Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ebook Essentials of Business Law PDF Full Chapter PDF
Ebook Essentials of Business Law PDF Full Chapter PDF
PDF
Visit to download the full and correct content document:
https://ebooksecure.com/download/essentials-of-business-law-ebook-pdf/
Download Complete eBook By email at discountsmtb@hotmail.com
Final PDF to printer
ESSENTIALS OF
BUSINESS LAW
Eleventh Edition
The Internet addresses listed in the text were accurate at the time of publication. The inclusion of a website does
not indicate an endorsement by the authors or McGraw Hill LLC, and McGraw Hill LLC does not guarantee the
accuracy of the information presented at these sites.
mheducation.com/highered
Dedication
To our faculty colleagues at Wilkes University
who, for so many years, have
provided us with support,
encouragement and friendship
Audrey Hepburn,
actress and humanitarian
AUTHORS
ABOUT OUR
Anthony L. Liuzzo, J.D., MBA, Ph.D. Dr. Anthony L. Liuzzo is Professor Emeritus at
Wilkes University where he served as Professor of Business and Economics and Chairper-
son of the Business Programs of Arizona.
Dr. Liuzzo is a licensed attorney and economist. He earned his PhD in business
administration, Master of Philosophy in economics, and MBA in management and orga-
nizational behavior from New York University; his law degree from St. John’s University;
and his bachelor’s degree in marketing from Fordham University in New York City.
Specializing in public policy issues, employment law, and holiday retail sales fore-
casting, he has been cited on numerous occasions in hundreds of publications—including
Courtesy of Anthony L. Liuzzo CNN, Fox News, Forbes, The New York Times, USA Today, the Arizona Republic, the New
York Daily News, the Philadelphia Daily News, the Chicago Tribune, the Washington Times,
the Cincinnati Enquirer, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the Detroit News, the Christian Science
Monitor, and the San Francisco Examiner—for his views on legal and business issues.
Dr. Liuzzo has been the author of several editions of the popular textbook, Essentials
of Business Law, and its accompanying assessment materials, mobile applications, and
instructor’s manual, published by McGraw-Hill.
Dr. Liuzzo is also the author of several books and numerous articles that
have appeared in scholarly and professional journals. He has served as editor of
a scholarly journal and has been instrumental in creating several successful small
businesses.
Dr. Liuzzo has testified as an expert witness in numerous civil and criminal
trials and has appeared before state legislatures for his insights into pending regu-
lations. He is an active member of many professional and community organiza-
©David B. Moore Photography tions and has served as a member and officer of several boards of directors.
Ruth Calhoun Hughes, J.D. Ruth Hughes serves as Associate Professor of Business
Law at Wilkes University in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania.
Hughes is a licensed attorney and received her JD from Washington and Lee Uni-
versity in Lexington, Virginia, and her BA in economics from Tulane University in New
Orleans, Louisiana.
She began her career as an attorney specializing in corporate transactions in New
York City and Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania. She was director of the Small Business
Development Center in Wilkes-Barre for many years before joining the faculty of the Sidhu
School of Business and Leadership at Wilkes University in 2013.
Her research interests, publications, and presentations include the areas of environ-
Courtesy of Ruth Hughes mental sustainability in business, equity crowdfunding, and emerging trends in securities
laws. She serves as a reviewer for several academic publications.
Hughes is an active member of many university, professional and community organi-
zations. She is married to Richard Hughes and the proud mother of three children, Callie,
Ellen, and Richard.
iv
Brief
CONTENTS
Preface xxiii
part 4 Commercial Paper 327
A Guided Tour xxx
Acknowledgment xxviii
22 Introduction to Commercial Paper 328
23 Transfer and Discharge
part 1 Introduction to Law 1 of Commercial Paper 347
4 Tort Law 48
25 Bailments 385
5 Constitutional Law 66
26 Landlord–Tenant Relations 399
6 Administrative Law 83
27 Wills, Intestacy, and Trusts 415
part 2 Contracts 97
part 6 Business and Technology 429
7 Introduction to Contracts 98
28 Intellectual Property 430
10 Consideration 142
31 Conducting Business in Cyberspace 478
Contents
Preface xxiii 2 Ethics and the Law 18
A Guided Tour xxx
Acknowledgment xxviii 2.1 UNETHICAL BEHAVIOR IN OUR WORLD 19
part 1 Introduction to Law 1 2.3 THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LAW AND ETHICS 20
CHAPTER 1 ASSESSMENT 11
Matching Legal Terms 11
True/False Quiz 12
Discussion Questions 13
Thinking Critically about the Law 14
Case Questions 15 ©Ingram Publishing RF
Case Analysis 16
Legal Research 17
vi
Contents vii
Unavoidable Accident 55
3 Criminal Law 32
The “Reasonable Person” 55
3.1 CRIME 33 Kinds of Negligence 55
4.8 LIABILITY 57
3.2 CLASSIFICATION OF CRIMES 33
Vicarious Liability 57
Treason 34 Strict Liability 57
Felony 34
Misdemeanor 34 CHAPTER SUMMARY 59
4 Tort Law 48
4.1 THE NATURE OF TORTS 49
4.2 DEFAMATION 49
4.5 NUISANCE 53
4.6 CONVERSION 53
©Tetra Images/CORBIS
4.7 NEGLIGENCE 54
viii Contents
5.2 THE COMMERCE CLAUSE, THE FULL FAITH 6.5 SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES BETWEEN
AND CREDIT CLAUSE, AND THE SUPREMACY CLAUSE 68 ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCIES AND GOVERNMENTS 88
Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3: The Commerce Clause 68 Similarities 88
Article IV, Section 1: The Full Faith and Credit Clause 69 Differences 88
Article VI, Clause 2: The Supremacy Clause 69
6.6 CRITICISM OF ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCIES 90
5.3 THE FIRST AMENDMENT 69
The Establishment and Free Exercise Clauses CHAPTER SUMMARY 91
Relating to Religion 69
Freedom of Speech 70 CHAPTER 6 ASSESSMENT 91
Freedom of the Press 71 Matching Legal Terms 91
5.4 THE SECOND AMENDMENT 71 True/False Quiz 91
Discussion Questions 92
Thinking Critically about the Law 93
5.5 THE FOURTH AMENDMENT 72
Case Questions 93
Case Analysis 94
5.6 THE FIFTH AMENDMENT 72 Legal Research 96
©Stockbyte/Getty Images RF
Contents ix
x Contents
CHAPTER 9 ASSESSMENT 136 11.3 LIABILITY FOR MINORS’ TORTS AND CRIMES 161
Matching Legal Terms 136
True/False Quiz 136 11.4 CONTRACTS OF THE MENTALLY INCOMPETENT 161
Discussion Questions 137 Contracts of Persons Affected by Drugs or Alcohol 162
Thinking Critically about the Law 138
Case Questions 138 CHAPTER SUMMARY 163
Case Analysis 139
Legal Research 141 CHAPTER 11 ASSESSMENT 163
Matching Legal Terms 163
10 Consideration 142 True/False Quiz 164
Discussion Questions 165
10.1 THE NATURE OF CONSIDERATION 143 Thinking Critically about the Law 166
Case Questions 166
10.2 CHARACTERISTICS OF VALID CONSIDERATION 143 Case Analysis 167
Legal Research 169
Legality of Consideration 143
Adequacy of Consideration 144
Possibility of Performance 144 12 Legal Purpose of Contracts 170
10.3 KINDS OF VALID CONSIDERATION 144
12.1 LEGALITY AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST 171
A Promise for a Promise 144
Classification of Illegal Agreements 171
A Promise of Forbearance 145
Effect of Illegality 171
A Pledge or Subscription 145
10.4 CONSIDERATION AND THE 12.2 AGREEMENTS IN VIOLATION OF STATUTES 171
UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE 146 Agreements Made on Sundays or Legal Holidays 171
Gambling and Wagering Agreements 172
10.5 GENERAL RELEASE 146 Usurious Agreements 172
Unlicensed Transactions 173
10.6 AGREEMENTS THAT LACK CONSIDERATION 147
12.3 AGREEMENTS AGAINST PUBLIC POLICY 173
Barren Promises 147
Agreements That Obstruct or Pervert Justice 173
Gratuitous Promises 147
Agreements That Restrain Marriage 174
Illusory Promises 148
Agreements That Interfere with Public Service 174
Agreements Supported by Moral Consideration 148
Agreements to Defraud Creditors and Other Persons 175
Agreements Supported by Past Consideration 148
Exculpatory Clauses 175
CHAPTER SUMMARY 149
Contents xi
12.4 ILLEGAL RESTRAINTS OF TRADE 175 14.2 RIGHTS OF THIRD PARTIES 199
Sherman Antitrust Act 176 Third-Party Beneficiaries 199
Robinson-Patman Act 176 Incidental Beneficiaries 199
12.5 LEGAL RESTRAINTS OF TRADE 177 14.3 ASSIGNMENT OF RIGHTS 200
Government-Granted Monopolies 177 Form of Assignment 200
Private Franchises 177 Notice of Assignment 201
Zoning Regulations 177 Rights That May Be Transferred 201
Environmental and Safety Regulations 177 The Assignor’s Guaranty 201
CHAPTER SUMMARY 178 14.4 CONTRACTS THAT MAY NOT BE ASSIGNED 201
Contracts That Include Assignment Restrictions 202
CHAPTER 12 ASSESSMENT 178 Contracts for Which Assignments Are
Matching Legal Terms 178 Prohibited by Law or Public Policy 202
True/False Quiz 179 Contracts That Require Personal Services 202
Discussion Questions 180
14.5 DELEGATION OF DUTIES 202
Thinking Critically about the Law 180
Case Questions 181
Case Analysis 182 14.6 ASSIGNMENT AND DELEGATION BY LAW 203
Legal Research 183 Death of a Contracting Party 203
Bankruptcy of a Contracting Party 204
13 Form of Contracts 184 14.7 NOVATION 204
xii Contents
part 3 Sales, Agency, and Business 17.3 ORAL, WRITTEN, EXPRESS, AND
IMPLIED CONTRACTS 249
Organizations 231
Contents xiii
17.9 REMEDIES FOR BREACH OF SALES CONTRACTS 254 Who May Appoint an Agent 280
Who May Be Appointed as an Agent 280
Sellers’ Remedies 254
Buyers’ Remedies 255 19.2 CLASSES OF AGENTS 281
xiv Contents
CHAPTER 19 ASSESSMENT 290 21.4 CHAPTER 7 OF THE FEDERAL BANKRUPTCY LAW 314
Matching Legal Terms 290
True/False Quiz 290 21.5 CHAPTER 13 OF THE FEDERAL BANKRUPTCY LAW 317
Discussion Questions 291
Thinking Critically about the Law 292 21.6 CHAPTERS 9, 11, 12, AND 15 OF THE
Case Questions 293 FEDERALBANKRUPTCY LAW 318
Case Analysis 294 Chapter 9 318
Legal Research 295 Chapter 11 318
Chapter 12 319
Chapter 15 319
20 Business Organizations 296
CHAPTER SUMMARY 320
20.1 ORGANIZATIONAL FORMS 297
CHAPTER 21 ASSESSMENT 320
20.2 SOLE PROPRIETORSHIP 297
Matching Legal Terms 320
Advantages of a Sole Proprietorship 297 True/False Quiz 321
Disadvantages of a Sole Proprietorship 297 Discussion Questions 322
Thinking Critically about the Law 323
20.3 PARTNERSHIP 298
Case Questions 323
Advantages of a Partnership 298 Case Analysis 324
Disadvantages of a Partnership 299 Legal Research 326
Limited Partnership 299
part 4
Limited Liability Partnership 300
20.4 CORPORATION 300 Commercial Paper 327
Contents xv
xvi Contents
24 Real and Personal Property 366 25.3 KINDS OF BAILMENTS AND CARE
DURING CUSTODY 388
24.1 CHARACTERISTICS OF PROPERTY 367 Bailments for the Sole Benefit of the Bailee 388
Bailments for the Sole Benefit of the Bailor 388
24.2 DISTINCTION BETWEEN REAL AND Mutual-Benefit Bailments 389
PERSONAL PROPERTY 367 Constructive Bailments 391
Real Property 367 CHAPTER SUMMARY 392
Personal Property 367
Real Property Can Become Personal Property 367
CHAPTER 25 ASSESSMENT 392
Personal Property Can Become Real Property 367
Matching Legal Terms 392
24.3 ACQUIRING TITLE TO PERSONAL PROPERTY 368 True/False Quiz 393
Finding Lost Personal Property 368 Discussion Questions 394
Abandoned Property 369 Thinking Critically about the Law 395
Gifts 369 Case Questions 395
Accession 371 Case Analysis 396
Legal Research 398
24.4 OWNERSHIP OF REAL OR
PERSONAL PROPERTY 371
Severalty Ownership 371
26 Landlord–Tenant Relations 399
Multiple Ownership 371
26.1 THE LANDLORD–TENANT RELATIONSHIP 400
24.5 REAL PROPERTY 372 The Difference between a Lease and a License 400
Land 372 Essential Elements of the Landlord–Tenant Relationship 400
Buildings and Fixtures 373 The Lease Is the Basis of the Relationship 400
Rights in Land Other Than Ownership 373 26.2 TYPES OF TENANT INTERESTS IN
24.6 INTERESTS IN REAL PROPERTY 374 REAL PROPERTY 401
25 Bailments 385
25.1 BAILMENT DEFINED 386 ©Ingram Publishing RF
Contents xvii
26.3 RIGHTS AND DUTIES OF THE PARTIES 402 Matching Legal Terms 422
True/False Quiz 423
Landlord’s Warranty of Habitability 402 Discussion Questions 424
Landlord’s Right to Rent, to Regain Possession, Thinking Critically about the Law 424
to Evict, and to Retain a Tenant’s Security Deposit 403
Case Questions 425
Landlord’s Right to Keep Fixtures and Permanent Case Analysis 426
Improvements 404 Legal Research 428
Landlord’s Duty to Mitigate Damages 404
Tenant’s Right to Quiet Enjoyment 404
Tenant’s Right to Acquire and Retain Possession
Tenant’s Right to Assign or Sublease
405
405 part 6 Business and Technology 429
xviii Contents
Contents xix
part 7
Rights of the Employer 517
Legal Environment of Business 494 33.4 ADDITIONAL EMPLOYEE RIGHTS 517
Family and Medical Leave Act 517
xx Contents
34.1 PRODUCT LIABILITY AND TORT LAW 526 CHAPTER 35 ASSESSMENT 548
Matching Legal Terms 548
34.2 BASES FOR PRODUCT LIABILITY INJURY CLAIMS 526
True/False Quiz 549
Product Flaw 526 Discussion Questions 550
Failure to Warn 527 Thinking Critically about the Law 551
Design Defect 527 Case Questions 551
Case Analysis 552
34.3 WHO CAN BE HELD LIABLE FOR
PRODUCT-RELATEDINJURIES? 527 Legal Research 554
Contents xxi
xxii Contents
©peterspiro/Getty Images RF
Preface
WELCOME TO ESSENTIALS OF BUSINESS LAW
The new, eleventh edition of the Essentials of Business Law program is a practical, concise,
and broad-based introduction to the vibrant field of business law. While continuing to offer
all of the features that have made the ten prior editions successful, this new edition includes
a chapter on the areas of law affected by social media, updated content, and enhanced
support materials. Both the traditional areas of law, such as contracts and property, and
the emerging areas of law, such as e-commerce and environmental, are covered in short,
informative chapters written to capture the essence of each topic. The objective of the text
throughout its coverage is ease—ease of use, ease of teaching, ease of assessment, and ease
of understanding. It has been developed for those seeking a more fundamental overview of
the concepts and principles that are vital to the understanding of business law.
NOTE TO STUDENTS
The eleventh edition of Essentials of Business Law covers the latest developments in the legal
field. This text will help you discover a wealth of information and learning opportunities
that will give you a clear understanding of business law topics. The text will also help you
identify, explain, and apply the principles of business law in your daily life and in the larger
world in which you live. The world of business is continually changing, especially with the
advent and evolution of the global marketplace. The concepts and principles presented in
the text will assist you in understanding those changes as they relate to business law.
The chapters in Essentials of Business Law are organized in a concise and easy-to-read
way. Numerous examples applying the law to real-world situations will assist you in under-
standing important concepts, whereas key term definitions are provided throughout the text
for your reference. The end-of-chapter assessments will help you apply your knowledge and
gauge your understanding of the material as you progress, and the extra resources accom-
panying the text will provide useful and easy-to-use tools to supplement your appreciation
of the material.
NOTE TO INSTRUCTORS
What sets Essentials of Business Law apart from other programs available is its concise organi-
zational nature and supplementary materials. Chapters are succinct, making it simple for you
to plan presentations and teach the course. Each chapter offers an abundance of assessment
tools that will help you evaluate your students’ progress. The new edition offers expanded
coverage of current or emerging areas in the business law field, including legal ethics and laws
applying to social media, e-commerce and health care law. In addition, the number of key terms
has been increased to include both legal and nonlegal definitions. As a result, Essentials of Busi-
ness Law offers you and your students the coverage of essential topics that many larger, more
expensive book programs miss entirely. The eleventh edition has been expanded and updated
to include a variety of teaching tools that make it simple for you to organize your classroom
xxiii
xxiv Preface
discussions, effectively communicate the important business law concepts in each chapter,
and assess your students’ grasp of the material. The book is accompanied by an Instructor
Resource Center, complete with an Instructor’s Manual, a Test Bank, and PowerPoint slides
for each chapter. Each tool makes planning and teaching the course easier than ever.
CHAPTER 2
Ethics and the Law has been revised with a different code of ethics example
CHAPTER 3
Criminal Law has been revised.
New to this chapter:
• A distinction drawn between federal and state crimes. Two figures (3.1 and 3.2)
added, providing the reader with 20 examples of federal crimes and 20 examples of
state crimes.
• Question 30 changed to reflect inclusion of the new material relating to federal crimes.
CHAPTER 4
Tort Law has been updated to incorporate posting on social media, and the relationship of
assumption of risk to negligence has been clarified.
New to this chapter:
• Inclusion of the number of states applying contributory negligence versus compara-
tive negligence.
CHAPTER 5
Constitutional Law has been revised to incorporate an updated Example 5.1 relating to the
doctrine of preemption.
New to this chapter:
• A new Example 5.10 covering the Fourteenth Amendment’s application to same-sex
marriage.
CHAPTER 7
Introduction to Contracts has been substantially revised to incorporate new technology
relating to the creation of contracts. It has also been updated to include current technology,
non-offensive terminology, and a new photo.
Preface xxv
CHAPTER 8
Offer and Acceptance has been modified to include the term “postal acceptance rule,” and
the mailbox rule has been updated to address voicemail, email, faxes, and text messaging.
CHAPTER 10
Consideration has been revised to include updated terminology and technology in Example
10.2. Also, Example 10.5 has been corrected and clarified.
CHAPTER 12
Legal Purpose of Contracts has added coverage relating to online gambling. In addition,
Example 12.11 has been rewritten for clarification.
CHAPTER 15
Discharge of Contracts has a modified opening quotation and a new photo. In addition,
Chapter Summary 15.8 has been modified to be more concise.
New to this chapter:
• A substantially revised Section 15.8 offering expanded coverage of Federal Trade
Commission regulations and the Truth in Lending Act.
• A new section entitled Punitive Damages and a new legal term.
• A new section entitled Liquidated Damages Clause, in which the definition of “pen-
alty or forfeiture” has been incorporated.
• Incorporation in the Assessment section of one new and two revised questions con-
sistent with the new coverage.
CHAPTER 16
Transfer of Title has been updated to include digital bills of sale.
New to this chapter:
• Revised question 47 in the Assessments.
CHAPTER 17
Changed opening quote and minor revisions to assessments
New to this chapter:
• Added Critical Thinking question 33 about software as “goods” under Article 2.
CHAPTER 20
Business Organizations has minor updates.
xxvi Preface
CHAPTER 21
Chapter 21 has been renamed Creditor’s Rights and Bankruptcy and has been substan-
tially revised to include an explanation of credits rights under Article 9 of the Uniform
Commercial Code.
New to this chapter:
• New Section 21.2, Creditor’s Rights, with corresponding learning outcome and chap-
ter summary.
• Streamlined chapter by eliminating separate section on the 2005 changes to the
Bankruptcy Code and incorporated those changes into the relevant sections.
• Added a Matching Legal Term on perfection.
• Eliminated Critical Thinking question on Chapter 9 Municipal Bankruptcy and
added a question on priority of state claims as new question 36.
CHAPTER 24
Updated quote at beginning of chapter
CHAPTER 26
Landlord–Tenant Relations has been revised to clarify the landlord’s right to keep fixtures
on termination of lease.
New to this chapter:
• New example 26.6. added to demonstrate the landlord’s right to keep fixtures.
CHAPTER 28
Intellectual Property had only minor changes in Assessments.
New to this chapter:
• Revised question 39, Working in Teams, to focus on trade names and generic use.
CHAPTER 29
Computer Privacy and Speech had minor updates.
New to this chapter:
• Updated Section 29.1, Computer Privacy, to include data privacy concerns.
• Changed question 31 in Question of Ethics to address data privacy instead of public
figures and privacy.
CHAPTER 32
The Employer–Employee Relationship had minor revisions in Section 32.3 to clarify that
employment at will cannot be exercised in contravention of an employment contract.
Preface xxvii
CHAPTER 33
Employment Law has been substantially revised to explain the methods of proving Title VII
discrimination
New to this chapter:
• Section 33.2 now gives a summary of the four methods of proving discrimination,
direct evidence, express policy, disparate treatment, and disparate impact.
• Three new examples were added to this chapter: example 33.6 for express policy,
example 33.7 for disparate treatment, and 33.8 for disparate impact.
• The subsection on Sexual Harassment was streamlined to contain a more consistent
level of detail with the other subsections by eliminating the detail on elements of a
sexual harassment program.
• Section 33.3 added an explanation of employees’ right to concerted action under
Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act.
CHAPTER 34
Product Liability had only minor editorial changes.
CHAPTER 36
The opening quote for International Business Law was changed, and the chapter was
updated to reflect updated status of treaties and international organizations.
New to this chapter:
• Section 36.4 updated to explain the current renegotiation of NAFTA.
• The list of European Union members was updated to eliminate the United Kingdom
with a corresponding explanation of status in the text.
CHAPTER 37
Business and the Environment had minor updates and changes.
New to this chapter:
• Section 37.7 was updated to include the phase out of chlorofluorocarbons
• Table 37.1 was deleted.
SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS
The Constitution of the United States can be found in the Appendix.
Acknowledgments
xxviii
Acknowledgments xxix
Finally, this content was but a raw, unsold manuscript until the skilled publishing team
refined it. Our manuscript benefited immeasurably from the guidance of the multiple levels
of skill provided to us by McGraw Hill. We respect and honor our Managing Director, Tim
Vertovec; Executive Portfolio Manager, Kathleen Klehr; Product Developer, Allie Kukla;
Marketing Manager, Claire McLemore; and its Content Project Managers, Fran Simon and
Katie Reuter.
Our System
TOUR
A GUIDED
of Law
L E A R N I N G O U TC O M E S
After studying this chapter and completing the assessment, you will be able to
The eleventh edition of Essentials of Business Law is designed to ensure that students will not
1.1 Discuss the application of law in today’s world.
only learn fundamental applications of business law, but also will be able to put those basics
1.2 Provide examples of how the application of law affects (a) one’s personal or social life, (b) business or business
into practice after reading a multitude of real-world examples and performing several skill
operations, and (c) governments.
assessment activities.
1.3 Identify the principal sources of law in the United States.
1.4 Explain the reasons for the preparation of the Uniform Commercial Code.
1.5 Cite and describe the major classifications of law.
“A concise,1.6
wellDistinguish
written, moral
introduction into Business Law
law from legal obligations.
that focuses1.7on Describe
essential knowledge regarding the vari-
the structure of our federal and state court systems.
ous topics. An excellent textbook for college students
embarking into the subject of Business Law.”
—Fran Tannenbaum, Northern Virginia
Community College: Woodbridge Campus
OUR SYSTEM OF LAW
terms Confirming Pages
“As long as I have any
plaintiff ordinance
choice, I will stay only
LEGAL
CHAPTER OPENINGdefendant
QUOTE administrative law
in a country where
chapter 1
Each chapter opens with a lighthearted
stare decisis Uniform Commercial
but thoughtful quote.
common lawquotes Code
The come(UCC) political liberty, tolera-
from a variety of moral law
sources, including
precedent tion, and equality of
case law
famous judges, lawyers, jurisdiction
entertainers, and all citizens before the
businesspeople. statutory law law are the rule.”
Albert Einstein,
Our System
noted scientist
of Law
Rubberball/Getty Images
2
L E A R N I N G O U TC O M E S
After studying this chapter and completing the assessment, you will be able to LEARNING OUTCOMES
1.1 Discuss the application of law in today’s world.
Learning Outcomes outline the focus of the
1.2 chapteror business
Provide examples of how the application of law affects (a) one’s personal or social life, (b) business and provide a roadmap for the mate-
operations, and (c) governments. rial ahead. Each is tied directly to a main head-
1.3 Identify the principal sources of law in the United States. ing in the chapter, as well as a corresponding
1.4 Explain the reasons for the preparation of the Uniform Commercial Code. Chapter Summary point, to help reiterate im-
1.5 Cite and describe the major classifications of law. portant topics throughout.
1.6 Distinguish moral law from legal obligations.
1.7 Describe the structure of our federal and state court systems.
xxx
OUR SYSTEM OF LAW
terms “As long as I have any
plaintiff ordinance
choice, I will stay only
LEGAL
OUR SY
LEGAL TERMS
Legal Terms are identified at the beginning of each terms Confirming Pages “As long
chapter, as well as in the margins where they first appear
plaintiff ordinance
choice, I
LEGAL
in the text. They offer expanded coverage to ensure stu-
dents are comfortable with the language after complet- defendant administrative law
stare decisis Uniform Commercial
in a coun
ing the course.
Chapter 2 Ethics and the Law 19
common law Code (UCC)
Confirming
political l
Pages
The news abounds with examples of unethical behavior in business, including poor treatment
statutory law
The federal government and many states have statutes that protect whistleblowers from retali-
law are th
of employees, using insider information for personal gain, violation of consumer interests,
ation. Still, with the possible exception of certain individuals who may have a personal grudge,
and environmental damage from operations. the usual motivation behind whistleblowing is the outrage to a person’s sense of ethics.
The federal government has now enacted programs to encourage whistleblowing by
providing financial incentives for doing so. For example, the Securities and Exchange
EXAMPLE 2.1 EXAMPLES
Commission, in an effort to enhance its reputation, has established a program to reward
whistleblowers with a percentage of penalties imposed. The Internal Revenue Service also
BP Oil operated a drilling facility in the Gulf of Mexico that exploded, killing 11 workers and cre- Examples throughout the chapter
has a similar program to reward the reporting of illegal tax activities.
ating a devastating oil spill that had an enormous negative impact on the ecosystem of the Gulf.
INTEGRATION OF ETHICS INTO BUSINESS help students understand concepts
AND GOVERNMENT
BP Oil was accused of using shortcuts in its well capping system and also appears to have had Rubberball/Gett
an inadequate response system in place for the spill. 2 in a real-world context. Each cre-
In the abstract, there is agreement that business should be conducted in ways that will not
harm the consumer or the environment. What is the most effective way to achieve this? The
ates
corporation may indeed adhere to the highest a scenario
ethical practices, but athat tiesexecutive
new chief directly to a
officer (CEO) or board of directors may discontinue those practices if they reduce prof-
CHAPTER SUMMARIES
technology. The expansion of global markets also ing programs. Governments enact legislation and
2.2
raises some ethical predicaments for business create programs to protect consumers and the envi-
professionals.
MORALS, ETHICS,
Chapter Summaries AND VALUES
correspond to particular per- ronment and to ensure ethical behavior of business
2.2 Morals are concerned with an individual person’s firms and the government itself. Trade and profes-
formance objectives and chapter headings, making beliefs as to right and wrong. Ethics is about sional associations develop guidelines for business
and professional members.
While morals, ethics and values may seem synonymous, the three terms have different the standards and principles for the behavior of
quick reference and retention of key concepts easy.
meanings. individuals within a society. Values are beliefs or
standards considered worthwhile.
2.5 Some ways business can ensure ethical prac-
tices include integrating corporate codes of ethics
Morals are individual and societal beliefs as to what is right and wrong. Ethics consist
2.3 Legalmorals
mandates are imposed on individuals or and relying on whistleblowers. Corporate codes
of the standards and principles that govern the behavior of individuals within a society. groups Beliefs about behavior as judged
by authorities or governments. In con- of ethics vary from one firm or industry to
by society.
Both ethics and morals derive from values—that is, the beliefs or standards that underlie an trast, ethical considerations generally spring from another. Whistleblowing is the exposing of an
individual and society’s beliefs. within individuals or organizations. However,
ethics unethical situation to an authority or the media.
Individual and group values are influenced by religion, traditions, and customs. Values The philosophical study of
what is right and wrong, good
may be influenced by a variety of factors from one’s culture—those of a nation or an ethnic and bad.
group. The American culture, for example, holds that such characteristics as freedom, indi-
vidualism, family life, fair play, hard work, and honesty are important. On the other hand, values
liu34544_ch02_018-031.indd 25 06/08/20 08:17 PM
xxxi
Beliefs or standards considered
the values held by a subculture—for example, employees of a corporation or a department worthwhile, and from which a
within a company—may differ from those of the larger culture. society derives its moral rules.
TOUR
1.2 Examples of how the application of law affects a
A GUIDED
is a set of laws that govern various commercial
person’s personal and social life can be seen every- transactions and are designed to bring uniformity
where from the foods eaten, the medicines used, to the laws of the states.
the goods purchased, to the clothing worn. Exam- 1.5 Law in the United States is typically classified as
ples of how the law affects business can be seen constitutional law, civil law, criminal law, admin-
in zoning ordinances, regulation of environmental istrative law, and international law.
pollution, and licensing laws. Examples of how the 1.6 Moral law is concerned with the unenforceable
law affects the federal government include laws obligations that people have to one another; legal
providing for funding for building highways or for obligations are those required by enacted statutes
low-income housing, or requiring that states, coun- and other laws.
ties, or municipalities maintain them.
1.7 The structure of the federal and state court sys-
1.3 The sources of law in the United States are the tems includes courts of original jurisdiction (fed-
Constitution, executive orders, treaties, com- eral district courts and state courts) and appeals
mon law, precedent, case law, statutory law, and courts (federal circuit courts of appeals, the U.S.
administrative law. Supreme Court, and state appellate courts).
1.4 To address conflicts in business law between
states, the UCC was prepared in 1952. The UCC
CHAPTER ONE
ASSESSMENT CHAPTER ASSESSMENTS
Chapter Assessments sharpen students’ critical think-
MATCHING LEGAL TERMS ing, decision making, teamwork, technology, and
Match each of the numbered definitions with the correct term in the following list. communication skills and aid in student retention.
a. administrative law g. executie order m. stare decisis Assessments include:
b. appellate court h. moral law n. trial court
c. civil law i. original jurisdiction o. Uniform Commercial • Matching Key Terms
d. common law j. plaintiffs Code
e. criminal law k. precedents • True/False Quiz
f. defendants l. statutory law
• Discussion Questions
1. A legally binding directive issued by the president. 1.
2. The portion of the law based on the decisions of the old • Thinking Critically about the Law
2.
•
English courts.
Confirming Pages
Ponzi scheme A Ponzi scheme is a type of securities fraud in which large gains are promised to
A type of securities fraud in
liu34544_fm_i-xxxvi.indd xxxii which large gains are promised 10/05/20
investors; but in reality, newer investments are used to provide a return on older04:45
invest- PM
to investors, but in reality, ments. These schemes inevitably collapse over time as older investments eventually
newer investments are used become too large to cover with new investments. For more information on Ponzi schemes,
Final PDF to printer
APPLICATION-BASED ACTIVITIES
New for the eleventh edition are Application-Based Activi-
ties for Business Law. This digital feature provides students
valuable practice using problem-solving skills to apply their
knowledge to realistic scenarios. Students progress from
understanding basic concepts to using their knowledge to ana-
lyze complex scenarios and solve problems. Application-Based
Activities have been developed for the most often taught top-
ics (as ranked by instructors) in the business law course. These
unique activities are assignable and auto-gradable in Connect.
xxxiii
PA RT 1
5. Constitutional Law
6. Administrative Law
chapter 1
Our System
of Law
L E A R N I N G O U TC O M E S
After studying this chapter and completing the assessment, you will be able to
Rubberball/Getty Images
2
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
In our country, the principles and ideals that protect individual liberty and freedom are
incorporated in the Constitution of the United States (the federal Constitution). This
historic document gives the federal government certain reasonable powers and, at the
same time, clearly limits the use of those powers. In addition, each state has a consti-
tution of its own that gives certain powers to the various levels of government within
that state. Like the federal Constitution, state constitutions provide safeguards for the
EXECUTIVE ORDERS
An executive order is a legally binding directive issued by the
president with the intent to change the manner in which federal
agencies and officials operate so as to improve the practices of
the federal government. Perhaps the most historically significant
example of an executive order was President Lincoln’s Emancipa-
tion Proclamation, an order issued on January 1, 1863, proclaiming
all those enslaved to be forever free, and ordering all segments of
the executive branch to treat these persons as free. Other exec-
utive orders include those issued in response to the COVID-19
pandemic.
TREATIES
A treaty is a written agreement between two or more countries
that serves to establish terms of an international relationship.
Treaties become legally binding when they are approved by two-
thirds of the Senate (see Chapter 36).
dent nation was to establish a system of law. Because the original states were formerly
English colonies, it is not surprising that the new states adopted the system of laws
that had been used in England for hundreds of years—that is, relying on previous legal
decisions when similar disputes arose. This practice of relying on previous decisions
is known as stare decisis, which means “to stand on decided cases.” The English sys-
tem is known as the common law and still influences legal decisions in the United stare decisis
The practice of relying on
States today. previous decisions in which
similar disputes arose.
on the case and whether the previous case was decided by the highest court in the same precedent
state. Decisions made by the U.S. Supreme Court, for example, must be followed by A model case that a court can
other courts. follow when facing a similar
situation.
Court decisions are recorded in writing so that lawyers and judges can refer to them
in preparing or hearing a case. These decisions are published in books called reporters,
and many of these decisions are available online. Each case decision is identified by a cita-
tion, which includes the names of the parties involved followed by the volume number, the
name of the reporter, and the beginning page number of the case. For example, the case of
Milkovich v. News-Herald, 473 N.E.2d 1191, is reported in volume 473 of the Northeastern
Reporter, Second Series, beginning on page 1191.
CASE LAW
Sometimes a statute or a common law precedent may be difficult to apply to certain cases
or, with the passing of time, may take on different meaning. An existing statute or an
accepted precedent may be based on outmoded standards of justice. In such cases, a court
may disregard earlier interpretations of a statute or a principle of common law, or it may
interpret them differently. The court’s decisions in these cases influence later cases because
they too become precedents that may be followed in similar cases. The effects of these deci-
case law sions have been called case law.
The effects of court decisions
that involve the same or similar
facts.
STATUTORY LAW
Both federal and state constitutions are general statements of the powers of governments
and the rights of individuals. The specific applications of powers and rights are provided
for in laws enacted by federal, state, and local governments. Each state constitution provides for
a legislature that represents the people. These legislatures have the power to enact laws so
long as they do not conflict with either the federal or the state constitution. The laws passed
by Congress and by state legislatures are called statutes, and the field of the law that deals
statutory law with these statutes is known as statutory law. A law that is passed by a local government,
The field of law involving
statutes, which are laws
such as a city council, is often called an ordinance.
passed by Congress or by state Not only do statutes provide the specific applications of the powers and rights in the
legislatures. constitutions, they also allow governments to respond to particular circumstances. For
ordinance
example, when the federal and state constitutions were written, cellular telephones and
A law that is passed by a local automobiles were not even imagined, much less matters to be regulated. Yet after these were
government, such as a city developed, various legislatures passed statutes that restricted the use of cellular telephones
council.
while driving.
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW
Protection of the rights and freedom of individuals and organizations is well established by
the federal and state constitutions, by statutory law, and by common law. Still, today’s com-
plex society and system of justice present special needs that require certain laws that include
their own administrative machinery. Sometimes when a federal, state, or local legislative body
enacts a law, it also sets up an organization to establish rules and enforce them. Administrative administrative law
The body of rules, regulations,
law is the body of rules, regulations, and decisions created by administrative agencies. and decisions created by admin-
The practice of establishing specialized administrative agencies has several advantages. For istrative agencies.
example, it relieves the police and the courts from having to establish and enforce regulations
that are often highly technical. Administrative agencies include federal agencies such as the
National Labor Relations Board, state agencies such as public service commissions, and local
agencies such as boards of health. These agencies have in common the authority to establish
rules that have the force of law, to maintain “courts” that are often called appeal boards, and
to conduct “trials” that are often called hearings. Because administrative law has become such
an important part of our legal system, an entire chapter will be devoted to it (see Chapter 6).
He drew in to the left bank and let the lock fill up. The rain, which had
been savage and relentless while they were on the river, was abating now
they were within easy reach of shelter; the intervals between the peals of
thunder were lengthening, and, most noticeable of all, the terrible
oppression was relieved. Melville hooked the boat on to the stakes below
the lock and backed her gently up the stream until he came to a spot where
they could land easily.
She raised herself on one arm and looked round. Hopelessness stared
from her large eyes, but Melville saw with relief that the insane terror had
departed from them; he was anxious to get her into the train without
exciting remark, and it was something that she had regained her self-
control. That her frock was dripping wet and stained red from the cushions
would not attract attention here where everyone was wet, and before they
reached Waterloo she would not look so deplorable, however cold and
uncomfortable she might feel.
"We won't go through the lock," he said. "I'm going to pay the man for
the boat and say he'll find her here. Pull yourself together as much as you
can before I come back. If we are quick I think we can just catch a train,
and we shall get away before all the people get out of the lock and crowd up
the station. Do you feel better now?"
"I can depend upon you until we get home?" he asked, with some
anxiety.
She nodded a vacant assent, and with that he had to be satisfied. He got
out of the boat and went to the lock to pay for its hire and tell the man
where to find it. Meantime, Lavender, realising that whatever the future
might have in store for her, no good could be done by a scene at St. Martin's
Lock, made an effort to pull herself together, and tried to readjust her
bedraggled costume. With one of the napkins from the hamper she dried her
face and hands, and wringing some of the water from her skirts and rubbing
her patent shoes, she succeeded in making herself a little more presentable.
Melville was pleased. They hurried to the station and were fortunate enough
to catch an up train and secure an empty carriage.
But as soon as the train moved away his manner changed. Even if they
were left alone during the whole journey they only had fifty-five minutes in
which to arrive at an understanding, for he was quite clear he could not go
back with her to The Vale. He took the corner seat immediately opposite to
her.
It was obvious to Melville that she was frightened of him, and he was
content that it should be so, for only by terrorising her could he hope to
maintain his ascendency over her; any woman might be nervous at being
shut up in a railway carriage with a murderer, but it was not of that
precisely that she was afraid, for she stood in no fear of violence at his
hands. There was something despotic about him that compelled obedience,
and even if she had not been naturally as truthful as she was she would not
have attempted to prevaricate.
"Now tell me," Melville rapped out in the same peremptory way, "did
you hear what we were saying in that room?"
"Some of it," she replied; "enough, at any rate, to know what you have
been doing to get money."
"You don't know what my position was," Melville said. "You remember
my leaving Monte Carlo—ruined?" Lavender nodded. "I went down to see
my uncle a few days after I got home and he refused to help me. I don't
know why. He had always been lavish to my brother, and had never refused
me anything before. I was in absolute need of shillings, and had to get them
somehow. After I heard of your marriage with him, I told him I knew and
got something from him."
"But you got it on the ground that I was in need of it," she said
indignantly.
"It was an outrage," she said, with suppressed passion. "I resent that as
much as anything else. After all the years I never touched a penny of his
money for you to tell him I was starving and pocket the money for yourself
is a thing you can't expect me not to be mad about."
Her eyes blazed from her white face, and Melville grew apprehensive.
"What do you think Sir Geoffrey's answer was?" he asked.
"What?"
"He gave me ten pounds as an act of charity, and said if you needed any
more you could apply to the people you'd been living with all those years.
So you see, if you had been starving, you need not have looked for much
help from him."
A flush shot over her neck and cheeks and ebbed again.
"It only makes it worse that your villainy provoked such a message—
such a gratuitous affront. Oh, what an incredible fool I have been! But I am
beginning to see you in your true colours now."
Melville looked at her, shading his eyes with his hand; it might not be
so easy to silence her after all.
"How can I say?" she protested. "I must have time. I can't even think
yet."
"You must think," he retorted curtly. "You must make up your mind
between this and Waterloo, and stick to it afterwards."
"I can't," she repeated. "What's more, I won't try." Her thoughts flashed
back from themselves to the dead man. "Why did you do it?" she sobbed.
"Why, in the name of heaven, did you do it?"
"Only the devil knows," he groaned; but the train was travelling rapidly,
and this was no time for vain reflection. "You must assure me, Lavender. I
must know that I can have confidence in you. After all, we're in this thing
together."
"Nothing," he answered swiftly. "I want your oath that you know
nothing of it."
"I can't give it. I'm not sure of myself. I can't live and be sure of not
betraying it. I shall never sleep—never know peace again."
"I want your oath," Melville said doggedly. "After all, you stand to gain
more by Sir Geoffrey's death than I do."
She looked at him, not quite grasping the purport of his words, but even
as he said them they gave him confidence. If she was recalcitrant, he might
threaten her.
"Except yourself, no one can ever throw light upon Sir Geoffrey's death.
You must swear that you will throw none on it."
She did not answer, but sat like a statue of despair, as white as marble
and as motionless. Already they were drawing near to Clapham Junction;
ten or twelve minutes were all that were left for him to get the oath he must
obtain.
"If it got to that, of course that would be the end of me," he said, "for I
should have to confess that the deed was only mine, and I could not be
taken alive. But think what you stand to lose: the income you have, the
fortune you may have, your name, your reputation, possibly your freedom.
You would be so involved in a scandal of bigamy and murder that in self-
defence you would have to disappear. Lavender, it isn't only for my sake
that I'm putting it all like this; I'm not asking you to do anything. I'm only
imploring you for both our sakes to do nothing. Will you give me your
solemn promise to hold your tongue for ever about to-day's work? Will you
swear not to say one word of where we have been, or anything else, to any
living soul? Will you, Lavender—will you?"
"Don't write to me or call," he said. "I must go home at once, and I shall
probably have to go down again to Fairbridge. They are sure to send for me.
I will write to you as soon as I can and fix up an appointment."
She looked at him in wonder. He had courage of its kind, and courage of
any kind appeals to women.
"You need not be afraid," she murmured. "I will keep my promise," and
as he told the cabman where to go, she leaned back and closed her eyes in
utter exhaustion.
"What sort of storm have you had here?" he asked, as he paid the
cabman.
"Ah, well," Melville said, "it's good for your business, I daresay."
He walked round the corner into Jermyn Street erect and steady,
although he felt so excited. How would things work out? The street was
almost empty, for London was dressing for dinner, and the commissionaire
was not standing by the front door of the chambers. A swift glance into the
office showed Melville that that was empty too, and rapidly he walked
along the thickly-carpeted passage. Opposite the lift he paused to scan the
names upon the letters stuck in the letter rack, and his heart leaped as he
caught sight of the orange envelope of a telegram addressed to himself. So
it had come! He put out his hand involuntarily to take it, but checked the
impulse and silently ran up the staircase and gained his rooms. Once there
he tore off all his clothes and hung them in a wardrobe, which he locked.
He changed his linen, dried and brushed his hair, and then, putting on a pair
of flannel trousers and a smoking jacket, rang the bell and lay down on the
sofa, a cigarette in his mouth, a paper in his hand.
"Went off duty, sir, at twelve. He'll be back at eight. Can I do anything
for you?"
"I wanted some tea," said Melville. "I'm ashamed to say I've been
asleep."
"Thanks," Melville answered. "You might see if there are any letters for
me," and he rose and stretched himself.
Tea arrived, and on the tray there lay a couple of letters and the
telegram. Melville tore it open, and an exclamation of surprise and horror
broke from him.
"When did this come?" he asked. "Half an hour ago! Oh, why wasn't it
brought up to me at once?"
"I'm very sorry," the manager said, "but I really didn't know you were
in."
"I've been in all the afternoon," said Melville. "Who would go out in
such a storm if they could help it? But, in any case, I think someone should
bring up telegrams to see if I am at home. It's awful—awful!"
CHAPTER XVI.
AN UNEXPECTED WILL.
That Sir Geoffrey's violent end should have an almost paralysing effect
upon the household that loved him so much was, of course, only to be
expected, but it is impossible to tell beforehand how great grief will
manifest itself in different people. Thus Ralph, who enjoyed a reputation of
being bright and frank and open-hearted beyond the common, became
morose and even sullen, nursing his wrath against the unknown murderer
and allowing the iron to enter into his soul. Melville, on the contrary,
hitherto self-centred and indifferent to the happiness of others, seemed to be
softened by the tragedy, and in many little ways displayed an eagerness to
comfort the rest and a regard for their sorrow that was very winning. The
inquest which was held two days after the outrage was ineffective: a verdict
of wilful murder was returned against some person unknown, and the case
was recommended by the coroner to the attention of the police. So far they
preserved a sphinx-like silence, and although conjecture was rife in the
neighbourhood it received no assistance or corroboration from the
detectives engaged.
The evidence given at the inquest was little more than formal; the
doctor's testimony was brevity itself, Ralph's was concise to the point of
curtness, and the police inspector had no suggestions to offer; the facts were
self-evident, and of the only details that seemed to promise any interest,
namely, the bloodstains upon Ralph's jacket and in the water in the basin,
his explanation was so obviously simple that comment was superfluous. Yet
upon the people in the court Ralph's manner had an effect not wholly
favourable. He appeared to resent their natural curiosity, was brusque, and
even in bowing to the coroner, when that functionary gave expression to the
sympathy felt by his court for Sir Geoffrey's relatives, did not err upon the
side of graciousness. But if Ralph thus failed to maintain the family
traditions of courtesy, Melville atoned for it. He was merely asked whether
he could throw any light upon the crime by suggesting any motive which
might have prompted it, and this, it is needless to say, he could not do. But
his quiet dignity in this moment of sorrow and his air of engaging candour
won all hearts, and he quitted the scene in full possession of the sympathy
of the audience.
There followed two most miserable days, during which Ralph smoked
in solitude upon his houseboat, and Melville, for the most part, idled at The
Grange. Music fits every mood, and there was no disrespect to the uncle by
the nephew turning to his Amati for comfort in this dark hour, and so he
played—played as if inspired by Saint Cecilia—and stole a little further into
Gwendolen's heart.
It was with a sense of genuine relief that the two brothers returned to the
Manor House after the funeral. There was a certain restraint between them
and an odd embarrassment as to their mutual attitude in the small matters of
daily life; thus Sir Geoffrey's chair at the head of the table was left empty
by consent, but it stood as a constant reminder that for one of them it
symbolised possession, and now that its late tenant was laid to rest with his
fathers, the question as to which of the two should sit in it by right was
about to be decided.
With the closing of the inquest Melville's first fears of detection were
allayed, and his mind was engaged almost exclusively with the problem of
his future. He took it for granted that his uncle had died intestate, and the
only complication he could foresee in the division of the estate was brought
about by the existence of Lavender, of which he believed he was the only
person who knew. Mr. Tracy might know, and if he did, Melville supposed
that half the estate would be held, pending Lady Holt's instructions, and that
the other half would be divided between his brother and himself without
undue delay. What action he should take with regard to Lavender it was too
early to decide, but in a vague way he was beginning to incline to the policy
of persuading her never to come forward, which he was confident he could
do, and, by-and-bye, her share, too, might be obtainable for himself, or, at
any rate, half of it.
The brothers were standing in the hall, both feeling rather aimless and
self-conscious, when Martin joined them.
"Mr. Tracy mentioned that he had to return to London soon after the
funeral, so I have taken some luncheon into the library. I thought, perhaps,
you would have business to do before he left."
The butler directed his remarks diplomatically between the two young
men. He assumed that the Manor House would be left to Ralph, as being the
elder, but he did not wish to make any invidious distinctions between them
at present. They looked at each other and went into the library, where they
found Mr. Tracy contemplating a substantial pie as if wondering what
description of animal food it might contain. The old lawyer looked up at
them with a smile, and settled all difficulties of precedence by sitting down
in the nearest chair, which happened to be at the head of the table. He knew
the utility of a meal as a preparation for an unpleasant discussion, and
although as Sir Geoffrey's solicitor he was only the mouthpiece by which
the dead man's disposition of his property was to be communicated, he felt
uncomfortable.
"I have had two copies of Sir Geoffrey's will prepared," he said, "and
perhaps you would like to look at them while I read the original. It is not a
long document, but the technical phraseology may, perhaps, seem confusing
to the lay mind."
"In its main features," continued Mr. Tracy, who seemed to be taking an
unconscionable time fumbling in his bag, "the will, as I have said, is
sufficiently simple, but it contains at least one element of surprise. I will
read it without further comment, and you can follow from the copies," and,
giving a type-written copy of the will to Ralph and another to Melville, he
read the original clearly and distinctly.
Beginning with legacies to the servants, ranging from a year's wages to
the youngest maid to life provision for Martin Somers, the will ordained
that a charge should be made upon the estate sufficient to give an annuity of
four hundred pounds a year to the testator's widow, Dame Lavinia Holt, to
be paid quarterly to her in person, on application at Mr. Tracy's office, the
first instalment to be paid upon her first making such personal application,
and not necessarily to accrue from the date of her husband's death; subject
only to these legacies and this one charge, everything real and personal was
bequeathed to "my dear nephew, Ralph Ashley," for his uncontrolled use
and enjoyment. Of Melville's name no mention whatever was made.
Mr. Tracy folded up the document and waited. The silence grew painful.
Ralph did not know what to say, and Melville could not trust himself to
speak. He was white with mortification and rage, and could have cursed
himself for having with his own hand destroyed his last chance for the
future. He cleared his throat and tried to speak, but the words would not
come. Ralph looked enquiringly at the solicitor.
"I can throw no light upon the mystery," Mr. Tracy said. "Sir Geoffrey
was not the man to give confidences. He drafted this will himself, less than
a month ago, and all I have done is to engross it and procure his signature. I
should like to say that I ventured to ask certain questions and even make
certain suggestions, but they were received with unmistakable disapproval,
and, of course, I could not pursue the matter."
"It is iniquitous," said Melville hoarsely. He rose abruptly from his chair
and faced his brother. "This is your work, you scoundrel! For years you
have left nothing undone to estrange Sir Geoffrey from me. You have
schemed and plotted for this, and at the last minute, curse you, you have
succeeded. Well, you may be hugging yourself now, but I swear you will
live to be sorry."
Mr. Tracy tried to pacify him, but in his heart he was not a little sorry
for him. It must be a terrible shock to find himself thus ignored by the uncle
from whom, for all the lawyer knew to the contrary, he had every right to
expect munificent provision. And the lawyer spoke the truth when he said
he had ventured to plead Melville's cause with Sir Geoffrey, although he
reduced to the lowest possible terms the substance of the old man's answer
to his pleading; yet even at that interview, when Sir Geoffrey might
reasonably have been expected to confide entirely in the lawyer engaged to
give legal effect to his last testament, he had refrained; his native pride
forbade him to dilate upon his story, and kindly, but quite firmly, he
declared his intention not to swerve from the course which he had chosen.
Now that the thing was done, however, Mr. Tracy preferred that the possible
quarrel between the two young men should be deferred until after his own
departure, so he reverted to the matter immediately in hand.
"Well, I will see about it," said Mr. Tracy, "and let you know the result.
Now I must really hurry away. I ventured to ask the butler to order a
conveyance to take me up to the station. Good-bye, Mr. Melville. I quite
understand your very natural disappointment, and I do not hesitate to say I
am sorry about it. If I can be of any service to you at any time do not
hesitate to command me."
"I'm all at sixes and sevens for the minute," he said, "but I should like to
see you again soon. Uncle Geoffrey may have left Melville nothing, but he
has made no conditions in leaving me so much. You can, doubtless, advise
me what would be the best thing to do about my brother."
"I shall be particularly glad to do so," the old lawyer replied heartily.
"Give me time to confirm any appointment, as I am very busy just now, but,
within reason, I can come here or see you in the Fields at any time."
"Of course I can," said Mr. Tracy. "Very delicate of you, I'm sure. I shall
be delighted to take part in so amiable a conspiracy," and, shaking the new
master of the Manor House warmly by the hand, he got into the carriage
and drove away.
Ralph watched the carriage disappear, and turned back into the house
with a sigh. How was he to deal with his brother in this moment of
humiliation, which Melville would with difficulty be persuaded was not due
to him? Although they were brothers and so nearly of an age, the difference
in their temperaments was such that Ralph felt certain beforehand that he
could not hope to appeal successfully to the better part of Melville's
character, which surely must exist. If Sir Geoffrey, with all the authority of
age and wealth, could not control his younger nephew, how could Ralph
hope to succeed? He lingered in the hall, reluctant to open what would be a
painful interview, and as he looked at the familiar things, with their
evidence of wealth and cultured taste, and realised that they were all his, he
became conscious for the first time of the duties and responsibilities which
he had inherited with his rights and privileges. There was no mental
reservation in the inarticulate expression of regret at his uncle's death that
escaped him. Even if it had come in the ordinary course of nature, he would
fain have postponed the day, and lived content and happy with the dear old
man, as he had done for so many years; but for the end to come so
tragically, so treacherously, increased the bitterness a thousandfold, and
Ralph's first emotion as he looked upon his goodly heritage was one of
unmitigated grief at having thus entered upon his own.
But after a little while he raised his head with a new expression of peace
and high purpose on his face. He would strive to be as good a master of the
fine old Manor as Sir Geoffrey had ever been, and the moment to begin his
duties had arrived. He must offer the hand of brotherhood to Melville, and
enlist his help in tracking their uncle's murderer to his doom. More
hopefully he went slowly from the hall to join his brother in the library; but
as he opened the door a feeling of chill disappointment stole over him, for
Melville, too, had shirked the interview and the room was empty. As Ralph
turned to the window with a sigh he saw his brother, looking tall and slight
in his sombre mourning, moving slowly over the sunlit turf and making
evidently in the direction of The Grange.
CHAPTER XVII.
AN ARREST.
It was the fact that Melville shirked a conversation with his brother
immediately after the reading of the will; the mental strain had been so
great that he could not be sure of his temper or judgment, and that being so,
common prudence dictated a delay which would enable him to consider the
new situation in all its bearings before risking a final rupture with the new
lord of the Manor. He sought a temporary refuge at The Grange, where he
knew he would receive commiseration upon his terrible disappointment,
and where he might derive some sardonic satisfaction from the knowledge
that his presence by Gwendolen's side would involve Ralph's absence from
the same desirable spot. Mrs. Austen was quite frank in her condemnation
of Sir Geoffrey's action.
"I dare say Sir Geoffrey had plenty to put up with from Melville," she
said, "but that is the penalty of having children, whether they are your own
or adopted by you. What makes this will so inexplicable is that it was made
such a little while ago, for just lately Melville seemed to be on better terms
with his uncle than he had been for years. I'm sure there is some mischief-
maker at the bottom of it all, and if it had not been for this terrible murder
Sir Geoffrey would have got at the rights of the story, whatever it was, and
made a new will."
Gwendolen sighed. She had not failed to observe the fact, but she could
throw no light upon the reason of it. Ralph resembled Sir Geoffrey in being
very taciturn where his private feelings were concerned; she remembered
the day when Sir Geoffrey said he had a bone to pick with Ralph. The
discussion ended satisfactorily, but she connected the slight trouble in some
way with Melville, who, as she afterwards learned, had seen his uncle the
previous night, and Ralph's championship of his brother's cause had been
discontinued from that time; since then, indeed, he never talked about him.
It was all very puzzling and sad.
But he did not forget his vow that Ralph should live to be sorry for
having contributed, however indirectly, to his disinheritance, and wherever
he went he sowed scandal with both hands. It is an invisible seed, of which
the fruit is more deadly than the upas tree, and in sowing it as he did it is
possible that Melville himself had no idea of what the harvest would be.
Society knew little of Sir Geoffrey, who lived a comparatively retired life in
his fine old Surrey home, but the mystery attaching to the unknown Lady
Holt tickled its palate, and the murder of a man who was one of its order
was not lightly to be forgotten. Thus at many a dinner party, where the
subject was delicately broached, and at many a little luncheon in the clubs,
where the conversation veered upon the question of undetected criminals,
remarks were made—no one could afterwards precisely say by whom—
which went to direct the general suspicion towards one point.
"What is the good of all this parrot-talk about motives," he said on one
occasion. "When once you set to work imputing motives you need never
stop. Anybody can tell you that half the murders in the world are due to
drink or jealousy. Neither comes into this case. And England isn't like Sicily
or Corsica, where vendetta is an institution. Sir Geoffrey could not have had
an enemy in the world, so you may rule out revenge as well."
"How about the lady?" someone suggested, but Melville disposed of the
idea.
"She can't have got her knife into him, or she would not have lain so
low all these years. Besides, it looks as if Sir Geoffrey believed her to be
dead, for he made some funny arrangements about her annuity. Anyhow, all
that is pretty certain to come to light, for I believe there is a big reward
offered to anyone who will produce her. No; I don't see much use in fooling
after motives."
It was not often he was as precise as that. For the most part he contented
himself with the vaguest remarks, all harmless individually, but totalling up
to an incredible strength when put together by skilful brains; and skilful
brains were doing it, brains owned by men who, in spite of all detractors,
are marvellously shrewd, and who do not often have to confess themselves
beaten in the end, although they may sometimes take a long time upon the
journey, and even make errors by the way. Whose business it was to gather
these rumours and carry them to the detectives engaged upon the case, it
matters not to enquire; popular opinion is no evidence, but it is often useful
as indicating where evidence may be found, and, Melville's expressed
opinion notwithstanding, all lawyers attach importance to motive in arguing
for or against the criminality of individuals. At any rate, they agreed in the
advisability of making an arrest upon suspicion, and their selection of the
individual was partly influenced by some of these random and irresponsible
remarks.
The Manor House was looking its best in the mellow light of an ideal
summer evening. It had been one of those days when it is impossible not to
feel delight in life, and Ralph awoke to full consciousness of the fact that he
had youth and love and wealth to comfort himself withal. He spent the
morning at The Grange, and after luncheon punted Gwendolen up the river,
arranging for Mrs. Austen to join them at the Manor House. There was no
flaw in his happiness that day, and, perhaps because of the violent contrast
between its morning and its night, it always stood out afterwards with
particular distinctness in his memory. Returning from Longbridge, he put
on his evening clothes and went to The Grange to fetch Gwendolen and her
mother; they strolled leisurely down to the Manor House and lingered over
dinner, discussing idly many little plans for alterations to be made in the old
place for the fuller satisfaction of its new mistress.
Martin hovered about them, anticipating their every want, and when at
last they left the dining-room they resumed the discontinued custom, and
decided to have their coffee brought to them on the houseboat. It seemed to
mark the closing of a tragedy and the resumption of the pleasant routine of
their country life.
Mrs. Austen was dozing comfortably in her chair, and Ralph sat close to
Gwendolen, smoking in perfect content. Both were seeing visions of the
future, a future of unbroken peace and happiness spent in each other's
company, and the interruption of their waking dream by the sound of
footsteps coming on board was not unwelcome, as it only suggested another
little touch in the picture of material prosperity of which they themselves
furnished the human interest.
Martin deposited his tray in the kitchen in the tender, and came up to
Ralph.
"Of course I must see him at once," said Ralph. "Why should he be
denied?"
"I can't tell you what I mean, Mr. Ralph," he said, "but I'm sure there is
some hideous mistake. I think—I think he thinks you know something
about it."
"Where is the gentleman?" he said, but the question was answered for
Martin. A tall figure was standing at the foot of the stairway, and bowed to
Ralph as he reached the bottom step.