Name: Cristy Ann V. Jayoma Date: July 22, 2021 Course: Educ - 207 Activity 2.1: Discuss The Criticisms Directed Towards GTM: Cite RRL To Support Your Answer
GTM : Translation, Memorization -Students master 1-Speaking or oral
Grammar of rules and vocabulary grammar communication is Translation items, deductive teaching -Students develop neglected Method of grammar, use of L1, reading and writing 2- not all teachers reading activities. skills. are good at -Students acquire a translating and large number of don’t know lexis via students’ L1. memorization.
DM : Direct Demonstration, miming, 1-fluency 1-fluency over
Method use of visuals, SSTMR, use 2-facilitates the accuracy of the target language, learning of 2-focuses on inductive teaching of vocabulary items. speaking and grammar, modeling. 3-makes the listening and process of learning neglects other enjoyable to skills. students. 3-demanding on teachers; they are supposed to have native-like accent and be fluent Behaviorism AL : Drills( Substitution, chain, 1-oral use of 1-mechanical drills Audiolingualis choral, backward), language is are m repetition ,inductive emphasized. counter-productiv teaching of grammar, use of 2- the skill of e (drill and kill dialogues, PPP. listening is exercises) developed. 2-meaning is 3-all students are neglected (blind engaged in the repetition of process of learning. words or sentences) 3- writing is not given its due attention Communicative Oral practice and Students develop -Only everyday language production, “presentation, communicative language is taught, teaching controlled practice , free skills. while other forms practice “ interactive Students practice of language are activities, group work , WH language in not taught questions. real-like life Grammar is not situations. systematically taught Writing and reading are overlooked Humanistic Community Translation, inductive 1-students learn 1-not all teachers approach language teaching of grammar, social and are good learning repetition, transcription, communicative translators reflection, group work. skills. (teachers may not 2- students’ know the mother inhibitions are tongue of the lowered.(promotin students) g favorable 2-time-consuming. environment for 3-fluency over learning to take accuracy. place) 3-generates independent students. The silent way Rods, coloured cards, 1-less TTT 1-to avoid pronounciation charts, less 2-students develop teacher-centered TTT, giving cues, non-verbal pronunciation (90% instructions, communication. they speak) things may go to 3-self-satisfication the other extreme (students need some directions) 2- time-consuming (Ss may struggle to understand a word for a while, whereas it can be explained easily by the teacher). 3-not all students are highly motivated. Suggestopedia Music, fine arts , visual 1-creates favorable 1-lacks flexibility aids, relaxation climate for the (not applicable to learning to occur. all classes) 2-students feel at 2-lacks tests ease. 3-negligence of 3-students increase grammar. their abilities.
Total physical Miming, commands, 1-comprehension is 1-cannot be used
response games, minimum verbal immediate and to explain abstract communication. easy. notions or 2-long-term concepts. retention (trace 2-students don’t theory) express 3-learning is fun themselves, they and enjoyable since only respond to it involves commands of the movements and teacher. games. 3-challenging for shy students. Task based Tasks, group work, 1-students become 1-Risk of achieving learning interactive activities. independent. fluency over (strategy) 2-students develop accuracy. social and 2-students may communicative not be committed skills. to the task or may 3-Increases use L1 while doing students’ intrinsic so. motivation 3- It may not be applicable to large classes Project based Group work, projects, -promotes learners’ -lack of resources learning guidance, presentations. autonomy. or knowledge of -boosts their the use of affects (self-esteem resources and (students may not self-confidence) know how to use -useful for mixed computers) abilities classes. - time-consuming -Be prepared for real-life situations -be creative Standards based Dialogues, discussions, -promotes learners’ -communities and approach speaking activities, tasks, independence. communication projects. -encourage oral use may not be of language. achieved. -prepares students - some students for real situations. don’t have the means to communicate, especially poor ones.
Name: Cristy Ann V. Jayoma Date: July 22, 2021 Course: Educ - 207 Activity 2.1: Discuss The Criticisms Directed Towards GTM: Cite RRL To Support Your Answer