Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Gourmet Ape
The Gourmet Ape
John R Krebs
ABSTRACT and evolution, and in particular how this might give rise to
This review explores the relation between evolution, ecology, and variation within and between populations.
culture in determining human food preferences. The basic physiol- The importance of evolutionary heritage is underlined by our
Am J Clin Nutr 2009;90(suppl):707S–11S. Printed in USA. Ó 2009 American Society for Nutrition 707S
708S KREBS
primitive, or ancestral, state. Lactose is an important component This mutation, analogous to sickle cell anemia, confers an
of breast milk, and therefore infants need to be able to digest it, advantage in resistance to malaria because it deprives the
but why should this be lost after weaning? Two arguments have Plasmodium falciparum parasite of oxygen in the red blood
been put forward. One pertains to the economics of metabolism: cells. The mutation is sex-linked and probably maintained by
there is a selective disadvantage in continuing to produce an heterozygote advantage in females. But there is a cost to males
enzyme, with its associated energy costs, once it is no longer bearing the mutation (as well as homozygous females) because
needed. The other argument is that the loss of lactase activity they are unable to digest one of the staple diet items of the re-
postweaning is an outcome of parent-offspring conflict. Evolu- gion, broad beans (a condition known as favism).
tionary theorists have pointed out (7) that parents and offspring The frequency of the mutation that causes favism is correlated
may often have divergent interests concerning the amount of with the geographical distribution of malaria in the Mediterra-
investment in an individual offspring. Each offspring values his or nean and Middle East. This suggests that there is a selective
her own survival more than that of his or her siblings, whereas balance between disease resistance and food consumption. In-
parents value each offspring more or less equally. In the simplest triguingly, some of the traditional herbs and spices used in
case, genes expressed in a mother producing offspring sequen- preparing broad beans in areas of high frequency of favism
Type 2 diabetes well as variation in these responses, this does not downplay the
Just as the prevalence of obesity is rising rapidly, so is the crucial importance of environmental, developmental, and cultural
prevalence of type 2 diabetes: it is projected to affect ’0.5 billion influences. In most of the examples I have discussed, the outcome
people within a few decades, at great cost both to the individual depends on a complex interaction between genes and environ-
sufferers and to the health care systems that support them. But ment. Second, in tackling the major challenge of the links be-
just as striking as the overall increase is that type 2 diabetes tween diet and disease, policy makers should aim to work with,
affects different groups to very different extents, from ’2% of rather than against, our predispositions. I can do no better than
the population in Europe to ’50% among Pima Indians of North quote from Gluckman and Hansen’s (30) book on the concept
America (24). Even within groups there are striking contrasts: of mismatch: “the mismatch paradigm, as part of a life cour-
for example, between rural and urban native peoples in Aus- se approach to understanding disease causation, can explain
tralia, or within the Pacific Island of Nauru over the past 50 y. and even predict the patterns of disease that are developing
Is this due to differences in genetic makeup or in the envi- rapidly . . . . It may hold the key to interventions which could
ronment? The answer is “both.” We know from twin studies, as pay off.” (Other articles in this supplement to the Journal in-
well as from genome-wide associations, that there is genetic clude references 31–59.)