Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Antifertility Effect of Alcoholic Extract of Cycle and Estrogenic Activity of Female Albino Rat
Antifertility Effect of Alcoholic Extract of Cycle and Estrogenic Activity of Female Albino Rat
www.ojadd.com
Original Article
INTRODUCTION
Numerous herbs have been repo- as traditional medicine. The seeds are also
rtedly used historically by women to aid known to exert its protective effect by
child delivery, stimulate menstrual flow or decreasing liver lipid peroxides and, as an
reduce fertility1,2. Throughout the history antimicrobial agent6. The stem bark of
women have tried to control or enhance their Moringa oleifera are used as purgative, are
fertility with various levels of societal applied as poultice to sores, rubbed on the
support. Many herbal remedies are temples for headaches, used for piles, fevers,
traditionally used as contraceptive (to sore throat, bronchitis, eye and ear
prevent the ovulation or fertilization), infections, scurvy and cataract; leaf juice is
abortifacients (to prevent implantation) and also believed to control glucose levels and
emmenagogues (to prevent the uterine flow) applied to reduce glandular swelling7,8,9. The
or oxytocics (to stimulate uterine stem bark is used as an antioxidant10,11. The
contractions, particularly to promote root of Moringa oleifera were shown to
labour)3. Herbal contraceptive offer possess antihelmithic, rubefacient,
alternative for women who have problems carminative, antifertility, anti-inflammatory,
with or lack access to modern contraceptive stimulant in paralytic afflictions; as a
options particularly women living in the cardiac/circulatory tonic, used as a laxative,
rural areas in developing nations with very abortifacient, in treatment of rheumatism,
high population like India, Africa and inflammations, articular pains, lower back or
Bangladesh4. Studying the potency and kidney pain and constipation12,13.
toxicity of local plants that are reputed for However, there is no information to
birth control in the folklore medicine of substantiate or refute the abortifacient
these countries may generate greater claims of Moringa oleifera stem bark in the
confidence in and wider acceptability of scientific literature. Therefore, the present
herbal contraceptive. work has been undertaken to validate
Moringa oleifera (Linn) is a scientifically the abortifacient role of
medicinally important plant, belonging to Moringa oleifera stem bark as acclaimed by
family Moringaceae. The plant is also well the traditional tribal users of Melghat region.
recognized in India, Pakistan, Bangladesh
and Afghanistan as a folkloric medicine5. MATERIALS AND METHODS
Moringa oleifera is a small or medium sized
tree up to 10 m tall, with thick, soft, corky, Collection of Plant Material
deeply fissured bark, growing mainly in The stem of Moringa oleifera plant
semiarid, tropical and subtropical areas5. (Family: Moringaceae) were collected from
Different parts of the tree have been used in Melghat region of Amravati district during
the traditional system of medicine. Survey in the period of September to December 2012,
the tribal belt of Melghat region (20° 51′ to identified and authenticated by experts from
21° 46′ N and to 76° 38′ to 77° 33′ E) of Botanical Survey of India, Pune (Accession
Amravati district of Maharashtra state of No. VZ- 1).
India revealed that Moringa oleifera stem
bark is being used traditionally as an
abortifacint. The stem bark has been used in
indigenous medicine for over many decades
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
cornification method was employed for the Those animals showing normal estrus cycle
estimation of estrogenic activity17,18. were divided in 2 groups of 6 animals each;
Immature ovariectimized female albino rats,
21-23 days old, weighing between 35-45 gm Group I- control, received distilled water
were used. The animals were divided into (Vehicle)
four groups, consisting of six rats each. Group II- treated, received alcoholic stem
Group-I: Control, received 0.2 ml of bark extract at dose of Moringa oleifera 100
distilled water orally. mg/kg body weight.
Group-II: Treated, received 0.02 mg Vaginal smear using saline solution
ethinyl estradiol/ kg/ rat per day in olive oil were taken twice daily during the entire
orally. treatment period, observation of the vaginal
Group-III: Treated, received 100 mg opening and the cell type obtained in a
alcoholic extract of Moringa oleifera (stem vaginal smear was also done. The duration of
bark)/ kg body weight in 0.2 ml of distilled estrous cycle together with that of various
water orally. phases was determined19,20.
Group-IV: Treated, received 100 mg
alcoholic extract of Moringa oleifera (stem Statistical Analysis
bark)/ kg body weight in 0.2 ml of distilled All the data are expressed as mean ±
water orally +0.02 mg ethinyl estradiol / kg S.E. Statistical analysis was done by Student’s
/rat per day in olive oil orally. t-test and one way ANOVA21.
All the above treatments were given
for 7 days. On the 8th day of experiment, the RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
animal were sacrificed by decapitation and
uteri dissected out and surrounding tissues Preliminary phytochemical screening
removed .The uteri were blotted on filter of Moringa oleifera stem bark revealed the
papers and weighed quickly on a sensitive presence of alkaloid, steroids, flavanoids,
balance and fixed in Bouin’s fluid for 24 hrs. phenolics compound and saponins
The tissue were dehydrated and embedded in respectively. Similar finding was reported by
paraffin. The paraffin section were cut at 5 Uboh et al.,22 while studying the abortifacient
µm and stained with hematoxylin-eosin for activity of the aqueous extract of Psidium
histological observation. The diameter of the guajava stem bark in rats. Phytochemical
uteri and thickness of the endometrium were screening has revealed that many bioactive
measured in 16 randomly selected sections agents of plant extract coexist and can thus
using an ocular micrometer. serve as precursors in the manufacture of
drugs. For example, alkaloid is known to have
Effect on Estrous Cycle adverse effect on pregnancy and is being used
The alcoholic stem bark extract of by physicians either alone or in combination
Moringa oleifera at 100 mg/kg was found to with oxytocics to induce abortion23.
be most active amongst the three doses in the Furthermore, antifertility and abortifacient
anti-fertility testing. Hence it was subjected to activities of phenolics, phytosteroids and
a detailed investigation for study of estrous saponins have also been sufficiently
cycle. The studies were conducted on adult confirmed in animal models24. Studies on the
female rats (150- 200 gm) for 30 days. To phytochemical investigation of the various
study the estrous cycle pattern, animal extract of the stem bark of Alangium
showing regularity in the normal cycle were salvifolium used as an abortifacient, showed
separated and chosen for further studies. the presence of alkaloids, steroids, saponin,
tannin and flavonoids25. Therefore, presence
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
of alkaloids, phenolics, steroids and saponins weight alcoholic extract treated animals. Our
in the extract of Moringa oleifera stem bark results are also in agreement of Zade et al.,28
which may act either alone or in combination while working on abortifacient effect of
may be partly responsible for the observed Plumeria rubra pods on female albino rats.
pregnancy-terminating effects in the present Aqueous and 90% ethanol leaf extract of
study. Moringa oleifera was found to be 100 %
The highest dose 1000 mg/kg body abortive at doses equivalent to 175 mg/kg in
weight was used for acute toxicity activity. rats29. The present work also corroborates
Clinical toxicity symptoms such as 100% abortive effect of ethanol extract of
respiratory distress, salivation, weight loss stem bark of Moringa oleifera at a dose of
and change in appearance of hair as well as 100mg/kg body weight. The antifertility
maternal mortality were not observed at any activity of 50 % ethanolic extract of Moringa
period of the experiment. Similarly no oleifera excluding root was demonstrated in
mortality and changes in the behavioural, hamstar30. The antifertility activity of 50 %
neurological and autonomic profile were ethanolic root extract of Moringa oleifera was
observed in treated groups. This suggested investigated and it was found that a dose of
that short term use for this purpose is 200 mg/kg led to foetal resorption in 60 %
apparently safe. Similar finding was also female pregnant rats31. All the treatment
observed by Wikhe et al26, while studying the reduced significantly the number of litters
effect of Cicer arietinum and by Dabhadkar et born, confirming the abortifacient activity of
al,27 of Plumeria rubra in female rats. the plant used. No vaginal bleeding was
Moringa oleifera stem bark extract observed. The litter born to the experimental
has a folklore reputation as abortive. In the animal did not show any morphological
present study the extracts when tested for defects hence, it can be stated that the
abortifacient effect in laboratory animals, treatment does not exhibit any teratogenic
exhibited abortive activitites in accordance. effect.
The oral administration of alcoholic extract of The ethanolic extract of Moringa
Moringa oleifera stem bark at the doses of 25, oleifera stem bark at the dose of 100 mg/kg
50 and 100 mg/kg body weight produced a body weight exhibited significant
dose dependent adverse effect on fertility abortifacient activity hence it was further
index and number of implantation in the selected for confirmation of the antifertility
uterine horns of the female rats by virtue of an activity of the plant. In the estrogenic study,
increase in the percentage of the post- the effect of alcohol extract of Moringa
implantation embryonic loss. All the oleifera stem bark revealed that none of the
experimental extract when evaluated for their control group none of the rats exhibited
abortifacient activity, were found to exhibit vaginal opening during the period of study.
pregnancy interceptive activity. The alcohol extract at the dose of 100 mg/kg
Administration of 100 mg/kg body weight of when administered orally for 7 days, showed
the alcoholic extract resulted in 100% vaginal cornification in all the animals and
abortion, while doses of 25 and 50 mg/ kg also increased the uterine weight (P<0.001) of
body weight of the alcoholic extract resulted immature rats significantly when compared
in 28.50% and 44.45% abortion (Table 1). with control (Table-2). The effect of alcohol
This was evident from decrease in the extract of seed of Moringa oleifera when
percentage of live fetuses. The percent administered conjointly with ethinyl estradiol
resorption index increased from zero in the caused significant increase in the uterine
control animals to 100 % in 100 mg/kg body weight (P< 0.01) when compared with
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
control, but the extent of the uterotropic the tube and disturbing the luteotropic activity
response was less than that produced by of the blastocyst32,33. The estrogen also
ethinyl estradiol alone (P<0.001). The number promotes cornification of the vaginal
of cornified cells in the vaginal smears were epithelial cells. Safranski et al.,34 found that
considerably higher in alcohol extract treated vaginal smear characterized by full
group (+ to ++) than those of the control (0 to cornification of vaginal epithelial cells require
+), but notably less than ethinyl estradiol a higher surge of estrogen level. Jacob et al.,35
treated rats (+++) (Table- 3). The test drug demonstrated the uterotophic effects of
significantly increases the diameter of the estrogen when administered to rats.
uterus and thickness of the endometrium (P< Ljungkvist36 associated these effects with
0.01; P<0.001) when compared to control vaginal opening and cornification,
group, but notably less than ethinyl estradiol endometrial growth and proliferation. Our
(P<0.01) treated rats. In histopathological results also corroborates with the finding of
study, the control rats uterine endometrium Keshari et al.,37 who reported that hexane
shows epithelial cell with elongated nuclei, extract of the stem bark of Nigella sativa L.
numerous endometrial glands and edematous when given orally possess estrogenic activity
stroma. The uterus shows numerous spots and in immature rats. Similar finding was
folds in luminal epithelium cells. Stroma in recorded by Dabhadkar and Zade38, while
control rats was oedematous with fibroblast working on abortifacient and estrogenic
type of cells (Fig. 1a). However the activity of Plumeria rubra pods.
histological evidences of the uterus treated In the present study, the duration of
with 100 mg/kg body weight of alcohol the diestrous phase was significantly
extract of Moringa oleifera stem bark clearly increased while those of proestrous and
supports an unfavourable uterine milieu, estrous phases were decreased (Table- 4).
showing obliterated lumen with loose stroma, This is suggestive of negative influences on
increased height of luminal epithelium and the estrous cycle as this reduces the number
stimulated uterine gland (Fig. 1b). Similar of days/ ova ovulated during the proestrous
picture was observed in histological section of and esrous phases. The reason for this could
uterus of ethinyl estradiol treated (Fig. 1c) and be due to the presence of high level of
ethinyl estradiol plus extract treated group of phytoestrogens like saponins and essential
rats (Fig. 1d). Therefore from the present oils39,40. This disruption of the estrous cycle
finding it can safely be said that the extract may be due to the effect of this extract on the
possesses estrogenic activity. Thus the ovary which disrupts ovarian functions and
alcoholic extract of Moringa oleifera stem estrous cycle via ovarian and extra ovarian
bark which shows estrogenic activity in hormones41. Cyclic changes in the vaginal
immature rats seems to be responsible to smear observed in the estrous cycle gives a
cause abortifacient activity. It is expected that reasonable index of the ovarian activity and
due to the estrogenic activity, the alcoholic its hormonal synthesis of estrogen and
extract may disturb the normal estrogenic titre progesterone. The levels of these hormones
in the uterus in order to insult the egg to are controlled by hypothalamic releasing
implant. The estrogenic activity of the extract hormones and pituitary gonadotrophins42. A
may also affect the rate of ovum transport or feedback mechanism also operates where the
may create non receptive uterine milieu. pituitary gonadotrophins secretion in turn is
It has been reported that abortifacient controlled by estrogen and progesterone. The
activity may be due to estrogenic activity cornification in the vaginal epithelial cells is
which is causing the expulsion of ova from mainly due to high levels of estrogens
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
32. Anderson LL, Moghissi KS, Hafez ES. functions in rats. Br J Pharmacol 1997;
Biology of mammalian fertilization and 121 (8): 1796- 1802.
implantation. Thomas: Springfield, 39. Watcho P, Ngadjui E, Alango NFP,
1972; pp. 379. Benoit NT, Kamanyi A. Reproductive
33. Eto TH, Masuda Y, Suzuki, Hosi T. effects of Ficus asperifolia (Moraceae)
Progesterone and pregn- 4- one-20-ol-3- in female rats. Afr Health Sci 2009; 9
one in rat ovarian blood at different (1): 49- 52.
stages in reproductive cycle. Jap J Anim 40. Shivalingappa H, Satyanarayan ND,
Reprod 1962; 8, 34- 39. Purohit MG, Sharanabasappa A, Patil
34. Jacob D, Morris J McL. Estrogenic SB. Effect of ethanol extract of Rivea
activity of postcoital antifertility hypocrateriformis on the oestrous cycle
compounds. Fertil Steril 1996; 20: 211- of the rat. J Ethnopharmacol 2002; 82:
222. 11- 17.
35. Ljungkvist I. Attachment reaction of rat 41. Lerner LJ. The biology of non-steroidal
uterine luminal epithelium. The effect of antifertility. In: Contraception, chemical
estradiol estrone and estriol on the control of fertility. Edited by Lednicer
morphology of the luminal epithelium of D, Marcel Derker Inc, New Yark, 1969:
spayed virgin rats. Acta of the Society of 161.
Medicine Uppsala 1971; 76: 139- 157. 42. Mandel AM. Cyclical changes in the
36. Keshri G, Singh MM, Lakshmi V, vaginal smear of adult ovariectomized
Kambhoj Posycoital VP. Contraceptive rats. Indian J Exp Biol 1951; 28: 585-92.
efficacy of the seeds of Nigella sativa in 43. Boettiger EG. Changes in the glycogen
rats. Indian J Physio Pharmacol 1996; and water contents of the rat uterus. J
39:59- 62. Cell Comp Physiol 1946; 27: 9-13.
37. Dabhadkar DK, Zade VS, Rohankar PH, 44. Yadav S, Agrawal M. Effect of Nigella
Pare SR, Wikhe MA, Estrogenic and sativa on the estrous cycle and ovarian
anti-estrogenic potentials of ethanolic activity in albino rats. Pharma-
pod extract of Plumeria rubra in female cologyonline 2011; 3: 997- 1006.
albino rats, Global J Pharmacol, 6, 45. Amah C, Ifeanyi, Yama O, Eboetse,
2012, 142-147. Duru F, Ikechukwu, Osinubi A, Noronha
38. Tamura K, Honda H, Mimaki Y, Sashida C, et al. Effect of Momordica charantia
Y, Kogo H. Inhibitory effect of new on estrous cycle of Sprague – Dawley
steroidal saponins. OSW-1 on ovarian rats. Pacific J Med Sci 2011; 8(1): 38-
48.
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
Table 1. Effect of alcoholic extract of Moringa oleifera (stem bark) on fertility of rats when fed
orally from day 11 to 15 of pregnancy
Treatment groups No. of foetus No. of rats No. of resorption No. of Abortifacient
(dose, mg/kg body wt) individual rats on delivered in individual rats resorption activity
Control Group- I Vehicle day 10
8,8,9,8,6,6 (litter size)
6(8,8,9,8,6,6) 0,0,0,0,0,0 (mean±
0 S.E) (%)
Nil
Alcoholic Group- II 25 10,6,8,7,9,8 6(9,4,5,4,7,6) 1,2,3,3,2,2 2.16±0.18** 26.26
extract of Group- III 50 9,9, 8,10,8,10 6(6,6,4,5,3,6) 3,3,4,5,5,4 4.00±0.58*** 44.86
M. oleifera Group- IV 100 3,6,2,8,6,4 6(0,0,0,0,0,0) 3,6,2,8,6,4 4.83±0.80*** 100
Values are mean ± SE from 6 animals in each group, P values: *<0.05, **<0.01, ***<0.001,
When compared between group, ns= non significant
Table 2. Estrogenic and anti-estrogenic potentials of the alcoholic extract of Moringa oleifera
stem bark in rats
Treatment dose Uterine weight Vaginal
Groups Vaginal status
(mg/ kg body wt.) (mg/ 100 gm body wt.) cornification
I Control ( distilled water) 72.83±2.28 Not opened 0 to +
II Ethinyl estradiol (0.02mg/kg) 179±2.97*** Opened +++
Alcoholic extract of M. oleifera (100
III 104±1.45*** c Opened + to ++
mg/kg)
Alcoholic extract of M. oleifera (100
IV 130±0.76*** b Opened +++
mg/kg) + Ethinyl estradiol (0.02mg/kg)
Values are mean ± SE from 6 animals in each group, P values: *<0.05, **<0.01, ***<0.001,
When compared with control, P values: a <0.05, b < 0.01, c <0.001, when compared with ethinyl
estradiol group, ns= non significant.
+ -nucleated epithelial cells, ++ -nucleated and cornified cells, +++ -cornified cells.
Table 3. Histological changes in the uterus and endometrium after treatment with the alcoholic
extract of Moringa oleifera stem bark in rats
Treatment dose Diameter of uterus Thickness of endometrium
Groups
(mg/kg body weight ) (µm) (µm)
I Control ( distilled water) 292.00±7.27 131.70±3.63
II Ethinyl estradiol (0.02mg/kg) 514.29±6.62** 345.50±5.67*
Alcoholic extract of M. oleifera (100
III 398±3.68*** b 310±4.76***b
mg/kg)
Alcoholic extract of M. oleifera (100
IV 479.4±2.14*** c 298±1.18**c
mg/kg) + Ethinyl estradiol (0.02mg/kg)
Values are mean ± SE from 6 animals in each group, P values: *<0.05, **<0.01, ***<0.001,
When compared with control, P values: a <0.05, b < 0.01, c <0.001, when compared with ethinyl
estradiol group, ns= non significant.
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
Table 4. Histological changes in the uterus and endometrium after treatment with the alcoholic
extract of Moringa oleifera stem bark in rats
Group-II
Group-II Vaginal opening/ cell type
Phases (Days) Alcoholic extract of M. oleifera
Control group obtained in a vaginal smear
(100 mg/kg)
25% to 40% /
Proestrous phase 0.63±0.09 0.43±0.03**
Epithelial cells only
Above 70% /
Estrous phase 0.60±0.15 0.53±0.01*
Few cornified cells
50% to 70% /
Metaestrous phase 0.87±0.31 1.00±0.08** Cornified cells plus many
leukocyte
Diestrous phase 50% to 70% / Leukocytes plus
2.37±0.13 4.29±0.68**
epithelial cells
Complete estrous 4.47±0.68 6.25±0.29*** -
cycle
Values are mean ± SE from 6 animals in each group, P values: *<0.05, **<0.01, ***<0.001,
When compared with control, ns= non significant
Figure 1. Histopathological change in immature ovariectomized uterus of rat when treated with
alcoholic extract of Moringa oleifera stem bark (Photomicrograph at a Magnification of 100X)
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
Figure 1b. T. S. of uterus of immature ovariectomized rat treated with ethinyl estradiol
Figure 1c. T.S. of uterus of ovariectomized rat treated with 100 mg/kg b. w. alcoholic extract of
Moringa oleifera stem bark
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235
Zade et al______________________________________________________ ISSN 2321-547X
Figure 1d. T.S. of uterus of ovariectomized rat treated with ethanyl estradiol + 100 mg/kg b. w.
alcoholic extract of Moringa oleifera stem bark
AJADD[3][3][2015] 223-235