Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jung 1 1983 4 2 1
Jung 1 1983 4 2 1
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted
digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about
JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Taylor & Francis, Ltd., C.G. Jung Institute of San Francisco are collaborating with JSTOR to
digitize, preserve and extend access to The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r
p-
i
Preface
r
I
Only those thoughts are true the opposite of which is also
true in its own time and application; indisputable dogmas
are the most dangerous kind of falsehoods.*
.. r.
l
the reality of the psyche as fact, both see man and God in an historical
process of co-evolution, with man necessary for God to become conscious
of Himself in creation. The touchstone shared by Jung and Sri Aurobindo
is the gnostic tradition, which recognizes man's urge to surpass the old
gods and to achieve his own direct experience. For this reason, I will
relate Sri Aurobindo's thought to that of Jung, emphasizing the similari-
ties in their viewpoints, as a contribution to bridging the gap between
East and West. The tension between these cultural and archetypal opposites
can be approached as a dynamis for the transformation of consciousness.
Sri Aurobindo's collaborator, Mira Alfassa (later known as "the
Mather" in Sri Aurobindo Ashram), came to India with a deep gnostic insight
derived in part from her prior study of Kabbalah. According to her, the
*Sri Aurobindo Birth Centenary Library, Pondicherry, India, Sri Aurobindo
Ashram Press, 1972, Vol. 17, p. 83. All subsequent quotations from Sri
r 1
Aurobindo are from the Centenary Library unless otherwise specified.
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
r This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 2 - Stein - - -
...I
Vedic and Kabbalistic traditions derive from an earlier, common source.
Her role in this work provides the essential feminine presence needed to
realize the teaching. What follows is a brief account of this emerging
spiritual renewal, exemplified by contemporaries who represent a link
in the creative synthesis of East and West.
A brief comment on the language of Sri Aurobindo is in order. The
sound of the Sanskrit language carries inherent "vibrations of conscious-
ness," which the science of mantra (repetitive chant of a sacred phrase)
uses to convey meanings beyond whJt is explicitly stated. Though Sri
Aurobindo wrote primarily in English, he continually used this occult
.. I,
Introduction
Aurobindo Ghose was born in Calcutta in 1872 just three years before
the birth of C. G. Jung. Jung, a Western psychiatrist trained in the
European philosophic and academic tradition, was able to extend his under-
standing of the human psyche, in part, by inquiry into the Eastern mind.
Aurobindo Ghose, whose early life was shaped by an Anglicized family and
a Western education, returned to India to find his own spiritual identity.
Jung approached the psyche as a doctor and a scientist; he had little in-
terest in politics, but his concern with clinical matters led him to ad- ..
dress more universal issues. Sri Aurobindo was a poet and a political
revolutionary, whose vision of India1s independence led him to the heart
of contemporary spirituality.
What follows is a brief biography, expanded by an overview of the
metapsychology and practice of his fourfold path of yoga. This will in-
,
clude a discussion of some parallels between his writings and Jung1s, con-
cluding with a speculation on the problem of evil and the role of the femi-
nine in the current spiritual transformation. It should be emphasized
that these considerations are not based on the treatment of psychologically
disturbed people; though they encompass a broad spiritual framework, they
do not underestimate the importance of the clinical or symbolic approach.
lilt
:\
Biographical Sketch I
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r - - - Yoga of Transformation - 3 -
-
i
cally active in an Indian student group known as the Majlis, which was
dedicated to India's independence from Great Britain. Following his
graduation, in 1893, he sailed for India and landed in Bombay. For
several months, he experienced a vast peace and calm, and later wrote
that a dark cloud, which had entered his being when he was sent away
to school, finally lifted when he returned to India.
As Professor of English and French at Baroda College, where he
was later Vice-Principal, he began writing political articles in support
of India's independence. As early as 1893, he wrote to his fellow Indians,
"0ur actual enemy is not any force exterior to ourselves, but our own
crying weakness, our cowardice, our purblind sentimental ism. (New II
came the warm embrace of the deity. Matter itself, as well as all life,
revealed a divine origin. A major focus of Sri Aurobindo's Integral Yoga
is the revelation of matter not only as divine in origin, but as capable of
tran~formation from its state of inconscience (lacking self-awareness and
connection to the central consciousness of one's being) to its rightful ,
place in the harmonious totality of matter, life, mind, and spirit.
The experience of Krishna brought with it the .need to find some link.
between the higher states of consciousness which lie both above the mind
and <;Jeep in the heart, with life in the world. In the sacred Indian text,
the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna admonishes the doubtful warrior, Arjuna, to
fight on the great battlefield, the Kurukshetra. Aurobindo had been doubt-
,
ful himself about the value of yoga prior to his imprispnment, seeing it
(as Jung did later) as an escape from life in the world; now he was to find
a means for an outpouring of the higher and wider states of consciousness
into his daily life. He realized that silencing the mind and opening it
, J
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r - - - Yoga of Transfo-rmation - 5 -
.
i
!'
ego is then guided and transformed by this consciousness. Sri Aurobindo
describes the functioning of this process on the mental plane:
The substance of the mental being . . . is still, so still
that nothing disturbs it. If thoughts or activities come,they
.. ~ cross the mind as a flight of birds crosses the sky in
a windless air. It passes, disturbs nothing, leaving no trace.
Even if a thousand images or the most violent events pass across
it, the calm stillness remains as if the very texture of the
mind were a substance of eternal and indestructible peace. A
mind that has achieved this calmness can begin to act, even
...
r In 1914 a French woman named Mira Alfassa came to Pondicherry with her
second husband, a journalist named Paul Ri~hard. Born in Paris in 1878, she
was a mystic with extraordinary conscious faculties. Even her childhood was
r~, marked by unusual inner experiences, including a guide who came in the form
of an Indian man. During her late teens, she went to Morocco to study eso-
,. teric Kabbalism with a Russian Jew, Max Theon. When she came to Pondicherry
at age thirty-six, she realized that Sri Aurobindo was the inner guide of
her early years. He, in turn, saw in her his spiritual collaborator. After
World War I, she returned from Japan to Pondicherry, where Sri Aurobindo
acknowledged her as the Divine Mother of Sri Aurobindo Ashram. This vision
r on his part was a deep recognition of her pre-eminence, signifying her as the
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
r This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 6 - Stein - - -
,
embodiment of Shakti, or the conscious force which carries the world pro-
cess of evolution to higher stages.
IIWhen I came to Pondicherry," he told his early followers, "a'
programme was dictated to· me from within for my sadhana [dis-
,
-'
the yoga evolved under the t{iotrler ' s guidance for those disciples' inwardly con-
nected to her.
With the yoga of Sri Aurobindo the descending Force opens very
slowly, gently, these very centers (the chakras) from top to
bottom. Often enough the lower centers do not open at all till
much later. This process has an advantage if we understand that
each center corresponds to a universal mode of consciousness or
,
energy; if, from the very beginning, we open the lower vital
and subconscient centers, we risk being now swamped not by our
own small personal affairs but by universal torrents of mud;
we become automatically connected with the Confusion and Mud of
the world. This is why the traditional yogas required the pre-
sence of a Master who protects. With the descending Force this
danger is avoided and we face the lower centres only after es- ,
tablishing our being solidly in the higher superconscient light.
(Satprem, p. 57)
(Those familiar with Kundalini yoga will notice a difference here; Sri ,
Aurobindo teaches that modern man, with his developed mental capabilities,
can open to the Shakti from above. This avoids' the unnecessary dangers in-
herent in raising the Shakti from below, as is taught in the older system. ,
The fact that this yoga involves the utilization of the Shakti connects it
to the broad category of tantra, to which the Kunda1ini system also belongs.)
,;,
,
During the World War I period, from 1914 to 1921, Sri Aurobindo wrote
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 7 -
r most of his major works, in the following way. Paul Richard, Mira's
husband, had asked him to collaborate on a monthly philosophic journal,
Arya, but was called away because of his duties as a journalist during
the war. Sri Aurobindo was left to write sixty pages a month of philoso-
phy, yoga, poetry, and social and cultural essays. These are now pub-
lished separately as his major works~ and include The Life Divine, The
Synthesis of Yoga, The Ideal of Human Unity, Essays on the Gita, Founda-
tions of Indian Culture, The Future Poetry, The Hour of God, War and Self-
Determinism, The Secret of the Veda, Heraclitus, as well as his transla-
tions and commentaries on the Vedas and the Upanishads. During the late
1920s and the 1930s he revised the first book of The Synthesis of Yoga and
all of The Life Divine, and he wrote extensive letters answering individual
questions about the yoga, which was evolving continually and was different
for each disciple. A relatively complete edition of his collected works
was published in 1972 on the occasion of his centenary, comprising thirty
r Aurobindo begins. There have been two great denials or partial seekings
after knowledge in man's search. Sri Aurobindo found the I'denial of the
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
r This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 8 - Stein - - -
This yoga, which combines the pursuits of the inner and outer worlds,
is based on a synthesis of the traditional Indian goal of spiritual transcen-
dence with modern biological theories of evolution. Sri Aurobindo sees
the evolutionary scheme as a spiritual process .
. . . behind the appearances of the universe there is a
,
reality of a being and consciousness, a self of all things, one
and eternal. All beings are united in that one self and spirit
but divided by a certain separativity of consciousness . . . It
is possible by a . . . psychological discipline to remove this
veil of separative consciousness and become aware of the true
Self, the divinity within us and all.
,
,
. . . this one being and consciousness is involved here in
matter. Evolution is the process by which it liberates itself;
consciousness appears in what seems to be the inconscient, and
once having appeared is self-impelled to grow higher . . . Life
is the first step of this release of consciousness; mind is the
second. But the evolution does not finish with mind; it awaits
a release into something greater, a consciousness which is spirit-
,
ua1 and s upe rme ntal . . .
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
,
r - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 9 -
..
ment. It is not, however, by the mental will in man that this
can be wholly done, for the mind goes only to a certain point
and after that it can only move in a circle. A conversion has
to be made, a turning of the consciousness by which the mind
..
~
has to change into the higher principle. This method is to be
found through the ancient psychological discipline and practice
of yoga. (Sri Aurobindo, quoted in r'1cDermott, pp. 29-30)
..
/.
..
chakras in the human organism. The most rarified of these is pure spirit
and the densest is pure matter; ultimately, spirit and matter, as well as
..
II
the manifest reality in which we live: matter, life, and mind. In the pro-
cess of evolution, these begin with matter, out of which emerges life, and
I
out of living forms emerges the mental being; man is the -highest example
'!! known thus far. As life emerges out of matter, however, there remains an
inertial pullan the life force; this regressive pull of matter on life is
the source of death. Death functions to break up material formations which
embody life, so that nature can experiment in creating new life forms in
evolution. In the same manner, when mental beings emerge from living forms,
the life energy or vital force maintains an opposing tension on the reasoning
processes; this persistence of the vital force in the mental being is desire.
Desire functions to expand the embodied mental being1s range of experience
and possibility of discovery.
Desire is the lever by which the divine Life-principle effects
its end of self-affirmation in the universe and the attempt to
extinguish it in the interests of inertia is a denial of the
'£.
divine Life-principle, a Will-not-to-be which is necessarily
ignorance; for one cannot cease to be individually except by
being infinitely. (Sri Aurobindo, Centenary Library, Vol. 18,
p. 195)
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
r This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 10 - Stei n - - -
.,
"
whose vital instincts and physical needs are in harmony. The Mother
commented that, though man is more conscious, the tiger is more divine,
that is, more in harmony with the totality of Nature. The emergence of
mind has upset the balance in man, leading to a tension and disturbance
in his functioning. Sri Aurobindo takes this as further evidence for
,
man as a transitional being in the scheme of development, having sur-
passed the harmonious interaction of matter and life, yet not having
achieved a new balance, which would incorporate the mental being but not
be based solely on its superiority.
Jun g echoes th is theme in II Answe r to Job. II
The ancient yogis spoke of transcendent states, beyond the primary terms
of consciousness, attained by release from the body, usually through the crown
chakra of the head. To the embodied mental being, these states seem
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
,, I
I
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 11 -
Sanskrit. for "being" .or pure exi:tence. It corresponds in the upper hemi-
sphere wlth the quallty of matter which just lIis. "Chit is translated as 11 ll
...i,
I'
"consciousness force." It is the impulse of consciousness to realize itself
in manifestation, and in the lower triad manifests as the vital or life
1 plane. The third term, IIAnanda,1I is translated as "b1iss,1I which is consid-
ered the source of the soul. The Taittiriya Upanishad (111.6) says, "From
,.. Delight all these beings are born, by Delight they exist and grow, and to
r and the descent of Krishna, as partial revelations from the Ovennind, that
1eve T of mi nd whi ch spawned the great re 1i gi ons of the worl d.
f
r The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 12 - Stein - - -
..
I
was a new emphasis on the soul, whose outer aspect he called lithe psychic
..
being." Here, the soul is a representative in the lower hemisphere of the
principle of Ananda of the unitary state. In this view, it is the soul
which functions as the true center for the process of individualizing con-
sciousness in the universe; the ego is its outermost instrument, the shell
necessarily created through the separation of subject and object. The
psychic being connects the deeper soul within to the instruments of the ego
(mind, life, and body) without. In the practice of the yoga, to be taken
up shortly, the soul is the guide, the still small voice, while Supermind
acts with the vision and force of transformation. Just as Supermind, as a
level of consciousness, mediates between the One and the Many, so the soul
is the point, in manifest reality, by which consciousness can establish an
individual center, yet remain aware of Oneness. ,
Ego's moth-wings to lift the seraph soul
Appeared, a surface glamour of brief date , .1
view.
cient rreaning of "maya" was that power of the original, divine totality to ..,
limit itself in order to create the universe of multiple forms. Below Super- !
mind! at the highest ranges of the mind, one perceives basic patterns of con-
sciousness which have associated images--these are experienced as "the gods. II 1
It is fascinating to see how closely this parallels Jung's conception of the
archetypes, which deintegrate out of the field of the Self. Sri Aurobindo
called this highest level of the mind the Overmind, to distinguish it from
the Supermind, and he considered it to be the source of all religion.
He was emphatic in his refusal to become the founder of a new religion,
based on an Overmental experience, preferring to allow others to find their •
unique experience in this spiritual transformation.
It is not his [Sri Aurobindo's] object to develop anyone reli-
gion or to amalgamate the older religions or to found any new
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983 •
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r - - - Yo gao f Tran forma t ion - 13 -
.
.. religion--for any of these things would lead away from his
central purpose. The one aim of his yoga is an inner self-
development by which each one who follows it can in time dis-
cover the One Self in all and evolve a higher consciousness
.. than the menta 1 . . . (Sri Aurobi ndo, quoted in McDermott,
p. 31)
,.
:1
intellect places man in a new position with regard to the Overmental exper-
ience of the gods or archetypes. According to Sri Aurobindo, the age of
collective religions is passing. In the new spiritual era, each individual
will develop according to his own unique soul experience, understanding the
..
II
truths behind many of the great religions, but identifying with and limited
r The Yoga
r The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
.
,
- 14 - Stein - - -
In the right view of both life and of Yoga all life is either
consciously or subconsciously a Yoga. For we mean by this term
a methodized effort towards self-perfection by the expression i
of the potentialities latent in the being and a union of the
human individual with the universal and transcendent Existence
. . . But all life, when we look behind its appearances, is a
vast Yoga of Nature attempting to realize . . . her potential-
ities and to unite herself with her own divine reality. In man,
her thinker~ she for the first time upon this Earth devises self- ,
,
conscious means and willed arrangements of activity by which 1
",
.
ll
This view is echoed by Jung in "Answer to Job :
,
Whatever man's wholeness, or the self, may mean per se~ empirically
it is an image of the goal of life spontaneously produced by the un-
conscious irrespective of the wishes and fears df the conscious
mind. It stands for the goal of the total man, for the realization
of his wholeness and individuality with or without the consent of
his will. The dynamic of this process is instinct, which insures
that everything which belongs to an individual's life shall enter
into it, whether he consents or not, or is conscious of what is hap-
pening to him or not. Obviously, it makes a great deal of differ-
ence subjectively whether he knows what he is living out, whether
he understands what he is doing, and whether he accepts responsi-
.,
bility for what he proposes to do or has done. (Collected Works,
.,
I
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 15 -
r
divinize that vessel. By self-perfection, he does not mean the achieve-
ment of some final, maximum state of being, but an ongoing harmonization
of the various elements of the psyche, an idea not dissimilar to Jung's
concept of individuation. Like Jung in "Answer to Job," Sri Aurobindo
finds God capable of imperfection and further evolution.
The Mother, describing her own struggle as a Westerner with the
Christian notions of God's perfection and manls original sin, comments on
~
the dark side of God as seen by Sri Aurobindo in his Aphorisms.
i'
III
All the believers, all the faithful (those from the West in
particular) think in terms of something else" when they speak
Il
~
I of God--He cannot be weak, ugly, imperfect. He is something
immaculate--but this is wrong thinking. They are dividing,
I
-
;l
254)
One of Sri Aurobindo1s main achievements is the synthesis of India's
two great streams of spiritual philosophy and practice, the Vedantic and
the tantric. The Vedantic practices involve a detachment from outer reality,
• while the tantrics worship the energies of nature, the earth spirits, and
strive to divinize them. There is a striking parallel between Sri Aurobindols
synthesis and Jung's discovery of alchemy as the compensatory philosophic
system to the Christian ideal. Sri Aurobindo found in the ancient tantric
view the necessary vitalizing force to bring the lofty spiritual attainment
of the Vedantic schools into human personality and daily life. Indian spi-
r rituality, especially Buddhism (from the fifth century B.C.) and the ascetic
tradition of Shankaracharya (from the tenth century), had rejected life in
the world in order to embrace pure states of Non-being (Asat) or Being (Sat)
,. respectively; but such spirituality was at the expense of the human connec-
tion to the earth. Sri Aurobindo was struck, upon his return to India, by
I the lack of mastery over matter and outer circumstances that he had become
accustomed to in the West. It was as though the natural, conscious link of
r the human mind to matter had been neglected by centuries of disuse and dis-
interest, replaced by an otherworldly spirituality which had little desire
for material progress. These conditions remind one of the Middle Ages in
Europe, a time which spawned the great alchemical studies which were to
fascinate Jung. There seem to be connections between the attitudes and goals
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
,
- 16 - Stein - - -
Hebrew Chochma, and the Indian Shakti. More than ever it seems, in this
century, we must struggle with the shadow cast by material science in the ,
alchemy of nuclear physics, and find a contemporary spirituality which
encompasses the dark power we have unleashed.
The Individual
,.,
11
,
himself into each form of his omnipresence; the self, the II
I
Being is at once unique in each, common in our collectivities
and one in all beings. God moves in many ways at once in his
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
.,
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 17 -
,..
development of the individual's gifts and potentials as a vehicle for the
Divine. Mind, life, and body are seen as instruments of the soul. They
are to be uplifted and transformed by the higher consciousness acting from
..
above.
II'
Essential to tthe work is an intentional deepening of awareness by
.I meditation on the heart center, which enables one to discriminate between
,.
II
the "desire soul l' and the "true soul" or psychic being. To e~hance this
meditation practice in his daily activities, the sadhak (one who practices
the discipline) tries to remain equal in the face of all experience, whether
'- pleasant or unpleasant. He cultivates a poise of consciousness within
based on peace and quiet and is attentive to moments of consciousness in
which there is some sense of light, heightened awareness, objectless love,
delight, or aesthetic appreciation. These he cultivates and offers to
their source, which is ultimately his higher self. In time the practice
r The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 18 - Stein - - -
.
,
,
In meditation, work, daily activity, or even sleep, one can become J
aware of a witness consciousness (purusha) as separate from the workings
of nature (prakriti). The separation of purusha from prakriti, and the
resulting ascent, was the goal of the ancient yogas; by a radical asceti-
cism it became a pure state, free from the flux of nature. Sri Aurobindo
however, teaches that from this ascended poise, the purusha can go further
to change the nature of prakriti and become more than a passive instrument
of consciousness (See his quote on nirvana, in the biographical sketch of
him, above.) As the sadhak establishes this stable poise, a subjective
sense of higher self develops which can begin to attain mastery over the
workings of prakriti. The first stage of this mastery would be the ability
to sanction or not a particular movement of consciousness. A later stage
would develop an inner source of activity, conscious of the internally
transmuted energies of nature. At this level, prakriti would be transformed
from an unconscious mechanism into the conscious, active feminine principle,
Shakti .
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
l
,. - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 19 -
I
ego and unconscious whereas for Sri Aurobindo it is the transformation of
inert prakriti into the goddess Shakti. (There are also striking similar-
ities to Gerhard Dorn's alchemical treatise, as described by Jung in
- Mysterium Coniunctionis, on the creation of the "un io mentalis and the unus
mundus. lI
)
ll
lI
-
"
Initially there must be an act of self-consecration which may be based
on faith (a temporary belief to be tested by knowledge as one does the prac-
..
I.:
I
tice). Doubt is accepted as a natural and useful function of the mind, to
be sincerely explored, though not to be indulged as an obstruction. One mea-
sure of success is that as the surrender proceeds, the sense of individual
..
t
I
effort, whether of the mind, vital urge, or physical body, is replaced by a
sense of harmony and support by the higher consciousness .
For Sri Aurobindo sacrifice has the literal meaning of "sacre ficio,"
to make sacred. More and more life energies and activities, as well as mo-
". ments of consciousness are brought into the field of the sacrament, or the
sacral as Eliade uses the term. Denial and repression are not advocated;
rather a true integration of aspects of the being into a centralizing con-
sciousness of the individual is sought.
The law of sacrifice is a common Divine action that was thrown
out into the world in its beginning as a symbol of the solidari-
ty of the universe. It is by the attraction of this law that a
divinizing, a saving power descends to limit and correct and gra-
dually to eliminate the errors of an egoistic and self-divided
,. creation. This descent, this sacrifice of the Purusha, the
I Divine Soul submitting itself to Force and Matter so that it may
inform and illuminate them, is the seed of redemption of this
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
".
I This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 20 - Stein - - - -
world of Inconscience and Ignorance. For "with sacrifice as
their companion," says the Gita, "the All-Father created these
peoples." The acceptance of the law of sacrifice is a practical
recognition by the ego that it is neither alone in the world
nor chief in the world. It is its admission that, even in this
much fragmented existence, there is beyond itself and behind
that which is not its own egoistic person, something greater
and completer, a diviner All which demands from it subordination
-
and serv; ce. Indeed sacri'fi ce is imposed and, where need be,
compelled by the universal World-Force; it takes it even from
those who do not consciously recognize the law, --inevitably
because this is the intrinsic nature of things. Our ignorance
or our false egoistic view of life can make no difference to this ~
11
fest, then slowly, painfully, but finally gladly brings the ego back to an
,
experience of its Divine origin. It is important to realize that the Purusha,
the Divine soul, also sacrifices itself, in the form of self-division and .,
resulting multiplicity, that manifestation might exist. This law of sacrifice
pervades the universe, and the ego, having been created by it, is ultimately
subject to it. i
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
,
r - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 21 -
,.
I
-
the right road when the conflicts of duty seem to have resolved
themselves, and you have become the victim of a decision made
! over your head or in defiance of the heart. From this we can see
the numinous power of the self, which can hardly be experienced
in any other way. For this reason the experience of the self is
always experienced as a defeat for the ego. (Collected Wor.ks,
Vol. 14, par. 778)
The darker tone of Jung's statements about sacrifice in contrast to
those of Sri Aurobindo seems to reflect the Judeo-Christian heritaqe. with its
clear division between Goo and man. In yogic tradition and gnosticism, the
possibility of man becoming God, along with the other way around, puts greater
r"
I emphasis on love with one's higher self as the motive power, without the
r
denial of one's right to divinity.
Jnana Yoga
The yoga of knowledge is based on silencing the mind to allow higher,
L
.. synthetic states and functions of consciousness to emerge. The physical,
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 22 - Stein - - -
,
vital, and intellectual levels of the mind are disciplined in order to
,
I
;
the intellectual mind. The sadhak is advised to seek and nurture moments
of quiet and silence through the use of meditation and concentration, and
to allow the emergence and operation of higher functions within the mental
sphere. Detachment from dogma and fixed ideas (mental formations), along
with fearless scrutiny of himself, frees his mind to explore wider vistas.
This process in jnana yoga creat€~ a calm state for thought and intellectual
activity, in much the same way that the poise of non-attachment and equal-
ity operates in the yoga of action. The mind is poised and receptive, but
, t,
does not grasp for knowledge or attach itself to any dogmatic posture.
The soul within, and the supramental consciousness above, become the active
organs of knowledge--the soul with its voice of wisdom and guidance, the
Bhakti Yoga I
,
of fire as the essential element was the last Greek philosophy founded on
mystical passion. From Aristotle onward, Western philosophy and theology,
founded on logos, has had to look eastward for its Divine eros. India
has preserved this tradition unabashedly in the practice of bhakti yoga,
which, in its pure form led to a loss of the sense of separate self
through passionate love. Many of the bhakti cults focus on the guru,
and express their mythologem in the stories, songs, and paintings of ,'I
Krishna and his amorous adventures with Rhada and with the Gopis.
However, a conscious coniunctio with the Divine Lover leads to a ,
more differentiated awareness and a devoted participation in life, rather
than to uroboric merger. Sri Aurobindo and the Mother, in fact, both es-
chewed prolonged use of the state of samadhi, or yogic trance, with its
loss of connection to the outer world. The emotional purification achieved
by this union with the Divine is to be lived in the world, according to the
principles of their discipline. The ultimate goal is an inner coniunctio,
,
which finds in its conclusion the gnosis of jnana yoga and surrender in
works of karma yoga. What is needed in bhakti yoga is neither a romantic 1
sentimentality nor a rigid asceticism, but a conscious turning of the pas-
sions and emotional energies towards a purity of love, in whatever form it .,
enters one's life.
Love is a passion, and it seeks for two things, eternity and ,
intensity, and in the relation of the Lover and the Beloved
the seeking for eternity and for intensity is instinctive and
self-born. Love is a seeking for mutual possession, and it is
here that the demand for mutual possession becomes absolute. ,
-Passing beyond desire of possession which means a difference,
it is a seeking for oneness, and it is here that the idea of
oneness, of two souls merging into each other and becoming one
finds the acme of its longing and the utterness of its
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
,
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
1
r
"
- - - Yoga of Tranformation - 23 -
.. The prob1~m of evil is complex, and perhaps itself demonic. Jung was
adamant that we not fall into the devil IS most dangerous trap, namely denying
his existence. Indian religious and philosophic systems are quite differ-
entiated in their exposition of the hostile powers; there are demons of all
The "shards ll
form the counterpoles to the ten sephiroth,
•••
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 24 - Stein - - -
1
the descent of the Supramental consciousness. (Here we approach Jung's
view, in "Answer to Job," on the importance of the bodily assumption of
the Virgin Mary; this point will be considered below.)
It is Falsehood which is the main force of evil in the world today,
,
j
according to the Mother, and the main source of the body's susceptibility
to disease and death. She feels that the task we now face is an evolu-
tionary challenge to bring into moment-to-moment awareness the power of
Truth-Consciousness, lest we destroy ourselves in our own lies. She even
pointed to Watergate as a major defeat for the Asura of Falsehood. The
problem of "disinformation," including the danger of excessive military
build-up in the name of security, could also be seen as an example of
1
this Asura. One might say further that a confrontation with the demon of
Falsehood, who wants us to risk nuclear war in the name of freedom, is
already happening in the collective psyche.
Collected Works, Vol. 11, par. 718) The Indian myth which expresses this
truth is Shiva, the destroyer, who dances at the end of each cycle of crea-
tion. In our time, the power of that destructive dance rests within our-
selves. It is, however, the individual who holds the balance, inasmuch as
he can see and act in accordance with his own inner truth, achieved through
1
struggle with the opposites.
Everything now depends on man: immense power of destruction is
given into his hand, and the question is whether he can resist
the will to use it, and can temper his will with the spirit of
love and wisdom. He will hardly be capable of doing so on his
own unaided resources. He needs the help of an "advocate" in
heaven, that is, of the child who was caught up to God and who
brings the "healing" and making whole of the hitherto fragmen-
tary man. (Jung, Collected Works, Vol. 11, par. 745)
~
Chaim Potok, in his Kabbalistic novel, The Book of Lights (New York, I
Ballantine Books, 1981) focuses on the alchemical geniuses of the
turn of the century, those nuclear physicists who placed this destructive
power in our hands (they were almost exact contemporaries of Jung, Sri
Aurobindo, and the Mother). The main character is a Kabbalistic rabbi,
whose individuation forces him to struggle with the collective shadow cast
by these giants of physical science. He quotes the following scriptural
commenta ry:
, I
"Until the day be cool and the shadows flee away. This refers II
~
to the secret known to the Companions, that when a man's time
comes to leave this wor1d i his shadow deserts him. Rabbi I
Eleazar says that man has two shadows, one larger and one small-
er, and when they are together, then he is truly himself. (p. ~
I
354) j
The bringing together of the two shadows is consistent with Jung's original
conception of the shadow as a collective product of the human psyche (mankind's
"evolutionary tail"), as well as an individual problem. Work on the personal
shadow is a necessary prelude to the direct encounter, within one's own psyche, , l
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
r - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 25 -
~
I
with the collective darkness common to all lives within a gl·ven epoch , e . g.
the nucl ear era. Sri Aurobi ndo woul d agree wi th Jung about the need for
man to free himself from the sense of original sin, to see the powers of
evil a~ objectively pres€nt, and to call on the grace from above, if the
- essentlal work of transforming the shadow is to take place. Jung points
out in lIAnswer to Job" that we are victims of our shadows far more than
were the early Christi ans.
As a result of the spiritual differentiation fostsred by the
Reformation, and by the growth of the sciences in particular
(which were originally taught by fallen angels), there is al-
ready a considerable admixture of darkness in us, so that com-
pa red wi th the puri ty of the early Chri st i an sa i nts . . . we
do not show up in a very favorable light. Our comparative
blackness naturally does not help us a bit. Though it miti-
-
r
11, par. 742)
Jung's major thesis in "Answer to Job" is that the dark side of Yahweh--
Satan--by which He tested Job and became conscious of His own demonic power,
...
I
!
brings with it the need for a redemptive feminine principle. In the history
of religions, the pagan myths of the divine mother and her son-lover, along
with the gnostic legend of heavenly Sophia, serve as prototypes for the earth-
ly human bride of Christianity, the Virgin, who in her purity can immacu-
,
~
lately conceive the divine child of God.
A further development of God's shadow is also foreseen in the New Test-
~ ament. Christ is modeled not only after Adam, but also Abel, who dies by the
I
hand of his murderous brother. Christ too suffers an early death, in a sense
as further appeasement of the wrathful diety; but in so doing, he redeems
man. The Christ child is God become man, a longterm goal of the deity, and
he paves the way, through the Holy Ghost or Paraclete, for the universal
div;n;zation of mankind. Yet as the Book of Revelations shows, the dark side
reappears in the apocalyptic vision of John, wherein it is seen that the
wrathful Lamb, the Antichrist, will reign over the second half of the Age of
Pisces. What struck Jung as crucial in this vision was
,. The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
l This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 26 - Stein - - -
,
II
I'
"He will redeem matter and the human ~ody from incon~cience.
In this investiture of fleshly life 1
A soul that is a spark of God' survives
And sometimes it breaks through the sordid screen ,
And kindles a fire that makes us half-divine.
rn our body·s cells there sits a hidden Power
That sees the unseen and plans eternity,
, I
,
Our smallest parts have room for deepest needs;
There too the golden Messengers can come:
A door is cut in the mud wall of self;
Across the lowly threshold with bowed heads
Angels of ecstasy and self-giving pass,'
And lodged in an inner sanctuary of dream
The makers of the image of deity live. ,
(Sri Aurobindo, Savitri, Centenary
pp.169-170)
Libra~y, Vol. 28,
,
The son of this new era can be seen as the transformative consciousness
which Sri Aurobindo and the Mother described as the Supermind. Its emergence
is a change in the operational functioning of humanity as great in magnitude , I
as the development of the first mental being. Sri Aurobindo describes the
portentous circumstances of this point in time in his poetic prose-invocation
liThe Hour of God. II
,
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
,
r
I
I
- - - Yoga of Tranformation - 27 -
There are moments when the Spirit moves among men and the
breath of the lord is abroad upon the waters of our being;
there are others when it retires and men are left to act in the
strength or weakness of their own egoism. The first are periods
when even a little effort produces great results and changes
destiny; the second are spaces in time when much labour goes to
the making of a little result. It is true that the latter may
prepare the former, may be the little smoke of sacrifice going
up to heaven which calls down the rain Df God's bounty . . . .
In the hour of God cleanse thy soul of all self-deceit and
r The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
- 28 - Stein - - -
,
lilt
giving expression to Supermind that it is beyond this review to enter an
exposition of its levels, functions, and effects on the other grades of mani-
festation. His writing, particularly the mantric poetry of Savitri and
the lengthy passages in Life Divine, provide the most direct access to this
"vi brati on of consci ousness. In a passage from The Synthesi s of Yoga, Sri
II
Aurobindo describes the unitary experience and its effect on the sense or-
gans: ,
Nothing to the supramental sense is really finite: . it is
founded on a feeling of all in each and of each in all: its
sense definition, although more precise and complete than the
, i
mental, creates no walls of limitation; it is an oceanic and
ethereal sense in which all particular sense knowledge and
1
,
sensation is a wave or movement or spray or drop that is yet
a concentration of the whole ocean and inseparable f~om the
ocean . . . . . This sense . . . is luminous with a revealing
light that carries in it the secret of the thing it ~xperi
ences . . . . (It) is strong with a luminous power that carries
within it the force of self-realization . . . . It is raptur-
ous with a powerful and luminous delight that makes. of ,
all sense a vessel of the divine and infinite Ananda. (Cen-
tenary Library, Vol. 21, p. 835)
,
,
It seems that the eternal verities remain, yet the evolution of conscious-
ness demands new forms and modes of being for their revaluation. The changes
brought upon us in this age demand a renewed commitment and growth, one which
is not limited by separate religions or cultural dichotomies like East and
West. Our individual struggles can be seen as part of this emergence, and
in seeing them in this way, Sri Aurobindo emphasizes our fundamental Oneness
with all creation, in the Self that unites all selves.
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
,
This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
1
r - - - Yoga of Tranformation - 29 -
..
1I
It works to find the doer of all works,
The unfelt Self within who is the guide,
The unknown Self above who ;s the goal.
..
-
.- I
t""
..
tI
.
..•
t
,.
The San Francisco Jung Institute Library Journal Volume 4, Number 2 1983
r This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 03:30:25 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms