2019 HSC Modern History Band 5/6

Question 10(a) Section II Sample 2

Annotation:

The response demonstrates extensive knowledge and understanding of

how Stalin was able to emerge as leader of the USSR. The high level

and sustained argument is supported by some sophisticated

understanding and use of historical concepts. The response

comprehensively addresses both mistakes made by Stalin’s adversaries

and how he used these opportunities to his advantage.

 2019 HSC Modern History Band 5/6
Question 10(a) Section II Sample 2

Option I 'Ill F=I<, IA, J· i ,' t'( + lvv,' eJ- vt,rn 'wl .
Q11estion Part
Answer this question on pages 2-8.

/,/- Wf{ l ~h{

C,u f Wl iil'W<J-1'0YI o.t t\ ri,,,1,;M hif ol__ kt~ l t±lM a I ~ do--Hph
Jta4£ri . k ~ - ( /11,J 'vu__ . ~ vi: tl,c . fldr/1? 'fv f'lL: ..-:
~ ~ I qQ Cl 'J ~ Jkltn. ~l CQ]{JhiJ[_bf·JtA__.~·er('ly ~'~
J,,,J· uf~_ovl-f-vYL i Mo·uJe. d & f.A,,v/f A ~,n1 hiJ
I
oclhn"'cM fl CA:11--'L .•!1t 1Andet3kuu<lb.j trl--·,ltve_ tl-~~e:1·
~ d i - lu UMA1·h1:J~ lld4/ &t/-cJy{f in h{J n';/-e_ h
b ~ & Nbri,]j fu ~/pu.,r;ne ~,kt/ ~~ llfl
I
&UJJf lo'd. I q{Lq_
-- ,

.. '

l'Jal,'n ~1 vinfYUK/fa.nd1t1JI- rf &p~ rl_i 'rlt. blvtA-fttu/Artl~

(X ~l-uj/fMAI- &b, h7y rk ·flJ✓!AJ?U-A, ·~,~ tr/
rr/leJ MJ ~ /n h,i ~~ v M Iefl!/L" !JnL k lt.L
-rfiuJ-- lh.PVI Hu_ UJ'II< MllJ Ii( m-t,...p~ no.-h'-rJh ✓ ( / ~
(

CJ) flhtfUu( .fu pev(ly, . . urn.m;Tkd,: 1r/-t ·rt:#;)r}b.- J~)J

IAJtld</i1lo od th lJ &cl- & undlKIftoti· lli .,t,n{[r/lYl. tUJ /J(JvVif J1,cd--
cr;wloLld 9/!A.Jhid &em C-uYibift/Lmg &pv11:) ;ntUJ,inf_ ft-J JIAlh,
·JWi'n culvpkt{ ~ 1UAA11 /J tr tJi!_ r/4'1,~rdl(J. 11-i [P'Wlmhz~ ur/
hovli n,,~ne J1 Jfevlfh J 0ihfAI llt1l Ltvn~f~n&ol-~
lfl'Ylpl-k,of H<.J ifirl.~f ~l()tlJ_ & 9YCMfJ17 tk YTAAAM.d
~ti({ ih l'Lul v-LJ-:1~ ~ -1-hM lu- UtNldcall
 2019 HSC Modern History Band 5/6
Question 10(a) Section II Sample 2

. lttf?kt11 ~ ,~l-aMCLd- P- cmft,rl. /J?'J rPk u Ctanm/JJtv 1J f-- /bL

,,

/UJ11A1h ;rupetkt-de ~I-al ~,n.i IJ.Lnll-e of

&, Wcrll//YJ
.remw,y ihe/nr:lfflttJ & OtJ rtupll:t11 £ tU lklOh, il-t,vt,'/2 c9•~f Jo ·. ·
1/Lclcu. Ml-Af Ii.art nae an I-:; J.. ~ d/Ji!ic/Mh art IA47& u
~ tt-:l tlH.4-« cdkirnf tefihfYJ/tdftrn d~/dhwlhtn
·& prih'l-hlll.O; UJ= ?frt1¥ ffl wit ic!J la- wtl✓ · adte,- P'f'~ #wt
Mnl Jf?16'rlc~ 1,VCl/ hit rd/-l<lff' ~ ~ . u/1lclt'
· td£~ol h Im k U,Unh't:tJ41 &-qcYY7{l:e_
-
~~de,n1:!J
I
&_ ~
/J-1 d_UClf:J,T <tbJin rJ-t>1- ,k_ IPl4- h!J trwn
o/-??~'i-Jl-nunh.
,

J (¥7' ~ 1n R tn1 t1mJ 111 Jt;//Vif p blt-ult72 tt /&Cr beu-eti

</lwt,~ ft.,ur l ~ · k hl% ·.tfwAd ~ ) y i?J1rnHJJ<
fJalrm~ ,& "'¥/ flfkthHI: Md DYWcJtU t,j h/J · ~ tJJ
Kftdu:,'
-,

~ ~ ~ ; 1 1 : 1 rllmely ~ & ~
·cf/e,J;n's Otlbu.tt of tu wlf of lu,tn 1 . W£C ,n.11-nvnvtltdrn hfJ
~ l L ~ ~ /)11,,( k.~ lkt/-/hd.iuf1r; J j ~
Jrui a. tl;/nlrlU1/al btl,'ng cuJ i'1 I o/2 31 1h rJhtcli un,n htAf=ffl1
...Jo httrth 01 d l J f ~ JMn1h lu.1 1.-MI: hl/11 & Tlu&A.rYliY14 ·
lidt1-t11, au itath-- ,n· a21- ·}A/C{J.11 ~~ -~U-tri ·. 1-~~
~ ~ J -I.- -

tlblb&J k ~ c 41 /lflliv. ·lhct pn1h byZnru~ htil-h

. JhtJtt:t i/ii. unitntJ err/ )..tA1/n if ·, b1iII l,Vt{J t#t ~
J{Jrn 'f-FCAn.6 b:ertUdl-e 1/ & u 11 kn h h0 d k-u/1 m,c_d (ll,1,/,
'
Jkvltn 11- ecire.eJ ooCU/IA/bkdiJJ. MJ1d d htvvt·tncluiWJ.a
& r1fY'1 ~an of lm,n &-rke. 11\1.tght--- hiJ tplt1»n ccvvriffl\. &1d1tt ~t
<nil1J oli'd unrn·~ ouAfll ~ f 'o'fe(),..''1 ~ ~nt ~
 2019 HSC Modern History Band 5/6
Question 10(a) Section II Sample 2

"Am hu pwl tu ~ 1-uHkuy, hwl .,'J- Ov0-, ~ d

. Jia);Jn; tk ~ ;<)j
, ~ Le,,nin 1I J ~ &-~ /4
~d- h/mldlu k1 JUC'-llfflY; & 61:Y c9atw in
Vzvn
ft£</?~~~ fl!} flrJ&4fdh(I 11.t funeral.~ J ~h'tJ
btm1-uf a1 cbtel:pall..J~ LM,,/r; 1/vM Mu h ~ / -
'1,tn1-eU1t> ~ 12r:u& & IA.t I~hlhh't @ 1k ~ lfl.in ✓ -Lev, J.
v-
)egaqy . He JtvN O&ft7 ~~h bic/41nlht ht} r~ «117lihj /2uv/) J
liuuraL, hfAUL1 h!M11(if thl ldf7-uhtlrW IJf b,:J lil;9l&11-- n1d
/11 de,1f,)y AMl'n Jy ~h4J h,'m ~IA/hlre1 !JM.ciihrf b/111
~Jb & fJtk/h§ Ju)n av ~er«u ~ {ffilh,'vlt a-w
41onht1I lt-n1n~ w1W}~Jk:uA11 dletlzk.fy ~ &
✓ I

~ t t n ( I ( :li>r hitnJ-e/1 ~nij'tib-Ai 1Z117M/l-lzrr~ lld ✓h t/J!/n~

btY u'whlyi1:!J /2iJ ,t?tlJ,/cLU ih k;rm✓ tt'( /..br}in 1'l/ ~ Mf4.·

ftp J!-VJ'J IZ?h rhJ J'J-ahn dluf,'k,,ly o,1--urlJ-h111 k Mh,
bdl.d
which MlJ -iidt hL~rcd:u/.llJ J ~ ,I aloud£ cl: /1,L ~
61- Linin «
d'JAYV1. vaL- d h.,:r tM'/1 1&4/ i)itfn.,J /v\.wife<.l.. c>i
i
htv ~ ~ - - cl.· UAAUL in & . ~ W's • '

. &1111ZM'tb J;e,,itn JJ 17 c1'1 Ji'IXJ/4 II M?1-e Gt(IA.,p l-1 d kb h!'J

lJL,/

~ ( ' t t r : ~ t 6 - I ~ ltvvib111Jy - .

in tfB ~ k f rf h'4:J & M1llevnw .fAAd , fY(famVJ k.L ,?i · 'n,

lw-~u ·tltJ /..e4u:lu: ft, ~ /J n,f/ bU!luh ,I- ~
cfJtdi~h _· hA.J iM u n. J~1al-er, ,t ,a. tcf,b~J b h,"J fJdluuu_tJe
~ in,'J-i~&rvlly ffTYVJ,~ tJLrbciL1.KYJVJ~ ·LfiLJa t:hl ult
{K,0vm-er1-w Ix Z,'tutvi w) {JJl11Pu1} LrtltUJJjJ -Jo urnp/,e,h,ld &ivfluh~
llL 1) en'n th"9 VIA H-7 -/ii£- n'gh-t oPP-«-JJ ?-.~ ( Bu kh c,1.-1'l'1 / ~ y kuY c(:! ·_
 • •a • • ¼ip'J-11? p l/t-{/4~Ul/?II:/ }} .hi ~l{llh ddo--J,1t,~U ·
~---lf'n?FJJ funowpVIJ Z J v ~ h1A'W f»f'b! Pf Y[ <fYJ nnt
~lfltff 'fiiur, ~J lL1! @"q W)Aff?j l7lb1 ?rw #ti }i, '"1 ~
ng ~ ~ ,?p✓ n i ~ l'1f l(]. 7'1ftA1JCt;tPujPif!'.
7-47"fVI £t{;,ff!/t7{11,fl{C/7'1f/ 1M IA11Cf
7111 f1J vy1YJ-s'--/tj;J110 r/ "if. vl.~INl
.. - ~ f l ~ 71-f /4 - f t i _ , ~ i ~ J; u_ tyJ9fp I ~ l11/4('!'
' .
~ rr"'/(l/ ' .l:'t·q p PqVPt0J7YltbJ1lUM 71jJ
~ ( IL(WJ .· ln1n11 (rp.i/JJ oiw:
r ht. ~,,i/4tl J}7fJ!71Jlf fl1
~ fi.;N -ru ~ 9 ~ IMJYrr}U(Lf11JV r fq_,, lWr f J-t✓f? U/ ffJ__iy,d
,/,J,qLr"nn YliJl {1/ JUf'7'?J,PP.J ./j ~ ~ fli't,/lF/' lit_l' JJ 1
fitlt~.P r ,I
2/UV}ltQ? ~ JrplYP/ t' P'iJ //Tpt-q;jd
-f r uu.rro/?4f nJ/11
-rP' -~1.A?vu~llf.1 ru · q/ th/I .rp.fi07PrJf:J1iJr » ~
d3N7YC//~ i f A , . t m · ~ /P[llfti ·(t·RqqwrJ no
·. I,// UJ.!.'1?J,r>oJ'v pm.~ f' ~Ui/ffetfL~ rJrVJ fl:
~
) ~ (cf~;vJ tnlle/ J/Ulilu1oy 7PJJIV r-JI ~ jtl?njl1.(7
1 o/ 1f-r]1/lftJ-tfCl 7 . r Plt/urJ yl)n,;_;up IJ/l"?f lrnt 'H1ffl/~
e.--fj},,_ ~ . I
·Rro,Wn;fJq ffi1ljli1 ]J?J)tr ( Q . / . 1 ~ - , ~lh1:
. I )mJl/P-11) fi;qJ)lf'ffWl J7J 'fOY)tJJL{t. ltp11.f Jf ·dlr>Pt# f;lrfJ]7P fl"P(O.
~ /-q ~ ~ J J (t?v//ZtpP~ .rrptchi:I ] ~ ~ ,,..,117?.
~ ; l?,m u o/ /?'J',Vrt u.,, -fWlil P()Dttfl'fJ1A1ll R_!f>J-/J' :ffJi11lll h1
"fj ~ ~t4j ltJ ~I/WJ1h µpP/ 1/)JJP/)i1 '/f11(7 fitwc/ ">J.W?t/J'JJ'f/;
71f r' f?;q/u J11 o? 11-/,,f /-P ~ -fu.,fJ-,;m-vr-; ·f91- '1-lfl 11 tJ '1zJp
-Q.bftr1JOCNI 11 i,~'Pff' p; n ,np"~' fJ f! If In-[ I! J lAir,) L(I ~I ftUJ,~:
~ I
l}'fi
{IP'?/ 'J:PI 71lr . ~ ;r~ f?l'~ tp ,iY
-!ti pv.,iJJY?, ii ~rrh? - 71!
til~-tw.,, 1 '11d"'1 r11 writ 1AfJ ~n-q·J'.Uf iu~~wrv!J /woit.11 If tftq1u1]Jl
Sample 2 Section II Question 10(a)
Band 5/6 2019 HSC Modern History
 2019 HSC Modern History Band 5/6
Question 10(a) Section II Sample 2

~ dun &411 & /wdy, fhfJ ~ ' b alJ-hlJ

l,yfnlf ~ .uYJ,Jfl & . tr,Lq &4J Cmpw!>i cJ_0.J,~-
~VJ ~~d tU tttl.t LULPUvqJ d1{nn·/Jm/# ~ P1~hl-,
/n dLUih)y .Mw ~ ~MWzttf/?J/ ()/ -~ /lady wll-1'
·MldJevnzomJ 1- ~'L&~·k/d--lvJRtJ_ ,_'lJ. l-iI) yl ~~
: 7
J9tAA}p_,)"". - '. I .' : i . . ;. \
( ! ·,

I
-.

Merl{,UvV/ tleAAinlc /J/A~ CJ>!A..fLuJ.. kitb , a rhlh1) !t

~(:fjAh'J;y . f-iaMJ1f_ .. l t l ~
I
11 J")'ntnt',U...k]f . e;-m,e~rl ttf>
~~r tt1J · It /I Clvif!dC d1Mi)1J neuatlrdfdtJJ0 Rj ul'ei: ti,
r/lf;fb,f/ u,n,e/uA.M.itnah"t ~ l y .~·/tr~. ~·

9 ~ Ol~/-flµ. Uu 11 I- he✓• w/lU tiplfy .hrtul 11Cmimcu.

:0nYl. fu,_ol{-dC It _d ii.1. t.e~ - · ~
ltwr''
· . ~ h.
f /. h I' J· · ~ . f l l l tD1d

·kMr,t/ A~<wudd I/HM & t~cY/& M./V"lfU.Jltrn ~

1ru-,ziiu o/ hlJ g,-1dAA= 4dtn/114'Jl-nw,k du71t1 hencf.ll!jl'
~MA- Mb111Mdk /rtU21 himlh&rtJUllf/·~
~~ tW-;~ bilr/ f?Ud--C !rt /Jr/vr/fPaMd'tm, at;# 1-c firJ/1 k;,t
inJ.e 111.,-»e,nu / di aP1):1na_ & 0<..crc1 -t:tn~ h,,y WU (VlMt,, .
/!e4n.d 17/ IJm t?lf,f'~d111-. ~ IIt!Yhe-v,«d-- . / Kty
uey-tlt:W
J .A17J'k1yJ ol,~ '+ wt11YJ f wh.i<± ~f~ m th! ~&1 C

~UY) ~ # QClMf·/-g n.tJr 01A/n,, & M /U.P h-, . '

•~flhj; wtlJ /ifl,JJ(~ k 1tt /1,,J? hv'ht ✓~

·u~4e..dolLodd # ~ ~ 1 / ) a ? <ft(fue./1,y~
11-evle}i N,A/4,r fu._d & wrrrcy ~ Q

. __~
,_41(/~ ,d//L
., v-,r;rf!,ru,if' u- ~, ·w't>Ltvvr ·~ i.l- -~1 ih fettf a r1.,u,tvn~
,,
 2019 HSC Modern History Band 5/6
Question 10(a) Section II Sample 2

(1/ fctchr,~1_ wn,,,''Vh ~ kµdhtcb- ~ dkdlrk

. k ~--'- k.~ d-·& /JU 8.. t!?J H,i l~ y;:,~
()Id
Wrifll I- JQvn,£ &.e&-a •i//tR 1._mi'h 1...1 d£.M'h,, evll,,-e d-eP
h& CPJvid-rdl1 ~ ic1: n o olVIA/bl r/i-,,A::/: be t,Ut,{Jtivk:

.IIjRPOUJ±u-h1~J A bult. thtHMlke J q-;pnu/hlm&J p.,,u,-e_

: /u £ ~ h'J--t ivf1,cl, ~ t,/W/ ~ 1~~ ~
. /

hh CEp~~

..

-7-