1

The Black Dahlia

Name

Course

Institution

Professor

Date
 2

Introduction

It has often been accused that The Black Dahlia is, though the life of Elizabeth Short

remains one of the most infamous unsolved murders in America. Dr. George Hodel is,

however, more often suspected, but evidence and motives still need to be provided in the

duality. This paper shall review the alternative suspects and scenarios that may bring to light

a mystery that will not die but is very interesting, if not gruesome.

The Case Against Dr. Hodel

Dr. George Hodel emerged as one of the prime suspects in the murder of Elizabeth

Short, primarily from allegations by his son, Steve Hodel. These ran from circumstantial

evidence to the sinister capabilities of Hodel (Fanning & O’Callaghan 2022). Critics of the theory

say much of the evidence against Hodel is speculative and lacks solid forensic backing. For

example, no physical evidence directly points at Hodel about the crime. Despite heavy

surveillance and investigation in the 1940s and renewed scrutiny in recent years, that physical

evidence does not exist.

Other Potential Suspects

To the extent that all inquiries have tended to focus solely on Hodel, other likely

candidates with their motives and opportunities have fallen by the wayside. Another suspect

who attracted police interest was Leslie Dillon, who worked as a bellhop and was familiar

with mortuary practices due to his very suspicious conduct and possible knowledge of the

details of the murder (Steenberg & Coulthard 2021). Mark Hansen, a nightclub owner, had a book

of hers and had a motive in unrequited love and jealousy as one of Short's friends (Wolfe,

2022). Further, with the brutal nature of the murder and the known presence of the Mafia in

Los Angeles, the theory of organized crime involvement again opens yet another wing of the
 3

investigation. Those suspects provide alternative possibilities to Hodel, each connected with

possible associations and motives for the crime.

Societal and Environmental Factors

This murder occurred in the rarefied, though also quite sordid, context of postwar Los

Angeles, a city rife with rapid growth, crime, and corruption. The media sensationalized the

trial, sometimes with such fervor as to create a narrative at odds with the search for truth or

even the basic facts of the case (Meikle & Morris 2022). The involvement of the (Los Angeles

police department (LAPD) was judged inefficient and condemned due to corruption, possibly

playing a role in mishandling evidence and losing leads (Lawless, 2022). The social landscape

represented allows the reader to form his or her assumption that the murderer could be just

about anybody from a friend to a common criminal benefiting from the chaotic environment

of that period.

Conclusion

The murder of the Black Dahlia is still a very curious mystery perhaps one that, in its

history, has not been equaled in shockingly violent crime and the considerable amount of

enigma that surrounds its investigation. While Dr. George Hodel has remained the suspected

perpetrator, his adamant point is straightforward: the evidence to pin him to the Hodel

murders just is not there. This means that all possible leads, in this case, should be followed

through to the very The interest in the death of Elizabeth Short is not only due to the various

possibilities and stories that have grown up around it, but it reflects the complex interplay of

fact and fiction and a cultural obsession. The real culprit may, therefore, have permanently

been consigned just beyond the reach of certainty, and the case of the Black Dahlia eternally

consigned to the ranks of unresolved cases in any history of true crime.

 4

References

Fanning, S. E., & O’Callaghan, C. (Eds.). (2022). Serial Killing on Screen: Adaptation, True

Crime and Popular Culture. Springer Nature. https://books.google.co.ke/books?

hl=en&lr=&id=FwefEAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR7&dq=Dr.

+George+Hodel+emerged+as+one+of+the+prime+suspects+in+the+murder+of+Eliza

beth+Short&ots=zahYGGTxuM&sig=ndv9rGen7Ze-

yo2Jp0d3I5Mc9D4&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false

Lawless, W. (2022, March). Risk determination versus risk perception: A new model of

reality for human–machine autonomy. In Informatics (Vol. 9, No. 2, p. 30). MDPI.

https://doi.org/10.3390/informatics9020030

Meikle, P. A., & Morris, L. R. (2022). University Social Responsibility: challenging systemic

racism in the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder. Administrative Sciences, 12(1), 36.

https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci12010036

Steenberg, L., & Coulthard, L. (2021). Noir Tourism and the Black Dahlia

Murder. Capitalism, Crime and Media in the 21st Century, 59-76.

https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-56444-5_4

Wolfe, D. H. (2022). The Black Dahlia Files: The Mob, the Mogul, and the Murder That

Transfixed Los Angeles. HarperCollins.