Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Insights Into Silicon Photonics MachZehnder-Based Optical Transmitter Architectures
Insights Into Silicon Photonics MachZehnder-Based Optical Transmitter Architectures
Abstract— Mach–Zehnder-based modulator architectures lend and cost effective high speed interconnects to overcome the
themselves to the realization of high-data-rate Silicon Photonics attenuation and crosstalk limits of metal links [2]. Optical
transmitters. In this work the challenges set by the integration communications are now expanding within data centers, where
of such devices on silicon are analyzed in depth. The two main
alternative electronic driver architectures, namely multistage and optoelectronic modules act as interfaces between the electrical
travelling wave, are compared with focus to power efficiency. and the optical domains to transmit data between switches
This is, in fact, a key parameter when considering the stringent and servers. Such modules are built with a large number
requirements of standard module form factors. A 25 Gbps of discrete optical and optoelectronic components plus few
multistage and a 56 Gbps travelling wave modulator have been electronic ICs and they are challenging with regard to size,
realized. Each electro-optical transmitter is obtained by the 3D
assembly of an electronic IC on top of a photonic IC through cost, and power consumption. In this scenario, Silicon Pho-
copper pillars. STMicroelectronics PIC25G Silicon Photonics tonics is attractive for large-scale industrialization of low-cost
platform has been adopted for the fabrication of optical devices, miniaturized optical transceivers addressing short/medium-
while 65 nm CMOS and 55 nm BiCMOS technologies are reach optical communications up to a few kilometers [3].
exploited to realize the electronic drivers. A 30% better power Silicon Photonics based transceivers can be realized by
efficiency compared to Silicon Photonics state-of-the-art at simi-
lar data rates and comparable extinction ratio performance has monolithic integration of optical devices together with elec-
been demonstrated in both cases. Since packaging is also a crucial tronic components. This solution suffers however from limited
aspect for Silicon Photonics high volume production, experiments flexibility and scalability. Thick SOI and BOX, generally not
on bare dice as well as on packaged chips are reported. included in standard advanced CMOS technologies, are in
Index Terms— BiCMOS analog circuits, CMOS analog fact required to obtain low-loss propagation for the optical
circuits, electro-optical modulation, power-efficient high-speed signal [3]. This in turn requires the development of dedicated
interconnect, silicon photonics. CMOS technologies, creating either local photonic substrates
on standard electronic platforms or integrating electronic
I. I NTRODUCTION devices on photonic substrates. In both cases the realiza-
tion cost increases and the performance of the electronic
S ILICON Photonics is emerging as a promising technology
enabling miniaturization and cost reduction of electro-
optical devices. These advantages can be exploited in various
circuits are not necessarily optimized. A 3D-integrated solu-
tion allows instead the use of separate Electronic Integrated
applications including but not limited to data communications, Circuits (EICs). This maximizes the EIC design flexibility
commercial video and consumer electronics, sensing, lab on since the electronic technology can be selected according
chip and gyroscopes [1]. Nowadays the evolution of this to the target application. Minimal performance degradation
technology is mainly driven by the fast growing market of compared to a monolithically integrated solution is obtained
data centers. The continuous increase of Internet data traffic realizing the 3D dice assembly through copper pillars. This
volume in fact mandates the development of power efficient recent bumping solution, already in high volume production,
in fact ensures fine pitch at low cost. The 3D structure has to be
Manuscript received April 14, 2016; revised June 10, 2016; accepted finally assembled on the substrate of the optical module. Low
July 12, 2016. Date of publication August 25, 2016; date of current version
November 21, 2016. This paper was approved by Guest Editor Elad Alon. cost electro-optical assembly techniques maximizing signal
This work has been carried out within the Studio di Microelettronica, a joint integrity are key and alternative solutions are currently under
research laboratory between Università degli Studi di Pavia and STMicroelec- investigation [3].
tronics.
E. Temporiti, G. Minoia, M. Repossi, and D. Baldi are with STMicroelec- This paper focuses on the transmitter portion of the
tronics, Studio di Microelettronica, 27100 Pavia, Italy. integrated optical transceiver, extremely challenging due to
A. Ghilioni and F. Svelto are with Dipartimento di Ingegneria Industriale e the power efficiency required by standard modules’ form
dell’Informazione, Università di Pavia, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
P. Orlandi is with STMicroelectronics, Studio di Microelettronica, 27100 factors. Different approaches for the design of Mach–Zehnder
Pavia, Italy, and also with Dipartimento di Ingegneria Industriale e modulators (MZMs) are analyzed and compared in the
dell’Informazione, Università di Pavia, 27100 Pavia, Italy. following. In particular, the analysis demonstrates that a mul-
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. tistage architecture adopting rail-to-rail inverter-based CMOS
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/JSSC.2016.2593802 drivers allows maximum extinction ratio (ER). However, as
0018-9200 © 2016 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
TEMPORITI et al.: INSIGHTS INTO SILICON PHOTONICS MACH–ZEHNDER-BASED OPTICAL TRANSMITTER ARCHITECTURES 3179
data rate increases, inverter-based CMOS driving is not fast Ring resonators and balanced Mach–Zehnder interferome-
enough. Travelling wave architectures adopting CML/ECL ters are the most exploited architectures to achieve intensity
driving are then preferred, even if at the cost of an ER reduc- modulation of light by varying its phase through refractive
tion caused by electrical propagation losses and bandwidth index changes. Ring resonator modulators have been recently
limitations of silicon integrated transmission lines. In this analyzed in depth for the realization of miniaturized silicon
work, alternative design choices relying on both CMOS and modulators [11]–[13]. However, they are very susceptible to
CML/ECL architectures are compared. STMicroelectronics operating condition variations, in particular temperature, thus
3D-compatible Silicon Photonics platform (PIC25G), imple- requiring accurate thermal controllers [14]. This not only
menting only optical devices in the front-end of line (FEOL), affects the overall power budget of electro-optical transmit-
has been used for the photonic section [4]. A 25 Gbps ters but also poses reliability and yield issues. Furthermore,
transmitter based on a multistage architecture and achieving an achieving moderate speeds of 20–25 Gbps with wide open and
ER higher than 4 dB [5] is presented together with a 56 Gbps symmetric eye diagrams is still critical [12], [13]. MZMs are
solution based on a travelling wave architecture and achieving the most mature solution for the realization of reliable exter-
an ER of 2.5 dB [6]. The comparison between theoretical nally modulated Silicon Photonics transmitters providing high
analysis, simulations and measurements is reported at probe- yield and well controlled performance. When implemented
level and on testboard with packaged samples. The paper in a push-pull configuration, MZMs allow achieving optimal
is organized as follows. An overview of Silicon Photonics chirp performance thus reducing dispersion [7]. Furthermore,
modulators is provided in Section II together with the basic MZMs can operate over a much wider optical bandwidth than
operation principles of MZMs. Sections III and IV introduce ring resonator modulators without requiring any device tuning.
the two main alternative Silicon Photonics MZM driving Finally, current-generation MZMs already show bandwidths
architectures for high rate communications: multistage and larger than 40 GHz [4], paving the way to the next generation
travelling wave. Section V compares the power efficiencies of optical modules.
of the two architectures. Section VI presents the design of the A MZM consists of a balanced Mach–Zehnder interferom-
demonstrators and the experimental results, providing details eter. The incoming optical signal is split into two nominally
about the package and testboard. Finally, Section VII draws identical optical paths and recombined after an induced phase
the conclusions. shift difference ϕ between the two paths [Fig. 1(a) and 1(b)].
The generated output power Pout , neglecting second order
effects such as unbalance in the two arms’ losses and deviation
II. OVERVIEW OF S ILICON P HOTONICS M ODULATORS
from the 3 dB condition of the directional couplers, can be
A modulated optical signal can be generated either by derived from [7] and it is given by:
direct modulation of the laser cavity or by modulation of
2 ϕ
the laser output through an external device. While direct Pout = Pmax sin (1)
2
modulation is advantageous in terms of simplicity and com-
pactness, external modulation provides an optical transmitted ϕ
Pout = Pmax cos2 (2)
signal with higher spectral purity [7]. Furthermore, in par- 2
allel applications with several lanes operating at the same The maximum output optical power Pmax is determined by the
wavelength (e.g., 100G-PSM4) external modulation allows continuous wave input power and by the optical propagation
using a single continuous-wave laser source to serve more losses along the MZM. The phase-shift difference ϕ =
than one lane. This simplifies the electro-optical transmitter ϕmod + ϕ0 is realized by means of a static phase shift
architecture and reduces the overall link power consumption. ϕ0 plus a variable component ϕmod obtained through a
Two alternative physical effects can be exploited for the real- high-speed modulating driving signal Vdrive [Fig. 1(a)]. The
ization of external modulators: electro-absorption and electro- static phase shift difference ϕ0 is introduced by means of a
refraction [8]. Electro-absorption consists in the variation of low-speed phase modulator (LSPM) within the interferometer.
the material absorption coefficient due to the application of an The operating point is set around ϕ = π/2, maximizing
external electric field. Intensity modulation of the carrier can the optical modulation amplitude (OMA) which is defined as
be performed through this effect. However, electro-absorption follows:
modulators do not lend themselves to the realization of silicon O M A = P1 − P0 (3)
integrated transmitters. In fact, since the primary electric field
effects exploited to obtain electro-absorption are weak in The varying phase difference ϕmod depends upon Vdrive and
silicon, their realization requires hybrid integration of III-V LHSPM according to:
materials [9] or use of Ge-based modulators [10]. While these
Vdrive L H S P M
solutions allow shortening the devices down to few tens of ϕ mod = π (4)
microns, the electro-absorption effect is intrinsically wave- Vπ L π
length and temperature dependent [10]. This limits the oper- where the high-speed phase modulator (HSPM) Vπ Lπ is
ating wavelength range and requires the use of a temperature set by the technology and represents the product between
control to achieve repeatable performance. Electro-refraction the voltage and the geometrical length necessary to achieve
instead consists in the variation of the material refractive a π phase shift. The driver supply voltage is limited by
index through the application of an external electric field. transistor reliability rules in integrated realizations, setting then
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3180 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 51, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2016
Fig. 2. (a) ER and (b) normalized OMA vs. HSPM total length for a PIC25G
push-pull multistage MZM architecture biased at quadrature point.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
TEMPORITI et al.: INSIGHTS INTO SILICON PHOTONICS MACH–ZEHNDER-BASED OPTICAL TRANSMITTER ARCHITECTURES 3181
Fig. 3. PIC25G HSPM + electrodes: (a) self-resonance frequency vs. HSPM sections length; (b) capacitance vs. frequency for different HSPM
section lengths.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3182 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 51, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2016
Fig. 5. (a) Dual-drive push-pull travelling-wave MZM architecture. (b) Periodically-loaded transmission line with HSPM sections interleaved by un-doped
optical waveguide.
ture. The ER instead monotonically increases with the MZM in factor δ. L e f f can thus be used in (1)–(5) to derive ER and
length for 0 < ϕ/2 < π/2. The electrical propagation losses OMA performance for the travelling wave modulators.
can be minimized by periodically loading the electrode trans- Fig. 6 shows the ER and the OMA as a function of
mission line with short HSPM sections [Fig. 5(b)] to isolate the HSPM length. A push-pull MZM realized with first-
longitudinal current flow in the metal electrodes [15], [16]. generation PIC25G HSPMs is considered together with a
In this way, lossy propagation through p-n junctions is avoided. driving architecture relying upon ECL pairs under a 2.8 V
The resulting filling ratio can be optimized to minimize supply implementing equalization techniques. A filling ratio
optical rise and fall times by ensuring matching between of 60% and electrical propagation losses of ∼3 dB/mm at
the delay of the electrical wave propagating in the elec- Nyquist frequency (28 GHz for 56 Gbps) are assumed. While
trodes and the delay of the optical wave propagating in the the travelling wave architecture enables operation at higher
waveguide. data rates than the multistage one, the maximum achievable
To derive the OMA and ER curves neglecting ISI effects, OMA is lower due to the lower driving voltage and the
(1)–(5) can be applied also in the case of travelling wave increased electrical propagation losses. In Fig. 6, the expected
modulators. However, in the travelling wave architecture not performance of the first-generation HSPMs is compared to the
all the sections along the MZM arm length equally contribute second-generation ones. For the latter, a filling ratio of 80%
to the phase shift. The un-doped parts between one HSPM and ∼3 dB/mm of propagation losses are assumed. Extinction
section and the other give in fact no contribution. Moreover, ratio values in the range of 5 dB, suitable for most standards
the provided phase shift reduces along the MZM arm as the for optical modules, are achievable using the most recent
voltage decays from its initial value Vdrive due to the electrical HSPMs.
propagation losses. To keep these effects into account, the A 56 Gbps transmitter relying upon a travelling wave
concept of effective length L e f f can be introduced. L e f f is the architecture, exploiting the above techniques and realized in
length of a HSPM that, driven with a voltage Vdrive assumed PIC25G and 55 nm BiCMOS technologies, will be described
constant along its length, provides a phase shift equal to that in Section VI-B.
of the analyzed HSPM. The effective length is thus defined
by the following equation: V. M ULTISTAGE VS . T RAVELLING WAVE
Vdrive L e f f MZM A RCHITECTURES
L H SPM ∞
−αz z − nL 1 The analysis carried out in the previous paragraphs show
= Vdrive e rect − dz (6) that multistage architectures based on CMOS drivers are
0 n=−∞
δL 2
preferred in applications requiring large ER values, but they
where z is the longitudinal dimension of the HSPM, L H S P M are limited in speed. Travelling wave architectures based on
is the entire geometrical length of the HSPM, α is the voltage CML/ECL drivers are instead preferred at higher rates, but
attenuation constant and the summation represents the periodic they do not ensure large ER values due to the limited voltage
loading of the electrode transmission line of period L and fill swing and the losses of the integrated transmission line.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
TEMPORITI et al.: INSIGHTS INTO SILICON PHOTONICS MACH–ZEHNDER-BASED OPTICAL TRANSMITTER ARCHITECTURES 3183
1 1 VT2W
PT W = · · (10)
ηT W 4 R
The driver efficiencies ηMS and ηTW take into account both
driver non-idealities, such as the finite slope of driving edges,
and the power dissipated in the pre-driving stages.
The resulting transmitter power efficiencies, defined as the
ratio between the power consumption and the bit rate and
expressed in pJ/bit, are plotted as a function of the bit rate
in Fig. 7. The transmitter power efficiency is independent of
the bit rate for the multistage architecture, while it improves
Fig. 6. (a) ER and (b) normalized OMA vs. HSPM total length for a PIC25G proportionally for the travelling wave solution. The crossing
dual-drive push-pull travelling wave MZM architecture biased at quadrature
point. point B0 , given by:
In applications with intermediate data rates and requiring ηM S 1 VT W 2
B0 = · · (11)
moderate ER values, the choice between the two architectures ηT W C R VM S
is driven by power consumption considerations. Assuming identifies the bit rate beyond which travelling wave architec-
pseudorandom bit streams with rise and fall times negligible tures are the preferred choice. Due to its dependence on ηMS
with respect to the bit duration Tb , the dynamic power for and ηTW , the absolute value of B0 depends on the specific
each arm of the multistage and travelling wave architectures, design implementation. As an example, assuming a 3 mm-long
Pdyn,MS and Pdyn,TW respectively, is given by: HSPM realized in first-generation PIC25G technology featur-
1 1 ing ∼300 fF/mm [4], a 50 sizing of the travelling wave
Pd yn,M S = · · C · VM
2
S (7) transmission line, driver efficiencies of ∼20% for multistage
4 Tb
and of ∼15% for travelling wave and comparable voltage
1 VT2W swings, a multistage architecture is advantageous in terms of
Pd yn,T W = V AV G · I AV G = · (8)
4 R power consumption at bit rates lower than 30 Gbps while
where 1/Tb is the bit rate, C is the average capacitance value a travelling wave solution is preferred beyond. Power con-
across voltage for the whole HSPM, R is the characteristic sumption advantages of a multistage architecture making use
impedance of the travelling wave electrode, and VMS and VTW of CMOS drivers versus a travelling wave architecture using
are respectively the driving voltages for the multistage and the CML/ECL drivers become even more evident as operating
travelling wave solution. The dynamic power is proportional rate decreases. This makes multistage architecture attractive
to the total HSPM length through the capacitance value in for multi-standard operation needing backward compatibility
the case of a multistage driving, while in the case of a with existing standards.
travelling wave driving it is independent from this parameter.
Considering also the driver efficiencies ηMS and ηTW , defined VI. D EMONSTRATOR D ESIGN AND I MPLEMENTATION
as the ratio between the dynamic power reported in equa-
tions (7) and (8) versus the total dissipated power, the powers One 25 Gbps and one 56 Gbps transmitters have been
dissipated by the multistage and travelling wave architecture, designed and characterized, comparing measurement results
PMS and PTW respectively, are given by: with electro-optical co-simulations. Both transmitters have
been realized using first-generation PIC25G technology and
1 1 1 operate at 1310 nm wavelength. The EIC has been 3D
PM S = · · · C · VM
2
(9)
ηM S 4 Tb S integrated on top of the PIC by means of 50 μm-pitch
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3184 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 51, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2016
Fig. 8. Schematics of stacked CMOS inverter drivers (top) and DC-shifter (bottom, with pre-charging MOS transistors in grey). Thick-line gates transistors
indicate thick-oxide transistors.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
TEMPORITI et al.: INSIGHTS INTO SILICON PHOTONICS MACH–ZEHNDER-BASED OPTICAL TRANSMITTER ARCHITECTURES 3185
Fig. 11. 25 Gbps MZM eye diagrams: (a) electro-optical co-simulations at quadrature point; (b) measurements with the oscilloscope standard triggering at
quadrature point; (c) measurements at increased ER with oscilloscope standard trigger.
TABLE I
P ERFORMANCE S UMMARY AND C OMPARISON W ITH S TATE - OF - THE -A RT S ILICON P HOTONICS T RANSMITTERS U SING C ARRIER D EPLETION MZMs
and discharge phases is detailed in Fig. 8. DC-shifted signals setup is shown in Fig. 10. Eye diagram measurements have
at driving stage inputs, for push-pull driving of two HSPM been performed by directly accessing input pads via RF probes
sections, are generated by means of boost capacitors C1-2 with 27 − 1 non-return-to-zero (NRZ) pseudo-random bit
of 350 fF and CMOS latch. CMOS latch allows proper sequences (PRBS7). The CW laser power delivered to the
operation also in the presence of long periodicity PRBSs and input grating coupler is close to 13 dBm. The optical eye
at lower data rate by avoiding undesired discharge of boost diagram at 25 Gbps with the MZM operated at quadrature
capacitors. No perceptible phase shift appears between nodes point is measured with the oscilloscope standard triggering,
L’ and H’. The DC shifter is enabled by the dedicated awake and compared to simulations in Fig. 11. Simulations have been
signals (AWK-∗ ). Pre-charging MOS ensure a well-defined performed by co-simulating electronic with photonic devices
state of the latch at startup. and show a very good agreement with the measurements.
Fig. 9 shows the photomicrograph of the demonstrator. The An ER of 4 dB has been achieved. This value can be increased
transmitter core occupies 0.6 mm2 and dissipates 275 mW up to 6 dB by a different setting of the MZM operating point,
at 25 Gbps. Lower data rates are also supported with a while maintaining the OMA penalty below 25% and the eye
dissipation of 75 mW at 10 Gbps in low power mode and diagram crossing point beyond 45%. Table I compares the
with less than 0.5 dB penalty on the ER [5]. Maximum OMA results of the demonstrator with those of recently published
is achieved at quadrature point, while the ER can be traded electro-optical transmitters based on carrier depletion MZMs
with the OMA by proper LSPM setting. The measurement and operating at comparable data rates [17], [18]. This work
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3186 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 51, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2016
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
TEMPORITI et al.: INSIGHTS INTO SILICON PHOTONICS MACH–ZEHNDER-BASED OPTICAL TRANSMITTER ARCHITECTURES 3187
Fig. 14. 56 Gbps MZM eye diagrams: (a) electro-optical co-simulations at quadrature point; (b) measurements with the oscilloscope standard triggering at
quadrature point; (c) measurements at increased ER with oscilloscope standard trigger.
TABLE II
S TATE - OF - THE -A RT 56 Gbps E LECTRO -O PTICAL T RANSMITTERS
current switching. In the pre-driving stage, two ECL pairs with This solution is effective also under large signals. SOA issues
different passive input coupling networks and shared loads are avoided using a cascode as shared load for the ECL pairs.
allow implementing both VGA and equalization functions. Shunt peaking has been implemented at the pre-driving stage
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3188 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 51, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2016
Fig. 15. 28 Gbps PRBS31 MZM eye diagrams: (a) measurements at quadrature point; (b) measurements at increased ER.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
TEMPORITI et al.: INSIGHTS INTO SILICON PHOTONICS MACH–ZEHNDER-BASED OPTICAL TRANSMITTER ARCHITECTURES 3189
Fig. 18. Optical eye diagrams at 40 Gbps and 56 Gbps: probe testing (a), (b) vs. packaged chip on PCB (c), (d).
point by π/10, while maintaining the crossing point of the eye a 4-metal layer printed circuit board (PCB) using 2.4 mm
diagram beyond 48% [see Fig. 14(b)]. Optical eye diagrams coaxial connectors (Fig. 16).
at 28 Gbps to demonstrate backward-compatibility are shown On the electrical side, the main issue of such assembly is
in Fig. 15. the signal integrity. It has in fact to be ensured up to 56 Gbps
Table II compares present work with published electro- through the whole electrical input transmission path, from
optical transmitters realized in different technologies and hav- the connector to the PIC pad. 3D electro-magnetic (EM)
ing similar data rates [19]–[21]. This work shows ∼30% power simulations have been set up to analyze and select the proper
saving compared to Silicon Photonics state-of-the-art [19], geometry of all interconnects, for input matching at the target
demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed equalization characteristic impedance over the whole bandwidth. Grounded
approach. Furthermore, it favorably compares with directly coplanar waveguides (G-CPW) have been adopted on both the
modulated laser (DML) transmitters, allowing more than LGA substrate and the PCB. A particular attention has been
500 mW power budget allocation for the external CW laser focused on the pitch of the ground vias to prevent higher-order
compared to the state-of-the-art of 1310 nm DML [20]. modes propagation. G-CPWs paths have been designed on
each substrate to ensure a phase matching between differential
signals better than 5 deg at 40 GHz. All transitions have been
C. Low-Cost Optical Packaging analyzed by means of 3D electromagnetic simulations and
Measurement results shown in Section VI-A and designed as transmission lines, rather than assuming them as
Section VI-B have been obtained by directly accessing input lumped elements or parasitics. Spring probes in the socket and
pads via RF probes to demonstrate the intrinsic performance bond wires have thus been EM simulated within their embed-
of the 3D-integrated Silicon Photonics transmitters and ding materials, taking advantage of the dielectric constant of
the accuracy of theoretical analysis. However, low-cost these materials to design transmission lines with the required
electro-optical assembly techniques maximizing the signal characteristic impedance. The transfer function (TF) of the
integrity are key and several alternative solutions are under complete transmission path has been derived by comparing
investigation. In this work, an electro-optical assembly the small-signal TF of the travelling wave optical transmit-
approach relying upon the wire bonding of the Silicon ter measured on-wafer to the small-signal TF of the same
Photonics 3D stack on a low-cost land grid array (LGA) optical transmitter measured in package, by means of a 4-
package with a 4-metal layer organic substrate [3] has port differential Vector Network analyzer in conjunction with
been used for testing purposes. Output optical signals have a reference photodiode. The comparison of the measured S-
been collected through a V-block aligned with the photonic parameters with 3D EM simulations is plotted in Fig. 17,
integrated circuit (PIC) grating couplers, directly glued on showing a good agreement. It must be noted that no high-
the PIC (inset of Fig. 16), while bondwires are covered by frequency characterization was available for the embedding
resin for mechanical protection. The packaged demonstrators materials, as well as for the top finishing of the GCPWs on
have been mounted into a custom plastic socket employing the PCB, which can justify the partial mismatch between the
spring probe contacts. The socket has been assembled on results. The smooth behavior of the attenuation of the electrical
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3190 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 51, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2016
input path allows the compensation of the bandwidth limitation [5] M. Cignoli et al., “A 1310 nm 3D-integrated silicon photonics
by means of equalization in the optical transmitter. Mach–Zehnder-based transmitter with 275 mW multistage CMOS driver
achieving 6 dB extinction ratio at 25 Gb/s,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Solid-
Optical eye diagrams at the output of the travelling wave State Circuits Conf. (ISSCC), Feb. 2015, pp. 1–3.
modulator described in Section VI-B are shown in Fig. 18 [6] E. Temporiti, G. Minoia, M. Repossi, D. Baldi, A. Ghilioni, and
to compare testboard measurements of packaged chips with F. Svelto, “A 56 Gb/s 300 mW silicon-photonics transmitter in
3D-integrated PIC25G and 55 nm BiCMOS technologies,” in IEEE Int.
probe testing results. The same input electrical signal has Solid-State Circuits Conf. (ISSCC) Dig. Tech. Dig., 2016, pp. 404–405.
been used and the same IC settings have been selected [7] E. Säckinger, Broadband Circuits for Optical Fiber Communication.
with no additional input equalization. The realized assem- New York, NY, USA: Wiley, 2005.
[8] L. Vivien and L. Pavesi, Handbook of Silicon Photonics. Boca Raton,
bly minimizes the degradation of the transmitted signal FL, USA: CRC Press, 2013.
versus probe testing up to 40 Gbps. The eye diagram is [9] N. Dupuis et al., “30-Gb/s optical link combining heterogeneously
still open at 56 Gbps even if slightly degraded due to the integrated III–V/Si photonics with 32-nm CMOS circuits,” J. Lightw.
Technol., vol. 33, no. 3, pp. 657–662, Feb. 1, 2015.
bandwidth limitation of the complete electrical input path. [10] D. Feng et al., “High-speed GeSi electroabsorption modulator on the
Larger equalization should be applied for further eye opening SOI waveguide platform,” IEEE J. Sel. Topics Quantum Electron.,
at 56 Gbps. vol. 19, no. 6, Nov./Dec. 2013, Art. no. 3401710.
[11] J. Buckwalter et al., “A monolithic 25-Gb/s transceiver with photonic
The proposed assembly approach and associated simulation ring modulators and Ge detectors in a 130-nm CMOS SOI process,”
method, adopted here for demonstration purposes, can be IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 47, no. 6, pp. 1309–1322, Jun. 2012.
leveraged to optimize future designs of electrical interconnects [12] M. Rakowski et al., “A 4 × 20 Gb/s WDM ring-based hybrid CMOS
silicon photonics transceiver,” in IEEE Int. Solid-State Circuits Conf.
on optical module substrates. (ISSCC) Dig. Tech. Papers, 2015, pp. 1–3.
[13] H. Li et al., “A 25 Gb/s, 4.4 V-swing, AC-coupled ring modulator-based
VII. C ONCLUSIONS WDM transmitter with wavelength stabilization in 65 nm CMOS,” IEEE
J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 50, no. 12, pp. 3145–3159, Dec. 2015.
Optical transmitters constitute the most challenging section [14] G. T. Reed, G. Mashanovich, F. Y. Gardes, and D. J. Thomson, “Silicon
of electro-optical transceivers due to the stringent power con- optical modulators,” Nature Photon., vol. 4, pp. 518–526, Aug. 2010.
[15] T. Baehr-Jones et al., “Ultralow drive voltage silicon traveling-wave
sumption constraints set by standard modules’ form factors. modulator,” Opt. Exp., vol. 20, no. 11, pp. 12014–12020, May 2012.
Among Silicon Photonics alternatives enabling cost reduction [16] G. L. Li, T. G. B. Mason, and P. K. L. Yu, “Analysis of segmented
and miniaturization compared to discrete duals, MZMs con- traveling-wave optical modulators,” J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 22, no. 7,
pp. 1789–1796, Jul. 2004.
stitute the most mature solution for industrial applications. [17] N. Qi et al., “A 25 Gb/s, 520 mW, 6.4 Vpp silicon-photonic
In this work alternative architectures for high data rates, Mach–Zehnder modulator with distributed driver in CMOS,” in Proc.
namely multistage and travelling wave, have been compared Opt. Fiber Commun. Conf. Expo. (OFC), 2015, pp. 1–3.
[18] S. Liu, D. J. Thomson, K. Li, P. Wilson, and G. T. Reed, “N-over-N
and analytical criteria for the choice between the two have cascode push–pull modulator driver in 130 nm CMOS enabling 20 Gbit/s
been provided. Demonstrators relying upon first-generation optical interconnection with Mach–Zehnder modulator,” Electron. Lett.,
PIC25G optical devices and achieving 30% better power vol. 51, no. 23, pp. 1900–1902, Nov. 2015.
[19] G. Denoyer et al., “Hybrid silicon photonic circuits and transceiver for
efficiency compared to Silicon Photonics state-of-the-art with 50 Gb/s NRZ transmission over single-mode fiber,” J. Lightw. Technol.,
comparable extinction ratio at similar data rates have been vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 1247–1254, Mar. 15, 2015.
realized for both architectures. Probe testing results have [20] T. Takemoto et al., “A 50-Gb/s NRZ-modulated optical transmitter based
on a DFB-LD and a 0.18-μm SiGe BiCMOS LD driver,” in Proc. Opt.
been compared with measurements of packaged chips on Fiber Commun. Conf. (OFC), 2015, pp. 1–3.
testboard, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed [21] D. M. Kuchta et al., “A 56.1 Gb/s NRZ modulated 850 nm VCSEL-
design methodology for assembled parts. Finally, performance based optical link,” in Proc. Opt. Fiber Commun. Conf. (OFC), 2013,
pp. 1–3.
improvements are expected from next generations of silicon
integrated optical devices, in particular HSPMs. It has been
then demonstrated that Silicon Photonics MZM-based optical
transmitters might be suitable to address not only current but
also next-generation optical communication standards.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to thank Anritsu and Tektronix for
providing test equipment.
Enrico Temporiti (M’13) received the
Laurea degree in electronic engineering from
R EFERENCES the University of Pavia, Italy, in 1999, working in
[1] R. Soref, “Silicon photonics: A review of recent literature,” Silicon, conjunction with Alcatel Italia.
vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 1–6, Jan. 2010. In 2000 he joined STMicroelectronics in the
[2] Y. A. Vlasov, “Silicon CMOS-integrated nano-photonics for computer Studio di Microelettronica in Pavia, Italy, focusing
and data communications beyond 100G,” IEEE Commun. Mag., vol. 50, on CMOS analog and mixed-signal integrated
no. 2, pp. s67–s72, Feb. 2012. circuits for high speed wireless and wired
[3] F. Boeuf et al., “Silicon photonics R&D and manufacturing on 300-mm applications. He is currently working as a design
wafer platform,” J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 286–295, Jan. 15, manager within the Mixed Processes R&D Team
2016. in the Digital and Mixed Processes ASIC Division
[4] F. Boeuf et al., “A multi-wavelength 3D-compatible silicon photonics of the Microcontrollers and Digital ICs Group. He holds several U.S.
platform on 300 mm SOI wafers for 25 Gb/s applications,” in Proc. IEEE and European patents, mainly in the fields of optical communications and
Int. Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), Dec. 2013, pp. 13.3.1–13.3.4. frequency synthesis.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
TEMPORITI et al.: INSIGHTS INTO SILICON PHOTONICS MACH–ZEHNDER-BASED OPTICAL TRANSMITTER ARCHITECTURES 3191
Andrea Ghilioni (M’12) received the B.S. and Matteo Repossi (M’05) received the Laurea and
M.S. degrees with honors in electronics engineering Ph.D. degrees in electronics engineering from the
in 2006 and 2008, respectively, and the Ph.D. degree University of Pavia, Pavia, Italy, in 2002 and 2006,
in microelectronics from the University of Pavia, respectively.
Italy, in January 2012, with Prof. Francesco Svelto In 2005, he was with DIEI, University of Perugia,
as Advisor. Perugia, Italy, as a Guest Researcher in the frame-
From 2012 to 2013 he was a Postdoctoral work of a national research project on wideband
Researcher at the University of Pavia, leading the RF-MEMS circuits. In 2006, he joined STMicro-
design of a 10 Gbps mm-Wave wireless short-haul electronics within the Studio di Microelettronica,
OOK transceiver in CMOS 28 nm. In 2013 he Pavia, where his research is focused on the design
become an Assistant Professor at the same Uni- and characterization of high-speed components and
versity. His current research interests cover Silicon-Photonics 3D-assembled circuits for RF and silicon photonics applications.
transceivers design for data-rates above 50 Gbps, and RF/microwave/mm- Dr. Repossi was the recipient of the Second Best Student Paper Award
wave IC design for multi-Gbps wireless communications. at the 2004 Applied Computational Electromagnetics Software Conference,
Syracuse, NY, USA.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROURKELA. Downloaded on September 16,2023 at 11:06:52 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.