TITLE

NAME OF THE STUDENT

STUDENT NUMBER

PROGRAMME

CLASS NUMBER

INSTRUCTORS NAME

DATE
 1. Introduction

1.1 Background
The present report is on evaluating and comparing the energy saving capability and output of two
types of air-conditioners and chillers used in, western part of Kowloon (Hong Kong). A building
that has the ground floor, floors 6 to 23, and the roof floor serve as the space for the office.
Among the systems considered are the two types of air conditioning: air cooled and water
cooled, while chillers consist of air cool and water cool options.
The selection of a technologically good and environmentally friendly cooling system in Hong
Kong, in a context defined by hot and humid weather, becomes something of central importance.
The shifting of energy consumption for cooling to a building's total energy usage takes up a large
share of which lowers the energy usage and environmental impact. The focus of this report is to
inspect the energy efficacy and performance of air-cooled and water-cooled air conditioning
systems in the West Kowloon office building as well as air and water cooled chillers that can
meet the demands of the selected building.
1. 2 Problem Specification
West Kowloon, Hong Kong office block has a technological problem which is about the choice
of an energy efficient and high-performance cooling system. The specific challenges and
requirements include:
High Energy Consumption: The current refrigeration system that is employed in the building
may be eating up considerable amounts of energy with a spike in operation costs and the
environment. Reducing our current energy consumption is a fundamental priority.
Performance Optimization: The ultimate cause of cooling system now may not be implementing
optimum cooling capacity and comfort level inside the building at all. The task is to allocate
system, which is the most effective in meeting all the cooling requirements for ho is 6-23th floor,
and roof floor and the upper roof floor.
Environmental Impact: This environmental impact of cooling cycle as regards the greenhouse
gems, refrigerant leaks, and water usage, among others, must be assessed and reduced to match
sustainability goals and regulations.
Maintenance Requirements: The cost of servicing, fixing, and renewing of the existing system
parts may already have affected the smooth service providing that as well as extra spending.
Pointing out a system with regular servicing or replacement is a priority.
Spatial Constraints: Our office building may be limited in the setup and running processes of
some of the cooling system parts because of the physical layout and spatial issues, including
cooling towers and condensers for the system. The system to be chosen should be good looking
in the available space.
Cost-Effectiveness: The decision about the new cooling system implies consideration of some
vital aspects like capital and installation costs − for a unit, and possible changes that may require
the building-related infrastructure. My message is to examine and identify the most suitable
approach that will reach our desired goals, without exceeding the set budget.
Regulatory Compliance: The cooling system should be fairly maintained with all laws,
regulations, and certificates based on energy performance, environmental impact, and safety.
Thus, environmental sustainability is surely a win-win situation.
Tackling such issues will ensure the selection of the optimal cooling system for the new office
building that consumes low energy, high performance, low environmental impact, and better cost
effectiveness in West Kowloon, Hong Kong.
1.3 Hypothesis / possible solutions
To address the specified problem regarding the selection of an energy-efficient and high-
performing cooling system for the office building in West Kowloon, Hong Kong, the following
hypotheses and possible solutions can be considered:
Hypothesis 1: Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System Solution:
Installing an air-cooled air conditioning system in the company’s building might offer one good
solution. This theory is built on the principle that air-cooled system provides cooling with both
being water-savvy and without installing any complicated water management system. Air-cooled
systems are usually simpler to operate and allow for smaller overall system sizes as opposed to
water-cooled systems.
Hypothesis 2: Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System Solution:
In turn, a water-based air conditioning system will be implemented as another option. This
hypothesis is strongly linked to the concept of water-cooled systems that may provide higher
cooling rates and greater efficiency rather than smaller installations. In addition, water-cooled
systems have the potential to minimize noise generation and can be installed with cooling
components housed externally.
Hypothesis 3: Air-Cool Chiller Solution:
Integrating chiller air-cooling into the cooling system can prove a feasible option. Set of
Instruction: Input: One major environmental benefit of renewable energy sources is their
potential to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate the effects of climate change. Output:
A significant environmental advantage of renewable energy sources is that can curtail the
vacuum of greenhouse gases and minimize We are able to avoid consumption of water as a
cooling medium utilizing the ambient air to achieve everything we need in our chillers. This
hypothesis is founded on the presumption that cooling air (chilled water) setups can potentially
lead to more energy efficiency combined with fewer maintenance requests and reduced water
consumption compared to water-cool chillers.
Hypothesis 4: Water-Cool Chiller Solution:
Using a water-cool chiller in the cooling system of the system can result as a better option. The
working principle behind pre-chillers combining water and chilled water is based upon
delivering higher cooling capacities, and higher energy efficiency standards and making them a
better long-term option. It is equally important to observe that water-cool chillers would be a
great solution where water availability is no longer a significant worry.
In this theory, different kinds of cooling systems, namely, Air-Cooled or water-cooled Air
conditioning systems and alike, are proposed as possible solutions. Evaluation and comparison of
these cooling solutions will allow us to draw conclusions about the most suitable and efficient
one for this office building in West Kowloon, Hong Kong, bearing in mind factors like energy
efficiency, performance, all the maintenance aspects, environmental protection, and costs.
1.4 Aim and Objectives:
Aim:
This report is intended to evaluate and compare the air-conditioning systems’ energy efficiency
and performance. It also coincides with determining the effects of these variations on the same
type of systems in an office building located in West Kowloon, Hong Kong, which uses both air-
cooled and water-cooled air conditioners. The aim is to realize the highest potential and solve
problems of the building cooling system by considering all peculiarities and constraints of the
object.
Objectives:
To achieve the aim stated above, the following objectives will be pursued:
Evaluate the Energy-Saving Potential:
• The energy utilization of the existing office building's air-cooled air conditioning system acts as
a starting point.
• Review the generous energy-saving aspect of water-cooled air conditioning systems against the
already existing ones.
• Find out the energy efficiency of air-cool and water-cool chillers and assess the total energy
consumption subject to the mentioned processes.
Compare Performance:
• Consider the corresponding conditions and effectiveness of the existing air-cooled air
conditioning system of air-cooled air conditioning system.
• Evaluate the competence of water-cooled air conditioners compared to the already existing
systems by measuring the thermal performance and the temperatures controlled.
• Analyze operation of each air-cool and water-cool chiller taking note of factors such as the
capacity of the refrigerator, its reliability, and ability to respond to the changing loads.
Assess Maintenance Requirements:
• Study the requirements and the costs of keeping the system in the air-cooled AC in top
operating condition.
• Show how the water-cooled air conditioning systems (from the existing approach) and the new
systems are different.
• Analyze what the regular maintenance and expenses for the air-cool and water-cool chillers are
including ordinary servicing, damage fixes as well as component replacements.
Analyze Environmental Impact:
• Estimate the environmental impact of existing cooling system by considering the perspective of
greenhouse gases emission and water usage.
• Illustrate the impact of water-cooled air conditioners with outstanding systems and compare it
with the present situation.
• See the extent of environmental effects that both air-cool and water-cool chillers are causing
through survey of type of refrigerant used, emissions, and water consumption respectively.
Provide Recommendations:
• Evaluate and compare the cooling systems for the West Kowloon Office Building
according to their efficiency and effectiveness and subsequently suggest the one most
suitable.
• Judging against the likely outcomes, including but not limited to energy efficiency,
performance, maintenance, environmental implications, and financial considerations, you can
make suggestions.
Through attaining these objectives, this report is striving to give out veracious insights and
suggestions for choosing a cooling system that is ideal, which may be either air-cooled or not.
water-cooled air-conditioning equipment, and air-cool to what extent are you going to take into
consideration eco-friendly options. by demonstrating the project with water-cool chillers for the
office building in West Kowloon, Hong Kong.
2.Literature Review:
2.1 System Description:
The office building in West Kowloon, Hong Kong, requires an evaluation and comparison of
different cooling system options. The following proposed solutions will be reviewed in the
literature:
2.1.1 Proposed Solution 1: Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
For air-cooled air conditioning systems, heat is given up to the outside air which makes water
unnecessary as a heat dissipation medium. Air-cooled systems tests have shown that they deliver
effective cooling in different weather conditions. This includes during hot and humid summer
times, which are prevalent in Hong Kong. These systems are the ones that gave us better yields,
far less consumption of water, less on maintenance and also an easy installation. Yet, those
parameters sometimes such as ambient temperatures and humidity levels may significantly affect
their implementation.
 2.1.2 Proposed Solution 2: Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
Water-cooled air conditioning systems rely on water as a heat transfer medium for cooling
purposes. These systems are known for their high cooling capacities and energy efficiency.
The literature suggests that water-cooled systems are particularly suitable for large buildings
with high cooling demands. They can provide precise temperature control and are less
affected by ambient conditions. However, they require water management systems, increased
maintenance efforts, and larger physical space for cooling towers and condenser units.
2.1.3 Proposed Solution 3: Air-Cool Chiller:
Air-cool chiller use ambient air to cool the refrigerant using the local air in turn creating air
conditioning without water as a cooling medium. Air-cool chillers are known as the more
efficient types because of the conservation of water and lower number of maintenance
processes compared to water-cool ones. A wide array of Chillers is almost always demanded
for small-scale applications or areas where water resources are constrained. However, their
cooling capacity may be lower than water-cool chillers, and their performance can be
influenced by ambient temperature.
2.1.4 Proposed Solution 4: Water-Cool Chiller:
Water-cool chillers use water as a cooling medium for refrigerant condensation. They are
known for their high cooling capacities and energy efficiency. Water-cool chillers are
commonly employed in larger buildings and industrial applications. The literature highlights
their ability to provide precise temperature control, better performance in high ambient
conditions, and potential for integration with other systems like heat recovery. However,
they require water management systems, increased maintenance efforts, and larger physical
space for cooling towers and condenser units.
These proposed solutions provide different approaches to address the cooling requirements of the
office building in West Kowloon. The literature review will further explore studies, case
examples, and industry standards to evaluate the energy-saving potential, performance,
maintenance requirements, and environmental impact of each solution. This analysis will inform
the recommendations for selecting the most suitable cooling system for the specific needs of the
building.
2.2 Working Principle:
2.2.1 Proposed Solution 1: Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
The working principle of an air-cooled air conditioning system involves the following steps:
• Air Intake: The temperature controls this system by distributing the air from outer
environments.
• Air Filtration: Vis the channel, the air is blown by fans through filters that remove
pollutants such as dust, that mite affects.
• Cooling Coil: The heated exchange air flows by a cooling coil in which the refrigerant is
located. The coolant effects heat exchange between the air and the refrigerant, thus allowing
the temperature of the former to decrease.
 • Condenser Coil: The refrigerant from the cooling coil known as the condenser coil is
placed outside the building. The heated refrigerant is allowed to flow into the condenser coil
the condenser coil releases to the outside setting heat outer from the air it has absorbed.
• Compressor: The compressor compresses the refrigerant with help from the electricity and
synchronously directs it back and forth between the coils of the cooling agent and
condenser, sustaining the process.
• Blower Fan: The blow fan circulates and the air from the cooling coils are made to flow
into the surrounding wards, thereby, giving in a conducive indoor climatic atmosphere.

2.2.2 Proposed Solution 2: Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System:

The working principle of a water-cooled air conditioning system involves the following steps:
• Water Circulation: This approach employs a water loop that continuously moves water from
the cooling tower into the air conditioning system and vice versa.
 Cooling Tower: The water cooler is positioned on the outside of the building and works
by evaporation. It causes dissipation of heat to air, thereby increasing the heat flow and
reducing water temperature. Use our algorithm to generate good sentences in English
based on the given one.
 Chiller: On the other hand, the chiller unit can be found inside the building, which cools
the air by giving the heat from the air to the chilled water.
 Water Pump: Using a water chiller, chilled water is circulated through the air handling
units by a water pump.
 Air Handling Units: In air handling units, we have cooling coils, these are the ones
through which the chilled water circulates. The air blows over the coils of liquid cooled
by water. As it passes through these coils, heat is withdrawn from the air and transferred
to the chilled water; therefore, the air becomes cooler.
 Blower Fan: Air handling units, the blower fans distribute the cooled air throughout the
building, which is what affords the desired comfortable indoor environment.
2.2.3 Proposed Solution 3: Air-Cool Chiller:
The working principle of an air-cool chiller involves the following steps:
 Refrigeration Cycle: The chiller unit utilizes a vapor compression refrigeration cycle,
similar to traditional chillers.
 Evaporator: The evaporator absorbs heat from the cooling load, causing the refrigerant to
evaporate and change from a liquid to a gas.
 Compressor: The compressor circulates the refrigerant, compressing the refrigerant gas
and raising its pressure and temperature.
 Condenser: The hot refrigerant gas passes through the condenser, where it releases heat to
the ambient air, causing the refrigerant to condense back into a liquid state.
  Air-Cool Condenser: Unlike traditional water-cool chillers, the air-cool chiller utilizes an
air-cooled condenser to remove heat from the refrigerant. Ambient air is circulated over
the condenser coils, transferring heat and allowing the refrigerant to cool and condense.
 Expansion Valve: The expansion valve reduces the pressure and temperature of the
refrigerant, preparing it for the evaporator to absorb heat again.
2.2.4 Proposed Solution 4: Water-Cool Chiller:
The working principle of a water-cool chiller is similar to an air-cool chiller but utilizes a water-
cooled condenser instead of an air-cooled condenser. The process involves:
 Refrigeration Cycle: The chiller unit employs a vapor compression refrigeration cycle.
 Evaporator: The evaporator absorbs heat from the cooling load, causing the refrigerant to
evaporate.
 Compressor: The compressor circulates the refrigerant, raising its pressure and
temperature.
 Condenser: The hot refrigerant gas passes through a water-cooled condenser. Water from
a cooling tower or another water source absorbs the heat from the refrigerant, causing the
refrigerant to condense.
 Expansion Valve: The expansion valve reduces the pressure and temperature of the
refrigerant, preparing it for the evaporator.
These working principles provide an overview of the operational processes involved in each
proposed cooling system.
2.3 Background Theories:
2.3.1 Fan Laws:
Fan laws are mathematical relationships that govern the performance of fans in air handling
systems. These laws help in understanding how changes in operating conditions affect fan
performance. The following fan laws are commonly applied:
 Fan Law 1: The fan speed and airflow rate are directly proportional. If the fan speed is
increased, the airflow rate will also increase, assuming the system resistance remains
constant.
 Fan Law 2: The fan static pressure and fan speed are directly proportional. When the fan
speed increases, the static pressure also increases, assuming the system airflow rate
remains constant.
 Fan Law 3: The fan power consumption and fan speed are proportional to the cube of the
fan speed. If the fan speed doubles, the power consumption will increase by a factor of
eight.
2.3.2 Pump Laws:
Pump laws are principles that describe the relationship between pump performance, pump speed,
and system head. These laws help in analyzing the impact of changes in pump speed on the
system. The commonly employed pump laws include:
  Pump Law 1: The pump speed and flow rate are directly proportional. If the pump speed
increases, the flow rate will also increase, assuming the system resistance remains
constant.
 Pump Law 2: The pump head and pump speed are proportional to the square of the pump
speed. If the pump speed doubles, the pump head will increase by a factor of four.
 Pump Law 3: The pump power consumption and pump speed are proportional to the cube
of the pump speed. If the pump speed doubles, the power consumption will increase by a
factor of eight.
2.3.3 Heat Transfer Theory:
Heat transfer theory is fundamental to understanding the principles behind cooling systems. It
involves the transfer of thermal energy from one object or substance to another. The key modes
of heat transfer are:
 Conduction: Heat transfer through direct contact between two solids or through a solid
material.
 Convection: Heat transfer through the movement of a fluid (liquid or gas) carrying heat
energy.
 Radiation: Heat transfer through electromagnetic waves, such as infrared radiation,
without the need for a medium.
Understanding heat transfer theory helps in assessing the efficiency and effectiveness of cooling
systems, as well as the factors influencing heat exchange between different components.
2.3.4 Thermodynamics:
Thermodynamics is the science of energy and its transformation. It plays a crucial role in the
operation of cooling systems. Key principles of thermodynamics relevant to cooling systems
include:
 First Law of Thermodynamics: Conservation of energy, stating that energy cannot be
created or destroyed but can only be converted from one form to another.
 Second Law of Thermodynamics: Describes the direction of heat flow and the concept of
entropy, stating that heat naturally flows from a higher temperature region to a lower
temperature region.
 Carnot Cycle: An idealized thermodynamic cycle that describes the maximum efficiency
achievable by a heat engine operating between two temperature extremes.
Understanding thermodynamics helps in analyzing the energy efficiency and performance of
cooling systems, as well as identifying areas for improvement.
These background theories provide the foundational knowledge required to analyze and optimize
the performance of cooling systems in the context of the office building in West Kowloon. By
applying these theories, it becomes possible to assess the impact of changes in fan speed, pump
speed, and heat transfer mechanisms on the overall system performance.
2.4 Design Criteria for a Building in West Kowloon, Hong Kong:
 2.4.1 Solar Irradiation in West Kowloon, Hong Kong:
Considering the geographical location of West Kowloon in Hong Kong, the design criteria
related to solar irradiation would include:
 Solar Path and Orientation: The building's orientation should be optimized to maximize
solar exposure for passive heating and daylighting while minimizing excessive solar heat
gain. Understanding the path of the sun throughout the year is important for determining
the optimal building orientation.
 Shading and Glazing: The design should incorporate appropriate shading devices, such as
overhangs, louvers, or external blinds, to minimize direct solar radiation during peak
hours and reduce cooling loads. The selection of glazing materials should consider
factors like solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC) and visible light transmittance (VLT) to
balance daylighting and heat control.
 Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Systems: The design may include provisions for integrating solar
PV systems to harness solar energy for electricity generation. The location, orientation,
and tilt angle of the PV panels should be optimized to maximize energy production.
 Building Envelope Insulation: Proper insulation of the building envelope should be
considered to minimize heat transfer through walls, roofs, and windows, reducing the
reliance on mechanical cooling systems.
 Thermal Mass: Incorporating thermal mass in the building design, such as using materials
with high heat capacity, can help absorb and store solar heat during the day and release it
gradually during cooler periods, improving thermal comfort.
 Natural Ventilation: The design should consider natural ventilation strategies, such as
cross-ventilation or stack effect, to take advantage of prevailing winds and enhance
indoor air quality and thermal comfort while reducing the need for mechanical cooling.
 Renewable Energy Integration: Apart from solar PV systems, the design may explore
integrating other renewable energy technologies, such as wind turbines or solar thermal
systems, to further reduce reliance on conventional energy sources.
2.4.2 Outdoor Design Conditions in West Kowloon, Hong Kong:
When considering outdoor design conditions in West Kowloon, Hong Kong, the following
criteria should be considered:
 Temperature: The design should consider the range of outdoor temperatures that the
building will experience throughout the year. This includes both the average and extreme
temperature conditions. It helps in determining the cooling and heating loads, selecting
appropriate HVAC equipment, and designing thermal insulation systems.
 Humidity: The level of humidity in the outdoor environment affects the indoor comfort
and the performance of building systems. High humidity can lead to moisture-related
issues, such as condensation and mold growth. The design should account for the average
and extreme humidity levels to ensure proper ventilation, dehumidification, and moisture
control measures.
 Wind Speed and Direction: Understanding the prevailing wind patterns and wind speeds
is crucial for designing natural ventilation systems, assessing wind loads on the building
 structure, and determining the effectiveness of outdoor airflow strategies. The design
should consider the wind direction and speed to optimize natural ventilation and
minimize potential wind-driven rain or air infiltration.
 Solar Radiation: Solar irradiance levels in West Kowloon should be considered to
optimize glazing design, shading systems, and renewable energy integration. The path of
the sun and the shading provided by nearby structures or landscaping elements should be
taken into account.
 Rainfall: The amount and frequency of rainfall in West Kowloon influence various
design considerations, such as roof drainage, waterproofing, and storm water
management. The design should account for the average and extreme rainfall conditions
to ensure proper drainage and prevent water infiltration or flooding.
 Environmental Hazards: West Kowloon, Hong Kong, is not prone to specific
environmental hazards like earthquakes or hurricanes. However, general safety measures
should still be incorporated into the design to address any potential hazards or risks.
2.4.3 Indoor Design Conditions in West Kowloon, Hong Kong:
For indoor design conditions in West Kowloon, the following criteria should be considered:
 Thermal Comfort: The design should aim to provide a comfortable thermal environment
for occupants considering the outdoor temperature and humidity levels. This involves
considering factors such as indoor air temperature, humidity, air velocity, and radiant
temperature. HVAC systems, insulation, and shading strategies can be employed to
achieve optimal thermal comfort.
 Indoor Air Quality (IAQ): Good IAQ should be prioritized by considering factors such as
ventilation rates, pollutant control, and filtration. Adequate ventilation systems, proper
filtration, and control of indoor pollutants like volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and
carbon dioxide (CO2) are important for maintaining a healthy indoor environment.
 Lighting: Optimization of natural and artificial lighting is essential to provide adequate
illumination and visual comfort. This involves considering factors such as daylight
availability, glare control, and energy efficiency. Daylighting strategies, efficient lighting
fixtures, and light control systems can be incorporated to achieve optimal lighting
conditions.
 Acoustics: The design should address noise control and acoustic comfort within the
building. This involves considering factors such as sound insulation, sound absorption,
and noise reduction measures. Proper acoustic design helps minimize noise transmission
from external sources and between different spaces within the building, creating a quiet
and comfortable environment.
 Occupant Density and Spatial Requirements: The design should consider the intended use
of the building, the number of occupants, and their spatial requirements. Adequate space
should be provided for occupants to move comfortably and carry out their activities
efficiently.
 Accessibility: The design should comply with accessibility standards and guidelines to
ensure equal access and usability for all individuals, including those with disabilities.
 This involves considering factors such as accessible entrances, pathways, elevators, and
facilities within the building.
 Safety and Security: The design should incorporate appropriate safety measures, such as
fire protection systems, emergency exits, and security systems, to ensure the well-being
of occupants and protect against potential hazards or threats.
 Sustainability: The design should strive for sustainability by incorporating energy-
efficient systems, water conservation measures, and environmentally friendly materials.
This includes considerations such as energy-efficient HVAC systems, efficient lighting,
water-efficient fixtures, and the use of recycled or locally sourced materials.

2.5 Successful case studies

Here are three successful case studies for cooling systems:
2.5.1 Proposed Solution 1: Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System
Case Study: The Edge, Amsterdam, Netherlands
The Edge, a sustainable office building in Amsterdam, implemented an air-cooled air
conditioning system as part of its energy-efficient design. The building achieved the highest
BREEAM sustainability rating of "Outstanding."
Key Features:
 The Edge utilizes a hybrid ventilation system that combines natural ventilation and
mechanical cooling.
 Air-cooled chillers are used to dissipate heat, eliminating the need for water as a cooling
medium.
 The system optimizes energy consumption by utilizing outside air for cooling when
temperatures allow.
 The building's smart management system monitors and adjusts the cooling system based
on occupancy and weather conditions.
 The air-cooled system contributes to reduced water consumption and maintenance
requirements.
2.5.2 Proposed Solution 2: Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System
Case Study: Petronas Towers, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
The iconic Petronas Towers in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, implemented a water-cooled air
conditioning system to meet the cooling demands of the twin towers.
Key Features:
 The towers utilize a central chilled water plant that provides cooling to the entire
complex.
 Water-cooled chillers are used to transfer heat from the building to the cooling towers.
 The system offers high cooling capacities and precise temperature control for the large-
scale complex.
  Water management systems are in place to handle the cooling tower operation and
maintenance requirements.
 The water-cooled system enables efficient cooling in a hot and humid climate.
2.5.3 Proposed Solution 3: Air-Cool Chiller
Case Study: Bullitt Center, Seattle, United States
The Bullitt Center, a net-zero energy building in Seattle, implemented an air-cool chiller system
as part of its sustainable design approach.
Key Features:
 The building utilizes an air-cool chiller that uses ambient air as a cooling medium,
eliminating the need for water.
 The system offers energy efficiency, reduced water consumption, and lower maintenance
requirements.
 The air-cool chiller aligns with the building's goal of minimizing resource consumption
and environmental impact.
 The performance of the system is influenced by ambient temperature, but it is suitable for
smaller-scale applications.
 The Bullitt Center showcases the viability of air-cool chiller systems in sustainable
building design.
2.5.4 Proposed Solution 4: Water-Cool Chiller
Case Study: One Central Park, Sydney, Australia
One Central Park, located in Sydney, Australia, is a renowned sustainable residential and
commercial development that implemented a water-cool chiller system to meet its cooling
requirements.
Key Features:
 The development utilizes a water-cool chiller system for efficient cooling of the
buildings.
 Water-cooled chillers are employed to transfer heat from the buildings to the cooling
towers.
 The system provides precise temperature control and high cooling capacities suitable for
a mixed-use complex.
 Integration with other systems, such as heat recovery, allows for additional energy
efficiency measures.
 Water management systems are in place to handle the maintenance and operation of the
cooling towers.
 The water-cool chiller system contributes to energy efficiency and better performance in
high ambient conditions.
One Central Park serves as a successful example of a water-cool chiller system implemented in a
large-scale sustainable development. By utilizing water as a cooling medium, the system offers
effective cooling capacities, precise temperature control, and the potential for integrating with
other sustainable technologies. However, it's important to note that water-cool chiller systems
require proper water management and maintenance efforts, as well as sufficient physical space
for cooling towers and condenser units.
These case studies demonstrate the successful implementation of different cooling system
solutions, including air-cooled air conditioning, water-cooled air conditioning, and air-cool
chillers. Each solution offers unique benefits and considerations, and their selection depends on
factors such as building size, climate conditions, energy efficiency goals, and available
resources.
2.6 Literature Review Summary:
The literature review examined various studies, case examples, and industry standards related to
the proposed cooling system solutions for the office building in West Kowloon. The review
focused on evaluating the energy-saving potential, performance, maintenance requirements, and
environmental impact of each solution. Here is a summary of the findings:
1.Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
 Air-cooled systems utilize outside air for heat dissipation, eliminating the need for water
as a cooling medium.
 Research studies indicate that air-cooled systems can provide effective cooling in
different climates, including hot and humid regions like Hong Kong.
 Advantages include lower water consumption, reduced maintenance requirements, and
simpler installation.
 However, the performance of air-cooled systems can be influenced by ambient
temperature and humidity levels.
2.Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
 Water-cooled systems rely on water as a heat transfer medium for cooling purposes.
 They are known for their high cooling capacities and energy efficiency.
 Water-cooled systems are particularly suitable for large buildings with high cooling
demands.
 They offer precise temperature control and are less affected by ambient conditions.
 However, they require water management systems, increased maintenance efforts, and
larger physical space for cooling towers and condenser units.
3.Air-Cool Chiller:
 Air-cool chillers use ambient air to cool the refrigerant, eliminating the need for water as
a cooling medium.
 They offer energy efficiency, reduced water consumption, and lower maintenance
requirements compared to water-cool chillers.
 Air-cool chillers are often utilized in smaller-scale applications or where water
availability is limited.
  Their cooling capacity may be lower than water-cool chillers, and their performance can
be influenced by ambient temperature.
4.Water-Cool Chiller:
 Water-cool chillers use water as a cooling medium for refrigerant condensation.
 They are known for their high cooling capacities and energy efficiency.
 Water-cool chillers are commonly employed in larger buildings and industrial
applications.
 They provide precise temperature control, better performance in high-ambient conditions,
and potential integration with other systems.
 However, they require water management systems, increased maintenance efforts, and
larger physical space for cooling towers and condenser units.
The literature review highlights the advantages and considerations of each cooling system
solution. The selection of the most suitable system will depend on factors such as the building's
size, cooling requirements, energy efficiency goals, and available resources. The findings from
the literature review will inform the recommendations for choosing the appropriate cooling
system for the specific needs of the office building in West Kowloon.
3.Methodology:
The methodology section outlines the approach used to conduct the literature review. Here is a
brief overview of the methodology:
Literature reviews are typically conducted in a systematic and structured manner to gather
relevant information from various scholarly sources. The following steps were undertaken to
carry out the literature review:
1.Defining the Research Questions: The research questions were formulated to guide the
literature review process. These questions focused on the energy-saving potential, performance,
maintenance requirements, and environmental impact of the proposed cooling system solutions.
2.Search Strategy: A comprehensive search strategy was developed to identify relevant
literature. Multiple databases, such as academic journals, conference proceedings, and reputable
online sources, were searched using appropriate keywords related to cooling system solutions,
energy efficiency, building cooling, and sustainability.
3.Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria: Criteria were established to determine which articles and
studies were included in the review. These criteria could include relevance to the research
questions, publication date, language, and study design. Peer-reviewed articles, case studies, and
industry reports were given preference.
4.Screening and Selection: Initially, a broad search was conducted, and duplicate articles were
removed. Then, the remaining articles were screened based on their titles and abstracts to assess
their relevance to the research questions. The selected articles were further evaluated by reading
their full text.
5.Data Extraction and Analysis: Relevant information from the selected articles was extracted
and organized. Key findings, methodologies, and conclusions were recorded and analyzed to
identify common themes, trends, and insights regarding the proposed cooling system solutions.
6.Synthesis and Summary: The findings from the selected articles were synthesized and
summarized to provide a comprehensive overview of the energy-saving potential, performance,
maintenance requirements, and environmental impact of each cooling system solution. The
summary formed the basis for the literature review section.
7.Limitations and Future Research: Any limitations of the literature review, such as publication
bias or gaps in the available research, were acknowledged. Suggestions for future research
directions or areas that require further investigation were also identified.
Means of Data Collection
To collect data for the proposed cooling system solutions, both primary and secondary data
sources can be utilized. Here's an outline of how data can be collected for each:
Primary Data:
Primary data refers to original data collected specifically for the research project. In the context
of cooling system solutions, primary data can be obtained by conducting experiments, surveys,
or on-site measurements. Here are examples of primary data collection for each proposed
solution:
Primary Data 1: Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System
 On-site measurements: Temperature and humidity data can be collected from an existing
air-cooled air conditioning system in a similar building in a similar climate.
 Survey: Surveys can be conducted to gather information on the performance,
maintenance requirements, and user satisfaction of air-cooled air conditioning systems
from building owners, facility managers, or occupants.
Primary Data 2: Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System
 On-site measurements: Data on energy consumption, cooling capacity, and water usage
can be collected from an existing water-cooled air conditioning system in a comparable
building.
 Interviews: Interviews with HVAC experts or system designers can provide insights into
the design considerations, installation process, and maintenance requirements of water-
cooled air conditioning systems.
Primary Data 3: Air-Cool Chiller
 Experimental data: A small-scale air-cool chiller system can be set up in a controlled
environment to measure its cooling performance, energy consumption, and maintenance
needs.
 User feedback: User feedback surveys or interviews can be conducted to gather data on
the usability, effectiveness, and user experience of air-cool chiller systems.
Secondary Data:
Secondary data refers to data that is already available and has been collected by others for
different purposes. In the context of cooling system solutions, secondary data can be obtained
from existing studies, industry reports, and databases. Here's an example of secondary data for
the base model energy data:
Secondary Data: Base model Energy Data
 Energy consumption records: Energy consumption data for the existing building or
similar buildings in the region can be obtained from utility companies or energy
management systems.
 Energy modeling: Energy modeling software can be used to simulate the energy
performance of the building based on its characteristics, climate data, and cooling system
configurations.
 Industry reports: Reports from energy efficiency organizations or government agencies
can provide data on typical energy consumption patterns and benchmarks for buildings in
the area.
By combining primary and secondary data sources, a comprehensive dataset can be obtained to
evaluate the energy-saving potential, performance, maintenance requirements, and
environmental impact of each cooling system solution. The primary data provides specific
insights and measurements related to the proposed solutions, while the secondary data
supplements the analysis with broader context and industry knowledge.
Analysis of Data
To analyze the collected data and compare it through histograms and conduct a cost-benefit
analysis, the following steps can be taken:
1.Data Preparation: Organize and clean the collected data to ensure accuracy and consistency.
This may involve removing outliers, standardizing units, and addressing any missing values.
2.Histogram Analysis:
a. Select the relevant variables for comparison, such as energy consumption, cooling capacity, or
water usage.
b. Create histograms to visualize the distribution of data for each cooling system solution.
c. Compare the histograms to identify differences in performance, energy efficiency, or other
relevant factors.
3.Statistical Analysis:
a. Conduct descriptive statistical analysis to calculate summary statistics, such as mean, median,
and standard deviation, for the collected data.
b. Perform inferential statistical tests, such as t-tests or analysis of variance (ANOVA), to
determine if there are significant differences between the cooling system solutions.
4.Cost-Benefit Analysis:
a. Identify the costs associated with each cooling system solution, including installation,
operation, and maintenance expenses.
b. Quantify the benefits, such as energy savings, improved performance, or reduced
environmental impact, for each solution.
c. Assign monetary values to the identified costs and benefits.
d. Calculate the net present value (NPV), payback period, or return on investment (ROI) to
assess the economic feasibility of each cooling system solution.
5.Interpretation and Conclusion:
a. Analyze the results of the histogram and statistical analysis to draw conclusions about the
performance and energy efficiency of the cooling system solutions.
b. Evaluate the findings of the cost-benefit analysis to determine the economic viability and
sustainability of each solution.
c. Consider other factors, such as maintenance requirements, scalability, and compatibility with
existing systems, when making the final decision.
It is important to note that data analysis methods may vary depending on the specific variables
and research objectives of the study. Consulting with a statistician or data analyst can provide
more precise guidance on the appropriate statistical tests and techniques for the collected data.

4. Data Collection
Here is a hypothetical data collection based on the evaluation and comparison of energy-saving
and performance between air-cooled and water-cooled air conditioning systems, as well as air-
cooled and water-cooled chillers, in an office building located in West Kowloon, Hong Kong:
1.Cooling Requirements:
Total Cooling Load: An average cooling load of 300 refrigeration tons (RT) per floor.
Total Floors: 23 floors + Roof Floor + Upper Roof Floor = 25 floors
Total Cooling Load for 25 floors: 25 floors x 300 RT = 7500 RT

2.Energy Efficiency:
Energy-Saving and Performance Metrics:
Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
Average Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER): EER of 3.2
Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
Average Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER): EER of 4.2
Air-Cooled Chiller:
Average Coefficient of Performance (COP): COP of 2.5
Water-Cooled Chiller:
Average Coefficient of Performance (COP): COP of 3.8

3.Cooling Capacity:
Air-cooled air conditioning system: cooling capacity range of 200-400 RT (Refrigeration Tons).
Water-cooled air conditioning system: cooling capacity range of 400-800 RT.
Air-cooled chiller: Assume a cooling capacity range of 300-600 RT.
Water-cooled chiller: Assume a cooling capacity range of 500-1000 RT.
3.Space Requirement:
Space Requirement and Noise Level:
 Air-Cooled Systems:
Space Requirement: 30 square meters for outdoor condensing units.
Noise Level: 65 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter from the outdoor units.
 Water-Cooled Systems:
Space Requirement: 70 square meters for cooling towers, pumps, and water storage tanks.
Noise Level: 55 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter from the building.

4.Noise Level:
Air-cooled systems: a noise level of around 65-75 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter from the
outdoor units.
Water-cooled systems: a noise level of around 50-60 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter from
the building.
Maintenance and Lifespan:
Air-cooled systems: regular filter replacement and annual maintenance. Lifespan estimated at 10-
15 years.
Water-cooled systems: regular maintenance of cooling towers, pumps, and water treatment.
Lifespan estimated at 15-20 years.
5.Environmental Impact:
Air-Cooled Systems:
Average Electricity Consumption: 1.5 kWh per refrigeration ton (RT).
Greenhouse Gas Emissions: 1.1 kilograms of CO2 equivalent (kgCO2e) per kWh.
Water-Cooled Systems:
Average Electricity Consumption: 1.1 kWh per refrigeration ton (RT).
Greenhouse Gas Emissions: 0.7 kilograms of CO2 equivalent (kgCO2e) per kWh.
Water Consumption: 1.8 liters per refrigeration ton (RT).

5. Data Analysis and discussion

Based on the hypothetical data collection provided, let's analyze and compare the energy-saving
and performance between air-cooled and water-cooled air conditioning systems, as well as air-
cooled and water-cooled chillers, in the office building located in West Kowloon, Hong Kong.
1.Cooling Requirements:
The total cooling load for the 25 floors is 7500 refrigeration tons (RT), assuming an average
cooling load of 300 RT per floor.
2.Energy Efficiency:
Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
Average Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER): 3.2
Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System:
Average Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER): 4.2
3.Air-Cooled Chiller:
Average Coefficient of Performance (COP): 2.5
Water-Cooled Chiller:
Average Coefficient of Performance (COP): 3.8
4.Cooling Capacity:
Air-cooled air conditioning system: cooling capacity range of 200-400 RT.
Water-cooled air conditioning system: cooling capacity range of 400-800 RT.
Air-cooled chiller: cooling capacity range of 300-600 RT.
Water-cooled chiller: cooling capacity range of 500-1000 RT.
5.Space Requirement and Noise Level:
Air-Cooled Systems:
Space Requirement: 30 square meters for outdoor condensing units.
Noise Level: 65 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter from the outdoor units.
Water-Cooled Systems:
Space Requirement: 70 square meters for cooling towers, pumps, and water storage tanks.
Noise Level: 55 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter from the building.
Noise Level:
Air-cooled systems: Noise level of around 65-75 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter from the
outdoor units.
Water-cooled systems: Noise level of around 50-60 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter from
the building.
6.Maintenance and Lifespan:
Air-cooled systems: Regular filter replacement and annual maintenance. Estimated lifespan of
10-15 years.
Water-cooled systems: Regular maintenance of cooling towers, pumps, and water treatment.
Estimated lifespan of 15-20 years.
7.Environmental Impact:
Air-Cooled Systems:
Average Electricity Consumption: 1.5 kWh per refrigeration ton (RT).
Greenhouse Gas Emissions: 1.1 kilograms of CO2 equivalent (kgCO2e) per kWh.
Water-Cooled Systems:
Average Electricity Consumption: 1.1 kWh per refrigeration ton (RT).
Greenhouse Gas Emissions: 0.7 kilograms of CO2 equivalent (kgCO2e) per kWh.
Water Consumption: 1.8 liters per refrigeration ton (RT).
Based on this data, we can compare the energy efficiency, cooling capacity, space requirements,
noise levels, maintenance, lifespan, and environmental impact of the different systems. This
analysis will help in making an informed decision about the most suitable air conditioning and
chiller systems for the office building in West Kowloon, Hong Kong, considering factors such as
energy efficiency, performance, space availability, noise levels, maintenance requirements, and
environmental considerations.
 5.1. Data Evaluation and Comparison
Evaluation and comparison of the energy-saving and performance of air-cooled air conditioning
systems versus water-cooled air conditioning systems, as well as air-cooled chillers versus water-
cooled chillers.
1. Energy Efficiency:
Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System: The average Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER) is 3.2.
Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System: The average EER is 4.2.
Air-Cooled Chiller: The average Coefficient of Performance (COP) is 2.5.
Water-Cooled Chiller: The average COP is 3.8.
Comparison: Both the water-cooled air conditioning system and water-cooled chiller exhibit
higher energy efficiency ratios (EER and COP) compared to their air-cooled counterparts. This
indicates that the water-cooled systems are more energy-efficient and capable of delivering better
performance in terms of cooling output per unit of energy consumed.
2. Cooling Capacity:
Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System: The cooling capacity range is 200-400 refrigeration tons
(RT).
Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System: The cooling capacity range is 400-800 RT.
Air-Cooled Chiller: The cooling capacity range is 300-600 RT.
Water-Cooled Chiller: The cooling capacity range is 500-1000 RT.
Comparison: The water-cooled systems have a wider cooling capacity range compared to the air-
cooled systems. This provides more flexibility in terms of selecting a system that can meet the
cooling requirements of the XYZ Tower.
3. Space Requirement:
Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System: Outdoor condensing units require 30 square meters of
space.
Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System: Cooling towers, pumps, and water storage tanks require
70 square meters of space.
Comparison: Air-cooled air conditioning systems have a smaller space requirement compared to
water-cooled systems. This can be advantageous for buildings with limited outdoor space
availability.
4. Noise Level:
Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System: Produces a noise level of around 65-75 decibels (dB) at a
distance of 1 meter from the outdoor units.
Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System: Produces a noise level of around 50-60 decibels (dB) at
a distance of 1 meter from the building.
Comparison: Water-cooled air conditioning systems generate lower noise levels compared to air-
cooled systems. This can contribute to a more comfortable and quieter environment for building
occupants.
5. Maintenance and Lifespan:
Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System: Requires regular filter replacement and annual
maintenance. Lifespan is estimated at 10-15 years.
Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System: Requires maintenance of cooling towers, pumps, and
water treatment. Lifespan is estimated at 15-20 years.
Air-Cooled Chiller: Requires regular filter replacement and annual maintenance. Lifespan is
estimated at 10-15 years.
Water-Cooled Chiller: Requires maintenance of cooling towers, pumps, and water treatment.
Lifespan is estimated at 15-20 years.
Comparison: Both air-cooled and water-cooled systems require regular maintenance, but water-
cooled systems typically involve additional maintenance tasks for cooling towers, pumps, and
water treatment. However, water-cooled systems generally have a longer estimated lifespan
compared to air-cooled systems.
6. Environmental Impact:
Air-Cooled Air Conditioning System: Average electricity consumption is 1.5 kWh per
refrigeration ton (RT). Greenhouse gas emissions are 1.1 kilograms of CO2 equivalent (kgCO2e)
per kWh.
Water-Cooled Air Conditioning System: Average electricity consumption is 1.1 kWh per
refrigeration ton (RT). Greenhouse gas emissions are 0.7 kgCO2e per kWh. Water consumption
is 1.8 liters per refrigeration ton (RT).
Comparison: Water-cooled systems have lower electricity consumption and greenhouse gas
emissions per refrigeration ton compared to air-cooled systems. However, water-cooled systems
do require additional water consumption for operation.
Based on the evaluation and comparison, water-cooled air conditioning systems and water-
cooled chillers offer higher energy efficiency, wider cooling capacity ranges, and lower noise
levels compared to their air-cooled counterparts. However, they have larger space requirements
and involve additional maintenance tasks. Additionally, water-cooled systems have lower
electricity consumption and greenhouse gas emissions per refrigeration ton, but they require
water consumption.

5.2 DISCUSSION
the hypothetical data and its implications for the evaluation and comparison of air-cooled and
water-cooled air conditioning systems, as well as air-cooled and water-cooled chillers, in the
office building located in West Kowloon, Hong Kong.
1.Cooling Requirements:
The total cooling load for the 25 floors is 7500 refrigeration tons (RT), assuming an average
cooling load of 300 RT per floor. This information provides an understanding of the magnitude
of the cooling needs in the building.
2.Energy Efficiency:
The hypothetical data includes the average Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER) and Coefficient of
Performance (COP) for the different systems. The air-cooled air conditioning system has an EER
of 3.2, while the water-cooled air conditioning system has a higher EER of 4.2. Similarly, the
air-cooled chiller has a COP of 2.5, while the water-cooled chiller has a higher COP of 3.8. This
indicates that the water-cooled systems are more energy-efficient compared to the air-cooled
systems.
3.Cooling Capacity:
The cooling capacity ranges provided for the different systems give an idea of the flexibility in
meeting the cooling requirements of the building. The air-cooled air conditioning system has a
cooling capacity range of 200-400 RT, while the water-cooled air conditioning system has a
range of 400-800 RT. For chillers, the air-cooled chiller has a range of 300-600 RT, while the
water-cooled chiller has a range of 500-1000 RT. These ranges show the different options
available to match the cooling capacity needs of the building.
4.Space Requirement and Noise Level:
The space requirements and noise levels are important considerations for the installation and
operation of the systems. The air-cooled systems require a smaller space of 30 square meters for
outdoor condensing units, while the water-cooled systems need a larger space of 70 square
meters for cooling towers, pumps, and water storage tanks. In terms of noise levels, the air-
cooled systems have a higher noise level of around 65-75 decibels (dB) at a distance of 1 meter
from the outdoor units, while the water-cooled systems have a lower noise level of around 50-60
decibels (dB) at the same distance.
5.Maintenance and Lifespan:
The maintenance requirements and estimated lifespan of the systems are important factors for
long-term operation and cost considerations. The air-cooled systems require regular filter
replacement and annual maintenance, with an estimated lifespan of 10-15 years. On the other
hand, the water-cooled systems require regular maintenance of cooling towers, pumps, and water
treatment, with an estimated lifespan of 15-20 years. These differences in maintenance and
lifespan should be considered when selecting the appropriate system.
6.Environmental Impact:
The environmental impact of the systems is assessed based on their electricity consumption,
greenhouse gas emissions, and water consumption. The hypothetical data shows that the water-
cooled systems have lower electricity consumption per refrigeration ton (RT) compared to the
air-cooled systems. Additionally, the water-cooled systems have lower greenhouse gas emissions
per kWh and consume more water compared to the air-cooled systems. These environmental
considerations are essential for sustainable and eco-friendly building operations.
In conclusion, the hypothetical data provides insights into the energy-saving and performance
aspects of air-cooled and water-cooled air conditioning systems, as well as air-cooled and water-
cooled chillers. The data highlights the energy efficiency, cooling capacity, space requirements,
noise levels, maintenance, lifespan, and environmental impact of these systems. By considering
these factors, stakeholders can make informed decisions regarding the most suitable HVAC
systems for the office building in West Kowloon, Hong Kong, striking a balance between energy
efficiency, performance, space constraints, noise levels, maintenance requirements, and
environmental considerations.
6. Recommendations
Based on the evaluation and comparison of energy-saving and performance between air-cooled
and water-cooled air conditioning systems, as well as air-cooled and water-cooled chillers, in the
office building located in West Kowloon, Hong Kong, I can make the following
recommendations:
Energy Efficiency:
Water-Cooled Systems: The water-cooled air conditioning system and water-cooled chiller have
higher average energy efficiency ratios (EER and COP) compared to the air-cooled counterparts.
Therefore, it is recommended to consider the water-cooled systems for better energy efficiency
and performance.
Cooling Capacity:
Air-Cooled Systems: The air-cooled air conditioning system and air-cooled chiller have a lower
cooling capacity range compared to the water-cooled systems. If the cooling load of the building
requires a higher capacity, it is advisable to opt for water-cooled systems to meet the demand
effectively.
Space Requirement and Noise Level:
Air-Cooled Systems: The air-cooled systems require less space for outdoor condensing units
compared to the space required for cooling towers, pumps, and water storage tanks in water-
cooled systems. However, air-cooled systems generate higher noise levels compared to water-
cooled systems. Consider the available space and noise considerations when selecting the
appropriate system.
Maintenance and Lifespan:
Lifespan: Air-cooled systems have an estimated lifespan of 10-15 years, while water-cooled
systems have an estimated lifespan of 15-20 years. Take into account the long-term maintenance
requirements and lifespan when making a decision.
Environmental Impact:
Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Water-cooled systems have lower greenhouse gas emissions per
kWh of electricity consumed compared to air-cooled systems. Consider the environmental
impact and sustainability goals when choosing the system.
Based on these recommendations, it is advisable to prioritize water-cooled air conditioning
systems and water-cooled chillers due to their higher energy efficiency, larger cooling capacities,
lower noise levels, and lower greenhouse gas emissions.

7. Conclusion
Here is a conclusion based on the data provided for the evaluation and comparison of energy-
saving and performance between air-cooled and water-cooled air conditioning systems, as well
as air-cooled and water-cooled chillers, in an office building located in West Kowloon, Hong
Kong:
Based on the analysis of the data, the following conclusions can be drawn:
1.Energy Efficiency: Water-cooled systems, both air conditioning systems and chillers, exhibit
higher energy efficiency ratios (EER and COP) compared to air-cooled systems. This suggests
that water-cooled systems have the potential for greater energy savings and improved cooling
performance.
2.Cooling Capacity: Both air-cooled and water-cooled systems offer a wide range of cooling
capacities to accommodate different cooling loads in the office building. However, water-cooled
systems generally have a larger cooling capacity range, making them more suitable for larger
cooling loads or buildings with higher cooling demands.
3.Space Requirement: Air-cooled systems have a smaller space requirement compared to water-
cooled systems, as they only require space for the outdoor condensing units. This makes air-
cooled systems more suitable for areas with limited space availability, providing more flexibility
in installation and utilization of space within the office building.
4.Noise Level: Water-cooled systems generate lower noise levels compared to air-cooled
systems. This is advantageous in office buildings where noise pollution can negatively impact
the working environment. Water-cooled systems provide a quieter and more comfortable
environment for occupants.
5.Environmental Impact: Water-cooled systems generally consume less electricity per unit of
cooling capacity compared to air-cooled systems, resulting in potential energy and greenhouse
gas emissions savings. However, water-cooled systems consume more water due to the operation
of cooling towers. The water consumption should be considered in water-scarce areas like Hong
Kong, weighing the environmental impact and availability of water resources.
In summary, water-cooled systems offer higher energy efficiency, larger cooling capacities, and
lower noise levels compared to air-cooled systems. However, air-cooled systems have the
advantage of smaller space requirements, making them more suitable for areas with limited space
availability. The environmental impact, including electricity consumption and water usage,
should be carefully evaluated based on local considerations and sustainability goals.

7 References
Lee, W.L., Chen, H. and Yik, F.W.H., 2008. Modeling the performance characteristics of water-cooled air-
conditioners. Energy and Buildings, 40(8), pp.1456-1465.

Chen, H., Lee, W.L. and Yik, F.W.H., 2008. Applying water cooled air conditioners in residential buildings
in Hong Kong. Energy Conversion and Management, 49(6), pp.1416-1423.

Yang, J., Chan, K.T., Wu, X., Yu, F.W. and Yang, X., 2012. An analysis on the energy efficiency of air-
cooled chillers with water mist system. Energy and Buildings, 55, pp.273-284.

Suri, R.K., Al-Marafie, A.M.R. and Maheshwari, G.P., 1989. Water-cooled air-conditioning systems for
energy and power saving. International journal of ambient energy, 10(3), pp.123-128.

Zou, S., Zhang, Q. and Yue, C., 2023. Comparative study on different energy-saving plans using water-
side economizer to retrofit the computer room air conditioning system. Journal of Building
Engineering, 69, p.106278.

Han, Z., Sun, X., Wei, H., Ji, Q. and Xue, D., 2021. Energy saving analysis of evaporative cooling
composite air conditioning system for data centers. Applied Thermal Engineering, 186, p.116506.

Yik, F.W.H., Burnett, J. and Prescott, I., 2001. A study on the energy performance of three schemes for
widening application of water-cooled air-conditioning systems in Hong Kong. Energy and Buildings, 33(2),
pp.167-182.

Kabeel, A.E., El-Samadony, Y.A.F. and Khiera, M.H., 2017. Performance evaluation of energy efficient
evaporatively air-cooled chiller. Applied Thermal Engineering, 122, pp.204-213.

Vakiloroaya, V., Samali, B., Fakhar, A. and Pishghadam, K., 2014. A review of different strategies for
HVAC energy saving. Energy conversion and management, 77, pp.738-754.

Zhang, X., Xu, G., Chan, K.T. and Yi, X., 2006. A novel energy-saving method for air-cooled chiller plant
by parallel connection. Applied thermal engineering, 26(16), pp.2012-2019.

Zhang, H., Feng, X. and Wang, Y., 2018. Comparison and evaluation of air cooling and water cooling in
resource consumption and economic performance. Energy, 154, pp.157-167.

Vakiloroaya, V., Samali, B., Fakhar, A. and Pishghadam, K., 2014. A review of different
strategies for HVAC energy saving. Energy conversion and management, 77, pp.738-754.
Vakiloroaya, V., Samali, B. and Pishghadam, K., 2014. A comparative study on the effect of
different strategies for energy saving of air-cooled vapor compression air conditioning
systems. Energy and Buildings, 74, pp.163-172.