conducted thorough psycho-
analysis of Koli to unravel his complex tendencies towards necrophilia, paraphilia, and
pedophilia.
Furthermore, high-level forensic experts performed ‘craniofacial reconstruction’ on the
recovered skulls, employing advanced forensic techniques to reconstruct the facial
features for identification purposes.

F. CONCLUSION

Forensic science has emerged as a compelling and indispensable tool in the Indian criminal
justice system, unraveling the mysteries of crime through scientific investigation. The fields
of forensic science, ranging from fingerprint analysis to DNA profiling, play a pivotal role in
the collection, preservation, analysis, and presentation of evidence in courts of law. Legal
provisions, provide a framework for the admissibility and use of forensic evidence in courts,
while judicial decisions have reinforced the importance of forensic science in establishing
guilt beyond reasonable doubt. As India continues to march towards a more robust and
efficient criminal justice system, forensic science will continue to play a crucial role in
uncovering the truth, ensuring justice for victims, and upholding the rule of law. With the
rapid advancements in technology and the constant evolution of forensic science, the future
holds immense potential for further innovations and advancements in this captivating field,
making it an exciting area of research and exploration for legal scholars, forensic experts, and
criminal justice practitioners alike.

G. WAY FORWARD

The following recommendations can serve as a roadmap for the stakeholders involved in
strengthening forensic science in India. With the advancements in forensic science and its
proper integration into the criminal justice system, India can achieve greater efficiency,

13

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

accuracy, and fairness in solving crimes, delivering justice, and ensuring the rights of victims
and accused alike.

• Promote Research and Innovation: Encouraging research and innovation in forensic

science can drive advancements in technology, methodologies, and best practices. Funding
research projects, establishing research collaborations, and incentivizing innovation can foster
cutting-edge forensic science techniques that enhance investigation, prosecution, and
adjudication processes.

• Enhance Forensic Facilities and Infrastructure: Investing in state-of-the-art forensic

facilities and infrastructure can bolster the capabilities of forensic science in India. Upgrading
laboratories, providing advanced equipment, ensuring adequate resources, and maintaining
high-quality standards can strengthen the forensic science infrastructure, enabling forensic
experts to perform their duties with efficiency and accuracy.

• Establish Forensic Science Training and Certification Programs: Implementing

comprehensive training and certification programs for forensic experts can enhance their
skills, knowledge, and professionalism. Offering specialized training in various forensic
disciplines, conducting proficiency tests, and promoting continuous learning can ensure that
forensic experts are well-equipped to handle the complexities of modern-day forensic science.

• Strengthen Current Legal Framework: Regularly reviewing and updating the legal
framework related to forensic science can ensure that it remains relevant, admissible, and
reliable in courts of law. Clear guidelines, standard operating procedures, and legal reforms
that align with international best practices can enhance the admissibility and acceptability of
forensic evidence in the Indian criminal justice system.

• Foster Interdisciplinary & International Collaborations: Promoting such collaborations

among forensic experts, law enforcement agencies, judiciary, legal professionals, and
academia can harness the collective expertise and knowledge to strengthen forensic science in
the criminal justice system. Creating platforms for regular exchanges, collaborations, and
knowledge-sharing can foster a synergistic partnership that enhances the quality and
reliability of forensic evidence.

14

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177

• Develop Specialized Forensic Units: Establishing specialized forensic units within law
enforcement agencies and judicial systems can facilitate timely and effective utilization of
forensic science in investigations and court proceedings. Dedicated units for DNA analysis,
digital forensics, fingerprint analysis, and other forensic disciplines can ensure specialized
expertise and efficient handling of forensic evidence.

• Build Public Awareness: Educating the general public about the role and significance
of forensic science in the criminal justice system can foster trust, transparency, and
confidence. Conducting public awareness campaigns, organizing community engagement
programs, and disseminating accurate information about forensic science can empower the
public to appreciate the value and impact of forensic evidence in ensuring justice.

• Regular Monitoring and Evaluation: Implementing a robust system for regular

monitoring and evaluation of forensic science practices, protocols, and outcomes can ensure
continuous improvement and quality assurance. Conducting audits, performance evaluations,
and feedback mechanisms can identify areas of improvement and enable evidence-based
decision-making for the advancement of forensic science in the Indian criminal justice
system.

15

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4565177