Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 4
Chapter 4
ciy1:er 4
-
Property Relations
124
PROPERTY RELATIONS
125
.'
Ptn ~ (l}IU .
If decedent was married w·th . . .
state need to be .. surviving spouse, property in the
_1
126
I ~, f,(lf(I l~·l:tt,,J,, .,
1
RING MARRIAGE
PROPERTY AC?Ul'RED DUive Property):
(Either Community or Exclus
. . be presu med to b long to
d . g ma rnage w1 11 rt P
Property acquired urm t be exclusive prope y rope 1
community unless it can be proven of.#cfe from a co mmon fund or fr
· .
acquired dunng mamag• e by onerous
. ILJ
rty
income of either of them is community prope .
2. Art. 92(2) of the New Family Code - ~operty for pe.rsonaf and
exclusive use of either spouse. However, JeWelry shall form part.
of the community property.
127
Ayv-ty 1?/,duJtt.1
Personal effects or . J
apparel, shoes and thbel~ngings such as clothing, wearing
either spouse ~re ~ hke for personal and exclusive use of
s
what was used to ~on i~ered exclusive property regardless of
acquired durin cqui~e th e property. In general, property
money or b e9 marnag~ by purchase with exclusive
considered y lxc~ange with exclusive property, shall be
exc us1ve property.
It
CPG APPLIES:
1. When the future spouses agree to it in the marriage settlement; or
2. To conjugal partnerships of gains already established between
spouses before the effectivity of the New Family Code (August 3,
1988), without prejudice to vested rig,hts.
129
P,/ "'! f 1y_l/t1,l111.;
*** Jewelry shall be considered community property even if they are for the exclusive use of either
spouse [under ACoP only as provided under Art. 92(2) of the New Family Code] .
A decedent died on February 29, 2020. The following assets were provided for the purpose
of determining the decedent's gross estate. If the item is an inclusion in the gross estate of
the decedent, classify the same as exclusive by writing "E'i or community/conjugal property
by writing "C" under the regime of conjugal partnership of gains (CPG) and absolute
community property (ACP). If the item is an exclusion from the gross estate, mark the item
as "X''
ITEM PROPERTY
CPG ACP
1. Cash owned by the decedent before the marriage
2. Commercial building owned before marriage \.
3. Income from item no.2 ~
130
AMIWAt:
I 'N
11. C 16.C
1. 6. X
12. C 17.E
2. 7. X
8. E 13.X 18.E
3. 19.C
4. 9. 14. X
10,C 15.C 20.E
5.
1. C 6. C. 11. C 16. C
2. C 7. C 12. C 17. E
,. 13. X 18. C \
3. 8. C
19. C I
4. 9. E 14. X
5. E 10,C . 15. C 20.E
I
CONJUGAL DEDUCTIONS, whether under absolute community or
property or conjugal partnership of gains:
4. All taxes, liens, charges, and expenses including major and minor
repairs upon conjugal property.
5. All taxes and expenses· for mere pre~ervation, made during the
marriage, upon the separate property of either spouse.
131 '
8. Th~ value of what is donated or promised by both spouses in favor of
their co~mon legitimate children for the exclusive purpose of
commencing or completing a professional or vocational course or
activity for self improvement.
■
Oblig~tions contracted during marriage are presumed to have
be~ef1t~d the family and therefore conjugal deductions. While
obhgat,ons contracted by either spouse before marriage are
exclusive deductions unless shown that the family gained benefits
from the said obligations.
132
TAT : xx xx
• R al r immovable property xx xx
• Tang1b\ p r onal property xx xx
11 lntangibl . prop rty* xx xx
• · rtain transfBrs 0
xx xx
Total xx xx xx
....Refer to certain transfers made before death but will take effect upon death (transfer rnortis causa) as
well as transfer under general power of appointment
r}
133
fL[usiRAr,oN 2 ,eased on RR 12-201a): -
proper Presentation of FAMILY HOME and STANDARD DEDUCTION under TRAIN Law
! (Other amounts are assumed for illustration purposes only)
I
------ ----- -- .
---- ---- --- ----
134
1-
l special Deductions p 10M r 0.0oo. rr1
Family Home (P30M/2): Max - _2 .00 ,UJui
1P32,0oo
1
Standard Deduction
2 ,00 0
Net estate (P 42 w2) - - _ 00, Of
Share of the Surviving Spouse . . - ~!1,00O,oot
Net Taxable Estate . . . ial deductions are neither classifi ed as excl usive
CJ If decedent is ma med. 5pee n0
common deductions.
; . . al valued below P10 000 000:
, CASED Decedent is mamecl' FH ,s con u Exclusive Con jugal To al
--:.
135
r
coMPLETE SEPARATION OF PR
OPERTY
The spouses shall be
roperty if the future spouses a go~erned by complete separation of
P . gree ,n the m .
property re Ia tions during the ma . arnage settlements that their
separation of property. To each rnage shall be governed by the regime of
or her profession, business or inipotse shall bel~ng all earnings from his
ciVil, due or received during th~s ry a~d all frwts, natural, industrial, or
property. marriage from his or her separate
In the absence of proof to the A party who .did not participate in the
contrary, · properties acquired acquisition by the other party of any ·
while they lived together shall be property shall be .deemed to . ~~ve
presumed to have been obtained contributed jointly m the acquis1t1on
· thereof if the former's efforts consisted _in
by their joint efforts, work or the care and maintenance of the family
industry, and shall be owned by and of the household.
them in equal shares.
136
,,
IN APACITATEO TO MARR~ by both of them through their actual joint
1. On\y th property acquire operty or industry shall be owned
contribution of money, pr . ·b t· . n 1
. . rt·
ornm n m propo ,on o t their respective contn u ions. (If silent ,
s ume equal shares).
Mr. P,m Musay, Filipino and married, died in 2019, leaving his estate in favor of his surviving
spouse. The following information were made available:
Real µroperty ii;. Qu.ezon City, ac uired during marriage. Said property is supported by a barangay
certification that the spouses resided in this property at the time of Mr. Musay's death. The fair
market value of this property as per latest tax declaration i P15,000,000 while the ~anal valuation
as of the time death is P 20 000 000. Said-re.aLpJQ~rty was held as a mortgage in a loan applied by
the spouses. As of the time of death, the outstanding balance of the mortgage payable amounted to
P5.000.000.
Real property in Batangas, inherited by Mr. Musay during marriage, two and half years ago, from his
late father. The fair market value pe~ ~~ deg~ ti.on as of his death i PB 000,000 while th~ 1_01391
valua ·on is P.!_2 000,000. Said property was previously taxed at a value of P10,000,00 when Mr.
M sa innen1ed the property from his father.
Real prope~ in Cawe, d~~ed to Mrs. Musay, 10 years a o (.b.~ore marriage) by his parents-in-
la . The f 1r market val1,1e as per latest tax dee ra IOI\ as of the time of Mr. Musay's death is
P3 '000 '00 while the~ zonal valuation is P4.0 , iOO.
Q!)er ,~elusive properties of Mr._Musay P1 ,OOQ,QOO; ; O~er propectie~ of Mr. and Mrs. Musay-
P3,000 ,000. Funeral expenses incurred by the estate dunng the wake and burial of Mr. Musay
amounted to P1 ,900,000.
Req ired:
. Compute item 34 (Gross Estate) of BIR form no. 1801 ; Ans.• P40,ooo,ooo
2. Compute Sch dule V (Ordinary deductions) of BIR Form no. 0801 ; Answer = P10,250,000
3. Compute item 40 (Net Taxable Estate) of BIR from no. 1801 : Answer • P31750,000
4. Compute item 20 (Estate Tax Payable) of BIR from no. 1801 ; Answer • P225,000
137
Solution:
·xc/11sivo ,,omJnon T2ta,J
RPOC
P20,000,000
RP Batanga
, ,
RP avite
" 12. ooo.noo
r· 4,000,000
ther excl 1,000,000
Other common
_3.(!_9~,000
GROSS ESTA TE mDJ P22,000,000 P27,000.000 P40,000,000
ORDINARY DEDUCTIONS.
r
M011gage Payable ~ (5,000,000) (5,000,000)
Vanishing deduction , • 5,250,000 .._ (5,250,0002
P7,750,000 P22,000,000 P29,750,000
NET ESTATE
Share of the SS (11 ,000,000)
Standard deduction {5,000,000)
Family Home (P20M/2) (1 0,000.0002
P3,750,000
NET TAXABLE ESTATE rml})
Estate tax rate 6%
Estate Tax Payable [mD P225,000
138
17~TaxR.IE
2 2 5
1'1..ess.:Taic
~FmiglE5'aeTiiX Pai
198Tai:Pilil i\ REiln~AE,d. l ti. is .wi Mll!lledRelnl
23 Mt Penalies •
DASudlilige
2.38!rwest
0 0
PAMPAM MUSA.Y
~-~
~
»~oeiiiMtlM
139 ·
B-IR Fam No.
1801
Jilf&IY :,OHi (ctel
PIQl2
Estate Tax Return
I I I I I I l J I I I J I
I
I I
TOTAL m, - N _,,, 3l?.l ' Em:libt illld otherS not cla5si'fi!!d ~ _ . (NfacJJ atnml fta/Slt18'M3om
F-alr Malli!I: Yalle
Schedule • -Business lntl!ffst such~ Net . R~~ . /ROO CQdf EXCLUSIVE c~
~Kilne Cl(~e65l'ilaml! I I
J I
I
ElCUJl!IVE OOH•~INAL
i....- T ---~
5,11111,8111
140
PROBLEMS
ACoP
1. Properties owned by the spouses before the
marriage
2. Rental income on a property acquired before
marriage.
3. Property acquired during marriage
-----
4. Income on property described in #3
5. Property acquired by gift before marriage
6. Income on property described in #5
7. Property inh~rited during marriage t, ,(
;
P4.2.
From the records of the estate of a citizen_;.decedent who died in 2018:
Properties- Land inherited from mother (td_yring marriage) two ,; P24,000,000
(2) years before death; valued at P1.5M when inherited , ·
Other personal property owned before marriage _,, Cb 16,000,000
Other personal property acquired during_ marriage _ f 5,000,000
Deductions claimed:
Casualty losses 500,000
Unpaid taxes 400,000
Clarms again.st the estate 600,000
/; C I L-- : ~~
lS ~} ,l
'!. I
_ ( S"')U i _~ _
141
( IS' I \}\)
i t\
(_Sl~i' )
. il~ , ti,)
(, "
I )I1 jf . "/)
<'
/} ./..
I \ .fj_ltl,U /)tl,S
f uneral exp n. e
Medical xpen . in urred and paid . . 300,000
death . . wil hin one year before 400,000
unpaid medica l xp . in urred within
Judicial expen es one year before death 300 ,000
120,000
DETERMINE THE FOLLO WING under A .
a) Net exclu sive property of the bsolu~e Community of Property:
b) Net commun ity property decedent
c) Share of the surviving spouse
d) Net Taxable estate
P4.3.
i'\.t
•
A on-resident
,- •
t
C
· alien,
I married,
. died on September 2018 . He Ieft th e fo 11 owing.
onJuga properties, Philippines, P5,000 ooo
Exclusive properties, Philippines, 2,000,000
• Conjugal properties, USA, 10,000,000
• Exclusive properties, USA, 5,000,000 "
·
1,, . r \, r' ~ 1 •
1
· •
{ t' '\
(\\ \H\) 142
: 11 <. h v)
November 2, 2018 . The follow
P4~4, -- ~ -·-:~ ~ - \ cli.?d intestate ~n n~
1
A esident ah~ ?'°
1 1
, .
- - - - vide o you. P20,0oo
data were pro USA (farni\y home) . 8 oa , OJ
~ ~n~~~~;;~t'~\tock, Phi~pines - 10',oo~·~
,,, / \nvestment i~ stock, U~SA (85% of the business of the 7,000:00D
/ \nvestment m _bo~d~~ the Phi\ippines)
USA Corporation is 3,ooo,00
r-ash in bank, Phi\\ppi~es ,, soo,oao
/V hT nes •
/ Cash on hand, P 1,pp, d btor who· resides m USA - 2,000.000
/ Accounts receivab\e frort:1 a e
(fu\\y unco\lectib\e)_ . . ... 8,000,000
·/ Vehicles in the Ph1hppmes 1,soo,000
Actua\ funera\ expenses
3,000,000
Judicia\ expenses . . 2017 , 1,200,000
/ Unpaid Philippine income tax for mcome m
Loss on December 31, 2018 due to theft . ,,.
800,000
;,Devise to Quezon City for chi\dren's playground ~ ~ 700,000
/ Receivab\e u!)der RA 4917 \ 500,000
Medica\ expenses 5,000,000
, DETERMINe THE FOLLOWING:
a) Net Taxab\e ~state
b) Estate tax due
P4.5.
Pedro Cruz died intestate on September 30, 2018. He was survived by his
wife and his two chi\dren. He \eft the following properties:
• Land (1,000 sq. m.) inherited from his father 15 months before
Pedro's death. Fair market va\ue per tax declaration at the
time of Pedro's death, 2.0,000-:000· Zonal value at the time of
Pedro's death, P30,000 per sq.m. · \1 1 18 ( l'r', : )-1 1 '
143
I n :., ·1 11
P4.5.
Pedro Cruz d\ed intestate on September 30, 2018 . He was survived by his
wife and his two chi\dren. He left the following properties:
• land (1,000 sq. m.) inherited from his father 15 months before
Pedro's death. Fair market value per tax declaration at the
time of Pedro's death, 20,000 ,000· ZQDaLv.all.Je at the time ol
Pedro's death, P30,000 per sq.m. '\ ~ \ u~rt :}~it'
• \j,9J.lS..ELand \ot (Fa_mi\y Home) acquired during the marriage,
_\fMY_~~5~.,0?0,000~. \ \ ..
·• · O1her tang,bTEr - personal properties (mode of acquis1t1on
unknown), FMV, P22,00,000~
1-
143
The estate of the decf1dent' • fat~inr r1 a d ttu-, 0 t: t,:, t;Ji rm U1(, I ir1 J ,. t
the fair market. value of I '2 ., ,000 ,OU . u, Hln(J thu rfHJrr n Jo , JJ(,(Jrf'I
mortgaged th e inherit d land for p 00() ()(JO for th, b m,flt ,Jf th
1 1
TRUE OR FALSE
Write True if the statement is correct, otherwise, write False,
1. Under the regime of absolute community f pr perty, the husband and
the wife place in a common fund the proceeds, producis, fruits and
income from their separate property and th se acquired by either or
both spouses through their effort or by chance.
2. The gross estate of a married decedent under the ystem of conjugal
partnership of gains during the marriage is a mixtu re of his exclusive
property and conjugal property.
3. The inclusion of claims against insolvent person in the gross estate of
the decedent spouse as either exclusive or communal property will
depend on the nature of the claim-whether it is for an exclusive or for
a communal property. ·
4. Funeral expenses are no longer deductible from the gross estate of a
decedent.
5. The share of the surviving spouse in the estate shall be deducted
equal to ½ of the gross conjugal property.
144
~ I'\t ;;:11(,·()fl :1
( ->1<11 /('I ' I ( ('( '/ '1'( : \(, \ 1~7,·:·ltj
11 Und r th sy ' hllll of conjuool p1Mtnun t llp . (:y' 9F1 in : thu vani :5hinf~ I
MULTIPLE CHOICE.
Principles
JJ\ 1. Under the law, the property relationship between husband and wife
shall be governed in what order? .
I. By marriage settlements executed before the marriage.
II. By the provisions of this Code
111 . By the local custom.
t"aJt, 11, Ill c .II, 111, I
b.l, Ill, II d. 111, II, I
145
Properties owned by the
marriage will be classified as ·spou ses before and brought into the
Under absolute com · .
a. Community mun,ty Under conjugal partnership
b. Exclusive Conjugal
i c·) Community Exclusive
'd. Exclusive Exclusive
Conju ga l
r, 5. The fruits from exclusive prope t f .
\
during the marriage are cla 'f• r Y O each spou se due or re .,e,ved
ss1 red as ·
Under absolute community ·
Under conjugal partnership
a. Community
Conjugal
b. Exclusive
Exclusive
c. Community
Exclusive
@? Exclusive Conjugal
146
. . ty of a spouse?
~., g Which is not an exclusive proper ·age as his or her own .
· -- · h · b ught to the marn
a. That wh1c 1s ro . d during the marriage by gratuitou
b. That which each acquire s
title . . .. ht of redemption.
c. That which is acquired by r_ig .ses' common fund
d-; That which is purchased with the spou .
. . · gal property from communit
1o. Which of the following distinguishes conJU Y
property? . .
Properties inherited during marriage. .
~: Those acquired through occupation during marriage.
c. Fruits of exclusive property. •age
d. Income earned by each spouse during marn ·
~ 11. The gross estate of a decedent who was married at the time of death
will be composed of:
a.
1 His capital property, the wife's paraphernal property and the
'-- common property
br His capital property and the common property
c. Common property
d. His capital property
Deductions
A. 13. Statement 1: Under the system of absolute commun·t
I
f rt
the vanishing deduction is a charge against community Y O prope Y,
..... _ Statement 2: Unde.r the system of conjugal partnersh·prope~.
re,
~ ,,,
vanishing deduction is a charge against exclusive pro iprt of gains, th e
a. Statements 1 & 2 are false. pe y.
b. Statement 1 is true but statement 2 is false
c. Statement 1 is false but statement 2.is true
147
cty.ro· Ecfr{',(Se,s - Pyae,Y ~UNu
d. Statements 1 and 2 are true
14. Statement 1: Judicial expenses for the settlement of the estate are no
V longer deductible from the gross estate of a decedent.
Statement 2: Medical expenses incurred before death are no longer
deductible from the gross estate of a decedent.
a. Statements 1 & 2 are false
b. Statement 1 is true but statement 2 is false
c. Statement 1 is false but statement- 2 is true
d. Statements 1 and 2 are true
1s. The following are required to be listed as part of the gross estate, but
1.; are exempted from estate tax, except
r, a. Share of the surviving spouse
I( b. Transfer for public use
c. Exclusive property of the decedent ✓
d. Amount received by heirs under RA 4917
r 16. All of the following items are allowed as deductions against exclusive
portion of the estate, except
~- Unpaid taxes
b. Claims against insolvent persons
✓~C. Vanishing deduction
✓d:· Family home
~ 17. The following are exclusiye ._p_CQperty of each spouse. Which one is
not?
That which each acquires during the marriage by lucrative title.
That which is purchased with the exclusive money of either
spouse.
c. That which is acquired by exchange with other property
belonging to the spouses.
,,er.--- That which is brought to the marriage as his or her own.
C 18. Net share of surviving spouse equals
a.Gross conjugal property less charges against conjugal
property.
b. Net conjugal property multiply by two.
@ Net conjugal property divide by two.
d. Net conjugal property divide by one-half.
148
1·· - ·I
£,rcf tlJ·e1·
1
,• _,- L
/'"I -
J
(Jhfj /L'/ C
estions:
ext four 4 u a resident of 0 uezon City,
. data for the n . . ines and
use the fo/lo~ncitizen of the Ph1l1pp is father during P2,soo,ooo
oeceden! is the following: ·nherited from h
died 1eav1~g use in satangas I
O
h. marriage 1,000,000
.. t Rest r before is before , s,OOO,0 00
\\i \vt• marriage . f m his mothe his mother
• d as 91ft ro ift from .
Car receive d ceived as g -
, ... l commercial Ian re . soo,oo0
marriage ommercial land 1,soo,O00
Income from the c hernal property) his spouse, during 200,000·
Building (wife's parap . property of
I.
·income from exclusive •' . 300,000
100,000
mJeawr:frgyeowned before the madrrwia,.gthe his own income ~:.. .: "
. · chase · · :: 1,OOO,O0_Q_
Clothes of his wife, pur . f her death · · · '- ·
Other properties at the time o h . th
. f gains how muc is e
. . al partnership o '
I,
'"I
19. Under the regime of co~JUQ rties?
decedent's gross e~clus1ve prope ·c. PB,700,000
. a. P8,800,Q0O .;t. P1 0 300,000
b. P8,600,000 ·._,,,: '
r · al properties?
20. How much is the gross conJug P.1 500 000
a. P7,700,000 ~ p '?oo'ooo
b. P9,200,000 "°· 1' '
21 . Under the regime of absolute community of property, how much is the
decedent's gross exclusive properties?
. P2,800,000 c. P3,800,000
~ P2,500,000 d. P3,500,000
22. Using the same assumption in the preceding number, how much_is the
/
gross conjugal properties?
a. P7,500,000 - P7,800,000
b. P6,800,000 d. P6,800,000
23. ~edro died on November _1, 2_018_, leavin~ the following properties:
fYClW ff A parcel of land tlbent~ during marriage from his father who died
on December 30, 20 4 ·
• Fair market value in 2010 - P3,5Q0,00O
• Fair market value in 2014 -.J2.S.'o.0_0.oo(f'
• Mortgage assumed and paid by Pedro_ PSOO,OOO
Additional information :
• The real property in the Philippines includes the family home
valued at R1 ,500,000. '
• Judicial exp·e-nses include P50,000 incurred to settle conflicting
claims of the heirs.
How much is the taxable net estate?
a. P225,000 i,) P2,025,000
b. P250,000 cl': P2,050,000
b ~ 25. The following data were provided by the administrator of Pedro who
died in 2018:
Conjugal real properties P7 ,000,000
5,000,000
Conjugal family home
2,500,000
Exclusive properties
,- I
3,500,000
. ../ Paraphernal .prope_rties ~ 1;, · • <
Deductions claimed:
Funeral expenses
300,000 V
150
Additional Information: ex enses were borne by the estate
• 25% of the funeral P, were incurred after one year from de
• 25% of "Other losses . at\
of the decedent. . to property taxes (conjugal asset )
·d taxes pertain s
■ Unpa1 th of the decedent
incurred a~er dea , were compensated by a health
5
• 50% medical expense
insurance company
Use the following data for the next two (2) questions: . ..
From the records of the estate of a decedent who was a_- c1t1zen:
Properties-Land; inherited from the mother /4 y.e ar~ P2,400,000
before death, during marriage (valued of P1--!5O0,000 ..
f --····-·
when inherited)
Other personal property owned before marriage 1,600,000
Other personal property acquired during marriage 500,000
Cost and expenses:
Claim against the estate 200,000
\ Medical expenses incurred within one year before · 700,000
death
Losses 100,000
. 151
fhe next two 2 uestions are b 1
The following were considered ,as deductions from the gross estate:
Actual funeral expenses p 1oo 000
Judicial expenses 1so' ooo
Medical expenses 200' ooo
ObliQations incurred before marriage that benefited 2so:ooo
the community properties
Claims against an insolvent debtor · 50,000
Unpaid mortgage on inherited land '. 100,000
Loss of car through theft on December 31, 2014 300,000
(part of personal properties acquir.ed
during marriage)
· Unpaid realty tax on real property received as gift 30,000
from his uncle ,
Additional information:
- The value of the real properties at the time of inheritance was
P300,000.
- The value of the real property received as gift from an uncle was
P1 ,000,000 at the time of donation.
- The donated· land and the house built on it were certified as the family
home of the decedent and his family by the Barangay Captain in the
locality where they were situated.
152
30 How much was th• total community property?
. - p3,4so,ooo _c. ps,1so,ooo .
b. ps, so,ooo d. None of the choices
2 E
C
\
E
I
153